LIVE: Keir Starmer At Prime Minister's Questions Amid Labour Deputy Leadership Crisis
Sep 11, 2025 #Keirstarmer #Politicians
by Ofcom. There are found to be deficiencies in practice by any of the firms that he mentioned.
We will, I'm sure, be taking appropriate action.
We go to topical, Susan Murray.
Question one, Mr Speaker.
Sirius Tate.
Mr Speaker, I'm delighted to join the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology. This
is a crucial area for our country, providing opportunities for jobs, for work and to improve
our public services. And as Secretary of State, I'm getting to work straight away.
As I've said, on Monday, I strengthened the law to add further protections from dangerous
self-harm material online. So social media companies have to take action now, not just
to remove this material, but prevent it from coming up in the first place, so that the
internet can live up to its real potential as a place of opportunity, where everyone
can learn, connect and be creative, free from fear.
Susan Murray.
Can I also welcome the Right Honourable Member to her place?
Mr Speaker, the Right Honourable Member's predecessor warned that losing control of
artificial general intelligence would be catastrophic, yet failed to deliver legislation to protect
the public. Will the new Secretary of State deliver on the AI Bill and ensure that the
British people benefit from the advantages of AI without becoming its victims?
I absolutely want to ensure that people, businesses, creatives throughout this country can benefit
from the huge opportunities that technological developments and AI promise, but make sure
that people are protected too. I am early in this job, I am listening carefully to all
those involved, but wherever action is required, that is what I will do.
Peter Lough.
Thank you Mr Speaker. Could I ask the Secretary of State what conversations have taken place
with UKRI around supporting the development of new sustainable transport technologies,
and how might this benefit constituencies such as mine and Crawley?
My Honourable Friend will know that UKRI is a world leader in research and innovation
over the spending review. We are delivering £86 billion for research and development,
which is actually a record level. UKRI invests more than £300 million a year in transport
innovation, with sustainability being a key focus. That includes projects to develop new
aviation fuel production technologies that could reduce emissions by up to 80%. There
is more that we can do here. I know that the right hon. Gentleman is passionate about this
issue and either I or my Ministers will be very happy to meet him to talk more about
what we can do.
We now come to the Shadow Secretary of State. I welcome her to her new position.
Julie Lopez.
Thank you Mr Speaker. I welcome the new Secretary of State to her place, and of course her stellar
team. The right hon. Member for Edinburgh South is so hot that he snared two jobs from
the guy who just fired him. As tech Secretary, she replaces the Ozempic of Whitehall, who
claimed his digital plan would shear £45 billion of fat from the Government. By how
much did it cut the civil service?
Let me say to the hon. Lady that I believe that using tech and AI to modernise our public
services actually enables people who work in the public sector to spend more time on
the things that they want, which is serving the users of public services, and less time
filling out all the red tape and bureaucracy, much of which was put in place by her Government.
Julie Lopez.
I fully agree with her, but the number of civil servants has risen to a 20-year high
under Labour. If somebody in the private sector led a reverse efficiency drive, they would
get sacked. Labour makes him Business Secretary. For a welfare meltdown, you get to be the
Minister for the Future, and as AI screams for cheap electricity, the Prime Minister
cannot sack his failing Energy Secretary. Why should the tech sector believe that this
is a Government of delivery?
Because this Government believe that science, technology and innovation are how this country
will seize the opportunities of the future. Unlike Members opposite, we are determined
to deliver that change for people in every part of the country, no matter where they
live, because our people are our best asset. We want to grow the economy, transform our
public services and sort out the mess that was left by Members opposite.
Too many of my constituents in Lichfield, Burntwood and the villages are struggling
with appalling mobile signal. It is a problem we see across the country, and it is often
worse in rural areas. What steps is the ministerial team taking to ensure that the Government's
review of the mobile market leads to a faster roll-out of 5G?
We cannot ensure that everybody in this country benefits from being online and the developments
that are there unless everybody is joined up to fast broadband. We have put £1.8 billion
over the spending review into making this connectivity work. I am working closely with
Building Digital UK. If the right hon. Gentleman has concerns about his constituents, he should
come in, meet me and them to get his constituents online, because that is how they will seize
the opportunities of the future.
We now come to Prime Minister's questions. I call Dr Luke Evans, No. 1, Prime Minister.
Can I start by expressing our sincere condolences to His Majesty the King and the royal family
on the death of Her Royal Highness the Duchess of Kent? Her life was filled with compassion
and dignity. She dutifully supported our late Queen Elizabeth II, comforted the runner-up
at Wimbledon and worked anonymously as a music teacher in Hull, typical of her unassuming
nature and human touch. Our thoughts, and I am sure the whole House's thoughts, are
with His Royal Highness the Duke of Kent, his family and all those whose lives she touched.
Turning to other events, I condemn the strikes that Israel carried out in Doha yesterday.
They violate Qatar's sovereignty. They do nothing to secure the peace that the UK and
so many of our allies are committed to. I spoke to the Amir of Qatar last night, soon
after the attack, to convey our support and solidarity. He was crystal clear that, not
withstanding the attacks, he would continue to work on a diplomatic solution to achieve
a ceasefire and a two-state outcome. He and I are on the same mind on this. That is why
I met President Abbas on Monday and why I will meet President Herzog later on today.
