https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fjb9JYHfsls
3 Video Views·Aug 28, 2025
Giving My Viewers Victorian Dating Advice
Welcome, esteemed readers of my advice column.
I am truly honored that you chose to confide in me in hopes of acquiring useful advice
regarding the matters of your courtship, or, as it were, the lack of it.
I shall do my very best to answer your pressing questions.
Dear Martha, I am alone and fear I may never experience such love as that of
Romeo and Juliet. Have the stars forgotten me?
Will I ever find my star-crossed lover? How long must I wait?
My heart aches and yearns for love while those around me seem to have it all.
Tell me what must I do to find love as a quiet and lonely Victorian girl?
Juliet, Annette, Nicolette, Clouette, Brown.
It seems to me that waiting is the wrong approach.
Truly one cannot expect to just stumble upon agreeable suitors at every given
opportunity. Some effort is needed, whether it be accepting a dance,
asking friends and family to introduce you to a desirable match,
or simply opening your heart where it so far has remained closed.
Dear Martha, that's me.
I was previously introduced to a suitor at a ball by a close friend of mine and
we proceeded to exchange letters for some time before he began an excursion.
I have not received word from him since his departure. How unusual.
I would endeavor to send an inquiry after him,
but do I risk shooting into the brown in such a manner?
Your advice would be most appreciated. Sincerely, Amelia Peabody.
There is generally no harm in a letter. However,
do be warned that were you constantly in his thoughts,
he would have surely inquired after you already. There is of course,
a small chance he perished in the seas,
but what I do find far more likely is that his excursion provided
entertainment enough to forget you as blunt as it may sound.
Dear Martha, I am at a loss and need advice.
I met Mr. Smithson through a mutual acquaintance at a dinner party and we
liked each other instantaneously.
I have danced with Mr. Smithson at several balls and he has even dined with my
family twice and taken tea with us on several occasions.
We have taken walks in the park with a chaperone of course,
and he has made it clear that he likes me very much,
but he has not yet asked for my hand.
Everything seems to be going in the right direction and I love him dearly,
but my friends have begun asking me why we are not engaged yet and I have
begun to wonder the same.
Mother worries that he does not take our courtship seriously and I fear she may
soon begin to warn me away from him.
I dare not bring up the subject with Mr. Smithson as he might think it forward or
improper, but I do not wish to lose him. What shall I do? Yours, Diana.
It is a great plague within modern courting that gentlemen fail to declare
their intentions early on or when a lady wishes to discuss the matters of her
heart and receive some sort of assurance,
she is told that it would be unwise to put a name on it.
There is nothing improper in making sure the gentleman's intentions are true.
Therefore I implore you to challenge your sweetheart on the matter and let the
answer decide the future course of the union.
Dearest Martha, I must speak now of a gentleman,
a man with whom I once shared moments so tender,
so spark filled that I genuinely believed we might be headed toward lifelong
bliss. And then dear Lord above,
he disappeared, vanished,
evaporated like the last biscuit at a tea party hosted by ravenous aunts.
Not a message, not a smoke signal,
not even a poorly calligraphed you up at 2am.
His affection it seems had the lifespan of a child with a chest cold.
And to this very day, nary a word has been heard from him.
I imagine he now resides in the same spiritual realm as lost socks and men who
just need time to figure things out.
How might a lady recover from the pangs of affection for a gentleman who has
withdrawn himself entirely and find solace in composure once more?
Lady Anne, as aforementioned, men have a growing tendency to vanish.
Not only is it a cruel blow to our trust,
it is also a great disrespect that you should not tolerate by conversing with a
gentleman any longer. Let the thought of that disrespect aid your healing.
For if a man did not consider you worthy of partying with dignity,
is he worth pondering on? And rest assured,
there are plenty of gentlemen who were raised properly.
So do not let that cloud your judgment when making new acquaintances.
Some wariness however,
is always recommended when dealing with the opposite sex. Dear Martha,
I have been trying to find a husband using a mail order bride company for some
time now, but with little success.
You may have heard about personal advertisements for brides placed in Western
newspapers like the Chicago Tribune in the recent decade. Well,
now Hinge & Co has expanded these advertisements to cities all across the world.
I have indeed heard of these services. I had a photographer
take a black and white photograph of me. What do you mean black and white?
Is there anything else?
But the men I write to have little interest in me.
And the men who write to me are not to my taste. What should I do?
Sincerely, Agnes Earnshaw.
The modern inventions meant to aid the courting process can both be a
blessing and a curse.
I cannot call myself a great admirer of these new techniques. It would be,
however,
a great injustice to criticize it since I happened to encounter my own
spouse while flipping through an advertisement section of a local magazine.
As with every pursuit, patience and persistence is key.
Even when one begins to lose hope.
