What California Could Lose if More Refineries Close | Skip York | Catherine Reheis-Boyd | Mike Ariza

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
41 Video Views·Sep 11, 2025
Gas prices in California are already high. With Valero's Benicia refinery shutting down and more production shifting overseas, the state's fuel supply is entering a more fragile phase. What could this mean for the state’s ability to keep up with demand?
This episode features Skip York, Chief Energy Strategist at Turner, Mason & Company; Mike Ariza, former Senior Refinery Controller at Valero; and Catherine Reheis-Boyd, President and CEO of the Western States Petroleum Association. They explore how infrastructure limits, policy decisions, and exposure to global markets are changing the risks.
A couple of refineries in California
have decided to shut down.
One is shutting down in the next few weeks,
Phillips 66 in Los Angeles.
And another one is Valero,
who's shutting down in April of 2026.
The state is trying to keep Valero from shutting down.
There are more refineries that potentially are at risk.
And these shutdowns could impact the gasoline supply
and many other products in California.
Today, we talked to multiple experts in this industry.
Propane, special people in the winter of 2026,
but losing those two fuel components like we do,
if we take any substantial hiccup
or we take another refinery downtime all at the same time,
Chevron show one of them has a fire
or something brings them down,
we're gonna have shortages
and it's gonna make the 70s look like a walk in the park.
I was alive then.
What does that mean?
Those pipelines that go to North and South
to the refiners from Central Valley
have got to be at least 30% capacity full.
Why?
Because they can't operate otherwise
because of all the pressure
and issues with those pipelines.
So they have to have enough oil in them to flow
or they shut down.
I'm Siamak Khorrami.
Welcome to California Insider.
Mike, it's great to have you on.
Welcome.
Skip, it's great to have you back on.
Welcome back.
Thanks for having me.
Thank you, sir.
Thanks very much.
We wanna talk to you about refiners in California.
This is a very crucial time for California and refineries.
Mike, you have a lot of experience
working in these refineries
and Skip, you have a good pulse on the industry,
what's happening with the data and the players.
Valero decided to leave California and shut down.
What are your thoughts on that?
I was quite stunned when I actually heard that.
Valero is the most efficient refinery in the state.
It's gonna be a big loss.
When they do shut down,
they're slated to shut down in April,
we're gonna lose the jet fuel,
the diesel and the propane production,
which nobody ever talks about.
But at the same time,
we're gonna lose 10 to 11% of the gasoline production
that Valero provides the state.
In addition, we're gonna go into our summer blend
of gasoline.
So we're gonna lose another four or 5%
going into summer of 2026.
That's really gonna hurt the state.
I personally see it possibly causing shortages.
More than likely, there will be some shortages
if we can't make it up somehow.
And prices are gonna go through the roof on gasoline jet.
Diesel and propane.
Mike lays out a good point,
is that California is already importing
about 150,000 barrels a day of petroleum products.
Most of that is gasoline.
Most of it's coming from South Korea.
Next largest source is India.
When you start pulling more,
and you're gonna be pulling
between Phillips 66 Los Angeles and Benicia,
and you're directionally looking
at maybe another 100,000 barrels a day of gasoline imports,
it's going to have to come in.
That's how we close the shortage.
But you're now gonna be pulling notionally,
close to 20% of California's supply
is gonna be coming from literally halfway around the world.
And there's another one, Phillips 66,
that's shutting down in a few weeks, right?
Yeah, it's already started.
They've already started the closure process.
So they expect to be done by the end of October.
But they are bringing the fuel in, right?
It's not that they are not gonna continue,
that they are gonna import it, right?
They're gonna continue bringing in finished products
to meet their marketing requirements.
One of the things that concerns me
is the congestion and the vessel traffic.
We already have congested harbors,
not just from petroleum tankers, but also just from cargo.
And when you think about it,
the product tankers are about half the size
of a crude tanker.
So when you close a refinery, for practical purposes,
you double the number of ships
that now have to service that market.
And there is a limit to how many ships can come in.
And I think we don't know what that limit is,
but we know that we're getting close to it.
Is there more refineries at risk right now?
There is a refinery, PBF has a refinery in Martinez
that is offline right now after a fire that it had.
But we're in a margin environment where I would say,
I don't think there's a refinery
that's not at risk economically.
The question is stepping back and saying,
from a company's perspective,
how does that refinery fit
within the company's broader portfolio
and their strategy for that portfolio?
And what opportunities does that company have
with their capital in other markets?
California is becoming increasingly difficult to compete
or assets to compete for capital
because companies do have options
with assets in other markets.
And they've got to look after the health
of the entire company,
not just one single asset in one location.
And that's kind of goes along
with what the CEO of ConocoPhillips
had just recently posted is,
they're shutting down Wilmington, as we know,
they're in the process of doing that.
But ConocoPhillips, the Rodeo refinery,
which they converted over to clean fuels, the biodiesel,
the CEO just recently said
they're losing over a hundred million dollars each quarter.
