Here’s how US train travel went from excellent to mediocre.
Subscribe and turn on notifications 🔔 so you don't miss any videos: http://goo.gl/0bsAjO
If you’ve taken the Amtrak recently, you might have no idea that the United States used to have the largest and wealthiest rail system in the world. How did the US go from having luxurious, widely used passenger trains to the Amtrak system we have today?
Video producer Dean Peterson makes a 72-hour journey on Amtrak from LA to NYC to show its current state of operation. From getting kicked in the head by his sleeping seat mate to taking in sweeping views of the desert at sunset, Dean shows the highs and lows of being stuck on Amtrak for days on end.
Along the way, he explains the history of passenger rail in the US — starting in the problematic robber baron era to the US government’s takeover of passenger rail. Will the United States ever catch up to the rest of the world when it comes to train travel, or are Americans stuck with an underfunded, inefficient rail network forever? Join Dean on his journey as he sets out to find out the answer to these questions and more.
Amtrak, America's Railroad: Transportation's Orphan and Its Struggle for Survival (Railroads Past and Present) by Geoffrey H. Doughty, Jeffrey T. Darbee, Eugene E. Harmon https://www.amazon.com/Amtrak-America...
The United States has always had a love-hate relationship when it comes to train travel.
The country was literally built on the backs of the railroads and the US used to have the biggest
and the most well-funded rail network in the world. But if you ask anybody that's
taken the Amtrak they'll tell you that that's not exactly the case anymore.
The US has fallen woefully behind the rest of the world when it comes to train travel.
So what the heck happened? How did the United States get so far behind and does it have any
chance of catching up? To find out the answer to that I'm going to take the Amtrak from here in
Los Angeles all the way to New York City and I'm going to have plenty of time to think about it
since it's a 70-hour journey. I guess I better get started.
The entire length of my journey from Los Angeles to New York is about four days long and for the
first leg of my journey there weren't any sleeper cars available. So this is what my living space
looks like for the next two days which as somebody that's years old should be really good for my back.
The journey I'm taking is pretty different than it would have been about a hundred years ago.
To see the differences let's take a look at this US map. The year is 1916 and there's about
254,000 miles of railroads. The highest number there's ever been in this country.
The Pennsylvania Railroad or the Penzey as it was referred to. I feel like that nickname could
have probably used a little more work. Nevertheless it was the largest corporation in the world at the
time. It's difficult to illustrate how influential these companies were and how much railroads were
interwoven into the fabric of American life. They were responsible for the temples of their time
like Penn and Grand Central stations. Also you would not believe how amazing train travel could
be back then. Sure they had basic boring train cars like the one I'm riding but the upscale
trains featured chandeliers, barber shops, pianos, and food service that would make the four seasons
look like Boston Market. One menu featured oysters, consomme, and celery fed duck. The bad news is my
train didn't have ducks that were fed anything. I ate the Thai red curry street noodles which
although I'm pretty sure they were just a microwave frozen package were actually pretty good.
And although the accommodations were a far cry from crystal chandeliers they were comfortable enough.
Good evening ladies and gentlemen this is the conductor speaking. It has now been five hours
and 15 minutes which is the time it takes to fly from LAX to Newark airport and we are still in
California. It's only nine o'clock but it already got dark outside so there's nothing to look out
the window and there's no wi-fi apparently so I guess I'm just gonna go to sleep. They leave the
overhead lights on all night but luckily I brought my trusty eye mask. I also brought some earplugs
which should come in handy because I'm sitting right in front of some iPad kids who are watching
movies at full volume with no headphones so that's fun. Alright I'll see you in the morning.
Did I sleep well last night? Hmm I'm going to say no. I'll spare you the details but imagine
getting literally kicked in the head by the woman in the seat next to you. I wound up retreating to
the observation car to sleep which was less than ideal. Like an astronaut in space I'm trying to
move around as much as I can so that my muscles don't deteriorate during my journey. So let's
talk about how American trains went from gilded pleasure palaces to this. Part of the reason why
railroads became so wildly successful in the first place is because they were run by what
were affectionately termed robber barons. Men like Cornelius Vanderbilt, Jay Gould, James Fisk,
and J.P. Morgan. These guys were ruthless, anti-labor, and really corrupt which was great
when it came to building an expansive kingdom of highly profitable rail companies but bad when it
came to just about everything else. As a result the train companies became pretty universally hated
by the general public as seen in what passed for scathing satire at the time. Now then Jim
no jockeying you know let him rip Commodore don't stop to water or you'll be beat. The federal
government saw the kind of crap these guys were pulling and was like whoa whoa whoa you can't do
that. So they instituted a bunch of regulations which among other things set fixed rates for the
railroad companies and also prevented them from raising their fares or changing their service
without the government's permission. This didn't seem like that big of a deal at the time because
as historian Robert Self-Henry said, the problem to some minds at least was how to keep railroads
from making too much money. After all railroads were still by far the most efficient and the best
way for most people to travel. This all obviously changed when affordable automobiles and later air
travel came into the picture. So much so that by 1956 only 4% of passenger travel was on trains.
