Man of Steel vs Superman: Who Really Won at the Box Office?

Latest Movie Reviews
5 followers
7 Video Views·Sep 5, 2025
Hello everybody, I'm Dan Merl and I'm here today to talk about a subject that I'm sure will be
very non-controversial, the box office performance of Man of Steel versus Superman. For weeks now,
some fans of Zack Snyder's Man of Steel and some fans of James Gunn's Superman have been
debating online about which movie is really more successful, with many of Snyder's supporters
saying that Superman is a massive failure, especially when inflation is taken into account,
and many of Gunn's supporters pointing to Superman's higher domestic gross.
Box office is one of the main focuses of this channel, so I decided to take a deep dive into
the box office of both Superman and Man of Steel, taking as many factors as I could into account
to determine where the truth lies. And to be clear, I am not advocating for one movie or the
other here, this is just an attempt to inject a little research into what is largely an
ideological debate, which always works on the internet, right? Also, I want to be very clear,
we are not talking about quality, we are not talking about expectations, we are talking about
theatrical profitability. How much money did each movie make or lose? When you look at what came in
from the box office, ticket sales only, I will address other streams of revenue at the end of
this video once I've run down where I landed for both of these movies. First of all, let's look at
raw numbers as they stand today. Both Man of Steel and Superman had a reported budget of $225
million according to multiple sources I found online. When it comes to marketing, numbers are
a little harder to come by because studios don't generally disclose those figures. Several sources
claim that Man of Steel had a marketing budget around $150 million. Reports for Superman's
marketing budget varied between $100 and $200 million, so I decided to set the number right
in the middle, matching Man of Steel's. Kind of like poetry, it rhymes. Right now, Superman has
the edge as far as domestic gross at $347.3 million versus Man of Steel's $291 million,
but Man of Steel has the edge internationally, bringing in $379.1 million to Superman's $258
million, meaning that Man of Steel also has the higher worldwide gross at $670.1 million to
Superman's $605.3 million. So based on the raw numbers, Superman wins domestically,
Man of Steel wins worldwide. But a dusty old metric that really, us box office nerds,
we used to be the only ones to care about that, has emerged in this conversation, and that is
adjusting for inflation. Over time, ticket prices go up, and when you adjust for inflation, it evens
out the grosses. Now, I'm not saying that Man of Steel would sell as many tickets today as it did
in 2013, what I am saying is that when you take the dollar amount of tickets sold for Man of Steel
in 2013, this is what it's worth today. When you adjust Man of Steel's domestic box office
gross for inflation, using metrics that are specifically targeted at movie ticket price
inflation, Man of Steel's domestic gross goes up to $419.1 million, easily besting Superman
by almost $72 million. Given that it already outgrows Superman worldwide, that means Man of
Steel is the box office champion by nearly $200 million. So that's it right? Video over. Man of
Steel trounces Superman. No, we're not even close. If we are adjusting the money that Man of Steel
made for inflation in order to accurately compare it to Superman, we also have to adjust the money
that it cost to make Man of Steel for inflation. After all, we're not just talking about which
movie grossed more, we're talking about which movie is more profitable. When you adjust Man
of Steel's costs for inflation as well, the budget increases from $225 million to $312 million,
with marketing expenses going up from $150 million to $208 million. That makes Superman
a substantially less expensive film to make, with budget and marketing coming in $145 million
lower than Man of Steel. And you might ask why Superman's marketing costs in particular
would be so much lower, but it has been reported that Warner Bros. leaned heavily into social media
promotion for the film, which is less costly, especially with the actors and director joining
in. And while social media was absolutely big in 2013, Man of Steel was released in an era where
promotion tended to lean more heavily into more expensive and traditional marketing strategies
like TV ad sales. Again, these are just estimated numbers based on what I could
suss out from multiple reports and industry news stories online. So, how does that affect
the profitability for each movie? Well, if you watch charts with Dan, this graphic should be
familiar to you. On the left is how much Man of Steel made in China, which returns an estimated
20% of total box office revenue to the studio. Internationally, which returns an estimated 40%
of box office revenue to the studio. And domestically, with the studio getting a larger
portion of the gross in week 1, then stepping down gradually to a 50-50 split in week 3.
And I will say that there are a lot of different reports about just how much money studios get
from ticket sales, so this is just my best estimate based on the information I can find.
Before adjusting anything for inflation, Man of Steel made $670 million worldwide,
and my estimates show that $304 million of that was net box office gross that was returned to
the studio. It's a little bit less than 50% of the overall gross because Man of Steel
earned more internationally where returns are lower than it did domestically.
When you subtract Man of Steel's $375 million in costs from its net box office gross,
I estimate that based solely on worldwide ticket sales, not including any other forms of revenue
like licensed tie-ins and DVD sales, Man of Steel fell about $70 million short of breaking even.
