Justice Amy Coney Barrett on independence of Supreme Court

World Cultural History
11 followers
7 Video Views·Sep 6, 2025
Justice Amy Coney Barrett emphasized the independence of the Supreme Court, asserting that the court is not influenced by politics or public opinion. She said that decisions are made based on the law, not partisanship, to protect justice and the public trust.
Comments are disabled for this video.
The Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett, who is speaking to CBS News in her first TV
interview since joining the court.
She's talked exclusively with senior correspondent Nora O'Donnell on a wide range of issues,
including the independence of the court from politics.
It's something she writes about in her new book, Listening to the Law, Reflections on
the Court and Constitution.
Here's part of their conversation for CBS Sunday morning.
President Donald Trump appointed you to cement a conservative legal revolution.
Are you concerned about the narrative of this court that it is no longer a separate and
co-equal branch of government as designed by the Constitution?
I disagree with that conception of the Supreme Court because the Supreme Court is an independent
branch of government.
And presidents appoint justices and, you know, presidents have whatever their own motivations
are for appointing justices.
But once justices serve on the court, the whole point of life tenure and salary protection,
which is guaranteed to federal judges by the Constitution, is to ensure their independence
from both the executive branch and from Congress.
But does the reputation of the Supreme Court matter to you?
I want people to have trust in the court.
And that's why I wrote this book, frankly.
I wanted people to understand how the court works.
I wanted them to understand how we get our cases and how we go about making our decisions
because the court belongs to every American.
And I want Americans to feel like they have a stake in the court and they understand what
the court does, because what the court does is not the same kind of work that Congress
does and it's not the same kind of work that the president does.
Those are the political branches.
The court is not one of the political branches.
Nora O'Donnell joins us now.
Nora, what insight did she share with you about how she makes her decisions on cases
before the court?
Well, a great deal of insight.
And this is important because legal observers say that Justice Amy Coney Barrett is the
most influential justice on the Supreme Court.
She was appointed by Trump back in 2020, but lately she has shown an independent streak.
So that is actually very fascinating.
What she said about these decisions is that she said, I don't just shoot from the hip
and decide this is constitutional or this is not constitutional.
She said that's the opposite of judicial rule.
In fact, she talked about the fact that there are turtles, yes, little turtle statues all
over the Supreme Court to make the idea that change happens slowly.
Why is that important?
Because lately in the last term, there have been a number of these rulings on the emergency
document all about President Trump's executive order.
So whether it's birthright citizenship, whether it's the use of executive power in terms of
freezing federal funding, those have all come before the Supreme Court.
And there have been rulings or holdings that are a big deal.
And those will likely be cases like birthright citizenship that also come back in this next
term before the Supreme Court.
Nora, it's a fascinating interview.
I can't wait to see the whole thing on Sunday.
But she talked about misconceptions at a time when Americans have doubts about the court.
Could you expand on what she said about how people see the court and then the reality
of the court in her view?
Well, look, there is so much mystery that surrounds the Supreme Court because it is
the one of the three branches of government that is not political.
And I think she's trying to make that case that they are independent because, as she
said, she had this lifetime tenure, that they'd work slowly, that their work does become clear
in their opinions, that at the end of the day, it's the nine justices in the room, no
clerks, no assistants who make decisions, that they're collegial behind the scenes,
that they're actually friendly and that they have lunch together.
And I think this is important because, as you know, this is the highest court in the
land. And with President Trump and Supreme Court's in the past, they mirror the most
controversial issues of the day.
And there are going to be a lot of them in the months and years ahead.
Sure will be, Nora. Thank you very much.
Really appreciate it.
And viewers, you can see more of Nora's interview with Justice Barrett this weekend on CBS Sunday
morning and then Nora will join us again live on Monday with even more from that conversation.