I will be absolutely clear that we condemn Israel's action. I will also be clear that
restrictions on aid must be lifted, the offensive in Gaza must stop and settlement building
must cease. However difficult, the UK will not walk away from a diplomatic solution.
We will negotiate and we will strain every sinew, because that is the only way to get
the hostages out, to get aid in and to stop the killing.
Mr Speaker, last night Russia launched drones into Poland in an unprecedented attack. I
have been in touch with the Polish Prime Minister this morning to make clear our support for
Poland and will stand firm in our support for Ukraine. With our partners and through
our leadership of the coalition willing, we will continue to ramp up the pressure on Putin
until there is a just and lasting peace.
This morning I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others. In addition to my duties
in this House, I shall have further such meetings later today.
Just to say to the House, I have sent a letter on behalf of Parliament,
a letter of condolence to the Royal Family on behalf of the Staten Islanders.
Right, let us come back to Dr Lukas.
Here, one year on, the country has seen a transport secretary resign over fraud,
an anti-corruption minister investigated for corruption, a homelessness minister make tenants
homeless and a housing secretary not pay tax on a second house. Prime Minister, we have also had
a Prime Minister who accepted more freebies than any other MP in the last Parliament.
Is this the integrity he meant when he came to Government?
Well, Mr Speaker, here is the difference. I strengthened the ministerial code.
I strengthened the independent adviser. The Deputy Prime Minister referred to herself
as the adviser. It was a clear finding and she did the right thing. Mr Speaker, contrast that
with the shadow Foreign Secretary. She was found to have broken the code under the last Government.
What did the Prime Minister do then, Mr Speaker? He ignored that. There was a resignation,
but that was the resignation of the adviser, not the person who is found to have breached the code,
and she still sits on their front bench. That is the difference.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. After almost two decades of the SNP and 14 years of the Tories,
Kirkcaldy High Street has been in a state of decline. That is why the Chancellor was right
to prioritise Kirkcaldy for multimillion-pound regeneration funding from the New Growth Mission
to build on the enormous potential of our town and beautiful seafront.
Does the Prime Minister agree that investment over decline is key to this Labour Government,
and will he ask the new Business Secretary to meet me to discuss this funding?
Well, I thank her for her question. She has been a tireless campaigner for investment
into her high street. Mr Speaker, I can give her good news because, thanks to funding committed
by the Chancellor and this Labour Government, I can confirm today that, subject to business
case approval, we will approve millions to transform Kirkcaldy's high street and seafront.
I will, of course, make sure she gets the meeting she wants with the Business Secretary.
The SNP has squandered the potential of these high streets for two decades.
Next year, people can vote for positive change with a Scottish Labour Government.
We come to the Leader of the Opposition, Kevin Baird.
Mr Speaker, can I associate myself with the comments the Prime Minister made about the
Duchess of Kent? She lived an exemplary life of public service and she will be very much missed.
I also agree with the Prime Minister, as should all of us in this House.
We stand shoulder to shoulder with Poland and all our NATO allies against Putin's aggression.
A NATO country has just had to defend itself against Russian drones. Now, more than ever,
we need our ambassador to Washington fully focused on this issue and liaising closely
with America. Does the Prime Minister have full confidence in Peter Mandelson?
Mr Speaker, let me start by saying that the victims of Epstein are at the forefront of our
minds. He was a despicable criminal who committed the most heinous crimes and destroyed the lives
of so many women and girls. The ambassador has repeatedly expressed his deep regret for his
association with him. He's right to do so. I have confidence in him and he's playing an
important role in the UK-US relationship. This is interesting, Mr Speaker. He says the
has expressed full regret, but the victims of the paedophile Jeffrey Epstein have called for
Lord Mandelson to be sacked. And just so the House is aware, in 2019, Jeffrey Epstein was convicted
of child prostitution and sex trafficking that took place between 2002 and 2005. That is the
precise period which Lord Mandelson called Jeffrey Epstein his best pal. Was the Prime Minister aware
of this intimate relationship when he appointed Lord Mandelson to be our ambassador in Washington?
Mr Speaker, as she and the House would expect, full due process was followed during this
appointment, as it is with all ambassadors. The ambassador has repeatedly expressed his
deep regret. He is right to do so. He's now playing an important part in the US-UK relationship.
Mr Speaker, I asked the Prime Minister if he knew. The fact that he didn't answer
indicates that he probably did know. I wasn't asking a question about process,
I was asking a question about his judgment. The Daily Telegraph reports today that while
Lord Mandelson was business secretary, he brokered a deal with Jeffrey Epstein while
he was business secretary, and that this occurred after Epstein had been convicted
of child sex offences. Given this new information, does the Prime Minister really think
it is tenable for our ambassador to remain in post? Mr Speaker, the relationship between the
US and the UK is one of our foremost relationships, and I have confidence in the ambassador in the
role that he is doing. Mr Speaker, I think it is embarrassing that the Prime Minister is still
saying that he has confidence in a man who was brokering deals with convicted child sex offenders
while sitting in government. That is a disgrace. This government has repeatedly, repeatedly refused
to declare Lord Mandelson's full interests, and as part of the appointment, there will have been
extensive government vetting, including details and timings of Peter Mandelson's dealings with
Jeffrey Epstein. So will the Prime Minister publish all these documents, including those
about his interests? Mr Speaker, as I say, a full due process was gone through in relation
to this appointment, as would be expected. As for the publication of documents, as she well knows,
that is subject to a procedure which includes an independent element. It is subject to the usual
procedure. The Prime Minister cannot answer any questions. That is not the behaviour of someone
who has full confidence. The ambassador should be in the White House talking about how we respond
to an incursion into NATO airspace. Instead, he is giving interviews about himself to The Sun.
