World War I: The Seminal Tragedy - The Concert of Europe - Extra History - Part 1

Explore History
10 followers
17 Video Views·Sep 12, 2025
The Seminal Tragedy of World War I - European History - Part 1
The Concert of Europe held the continent together for years after the Napoleonic Wars, but as the leadership of great nations weakened over time, the stage was set for a colossal tragedy.
Human history is equal parts heroism, tragedy, and misunderstanding.
Very rarely have we displayed all three to such a degree as in the First World War.
This war is called the seminal catastrophe of the 20th century,
because without it there is no Stalin and no Hitler, no fascism or World War II.
Without it we don't have a Cold War that leads us to the very brink of annihilation,
nor do we see the Middle East carved up by old men,
and still bitter from four years of meaningless self-inflicted catastrophe.
Without this war we probably don't have 9-11 or the turmoil in the Middle East today.
This war ushered in the modern age,
born in a crucible of gunpowder and toxic smoke and the blood of 10 million men.
Blood spilt in war from the fields of France to the waters off America,
from the Russian frontier to the sands of the Middle East,
from the Chinese mainland to the deepest parts of the sea.
This war broke empires.
It shattered the past and forced us to give up our last ties to our medieval understanding.
When the smoke cleared and a stunned world climbed out of its trenches,
we lived in a new age, with new powers, new ideas and new terrors.
It is the defining event of the 20th century.
It is the Great War.
But it's not the war itself that we're here to talk about today.
Hopefully, over the course of this show,
a bit at a time we'll slowly, story by story,
cover the sprawling events of this turning point in history.
But today, today we are focused on the events that led to this war.
For if the war itself is the seminal catastrophe of the 20th century,
then the weeks before the war are its seminal tragedy.
In these next few episodes, we'll focus on the very human,
very personal stories that led Europe to consume itself,
to ignite itself in one suicidal blaze from which it still hasn't recovered,
because it is a tragedy of the highest order.
It's like a play, a Greek epic,
a story so grand we would think it must be fiction,
if the scars of the war couldn't still be seen on the fields of France.
It's Shakespeare living out before us.
It begins with the death of a prince and his lady,
and ends in mass slaughter the likes of which the world has never seen.
So let's set the stage.
For a hundred years, Europe has been at peace.
There have been wars, sure, but they were minor wars.
Wars on the periphery.
Wars without many of the great powers involved.
Not since Napoleon did the great states of Europe vie in bloody battle.
For after the ravages of the Napoleonic Wars,
the statesmen of Europe had come together
to try to stop such a catastrophe from ever happening again.
They created a system called the Concert of Europe,
so that whenever war seemed perilously close,
the nations of Europe would come together in a congress, a conference,
and instead come to a settlement that all parties would abide by.
But Europe has changed since those weary of the Napoleonic conflicts
first came together to create the Great Concert.
The first and most major change was the formation of Germany.
At the time our story begins, it's important to remember
Germany as a nation was only 40 years old.
It's a young nation, a strong one, a nation looking to claim its own.
But to say that Germany was a strong nation
is to undersell the magnitude of its creation.
I mean to say that the birth of Germany
was something perhaps unique in the history of the world.
For overnight, with the signing of a few papers,
the middle of Europe was transformed
from a thousand tiny squabbling states
to the greatest land power the world had ever known.
In one night, suddenly the most powerful nations of Europe
Russia, France, Austria-Hungary, and England
were not the most powerful nations in Europe any longer.
Overnight in the very heart of Europe
had been created a nation with more manpower,
natural resources, and economic strength
than any other nation in the world
except perhaps for Great Britain.
Moreover, this creation was cemented
in the defeat of France, which at the time
was considered the strongest land power in Europe.
And at the time of our story, that defeat
and its memory still run deep.
And now, look at the world from the perspective
of that powerful new German nation.
Here they are, arguably the most powerful country
in the world, and yet they see themselves
being denied all the rights of a great world power.
Britain and France held territories
across the globe, even the Netherlands,
a nation which the might of the new Germany
could wipe off the face of the earth in a week,
had colonies from Asia all the way to Africa.
But Germany, for all of their strength,
had been denied those possessions, simply because
their nation was young. Imagine what this does
to the balance of power. Imagine what this does
to the geopolitical scene. Think what would happen
today if, say, the entire EU
declared themselves a single nation
with a single economy, a single military,
and a single foreign policy. Imagine if they
said that they wanted greater access to Middle Eastern oil,
and Russia and the United States said
no, we were here first. Imagine now
if representatives from Russia and the United States
smiled and told this young nation that they'd
be happy to continue to sell them oil at an
inflated price, though. This was the position
Germany found itself in. How was
the concert of Europe, a system built around
a balance of power and compromise,
to last in these circumstances?
And yet, for 40 years, it did, and this
brings us to the second major change since the
Napoleonic Wars. The men.