When you take into account that 40 years earlier that number was 98% you can see how much the U.S.'s
priorities had shifted when it came to travel. The train companies were far from a monopoly anymore
but they were still being regulated as if they were, which was killing them. Okay so right now
we are being held on the tracks to let a freight train pass and this is actually the perfect time
to talk about something. Private commercial passenger trains have never been very profitable.
The lifeblood of the industry has always been these, freight trains. But rail companies were
always forced to provide passenger service as a benefit to the public. So when the rail companies
began to suffer and then eventually fold, the government had the idea to take the responsibility
for passenger service off the plates of the rail companies who could then focus on the profitable
freight side of the business. They took all the passenger service and combined it into one company
which is how in 1971 we got Amtrak, which stands for the American Train Track. Again what is up
with these nicknames? Amtrak makes it easy come easy go to more than 450 cities in the USA.
But here is the thing, Amtrak was designed to fail from the beginning. That may sound ridiculous but
let me explain. First of all the government created Amtrak as a for-profit corporation
despite the fact that virtually no passenger service anywhere has been profitable. After all
the government broke off all the passenger trains from the rail companies because they weren't
making money. When the government formed Amtrak they tasked it with employing innovative operating
and marketing concepts to develop the potential of modern rail service. And how much did congress
give them to do that in their first year of operation? Just 40 million dollars. Their budget
has gone up a lot since then. Their budget for the year 2022 was 2.3 billion dollars. Which sounds
like a lot doesn't it? But when you take into account that the federal highway budget for the
same year was 64.3 billion dollars, you begin to see the inequity. To put it even more into
perspective, the sum total of all the subsidies that the U.S. has allocated to Amtrak in its entire
history is less than one year's funding for the interstate highway system. This right here shows
where America's priorities lie when it comes to travel and why Amtrak has failed to majorly expand
or innovate. Okay so we just got to Chicago. I got off the Amtrak about 45 hours after I left Los
Angeles and needless to say I do not smell very good. I have about a seven hour layover here in
Chicago and right now I'm in Union Station which is actually kind of amazing. As you see I got a
chance to put on some clean clothes which feels amazing and now I'm just here in Millennium Park
rolling around with my suitcase like a dang tourist and I'm just trying to enjoy not being
on a train as much as possible before I get on the second leg, the second and final leg of my
journey. I've achieved the holy grail of my own private room. I want to show you my favorite
feature of the entire room. You're gonna like this. Hidden sink. This train is a little bit more
dynamic shall we say than the last one but I'm hoping that all the movements will just
help rock me to sleep. When I woke up we had reached Ohio, about 2,600 miles through my journey
and 50 something hours. There are a lot of reasons why people still want to take the train.
A big one is the environment. According to a study by the University of Pennsylvania,
a long distance train trip produces 37% less emissions than taking a flight. Trains are also
much safer than cars. You're 17 times more likely to die while driving than taking a train. Flying
and driving can be faster and sometimes even cheaper than taking the Amtrak but they're both
often miserable experiences. Going through TSA, dealing with flight delays, or being stuck in
traffic and not being able to do anything because you need to be driving the car. While I've been
on Amtrak I've been able to just stare out the window and see the country go by or read a book
or take a nap or whatever. I've been able to wander around the train whenever I want and stretch my
legs and I've had the enjoyment of having my own private little room and this is with Amtrak being
perpetually and profoundly underfunded. Imagine what it would be like if this were evened out.
So I made it. All total it took me about 72 hours and 17 minutes which granted it would
have taken me between five and six hours to fly that distance. I don't actually know the distance
off the top of my head but I'm gonna add it in post right here. But here's the thing. I had a good time.
It was actually really fun aside from a couple of hiccups at the very beginning. It was a really
pleasant memorable experience. I got to see parts of the country that I had never seen before
and overall, dare I say, it was a pleasant experience. Right now Amtrak covers roughly
21,000 miles of passenger rail in the U.S. but when you look at the map you can see it's sparse
coverage, routes that don't connect, and sorry Wyoming and South Dakota you don't get any trains.
If the United States took Amtrak off life support it would revolutionize the way people travel
around the U.S. When he was retiring former Amtrak president Graham Claytor said,
when I came to Amtrak I was convinced I could save it but finally came to the conclusion that
only the American public can save it when they say they want it. Now if you'll excuse me I'm
gonna go take a much-needed shower and go to sleep in a real bed. I gotta rest up for my flight back
to California tomorrow. For me one of the best parts of riding the Amtrak is just throwing on
some Phoebe Bridgers and wistfully staring out the window for hours on end.