How Tennyson Grieves In Poetry

Classic Art
36 followers
22 Video Views·Aug 28, 2025
Break, break, break on thy cold gray stones, O sea, and I would that my tongue could utter
the thoughts that arise in me. O well for the fisherman's boy that he shouts with his sister
at play. O well for the sailor lad that he sings in his boat on the bay. And the stately ships go
on to their haven under the hill, but O for the touch of a vanished hand and the sound of a voice
that is still. Break, break, break at the foot of thy crags, O sea, but the tender grace of
a day that is dead will never come back to me. Alfred Lord Tennyson is the great English poet
of grief, which is the kind of title that nobody really wants. I mean, to write insightfully about
loss, you unfortunately need to experience it. The loss that changed the course of Tennyson's
life and poetry was that of his dear friend, Arthur Henry Hallam. And I'd wager that,
given the power, Tennyson would have traded all his memorial verses and the acclaim they brought
him for just a little more time with his friend. Tennyson met Hallam in 1828 at Cambridge,
and they rapidly developed a deep bond. The two young men loved to discuss literature and society,
they traveled through Europe together, and Hallam often visited Tennyson at his home in the village
of Summersby, where he met and eventually became engaged to Tennyson's sister, Amelia.
Both men wanted to be poets, but Hallam quickly realized that Tennyson was the genius of the two,
and so he worked hard to get his friend's work published and into the hands of influential
people in Victorian England. Before Tennyson had much of a reputation at all, Hallam predicted
with confidence his friend's future prestige. As he writes in an 1831 letter to Amelia,
Many years, perhaps, or shall I say many ages, after we've all been laid in dust,
young lovers of the beautiful and the true may seek in faithful pilgrimage the spot where Alfred's
mind was molded in silent sympathy with the everlasting forms of nature. Critic after critic
will track the wanderings of the brook or mark the groupings of Elm and Poplar in order to verify
the ode to memory in its minutest particulars. In September 1833, Hallam was traveling with his
father in Vienna when a blood vessel suddenly burst in his brain and he died while his dad
was taking an evening walk. He was 22. The poem I read before was written in early 1835,
a little over a year after Hallam died. It's one of many examples of Tennyson trying to process
and explore his grief. His greatest expression of mourning is an elegy of almost 3,000 lines called
In Memoriam, A.H.H. for Hallam, which took him 17 years to compose and is arguably his best work.
Break, break, break, on the other hand, is only 16 lines, but its shortness isn't a fault,
its brevity is its power. The first stanza sets the scene, and as biographer Michael Thorne notes,
the scene is almost cinematically clear. We have the speaker standing on the shore of the sea,
watching the waves break on stone as he thinks about someone who is gone. The second two lines
here are ambiguous. They suggest either that the speaker is too sad to speak his thoughts,
as in he literally can't get the words out over his tears, or that his thoughts are too big,
too strong, too recent to be adequately captured in words. In articulate, these feelings emanate
from him like waves breaking over and over on cold gray stones, which had put us in mind of
gravestones. Of course, the irony is that this account of inarticulateness is highly articulate.
In the second and third stanzas, the speaker turns away from the waves and observes a world that's
indifferent to his desolation. In fact, it's a particularly happy world, which provides the
He sees young siblings at play, a young man singing in his boat, and grand ships sailing off
into the horizon. But why these three images? If at first they seem random, a closer look shows that
they've been deliberately chosen and deliberately ordered. What you have is first, a child, second,
a youth, and third, stately ships representing adulthood sailing away to a far haven, which means
port or harbor, as well as a safe place or refuge. If the word puts you in mind of heaven,
that's no coincidence. What we're seeing here is the full progress of a life into death.
Now, for Tennyson, the writer, that was deliberate. But for the speaker, it may be that he was just
looking around and that his grief, reaching out for some articulation, finds a pattern in his
Regardless, by the end of stanza three, he's brought back to himself. His loved one may be
at peace in their haven, but he's left behind and can feel nothing but absence, a vanished hand,
a still voice. In the final stanza, the speaker returns his focus to the waves breaking against
the crags and inarticulate grief still pulsating within him. And then we get this bleak final
sentence. But the tender grace of a day that is dead will never come back to me. You know,
he's thinking about the past, but this phrase, day that is dead, it casts a shadow back over
the rest of the poem. Now we can't help but see these happy people as future vanished hands and
still voices, this happy scene as a future dead day, its tender grace irrecoverable by those who
will grieve it. In a sense, having read beyond these verses in the poem, that scene is already
gone. Break, break, break imagines grief as an incessant reaching for something that's not there.
As Tennyson puts it in another poem, God gives us love, something to love, he lends us. But when
love is grown to ripeness, that on which it drove falls off and love is left alone. When Hallam
died, Tennyson's love for his friend was left alone. But despite what break, break, break says,
he was able to transform that feeling into poetry, giving form to the thoughts that arise
in all who grieve. In the end, Hallam was right about his friend. Tennyson's reputation is enduring
and it will endure for ages to come, if only it were for a different reason.
Hey everybody, thank you so much for watching. I love doing these poetry videos. This episode
was brought to you by Squarespace, the all-in-one website platform for entrepreneurs to stand out
and succeed online. Whether you're just starting out or managing a growing brand, Squarespace makes
it easy to create a beautiful website. And now you can make a completely personalized website
with their new guided design system, Squarespace Blueprint. Choose from professionally curated
layout and styling options to build a unique online presence from the ground up, optimized
for every device, and with optimized SEO tools so you show up more often to more people. You can
upload video content, you can even sell access to your video library, all from within Squarespace.
Basically, a Squarespace site is going to make whatever you're sharing or selling look professional
and that's going to help you get the word out, whatever that word actually is. Head over to
squarespace.com for a free trial and when you're ready to launch that site, go to squarespace.com
slash nerdwriter for 10% off your first purchase. Thanks guys and I'll see you next time.
