Europe's Undeciphered Prehistoric Tablets - Enigmatic Artefacts

Artifact Archives
9 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 9, 2025
Brotlaibidole/ Tavolette Enigmatiche were bronze age tablets in use across central Europe but what were they for?
Huge thanks to Holger Kieurg for facilitating this whole thing and coming up with the idea for the video.
Huge thanks to Wolfgang David for being willing to share his extensive expertise.
Huge thanks to Ettore Mazza for doing the artwork
Huge thanks to Joey Yee for editing it all.
Huge thanks to my generous patrons
This tablet doesn't have a name in English. Nor this one, or this one, or any of these.
In Italian they are Le Tavolette Enigmatiche, the enigmatic tablets. In German they are
Brotweib Idole, the bread loaf idols. They all date to the Bronze Age. Hundreds of them have
been found across Central Europe and we have no idea what they were for. We can't really read or
understand the symbols on them. We don't know who made them. We don't know why they were made. All
we know is that they're so widespread that they must have been used for something. Really is an
enigma. Really is a mystery. Let's see what we do know about them though and see if that gives us
any clues to the purpose of Europe's undeciphered prehistoric tablets.
Made a little replica myself just now. Actually harder than I thought
for such a simple object. Researching this video was really difficult. I'm always trying to come
up with interesting and novel videos about prehistory and ancient history for you guys.
And this one I think I really succeeded because there's very little information online about these
tablets. They don't even have an English language Wikipedia page. They don't even have a name in
English. And in my archaeology degree where I did a lot of prehistoric Europe, a lot of Bronze Age
Europe, I don't remember them ever coming up. But I could have entirely forgotten because that was
a particularly hazy time in my life. I actually only heard about them because I did a guest seminar
at the University in Frankfurt and through that met archaeologist Holger Kieberg who mentioned
they were putting on a display of all these artifacts and asked if I would like to make a
video on it. Through him I met Wolfgang David who probably knows more about these tablets than
just about anyone alive today.
They're called loaf of bread idols because they're deceptively small. The biggest is only about 10
centimeters. This like little replica I made super quick, this would probably be one of the bigger
ones. They're made out of clay which has been fired. Mine is obviously freshly made so mine is a
tad floppy. And they have these very interesting patterns on them. Often some sort of indentation
like a circle or maybe like a flower. Some sort of symbol on them and then these horizontal lines
across them almost like a chocolate bar. Although there are a couple of examples that seem to be
much more ornate. So far around 400 have been found but Wolfgang thinks they're small size
and the fact that they're made out of clay has meant they might be kind of underrepresented.
Could have been easily tossed aside.
The main working hypothesis is of course that these tablets were trying to communicate something.
I know what you're thinking, Stefan. I'm a copper merchant sailing up and down the Danube. I love
communicating things but my phone bill is too high when I'm traveling. Well Aerolo makes it easy to
communicate when you're traveling the world and at the minute they're offering three dollars off.
They're the world's first eSIM store. They allow you to conveniently and safely use your phone in
over 200 countries and regions. No more ridiculous roaming fees, no more buying local sim cards so
annoying, no more standing in the outside the train station because it's the only place with
wi-fi. Been there. Aerolo has helped over 20 million people stay connected whilst they're
traveling. Call, text, post on social media, go down internet rabbit holes about obscure archaeological
artifacts. You can do it all and the best part is you don't even have to change your phone number.
It just takes a couple of minutes to set up. Boom. Super easy stuff and you're away. Install Aerolo
today so you can stay connected wherever you travel and use my code stefanm3 to get three
dollars off your first eSIM. It's so easy. Check it out in the description or scan the QR code
that's around here somewhere. Thank you so much Aerolo for supporting the channel.
Okay I think the first step in understanding these tablets is to discuss their age and their
distribution. That's the first clue. Roughly they all date to the sort of transition period
between the early bronze age and the middle bronze age in Europe.
