Paul Scholes DISAGREES with Gary Neville! Arsenal CAN Win the Premier League!

Football Fans
14 followers
7 Video Views·Sep 5, 2025
Comments are disabled for this video.
Big chat with a lot of Arsenal fans about this.
What did we mostly do in the window?
We bought creative players.
But halfway through the second half yesterday, I was like,
we're going to be creative guys.
Like, just a little bit of creativity would be great.
I don't think I can make that call three games in,
just because I love him.
For 270 million spend total,
let's say we get to the end of the season
and we don't win a trophy.
What, because you're more neutral than I be,
what do you think happens to Arteta?
Does he stay? Does he go?
I mean, does he have to win something this year?
Yeah, he's got to.
Well, I know, that's a fair point.
You know what I mean though.
I think we all agree that what he's done,
he has turned the club around.
Yeah, for sure.
I think he's done a great job to get them where they are now.
He's just got, is he capable of taking them
that next level over the line?
We said this about Gareth Southgate, didn't we?
He did brilliant with England, got into the finals,
but you didn't think he was capable
of them actually going and winning it.
I think Arteta's coming into that a little bit.
And I'm trying to think of a statement,
a statement win he's had in the Premier League.
I think going to Liverpool yesterday.
And I always think, in the first few weeks of the season,
I think there's always a statement win from a team
and you think they're going to win the league.
And I thought that with Liverpool at Manchester United
last year, and probably United's not probably, so.
Yeah, but it's a big game.
It's a big game, it's still a big game
for everyone to go there.
Even the way they won at Manchester United,
it wasn't convincing, was it?
And I just think, I just don't think they're quite right,
that they're quite ready.
And I don't think the manager,
you know, when you think about it,
third game of the season, it's a free hit, really, isn't it?
To go there and give it a right go and say,
look, we're ready, we can play,
we can get against this team as Liverpool have shown.
The defensive did not been great so far.
So it's a great chance to play.
You know, players bring a man, you think,
bang, go to Liverpool.
That's why I didn't mind the first half,
because do you remember the Anfield game last year,
when we were 2-0 down at half time
and looked like the worst team to ever have played
in the Premier League?
So that's what I thought the mentality was.
First half, you can't get it this time.
In second half, that's what I thought we were going to get.
Let's go, free-flying football,
let's bring on Eze at half time.
It's never going to happen with a team,
as Jamie said, when you saw that team, you thought...
Mourinho was not the best.
0-0, it has to be 0-0.
It was obvious that the plan before the game,
it was get to 70 minutes at 0-0,
and we've got a stronger bench than Liverpool.
Now, obviously, that's going to change in a few weeks.
Obviously, Eze's there, maybe Ige comes into Liverpool.
But Liverpool right now have won games from the bench.
But we know, as Liverpool supporters,
the bench isn't the strongest.
You're bringing Kiers, you've got a young 17-year-old kid.
So when I actually saw the bench and the team they picked,
that was the plan.
Get to 70 minutes, 0-0.
But why is the mentality to get to 70 minutes at 0-0
when you come up against the Liverpool team?
Yes, we know the champions, we know it's Anfield,
but you know Liverpool are not at the races
in the first three games of the season,
including the Community Shield as well.
They've got a lot of new players that they've spent money on,
but it's not quite right.
Even yesterday, there's still things at the O,
it's not quite, but Liverpool will get there at some stage.
I just think that was a massive opportunity for Arsenal.
And it's not about that game.
It's the bigger picture, the Man United game.
You didn't have Odegaard and Saka played in that game,
but it was still the same.
I don't think the team is set up,
or there's the mentality thing,
we're going to create chances.
It's, we've got the best defence in the league,
and you have by a long way.
We're going to keep a clean sheet,
and we're going to score us goal from a set piece,
and that will get you really far.
But it's whether it will get you across the line.
And that would be my big worry as an Arsenal fan.
What I will say to defend them a little bit is that,
you know, Llores is new, Zuberendi is new.
You know, Manuel Akay is new, Eze is new.
So I think we have to give them some time
to see if we are going to start heading more in that direction.
Like, if we gave Liverpool the same kind of respect to say,
you've got new players, how are they going to fit into the system?
I'd like to do the same for Arsenal.
I just think yesterday, the reason it feels,
well, it's the biggest game of the season so far,
it's the two title contenders.
But I think a lot of Arsenal fans have seen
what Liverpool's defence was like,
and just, even if it's for 10 minutes,
just see if, and we didn't push them at all,
that's the issue.
But I don't think we'll get to 10 games in the season,
and you won't see Eze with the creative balls,
and Oligar doing the same thing.
And listen, Llores had no service yesterday.
What I've learned about Llores is,
he is the player I wanted him to be.
He'll stand there, give him the ball,
we'll put it in there, well, he'll still try.
He had nothing, so he's not going to drop back
and start playing into the channels, et cetera.
Even the goal he scored against Leeds
was essentially, he took the ball and went,
screw this, I'm going to cut in and score.
So I would like to give it to more November-ish.
Listen, once again, I understand,
people watch this, they go,
of course he's saying that, he's an Arsenal fan.
