2025-26 season preview: Rookie & keeper rankings

Amazing Hockey Stories
49 followers
Sep 11, 2025
And now your go-to source for year-round fantasy hockey advice,
DFS, and betting coverage. This is NHL Fantasy on Ice.
One month until puck drop. Fantasy drafts are just around the corner. It's time for another
episode of NHL Fantasy on Ice. Nick Alberga, Jake Hahn, Pete Jensen, and Chris Meaney.
On today's agenda, Jake, rookies and keepers. Always fun. How are you?
I'm great. One of my favorite things to talk about, obviously, young players in this league,
and we're coming off an excellent Calder Trophy race last year, Nick, with so many different
contenders. And it goes well beyond that. It's not just second-year players. There's a lot of
other young players we can get into as well. We debated Celebrini and Bedard briefly on last
week's podcast, but we'll go well beyond that one on today's.
Yeah, we're going to continue with that for sure. And I will preface this entire conversation by
saying a year ago, and I remember it vividly, I came back from Europe, same type of situation,
and we're like, Matt Vymichkov, it's his to lose. It's his to lose. Well, he lost it.
Lane Hudson won the Calder Trophy. So you're going to hear a lot of conversation over the
podcast today about Ivan Demidov, and rightfully so. I think he's the odds-on favorite right now
to win the Calder Trophy. But there's a lot of enticing names. So right off the bat, I ask you,
I give you Ivan Demidov or the field. Who are you taking, Jake?
It's tough. I mean, all odds equal, I think I got to go with Demidov. I think he's just set up
perfectly to go out and win this award. But you're giving me the entire field. Someone's going to
step up and surprise us, right? It cut too clean last year, looking back at it. I mean, you
mentioned Vymichkov at a moment where he would have been the frontrunner, the favorite to win
the Calder. Obviously, Celebrini was the guy going into the season. And what else did Celebrini have
to do to win the Calder last year, Nick? I mean, look at those numbers. If I would have just shown
you those numbers, you'd say, yeah, he's probably winning the Calder. But obviously, Lane Hudson
deserved that thing, no doubt. Dustin Wolf had his moment as well. So I'll take the field if
you want, Demidov, because I just feel like someone's going to step up, maybe that we're
not even going to talk about today. You know, I was curious. And so I looked back last year. Again,
a lot of the convo was about Vymichkov and Celebrini, rightfully so. And Lane Hudson was
an afterthought. Like, we knew he was in the Calder conversation, but we didn't look at him
as a legitimate threat. And I'm with you. I've got the field as well, and that's taking nothing
away from Demidov. This guy is a supreme talent. Would I be shocked if he won the Calder Trophy
this season? Probably not. But I'm going to bring you two names on today's podcast. I don't know if
you want to call them sleepers for the Calder Trophy, but guys, I somewhat believe in, to
surprise some people, number one's another defenseman, Zane Parekh with the Calgary Flames.
Scored in his NHL debut last year, Jake, only one game to his name so far. 33 goals,
107 points in 61 games for Saginaw last year. And the most important note here in Calgary,
a lot of moving parts, but I could see a pathway where Parekh is running that first power play
unit, maybe in November, December, something like that. How do you feel about that?
Well, that's something Calgary is lacking right now. I mean, they're obviously not a perfect
formula, but they did have a good season last year. They surprised a lot of people. They're
trying to do this thread the needle thing where they're keeping some of their veteran players.
They still got guys like Huberto, Kadri under contract, making big money, but they actually
are starting to infuse some youth there in Calgary. It's a really interesting mix. We're
seeing the Matt Coronados, Connor Zares, all these different young players. And now you mentioned
Parekh possibly getting a chance. And I'm looking at that back end and I'm thinking, yeah, there's
a path here to the first power play. There's no guy that's locked in on that first power play role
in Calgary. And I actually think this team has more talent than people give them credit for.
Some are going to be looking for them to take a step back. Nick, I think they're going to be in
the mix for a playoff spot in the West. It's going to be tough to make it, but I think they're going
to be in that conversation. And I love the Parekh shout. I think he's got a real legit
shot to take over that first power play at some point. On the topic of the Calgary Flames, guys,
how are we feeling about Dustin Wolf after a magnificent, let's be honest, Lane Hudson and
were awesome. But didn't Wolf come in second, I think? And I think that he really opened eyes.