This was a time period where a lot was going on. Greece at this time was home to the Mycenaeans
and the Minoans. They built large palaces and urban centers on the tops of hills and in prominent
locations. It was the start of these so-called palace cultures. A real sort of centralization
of political and economic and spiritual activity it seems. Art and technology really flourished
in these urban environments. I've got some of them now. I mean they're just absolutely spectacular
and at least some of these people were jumping over balls which is always cool. That's a cool
thing to be able to say that you've done no doubt about it. Over in Anatolia the Hittites were
ruling their empire from their capital Hattusha. Their empire went all the way to the borders of
Egypt and connected the old cities of Mesopotamia to the Mediterranean world. Crucially both these
cultures were writing. Mycenaeans, Minoans they had linear A, linear B. The Hittites had their
own version of cuneiform. Both of those civilizations are in contact with Egypt,
of course famously had lots of writing. We know that these regions were in contact with whoever
was making these tablets. From artifacts and trade goods found at excavations we can see
that the rivers of Europe, the Danube and the Po were really like trade arteries as they are now.
These are some really interesting artifacts made out of bone and things like that that
seemingly have designs from the eastern Mediterranean. These are small containers,
maybe these are for luxury goods. This is a part of a horse's bridle again with that same pattern
on. These rivers, these areas of contact, these areas of trade are precisely where we find these
bread loaf idols. You can see their distribution on this map here. There are a lot that follow
the Danube up from Romania and Bulgaria and Serbia into Hungary and Austria, Slovakia, Germany.
Then there's a second concentration around the Po river valley in northern Italy. These little
chaps, these broken slivers of tablet were from even as far away as Corsica. So it's a pretty
wide distribution but mainly you could say focused on two major river systems, the Danube and the Po.
Wolfgang wonders if the inspiration behind these tablets was in some way inspired by the connection
with these worlds who are writing, with these people who are writing tablets.
They must have been for communicating something because
all of these regions like up the Danube and in northern Italy, they each had their own culture.
They produce different art, different symbols. These people are certainly not united politically
and probably they have many cultural differences too. But they're united by the use of these
tablets. Almost certainly something had to be communicated with them.
Wolfgang
is right. These are for communication across these different cultural groups.
What are they saying? What are you saying? You guys know the stereotype when there's an object,
an artifact that is a little bit enigmatic, hard to explain. The default explanation is ritual.
And I'm rather partial to that explanation myself if you saw the Roman dodecahedron video. But in
this situation that really doesn't seem to be the case. The context that these tablets are found in
isn't obviously connected to ritual anyway. And we have a lot of ritual sites from the Bronze Age.
It's not like we don't know where these people were conducting rituals. There are only two cases
out of the over 400 that have been found so far where they might have been connected to a grave.
And even that's not obvious. They're just close to graves. All the rest are basically just found in
domestic settings just scattered around Bronze Age villages. One village in particular had lots
of these in the Slovakian village of Nitriansky Hradok. Almost 50 of these were found just
scattered across the site. So discarding this sort of like ritual hypothesis, do we have any
other clues to their to their purpose? If we look at the tablets themselves, apart from the symbols
on them, the most striking thing is how many are seemingly deliberately snapped. Deliberately broken.
All the tablets found so far are either complete or incomplete. Which I know is like those are
the only two possible options. But for example, when one is snapped we have never found two halves
of the snapped tablet. It's either snapped and a piece has disappeared or they're fully
incomplete. The lines on them, it does seem to suggest that these are meant to be broken.
And it's almost as if when they are snapped, I can't snap mine because it's too floppy, but when
they are snapped it's like someone else has ended up with this piece. It's not at the site anymore.
So there are a few hypotheses that are connected to that. Maybe this is some form of identification.
The messenger can snap it or prove that a message came from someone perhaps
when pieces are reunited. Maybe there's something to that idea. Maybe a messenger was sent away
and when the answer came back you could prove that you were the messenger or something by
reassembling them. But then we might find broken pieces together maybe, as this message was
completed. One of the reasons that it's so hard to understand what's going on with these tablets is
that we're probably, well not probably, we're certainly missing the oral information and
understanding that came along with them. And ethnographically we do know of kind of similar
objects being used as a messenger system. These are message sticks. They're from Australia.
They come in all shapes and sizes. These are not writing as such, but they were aids to deliver an
oral message like news of a death, declaration of war, things like that. Things like that.