But I think once all the, it's true,
once all the players settle in,
if we have this conversation,
something like early November,
and we're still doing that,
I'm up the rude words creek, right?
There's nothing that I can say.
But I think, let them settle in, give them time.
Yeah, it's a family show, right?
You know what I'm saying?
So that's my big thing.
See, what you're saying there, though,
it sums Arsenal up a little bit.
So you're saying in a few weeks,
we'll have Eze, we'll have Odegaard,
we won't be playing against better teams,
but we'll start playing brilliant football.
You've got to do that against the better teams.
I want to make sure, I do agree with you on that.
But I just think it's a,
listen, of course I'm going to sort of
try and find ways to be positive about it.
But I think just because there's sort of
four or five new players in there,
I do want to give them time to settle in.
The point I'm trying to make is,
I think because of the situation
Arsenal find themselves in with it,
Arteta being five years in and not winning a trophy,
I think there'll be so many eyes and focus on Arsenal.
And I think Arsenal fans,
when I was looking on social media,
feel a little bit hard done by after the game,
turned to the criticism, thinking,
okay, you know, we lost to an amazing goal.
There was nothing really in the game.
But I think it's going to be like this every week for Arsenal
because it just feels like it's now or never.
And it did feel like that opportunity was there for them
for the reasons that Gareth mentioned,
you know, with Liverpool being a new team,
looking a little bit vulnerable defensively.
What were your thoughts, Scolesy, watching it?
It was when I first saw the team.
When I saw Arsenal's team, I thought,
yeah, they might control possession a bit,
but it's not a team to go to Anfield and win.
Do you know what I mean?
They weren't going to go and put on a great performance,
blow them away.
Couldn't create chances.
They just signed Eze, brilliant footballer, creative.
Odegaard, the most creative player they've got.
Now they bring a centre-forward in for one of them players,
because everyone's saying Odegaard's not great last year.
He's not got a centre-forward to pass to.
They bring the centre-forward in and don't play Odegaard.
It was just a little bit of a negative mindset, I thought.
Now, I remember I had a go at Arsenal last year
about when they went to City and celebrated the draw.
I thought that was a different stage.
I actually think going to Anfield and getting a draw this time
would have been a good result.
You take that all day long.
I think the thing with City was,
City had about six or seven players.
It was towards the end of the season.
This is the start of the season.
There's always a little bit different.
Going there would have been a great point,
but if they'd have come away with a nil-nil,
you said, yeah, great, brilliant, great result.
But once they scored Liverpool, you had nothing else.
It's very hard to switch from a mentality
of going for a point,
then all of a sudden we've got a great chance
and get after them.
You just couldn't do it.
God, it's one of those...
Paul Scholes doesn't see Gary Neville,
William Gallas,
or Jamie Carragher's vision that Arsenal can
and must win the Premier League title this season,
declaring Mikel Oteta's side is still nowhere near ready
after losing to Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday.
The Gunners were shut down 1-0
by a late strike from Dominic Sobarslai,
sealing the points for the Reds
and thrusting them to their recently familiar home,
the top of the league.
Arsenal's performance appeared full of hesitancy
and short on creativity,
and Leandro Trossard was left on the bench
with the youngsters.
While Scholes praised Oteta's ability
to take the club from finishing eighth
in the table two years in a row,
to finishing top two consecutively for three years,
he remains unsure if the manager
can take the team to the next level.
Mikel Oteta has turned Arsenal around.
Has done a great job getting them to where they are now,
but the question is,
is he capable of taking them to the next level?
Scholes said.
We spoke about this with Gareth Southgate in England.
He did brilliantly, taking them to finals,
but we didn't think he was capable of winning tournaments.
Arsenal are not quite ready.
It was a great chance to play your new players
and make a statement.
The stats from Sunday saw Arsenal
with the possession advantage at 53%,
but registering just one shot on target all afternoon.
Odegard came off the bench,
he struggled to make any impact,
and the Gunners were out-fought across the midfield
by Alexis McAllister and Ryan Gravenberch.
For Scholes, it was proof that while Arsenal
have improved from the days of being bullied
at big away grounds,
they are still a few signings away from being a side
that can dethrone Liverpool and Manchester City
for the duration of the season.
The defeat left Arsenal three points off
the early league leaders after they dominated Leeds 5-0
and defeated Man Utd in the season opener.
Scholes not only disagreed with Neville
but doubled down,
insisting Arsenal's mindset was all wrong
from the opening whistle of the match.
When I first saw the Arsenal team against Liverpool,
I thought that it wasn't going to be a team
to go to Anfield and blow them away.
They couldn't create chances.
They just signed Eberechi Eze,
a brilliant footballer, creative.
Martin Odegard, the most creative player Thieve got.
They bring in a centre-forward in Victor Dziokas,
but then they don't play Odegard.
They had a bit of a negative mindset,
he added.
Scholes remembered criticising Arsenal last year
for celebrating a draw at Manchester City.
This year, he believed that a draw at Anfield
would have been a positive outcome.
The former Manchester United captain
still believes Arsenal can be serious title challengers,
pointing to the depth Ateta has built
and his ability to put together long unbeaten runs.