They're not even up to the rates
of the run of the rates
that they want to run for the biodiesel.
And he basically said that this is unacceptable.
These margins are unacceptable.
These losses are unacceptable and it's unsustainable.
So, I mean, Valero and its efficiency
as an efficient refinery as it is,
I mean, take the fine aside,
they still, they're the most efficient refinery.
So, like you're saying, I could see Shell, Chevron,
they're probably on the edge.
They're probably losing money too.
I would have no reason to think they're not losing money.
The whole thing is just getting tighter
and tighter and tighter.
And when you're just, you know,
like when you're the CEO of Valero,
I mean, obviously I can't speak for the man,
but you know, when he's looking at this going,
okay, we're losing money and we got a fine
and we can't really contest it.
And then what are we going to get next year?
You know, I'm making money everywhere else,
but we're losing a lot of money here
and getting these big fines.
So, just from a business standpoint, why would you stay?
And given the fact that they bought the refinery
for $820 million back in 2000 from Exxon,
and now they're having trouble even selling it
to the point to where I think they've given up on
selling it.
They're just going to shut it down.
Can you tell us more about this fine?
My understanding is that the air quality board
fined them for CO2 emissions, right?
Off of the hydrogen plant.
Correct. Right.
But some of the CO2 emissions were being captured
and some of them were being released,
but that's kind of what the standard operating procedure
had been for really since the inception of the refinery.
56 years.
And now all of a sudden it was violating some standard.
Maybe Mike, you could go into more detail on this.
How did that actually end up being a fine?
Yeah, they're stating, it goes back to 2003.
One thing was smog, even though I was looking
at the AQIs, having worked there,
I know the air there normally is very clean.
It's very, I've been up on the towers many times,
but the AQI for the EPA air quality index,
Solano County, I only looked at 20 counties,
but Solano County was number two for clean air.
It had no unhealthy days, 10 moderate days,
and every other day was good air quality.
So the smog thing, it really doesn't hold water.
And then they're talking about some minute releases
of carcinogen reproductive harm agents.
I'm not sure exactly how they're measuring all this stuff
since 2003, because this, if you look back to 1969,
when they started up, you're looking at,
look at the refinery personnel.
I know a lot of people that have been there,
worked there for 30 plus years, including my father,
the whole city of Benicia and the whole industrial park,
everything surrounding it,
there have been no elevated cases of anything.
As far as cancer, reproductive harm,
those are very healthy communities.
The fine, you know, goes out to the affected community.
Well, I don't understand what the effect is
on the community.
And I'm sure that's what the CEO of Valero's looking at.
This is our clean hydrogen generation unit.
Other refineries, as a matter of fact,
it's fourth in hydrogen and CO2 generation
behind El Segundo and Chevron Richmond
and I think the Marathon Refinery.
So they're like the fourth on generating this stuff.
And it is, it's carbon dioxide.
The vent's way up in the air.
It's been doing it since 1969.
There've been no health problems.
The community hasn't been affected by it at all,
yet they're levied with an $82 million fine.
And did that fine send a message to the industry?
I think the message that it sent was similar
to what Mike was just saying,
is that if this fine's coming down,
you know, what's the next shoe that drops?
And I can't plan for that.
But if I'm already in a place where margins are thin,
at best, margins are thin.
Thin, right.
And I've got a, how much capital do I want
to be putting into an asset
where these fines can just be dropping down,
these ad hoc fines might just be dropping down
into the business case and wiping out
whatever the business plan was gets wiped out.
The other thing I heard, which I couldn't ever verify,
which I hadn't verified, right,
but what I heard from other people
was that the county also was thinking about now
also coming in and levying fines on the same emissions
after the $82 million fine was levied.
Now, I don't know if that's true,
but that's kind of what the industry just scuttlebutt was.
And now you've got sort of this,
you know, now you've got a double dipping going on.
And I think now you're sending this,
the signal that it's sending to the industry
is it's not only the regulatory uncertain,
it's just regulatory uncertainty.
So not only do I have this uncertain market
that I'm dealing with and margins are thin,
but I can't even have a future view
of what the regulatory environment looks like.
And it just makes it that much harder
to justify spending capital at Benicia
to keep it maintained and operating
when I could spend that capital at one of my other assets
in another jurisdiction where that capital
is gonna earn a better return for shareholders.
Yeah, Valerio's stock actually went up
when they announced they were gonna pull out of California.
They were just, the shareholders were happy.
They were just getting out of California.
The losses, it's like, you're looking at,
you get this $82 million fine,
maybe the county's gonna get involved now.
And then, you know, you're looking at, okay,
what's it gonna be next year?
And what's it gonna be for?
These are the cleanest running refineries
pretty much in the world.
I don't know of a single operator
that's ever said, we don't want rules.
They've always said, just give us a set of rules.
And just let us comply with those rules.
But don't have a set of rules and then 10 years later
tell us that you're gonna penalize us
on a different set of rules that weren't in place
for the last 20 years.