This is a man who already had to be removed from Cabinet twice, and now we learn that he was
brokering billion-pound deals with Jeffrey Epstein while being Business Secretary. I did not get a
proper answer. He is talking about process. This is not about process. This is about judgment.
Just last week, I told him that he should sack his Deputy Prime Minister. They all cheered
and congratulated themselves. She was gone two days later, his face too is broken,
and he has a wholly new front bench. Will he make sure that these documents are published,
and will he instruct Peter Mandelson to publish all his correspondence with Jeffrey Epstein?
The Prime Minister says that the ambassador should be in the White House discussing NATO. He is,
as we all are, with a number of international calls this morning,
and on Ukraine, as well as the attack in Doha yesterday.
I see that the Prime Minister is finally catching up with the questions that she should have asked
about the Deputy Prime Minister. In the meantime, we have opened up a new schools-based nursery.
On Monday, we have the defence industrial strategy. On Tuesday, we published NHS league
tables to push up standards. We reopened Doncaster and Sheffield Airport yesterday,
and today we have set out how we are repairing the concrete in our hospitals.
A load of waffle and whataboutery. All they are interested in right now is their pointless
deputy leadership election, while the country is out there suffering from an economic crisis.
The Prime Minister has an ambassador mired in scandal, not focusing on NATO. He lost his Deputy
Prime Minister just last week for evading taxes. He has a new Home Secretary and a new Foreign
Secretary who are just learning the ropes and are not able to help with this issue. We have strikes
crippling our capital city and damaging our economy. He could use minimum service legislation,
which we introduced, to make the lives of the people out there better, but he will not,
because he does not have the backbone to face down the unions. The unions are running this
Government, and all the deputy leadership candidates are chasing after them. While
with this Government, it is more strikes, more scandal and more chaos. The link between all of
his bad decisions, his bad judgment and his total weakness.
Our deputy leadership contest started this week and ends on 25 October. Their leadership contest
has been going on for months and will continue for a very long time. This noise from the arsonists
while we are putting out the fires that they left behind. Interest rates and waiting lists are down.
Wages, investment and food production are up, and now we are stepping up defence spending,
creating new jobs, driving up standards in our NHS and rebuilding our crumbling schools
and hospitals. This is a Government of patriots fighting for working people.
This Labour Government are getting our NHS back on its feet, with 20,000 fewer patients on waiting
lists at my local trust since the election, but there is still more to do, including making it
easier to see a GP. Can the Prime Minister set out how this Government will give my constituents
in East Worthing and Shoreham access to the healthcare that they deserve?
I am very pleased that we have made progress on the NHS. We promised 2 million extra appointments
in the first year of a Labour Government. We have delivered not two, not three, but over 4 million
extra appointments, with 2,000 extra GPs and clearing up the dangerous rack in our hospitals.
The National League tables that we published this week will make sure that investment goes where
it is needed most, and our 10-year health plan will see neighbourhood health centres in every
community to treat patients closer to home. There is more to do, but we have made a lot of progress.
Sir Ed David, Leader of the Liberal Democrats.
Can I join the Prime Minister in sending our condolences to his Majesty and the royal family
on the death of the Duchess of Kent? I echo the Prime Minister's condemnation of Netanyahu's
attacks on Qatar. These are not the actions of a leader truly focused on getting hostages home,
and I hope the Prime Minister will say that directly to President Herzog later today.
On Suicide Prevention Day, can I thank all working to prevent suicides, from professionals
to charities like the Samaritans? When I talk to parents of disabled children,
there is one complaint about government that comes up time and again. All the hoops
they must jump through, from EHCPs to the DWP to HMRC. Caring is exhausting enough without all
the forms and rules that show no understanding of the realities of life as a carer. That is
something Emily and I know well, and it is something that the now former Deputy Prime
Minister brought attention to last week. Will the Prime Minister work with carers across this House
to overhaul systems for family carers, so that government works much better for people looking
after their loved ones? I do not agree with the Prime Minister. There are too many hurdles and
hoops that have to be gone through, and that is why we are simplifying the system. We will, of
course, work across the House with all those who want to achieve that outcome. I also thank those
dealing with suicide prevention. I think probably everybody in this House knows someone who has
taken their life. It touches all of us, and we must do everything we can together to prevent suicide.
Sir Ed Davie. Moving on, Mr Speaker, as the Leader of the Opposition said,
Lord Mandelson has omitted to continuing his relationship long after Epstein was convicted,
and there are more embarrassing details we do not yet know.
