Who are the Magi - Myth and History

Myths and magic
3 followers
Sep 3, 2025
The Magi are famed as ancient keepers of esoteric wisdom. From serving as Zoroastrian priests, experts on the occult sciences - especially astrology - and most famously following a mysterious star to the infant messiah Jesus. Indeed, no image of Christmas can be conjured without them presenting their three gifts. What do we know about the Magi? How did the mythology around them develop in early Christianity? How were these pagan priest-kings understood by early Christian theologians?
Among the beautiful pageantry of Christmas are images indelibly impressed upon the symbolic
landscape of the season. The silence of the manger scene, the holy family pressed in close,
the infant Jesus laying among the straw in a humble trough. Overhead, a huge starry light
shines heralding the birth of the Messiah, and around the divine infant and his family are
curiously dressed foreigners offering precious and exotic gifts. The manger scene, from the
masters of western art and music to the diorama style displays down the street from my house at
the local cathedral, is a staple of Christian religious mythology and faith. But central to
that symbolism is a bit of mystery. Well, a few mysteries if we're going to be honest.
But just who are those strange pilgrims? The Magi, learned wise men, sometimes even kings or
Zoroastrian priests from the far east, following a miraculous star to that manger in Bethlehem.
Let's dive into the myth and history of the Magi, the very root of our word magic,
and the star that led them to the Christian Messiah.
If you're interested in magic, hermetic philosophy, alchemy, the occult, or the history of the
academic study of esotericism, I'd hope you'd subscribe here to Esoterica and check out my
other content and topics in the academic study of western esotericism. Also, if you want to
my work of providing accessible, scholarly, and free content on topics like this here on
YouTube for free, I'd hope you consider supporting my work over at my Patreon with a one-time
donation with the super thanks option you can find just below the video or by picking up some
of the merch from our channel's store. But now let's turn to those mysterious,
wise kings of the east, the Magi, and their stellar guide in history, theology, and legend.
I'm Dr. Justin Sledge, and welcome to Esoterica,
where we explore the arcane in history, philosophy, and religion.
Disentangling myth from history is a fraught task. On the one hand, there's just the technical
difficulty of trying to figure out the Rancien wie ist eigentlich gewesen, the what really
happened for the historical Jesus, along with the historical Magi of that period,
and leading up to this story in the Gospel of Matthew. Often, that historicizing comes across
as an attack upon the mythology upon which faith relies. But, that's the task. This is an academic
channel. However, there is also a second, and to my mind, be very frank, equally important task.
It's to take faith very seriously. Not literally, but seriously. And in that way, I also want to
ask in this episode, what did the Magi and the star mean to the early followers of the Jesus
movement? And to answer that, I want to take a look at the very brief, shockingly brief passage
actually in the Gospel of Matthew where the Magi appear, the only place really they appear in the
Gospels, but also in a bit, to say a good bit more, about how the Magi and their star feature
in those very first early years, those first centuries of Christian mythology. So, let's
turn to the Gospel, the historical Magi, and the richly symbolic early Christian mythology
built up around them and the star they followed. The Gospels of both Matthew and Luke record
birth narratives about Jesus, but only the Matthew account details the Magi star narrative.
There we read in Chapter 2, following the translation here given by Vanden Eichel in
his wonderful magisterial book on the Magi that I'll recommend at the end of the episode,
After Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea in the days of Herod the king, behold, Magi from the east
came to Jerusalem, saying, Where is the one who has been born king of the Judeans? For we saw his
star at its rising, and we have come to honor him. King Herod panicked when he heard this,
and all of Jerusalem panicked with him. He gathered together his chief priests and the
of his people, and asked them, Where is the anointed one to be born? And they said to him,
In Bethlehem of Judea. For thus it has been written by the prophet, And you, O Bethlehem
and the land of Judah, are by no means least among the leaders of Judah. For from you will come a
who will guide my people, Israel. Then Herod summoned the Magi in secret, and he interrogated
them regarding the time of the stars appearing. And as he sent them to Bethlehem, he said,
Go, and investigate carefully concerning the child, and as soon as you find him,
report back to me, so that I may too go and honor him. They heard the king, and then they set out,
and behold, the star that they saw at its rising went on ahead of them, until it came,
and it stopped over where the child was. When they saw the star, they celebrated with a joy
that was exceedingly great. They entered the house, and saw the child with Mary his mother,
and falling down, they honored him. They opened their chests, and offered him gifts,
gold, incense, and myrrh. Having been warned in a dream not to return to Herod,
they returned to their own land by another route. And at this point, the Magi exit stage left,
and they do not reappear in the entire biography of Jesus, the Holy Family taking off to Egypt
directly following this narrative to avoid the wrath of the bloodthirsty Herod.
