CFA® Level II FSA - Equity Method of Accounting (Investments in Associates)

Financial Guardians
7 followers
When the ownership interest is between 20% and 50%, the investor generally has significant
influence on the investee, which means that the financial and operating performance of the
investee is partly influenced by the investor. The equity method reflects the economic reality
of this relationship and provides a more objective basis for reporting investment income.
The general premise is that the earnings or losses of the associate are reflected in the
Let's look at how this is done. Let's say the investor takes a 40%
stake in the investee at a cost of $1,000. The initial investment is recorded at cost
and reported on the investor's balance sheet as a non-current asset.
We call this the investment account. In subsequent periods when the associate
makes profits or losses, the proportionate amount is used to adjust the carrying value
This same amount is also reported in the investor's income statement.
For example, if the investee made a profit of $300 one year after the investment was made,
$120 will be added to the investor's investment account.
This is also added as profit in the income statement.
However, do take note that dividends or other distributions received from the
reduce the investment account and are not reported in the investor's income statement.
This is because, under the equity method, dividends from associates are treated as
a return of capital, not as income. So in this case, if the total dividend
paid by the associate is $100, the $40 cash dividend received by the investor
reduces the investment account, and the amount is not reported in income statement
In essence, remember that the ending value of the investment account is its beginning value
plus the proportional profit from the associate or minus proportional losses made by the associate
minus the dividends or any distributions received from the associate.
The ending value of the investment account after the first year is therefore $1,080.
The income statement should only record the proportional income or loss from the associate,
which is just $120. The equity method is often referred to as
one-line consolidation because the investor's proportionate ownership interest in the assets
and liabilities of the investee is disclosed as a single-line item on its balance sheet,
and the investor's share of the revenues and expenses of the investee
is disclosed as a single-line item on its income statement.
Now, let's say in the following year a financial crisis swept through the world,
and the investee made a massive loss of $3,000, and as a result, no dividend was paid for the year.
What do you think is the effect on the investor's balance sheet and income statement for the year?
You may want to pause the video and ponder over this.
And we're back. If you've attempted, you would have run into a problem.
The proportional loss is supposed to reduce the investment account by $1,200,
but the carrying value of $1,080 is less than that.
In such a case, the standard procedure is to reduce the investment account to zero,
so the investor records a loss of $1,080 on its income statement.
The equity method is halted when the investment account reaches zero,
and the share of losses not recognized is simply recorded to be recovered in future periods.
As the loss from the associate was supposed to be $1,200, $120 of it is unrecognized.
The equity method only resumes when the unrecognized losses have been recovered.
So in this case, the $120 unrecognized loss must be recovered before the equity method can resume.
So, let's practice again. In the following year after the crisis,
the investee makes a quick recovery and recorded $800 in profit and paid a total dividend of $150.
What is the effect on the investor's balance sheet and earnings?
Pause the video now and work out your answer.
And we're back. Taking 40% share, the proportionate share of earnings to the investor is $320.
Of the $320, $120 goes to recover the unrecorded loss from the previous year.
Since the unrecognized losses from previous periods have been fully recovered,
the equity method can resume. Therefore, this increases the investment account by $200.
The net income recorded from the associate for this year is also $200.
But don't forget the dividend from the associate, where $60 is received.
As mentioned earlier, dividend received is regarded as a return of capital,
so the amount is subtracted from the investment account. The balance is therefore $140.
Now that we've learned the basic principles of the equity method, let's go deeper.
What we've learned so far applies to the ideal case where the investor acquires the
shares at book value. So in this case, if the net asset of the investee was $2,500
at the point of acquisition, the investor would have acquired the shares at book value.
So the basic equity method of accounting that we've learned applies. In the real world,
the cost to acquire shares of an investee is often greater than the book value of those shares.
So let's say the net asset of the investee is just $1,750. The investor would have paid $300
excess for the shares over its book value. This is because, among other things, many of
the investee's assets and liabilities reflect historical cost rather than fair value.
To break it down, the $1,000 purchase price is recorded in the investor's balance sheet as
follows. The pro rata book value of the net assets, which is $700. Now you may be tempted
to account for all the excess of $300 as goodwill. However, let's revise the definition of goodwill
that we learned in Level 1. Goodwill is by definition the portion of the purchase price
that's higher than the net fair value of all the assets purchased and liabilities assumed.
Notice that the benchmark for goodwill is the fair value, not the book value. As such,
this excess of the purchase price has to be allocated to the investee's identifiable assets
and liabilities based on their fair values first. Only the remainder is considered goodwill.
For instance, if the fair values of the investee's assets and liabilities all match their
book values, except for its non-current assets which has a fair value of $1,750 versus a book
value of $1,250, $200 of the excess purchase price is attributable to the non-current assets.
The remaining $100 excess is recorded as goodwill. In subsequent periods, the excess allocated to
the non-current assets is expected to be amortized. For example, if we assume 10-year
useful life for the non-current assets with zero residual value, the amortization per year should
be $20 on a straight-line basis. Goodwill, on the other hand, is not amortized but is reviewed for
impairment on a regular basis and written down for any identified impairment. Let's now learn
how the equity method works in this case where there is excess purchase price involved.
We shall illustrate using the same scenario where the investee makes a profit of $300 in the first
year and pays out a total of $100 in dividends. The proportional share of profit that the investor
should receive is $120. However, we should deduct amortization cost of $20 for the excess paid
on the non-current assets. If there's no impairment of goodwill, the net income from
associate should be $100 for the year. This is added onto the investment account.
Not forgetting to subtract the dividend of $40, the new carrying value of the investment account
is therefore $1,060. So, in essence, under the equity method, the initial cost of the investment
is recorded on the balance sheet as a non-current asset. If there is excess purchase price above the
book value of the shares, it must first be attributed to the fair values of identifiable
assets above their book values and the remaining recorded as goodwill. In subsequent periods,
the proportionate profit or loss is recorded on the income statement, less the amortization of
excess purchase price, and less any impairment of goodwill identified. The net equity income from
associate is added to the investment account. The amount of dividend received is subtracted
from the investment account. You're watching an excerpt from our comprehensive animation library.
For more videos like these, head on down to prepnuggets.com. At PrepNuggets, let us do the
hard work for you.