We knew he was coming, but we didn't quite know how good he would be immediately. Where do you
view him in the keeper goalie debate moving forward? Right now in our keeper rankings,
which you can find on NHL.com slash fantasy, he's number one among 25 and under players at the goalie
position. Do you agree with that, Nick? To a degree. I think there's got to be some negative
regression that happens here, just because everything we mentioned, like Calgary was a
team that snuck up on people. And I just wonder this year when people know they're legit now,
know they have some really decent players and play with a system and a purpose. And you look at Wolf,
you wonder if maybe he takes a bit of a step back, but I think he's high atop there. And it's
funny you bring up that conversation too, because I was trying to handicap some names
for the Calder Trophy and Yaroslav Askarov is a guy I could foresee playing sort of that pathway,
that vision, if you will, of Dustin Wolf sneaking into that conversation of the Calder Trophy. Like
I think you look at San Jose, you look at the comps to the Calgary Flames, some young potential
players, maybe some more veterans on a team like the Flames, but San Jose has set itself up to
surprise people this season, Jake. So I like the shout. It means we'll go to you next. I love the
shout on Wolf, had an excellent year, sort of came out of nowhere. Like we knew he had something,
but it was his first full season. And I wonder if Askarov's the guy we look at it this year.
Yeah, Askarov's extremely interesting, especially in the batting market too, as a long shot. And
you know, when you're looking at goalies at 25 and under, he does check in at number two for us,
Lucas Dostal at number three. After that, you know, it's, let's be honest, Jacob Fowler, we're
not going to see him with the Canadians this year, Spencer Knight, you know, in front of a Blackhawks
team that has a lot of question marks. Jesper Wolstad as well. We might see a little bit more
of him, but he's not the number one. He probably is only projected for 20 games or so this year.
So Wolf is no question, in my opinion, the number one goalie, 25 and under. And even if you're just
starting, Jake is like a fresh dynasty league and you're thinking about goalies. You can consider
him after the big five come off the board, maybe around goalie 10, because yeah, he is locked into
the future in Calgary. And as for Parekh, I kind of disagree with you guys. I think he's
a fantastic talent, but I do think he's blocked at the moment. Like Wieger and Anderson are there.
Let's remember, it took a little bit of time for Lane Hudson to get that first power play. So if
they make some sort of move, maybe it is November, like you mentioned, Nick, then he can kind of
take off in terms of his talent. A good point with those veterans there, where he's probably
going to have to start on power play unit two if he gets a crack. And if he does something special,
then maybe they do make a change there. Nick, while we were on goaltenders, though, I did want
to get your take on a couple of guys. We talked about Askarov there. I mean, the concern with
Askarov is obvious. How long until the Sharks are a little bit more of a finished product? I think
they're still going to be a mess in their own zone. So not exactly the greatest spot for a
goaltender, but looking long term, he looks like he could be a part of this thing in San Jose.
But going further down the board, I want to get your take on this name that's getting a little
bit of hype, not too much, but maybe the closer we get to fantasy drafts, we're going to talk
more about him. How do you feel about Jett Greaves out in Columbus? We know Columbus has needed
someone to make a consistent save for a while, and they were a great story last year. I think
they're hoping to be competitive in the Eastern Conference, looking for a playoff spot. If they're
going to do that, they're going to need a goaltender to step up and make those consistent
saves that I mentioned. And it does feel like Jett Greaves, he could be that guy. The sample size is
small, but I think I'm going to have a little bit of interest in him in fantasy this year.
Yeah, he's definitely a guy I would pick up for my third string purposes. To answer your question,
I'm probably lukewarm. I think Columbus is another team that could experience some negative regression.
I think you look at that team and what they put together, and this is a theme around the NHL. I
said this on last week's podcast. It had to be one of the most disappointing off seasons in NHL
history. Not much happened, right? And you look at Columbus, what do they really do? Did they
improve upon other teams in the conference, in the division? Probably not. I think a lot of things
went their way last season. I like the job that the new coaching staff did, and some of the players
really elevated the younger players, specifically what we've been waiting for. But I think when you
compare them to some other guys, namely Dostal, I'm probably staying away. But certainly on my
monitor list, Jake, I still need to see a bit more from a guy like Jett Greaves before I commit
long term, if that makes sense. Well, I think a lot of us, and I might fall into this as well,
are just assuming, okay, the Devils will be healthier, so they'll be back in the mix in the
Metro. The Rangers, they're not as bad as they were last year, so they're going to bounce back.
They still have all these great players, and you're hearing guys say all the right things in
the off season. But I don't know if it's going to be quite that easy. I think there's some other
hungry teams in the Metro that would like to take that step. And I think Columbus, Nick, is a team
I am going to be targeting. I don't know if I'm putting all the chips in the middle in a fantasy
draft, but I think there's going to be three or four names when I enter my queue where I'm loading
up on a couple of guys where I still think we're going to get some value. And I do like that crop
of young forwards. So you mentioned it, probably more of a third goaltender on your roster for
Greaves. But I think somebody with a high enough ceiling, where if he takes over, Columbus is a
legitimate playoff team, I think he could get some nice value with him. Let's further that
conversation. Stick on Netminers for a second. Why don't I throw Spencer Knight into the equation?
And I know, Pete, you've been big on this name the last couple of years, so why don't you start
this conversation where you feel about Spencer Knight, maybe compared to Greaves, compared to
Askerov? I think he's going to face a lot of rubber and he'll be up to the task many nights. I think
that the young core in Chicago is advancing little by little. There are a lot of questions, right?
