19th C Realism in Part 1 Daumier Courbet cc

Realism in Fine Art
22 followers
4 Video Views·Sep 12, 2025
For all the videos in order with study guides please visit,
https://www.kenneymencher.com/
This next lecture is on the 19th century in France, and we're going to be focusing on a style that's
called realism, but it also, sometimes if you go to museums, some of these artists will be
in the impressionist section as well. This artist that we're starting with named Henri Daumier,
he's actually a realist, but he's also a political cartoonist. And one of the things that I really
think is important to study about art history has to do with the idea of a continuum, that
there's a schema and then there's a correction that leads to the next phase. So if you think
about the subject matter of art up until this point in time, we actually started primarily with
religious art, and religious art that was in support of a propaganda that supported the
Catholic Church, primarily. And as we move forward, we got into some more secular kinds of imagery and
a little bit more secular humanism when we were discussing, for instance, classicism and classical
imagery, and then we moved into portraiture. And as we move forward in time, some of the things
that started changing a little bit had to do with art that was actually in the service of politics
and recording current events. One of the other things to keep in mind also about this sort of
continuum or this evolution of what's happening in terms of art and art history is that printmaking
is a big deal, too. And I want to remind you that we began studying printmaking primarily
with Albrecht Dürer, and one of the other printmakers who is kind of important is Rembrandt.
And then we moved into William Hogarth, and an interesting little detail about Hogarth was when
he started making these prints for popular consumption, there was an act passed in
Parliament because people were actually plagiarizing his prints, and the copyright laws were established
because there was this idea of intellectual rights and that people were stealing his ideas, and he got
that passed in Parliament. We also looked a little bit at Francisco de Goya, and we looked at his
personal prints, and he was using etching and aquatint. Now we're looking at a style of printmaking
that's called lithography. And lithography, if you break down the word, litho means stone,
and graphos means to write or make a mark. And so lithography is basically this technique. You can
actually even do it on metal plates, but what you do is you draw on the plate with a crayon,
and where you've drawn with the crayon, it sort of resists whatever the acid is that you're applying
to the top of this stone. And because crayons kind of skip and can create almost a value structure,
you get a lot of gray tones and a lot of really nice mixtures of value structure and shading.
And this kind of process of lithography was used in the 19th century in newspaper illustrations,
but also Daumier did it as a form of fine art. So one of the ideas that's kind of coming together
here is that there is a sort of confluence or coming together of high art and low art.
Popular arts, for instance, newspaper arts and fine arts are coming together in Daumier's work.
This is going to become a little bit more separate later on, especially in the 20th century, where
people start thinking of anything that's in a newspaper as an illustration and not a very fine
art, and that it's a cartoon, and that anything in a gallery is high art. But one of the things
that's happening then is the quality of art that's mass produced printmaking will eventually,
in some people's mind, not necessarily in mine, will drop off and they'll start calling
art that's published and mass produced as low art. I don't think that that's true,
that popular art is low art or bad art. Now all of this comes together in terms of iconography
and in terms of ideology. Daumier got himself into trouble with Louis Philippe, basically Napoleon's
nephew, who was in charge of France at that point in time. And this is a print that's more or less
kind of like the horrors of war that Goya produced, in which he is talking about something that is
straight out of Victor Hugo's Les Miserables. The streets of Paris are very narrow, or they were
very, very narrow. And all of the dislike of Louis Philippe's empire and regime sort of came
together in how the gendarmes, the police force, were seen or viewed during the 19th century in the
early 1800s. And there are actually stories about people building barricades across these very
narrow tiny streets, and that's going to come up in my lecture on Paris later on, how Louis Philippe
and Baron Haussmann restructured Paris. And what I'm suggesting is that this murder, well, it's
Rue Transonaine, and my pronunciation is really horrific when it comes to French, so
please forgive me if I botch any kinds of pronunciations in other languages, because I'm just
really terrible at it. But this scene is actually an event, a current events thing, in which the
police were going down these narrow streets, and what some of the revolutionaries in Paris would do
is they would go up onto the roofs, they would remove the paving stones, those big blocks of
stone, and they would drop them on people's heads and drop them on the police force's heads when
they were being pursued. And it was seen as a sort of guerrilla war tactic. And so what happened one
night was this happened, and the police stormed one of the buildings, but everybody was asleep
in their beds. These people weren't even responsible, and they killed everybody in the house.