Mr Speaker, people will be surprised by the Prime Minister giving Ambassador Mandelson
such strong support today, so can he tell the House, has the Prime Minister asked the Ambassador
what other compromising material the Trump Administration might have on him
as he leads Britain's negotiations with the White House?
Well, Mr Speaker, as I have made clear to the House,
a full due process was gone through when the appointment was made.
George Sturbery. Thank you, Mr Speaker. My constituent, Conor Edwards, lives with Ehlers-Danlos
syndrome and cranioservical instability, which in his words means his head is slowly falling
off his body. Having once enjoyed fishing and mountain biking at the age of 30,
Conor is now largely bed-bound and says his condition has destroyed his quality of life.
He is also having to crowdfund for treatment in Spain because the NHS cannot give him the
help he needs. Could the Prime Minister ensure that myself, Conor and EDS charities get a meeting
with the Minister to discuss what more we can do to give thousands of people like Conor their
freedom back? Mr Speaker, I have read through the details of Conor's case that have just been
summarised. It is heartbreaking. I do thank my Honourable Friend for consistently campaigning
and championing all of those who are affected. I will make sure that he gets the meetings
that he needs so that we can hear from Conor and others and learn from their experience.
Gaza is a graveyard, but rather than end arms sales, extend sanctions and stand by international
law, the Prime Minister will today welcome into his home, a home entrusted to him by the people
of these isles, the man who called for the collective punishment of the Palestinian people
and who signed the artillery shells that destroyed their homes, their families and their friends.
A man who will ignore every word the Prime Minister says. Would he invite Vladimir Putin
into number 10? Would he invite Benjamin Netanyahu into number 10? What does it say
of this Prime Minister that he will harbour this man whilst children starve?
Mr Speaker, for the record, we have suspended arms that could be used in Gaza,
we have sanctioned extremists, we have suspended trade talks, but the point he raised is a very
serious one. We all want an outcome that ensures peace, that the hostages get out,
that aid gets in and a two-state outcome. It is the only way we will get peace in a region that
suffered conflict for a very, very long time. I will not give up on diplomacy.
That is the politics of students.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Let's talk about fracking. It contaminates the water table,
it causes air pollution, the test drilling in Lancashire led to earthquakes,
so will the Prime Minister stand up to the climate deniers? Will he ban fracking once and for all,
and does he agree that those who are backing it are supporting fracking stupid reform?
Mr Speaker, we will ban fracking for good, and let's be absolutely clear,
the biggest risk to energy prices is staying hooked onto volatile international fossil
fuel markets, and in stark contrast to reform, they're ignoring local communities,
they're putting green jobs and investment at risk, and committing to higher bills
by warning renewable companies not to invest. That is shocking.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. A few short weeks ago, a constituent of mine died in a tragic fire
at the Lady Bailey residential park in Winterbourne, Whitechurch. That was attended
by 50 Dorset and Wiltshire firefighters and others. This summer alone, 900 grassland,
woodland and crop fires have equalled the busiest year on record for that fire service. I extend my
thanks to all of them for all that they do. He will be aware that rural funding is always an
issue, and the funding of rural services, the delivery of rural services is always a challenge.
Would he arrange for a meeting with the relevant Minister in the Home Office,
for the senior officials at that fire service and me to meet to discuss the needs of our rural area,
to ensure that my constituents and those across the counties of Dorset and Wiltshire
are kept as safe as they possibly can be?
Can I say I'm very sorry to hear about the particular case that he raises, and I'm sure
the thoughts of the whole House are with the friends and family of the constituent that he's
referenced. Our thoughts are actually with all of those affected, particularly farmers. I want
to join him in thanking our firefighters who've worked tirelessly to keep people safe. We have
provided Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Authority with an increased budget of almost £75
million, and I will make sure that he gets the meeting that he asks for to ensure that we can
properly support our firefighters and protect our farmland.
John Trickett.
Thank you, sir. This morning I spoke to the parents of a young man who's unemployed in my
constituency. There are 20 people on the dole in my area for every job that's been advertised.
Unemployment is a personal crisis and a social crisis. Will the Prime Minister join with me
in reminding the House that unemployment is not a price worth paying, which the Opposition party
clearly believes? And will the Prime Minister indicate that he will break
with the failed economic orthodoxy which suggests that such a thing is true?
Mr Speaker, I'm pleased that the employment rate is up, inactivity is down, and we've created over
380,000 jobs since we've been in power. Mr Speaker, going further, as a proud Yorkshire
man, he will know, and he will welcome, the reopening of Doncaster Sheffield Airport just
yesterday, made possible by the decisions that we've made. That's a Labour mayor working with
a Labour government to create jobs across the country.
Mr Speaker, 51 Israeli arms companies are exhibiting at the DSEI arms fair in London
this week. Some of them even boast that their products are battle-tested. We all know what
that means, used to kill men, women and children. So this government often asks us what more we
expect them to do when it comes to Gaza. Here's one. Will the Prime Minister stop Israeli arms
dealers from parading their Gaza-tested weapons on UK soil? Mr Speaker, we have very clear and
strict rules in relation to this, and we have taken action in relation to arms sales.