Like, is Frondel going to make the team right off the bat? And same hold for some of these other
teams with the top three picks in the draft last year. I'm talking about Schaefer with the Islanders
and Michael Mesa with the Sharks. So, still more to be determined in training camp on all three of
those fronts. But I think that Spencer Knight could play 45-50 games and get you a save percentage
over 9.05, which would make him a relevant goaltender. We know all these, you know,
even if you don't make the playoffs, if you're facing that much rubber and playing that many
games, you're going to be, especially in leagues that count saves, you're going to be really
valuable. I don't think there's any question that him and Askerov, these goalies we're talking about,
they have a ton of skill. And the upside is, it's nice. It's tremendous. It's unknown. But,
you know, from a redraft standpoint, you kind of have to fade both of these guys unless you're
in a points league. You know, Pete's talking about saves. You know, there's going to be
multiple games where Spencer Knight and Askerov both flirt with 35-40 saves. And that even if
they allow three or four goals, it's not going to kill you at the end of the day. But, you know,
if you're going to take these guys in a keeper league and a dynasty league, Nick, you just have
to be patient. And even knowing the teams that they're on, you can still probably get them
outside of goalie 20-25 and just have them as your third goalie. And like the Hawks and like the
Sharks, you just stay the course and you rebuild. I like that. You're right. And tread carefully is
probably the way we'd say it. I was actually thinking about goaltending in my fantasy draft
before starting today's podcast. And I'm like, volatility at its best. You got to be careful.
Got to be patient. I think that's where you find the value, whether it's Askerov, Knight,
Greaves like that. So, you know, that conversation over the next month will be intriguing as well.
Jake, I did want to get into sort of some teams because I think that is a theme around this league
is some of the young talent that's really come to the epicenter. And right away, San Jose,
Montreal, when looking at your dynasty lists over at NHL.com that really, really stick out.
For San Jose, got Celebrini at one, Smith 14, Misa 18, Eklund's on that list,
Askerov's on that list. Then you got Montreal, Jake, with Hudson, Suzuki, Caulfield, Demidov,
Slavkovski, Fowler, Dobson. I mean, the list goes on and on. Who do you like the better build when
it comes to that right now? Is it Montreal or is it San Jose, Jake? Well, Montreal's closer. We
know that, right? They made the playoffs last year. I think their players are a little bit
more legit. So if you're looking short term, I think the Habs are the play, right? But if you're
going dynasty league, keeper league, I think San Jose has tons of appeal. I don't know what to do
with Misa. I mean, obviously in a redraft league and in a league where you're looking for points
this year, I think that might be too much too soon. But if you're looking down the line, I mean,
kid's got a ton of talent. So I think where the boys have him ranked is completely fair.
I'd look way down. I think there's some value. I know he's a little bit of an older player when
we look at this group of young players in San Jose, but Will Eklund is somebody I've got a
ton of interest in that. I don't think he's going anywhere in that top six and he's getting
legitimate power play time. So I really like Eklund and that Sharks team is just loaded. So I
don't think they're ready to take a huge step this year, but I do think they're going to be a fun
fantasy team. And Eklund's a guy, especially in redraft leagues, where I'm going to have my eye
on. I think you're going to get a really nice amount of value with him. One guy I'm really
excited about. I don't know if he's going to crack the lineup this year, but when he does,
like not far behind Nick Sky Perreck is Sam Dickinson, former high pick defenseman, a guy
that was killing it with 90 plus points in 50 some odd games in the OHL last year and just has
an enormous ceiling because that power play one spot is up for grabs. We saw it with a couple of
guys through the years, the damage that could be done in that spot, namely Eric Carlson, when he
had the hundred plus points in a garbage season for the Sharks, you know, missing the playoffs
by a mile and stuff. I really want Dickinson and Misa to make this team. Like those are two players,
like Pete just mentioned it, the 90 plus points mean 31 points in 17 playoff games, over 160
points in his last two years with London. And just we know that he's going to quarterback that power
play. I don't know if we'll see a whole lot of him this year. They do have some veteran presence
there like Klingberg and Orloff. Maybe they'll just kind of ease Dickinson in. But you guys
were talking off the top, like who's the player that could win the Calder and it's Michael Misa
after Demidov. Like this was the OHL's most outstanding player, top score in the league,
134 points guys in 65 games. He had at least one point in 60 of his 65 games. So I think overall,
when you're comparing these two teams, you have San Jose top heavy with like top talent,
love the Eklund call, Will Smith. The Habs are kind of like more spread out with maybe not as
much top tier talent. But man, both of those teams are well on their way, Nick. We haven't
even really, when it comes to rookies, talked about Ike Howard, where Edmonton is so fascinating
to me, Jake, where there's been a lot of turnover, gone are a lot of the vets, a lot of youngsters
like Savoy and Ike Howard in that lineup. And it's pretty crazy. This guy's yet to play an NHL game
and he's already earmarked for the top six, which could be some severe attachment to some big boys.