Of course, there is a ton to unpack here. The first is what actually isn't said in this
narrative. Note that the Magi are never referred to here as wise men or kings. That's a later
development of the myth that we'll circle back to here in just a little bit. Also, note that their
panic-inducing first stop is in Jerusalem in their visitation with King Herod. I would argue that this
first interlude in Jerusalem is actually the most important part of the narrative,
but it often just gets sort of lost in the more manger-centric depictions of the story.
The point of these twelve verses isn't so much, I think, to laud the infant Jesus,
but to pit the false king, Herod, the despised Edomian and Roman puppet,
with the true messianic king as detailed by Jewish prophecy and natural portent
in the form of that star recognized even by non-Jews in the story. And again, more on the
star in a moment. It really becomes a character in its own right as the mythology around it develops.
But I think the point here is for the author to establish the legitimate messianic king
over and against his earthly rival, King Herod. Lastly, the Magi visit a house, not a manger.
They go to a house and not a manger. The manger is more of a Gospel of Luke thing,
but these narratives get mushed together, I mean harmonized. Yeah, they get harmonized.
And while there are three gifts offered, the number of the Magi isn't. Traditionally,
we see that there are three of them, each with one gift, but as we'll see in this
developing mythology, the number of the Magi, and even the number of their gifts,
will alter and expand as the mythology develops.
So, are these birth accounts in the Gospels, Rankian vs. Aginlikivazin? Is that how it really
happened? Most scholars of the historical Jesus, along with myself, are pretty profoundly skeptical
of the historicality of these birth narratives. Both accounts are very carefully crafted,
though in very different ways, to situate the conception and birth of Jesus within the
context of messianic prophetic expectations of that time, especially being born of Davidic lineage,
and very specifically being born in Bethlehem. Neither of which I think were probably true of
the historical Jesus. The Gospel writers have kind of fudged this in several important ways,
including tracing Junius's lineage through Joseph, which doesn't really work if you
want a virgin birth out of all this, nor does tracing the lineage through his mother.
Further, most of the scholars of the historical Jesus, and again myself, suspect that he was
probably born where most of his life took place, up in the Galilee, and probably not in Judea.
Regardless, the nature and location of the birth of Jesus is probably just lost to history,
but what remains is the symbolic power of those narratives that early Christians
chose to craft and develop. And that the writer of Matthew chose, of all the narrative decisions
available to them, to choose the Magi and the Star, is important, and absolutely worthy of
scholarly analysis, and worthy, frankly, of recognition for its incredible symbolic beauty
as mythology, regardless of any historical reality.
So, let's start with the Star before turning to the Magi and both history and myth. To grasp the
importance of that Star, we have to strip away our conception of the night sky and try to adopt one
of the time in which this Gospel is being written. At that time, there were two kinds of stars. There
were fixed stars and wandering stars. They were no planets or extraterrestrial worlds as we know
them these days. For most learned people of the time, the position of these stars either
communicated the divine will through sign, simeon, or they directly determined the future through
efficient causation trickling down through the cosmos. In both cases, the stars were the highest
visible objects before the realm of the gods, if they just weren't, well, gods themselves,
and their paths and locations through the sky were anything other than meaningless.
And, admittedly, while Judaism has had a very complex, fraught relationship with astrology,
it's clear that many Jews did accept the importance of astrology at that time and prior.
Little bit later, Beit Alpha Synagogue actually displays an amazing zodiac mosaic on its floor,
though two specific stars are probably worth mentioning in this context of the Matthew
Gospel. The first is the messianic nature of the star mentioned at Numbers 24 17 where it read,
What I see for them is not yet, what I behold will not be soon. A star rises from Jacob,
a scepter comes forth from Israel, it smashes the brow of Moab, the foundation of the children
of Set. This verse was and would become loaded down to this very day with messianic prophetic
value. So much so that even a hundred years after the execution of Jesus, the messianic claimant,
Shimon of Koziba would become known to history as Shimon Bar Kokhba, Shimon, son of the star,
in reference to that very verse, though most of the rabbis at the time derided him as Shimon Bar
Koziba, son of Eli, punning on where he was from, Koziba with Kokhba star and Koziba liar,
warning Rabbi Akiva that grass would grow in his cheeks and the son of David will not have come.
Of course, grass did not grow in the cheeks of Akiva because the Romans flayed him alive
and then burned him as his stellar messiah perished at the Battle of Betar near Bethlehem
and prompted a truly apocalyptic Roman genocide in the region. Messiah, the game where everyone
loses. Regardless, the star prophecy is, I think, pretty clearly a motivation here.