Yeah, I would be in, go to meetings,
production meetings, management meetings,
the refinery manager, the operations manager
would be in it, and they would ask,
we got room to push the Outer Continental Shelf OCS crude
or back when we could push more San Joaquin Valley
or other con-carbon or high sulfur crudes.
I was pretty much the expert, the subject matter expert
at pushing the units to their maximum
to make sure we were not exceeding
those environmental limits on the main stack
on our tail gas scrubber with regards to hydrogen sulfide.
And I would tell the manager, whichever one was there,
no, we're running about as hard as we can run.
We don't have any room.
I mean, it's big margins, big money, you're talking,
but they'd look right back at me,
Margolisi and different ones that were there and say,
okay, Mike, just let's hold everything steady where it is.
They wouldn't push it.
You got up near an environmental regulation.
The management team was all, okay, let's keep it there
and we'll make what we can.
So now this gas is gonna come from other refineries
across the globe, right?
Is that gonna match the blend that we have?
How do we verify that?
Well, it will match the blend
because the specification has to be met in California.
So most of the gasoline that comes into the state
isn't carb gasoline when it leaves the refinery
in South Korea or India.
It comes as a series of blend components.
And when it reaches California,
the marketer knows how to make that gasoline
to specification and they will take
those various blend components,
blend them together to specification.
So I'm not worried about making fuel to specification.
The concern is gonna be,
can you get the components that you need?
In particular, there's a specific blend component
called Alkalet that is already in short supply in the world
and California gasoline needs Alkalet.
Every gasoline in the world likes to use Alkalet
in its blend.
California has to use it and it has to use it
in a higher proportion than other gasoline blends use
because of the tighter specifications.
There is no way to make the spec
without about 18 to 20% Alkalet in the pool.
So California will continue to make spec
and it'll continue to draw.
The question is, will there be specific blend components
available at the time that they need to be had?
And that's where when we start talking about
what happens to California gasoline prices
going into the future,
that's what I'm worried about
is specific blend components may not be available
in the volumes that California will need to import
and that's gonna induce some price volatility.
So it's much more complex than just buying it from overseas.
They're always blending, but we were making this.
You had to tank with the Alkalet,
tank with the Hydrocrackade, the Catnappas
and they wanted to make a tank of premium gasoline
for instance, they say X amount of this, this,
and this, boom, pump them in, mix the tank,
test the tank once it was tested to finals
and it was shipped via pipeline all over the state.
Now, like Skip's saying, you're gonna be relying
on all these different components
coming in from different places.
And if you're short of Alkalet,
then you can't make the specification
you need to make for the carb gas.
So that's where we're really vulnerable.
It would be better if the gasoline came carb ready,
it'd be a lot easier just to coordinate that,
bring it off, load it and get it out
to where it needs to go, but bringing it in by components
and then having to mix it when it used to be done
in the refinery where you had very positive control
over the situation, now your control is really vulnerable.
I mean, it's almost to the point like it's,
I don't know, I'd say a national security risk,
but then you're getting these refineries elsewhere
increasing their rates.
And it's like we were talking earlier,
some of them are buying crude oil from Russia,
which is not the best thing to do right now.
So we're indirectly, instead of producing,
having our jobs here, having our refineries open here
and producing more crude oil here,
making tax money and all that, our state's hurting
and then producing our own product.
Now we're looking at getting it from overseas
and we're gonna have to get it from overseas
or we're gonna have major shortages across the state.
And if we have one major, even minor hiccup
in any of that supply chain,
we're gonna see shortages here.
I've heard, I think gasoline, you have 10 to 12 bucks
a gallon, it's gonna vary on things like that.
And all this while we're paying more
and we're paying another country to make something
that we can do here and another country
that's buying crude oil from Russia,
then looking at like the Ukrainian war,
we're helping Russia fund its war effort
when we can do that here.
To me, it makes so much sense.
What I'm genuinely worried about is we have the potential
with gas, with jet, flights being cut back at LAX, SFO,
SAC, propane, especially with people in the winter of 2026,
but losing those two fuel components like we do,
if we take any substantial hiccup
or we take another refinery downtime all at the same time,
Chevron, Shell, one of them has a fire
or something brings them down,
we're gonna have shortages and it's gonna make the 70s
look like a walk in the park.
I was alive then.
I mean, you think about it, it's really just common sense.
We're getting it from halfway around the world.
It's gotta get here.
It's like Skip is saying, you got one component,
we can't get alkaline, we can't make the blend.
So what do they do?
They're gonna have to give waivers.
They're gonna have to give waivers on that carb blend.
That's the only way they can do it or we're stuck.
Skip, do you have any thoughts on the price?
Have you guys done any calculations?
We don't really have like a firm idea on the price.
We do think the price gets elevated
and we think it gets elevated in a couple of ways.
We think the new LCFS standards
is going to push through higher prices
and that's before we even get to-
Which is the low carbon emission.