But are you actually a believer in Ike Howard having a monster rookie season here at Edmonton,
Jake? Oh, Nick, the September tradition of who's playing in Edmonton's top six that we can get
some attachment to McDavid and Dreisletter. I feel like we play this game every year with
different names, right? It's not always young guys like Howard. I think Howard's intriguing
because there's the unknown, right? He could be awesome. We don't know this, right? He could step
in, he could get an attachment to one of those guys, he could just roll with it and have this
great season. Or maybe he's not an NHL ready, right? There's a downside to it. So I think it
could go so many different ways with him. But look, we're here to take some risks. We're here
to take some shots. So if you're willing to roll the dice, I think there is enough upside there
where it could be one of those league winning type plays. I think it could also flame out.
But I think where you're drafting him, I don't think it's going to kill you too much if you hit
on your other picks. So I don't mind taking a shot on him. But yeah, this is the September
tradition like no other is who's getting the attachment to McDavid and Dreisletter this year.
I'm in. Absolutely. Nick, you man. Oh, I'm totally in in terms of the odds, too. I mean,
he's got the second shortest odds. He's tied with a few defensemen. And we could also bring up here
in a little bit. But yeah, there's an opportunity for him immediately. All those guys that they
tried last year, Vander Cain and Victor Arvidsson and, and Jeff Skinner, like they're all gone. See
you later. This kid's got a ton of speed, a ton of skill, his elite playmaking. He's not afraid
to rip the puck. He's got the best playmaker in the world playing alongside him. He may even get
some power play time at moments. You know, if if Hyman and Ryan Nugent Hopkins are not living up to
expectations, but 52 points and 37 games of Michigan Hobie Baker award winner. I'm surprised
the lightning gave him up like I maybe there's something we just don't know. But that's a good
get by Edmonton and they desperately need somebody like that in their top six means I'll tell you all
fair what happened. Okay, we're not going to bring it to this podcast. But this screams Rutger McGrory
to and we're all familiar with that name. Okay, this guy wants to be in the show.
Doesn't want to be on the fourth line wants to be on the first line. So he's going to get his chance.
I think it lasts maybe as long as this cup of coffee I'm having on this podcast. Okay, we have
this combo with young players every year in the preseason. Can they stick does even make it out of
the preseasons my question, and it's nothing against from the kid. I think it's a difficult
league to play in and it's difficult specifically to play with Connor McDavid or Leon dry settle.
So I think at the end of the day, we're going to find a vet on that line. I think if you want to
have a look at a deep sleeper, I cowards guy you snatch with like one of your late picks and you
hope for the best but I don't see this working out Jake I don't. Well, and again, like I said,
I obviously meanies in I think you're a little bit more skeptical. I'm of the mind where I'm
okay taking a shot just because of the upside and meanie talks about some of that upside,
right and you're talking about the downside of it, which I could totally see as well. He comes in
NHL is a tough league. I think it's a little bit of an easier league when you've got guys like dry
settle and McDavid there and you know, hopefully kind of take up take them under their wing and
make it a little bit easier find some space out there for him. So he's going to get that opportunity
early in the year, but we have seen a lot of players get that opportunity on on the line of
either McDavid or dry settle and it not work out. I want to guess one of those defenseman that meanie
was hinting at though Nick and I'm curious your take on this is Eve Boyum out in Minnesota. I'm
I've got a lot of interest here again talking about upside. I know Faber's there, but they're
looking for someone to run that power play and maybe different from our Calgary conversation.
Chris made the point about, you know, maybe the spot for Parekh on that first power play is not
going to be as easy to go and grab. I think for Boyum, Minnesota probably wants him to just go
out there and take it early in the season. So I've got some interest on in him. This is always welcome
news in fantasy hockey when there's hot prospects coming up on the blue line because as you guys know
it really there's a significant dip when it comes to the blue line in fantasy hockey. So like, yeah,
I'm I'm pretty in on Boyum. I think there's opportunity. I think there's a, you know,
Minnesota's a team a lot of people sleep on but they actually have a lot of value whether it's
in the crease, blue line, up front obviously with guys like Kaprizov and Boldy and I think he's
certainly a guy means that I would identify late in my draft that it would take a flyer on.
If it works, it works. If it doesn't, it doesn't. You move on, you get somebody off the waiver wire.
Yeah, that's exactly it. I mean, this is a great class in terms of defenseman. Last year, we really
just had Lane Hudson. You guys talk Parekh and I love the skill set. I truly believe he's blocked.