But another star is also probably very much alive in the imagination of the writer and
readers of this text. In the months following the assassination of Julius Caesar in 44 BCE,
a comet appeared in the skies over Rome, a hairy star as Suetonius has it, which was so bright it
could even be seen in the late afternoon. It was taken by many people, common people and elites,
as a sign that Caesar had been deified, a concept readily embraced by his nephew
Octavian. After all, divine uncle, august nephew. The symbol of the Julian star became central to
the state cult around Caesar, appearing on temples and even cornige all the way into the
second century of the Common Era. Thus, for a learned, literate person living in the Roman
Empire, penning a gospel, which is, by the way, a kind of literature associated with imperial
declarations at the time, the divine Julian star, the general astrological worldview of the time,
and the indigenous Jewish messianic star prophecy, given all this, it's not at all surprising to find
a stellar herald of the messiah in the text. Of course, it's also possible that the text does
an actual astrological event sometime around the birth of Jesus, and a lot of ink has been
spilled trying to sort that out, from Halley's Comet appearing in 12 BCE, the conjunctions of
Jupiter, Saturn, and Mars in 7 and 6 BCE, a hypernova over in the Andromeda Galaxy in 5 BCE,
a couple supernovae in 4 and 2 BCE, and much else besides. Though, honestly,
I think that if the author wanted to be specific about the nature of the star,
and astrological science at that time was well developed enough that they could have if they
wanted to, well, they didn't. And the fact that they didn't tells me that at least in part,
the function of the star in this story is primarily, maybe even exclusively, symbolic.
And as we'll see very shortly, the star itself will go on to become a character in the birth
narrative itself, it will outshine all other stars in the sky, including the sun, it actually
becomes identified with an angel, and eventually, it becomes identified with Jesus. So, Jesus Christ,
literal superstar. While the star that they followed is complex and probably symbolically
over-determined, who followed it is equally complex. Who were these Magi? Already by the
first century, the Magi were a complicated and polarizing group in the ancient world.
Exotic Easterners associated with, at times, the hated Persians, but universally recognized as
experts in magic, arcane religious rituals, but more than anything with the science of the time
of astrology. But, to get their symbolic function as it appears in this myth, let's turn to what we
know about the actual historical Magi. The term Magus, from the old Persian Magu Magush, though
the etymology is opaque here, first appears on the Besuton inscription of Darius I around 522 BCE,
which actually names a Median Magus named Gamata, the son of Cyrus II, the former king who
the Greek historian Herodotus will know as Smerdis. The term is attested in a wide variety
of ancient Near East languages, Old Persian, Elamite, Akkadian, Aramaic, Parthian, Sassanian,
and it's denoted always in the form of Magus or Magush, denoting it as a technical term,
being transliterated from language to language rather than being translated from Magus to some
other term in those languages. It appears that they were a Median
priestly group, the exact nature of which is heavily debated now in the literature.
Some scholars see them as a priest class, a specific Median tribe, as Herodotus notes, or
something perhaps akin to the Israelite Levites, who are uniquely tasked with ceremonial life,
or specifically trained ritual experts. However, in this earliest period, they are not yet
much less uniquely associated with the emergent Zoroastrian religion.
From surviving documents of this period, it appears that the Magi were typically associated
with receiving ritual foodstuffs, specifically barley and wine, and by the time of Darius I,
they're also functioning basically as the official priests of the Achaemenid kings.
Here, their cultic functions include a wide range of sacrifices of livestock, including horses,
libation offerings to rivers and mountains, memorizing and reciting scriptures,
some of their names seem to indicate that they were specifically memorized, like Hafiz
along with a range of state bureaucratic duties. Their geographic distribution also became
incredibly wide, and they are attested at a wide range of cultic functions, from Persepolis over
in what is now Iran, all the way over to the Elephantine island in Upper Egypt.
They do not seem to serve a specific god, however, and the Magi appear in ritual contexts
associated with the Persian Ohura Mazda, the Elamite Humban, and overseeing flower stores
at the Temple at Inanna at Uruk, in Babylon. This religious polyvalence has led some scholars
to see them as kinds of religious mercenaries, or a type of religious apparatchiks of the Persian
state, kind of having their finger in the pie of, well, lots of religions. I know that's a strange
image. Sorry. The Magi are also well attested in Greek literature as early as the Persi of Aeschylus
and even about 500 BCE in a fragment of the wonderfully cantankerous Philosopher Heraclitus.