The low carbon fuel standard is gonna push through
but that's even before we get into the economics
and the importation of gasoline.
So we think there's gonna be a wedge of price increase
that's gonna come from the tighter LCFS standard.
Then we think there's gonna be increasing pressure
on some of the blend stocks, in particular the alkaline.
And it's really hard to say,
is that a nickel a gallon, is it 50 cents a gallon?
That's really hard to figure out.
What we do know is that if you look at the difference
between sort of like US Gulf Coast gasoline
and California gasoline,
about 35 cents a gallon of that difference
is explained by the difference in alkaline.
The value of alkaline in the US Gulf Coast
versus the value of alkaline in the US West Coast.
That explains about 35 cents a gallon
explains that difference.
Because it has more?
Because it has more and it's also because of the limited,
the limited optionality of where you can get it from
because there's just more alkaline capacity
in the Gulf Coast and it's not as in greater need
because you can blend US reformulated gas
and you can blend conventional gasolines
with about 10% alkaline.
You'd put more in if the economics allow you to
but you can do it with about 10%.
In California, it's a minimum of 18%.
So I've got more alkaline and I don't need as much.
California, I need more alkaline and I don't have it.
So I'm having to pull it from overseas.
And that's not law.
And here's the other dimension
that gets hard with doing price views.
That's not lost on the refiners overseas.
So when you come looking for alkaline
and you're a West Coast marketer,
that refiner knows exactly what your economics are.
They can back what your economics are.
They know what you need.
They know how much you can pay.
They know how much you,
and they can sort of try to price a premium
into that alkaline.
And they can't get it here from the rest of the country
again, because we don't have any pipelines coming in.
Coming in, or if you wanted to move alkaline
from the Gulf Coast in,
you have to go through the Panama Canal
with a Jones Act tanker.
And there are no excess,
every Jones Act tanker, product tanker
is already fully deployed moving product
from the Gulf Coast to the East Coast.
So you'd have to go and build Jones Act tankers
in order to put them into service
to the Gulf Coast.
So it has to be imported.
That's the way.
So right now it has to be imported.
Now, if alkalite got so valuable
that it justified building a Jones Act tanker,
now maybe that changes at some point in the future.
But that's not today.
That's not gonna solve your alkalite shortage today.
Yeah, the Jones Act tanker isn't built in one day.
It takes a while.
Three to five years.
Three to five years, so.
If Valero goes down,
who is going to supply that gasoline?
Like who is going to do this work of importing and bringing?
Are there players that are gonna do that?
That's a big part of the problem.
You're not, we're not talking
a couple million gallons a day.
A million gallons a day, we're talking a big supply.
And then we shoot ourselves in the foot
right when they go down by the summer blend,
implementing the summer blend.
So we're gonna lose five, six, maybe eight,
at least seven and a half million gallons a day
of gasoline are gone, so.
Now you mentioned that during the summer,
the need is higher.
Like we need to have 5% more.
How does that work with the summer blend?
Oh, it's 5% less.
The need is, the demand is higher,
but because of the vapor pressure, re-vapor pressure,
they don't allow the refineries,
the butane, they allow the refineries to blend butane
into the gasoline pool during the winter
and not during the summer.
Butane is a byproduct of the refining, cracking,
or conversion process where they're breaking the molecules.
So if you have 20 carbons, you can get eight carbons,
eight carbons, that's gasoline,
and you'll have four carbons left, that's butane.
And same thing happens with propane,
you end up with three propanes.
You make a lot of, through the conversion process,
you make a lot of butane and you make a lot of propane
through the refining, the actual cracking process.
I've had, it's been very rare,
but there have been occasions where we've had so much butane
during the summer and they're in rail cars
and they can't get them out fast enough
or we've had to cut the,
on top of losing that in the gasoline pool,
we've had to cut the refinery rates.
Actually cut it back.
So the production goes down because-
The production goes down.
I have to throttle back because the cracking process
has made too much butane along with gasoline.
See, the HydroCracker unit at different refineries
provides different functions, as big as the same unit,
but when Valero built or Exxon built that refinery in 69,
it was gasoline, that's all they cared about, okay?
Whatever jet is in, distills out of the crude oil,
whatever diesel distills out of the crude oil,
they take that, which is about 14,000 barrels a day
on each one, give or take, the crude slate.
The gasoline is cracked in the HydroCracker.
They make the gas, the cat unit in the HydroCracker,
you get a lot of gasoline production.
Now at Chevron, they run their HydroCracker
a little different.
They have big jet contracts.
So they get jet and gasoline off the HydroCracker
and then down in South, like that Flying J refinery,
it's HydroCracker made diesel.
It depends on the market and what their contracts are.
So each one of them prioritizes one product
and then the other ones are byproducts that they get.
For the most part,
but the propane and the butane especially,
but we're sitting here making butane.
The thing is now,
we have so many electronically fuel-injected engines.
Looking at just kind of a common sense standpoint,
we have very few carbureted motors out there in our state.