The 70 years after those wars was a time
of giants, men who towered over the world
stage. Time and again here, Europe
rolled well on the dice of history, and came up
with leaders who were capable of navigating an increasingly
complex and increasingly modern
geopolitical world. In the 1800s,
Russians saw men like Alexander
II, who understood that Russia needed
to modernize to survive. He began
dismantling serfdom, reformed judicial
practices, encouraged universities,
and pursued peace, understanding that Russia
was in no position to fight the major European
powers. Like all the men here,
this guy was not all chuckles and sunshine.
Alexander II brutally suppressed
revolutionaries and separatists in the territories
Russia controlled. Still, he was effective,
without question. By 1900,
we have in Russia Nicholas II, a deeply
reactionary, deeply conservative man
who history records as being of middling
intellect, with neither the training nor the
inclination to properly rule. His reign
is a catalogue of embarrassing mismanagement.
This is the man who fell under the
sway of the mystic Rasputin. This is a
man who couldn't even coordinate his own coronation.
A man who let 1300 people die
in a human stampede on the day he was crowned,
because, I kid you not, there was not enough beer
and pretzels. And this is the man who
held a ball that day anyway, because, hey,
why let a few hundred deaths spoil your day?
And this is the man who will, in the end,
hold the fate of the world in his hands.
And by this point in Austria,
we have as emperor an 84-year-old man,
two years away from his death, and battered
by the weight of the life he's led.
His foreign minister, Berthold, is neither a bad
man nor a stupid man, but he is a
weak and vacillating man at a time when
European politics are all about strength.
And Germany? Germany during the
20 years following its creation had
unquestionably one of the greatest diplomats
the world has ever seen. Otto von
Bismarck. This is a man of great ability
and great appetites. A man known to
smoke three cigars at once and down a
bottle of champagne at breakfast. A man who
probably deserves an entire episode just to himself,
but, for our purposes, he is the man who
held the concert of Europe together under
the incredible strain of the creation of the new
German state. His life's work was to
ensure that France and Russia never
allied, so that Germany would never be
surrounded. This was his nightmare,
his greatest fear. And in this,
like in many things, he turned out to be right.
He famously said that the great European
conflagration would come from some damn
fool thing in the Balkans, and he warned Kaiser
Wilhelm II that within 20 years,
his bellicose policies would destroy the Kaiser
Reich. And he was correct, almost
to the day. But he was fired
by Kaiser Wilhelm II, who has
too much historical baggage to get an accurate
view of. Suffice it to say that the Kaiser
often ends up with a reputation for feeling
inadequate. Having been born with a
withered arm and grown up hounded by his mother,
he came to believe that he had to prove he
was masculine, and so set out to break
with Bismarck's policies, and show that he was
his own man, by abandoning the German alliance
with Russia, and moving Germany towards a much
more expansionist stance. He was
known for being brash and impulsive, with little
tact, crumbling the carefully balanced
alliances that had for so long kept
the concert of Europe in place. Now, to
all this, we have to add one last piece
to the stage. Fear. The fear
of the dying empires. The fear of those
once great nations that now so clearly
saw the shadow of death approaching them from
behind. The Ottoman Empire, the
Austro-Hungarian Empire, and the Russian
Empire. The Ottoman Empire
was long known as the sick man of Europe.
Its decline had been long and slow,
with the surrounding nations taking bites out of its
carcass as it slowly died. The
Austro-Hungarian Empire looked at the fate of the
Ottomans, and saw shadows of what was to come.
They feared they'd be like the Ottomans,
dismantled, taken apart piece by piece
until they were too weak to fight back.
They had once been the most powerful state in Europe,
but they ruled over many nations, and many
peoples. And over the 19th century, those peoples
had asserted themselves, crying out for their own
nations, crying out to be free, to,
as people, decide their own fate. And so,
through the 19th century, the Austro-Hungarian
Empire saw its territory chipped
away, as the other great nations of the concert
of Europe ruled in their conferences that
those people had a right to be free. And with each
loss, those peoples that the Austro-Hungarian
Empire still maintained control of,
agitated for their own freedom to a greater and
greater extent, causing unrest that
rocked the empire to its very core.
And lastly, we have the Russians.
The Russian Tsars ruled the largest country
in the world, but, like the Ottomans, their
military, economy, and infrastructure were
woefully behind the times. And in 1905,
when the Russians lost a war with the
Japanese, the first time a European power
had lost a war to an Asian one in modern history,
their weakness became eminently
clear to the world. This loss
caused a revolution that forced the Tsar to
accept a parliament and a constitutional monarchy.
But it wasn't in the nature of Alexander
II to accept a parliament, and
he rebelled against these constraints, leaving
his country precariously perched on the verge of
revolution. So, with a new superpower
in the midst of Europe, fear driving
crumbling empires to irrational and desperate
decisions, and a group of leaders simply
not equal to their forebearers at the task
of guiding the ships of state, the players
are all in place. The stage is set,
and the curtain begins to rise on the war
to end all wars. Join us
next time for an improbable assassination,
the death of a prince, and a sandwich which
changed history.