The most sustained discussion of the Magi in history, frankly, is from Herodotus,
the Greek historian, where we learn that they were the direct counselors of kings of Persia,
they interpreted dreams, and they performed libations and sacrifices, including the horse
sacrifice, which again, may be a sort of Indo-Persian kind of religious ritual like the
Ashva made found in the Rig Veda, all of which, again, these functions agree with other ancient
Neri sources. Other sources, like Marcellinus, confirms the role of the practice of what appears
to be sky burial, that is, the dead being picked clean by vultures upon death. Xenophon recounts
that the Magi were the tutors of the Persian kings and they performed a range of ceremonies,
including the coronation of new kings. Curtius Rufus has the Magi carrying sacred flames before
battle and chanting hymns alongside the Persian warriors. Again, more monthly horse sacrificing
like the Ashva made and guarding the tombs of dead Persian kings. Aristotle ascribes to them
a dualistic religion, with Zeus or Oromazdes ruling in goodness and Hades or Armanus in the
role of the evil god, and images of them officiating are attested in grand monumental
inscriptions, little golden figurines, and seal stamps found all over the Persian empire,
prior to the Persian empire, and well into the Sasanian period and beyond.
Certainly, by the Parthian and Sasanian period, they are known for keeping alight sacred flames
and had consolidated a religious ceremonial monopoly in the region. And, as we've seen,
very little can be known about the exact religious beliefs of the western Magi
in the earliest period. It appears that they do, however, at some point, come as a group
to become disciples of the newly adopted prophet Zoroaster. Now, this is a very thorny issue in
Zoroastrian studies and scholarship. Some scholars regard the Magi as having
always been Zoroastrians. Others even make them out to be anti-Zoroastrians at first.
Acolytes of the indigenous but heavily syncretized Median Mazda worship, some of them see them as
kind of religious mercenaries and functionaries of the state religion, of a highly syncretized
version of Zoroastrianism and Persian religious interests more generally. As we've seen, by
Xerxes I, they're functioning in an official capacity in the state, especially tending to
sacred fires, offering libations, including the juice of the Homa plant, livestock and probably
horse sacrificing, along with a range of ceremonial and bureaucratic functions in the empire. But when
and to what degree they become associated with the emergent religious or religious reforms of
Zoroaster isn't exactly clear. However, by 520 BCE, Darius I had definitely begun to introduce
a kind of Zoroastrian prioritism, declaring that Ahura Mazda was the highest of the gods,
but he didn't dismiss other gods such as the Elamite Humban, the sun god Mithra, which was
very popular, or again the fertility goddess Anahita, again very popular, all of whose devotion
continued well through the Persian empire, not to mention lots of other versions of Christianity and
What seems to have happened is that the Magi class of priests would eventually
accept a syncretized Zoroastrian doctrine sometime in the first half of the 4th century BCE
and continue to work in the ecumenical policy within the state's Persian policy of religious
toleration. Now that wouldn't always work, but as we'll see, in general the Persians were quite
tolerant and tolerant in general. Now this is not the place to discuss the Zoroastrian
religion in general. If you want a general introduction to Zoroastrianism, check out
Philip's channel Let's Talk Religion, he has a great video on the topic and I think he's going
to remake it pretty soon. But I do want to mention that we do know a little bit about a few actual
Magi from roughly this time period, though mostly from periods after the period of the composition
of the Gospel of Matthew. The best documented Magi we know of was Cartyr, who served as chief
priest during the reign of four Sasanian kings during the 4th century of the Common Era. Again,
a bit beyond our time frame, but I think he's worth mentioning because we do know something
about an actual Magi, and he's known from at least four inscriptions and a handful of narratives.
He was perhaps a eunuch, he's always depicted as beardless, and Cartyr would emerge under the
tolerant rule of Shapur I and become Mobed or High Priest during the reign of Hormizd I, who
died shortly thereafter. However, with the rise of Barum I, the Zoroastrians led by Cartyr seem
to have asserted Zoroastrian hegemony and curtailed the more tolerant position of Shapur I, which was
centuries old. This shift would eventually lead to the imprisoning of the prophet Mani of the
duals religion Manichaeanism and his eventual execution, perhaps at the bequest of Cartyr
himself. He definitely appears as the bad guy in the surviving Manichaean accounts of the events.
Further, it seems that at this moment he executed a kind of, I don't know,
inquisition in the area controlled by the Persians, which sought to suppress the various
religions active in that region. Cartyr brags about suppressing Buddhism, Christianity, Judaism,
and various other kinds of dualist religions. Again, in a royal inscription he brags about this,
though frankly it's not even clear that it was ever carried out. He might be lying.
The Babylonian Talmud was being composed at exactly this time, and it really never mentions
state Sassanian religious repression. However, the policy of religious toleration would be
reinstituted by Narsa, and Cartyr, aside from the inscriptions and his frank infamy in Manichaean
religious texts, would all fade into relative historical oblivion after this point. While it's
not exactly the most flattering account of Amagus, we don't see Cartyr bragging about
all the cool esoteric astrological knowledge he has. It's a bit narcissistic and inquisitorial.