When you had carbureted motors and it was hot in the summer,
you could end up with excessive vapor emissions,
excessive vapor locks sometimes in cars.
You don't hardly ever see that at all at the EFI engines.
So those emissions, just from our technology and the motors,
it's like diesel trucks, same thing.
The emissions technology is so good.
The emissions have gone way down.
So I'm not sure.
It just seems to me like this butane
that is pulled out during the summer,
they should be able to blend it in.
And that's what's gonna hammer us.
When Valero goes down,
we also lose that butane cannot be blended back
in the gasoline pool.
And that's 4% maybe, something like that.
So you're losing 11% with Valero.
It's a 15% hit at one time.
And you already got ConocoPhillips down
with 10 or 11% from them shutting down a few months before.
So the actual timing of Valero going down,
it's not gonna be a 20% hit.
It's gonna be a 25% hit total
on the state's gasoline supply.
And that's what you gotta make up.
And you're looking at 13, 14,
depends on the crude slates,
as much as 15 million gallons a day is gonna go away.
And making that up,
I don't know where we're gonna get it from overseas,
India or wherever, but that's a huge chunk to make up for.
And it really leaves us wide open
to shortages like I was saying before.
Skip, is there a chance to keep Valero from leaving?
Because I know that the state
has been trying to work with them.
I've heard from a number of different people
that the state of California
is actually trying to figure out some sort of solution,
including potentially finding a buyer for the refinery.
And so Valero would sell the refinery
to some other operator to keep the refinery operating.
That's an option that's out there.
But similar to Phillips 66 in Los Angeles,
that window's starting to close
because it takes about eight weeks.
And you might correct me if I'm wrong,
but it takes about eight weeks to shut down a refinery.
From when you say, I'm gonna dial this thing down
to actually taking it down cold.
Takes about eight weeks.
And there's probably about another four to six weeks
ahead of that where you've passed the point of no return.
You are now closing the refinery.
So there's maybe about a three-month window.
There's a two or three-month window, yeah.
You have to get everything cold.
You gotta clear everything.
You can't leave the vessels full of whatever they had in them.
You gotta dump the coker.
You gotta dump the catalyst out of the hydrocracker,
out of the caffeine hydrofiner, the cat unit.
You have to dispose of all of that material,
which is tons and tons and tons of it.
It's unbelievable amount of material.
And then you have to clear those vessels out
so they're not sitting there as hazardous waste domes.
So if you're looking at Benicia closing in April,
you get to sort of like December, January,
you're past the point of no return.
You will be if it starts cutting back.
You can cut it back fairly quick,
but it's in the fact of a more controlled, slower shutdown.
That's probably January, February.
By March, they'll probably be at minimum rates
and by April, off.
And then they go in.
Basically, they go into the process
of when they do maintenance on the refinery.
It's called a turnaround.
They shut down, they clear everything
using various mediums, nitrogen, steam,
to clear all the pipes, the vessels.
That's another thing is, like Skip was saying,
the margins are so terrible here.
Those turnarounds aren't cheap.
They're typically hundreds of millions of dollars.
It's like, do I wanna invest that in this refinery
and come back up and deal with what we're dealing with?
And that's where Valero's clearly made the decision,
no, we don't want to.
How hard is it to reopen them?
Let's say Valero shuts down
and then another operator comes in a year
and wants to start again.
The longer it's been closed,
the harder it is to restart a refinery
because you haven't been doing the maintenance.
And so part of the restart is you're having to go back in
and you're gonna find that there's pipes or valves,
you've had corrosion issues
or things that have to be worked on.
There's maintenance that has to be done
in order for you to restart.
Yeah, you gotta go in and work on,
you gotta go in and inspect.
And with the refinery, they know a lot of these areas,
just in general refining where you have problems.
During shutdown, they know where they're tunneling through,
looking for any damage, typically damage that occurs.
So they'll have to repair that.
Then, you know, like these catalysts that they dumped out,
they'll have to, it's a big,
whoever buys it is gonna have to go through all that
with inspecting, with repair, with bringing coke.
I mean, if they empty the coke silos at Valero,
that's gonna be a bear
because there's really no way
to get it back in the coke silo,
to get it back on the dock,
bring coke back on the dock, offload the ship.
I quite frankly don't know if it could be done.
They'd have to put in facilities
to be able to do that.
Then you have to bring in all your catalysts.
You have to buy all that all new
and you have to reload everything.
That's kind of typical from a turnaround,
but typically it's already there, it's already paid for.
So whoever buys it also has to make a tremendous investment
in restarting it.
And it won't, you know, it won't be two days later.
You're talking a couple of months.
I think you're talking months.
Three months, maybe.
Yeah, I think you're talking.
To restart it, yeah.
Assuming that it was closed down properly.
Right.
And you don't find any major issues
when you do the inspections.
And there are other ones that might be at risk.
Can you tell us more about those?
I think there's a couple of big questions,
like what's their margin environment?