And so Daumier is protesting the police action. It's almost like the DEA coming into someone's
house and getting something wrong. And you can see that this guy is, he's been murdered in his bed
cloth, in his bed clothes. Underneath his body is a child. To the right of him is an old man, and to
the left is clearly a female figure, and they've all been killed and pulled out of bed. Chairs are
overturned, and this was seen as a completely horrific kind of thing. Obviously it is. So this
ties in a bit with iconography of the past, where we've seen foreshortened and reclining figures
like this before, like for instance in Andrea Mantegna's Dead Christ. And in this foreshortened
figure, we have a pathos, we have this sort of sympathy for him. Now remember, when Mantegna
foreshortens this figure, he does it in a sort of awkward way. But Daumier, I think,
is doing it a little bit more accurately, but because he's almost a sort of cartoonist,
he's not as involved in accuracy in drawing as he is in really expressing something emotionally.
And in this way, he sort of shares something with Goya. But I also think that the sort of history
of foreshortened figures and showing martyrs as foreshortened figures, we also see that in
the conversion of Paul and some other images from Caravaggio. Now, one of the ideas here is a sort
of update of the original schema of a Christ-like martyr, and this everyday man. It's sort of a
genre scene, but a genre scene that is not necessarily an everyday scene. It's something
that is a completely horrific thing, and he's kind of showing you that this figure is almost
like how Jesus was killed, and that it's a sin in a way. It's man's inhumanity against his fellow
man. And that's very similar to some of the images that we saw in Jericho and in Romanticism.
So the lithographic process and how Daumier used it was really a very political thing for him.
And he used it to really say some things about the politics of the time. And in fact, there were
times when he was thrown in jail for this. And so one of the things that he's kind of expressing
in this gargantua is the idea that Louis-Philippe is a terrible ruler. And this ruler, what he's
doing is he's sort of eating up the resources of Paris, and he is pooping out edicts and paperwork
and he himself is a pear-shaped person, which is a kind of insult, I guess, in any language. If you
were to call someone pear-shaped, it means they're slope-shouldered and fat on the bottom.
And it's showing that his legs are useless and that he's just basically sort of this sort of
Minos-like character like we saw, for instance, in Giotto's painting of The Last Judgment.
Daumier also documented some of the things that were going on around Paris at this point in time
and some of the changes that were happening. And some of the big changes that were happening
are due to economic and changes in the infrastructure of Paris, literally.
So how does all this come together? Let me do a quick description of what's going on in Paris.
With the rise of industrialization, you have some things going on and one of the things that's
happening in Paris at this point in time is the influx of workers that are being brought in by
railroads and also by street carriages. So for instance, in Daumier's time, railroads and street
cars were being utilized to bring workers to and from areas and also to help commerce throughout
the city. And one of the things that is kind of important, it's because of industrialization and
the move towards urbanization that cities become more and more populated and there are more and
more opportunities to work and people literally need to start commuting across town. And so public
transportation becomes a necessity, especially since having a horse and carriage is very
expensive and they don't have cars. And so one of the things that he would do is he would sit on
the carriages and he liked to document life in these carriages. So this is a depiction of the
third class carriage. It ties in an awful lot with some of the things that Jean-Jacques Rousseau was
talking about, especially about the third estate, if you remember in the lecture on the French
Revolution, that Rousseau kind of talked about the peasant and worker class in a sort of aggrandizing
way, that they were noble in some ways. And I think that Daumier kind of takes that up and shares that.