It's still one of the best preserved accounts we have of a Magi from classical antiquity,
and as much as the term applies to Sassanian Persia. Of course, Zoroastrianism would continue
to produce Magi's, I mean really ingenious scholars in the history of Zoroastrianism,
including the composers of incredible religious texts like the Dinkard there around the 10th or
9th century of the Common Era. However, by the turn of the Common Era, getting back to our time
near the composition of the Gospel of Matthew, the image of the Magi were basically settled
into the minds of those living in the Eastern Mediterranean as an elite group of exotic
eastern wise men heavily associated with magic, dualism, and especially astrology.
Again, it was also during this period that the Magi probably now became fused with state
Zoroastrianism, and again became strongly associated with the occult sciences, especially
astrology, which had been both indigenously developed in Persia, but also imported in a
frankly hated Persians, were typically denoted as what the Magi do in the word
Mageia. This anti-Persian bigotry led to the dysphemism such that
malevolent supernatural causation, for lack of a better phrase, entered their language as it did
ours, as the term Mageia, magic. Yet, the Greeks had to admit the reality of the Persian genius
held secret by the Magi, and this conception of the Eastern Magi with esoteric knowledge of the
stars and the occult was absolutely current during the time of the composition of the Gospel of
Matthew, and it survives down to us in terms like magic and magus as someone who's a wielder of
supernatural power. Thus, again, the question to me is how are the Magi functioning in this story?
The Gospel of Matthew, for all of its alleged Jewishness, is actually very much concerned with
its contention with the wider Jewish community of the time of its composition, and I suspect
the Magi are functioning very much in that context. Specifically, I think it's meant to be
very much ironic that non-Jewish Magi are literally able to read the signs in the sky of
some kingly portent which the Jews, especially Herod, the King of the Jews, is just thrown into
a panic about his usurpation. Further, that the star eventually takes the Magi to the true King
of the Jews is also functioning as a literary bookend to the execution of Jesus, whose very
implement of execution would actually bear the sign mockingly proclaiming him King of the Jews.
Thus, the Magi inaugurate at the very beginning of Jesus' life a non-Jewish recognition of his
messianic, even divine, nature as a legitimate King of the Jews, but also as a universal messianic
king over Gentiles as well, vouchsafed by the universally recognized wisdom of the Magi.
Of course, those twelve verses in the Gospel of Matthew would be by no means the last appearance
of the Magi in Christian mythology, or even in the New Testament, they appear as bad Magi later
in the Book of Acts. In fact, if you've ever seen a nativity scene, you've probably seen elements
of the Magi narrative that developed in the centuries after the composition of the Gospel
of Matthew. For instance, their representation as wise men or kings, that's nowhere to be found in
Specifically, there are two tracks here by which the Magi narrative
is expanded in early Christian history and mythology.
The first vector has their role in the nature of the star they followed greatly expanded
in infancy gospels and lives of Mary biographies in what is now called the apocryphal literature
of that time. And the second vector is the theological meaning of the Magi and their star
in the patristic literature, what it means theologically. Let's take a brief tour of each.
Apocryphal literature are texts composed in the early centuries of Christianity that basically
act as Jesus fan fiction. You like the stories of the Gospels, but you want more.
There are legends and stories about the figures of the early Jesus movement,
often told in the form of Greco-Roman novels, very much like the form of Luke Axe. Of course,
with the early life of Jesus being very scantily recorded, where in the world did he go? Maybe
India. In what became the four canonical Gospels, tales of Jesus' early life, including his birth,
are bound. People love these stories. In fact, one of these tales, Jesus turning clay chunks into
birds and throwing them into the air, appears to be taken from the apocryphal infancy gospel of
Thomas or some similar source. That story of Jesus turning the clay into birds? That ends up in
nothing less than the Quran. So, that's a thing. Now, are these stories historically reliable?
No, probably not. But frankly, neither are the Gospel accounts of Jesus' birth or his trial,
for that matter. But they do tell us about the Magi and the star, what the Magi and the star
meant to early Christians. And that information is, to me and scholars, incredibly important in
itself. For instance, in the Proto-Evangelium of James, this is from the latter half of the
second century, it further emphasizes the kingship of Jesus, along with the Magi directly making
their way to Bethlehem. They don't stop in Jerusalem in this one. I think that's frankly
how it plays out in most people's mind when they actually think of the birth story. They don't
really talk about the part where it stops off and they chat with Herod for a minute.
And it focuses on how the star outshines every other star in the sky. Something that doesn't
happen in the Gospel of Matthew, thus showing the ascendancy of Jesus above all other earthly kings.
Again, this is a neat new detail developed out of Matthew, but not really there.