Thank you Mr Speaker, and can I thank the Prime Minister for his sympathy and words of condolence
regarding the sudden and untimely death of Hefin David, our Welsh Member of the Senate for Caerphilly.
His contributions over the last 18 years as a councillor and a Member of the Senate since
2016 were always relevant, witty and incisive, and our thoughts are with his partner and his family.
Drone Evolution is a manufacturer based in Caerphilly, and Airbus in Newport West are
just two of the companies that will benefit from Labour's investment in defence. So can I welcome
this new defence industrial strategy and ask the Prime Minister to update the House on how the new
defence growth zones will create more jobs across Wales and beyond? Mr Speaker, Hefin was a proud
Welshman and champion for Caerphilly, and we send our love and support to his partner Vicky,
his daughters, to his family and his friends. Wales does have a thriving defence sector,
and I'm delighted it will host one of our new defence growth zones. That's investing £250
million to make defence an engine for jobs and growth across the United Kingdom. That's what
you get, Mr Speaker, when you have a Labour Government in both Cardiff and Westminster
working together to deliver for Wales. Mr Speaker, my local borough commander in Romford
tells me how much valuable police time is being wasted investigating trivial social media posts
and non-crime hate incidents. Shouldn't the police be patrolling our streets rather than
moderating the internet, Mr Speaker? So, will the Prime Minister commit to urgently updating
the Public Order Act to reflect the realities of the digital age so that our police are focused
on tackling real crime and upholding freedom of speech rather than suppressing it?
Well, Mr Speaker, I've been clear on a number of occasions, I do want the police to concentrate
on serious crime and on crime that matters most to our communities in each of our constituencies.
I've said that before and I'll say it again today.
People in Crackley and Bradwell and Whitecross and Newcastle underline a sick and tired of
anti-social behaviour going untackled. I welcome the Government's commitment to
taking back our streets, but we need action. So, will he join me in urging the Conservative
Police Commissioner in Staffordshire to use the resources that he's been given to support our
local police and to finally get a grip so my constituents can live their lives free of hustle
and, most importantly, safely? Well, Mr Speaker, the party opposite decimated
neighbourhood policing. People should feel safe in their communities and that's exactly why I've
committed to putting 13,000 additional police personnel back in our town centres and communities.
That means, Mr Speaker, there will be a named police officer in every community,
armed with tough new respect orders to break up anti-social behaviour.
These powers are contained in our Crime and Policing Bill, which the party opposite,
in reform, voted against.
His Majesty's prison, Stoke Heath in Shropshire, has seen six deaths in custody in less than
two years. That is above the national average. Will the Prime Minister join me in calling upon
the Ministry of Justice to ensure that there are enough resources and the right governance
is in place at Stoke Heath? The Secretary of State for Justice will look into this and take up the
suggestion and I'll arrange for a meeting as soon as possible.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Vaccinations were invented in Barclay, in my constituency,
230 years ago and, as a GP, I have jabbed literally thousands of children and adults.
Would the Prime Minister update the House about our new rollout of chicken pox vaccinations,
which will further protect our children? And would he also agree with me to condemn
other political parties that give platforms for people who spread false rumours about vaccination?
Well, my Honourable Friend speaks with great authority and I'm proud
that Labour are protecting half a million children by rolling out the chicken pox vaccines.
In stark contrast, the man who wrote Reform's health policy has made shocking and baseless
claims that vaccines are linked to cancer and that's been endorsed by Reform. They laugh,
they laugh at it. These dangerous conspiracies cost lives and it shows that Reform can't be
trusted with our NHS. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Seneca Solar Farm, which runs through my constituency,
was given permission by this Government and there are more solar farm applications in the pipeline.
My constituents are concerned that these are being made without a land use framework,
which would have provided reassurances that the competing demands for land are balanced
effectively. Will the Prime Minister make a commitment to give the land use framework
statutory weight to ensure that land is used strategically to get the best for new, clean,
renewable energy, which genuinely benefits communities and for farmers, nature, water and
housing? Mr Speaker, it is important that we move to renewables in order to have energy
independence and to keep our bills down and this will benefit lots of communities, including her
own. I do want to reassure her constituents that we will of course follow process and that they
will always have a say in any decisions that we make. The leasehold system is fundamentally broken.
Thousands of leaseholders in Hendon are getting a raw deal, paying ever-rising service charges
for ever poorer services. It's why I welcome the Government's commitment to end the feudal
system of leasehold once and for all. Will the Prime Minister share with the House what action
this Government are taking to help leaseholders and bring in a system of commonhold?
Well, Mr Speaker, the last Government shattered the dream of home ownership.
We are reforming the outdated system so leaseholders receive stronger rights, powers
and protections. We will bring to an end the feudal leasehold system, reinvigorate commonhold
and deliver the biggest boost to social and affordable housing in a generation.
Dr Al Pinkerton.
Oh, thank you Mr Speaker. Since May, my Surrey Heath constituent, Sue, has received thousands
of pounds worth of fines after a criminal gang in London cloned her number plate and went on
a rampage through the capital. In an age of increasingly sophisticated digital security,
the number registration system seems like a remarkably analogue anachronism, is ripe for
abuse and is failing drivers. Will the Prime Minister look at my presentation bill laid last
week, pick it up and strengthen legislation, ensure police services have the tools they
require to tackle this growing crime and to protect law-abiding motorists?