There's another guy in Carolina as well, Alexander Nikishkin. Maybe the doors open a little bit more
for him with Orloff and Burns being gone, but he's probably not going to see top power play time
either with Shane Gossespierre there and this is a guy that's had 17 goals in each of his last two
seasons, 50 plus points in two of his last three in the KHL and throws his body around. He had 17
hits in four games in the playoffs, but Ziv Buyam, this is what Minnesota has needed for years. Like
we could sit here all day and think about the defense and they've tried on their top power play
like no disrespect to Jared Spurgeon, but now they have a guy who's had nearly 100 points in the last
two years playing in the University of Denver. They gave him a taste, Jake. Last year in the
playoffs, it was a small sample. They kind of shielded him a little bit, but when he played,
he played on that top power play. Kaprizov, Boldy, Rossi, he's got a great path for a really good
season. It was one of my favorite targets. And I think the fact, and you made the point about
him doing that in the playoffs, tough competition against Vegas in that first round where I actually
thought Minnesota could have easily won that series. They did a lot of things to kind of get
me excited about wild hockey for this season and the future. The fact they're doing that in those
type of games, those important games, makes me think they're going to give him the shot in the
regular season for sure and see what he can do and kind of just let Faber be that all-round defensive
guy. That really solid rock that's going to log all those minutes. So I'm bullish on Minnesota
wild hockey. Nick, where are you at on Anaheim and some of their young players right now? A couple
guys a little further down the list, but not too far. I still think we're excited, but Anaheim's
now trying to blend in some veteran guys in that lineup. I don't know how this will affect
young players. So Zgris is out. Kreider obviously comes in into that top six situation, but you got
guys like Cutter Gauthier there, Mason McTavish. Is there anybody that catches your eye still in
Anaheim? All right, here's my first bold take of the preseason. The Anaheim Ducks will make the
Stanley Cup playoffs. Oh, you know why? I dig it. Joel Quenville, three-time Stanley Cup champion
in the last 15 years back in the league and taking this team in a really, really intriguing
fit. You talk about the young players, Gauthier, Carlson, McTavish still without a contract.
Jackson Lacombe, I don't know if you guys saw this. I interviewed Matthew Nyes the other day.
Jimmy Snuggerud, Matthew Nyes, and Jackson Lacombe lived together in Minnesota this past summer.
That can't be good news to the rest of the NHL, okay? You know those guys just brought it all
summer long, so I'm looking forward to Lacombe after the breakout last year. Olin Zellweger's
another guy, Minchikov, Dostal. I mean, there's a lot of really good, intriguing young names,
but then you sprinkle in guys like Kreider, and I think they're on to something really,
really special here. I know it's been taking a while to see Pat Verbeek's vision, but I like
to pick up with the head coach, and I do think head coaches do wonders in this league, Mason.
Man, I like the call, and they remind me of the Canadians, and the Canadians made that jump last
year, too. It's a good mix of youth and experience. You know, you mentioned Joel Quindle.
They had the worst power play in the league last year. What do they do? They bring in Kreider. All
he does is score power play goals. You look at last year, and it's like, ah, he didn't have a
great year. I think he still scored 20 goals, and then they bring in Mikhail Granlin, who,
you know, was solid with Dallas, was great when he was the man in San Jose, so they have a really
nice mix of some youth, and some skill, and Calorin, and Strom. Who's the team that doesn't
make it in the West, Nick? Who's the team, like, off the top of your head that... Edmonton. No,
I'm kidding. Now, that would be bold. Yeah, no, that'd be too bold. I think they're obviously
going to make it. I don't know. Every year, I would just say this, and I wish I had a better
answer for you. There's always, like, one or two teams where, like, you're not even,
they're not even on your radar to miss the playoffs, but something goes awry, something
goes wrong, and they miss, but I don't know. From the onset of the offseason, where it all started
with the Quinville pickup, I just identified, Jake, a team like Anaheim that could surprise
some people this season, I think. Well, we had, what, three of those teams, at least, last year,
right? Everyone assumed Nashville was going to make it. Everyone assumed the Rangers were going
to make it. Certainly, Boston. I mean, Boston's there every year, and not only do they miss,
but they're not even close. They look like a lottery team, and now we're going to have that
debate, so you're right. You're going to pull up the standings sometime around Christmas and go,
wow, I can't believe this team is not even close to the playoffs, and, you know, it cuts too clean
that everyone's just going to make it. So I'm probably not there on the ducks to make the
playoffs, Nick, but I do appreciate the bold call, and I like what they're doing long-term in
Anaheim, and I do see some fantasy value. I'm just having a tough time with my guy Mason McTavish
right now. No pen to paper. They got to get that contract done. I love McTavish. I think he's a
heck of a player, but I don't like these situations for fantasy hockey. I tend to think they don't
work out too well when it bleeds into the season or it gets close to the year. Guys get off to that
weird start. So, Pete, how do you feel about Anaheim, where they're at? Is there anybody
there that you think's got some value, and are you worried about this whole Mason McTavish
situation? I'm a little worried, but I think that from what we've seen so far, he was a rookie last
year among the best even strength goal scorers among rookies. I think he was tied at the top.