And remember that some gentlemen struggle greatly with letters as the means of
conversing.
So it is always far better to arrange some sort of a formal introduction rather
than pick apart the letters line by line, week after week,
trying to decipher their meaning.
Dear Martha,
my betrothed possesses a rather forgetful disposition and I harbor no desire to
embark upon a path of parental admonition or incessant urging.
What might be the most judicious means by which I might evoke his recollection
of significant dates, obligations, and social engagements.
Vera Raydale.
It is indeed very troubling to feel like the only person keeping the household
intact. However,
do keep in mind that there are types of ailments of the human mind that have a
little chance of ever being rectified.
Does the gentleman's inability to better engage in the household affairs stem
from a place of comfort and laziness,
since he can be assured there is someone already engaged in those matters or does
it seem that no matter what you do and how many attempts he is simply unable to
remember. If it is the latter,
approach the matter with compassion and consider inquiring after a physician
trained in detecting such ailments. If the former,
some serious discussions must be had.
Dear Martha,
back in my youth I had an engagement with a trained conductor for several years.
Both our families supported the engagement,
but a few years in we had a cholera outbreak that forced us inside and he ended
the engagement soon after via letter.
When we were due to meet mere hours later, I was devastated. Of course,
I had been devoted to him and he didn't even have the grace to end the
engagement in person. Half a decade passes.
I'm visiting some gardens in the summer and guess who I find tending to the
roses. My problem, my dear Martha,
is that I think I'm still in love with him despite his inexcusable behavior.
Obviously we can't be seen together given our circumstances.
So I don't know what I as a proper lady should do. Dorian Thorne.
One cannot help but wonder what was the reason
for his inability to properly end the engagement? Was it fear?
Was it anticipating your reaction? In any way, such behavior is unacceptable.
The only thing working in his favor is the passage of time.
One can carefully assume that half a decade was enough time for him to change
his ways. However,
such are the age teachings of professor Delulu,
which has since been discredited in the medical community.
It is of course entirely possible that he learned nothing from the whole affair
and does not even consider his conduct improper.
I understand there are more questions that have tortured your mind ever since,
and I do believe it is not improper to inquire after the answers. However,
do remain cautious for if someone trifled with your feelings once,
they might well do it again. Dear Martha,
for some weeks now,
my heart has been plagued by conflicting feelings and I write to you in hopes
that your wisdom will lend me some clarity.
I have always been of the romantic persuasion,
the sort of gentleman who dreams of a profound love and swaying the heart of his
beloved with sonnets and bouquets of wildflowers.
I have over time met with several incredibly attractive matches who shall
remain nameless.
There have been secret escapades and intriguing proposals that made my
heart flutter. Yet each time I find myself turning them away in spite of my
yearning. Why is my soul aches for true love?
Do I flee when it draws close? It troubles me deeply.
I fear that in my pursuit of the ideal love,
I have become paralyzed by the thought that none will ever be quite right.
And what if I were to mistakenly turn my one true love away?
The idea alone fills me with dread. Whatever shall I do?
I await your response with a heart full of hope. Yours faithfully,
Sir Jonas Love Boat.
The only way to overcome those fears is to face them, I'm afraid.
Whenever your heart longs to turn away, persist.
Whenever it tells you to run away, stay.
Whenever it whispers that the person is wrong,
acknowledge that it is your mind trying to steer you away from happiness
under the guise of regaining peace. Love is a scary affair,
but so is loneliness.
Dear Martha, I am desperately seeking advice for my current situation.
My disposition is bright, but I fear my future is looking bleak.
I have been exclusively courting a childhood friend of mine,
Mr. Dean for almost seven years now.
I am 21 years of age and I'm not getting, and I'm not getting any younger.
At this rate, I face becoming a spinster instead of a wife.
How might I convince Mr. Dean to make me his Mrs. Dean?
While seven years might seem like a long enough time to finally enter a proper
engagement, keep in mind, you began courting as children.
Unlike what family columns in women's magazine tell you,
you are only beginning your life at 21 and there shall be many more changes and
storms along the way.
It is best to see whether Mr. Dean remains truthfully and duly by your
side before entering a formal engagement. If you, however,
sense that there is something in his approach,
marriage and family life that disagrees with yours,
it is worth discussing to make sure it will not lead to disappointment later on.
Dear Martha, I have been courting my love for seven years.
Is that the same person?
Since we met as young lovers at various balls our parents through,
while we are now of age to marry,
between my studies at university and my love's dutiful apprenticeship under the
brilliant Miss Mary Anning,
we have held off so that we may wed as the best versions of ourselves.
Alas,
my schooling has taken me to accept a position in the newly open country of
Japan and there I shall remain for a period of several months.
While letters may help us keep in touch,
I worry for the tender heart of my love.