I think we all want to believe of the idea that's actually something that's in the
New Testament, which is that the meek shall inherit the earth and that the poor are the salt of the
earth and that rich people in some ways are bad people. All of those things are sort of stereotypes
in a way that are meant to teach us to be humble and Daumier is kind of supporting that and Rousseau
kind of takes up that idea. And so he's showing you this third class carriage where these people
are sort of warm and humble and are leaning against each other. There's a grandmother,
there's a child, and there's a woman breastfeeding. And so the third class carriage is filled with
humanity, with a sort of kind look at humanity. And this painting that's oil on canvas, and this one
is in the National Gallery of Canada, also is taken up several times in other parts of his work.
And he does drawings of it and this drawing looks almost exactly like the other thing that we just
looked at. And if you zoom in a little bit more closely on this drawing, you'll see that there's
a sort of grid pattern on the drawing and that's why it looks exactly like that. Remember in some
of the earlier lectures, we talked about something called grid and transfer, which is literally a way
of putting a grid on a work of art and then transferring the drawing almost exactly by
drawing what you see in each one of the squares. So Daumier makes this image many times using the
grid and transferring. You can actually see the grid on this one as well. And this is an unfinished
oil on canvas of the same painting. And so for him, this image was very compelling and he approached
it several times and depicted it several times as a way to show how he felt about the third estate
in the third class carriage. Now the third estate also contains wealthy people now as well and
they're the upper class bourgeoisie. And let's take a look at how he viewed wealthy people as well.
In the first class carriage, compared to the third class carriage, I think what he's trying
to show us is almost how Jane Austen kind of depicts people in the 18th century and early
19th century. That these are people who are sort of detached, sanitized, they're not very
human-looking in the way that the third class on the right-hand side are looking.
None of them are smiling, really. They're all just kind of a little bit stern and detached.
And I think that that's a stereotype that's going to be coming out in some of the art of
the 19th century and of realism and of impressionism, that we're going to start
seeing a view of humanity. And this view of humanity is going to be sort of based in earlier
traditions and you can trace it back literally to the New Testament, where Jesus sort of talks about
the classes, where he talks about wealthy people versus poor people. But I think Jean-Jacques
Rousseau and in the American Revolution, there are these ideas that the peasant classes and the
working classes are taxed unfairly and that they're not seen in a positive enough light.
And there's this rising middle class and a rising lower middle class that I think that a lot of
artists tend to romanticize and look at in a very positive way. I'm not really sure if those
romanticizations of those things that are really accurate. I think that it's just basically based
in some sort of middle class guilt. And this romantic view of poor people is often shared
by fairly wealthy people. And that's where we start talking about Gustave Courbet. Gustave Courbet,
if you look at his biography, basically his father was a wealthy landowner and wanted him to go to
study law, wanted him to become more or less a lawyer or an academic. Sends him off to law school
and Courbet absolutely hates it. So if you think about it, his father is a gentleman farmer who's
fairly wealthy. And Courbet comes back to his dad and says, dad, I really hate this. And so his dad
replies more or less, check the facts on this, get a better biography than the one I'm giving you.
He says, well, if you fail, it's not going to be because of anything that I did. It's going to be
under your own steam. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to fund you. I'm going to get you some
teachers and I'm going to set you up in Paris as a painter. So Courbet, it's already too late for
him to get into the École des Beaux-Arts, that official school of art. And he starts painting
on his own. And his father actually provides him with studio space and gallery space, which is,
you know, something pretty radical that this artist is more or less promoting himself using
his father's money to do this stuff. And this is one of the most famous paintings he's did.
It's unfortunately, this painting has been destroyed, I think, in some of the bombings
during World War II. And we only have prints of it that exist, you know, basically photographic
prints. But this is pretty well documented. And I think it's neat that we can see it.