Cutter Gautier, what he did in the second half, like that's a guy that I'm going to prioritize
in a keeper or dynasty league because, Nick, whether it's this season or next season or the
year after that, Anaheim's coming. We know it. You just said it for all those reasons. You know
that it's coming, and Cutter Gautier is going to be that 40-45 goal scorer. I think you could take
that prediction to the bank, whether it's this year or next year. It's coming very soon for
Gautier. We saw a glimpse of it last year. We know he's got that confidence too, and let's
piggyback off that because I think a team that they're going to be competing with, at least in
my mind, is the Utah Mammoth. Now, with a nickname, but Logan Cooley, Dylan Gunther, Barrett Hayton,
J.J. Peturka, some names, some younger names, some dynasty keeper-type names that would be in
the equation. Jake, we're waiting for that team to take the next step. Is this going to finally
be the year for that franchise? I'm going to say yes. I got to figure out who's coming up,
but like your take, I think it's a little less bold than the Anaheim take. I think the Anaheim
take to make the playoffs would be more bold. I feel like this Utah team is more ready to do it,
but they got all the parts. They really do. I think the blue line is solid enough when they're
healthy. I don't think it's perfect. I think they are probably going to have to win their fair share
of high-scoring hockey games, but look at the names that you just mentioned, Nick. These are
young players, but they're players that do have some experience in the National Hockey League.
I think when you're looking keeper, dynasty, maybe you're looking at some of these other
younger teams, right? The San Jose's and teams where these guys have barely even played yet,
but I think when you're looking redraft and you're specifically just looking for this year,
Utah is just loaded with talent. I can't help but be in on J.J. Paterka. I still love what a guy like
Logan Cooley is doing in that offense. All of it centers around Clayton Keller, who I think is one
of the most underrated players in the league, one of the most underrated top players in the league.
I'm all in on the Utah Mammoth this year. A hundred percent. We were talking, Pete and I,
off air about Utah and Clayton Keller and maybe just being one of the most underrated players.
He was among the leaders in points in the second half, and he's the straw that stirs the drink
there. I wanted to see what you guys think about Dylan Gunther's ranking here. We have him pretty
high in the under 25. We talked about Celebrini and Berdard last week. You have Kachuk, Suzuki,
Jack Hughes, Wyatt Johnson, Mitchcoff, Stutzler, Caulfield. Then we get into Dylan Gunther,
and there's a nice crew of young talent here. Will Smith, Matt Boldy, Michael Miza, Demidoff,
Cutter, Gauthier, Slavkoski, Raymond. That's pretty high for Dylan Gunther.
Pete's saying Cutter, Gauthier, 40, 45 goals. Dylan Gunther, to me, is a future 50-goal
scorer in this league, given his shot. Easily. I think that's just a compliment.
I think Utah is another prime example of people that just gloss over in fantasy hockey,
and they're like, oh, there's no sex appeal there. Gunther has proven year after year
gets that extension. I know even in one of my keeper leagues, people were chirping one of my
buddies for keeping Gunther, and it's like, you don't know. Then he had that huge start to the
season a couple years back, where we're like, okay, I get it now. I think you got to remember,
too, a lot of players these days are paid for projection. Just look at Frank Nazar,
of course, with Chicago. It happens quite frequently. I think you're paying before
the blowup. I think Gunther's been trending this way for a couple years, Jake, and certainly a guy
I'll be looking at very, very closely in fantasy hockey and drafting, for sure.
I think the boys have him properly ranked. You could maybe even argue a couple spots higher,
if you want. Meaning he talks about the 50-goal potential. I mean, this guy is a shoot-to-score
type player. If you watch him, I don't think he's ever hit a goaltender in the chest in his
entire life. He just goes for the corners. He might hit the post, crossbar a couple times,
might even miss the net, but he is going for those thin margins, and he's got the ability
to pick those corners. It's incredible to watch, compared to maybe some other guys you watch,
and you're like, okay, he's a shoot-to-shoot player, which is fine, too. It creates a lot
of chances, but I love the guys with this kind of talent. I think him and Boldy are kind of an
interesting conversation. Boldy out in Minnesota, where I look at and think, yeah, he hasn't hit
40 goals yet, but he's got that 40-goal potential, Pete. I'm with you guys. You guys have Gunther,
I think, two or three spots ahead of Boldy. I'm with you on that. I think he's got more potential
to even go higher than that, but there should be some interest in Boldy in Minnesota, as well.
Very high ceiling for him. Also, Clayton Keller. I don't think the general public realizes that if
you look at our point projections, which, again, you can find on NHL.com slash fantasy,
he's in the same range, or even ahead of some of these names. Austin Matthews, David Pasternak,
Sidney Crosby. He's right in that 90 to 95-point range, because he was in that range last season.