Our separation could lead to my love's despair as while we are often separated
and write often, never before has it been through such a great distance.
What is it that I should do to keep my love's tender heart from breaking?
Do not let your feelings prevent you from going on adventures.
That is my advice.
There is thousands of lovers separated by land and sea and we live in an era
where post is quite speedy,
might I say allowing for frequent communication.
Several months may seem unbearable at this point,
but they will likely go in the blink of an eye and you will soon find yourself
reunited with your beloved.
Your bonds strengthened and with many stories to tell.
Dear Martha,
it is my duty to bring your attention to the most bizarre adventure that has
recently befallen me.
I met a charming young man in one of the college courses I am allowed to take.
He is my age and of good family.
He is courteous and gallant and I had foolishly believed he was infatuated with
me.
I was sure that he was courting me,
but his flattery never led anywhere so I had to ask him if his intentions were
serious and I probably made a fool of myself.
His answer was this.
He had not at all noticed my growing affection for him and in fact thought that
I only desired to be his friend.
Much to his chagrin,
he was forced to decline my affection because according to him he was
considering a career in the church,
in the Catholic church if I must be precise.
I was so shocked by his affirmations that I could only laugh hysterically.
What is a lady to do in such a situation?
Lady Burnett.
It is a growing concern of mine the way young men trifle with young women's
feelings.
They strive to achieve familiarity but shun the responsibilities and then after
employing every tool akin to courtship,
they seem surprised,
nay shocked that a lady should think of the acquaintance with fondness.
Laughing seems to be the appropriate reaction for there is not much more those
kinds of gentlemen deserve.
Dear Martha,
I find myself rather at my wit's end.
A week ago while attending Lady Harrington's ball,
I made the acquaintance of one Mr.
Henry Tyndall.
At first,
Mr.
Tyndall appeared to embody all the geniality and wit a lady might wish for in a
suitor.
His conversation,
if a touch eager,
sparkled with cleverness and his manners,
though enthusiastic,
seemed sufficiently well bred.
For a moment,
dear Martha,
I dared to indulge myself in hopeful reveries of friendship and perhaps with
time,
love.
These fancies would not last,
however,
as the budding bloom of hope swiftly revealed its thorns.
In the days that followed,
Mr.
Tyndall's attentions grew not only more frequent,
but alarmingly fervent.
Where once his words had charmed,
they now pressed upon me with the weight of unwanted urgency.
He began to appear at every turn upon my daily walks at the milliner's,
even intruding upon the sanctity of my quiet afternoons at home.
I confess I have had to make use of deceptions such as feigning fainting
spells and illnesses,
all in desperate hope that he might take his leave and give me a moment's
respite.
I have told him in as many ways as words would allow that his affections are
unwanted and unappreciated.
I confess to you with all the sincerity in my keeping that I am quite at the end
of my patience and do not know what to do short of resorting to violence.
Pray Martha,
how might I rid myself of Mr.
Tyndall's entreaties one and for all?
With all sincerity and desperation,
Adeline Whitlock.
It is quite shocking the stubbornness with which gentlemen or men rather,
for there is nothing gentle about their manner,
choose to bestow their feelings upon an unwanted recipient.
There is a point,
however,
in which one has to employ some help,
whether it is a male relative,
a group of dear friends,
or even getting the police involved.
Someone must stop Mr.
Tyndall in his tracks before your gentle mind becomes unwell or something worse
happens.
I believe we should treat such cases with utmost seriousness.
For no lady deserves to be troubled by a man she was once cordial to.
Dear Martha,
since our youth,
a wonderful lady and I have been bosom friends and she is my dearest confidant
in the entire world.
Spending soirees and balls together,
convincing our parents to share tutors so that we may study in unison,
embroidering handkerchiefs for each other.
We share a kinship so close,
I would believe ourselves to be woven of the same fabric.
My heart yearns for no Lord,
the way it yearns for her.
But dear Martha,
although I see no fault in my feelings,
I am afraid she does not reciprocate.
So far,
I have not been able to gather the courage and speak plainly with her.
One magical night in the midnight garden of the Queen's bowl,
she confessed to me that she would most desire to marry me if such a thing were
possible.
However,
to my great chagrin so far,
she has only discussed potential relationships with undeserving Lords for her
family desires for her to find a suitable match as well.
I am afraid my heart will soon tear itself to pieces with uncertainty,
but I would never want to tarnish our wonderful friendship with foolish
confessions.
Is there a way to determine if she reciprocates my feelings at all?
A friend of Sappho.
I do find it concerning the way she declared with such easiness that she would
marry you.
Is it possible she was say testing the waters in order to see what
reaction such declaration brings?
Could it be that her family's pressure to find a suitable match prevents her from
expressing her feelings for you in any way?