I've seen other Courbet paintings. And I think that one of the things that is worth noting about
it in terms of the formal stuff, so we'll start with a physical description, is that the surface
of these paintings are often a little rougher than you might expect of a painting. They have
what's called impastos, I-M-P-A-S-T-O-S. An impasto, it's basically a thicker kind of paint.
And I was taught that he actually painted an awful lot of his painting with palette knives,
that he would apply it with the flat of what almost looks like a butter knife, so that it
would have a sort of rough texture. We're going to talk about how that rough texture in those
impastos are sort of iconic for Courbet, because they represent the roughness of life.
And then another thing that I think is important to talk about in terms of this painting
is it probably takes a page out of some of the other painters who are the almost social realists
like Gruss that we looked at from earlier in Chardinan, that it's earth-toned, a little bit
of Velázquez-like color as well. But it also takes a page out of Gruss, for instance, because it's
set up kind of like a tableau, a stage-like design where these figures are in the foreground,
almost like actors, and that there's a dark background that sets them off as if they are
actors up on a stage. And in fact, it almost seems to me the way that we're looking at them,
that we're kind of looking at them on a tilted stage. So, let's talk about this in terms of
the iconography and what Courbet is supposedly saying with this. Remember, Courbet is a rich kid
and he is talking about the lower classes who are disenfranchised. And so, this is a scene that he
would have seen possibly even people working on his father's farm. And the kid is way too young
to be doing this kind of work. What they're doing is they're breaking stones and, you know,
I almost feel like he meant that literally as a sort of pun that they're breaking their stones
to make a living. And so, this kid is very young. He is carrying this basket of rocks and they're
clearing stones from fields and breaking up stones so that farming and roads can be built.
And the guy on the right-hand side is way too old to be doing this work. I think there's also
another element that they're anonymous, that both of them, you can't see their faces. And so,
they are sort of the anonymous poor that we tend to not look at. I recently judged a high school
show of photography and painting. And I was amazed at how many kids from this very affluent,
wealthy community would go and take pictures of homeless people who were clearly down and out
and depicted them in a very picturesque way as if we're supposed to have sympathy for these people.
But the kids who are doing it, I don't think they're putting their money where their mouth is.
I think that the same thing is going on with Courbet. And I don't mean to offend anybody with
this. I think it's human nature to look at these people and be fascinated by people who are less
better off than us and who are doing things that are socially what we would never do.
But I think Courbet is sort of playing on this and he plays on this with the roughness of the
texture and with the color. And so, this is a realist painting because he's trying to show
you the realism of life. I think a lot of this stuff ties in with some of the literature that
was being produced in the 19th century, especially when Courbet was painting. And so,
for instance, Victor Hugo's Les Miserables has scenes that kind of depict these disenfranchised
and sort of abused lower class people. Jean Valjean in Victor Hugo's Les Miserables
is a guy who basically is being pursued by a cop for years for stealing a loaf of bread to
feed his kid. But there's other writers, Emile Zola and Gustave Flaubert, who are also taking
up this sort of mantle of realism and showing some of these people. And I think Flaubert,
in particular, in Madame Bovary and also a short story that I have in my textbook that I've asked
my students to read called A Simple Heart. It's a really easy read. And I think it's about 40
pages long, 30 pages long. And it's a really good story. And it basically sort of documents in a
sort of rough, matter-of-fact way the life of a servant woman and how she sees the world.
And because we are so educated, we see her almost like she's an ant in a microscope.