Further, the Magi are led not to a house in this document, but to a cave to present their gifts to
the infant king. The cave here is probably serving as a kind of literary bookend as the title of
King of the Jews that I mentioned a moment ago. Jesus being born and eventually buried in a kind
of cave or rock-cut tomb. In another document, Pseudo-Matthew, a Latin Gospel-like text from the
6th or 7th century of the Common Era, the Magi are again led to a cave, but now two years after
Jesus' birth. It took them a couple years to get there. This Pseudo-Matthew text has them traveling
from the east, but remember, it never tells you how long it took them to get there. It just says
they traveled from the east. Pseudo-Matthew has the star appearing upon Jesus' birth, and it takes
them two years to get to Jesus. He's already a toddler by the time they get there, and they seek
out the king born to us, as opposed to the king born only to the Judeans, thus greatly expanding
Jesus' kingship to both Jews and Gentiles alike. Along with the traditional three gifts, they also
bring Jesus gold coins, though the text here is probably pretty corrupt, and this is probably
symbolic acting as a kind of royal tribute to the toddler king, Jesus. The 6th century Armenian
Infancy Gospel, based on an early Syriac text, gives us actually the exact date when the Magi
arrive. January the 8th. Also, we learn that the Magi are also kings, along with the names of the
kingdoms that they're kings of. Melkon is the king of Persia, Gaspar is the king of India, and Balthazar
is the king of Arabia. So, you can break out with your we three kings on your caroling rounds next
time, thanks to the Armenian Infancy Gospel. However, they go on a nine-month journey, the star
appearing at Jesus' conception, and then an angel telling them to get going, and boy do they go
with their 12,000 troop army. I imagine the music in the pilgrimage montage of the Magi here is
definitely a white-striped seven-nation army. This is why when they arrive to Herod, all of
Jerusalem is said to have been thrown into a panic. They think they're about to be under a
siege. The Armenian Infancy Gospel is by far the most detailed of these Magi narratives,
with in-depth conversations with Herod, secret esoteric documents passed down from Adam to Seth
and then given to Jesus on the second day of their visitation. They stay there three days in this one.
These documents somehow survive the flood, and they're given over to the infant Jesus,
who can somehow read them. Upon reaching Jesus, they and their armies dance in joy.
Jesus is given a much fuller array of treasures, and they're all meant to enthrone the infant as
a messianic king. As they depart from the Holy Family, they're given over to ecstatic visions
of the life and messianic future of Jesus, though this gospel does end with a
somewhat depressing note. We're actually told that the three kingly Magi were not
children of the kingdom, and that they were going to denounce the Savior, despite all this other
stuff. Perhaps teaching that no amount of good deeds, mystical visions, or kingly wisdom can
In the positively surreal revelation of the Magi, which was preserved in a single Syriac copy of the
8th century over there in the Vatican Library, which there are all kinds of silly conspiracy
theories about, that tells the experience of the Magi's encounter from their own perspective.
Again, we have the Magi as kings, but now there are twelve of them, probably mirroring the tribes
of Israel, the Disciples, or the Zodiac, and they emerge from the most easternmost part of the
world, a land called Shir, a land that is dominated by ritual purifications, by bathing, and other
strange and interesting wonderful rituals. In their land is also a cave of treasures of hidden
mysteries, which will be eventually mirrored by the same cave they encounter the baby Jesus in.
Though, in this tale, the star they follow is the outstanding character, because the star is none
less than Jesus himself. In this story, while the Magi are ritually purifying themselves through
immersion, the star appears to them, and only them, shining brighter than the sun. They follow
the star into the cave of treasures in their own land, where it becomes the form of a person and
speaks to them about his, well, Jesus' literal star. Gazing upon the star, they're given ecstatic
visions of the life of Jesus and his messianic redemptions of the world, and we're even told
that this star hovered above the Tree of Life in the Garden of Eden. So, it's really the beginning
to the end of everything. The star leads and literally clears the path for them on their
journey west. It flattens mountains. It drives away snakes. It allows them to pass over rivers
effortlessly. It also multiplies food for them along the way, all invoking images of mosaic and
Jesus-like miracles as they make their way west, over to the cave at Bethlehem. They meet Herod,
now demoted as a mere governor of the region. Take that, Herod. And they request to see the,
Messiah, life-giver, who gives himself to death for the sake of the whole world.
Herod proves useless, and they follow the star again, which now descends down and is flanked
by two angels, into the cave where Jesus is. They remove their crowns, place them below the feet of
Jesus, who speaks to them, and tells them of the impending darkness on the day of his
crucifixion as a sign to come. And he commissions them to go back to their land, to the land of
Shear, to spread the gospel among their people, with the star again appearing, again leading them
back to their distant homelands. Again, these are positively lovely tales. Well, with the
exception of that kind of sad one. But they all serve to me the exact same purpose, in some sense.