So what is that refinery's margin,
which is different than the industry margin?
So what's its margin environment?
What's its turnaround cycle?
What's the next major turnaround for that refinery,
which could be five, six, 700 million dollars.
Yeah, Valero was like three years.
Yeah, and the money on those is,
and that's planned, where if you're not finding
any substantial damage, you know,
it's like on one time, our sulfur unit,
there was a set of fin fans.
They're made out of stainless steel.
That was like an eight million dollar.
They tried to pass it, and then the night,
the inspector for the unit during the night shift,
during the shutdown, we came in the next morning,
he had a tag on it that said condemned.
So it's like, okay, we're changing that.
But another thing that people don't realize
is Exxon, when Exxon owned it,
they had their own crude oil.
Okay, they sold their crude oil to the refinery.
If the refinery margins were so-so,
or even if they were losing money a little bit,
you know, because they would come into us and say,
well, we don't know about pay raises,
your refining's not, it's like,
oh, what did you make selling the crude oil to the refinery?
Give us a break, we're not stupid.
But Exxon had that flexibility.
Valero doesn't.
That's another part of the problem of Valero.
They're buying crude.
The Valero Corporation, it's like Sinclair.
It's another problem with Sinclair.
They don't own crude oil.
Valero does not own crude oil.
Exxon would make a ton of money selling their crude oil,
the Alaskan North Slope that they used to run to it,
89,000 barrels a day, it was a lot, you know.
So they would make a ton of money.
And if the refinery actually lost a little bit of money,
they'd wipe it off.
That, you know, perfectly legitimate thing to do.
But from a business standpoint, that was sensible.
But they were making money hand over fist, you know,
almost all the time selling the crude oil
to their own refinery.
Valero doesn't have that flexibility.
So you find a buyer,
you find a buyer that does not own crude oil,
their chances of success in Venetia
with the current environment,
with the air districts and all that,
their chances of success are slim and none.
And they know that.
And the buyer, I think it was Sinclair
that the CEC was trying to, you know,
work with Valero to get them to buy.
They pulled out, like Skip was saying.
And I also, I don't know what they,
I think it was the air district forced Valero
to build a $600 million scrubber,
wet gas scrubber for the main stack.
So for 40 years, they've been going out the main stack,
three furnaces, the two crude furnaces, the jet furnace,
went out the main stack, okay?
No real problems in 40 years,
but now you have to build a 600 million,
like you were, Skip, like you were saying
about the regulations changing.
And I think he's raising sort of like the third issue
is not only the margins or the ability
to afford the next turnaround,
it's the regulatory compliance.
Is there some big regulatory milestone that's coming
that's going to require a big expenditure of capital
in order to comply?
And you get up to that regulatory compliance
and that's the point that you say,
I'm out and I'm closing down the refinery.
So when you say,
what's the status of those other refineries?
It's a function of all three of those.
What's the margin inside that refinery?
What does its turnaround schedule look like
and how expensive is that next turnaround?
And also, does it have a regulatory milestone coming
and is it going to be willing to expend capital
on that regulatory compliance?
Because from an operator's perspective,
you assume that the rate of return
on regulatory compliance is zero.
It's sunk capital in order to keep the refinery running.
So you have to spend hundreds of millions of dollars
every few years.
Spend hundreds of millions of dollars
that I'm not going to earn a return on.
It just enables me to keep running the refinery,
where at least with turnarounds,
there's an economic justification for it.
I invest hundreds of millions of dollars
in maintaining this asset.
And when I start it back up,
I'm going to recoup this margin.
Maybe I've put some sort of beneficiation in.
When I did the turnaround
and I'm going to capture a little bit
at an incremental value by doing it,
the regulatory compliance is sunk capital.
And that's why I would say every refinery
in California is at risk
because they all have those three economic realities
that they have to face on a regular basis.
And that's being discussed in their respective boardrooms.
Every year when they put their capital budgets together,
those issues are being discussed, not just in California,
every refinery that they own in their entire network,
they're having that same discussion
about every single refinery.
It's just that the capital costs of compliance in California
and the margin environment in California
makes it a harder conversation for a California asset
as opposed to an asset
that sits in some other jurisdiction.
Now, what do you guys recommend to the state?
Well, in 2004, 2005,
Shell was shutting down in Bakersfield.
I went, as a matter of fact, Mr. Ellis worked down there too.
We found out we both work
at a couple of different plants together.
Kind of interesting.
But there were regulatory requirements
that San Joaquin Valley Air District was implementing
and they postponed those for two years
to help facilitate, I believe it was Senator Boxer
and Attorney General Lockyer.
They got involved and told Shell,
hey, you don't shut that down.
You sell it to somebody.
It's gonna affect California supplies
and we're already paying more
than anybody else in the country.
So you need to sell it.
So they did.
The Air District worked with them
to suspend those two requirements
that were coming for two years
to give Fly-N-J a chance to help them succeed, more or less.