I do believe such matters should be discussed even at the cost of a great
kinship.
Otherwise one person remains secretly a prisoner of the other.
Dear Martha,
I regret to inform you that I am a spinster at the ripe old age of
32.
Not only do I remain unwed,
but I have not had a single serious suitor throughout my three decades of life.
At least not one,
which I regarded with the same level of affection.
I am not inclined to the religious life,
nor am I content to be the eavesdropping aunt of music hall comedies.
I know of other women who have happily found their match at my age,
yet I cannot help but feel that my vast inexperience and natural shyness
has rendered me incapable of following their example.
Tell me,
dear Martha,
is my situation hopeless?
P.S.
My sentiments have a touch of lavender to them.
Lavender spinster.
As shocking as this may sound for a person of my standing to say,
this is entirely normal.
In fact,
I did not court anyone before I met my dear Reginald.
Long nights of pondering on whether I even deserve anyone's affection,
since I've been so long denied it,
are behind me,
but I remember them well.
What I would suggest is a change of strategy.
Since whatever you did to find yourself a proper lady did not succeed,
it is time to do the opposite.
If you avoided looking for one in the mail,
it is time to start.
If you were attending dances and balls in hopes of finding one,
try book clubs instead.
If you perhaps had a habit of giving your attention to the flimsy beauties
that did not care one bit about you,
maybe it would now be wise to give a chance to the shy intellectuals.
In this war on loneliness,
you need to be fierce.
Do not let your inexperience or shyness keep you back.
Dear Martha,
I will be trying my best to write in the Shakespearean language,
as I am cursed with being a Frenchman.
It was 20 springs ago.
I was merely a sprog,
bored at the chess club,
and I kid you not,
I met the most beautiful eyes mine could never dream to meet one day.
Her name was Constance.
The most shocking of facts was that she as well liked me.
My left cheek once had the honor to receive the sweetest of gifts,
a kiss from the girl I loved.
The chess club shifted from being a lieu of ennui to a place where I felt loved
and alive.
Sadly,
my dear family decided to move to Paris,
far away from my countryside love.
Aeons have passed.
I've grown into a fine gentleman and I'm traveling as an artist around my beloved
country with all my past buried under the years of work and traumas like every
other respectable French person.
One day I received a letter.
When I laid my eyes upon the first words,
my heart nearly surrendered.
It was her,
Constance.
She moved heaven and earth to find me.
I couldn't believe it.
My memories flooded back in my mind,
her eyes,
her name,
her kiss.
So we sent letters to each other for a long time.
Catching up and talking about our young adult life.
I feel alive again,
terrified too.
In a mere few months,
I am going to meet her in person at a gallery after two decades separated.
I know for a fact after a long time of exchange that she isn't romantically
available for now.
Martha,
what is your wisdom for this date?
I fear that this love may be one sided this time.
Should I preserve it for a more fortunate time or should I bury this love back to
where it originated in the past?
Sincerely yours,
Sir Bergerou Delassus.
I must admit the end of your letter has me quite concerned.
All this exchange of letters and thoughts only for her to not be available.
Is it due to some different union or her own obligations?
Either way,
it does not seem like a good time to inquire after her feelings.
I implore you to observe where the meeting is going,
but at any sight of indifference or over friendliness,
withhold your feelings in case they might be unwanted.
In fact,
it might be better to see if a second meeting is suggested and wait for a more
convenient time to reveal your true feelings.
After all two decades is a long time and you should get to know her character
first.
It is entirely possible that you are in love with a vision of her rather than the
constants she is now.
Dear Martha,
I earnestly request your advice always given with such grace and good
sense.
In this matter concerning my beloved Michael,
although I've always known him to be a sullen and downtrodden creature,
my foolish heart desired an engagement.
Two summers ago,
his want of new employment with all his attractions against our humble and rural
home led us to run away to the coast.
Oh,
my folly in this without a secure engagement.
I now live as an invalid with little friends and fewer family to nurse me as
tenderly as Michael upon his return for supper.
I feel quite unworthy of his love yet remain indignant.
His love is rarely professed.
Our precious feelings persist,
but how can one be sure of such an attachment and constancy without an
engagement?
His reservations with the ceremony of marriage pushed me to such an acute
melancholy.
I am approaching seven and 20 if I am persuaded to remove myself from these four
years of entanglement,
what will become of my prospects?
I freely admit I have never been particularly handsome and my talents for
science and writing are particularly undesirable.
Shall I remain in ridiculous love or resign myself to become a disagreeable old
maid? Respectfully,
this consulate in Devonshire.
I must admit you make it sound as if an engagement is required as a solution to
your problems,
but I sense there are more pressing matters regarding your predicament.