And then you look at the supporting cast beyond all those names you mentioned, Nick. In Utah,
a lot of 29-and-under players, including Karol Wymelka, workhorse goalie. He's a fantasy sleeper,
and he should have the lion's share of the workload. Nick Schmaltz is only 29. Sergachev,
a player that I love, had 50-plus points in a bounce-back season last year. Didn't even
hit his full ceiling. He's only 27. Dursey, 26. And then, oh, yeah, you have Jerome McGinless' son,
Teja Ginla, waiting in the wings. That's a guy I'd love to have on my team,
based on how his father played all those years. Oh, definitely. And so many moving parts, in
general, in the Western Conference. And you'd have to think a couple teams are going to move out,
a couple are going to move in, but you just never know on a year-by-year basis.
I think we should dovetail this conversation, too, by mentioning Matvey Michkov. If you guys
remember, the last 30 games of the season, he had 29 points. And you start to wonder,
can he be a point-per-game guy moving forward, maybe above that? And Rick, talk it, where he
fits in in Philadelphia. But Jake, how do you feel about Michkov? It happens a lot with young
players. There's going to be ups, there's going to be downs. And certainly, we saw that in year
one under John Tortorella, of course, for the most part. So Philly's a situation, obviously,
we're going to have to make the decisions before the season starts in our fantasy drafts and things
like that. But I really want to watch how Philly plays the first couple weeks, even couple months
of the season. You mentioned Rick Tockett coming over. And all the talk will be, okay, John
Tortorella, he kind of kept the leash on some of these young guys, right? If you watched Flyers
games over the last couple of years, he's trying to play this lock it down, defensive style,
two-way game, which I get what he's trying to teach the young players, but they weren't built
to play that type of hockey. They don't have any goaltenders either. So I think that's part of the
reason why they were struggling so much at times. I'm curious what Rick Tockett tries to do because
he can be pretty defensive as well and try to play that style. He tried to play it in Vancouver a
little bit. I hope he takes the leash off these guys and just lets them do their thing, make some
mistakes. And if that's the case, then I'm going to love Mitch Kov and maybe even Zgris with a
little bit of a bounce back coming over. I'm just very curious how he handles the situation in
Philly and what style of play he decides to play because, look, it's not going to be as easy as
all these great rookies from last year means. They're just going to continue on that trajectory.
We do see a lot of sophomore slumps in this league and one or two of them, I feel like,
are going to experience that next year. Yeah, and one of those guys could be Lane Hudson. I mean,
what he did last year was pretty spectacular setting records. There could be some regression
overall. But for Mitch Kov, I think we have to be optimistic that there is a new coaching regime in
Philadelphia. He was very outspoken. He sat on the bench a few times. It just wasn't going down
the correct path. I think Philly's a little bit weak down the middle of the ice. If Sean Couture
he's not going to be playing with a great center. But in the second half, especially when they moved
on from Torrance, Nick, this was a point per game guy. He was shooting the puck more. He was getting
more ice time. You figure the power play is going to be better with Zgris. Maybe Jamie Drysdale can
turn the clock back a little bit there in Philadelphia. He's certainly a target of mine
and we have him as a borderline top 10 player overall, 25 and under. I think that's fair.
It's fair. And I know it's Rick Talkett from John Tortorella, but it really feels like Forrest Gump
and the knee brace is coming off for Mitch Kov. So I think look out for him. And Pete, I wanted
to ask you as well about the New York Islanders. It's funny. We've had this entire conversation
about rookies and keepers for 30 minutes or so. We haven't talked about the guy that went first
overall, but what are the chances we see Matthew Schaefer make the the Islanders here?
I think they're in the mindset that they're building their franchise around this player
and the rebuild, which is something that they were avoiding the past couple of years under
Lamorello. The rebuild and retool is in full force now that they got the number one pick.
I also like some of the moves they made to acquire. They got Kalem Ritchie in the trade
for Brock Nelson. They got, of course, Shabanov from the KHL. I thought that was like a stealth
pickup for them in terms of a fantasy sleeper, a guy who could maybe land in the top six with
some quality players. So overall, I feel like if you went back to, say, last June when they
got Cole Iserman in the draft and that was their only real prospect with any worth, no disrespect
to everyone else, but nobody else was stacking up to the other teams around the league, now you
could pinpoint about six or seven Islanders prospects that are worth something and that
have some potential fantasy upside maybe two, three years from now.
I like that. Don't sleep again, as Pete mentioned, the name Kal Ritchie. If you guys recall, last
year had a great start for Colorado before being sent back to Oshawa. All he did was get 70 points
in 47 games. I really, really like that pickup. And so Kal Ritchie is a guy I've identified. We'll
see what he does in camp, but it means the Islanders are begging for somebody to take
over here outside of Barzell up front. I think Ritchie is a prime example of that.
Yeah, he should get an opportunity, right? I mean, the Islanders had a really good offseason.
I don't feel like they're a playoff team and they may be patient with Schaefer. He only played 17
games last year before he suffered the injury at the World Juniors, but this kid's going to be a
superstar. If you're thinking about a rookie-only draft after Demidov, I would be highly thinking
about him. I'd probably go Demidov, Misa, and then I'd be thinking about him and Dickinson
and some of these other defensemen that we talked and discussed. But Jake, I wanted to
throw a couple more names at you guys before we wrap. There's Ryan Leonard and Jimmy Snuggerud.