And there's this way of looking at her that you could either see her as being someone who's a
very sympathetic character or see her as someone who is a very stupid character. And I think
Courbet kind of has shades of that in all of his paintings. So, for instance, this painting,
Burial at Ornans, is a painting that really depicts the same kinds of imagery that we see,
especially in Victor Hugo's novels, where these are poor people who are in the countryside,
who are going to a burial. And in the center of the composition of this enormous painting,
it's 51 by 58 inches, you have this grave. And it always reminds me of Charles Dickens'
A Christmas Carol, where Scrooge is looking at his grave and then death sort of throws him into
the grave to show him that if he doesn't get right with God and doesn't get right with humanity,
something's going to happen to him. And this is a mass of humanity standing in a tableau,
almost like a stage set. And we see the lawyers with their red gowns on the left-hand side,
we see the priest. If you look closely at some of these people's faces, they're not
very good-looking people, they're very rough-looking people. And that cross sort of rises above it,
almost like the mast in Jericho's Raft of the Medusa. It's almost like this thing that
these poor, simple hearts, like the story Flaubert wrote, the simple hearts,
would see as something that would redeem them, and that there's supposedly a dignity to their
ugliness. All of those are interpretations that have been brought forward by my teachers, and I
think that those are probably pretty accurate points of view, that Courbet is looking at this
third estate almost as if he has a pity for them, and he's looking at these lower-middle-class
people and saying that their faith is saving them. But I also think that there's a bit of
a sarcastic kind of view of religion in this as well, almost like the Marxist idea where he said
religion is the opiate of the masses, and that it lulls the middle classes and the lower classes
into behaving themselves, and that religion has been often used as a tool of control.
And I suspect that may be part of what he's saying. Just to combat that point of view for
a second, though not necessarily about this painting, I remember listening to an inner-city
preacher once, and he said, you know, religion is not the opiate of the masses. Opium is the opiate
of the masses, and drugs are the opiate of the masses. And I think that that's probably a little
bit more accurate, a little bit more true. So this painting is really a monumental painting
that's meant to make us see things in a different way. Again, we have local colors. It's painted in
a very rough kind of style, which is meant to depict the rough lifestyle of these people.
Now, something else is going on in the 19th century that Courbet is probably reacting against
in some ways, and I think that this cartoon and this painting on the right-hand side
really tell us the story of how he's reacting against them. In past lectures, I discussed the
founding of the academic tradition that was really, it started even before Jacques-Louis
David, but the official style of the academic tradition was to use classicism and also to use
Orientalism, and that it was almost an emperor's new clothes kind of deal, where there were all of
these classical figures, but they were basically excuses to look at new figures, and that in
Orientalism, it was the same kind of thing, and it was a way of creating some sort of political
control. And I love what Daumier has done with this cartoon, because he's sort of revealing
emperor's new clothes style. If you haven't read that story, you need to just look it up on the
internet, the emperor's new clothes. And basically what he's doing is these innocent middle-class
women are kind of going through the official school, the salon is the official school's
exhibition every year of the accepted work, and you can see all these nude figures above them,
and the women are like kind of throwing their hands up and saying, there's always venuses in
the show, this year venuses again. And what they're commenting on is that even though they're supposed
to be sort of dignified and conservative middle-class people, what's with all the naked
people and all the sort of sexy naked women? And then as long as you put the title underneath it,
it's a Venus, all of a sudden you're allowed to look at something that is literally just kind of
a dirty little painting. And I think that this is a way of showing that, and that artists and writers
and social critics were aware that the traditions they had were sort of corrupt and bankrupt already,
and that the depictions of classical themes were no longer meant to call people to a higher ideal,
but were being used more or less almost for semi-pornographic purposes. Well, remember that
there's a sort of battle between the romantics and the bohemians against the classical school
of art, and we talked about this in the lecture on romanticism and orientalism, and that in some
ways the romantics are the fathers of the realist movement evidenced by Corbet, and that these people
are really trying to make a social change, and that interestingly enough, the people who are in
the official school, the academic school that's being supported by Louis Philippe, are supporting
and defending the older traditions that have been around now for more than 100 years, and
the classical traditions, and that they're trying to create change through art in a way, and that's
what some of those authors are trying to do, and some of the romantic poets like Baudelaire.
So, how is this brought about? Well, what kind of changes happen?