Well, can I say I'm sorry to hear about his constituent. That's an awful
situation for anyone to find themselves in. I'll of course look at his bill.
Dr Rupert.
Thank you Mr Speaker. I'm sure the Prime Minister recalls visiting the Ukrainian community of Acton
with me soon after Putin's illegal invasion. They still fondly do and they wanted me to ask him
next week at Trump's state visit, can he harness his unique role with US influence
and the coalition of the willing in Europe to the max and redouble all efforts to find a just
peace with security guarantees for them and war crimes punished so that we can end this war that's
gone on far too long? I do recall the visit, it was extremely good and very welcoming and our
support for Ukraine Mr Speaker remains unwavering and the attack last night in Poland shows that
Putin's belief that he can somehow act with impunity and that's why we're working so hard
with the coalition of the willing to ensure that there are security guarantees as we go forward,
made real progress in recent weeks. We must continue to ramp up the pressure on Putin.
Today is the 10th annual Back British Farming Day
and given the Prime Minister is so keen on resets in recent weeks,
will he reset his relationship with our farmers and reverse the family farm tax?
Well Mr Speaker let me tell you what we're doing, we're working with the former president
of the National Farmers Union, Baroness Minette Batters to review farm profitability. Mr Speaker
this is the key issue, we are delivering the 25-year farming roadmap and of course we've
struck a deal with the EU which is of great benefit to farmers which of course they all
say they will reverse. Mr Speaker that's on top of the five billion pounds that we put into farming
in our last budget. Final question Liz Twist. Thank you Mr Speaker. Today is World Suicide
Prevention Day. It can be scary to talk about suicide but we need to. So many of our constituents
will know or love someone who has taken their own life or they may have suicidal thoughts themselves
but suicide is not inevitable, it's preventable and everyone has a role to play in saving lives.
So will the Prime Minister reaffirm this government's commitment to preventing deaths
by suicide and say how the government is tackling this vital issue?
Mr Speaker can I start by thanking her and paying tribute to her for her work as my PPS
for the last 14 months. She has worked tirelessly with huge commitment and respect
across the whole of this house. In relation to suicide prevention I think this is something
that matters to everybody in this house. I will reaffirm our commitment and I'll work across the
house with all members to deal with suicide prevention. We'll let the front benches change
for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs to make a statement on the implications of Israel's
strike in Gaza for peace and stability in the Middle East and on UK foreign policy.
Minister. Mr Speaker the UK government is deeply concerned by Israel's strike in Doha yesterday.
As the house heard a few minutes ago from the Prime Minister he and the Foreign Secretary
have condemned these fragrant violations of Qatar's sovereignty which will set back the
cause for peace and risk further escalation in the region. The Prime Minister spoke to the
Emir of Qatar to express the UK's solidarity and support and to reaffirm our shared commitment to
regional stability. The Prime Minister also gave his condolences for the death of a Qatari security
officer killed in the attack. Sadly Qatar's Ministry of Interior has overnight confirmed
the death of a second person. Qatar is playing a critical role Mr Speaker in mediating this conflict
driving efforts to secure a ceasefire and to facilitate vital humanitarian access to Gaza.
That must remain the priority. This government continues to support them in their efforts
to push for an immediate ceasefire, for the release of all hostages cruelly detained by
Hamas, for the protection of civilians and the unrestricted flow of aid into Gaza as the vital
first steps towards long-term peace and stability. This is the only way to achieve lasting peace and
security for Palestinians and Israelis alike. That is why we are working with partners to develop a
framework for peace that addresses governance, security, humanitarian access and political
reform. Negotiation not more violence is the way to achieve that. We are actively working together
with our international partners including the G7 and the UN Security Council to coordinate efforts
aimed at de-escalation and reiterate our full support for the sovereignty of Qatar.
Earlier this week the Prime Minister met with President Abbas to discuss the intolerable
situation in Gaza, the need for an urgent solution to end horrific suffering and famine
and the Palestinian Authority's reform agenda vital for a two-state solution.
Today Mr Speaker the Prime Minister will meet President Herzog of Israel
and reiterate the Ukraine's grave concern following yesterday's strikes and reiterate
that man-made famine in Gaza must end and the renewed offensive in Gaza must not happen.
We will continue to push for a political resolution to end this conflict and strive
towards a lasting peace. Thank you Mr Speaker for granting this application for an urgent question
and I'm grateful to the Minister for his statement. Last night's Israeli strikes against
Hamas officials in Gata heralded a new and grave escalation in this terrible conflict.
Prime Minister Netanyahu's willingness to strike Doha will undermine efforts to secure the release
of the hostages still held in Hamas captivity and set back the path to a desperately needed ceasefire.