Living away by the seaside with little friends or family and in your delicate
condition,
it might feel like you have no other choice but to resign yourself to him.
But is it really Michael you want or is it the feeling to be cared for and
secure?
One should not desire marriage just to avoid courting again.
Perhaps there is a gentleman that would do all Michael does,
but would not feel so adamant on the matter of marriage that is so close to
your heart.
I suggest looking into your heart and ensuring it is not purely a matter of
convenience that keeps yourself where you currently are.
Good Martha,
I'm seeking your help in a helpless matter.
I have been married to my husband for eight years and we are extremely happy.
Lately I have noticed him being more distant and distressed with his work
matters.
His distant cousin who is practically a brother to him,
they grew up together,
has been visiting us for several times trying to help him with his work.
The cousin is a handsome man,
kind and of a good humor.
Now with my husband being distant and his cousin being very attentive and kind
to me,
I must confess I might have a,
how do you say a crush on him?
Oh Martha,
what should I do?
I love my husband and I don't want to complicate their relationship,
but it burns me to see him leave.
And the only thing I can think of when he is gone is him desperate.
I am quite shocked at your revelations.
It is only natural to consider other gentlemen agreeable,
but why even entertain the thought of acting on those feelings,
especially since the said gentleman is not only a relative by marriage,
but a closest of friends to your husband,
your loyalties lie there.
And if the work matters distress him,
so it is even more so your duty to be there and offer your support.
Is it not?
Dearest Martha,
I do find myself in a predicament concerning matters of the heart and I write
to seek your kind and wise counsel.
There is a charming gentleman merchant residing in the new world for whom I have
come to have strong admiration.
He carries himself with kindness and he is quite industrious with his hands.
His work inspires joy and goodwill in those that witness it.
Fortune brought me to him through the medium of long distance communication
intended for strangers called the social gazettes.
I am but a humble spinster from the edge of the great empire who finds his work
simply delightful that my fondness for him ever grows as I engage with his
artistry and humility.
I have penned him many a note expressing my being enamored,
but I always fall short of sending them.
I do believe that a gentleman of his refined character does frequently receive
such messages and I would abort to be viewed as disrespectful and intrusive.
I thus ask if it is proper to pen a note to the lovely gentleman respectfully
expressing my admiration and fondness or put my flights of fancy to rest as
spinster and thread station and at heart Ethel. As I have previously said,
there is no harm in a letter. I do advise you to be cautious. However,
as you have already noted,
a gentleman of his standing surely is keeping correspondence with plenty of
ladies. If your message is ignored or kindly rejected,
pay it no mind and seize the correspondence. If it is accepted,
do not let your admiration of the gentleman's skills cloud your judgment and
remain skeptical. That is my advice. Dear Martha,
I am in my later years and have been made to notice that my family and friends
wish for me to make a match. As a woman, I suppose it is my duty,
but I would rather make myself meals whenever I like walk and talk with
whomever I choose and retire to bed with nothing more than a soft cat as
company. How do I make plainer to my relatives,
the joys of living for my own happiness rather than the constant work of keeping
a husband?
Is there a delicate way to extricate myself from this expectation?
Sincerely, Ms. Comfort Abel.
There seems to be a general misunderstanding of people content with their
independence.
It is especially difficult to convey such preference to those used to their own
way of thinking.
I say make one last attempt at expressing your true feelings after
which you are, in my opinion,
fully entitled to require no more mention of it.
Dear Martha,
I humbly beseech your wisdom on a matter most vexing though I am soon to be
joyfully betrothed to a most honorable gentleman.
I find myself tormented by the cruel machinations of two loathsome aunts.
They are mine own blood who alas take the greatest delight in my sorrows.
My mere happiness turns to ash in their hands,
which they make sport to trample upon.
I am shadowed by an ever dark tower in their presence as they do berate my every
move, especially in the matters of my heart.
The occasion of my wedding though joyful plagues me with a question.
Ought I to extend an invitation to these ever meddlesome matriarchs?
To do so would preserve appearances,
yet at the cost of them selling my most precious day.
I await your counsel, madam, your distressed right to be Lady Copenhilly.
Your wedding is the one day you should only think of yourself and if their
presence would be in any way vexing to you,
I believe you are free to omit them from the guest list.
It is of course entirely possible they shall never speak to you again.
The real question is would your heart weep at the loss of such acquaintance?
Are such evil creatures even worth knowing?
Dear Martha,
I have heard that you are of particular adeptness in matters of courtship.
So I am, I should like to disclose to you my ponderous situation.
I am quite an old maid now approaching my 25th year and have only just this
spring come into what seemed to be a promising acquaintance with a delightful
gentleman of good reputation.
Mr. Graham and I have pursued acquaintance by going on various outings to
provide opportunity for good conversation.