So maybe these tablets operated in the same way. There's some sort of aid to an oral message
and when it's delivered, snap. Why do different people end up with different halves of them?
It's tricky. It's tricky that. That's a real tricky aspect of it, the fact that they're broken.
One hypothesis I like, which could account for the symbols and the lines, is that
this could be for some sort of timekeeping device. The symbol might represent something
and then as, you know, as it's getting closer to that date every week or month or season perhaps,
snap, snap, snap, a different piece is broken off. And that maybe could explain the variability
in how many sort of chunks and divisions these tablets have because, you know, different things
take different amounts of times. And yeah, it could explain why they're being broken seemingly
so randomly. That's an interesting idea.
Wolfgang is really keen on opening up this debate to the public. These tablets are not
as famous as they should be and if you have an idea about what could be communicated
with very simple patterns and yet seemingly the breaking of them, if you have an idea of
what kind of information you could convey with that, then let Wolfgang know. No one else has
figured it out so he's really keen to increase the profile of these artifacts and see what
ideas are out there. You know, if you're an MI6 or the CIA or even the KGB,
hope I don't have too many KGB viewers, but if you were, you know, and you've got an idea about
what could be sent with, what kind of message could be sent with a tablet, let Wolfgang know.
Let Wolfgang know. I mean, it could even be possible, of course, that trying to find one
answer to this problem is a fool's errand.
In the past, when we've deciphered lost languages, lost tablets, there's often been a key,
like a Rosetta Stone, that we've been able to use to understand this. In this scenario,
because of how old they are, they're in an environment that doesn't have written language,
and the symbols on them are very simple, it's unlikely we're going to find a Rosetta Stone,
right? That probably is not out there waiting to be found. So I really wanted to ask Wolfgang
how he thought we could solve this puzzle.
What we really need to find, yeah, it's just one of those things, we need more examples,
we need to dig more, we need to find more. What we really need to find is one of these tablets,
if it is connected to trade, alongside the good that it is traded with. That might be really hard,
that might be really hard, but there is sort of a really cool example from the Balkans which
might give us a clue to how we can solve this. So take a look at these objects here,
these are believed to be bird rattles. Maybe it's for a kid, maybe it's a musical instrument.
They're really beautiful, I kind of love the abstractness of prehistoric art in Europe,
I really love it. I know it's like a big inspiration for Picasso and things like that.
They were found in Ostrava Mare on the Romanian side of the Danube, along with a lot of other
really cool artifacts. Just a few kilometers south in the Serbian village of Pravo,
a tablet was excavated, one of these bread loaf tablets. As you can see, they share a really,
really similar pattern on them. The front of this bird and the bread loaf tablet,
and this same pattern was recovered from the pot of a lid at Ostrava Mare, I believe as well.
This is the kind of information we need to solve this riddle. We need to find a way to
connect these patterns to other things going on in these cultures, these civilizations,
and see if we get a lot of examples of this, more examples of this kind of thing,
what patterns emerge from that. Maybe we can use some science to identify the contents of pots
that share a symbol on these bread loaf tablets. Maybe if we find a lot of these, perhaps some
mathematical statistics or even AI could really help us recognize a pattern that's
difficult for us to see ourselves. At the minute, with 400 examples, Wolfgang thinks we just don't
have a large enough database to apply these kinds of things, but if we keep finding them, who knows?
That's probably the closest archaeology can get to a Rosetta Stone, is finding the connections
between these symbols and other cultures and other stuff going on in these cultures. That's probably
as close as we'll ever get. Whatever purpose, whatever function they served, the final mystery is
why they disappeared.
If these little things were truly inspired by connection to the Mediterranean world and access to
writing and things like that, then why did this experiment not take off? What purpose did they
serve that it was now obsolete? What happened there? If it was for counting goods and things like that,
why did this idea of writing not expand like it did in Egypt and Mesopotamia and Greece?
It didn't seem to apply to other areas of their lives, perhaps, and was easily discarded.
It's an interesting one. They disappear as suddenly as they appear. Instead of Europe's
first writing system, we're left with these bread loaf idols, these enigmatic tablets.
Baked into clay over 3,000 years ago. Enigmatic artifact indeed.