Liberal Democrats have called for more diplomatic pressure to be placed on Hamas by the Qataris
including with the threat to exile Hamas's leadership from Doha unless we see the immediate
and unconditional release of the remaining hostages. That is the kind of diplomatic
pressure which must be brought to bear. Instead the Israeli government has chosen a path which
even President Trump, Netanyahu's biggest cheerleader, appears appalled by. And let me be
clear Liberal Democrats support the right of the state of Israel to exist and its right like all
nations to defend itself yet Israel has obligations under international law and duties to its allies
both of which it has breached. Can the Minister confirm whether any UK entity including the joint
command at the Al Udeid base were informed by Israel of the attack in advance? Can the Minister
confirm that in addition to what he's already said that in his meeting with President Herzog
today the Prime Minister will condemn yesterday's attack in the strongest possible terms and make
clear that the UK views this as a flagrant breach of international law? Last night's strikes are of
course inseparable for the ongoing humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza. They further eroded our
collective hope for an end to the suffering of both Gazans and the hostages and so it is time
for meaningful action by this government. Will the Minister confirm that the UK will take the
steps necessary today to end the export of F-35 parts to Israel? And in light of the further
egregious breaches of international law directed by Netanyahu overnight, will he confirm that
President Netanyahu will be sanctioned? Mr Speaker as you would expect I won't be commenting on
sanctions from the dispatch box as is our usual practice. The Prime Minister set out to this
house his intentions for his meeting with President Herzog later. I can confirm that the Foreign
Secretary met with President Herzog this morning and raised these points among a range of others
including the urgent need both to ensure aid into Gaza but for further Israeli support to British
efforts to medically evacuate injured children and fully funded scholarships to the UK.
Thank you very much Mr Speaker. What happened overnight illustrates a problem that a huge
problem that the new Foreign Secretary is going to need to deal with and I'm pleased that the
Minister will ably be helping her. But the problem is this there is an emboldened far-right
Israeli government who believe that they can do whatever they like and there won't be any
consequences. And on the other hand we have a country like Qatar who is genuinely working
towards peace. I know the Minister has met the Ministers. I have met them too. They couldn't be
more sincere in the efforts that they're making and they get bombed for their efforts.
The question really is for the new Foreign Secretary is how can we make sure that we
aren't just bystanders and are actually playing an active role in in dealing with this issue
and in what way will the Prime Minister be able to convey such a message to President Herzog this
afternoon? I thank my right honourable friend for the question. It is vital that at such serious
moments the UN Security Council plays its full part. So I can confirm to my right honourable
friend that the UK is supporting calls for an emergency session of the UN Security Council
this evening. The Foreign Secretary will be joining calls with her E3 counterparts this afternoon and
we will be discussing this matter as she would expect with a range of G7 allies including the
United States. We come to Shadow Foreign Secretary Dame Priti Patel. This is clearly a very very
serious moment for the Middle East and no one in this house wants to see a spiral of escalation of
hostilities. Israel and Qatar are both important and valued strategic partners for the United
Kingdom and we value and recognise the extensive efforts by the Qatari government to secure the
release of hostages and their work towards securing a ceasefire. It is tragic as the
Prime Minister has already highlighted that security guards were killed in this attack.
But I think Mr Speaker there are some fundamental issues here and many of these points have been
made from the Dispatch Box time and time again that this is a moment for our country. Britain
must contribute to and provide the British expertise that is necessary when it comes to
the conflict resolution and support strong regional initiatives including backing Qatar
and the Qataris when it comes to releasing the hostages but also achieving a ceasefire.
On top of that of course we have to be working with our allies in the United States and looking
ahead to next week with the visit from President Trump this is a crucial crucial moment and there
can be no equivocation anymore as this issue just continues to inflict the region day after day
after day. Mr Speaker it's also true that we certainly should not beat mourning those Hamas
leaders who have been killed. They have held innocent hostages in terrorist captivity for over
700 days and they were responsible for the atrocities of the 7th of October 2023 which
also killed British nationals. In recent months Israel has been removing terrorist actors across
the Middle East. The leadership of the Houthis, Hezbollah and malign individuals in the Iranian
regime too. Now of course that does also mean that our government must play a strong role and
stand firm when it comes to degrading Iran's nuclear capabilities and that malign influence
in the region. So recognising the sensitivity of the situation in the Gulf, can the Minister
confirm what actions he and the FCDO will undertake to stabilise efforts to secure the release of the
hostages, what proactive steps are being taken to degrade Hamas and their capabilities and of
course how do we work constructively with our partners in the region to drive the right outcomes
including a ceasefire? I thank the Right Honourable Lady for the important questions. I can
commit that the British government is fully committed to efforts with our Gulf partners, with
our partners across the G7 to try and ensure that the negotiations currently ongoing come to the
conclusions that we wish to see. Those are conclusions both in the short term, we have long
repudiated Hamas's hostage taking, the hostages need to be released immediately as must humanitarian
aid get into Gaza but as I said in response to the Honourable Gentleman's question, there are
also other questions about governance and security and the long-term prospects for a Gaza, a West Bank,
a state of Palestine and state of Israel living side by side and we are fully engaged in that
diplomacy as she would expect. On the wider questions which she points to of fragility in
the region, she will be familiar with the decisions that we took in relation to snapback. I imagine
we'll return to discuss Iran in greater detail at some point in the future. I'm conscious that
there were developments over the recess. We have triggered snapback and we will continue to return
to the House to discuss the threat of Iran's nuclear programme.