Always we end up talking for hours and I do believe that this has resulted in
affections on both sides. This all seems well and good.
However, the trouble lies in our communication.
I regretfully find myself to be the one writing all the letters.
This being the situation,
one would assume that my gentleman has abandoned any attachments or interests
in me that he may have previously held.
But when we occasionally meet at a public tea house or to stroll through the
park or to view a gallery, he suggests no second thoughts or cooled emotions.
We, without fail, engage in long,
lively conversation and afterward part ways with mutual enthusiasm to continue
our courtship. But then alas,
I proceed to hear nothing from him for above a week. Pray, dear Martha,
what shall I do about my seemingly perfect,
but maddeningly elusive suitor? Yours respectfully, Miss Healy.
Some gentlemen are truly hopeless at writing letters.
I think it would not be unwise to inquire after the reasons for his silence or
express your willingness to receive correspondence more often.
Shall he then fail to improve his behavior?
You could assume there are other reasons that you have mistaken his cordiality
for affections and that he is indeed not as enamored with you as you are with him.
Dearest Martha,
I fear I am in desperate need of both your advice and a great deal of bravery.
For there is a lady.
We found one another in the papers with only a handful of words and a spare
portrait to connect us.
And in an instant I was drawn to her beauty and jesting tone.
On the first occasion she wrote to me, I could hardly believe my luck.
Before I knew it,
a fortnight has passed hardly leaving my writing desk for how often we shared
our small letters,
discussing everything from our favorite novels to the matters of identity and
the heart. Upon our first meeting,
we took a turn about a garden before attending an Opera and dearest Martha,
she was even lovelier in person,
both in the softness in her eyes and the kindness of her words.
I admit I was a little stunned,
my hands trembling on more than one occasion throughout the evening.
But here is my problem, dear Martha. I am unfortunately terribly shy.
I am seeing the lady again tomorrow for tea and I am disquieted by the notion
that I will not possess the same openness and cleverness face to face that I do
throughout letters.
It is so much harder to be clever and bold when she is before me.
And it is so very easy to make a fool of myself when I get all tongue tied and
clumsy. I like her entirely too much already.
And I am frightened I will do something silly to ruin it before we can even
begin. For I am, as the poet Sappho once said,
unable to even do my weaving as Aphrodite has overcome me.
How can I express what I think and feel despite my shyness?
How do I be brave? With deepest gratitude, Margaret.
Not every feeling that is inconvenient is unnatural. In fact,
it sounds terribly normal to fear a meeting such as this and not be able to
express yourself fully upon the first or second introduction to a lovely person.
It is not impossible that the lady is currently overcome by the very same
feelings and fears. You have already formed a valuable connection in pen.
So assuming she might be put off by your demeanor isn't wise in my opinion.
And shall shyness get overwhelming.
I am certain she would appreciate you asking for her understanding and
expressing bluntly that the whole endeavor puts your nerves through a storm.
Dear Martha,
I being a lady of class and refinement have undoubtedly attracted many
admirers and not necessarily only of the male sex.
One would think that such an array of potential suitors would flatter me,
but alas,
I feel nothing but dismay upon hearing their tender professions of love and
admiration. The truth is simple. None shall ever have my heart.
How they plead for my address as they wish to send me letters late in the night,
but I've no interest in reading their messages. But how can I express that?
This is my dilemma. To accept their proposals would be dishonesty,
but to reject them would break their poor sensitive hearts. Pray tell,
what must I say?
How might I express my sentiments or lack thereof without shattering the dreams
of these unlucky ladies and gentlemen? Adeline P. Lam.
To be cursed with eliciting admiration while not longing for any
is indeed a tragedy.
Perhaps there is a way to alert them early on to your staunch dislike of
courtship. So they do not garner any hope in their heart.
Now that the damage is done, nothing else remains,
but to give them a kind but firm rejection.
But it is something to consider for the future as it seems to be a recurring
problem.
Dear Martha,
my friend Elizabeth and I were both introduced to two gentlemen at the same
ball. Both of us started courting these men. Three years later,
my gentleman is my husband and father of our beautiful baby daughter.
Elizabeth gentleman has still not made his intentions clear.
I know Elizabeth has set her heart on marrying this man.
I fear he is leading her not to the altar, but to sin and ruin.
I do not intend to be a busybody, but I seek to protect my friend.
What do I do? Busybody friend. Courtship, marriage,
and the family in three years. It seems that you wasted no time,
but Elizabeth and her gentleman might follow a different path,
the slower one perhaps.
While I do not know Elizabeth's expectations of her situation,
I would not rush into action just yet.
Share Martha.
I require your immediate support as I am terribly clueless on how to handle
my predicament.
I am currently doing my studies abroad and have a sweetheart at home who I have
been pining over since the moment we met 20 years ago.