To exalt the Magi so as to exalt the kingly messianic status of Jesus. That, and just to
fill out the otherwise terse narrative of the Gospel of Matthew. And, as I pointed out a minute
ago, if you've heard carols or seen nativity scenes or nativity dioramas, you've probably
heard elements of these tales already. They've made their way into Christian Christmas legends,
regardless of their historical or doctrinal validity. So, take that historical and doctrinal
validity. I'll leave a link in the description to a great collection of Christian Apocrypha
if you want to check out some of these or many of the other wonderful forms of Jesus fan fiction
from that time. So, have fun with all that stuff. I love that apocryphal stuff.
Of course, the account of the Magi and their star wasn't going to be just grist for the mill
of ancient Jesus fan fiction writers. It was also going to have a much more boring
task to play. To underwrite patristic theology. I kid. I really actually love studying the early
church fathers. I really do. I'm being honest. But, that's also because I'm Jewish and it's
just like reading a bunch of manuals for role playing games that I don't ever, ever want to
play. But, as early as Ignatius of Antioch, theological speculation on the nature of the
Virgin Mary and the birth of Jesus were already in currency. In a bit of an oblique reference to
the birth of Jesus, Ignatius kind of breaks into a hymn, which is I think really worth quoting
in full. It's not terribly long and it's frankly incredibly beautiful and a bit metal. It says,
A star shone forth in heaven above all the other stars, the light of which was inexpressible,
while its novelty struck men with astonishment. And all the rest of the stars with the sun and
the moon formed a chorus to this star, and its light was exceedingly great above them all.
And there was agitation felt to whence this new spectacle came, so unlike everything else in the
kingdom abolished, God himself being manifested in human form for the renewal of eternal life.
And now that took a beginning, which had been prepared by God. Henceforth, all things were in
a state of tumult because he mediated the abolition of death. Mediated the abolition of
death. It's pretty impressive. As we'll continue to see, this is a core theological concern about
the star inaugurating a kind of apocalyptic period marking the beginning of the end of this fallen,
sinful world and the arrival of a new one. Further, it's also worth mentioning that one of
the things that's destroyed in the tumult here of Ignatian of Antioch's hymn is precisely magia.
Magic. Somewhat ironic considering the central role of the Magi for recognizing this star in
the first place. A point that could not have been on accident for the learned Ignatius.
Finally, the star is revealed to be something just more than any normal stellar object.
It's wholly supernatural, even kind of quasi-divine in nature. This is going to matter immensely
because if the star heralded, or worse, dictated the coming of the Messiah,
then astrological influence would prove decisive in God's divine plan. Something absolutely anathema
to early Christian theologians, but grist for the mill of early pagans who deeply dislike Christianity
like Celsus. And it's precisely to those two later points, the diminution of the Magi and
the non-astral and non-astrological nature of the star that subsequent theologians like
Justin Martyr take up and write about at length. For Justin, Martyr, not me, I'm still here,
for a while, the star is actually part and parcel of a messianic prophecy,
specifically initiating a kind of ironic reversal in Israelite history altogether.
Carefully knitting together verses from the prophets, Justin understands the Magi and their
star as eastern Assyrian kings returning to visit the king of Israel with gifts, thus reversing the
historical destruction of the ten tribes that constituted Israel there in the north, the so
called Ten Lost Tribes in 722 BCE. Thus Israel is restored and the messianic king is crowned by the
easterners that destroyed the ten northern tribes with the treasures of the Magi.
Further, Justin has little respect for the Magi. They're just part of a prophetic mechanism,
and according to Justin, they were even under demonic control until the visitation by the
redeemed them. For Justin Martyr, the wisdom of the Magi, or the prophecies of the Jews for that
matter, are just worthless without the knowledge that is redeemed through the salvific power of
Christ. Otherwise, their wisdom is just folly. Thus, the wise men from the east,
they're not wise at all. That is, until their conversion experience honoring the infant Jesus.
Further, Justin and the hymns of Ephraim the Syrian both reject the star of the Magi as truly
a star at all, and thus it is not the object of astrological speculation, much less astrological
influence on the birth and life of Jesus. Rather, the star is an announcer and guardian of the
birth of Jesus, much more akin to an angel, especially in Ephraim, than a stellar object.
Again, with the backwards dark and blind Magi finding redemption in their encounter with Jesus
by symbolically crowning and enthroning the messianic infant, again reversing the traditional
harms the nations had done to Israel. Interesting, the star here acts as a guardian of the infant
Jesus from the murderous King Herod, only to preserve him from the murderous Pilate. Though,
again, rather than as an infant needing astral angelic protection, the adult Jesus will
willingly go to his fate for the redemption of all sinful people. John Chrysotem, on the other hand,
the most important theologian for the east, whose liturgy is still used in the eastern church,
also argues that the star of the Magi isn't a typical star if it's a star at all.