Thank you Mr Speaker. The longer Israel is allowed to act like a rogue state,
bombing sovereign countries with impunity and expanding its war in the Middle East,
the weaker our words look. Gaza, Lebanon, Yemen, Iran, Syria, Tunisian soil and now Qatar.
Why are we meeting Israel's President Herzog today when his own words and those of Netanyahu
show a complete disregard for international humanitarian law?
Mr Speaker, I'd like to pay tribute to the work of my honourable friend on a whole range of
questions including efforts currently underway to try and assure the successful evacuation
of vulnerable people from Gaza. It is important that we raise our concerns directly with the
Israeli government both in order to try and contribute towards a diplomatic process but
also to try and secure the practical and tangible help required to get people out of Gaza. The
British Foreign Office cannot on its own secure the speedy departure of those we wish to see.
Andrew Mitchell. Mr Speaker, do not the events of yesterday underline the critical need to
secure a ceasefire but above all to move into a political process and will the Minister commit,
we're all very pleased to see that the Minister continues in his role following the reshuffle,
will he commit to try and build on the important work that has been done by Egypt, Turkey,
Qatar and Saudi Arabia to affect that peace process? All of them have underlined that there
is no place for Hamas in Gaza or anywhere else in government following the events that have taken
place. Mr Speaker, I'm grateful for the kindness of the right honourable gentleman's words and
I heard from behind me as well I am continuing in my role and will look forward to returning
to this house in the usual way. He is right to emphasise the importance not just of the
statements and words of the UK and our western allies but the very important commitments that
have been made particularly in July but since as well by Qatar, Egypt, Turkey and a range of
other states who have a real role to play in both mediating the immediate pressures and
trying to end up in, as he says, the more permanent ceasefire that we want to see.
Claudia Session-Lewis. Thank you Mr Speaker and I thank the Minister for outlining the
strongest condemnation of the attacks and a blatant disregard for Qatar's sovereignty.
I refer members to my register of interests having visited Qatar last year and speaking
with the Ministers there, seeing how diligent they are working day in day out to secure the
ceasefire, secure the hostages and get that urgent aid in. Does the Minister agree and share my view
that Qatar's role in mediating this conflict will be blamed into jeopardy by these blatant attacks
and will he continue to make sure that the Prime Minister continues to condemn this when he meets
with the Presidents later this week? The Friend is quite right. Qatar has played a
vital role in this conflict and I work closely with my Qatari counterparts, not just on the
urgent issues of the Middle East but across a whole range of difficult conflicts. They play
a vital role. They are committed, as the Emir of Qatar said to the Prime Minister this morning,
they are committed to continue to play that mediation role. I cannot see how such strikes
could help them perform that role but they are committed nonetheless to continue with it and
they have our full support. The events of yesterday come as no surprise to those of us
in this Chamber who have been raising the Israeli Government's crimes committed in an era of complete
impunity and it should now be crystal clear to the Minister, as it is to so many across the world,
that the Israeli Government is not interested in the slightest in peace or indeed the fate of the
hostages. So in that light I have two questions. First of all, what military and intelligence
assistance will we be providing to the Qataris to allow them to defend themselves against further
attacks? And secondly, will the UK be adding its voice to the growing calls across the world for
the formation of an international protection force to enter Gaza and enforce a peace?
On the first point, we are committed to Qatar's security and defence. We have a close
relationship with them on both and we are of course in constant discussions with the Qataris
about the importance of that collaboration. On the second point, on a protection force and perhaps
taking advantage of the question from the right honourable gentleman who was the Secretary of
State for the Department for International Development when I was posted in South Sudan
with a chapter 7 UN peacekeeping force at the time with the most far-reaching mandate to protect
civilians, we cannot in this chamber pretend that UN peacekeeping forces are able to impose
peace where there is none. There must be a ceasefire negotiation. In Juba I saw, as did the
world, the horrifying ethnic cleansing that followed the inability of the UN mission to
protect people. You must have a ceasefire. It is easy to get distracted with other alternatives
but the truth is it is only a ceasefire that will protect civilians in Gaza.
Given that any pre-emptive strike under article 51 is normally regarded as being justified only
when a threat is imminent, that article 2.4 states that all members shall refrain in their
international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity
or political independence of any state and article 48 states measures taken by members
in the exercise of this right of self-defence shall be immediately reported to the Security
Council. Does my honourable friend agree that international law and the preservation,
strengthening and more of the rules-based system is vital for the peoples of this region,
the wider world, our ally Qatar and the UK and will he make it clear to Israel
that we expect them to obey international law?
We do expect Israel, alongside all of our allies and indeed every state, to abide by international
law. He sets out the relevant tests of self-defence and imminence. As I say, the UK is supporting
an urgent session of the Security Council this afternoon on this question.
Members of this House have already outlined the reasons why Israel has violated international law
by attacking Qatar. Will the UK Government therefore lay down a motion at the UN to
condemn the actions of Israel? As I said, the UK is supporting a motion for a session of the UN
Security Council this afternoon. If that is granted, I would expect it to be in the evening hour time.
Israel is a rogue state that blatantly disregards international law. This bombing was a blatant
attempt to scupper peace negotiations. Pleading with Israel will do no good. So how many more
war crimes are we going to see?