And it turned out that he felt the same.
He is the first man that makes me feel comfortable around him.
And I love him so much.
We have been courting each other since four years now,
but me being abroad has slowed things down considerably.
Now that the end of my studies is nearing,
he desires nothing more than to live together.
The problem is that deep in my heart,
I strongly feel that I shall never be able to live with another person or at
least not anytime soon.
Nothing brings me more delights than being in living by myself and having my own
place.
I know for a fact that I will not be comfortable or feel at home if we were to
live together.
How do I tell him about these feelings without hurting him?
I do not want to lose him because he is the only person I have ever loved and
will ever love.
There is a reason why I'm so very sure about this,
that I cannot openly discuss to protect my privacy.
Regardless,
I sincerely hope that you can help me share Martha.
You should discuss the matter with the gentleman as soon as possible.
If your desires are thus misaligned,
I do not wish to pry after your reasoning,
but is there any room for negotiation?
Could you possibly ask him to put the matter aside for now as you take your time
to think of a proper solution?
This is a very delicate matter as both of you deserve to live in perfect
happiness.
Dear Martha,
I am writing an utter agony and despair close at my skirts,
threatening me to fall upon the floor in complete hopelessness.
It was not even a year when I met this incredible gentleman,
a Viscount's son who had been emboldened to pursue his hobbies of sailing and
carousing with merchants.
We exchanged countless letters.
I had even thought he meant to propose to me perhaps someday.
Then tragedy.
I have not heard from my dear Reginald in months.
His ship was lost at sea.
His last voyage struck by Poseidon.
Some of his merchant friends claimed that he had arrived safely at his port in
France,
but this is impossible as he surely would have contacted me as soon as he
arrived.
They even claimed this spectre was exchanging poetry with another woman.
Impossible.
I am at a loss of how to cope with my grief.
Some tell me to simply forget my one true love.
Others encourage me to believe in these tales of phantoms.
Should I resign myself to chasing ghosts or do I ask my heart to learn how to
forget the warmth of Reginald?
Kind regards,
distressed widow.
Those manly spectres are more and more common and loving a ghost would be
rather unwise.
Whether or not his shadow is serenading another now should not be a concern of
yours.
Take your time to grieve his disappearance and move on to another.
My beloved Martha,
for the past three years I am in a relationship with a former friend of mine.
Recently,
as I work in the colonies and she works in the mainland,
we are not seeing each other much.
I sent her letters that indicate my interest of her life and wellbeing.
In addition to narrating my life in the colonies,
I know love is not a trade agreement that requires both sides to give an equal
terms,
but nonetheless I feel as if I am neglected in a way.
She is so busy even not to send a single letter about me in months.
And even when she does,
she only concerns herself with her life in the mainland and does not even ask me
about my health,
which she knows is not in a good shape.
When I confronted her about this situation,
she yelled at me,
vented about how I do not understand her situation and that she has absolutely no
time even to think about me in her busy life.
At the end,
she accepted and apologized for her actions while crying,
but I was hurt.
I do not know what to do.
And sometimes I think about ending the relationship.
I noticed that one sided plead,
but I hope you understand me.
I am waiting for your reply.
Sincerely,
Maleth.
No life is busy enough to forget where one's heart truly lies.
I am therefore inclined to believe that your love being separated from you has
discovered the pleasantries of life more attempting than your company,
but it brings her comfort.
There is someone waiting.
If after expressing your feelings so fully,
her behavior shall remain the same.
I would take it as a confirmation of that thought.
Dear Martha,
I must request your advice on a situation most foul.
There exists a fair maiden,
one such as myself that I find I am utterly incapable of reading my thoughts
off.
The problem herein lies in the matter that I have already once engaged in
courtship with the lady.
The matter is rather intricate.
We commenced our dalliance for a duration of the year,
experienced the separation,
rekindled our affection two years hence only to culminate in another parting,
just shy of a year thereafter.
It has now been approximately two years since our last farewell and over five
since our initial engagement.
Yet I still cannot surmount my feelings for her.
There remains a pronounced absence of closure.
We concluded our schooling.
Thus she chose to part ways with me for an internship in a distant town,
a good six hours hence.
Only I found that engagement lasted but two months before we were brought to the
same locale once more.
Yet she then seemingly vanished from the realm,
no longer communicating with our mutual acquaintances as if she had simply
dissolved into the ether.
I do not yearn to reestablish our romantic bond,
yet I find the absence of my closest companion more poignant than any other
longing.
I beseech your counsel in this matter.
P.S.
I find it notable to articulate that I find myself rather solitary in the realm
of companionship during these days and I am indeed tragically deficient in social
graces. Clementine.
She seems to be appearing and disappearing from your life like some sort of
ghostly creature and with each apparition your feelings for her awaken twice as
strong.