A lot of these taxes that are levied,
this summer blend needs to stop.
You gotta make it more attractive for these refineries.
So I would do two things.
One is what can you do to sustain
or just slow the decline of crude oil production
in California, specifically in the San Joaquin Valley?
Because those pipelines are,
we're seeing flow in those pipelines decline
and like a refinery, pipelines get to a certain level
and they just have to shut down.
And if you lose a pipeline,
you start losing big chunks of production
because you will not be able to truck
San Joaquin Valley crude out of the valley
because it's just too heavy.
And you don't have the trucking facilities in place anyway.
And it goes back to the,
you're not gonna invest capital
into building trucking facilities.
So what can you do to sustain
or try to slow down the rate of decline
of production in California?
And that does two things.
It keeps the existing production online
because the pipelines stay feasible.
The other thing it does is that
every barrel of crude that you produce in California
is a barrel that you don't have to congest a port with
because you're already gonna be importing products
because we're losing refineries.
But at least if you could produce more crude in California,
you could reduce the number of crude tankers
that you're bringing in
and help with that port congestion issue.
That's one thing I would do.
The other thing that I would do is
we haven't tested,
the EPA has not tested the tailpipe emission profile
of carb gasoline versus reformulated gasoline since 1993.
And the specifications of both those fuels
have changed over the last 30 years.
Why don't we test the tailpipe emission profiles
and say, are those two fuels close to each other?
And I don't know.
I don't know if-
What's the difference?
One of them is the California one
and the other one is the national one?
The other one is the reformulated gasoline
is the clean air gasoline that's produced
for the other non-attainment areas in the United States.
So where you've got air pollution problems
in Houston or Dallas or New York City.
So there's a national blend.
There's a national blend and it's called RFG.
It's reformulated gasoline.
And carb is a reformulated gasoline,
but it's a tighter specification
because California's air quality problems back in the 90s
were so much worse than the rest of the country.
And that's why that separate specification was made.
But those specifications have,
both fuels have changed over time,
but we haven't tested the tailpipe profiles
of those two fuels since the initial designation
of carb versus RFG in the 1990s.
I think it'd be prudent to go
and test those tailpipe profiles and just say-
Is this really helping?
Is it really helping?
Are they, how close are they to each other?
And I don't know what the answer is,
but I think we got, but if I was the state of California,
I think you ought to know that
because it might be that the specifications
or the tailpipe emissions are so far apart,
RFG doesn't solve your problem.
And there's no fungibility.
Or it could be negligible, yeah.
But maybe the profiles have gotten close enough
to each other that maybe RFG becomes a substitute
or a substitute with some sort of waiver.
Maybe it becomes a winter fuel that you could use.
I don't know, but unless we find out
what the 2025 profile tailpipe emission profiles look like,
we don't know if there's another fuel source out there
in the United States that could be used
as a supply source for California,
as opposed to importing things
from halfway around the world.
When Valero announced they wanted to leave,
Governor Newsom directed the California Energy Commission
to work hard on keeping them here.
Now we go to Kathleen Reyes-Boyd,
who's been watching this
and she's monitoring the legislature
and what's happening there.
She's gonna tell us what the lawmakers
and the state is doing about this.
I'll start with what happened on the 29th of August.
And that was the decision
by the California Energy Commission,
as we previously talked.
What they had before them was passing
or deciding what to do with the margin cap and penalty,
which is basically the profit cap on refineries.
And that was a very important decision, as you know,
because it sends that signal to the market
on whether there's going to be any certainty
for future investment.
This was a very big deal.
So what the California Energy Commission did
was certainly take a good first step
and they did provide some certainty.
They didn't provide the certainty
to the level that we had hoped.
As you recall, we wanted them to repeal
the complete margin cap and penalty
because that sends the most signal to the investors
that California is open to business.
They didn't do that.
What they did instead is passed a five-year pause
with the opportunity for another five years
if certain investments were made.
So is it a good first step?
Yes.
Is it a decent signal?
Yes.
Is it enough?
The market will tell us whether it's enough.
I would say just directionally,
a step in the right direction.
This was a legislation that was passed
a couple of years ago, right?
And it hasn't really gone into effect, has it?
Well, what was passed in the legislation
was that special session.
And you recall those wonderful SBX1-2 and ABX2-1.
And what those sessions did is they told
the Energy Commission, go collect a lot of information
because the governor's asserts that there's price gouging.
We want you to collect the information
and decide whether there is.
So the Energy Commission did that
and the data did not support the assertion.
There was no price gouging.
And in fact, in some cases,
many months refiners were losing money.
So as a result, they took action
to pause the margin cap and penalty.
So that is on the regulatory side
with the Energy Commission.
And then I'll move to the legislative side.
The refineries that are leaving right now
or shutting down, were they doing that
because they were scared of these new regulations
or are they impacted by the regulations
that are already in place now?
Great question.
And it's a combination of both, right?