Let's compare that to Superman. As of right now, I estimate that Superman is about $77
million short of breaking even theatrically before ancillary revenue kicks in, netting
$297.1 million from its $605 million worldwide gross. It's a little closer to 50-50 than Man
of Steel, because Superman was stronger domestically, where more of the ticket sales
come back to the studio. So before we adjust for inflation just based on raw box office numbers,
Superman and Man of Steel performed about the same theatrically. They both fell between $70
and $80 million short of breaking even in the theatrical window, though to be fair,
we haven't adjusted for inflation yet. But when we're talking about worldwide,
global box office numbers, adjusting for inflation can be a little tricky.
In order to do it accurately, I would need to go back and figure out how much money Man of Steel
made back in 2013 in each country in their local currency, then adjust that total for their local
rate of inflation, then take that amount and convert it to $2025 using current exchange rates.
It would be an arduous multi-step process that only someone with an unhealthy box office obsession
would undertake. So I did it. Not for every single country, because some of that data is
practically impossible to find, but I was able to find it for the countries where Man of Steel
earned the most money internationally. This is a look at Man of Steel's profitability with domestic
grosses and expenses adjusted for US inflation, as well as grosses in top markets adjusted for
local inflation. The remainder of the international gross that I wasn't able to convert locally
just had its total US dollar amount adjusted. It's not perfect, but this is just a general idea.
Because not all countries have seen inflation rates as high as the US,
the increase in costs actually drove down Man of Steel's worldwide profitability.
Using this metric, I estimate that Man of Steel fell about $115 million short of breaking even
theatrically. But because I wanted to give the movie a fair shake, I also used the much simpler
method of taking Man of Steel's international gross in dollars and just adjusting that for
inflation. Using that metric, Man of Steel falls short of theatrical profitability by $89.2 million.
However, both figures mean that inflation adjusted, this metric has Man of Steel losing
more money in the theatrical window between $89.2 and $115 million than Superman when you adjust
costs and grosses. So let's look at all of those profitability numbers together on one chart.
When looking at worldwide theatrical profitability without adjusting for inflation,
Man of Steel has the edge, losing about $7 million less in the theatrical window than Superman.
However, using either metric of adjusting for inflation globally, Superman has the edge. Though
both movies lost money theatrically, at least according to my calculations. It's just a degree
of how much. Even if you disagree with let's say the split of the box office that I have going back
to the studios, if you think they get more money than what I have on my chart, the overall result
is the same. The movies still perform the same way relative to each other. But theatrical ticket sales
aren't everything. Movies make money in a lot of different ways and because both Superman and Man
of Steel feature one of the most recognizable characters in the world, both movies were able
to attract multiple lucrative licensing deals from brands that wanted to be part of each movie's
promotional campaign. According to a June 2013 article in the Hollywood Reporter, Man of Steel
had 98 partners for its promotional campaign, bringing in $170 million. And according to
reports this summer, Superman attracted a similar number of promotional partners and one would think
a similar amount of revenue. And that's not even mentioning the reported $120 million worth of DVD
and Blu-ray sales that Man of Steel generated, nor the revenue generated by Superman's digital sales
so far. For every $20 rental or $30 purchase digitally, Warner Brothers gets a reported 80%
cut. Which means if just 1 million people have bought or rented Superman digitally, split 50-50
purchase and rental, $20 million has already been generated just from digital sales.
My point is this, given every metric that I use to calculate theatrical profitability,
both Superman and Man of Steel have made up that difference in licensing tie-ins and home viewing
already. Any debate about their box office performance is really about the degree to which
each movie made Warner Brothers money. If you want to debate about whether one of those movies
should have made more money based on audience expectations or based on how comic book movies
were performing in 2013 vs today, that's fair game, but that's all about perception and speculation
and largely point of view. But a large part of the tone and tenor I've seen with the conversation
around these two films is that, most of the time, Man of Steel is painted to be a box office triumph
and Superman is portrayed as an abject failure. And when you look at the numbers,
when you properly adjust for inflation, applying it to all aspects of production and not just
cherry picking which numbers to adjust and which ones not to adjust, my conclusion is that both of
these films performed in the world of theatrical profitability very similarly. Man of Steel was
a bit of a disappointment in the context of a thriving comic book movie boom in 2013 when
Iron Man 3 had already broken the billion dollar barrier and we were just one year removed from
Dark Knight Rises doing the same. Superman certainly didn't live up to many people's
expectations that it would propel DC back into the stratosphere, leveraging both a lull in the
MCU's performance and a new, brighter tone with James Gunn at the helm. Both movies performed
well enough with lots of room for improvement, but neither film was a failure. And I think the
numbers back me up on this one. But what do you think? Are you not a fan of all these numbers and
calculations? Are you much more of a feel-it-in-your-gut person? Let me know down in the
comments below. And as always, thank you so much for watching me here on the channel. If you're
not subscribed, be sure to hit that subscribe button. Hit the bell so you know when I upload
a new video. But most of all, thank you for watching this video. Be sure to come back for
the latest in movie news, box office reviews, and more. Until next time, stay safe and I'll see you
then.
