Engel v. Vitale: Banning Prayer in School | 5-Minute Videos | PragerU

PragerU
800 followers
430 Video Views·Sep 1, 2025
Does a simple classroom prayer violate the Constitution? That was the question before the Supreme Court in the 1962 case Engel v. Vitale. Joel Alicea, Associate Professor of Law at Catholic University, explains why this ruling dramatically reshaped the role of religion in public life—and why its impact is still felt today.
📲 Watch our content ad-free on our app: https://prageru.onelink.me/3bas/vgyxvm79
Donate to PragerU: https://l.prageru.com/4jiAT85
Follow PragerU:
Instagram ➡️ (https://www.instagram.com/prageru/)
X ➡️ (https://twitter.com/prageru)
Facebook ➡️ (https://www.facebook.com/prageru/)
TikTok ➡️ (https://www.tiktok.com/@prageru)
Almighty God, we acknowledge our
dependence upon thee, and we beg thy
blessings upon us, our parents, our
teachers, and our country. In 1951, the
board of regents of New York recommended
that New York public schools open each
day with this prayer. Its intention was
to promote gratitude, good behavior, and
a recognition of God's role in American
life. The parents of 10 students in Long
Island strongly objected, claiming that
the prayer violated their constitutional
rights and the rights of their children.
Were they correct? Did the Long Island
school district violate the
constitution?
Specifically, did it violate the
establishment clause of the first
amendment which reads, "Congress shall
make no law respecting an establishment
of religion."
That was the question before the Supreme
Court in the 1962 case Angel. Vitali
Steven Angel was the lead plaintiff for
the parents who objected to the prayer.
William Vitali Jr. was the president of
the school district. The two parties
argued over three questions. One, was
the prayer voluntary? The school
district said it was. No one was forced
to say the prayer. A student could
remain silent or be excused from class.
The parents argued the prayer was in
effect compulsory. Children can't be
expected to resist peer pressure or the
implicit demand of the teacher to say
the prayer. Two, was it appropriate for
a teacher to recite a government
composed prayer? The school district
noted that prayer was common place in
many government settings. The Supreme
Court itself opens its sessions with the
prayer God saved the United States and
this honorable court. The parents
countered that school prayer violated
the establishment clause because its
purpose and effect was to promote belief
in the existence of God.
The answers to questions one and two
both hinged on the answer to question
three. What was the purpose of the
establishment clause? The school
district asserted that the clause was
not meant to prohibit prayer in public
life. It was meant to prohibit the
creation of an official national
religion of the kind that had existed in
England at the time of the
constitution's writing.
The parents maintained that the clause
goes further and prohibits the
government from composing and
encouraging a prayer to be said in a
public setting like a classroom.
This is the argument most people are
familiar with, that there must be a wall
of separation between church and state.
What many people don't realize is that
this phrase is nowhere to be found in
the Constitution. It's a phrase taken
from a letter Thomas Jefferson wrote in
1802 to the Danbury, Connecticut Baptist
Association.
Nevertheless, the court found the
separation of church and state argument
persuasive and issued a broadly worded
decision. By a vote of 6 to1, the court
held that it was unconstitutional for
the government to compose a prayer and
have it recited at a public function.
Importantly, the court said that the
prayer was unconstitutional even if it
was voluntary. And the court didn't
limit its rationale to schools. It went
much further, suggesting that government
composed prayers were inappropriate in
all public settings. Justice Hugo Black,
a strong liberal voice on the court at
the time, wrote the majority opinion.
The First Amendment was added to the
Constitution to stand as a guarantee
that neither the power nor the prestige
of the federal government would be used
to control, support, or influence the
kinds of prayer the American people can
say.
The court took pains to clarify that its
decision was not intended to display
hostility to religion. Quite the
opposite. The court argued that its
decision was intended to protect
religion from government interference.
Justice Potter Stewart was the lone
denter. I cannot see how an official
religion, he wrote, is established by
letting those who want to say a prayer
say it. On the contrary, I think that to
deny the wish of these school children
to join in reciting this prayer is to
deny them the opportunity of sharing in
the spiritual heritage of our nation.
Most Americans agreed with Justice
Stewart. Newspaper editorials across the
country denounced the ruling. The Los
Angeles Times's response was typical. It
mocked the decision as perverse, a
solution in search of a problem.
But as the nation moved deeper into the
tumultuous 60s, the Kennedy
assassination, the civil rights
movement, the Vietnam War, Angle faded
into the background,
or did it? Can we trace the country's
moral decline, assuming you think there
has been a moral decline to the fact
that our public life has become
disconnected from religion? Many say
yes. It's not a coincidence that so many
social ills like drug use, alienation,
and depression proliferated in the
subsequent decades. Many say no. In a
nation that was becoming ever more
diverse, the court preserved an
essential liberty, the freedom to
practice any religion or no religion.
Whatever you think of the decision,
perhaps we can all agree on this. Angel
profoundly altered the role religion
plays in public life, making it among
the most consequential Supreme Court
decisions in American history. I'm Joel
Alisa, associate professor of law at
Catholic University for Prager
University.
Thank you for watching this video. To
keep PragerU videos free, please
consider making a taxdeductible
donation.