We've had 20 years of decisions in the state,
not saying they weren't meritorious
from an air quality standpoint
or a climate change standpoint,
but what they did is put additional cost
on refiners and producers of oil
in the state over a 20 year period.
And so it has been accumulation
of those policies that have got us here.
But then when you look forward,
there's only continuing policies
that are going to put an additional cost burden.
And so it is a combination, great question,
but it's a combination of both really,
from the past and what is viewed
from the future going forward.
Now, what's happening in the legislature?
Is the state changing its plans?
Let's take the production side first.
So as we talked, it was very important
that the legislature codify what's known as the current EIR,
the Environmental Impact Report.
That's been going on for two decades.
It's finally done.
It is allowing production to occur in Kern County
to go in those pipelines to the north and south
so refiners can have a more cost effective solution
to make gasoline, diesel and jet fuel.
That has been under litigation for the last two decades.
And as a result, if you codify the current EIR
in legislation, then it supersedes that
and you're allowed to continue.
Can you explain what that is?
So if that happens, if that's codified,
then Kern County can begin to issue new well permits.
And as we talked before, we have not received
any new well permits for two and a half years
and not because we don't have the oil,
just because the state has chosen not to issue permits.
And so as a result, we're in a 15 to 16% decline
in production in Kern County.
What does that mean?
Those pipelines that go to north and south
to the refiners from Central Valley
have got to be at least 30% capacity full.
Why?
Because they can't operate otherwise
because of all the pressure and issues with those pipelines.
So they have to have enough oil in them to flow
or they shut down.
And as they shut down, the field shut down.
So that's why this codification is so important
to get the permits issued, to get that oil in the pipelines,
to get it to the two refiners, especially PBF,
who is dependent on Kern County oil
for their ability to continue.
And we cannot, as we talked before,
have two more refineries close in California.
So this one action on Kern County production
is super and special and it's super important
and we have one week to do it.
If they decide to do this,
how long does it take for all of this to start?
It can actually start pretty quickly.
If the permits are issued,
there is obviously still some logistics
that have to happen since it's been not down for a while.
However, that being said,
our companies are well-prepared
to begin to initiate production
and produce oil to put in those pipelines
to go north and south.
So it's not a long timeframe for this to happen
as long as they are given the permits to act.
So they're well-positioned to do so.
They just need the authority to have a permit
to begin to produce that oil
and put more into the pipelines to flow.
If this doesn't pass,
a refinery like PBF, you mentioned they're at risk,
can they get it from other sources
instead of from Kern County?
Can they get-
Here's the problem for particular refineries,
and not all refiners are the same, right?
Some are better positioned marine-wise
from where they're located.
PBF is a refinery that bought,
especially Southern California, bought from ExxonMobil.
And so that refinery is not as positioned well
on the marine side.
So they've always had a dedicated pipeline
to Kern County, to Central Valley.
So their whole facility, their whole infrastructure,
everything is set up around that.
So it's very important for them
to be able to access more crude
in the pipeline that they really own
from Kern County down to them.
And that's been limited.
And it's the same with the North.
So it is a very important decision
for two refineries which would impact
both the North and the South.
There is another refinery, Valero,
which is decided to leave.
Is there efforts right now from the state
to keep them here?
So as you know, we're not really previewed
to those negotiations because it's completely
between Valero and the state and whomever else.
But we do know that when Valero announced
they were potentially closing in April of 26,
that if there was not some solution put on the table
to make this more economic for them to stay,
then they would proceed with that.
So we're still in this area of figuring out
whether or not something has been put on the table
for them to stay.
Obviously, this is a very critical decision.
Valero is very well positioned in the North
for many reasons and also for the production
of asphalt oil.
Everybody sort of forgets about this piece,
that asphalt oil, which makes all of our roads
throughout the state, is a very necessary component
that is a byproduct for some refineries
and Valero is one of them.
And so this is a rippling effect
that begins to impact everything.
Of course, the city of Benicia is very dependent on Valero.
So it impacts the city tremendously if they don't stay.
And there's a lot of laws that are gonna pass.
Is there enough time to consider all of this
from what you're seeing?
It is a very good question.
And time is not on our side.
I have seen in the past, we seem to do
really amazing things in crisis.
We're always governed by crisis,
which is not a good way to govern, by the way,
but we seem to do well with it when it happens,
rolling blackouts as an example.
But I think, I'm not saying it's impossible
because I have seen it happen.
I think it's a big challenge to get this done in a week.
Hopefully, it will all go well.
Catherine Reyes-Boyd
with Western State Petroleum Association,
it was great to have you on California Insider.
Very so, my pleasure, my honor to be with you again.
Thank you so much for having me.
Let us know what you think the state should do.
Should we put a lot of effort in California
to keep the refiners here,
or should we go and rely on imported products?
You can always comment or email us.
And when you comment,
make sure to consider all parties involved.
We wanna bring all Californians to our platform
so people can express their ideas and opinions
so that the state can improve.
I'm Siamak Khorami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.