Nick mentioned him. Leonard's going a little bit higher in redraft leagues.
He may be the better player in a dynasty league, but I think Snuggerud has got a really good
opportunity at a top-six role as Washington's a little bit deeper. Leonard's probably a third-line
player, but in seven games in the regular season, he had four points, 15 minutes per game.
In the playoffs, it ramped up to nearly 18 minutes. He had four points, two goals in seven games,
and he played with Thomas and Bucinevich. I thought that was extremely telling
for his outlook moving forward and this year too.
I'm glad you brought these names up, Mini, because they jumped out to me on the list as well.
Ryan Leonard, look, there was a lot of excitement for him coming over. I think it's harsh to judge
him on what we saw last year because the sample size is small for one and the games that he had
to play. It's late in the season when it's getting intense and then playoff games. I think a lot of
people are going to look at his numbers and go, oh, he really didn't do much. I don't know. Is
there going to be a lot of interest? There usually is with some of these young guys. I'm with you.
I'd prefer Snuggerud and his spot in that St. Louis lineup. I think he's got a legit shot,
Nick, to make an impact in that top six. I'm bullish on St. Louis. I think we're kind of
looking at, okay, what's that Central Division going to look like? We know who the top teams are.
I think St. Louis and Minnesota are both legitimate, so it's going to make it very
interesting in that Central. If I also like Utah too, there's only so many spots. All these teams
are going to have to hit the ground running, but I'm interested in what's going on in St. Louis,
including Snuggerud up there. Yeah, call it a clean sweep. It's more about pathway.
Like Ryan Leonard is a guy it could easily see start in the third line, and that's just not
going to do it from a fantasy perspective. Then there's the other big boys. St. Louis is always
a team built around their depth, and Snuggerud could be on the first line. It could be on the
third line, but I think you have to start him on that top line because if everything means,
just mention how good, how strong he looked in the Stanley Cup playoffs playing those seven games,
getting four points. I think the instant value is going to be there with a guy like Snuggerud
over Leonard, but two premier young talent players. I think that's a theme in general,
just to tie a bow in this conversation today, Jake, is just how much young talent there is in
the game right now. Well, yeah, we're talking about a guy like Snuggerud that we're all kind
of excited for. I was pumped for Jake Neighbors last year. He was my guy in St. Louis. Didn't
really end up happening. Now it kind of feels like maybe he's getting past, but a lot of times
we're a year early on these things, right? So maybe there is still some value with a guy like
that. I think the theme of today, or the one thing I'm really going to take away if I didn't know it
already, the amount of young talent in this league, not just like we talked about the great Calder
race from last year. Obviously, we've got some other great names this year, guys we haven't even
seen, and also just guys that have been in the league for two or three years that we look at on
the under 25 list and go, wow, that guy, he's still only under 25, and you kind of forget,
because these guys have already made such an impact. So blessed with so much young talent
in this league right now. Last word here, one name I don't think we've mentioned so far today,
Gabe Perreault from Boston College. He's going to be suiting up for the New York Rangers under
Mike Sullivan this year. I actually like how Sullivan early on in his Penguins tenure,
remember when they won the back-to-back cups, how he implemented some young players.
I'm talking about Jake Gensel. I'm talking about Matt Murray. At the time, it was a bold thing to
do that, and I think that he could do a better job than the previous iterations of Rangers coaches
that have failed to get the progress and the potential out of players like Lafreniere and
Kako, Keandre Miller, etc. I think that Gabe Perreault could be a rookie sleeper in fantasy
this year in the top six for the Rangers. Yeah, with Chris Kreider gone, there's an
opportunity for him as well. Final words for me, Sam Renzel. Nick, I know you're a big fan.
Go back and listen to Sleeper episode. I think he's in for a massive season quarterbacking that
top power play in Chicago. Billy Koivunen, it's a guy to consider in deep, deep, deep leagues,
very small sample size. Eight games, played seven of them with Sidney Crosby, had seven points,
five points in his final five games. And then final words for me, Demidov's a word to lose,
guys. He's winning the Calder. Okay, there you go. So you're not taking the field in that
conversation. But yeah, Montreal in general, guys, really, really excited to see that team play just
because of the extreme fantasy value. So great job today. I think we're looking at, what,
mock draft 1.0 for the next episode, Pete? Yeah, let's get it going. We're going to have to knock
out that mock draft sometime this week. And hopefully no big trades before the big podcast.
But yeah, mid-September next week, let's pencil it in here. Pete, don't hold your breath. Nothing
has happened. Carey Price got traded, okay? You want to talk about Carey Price in San Jose, we
can do that. But excellent job, guys. We'll talk next week. Thanks to producer Phil Constantino
for JCon, Pete Jensen, and Chris Meaney. I'm Nick Elberg. You've been listening to NHL Fantasy
on Ice. We'll talk next week. Take care, everybody.