Its movements are erratic, as if it's driven by some divine intelligence. And he even goes as
far as to insist that, at the time, it could even outshine the sun, one of those elements we saw
already in some of the apocryphal birth stories. Further, Chrysotem follows the more apocryphal
tradition as we've seen that the star appealed well before the birth of Jesus, so that the
with Jesus would teach them that they're not visiting any kind of normal, regular earthly
king. This need for the education of the Magi is another slight on the idea that the Magi are wise
men. They're not for these church fathers. Rather, Chrysotem calls them barbarian Persians in need of
salvation that, frankly, only Jesus can offer. Interestingly enough, he has the barbarians
teaching the Jews that a king had been born as witnessed by this star, but it's the blind and
stupid Jews who teach the Persians that the king is indeed the king of the whole world,
the messianic king of kings. Thus again, all of this is really to showcase the theological
commitment to supersessionism of the theologians of this period, and now kind of, that Christianity
had come to educate so-called pagan wisdom, and to complete and overcome Jewish legalism and
blindness to their own prophecy. The Jewish priests and scribes and the Magi, the Persian Magi of the
Gospel of Matthew, are being played against one another in some sense, though with the Magi giving
over their treasures as a sign of them relinquishing their paganism for service with Christ,
while the Jewish Herod and his priests and scribes go on a bloodthirsty rampage.
The seeds of antisemitism? That's cheery.
The 7th century Maximus Confessor also makes it abundantly clear that the star
was not a star at all. Again, the anti-astrology polemic here is pretty strong,
but it was an angel. He's very clear, Maximus is very clear that it was an angel,
sent as a power from above that completely abolished the deception of astrology
and annihilated the darkness of such ignorance.
Again, Maximus has the Magi as being virtually demonically possessed by demons of the air,
and they're only redeemed by their visitation with the infant Christ,
again with the transfer of their gifts, simultaneously ridding themselves of their
pagan ways and depossessing themselves, but also crowning and enthroning the infant as the
world king. This repeated theme of the conversion of the pagan Magi, but the recalcitrant Jewish
rampage of Herod, of course, would set the stage for the conversion of the Gentiles.
It's a huge idea inaugurated by Paul that the Magi, in some sense, are the first
converted Gentiles, but also the trope of the stubborn Jews unwilling to see,
much less accept, Jesus as the Messiah. A trope that's absolutely harmed no one
at all in history, ever. That has never hurt any.
Alright, I didn't really expect this to become a nearly hour long deep dive onto the Magi, but
here we are. As you can see, these twelve verses in the Gospel of Matthew have been the grist for
the mill of fan fiction, theological speculation, and esoteric interpretations of Christianity.
Dioramas, art, and Christmas carols. Hell, some of you have probably even dressed up as Magi for
Christian pageants and stuff. But, as we've seen, the Magi and their star had only a very
tenuous, even frankly stereotyped connection to the actual Magi of ancient Medea and Persia,
and their connection to state Zoroastrianism. In fact, they were probably just stock characters
for the Gospel of Matthew, kind of like Gandalf-like wizards with like beards and pointy
hats are for everything. However, writers of the Christian Apocrypha, along with early Christian
theologians, had an absolutely positive field day with these mysterious visitors from the east,
and their equally mysterious star, all in all producing a wonderful collection of lore,
hymns, tall tales, anti-astrology polemics, and theological speculations on the Magi and the star
that led them on their way. Vanden Eichel's recent book on the Magi was indispensable for putting
this episode together, and it is well worth you picking up if you're interested in these
characters and their star. It's honestly the best kind of writing. It's accessible, it's scholarly,
and it's poignant. Just a great book. If you ever want a real deep dive on topics in Zoroastrianism
like the Magi or the Dinkard or any other topics, the best resource, in my opinion,
is the massive two-volume collection of articles on those topics as part of the Encyclopedia
Ironica, edited by Mahnaz Mozami. It can be a little tough to find, but if you do find it,
it's only like 70 bucks for two massive volumes, and it is the single best academic resource I've
found on topics in Zoroastrian studies. I'll come back to Zoroastrianism at some point in the
future, but it's a great collection. It can, however, be a bit technical and specialized, but
again, an amazing resource, though the entire Encyclopedia Ironica and its articles are
fantastic and you can find it all online for free. I'll put a link in the description.
But, really, I want everyone to have a wonderful Christmas if you observe,
I hope that no one gets any coal, and may we all find our shining star to guide us
on the paths of wisdom, joy, and peace to all. Until next time, I'm Dr. Justin Sledge,
and thank you for watching Esoterica, where we explore the arcane in history, philosophy,
and religion.