This combined with your lack of other courtships to entertain you seem to be the
problem.
I firmly believe that were you two destined to join hands in marriage,
it would have happened already and without complication.
Years go by and you should focus on other prospects.
For there might be someone much more fruitful and poignant around the corner,
which you are unable to reach when held back by the shadows of the past.
Dear Martha,
recently at a ball I danced every dance with a rake named Charlie.
He is known for breaking engagements and behaving in an ungentlemanly manner to
those he is courting.
Though I knew it would cause some scandal to dance with him,
he was so charming I found it hard to care.
Throughout the night he told me how long he had wanted to dance with me and how
he hoped to do it again often in the coming season.
The next morning I told my friend Beatrice and she informed me that Charlie had
secretly been courting a friend of hers, Ada.
I of course immediately wrote a letter to tell Ada and I hear she is quite
heartbroken and has called off the engagement.
My dilemma is that while I would not like to court Charlie,
I would very much like to continue to dance with him.
As they will not be formally engaged,
I think Charlie and I should be free to dance,
but I know this would upset Ada,
which would put Beatrice in an awkward position.
Flora,
I see no real value in dancing with a snake and there's plenty of partners to
dance with equally or even more pleasurable than a man who has no respect for
you or your friends.
Do not let your desire for dancing cloud your judgment as you might find
yourself in a difficult situation.
Dear Martha,
I hope this letter finds you in good spirits much better than my own at the
present.
It is painful to admit,
but ever since Tom and I moved abroad something vital between us has grown
cold.
The tenderness that once made the risks worthwhile has faded and in his place
have settled habits and all too often his ungovernable temper.
I find myself so far from my beloved home wondering whether I ought to leave,
but I am not young Martha and I am petrified by the thought of never being loved
again.
Tell me honestly,
am I a coward for staying?
Should I still keep hope in my heart that things might yet improve?
Lady Adelaide,
moving abroad seems like a significant change.
One that is difficult to you both.
It is possible that the predicament is temporary only and will ease with time.
Do not,
however,
let your fear of loneliness keep you from following your heart.
Dear Martha,
my husband,
Edward,
whom I love dearly has recently declared that he wishes to leave his job at the
railway office.
I must follow my passion.
He said,
while buttering toast with unusual intensity,
I had hoped his passion might be punctual income.
Alas,
it appears to be self-employment.
He speaks vaguely of working with his hands and being his own master.
I have known Edward for 13 years.
The only thing he's built in that time was a shelf that immediately collapsed
under the weight of a single teacup and he is not even a master of his own sock
drawer.
Still I see in his eyes,
the gleam of a man convinced that fulfillment lies just beyond the next
financial disaster.
I want to support him truly,
but I also want to keep children in boots and myself in candles.
I've tried to suggest he secure another position before leaving his current one,
but he muttered something about the tyranny of timetables and then went to the
shed where I fear he is now communing with a broken wheelbarrow.
Martha,
how does one balance dreams with the price of coal?
How do I remain the encouraging wife while gently reminding him that inspiration
though noble does not pay the milkman. Franny Cunningham.
I assume the position he was previously at brought him much grievance and
affected his wellbeing,
but the wellbeing of you and your children is also at stake.
And so I would negotiate possibly agreeing on a particular date.
Shall your husband managed to secure his own business by that time and reached
the agreed goals,
he then would be allowed to continue if however the set date goes by and no
business is inside.
He should go back to the work he found so unpleasant simply because hunger is
not a pleasant thing either. Gracious greetings,
my dearest Martha. Thank you.
I find myself in quite the dilemma and solicit your precious and sensible
advice. My darling sailor,
the Commodore is quite enamored with my person and I am beginning to acquire
fondness for his person as well.
The Commodore and I are in a quarrel as he says that I am very much held back by
my Regency style beliefs about the lady not being too forward before the proper
formalities have been met.
The Commodore has respected my beliefs and not imposed himself upon me.
Yet I feel I must set him free as I do not wish to detain his will.
Please advise me dear Martha, as I do not see any other way around this issue.
Always grateful your friend and most thankful Penpal Hyacinth.
A true gentleman will never disrespect a lady's beliefs,
let alone try to persuade her to abandon them.
It is just as much about setting him free as it is about setting yourself free
from a man who expects you to yield to his expectations.
Dear Martha,
for some time I find myself engaged in a deep courtship with a fair and lovely
lady who I dare say I love well and earnestly.
The matter arises from finding that conspicuously the Dame seems to have a
penchance for vocalizing every worldly thought that seems to pass her intellect.
I wonder if perhaps being of a masculine persuasion makes me less tolerant of
such talk of trivialities,
for we know that the female mind is naturally more prone to discussing the
mundane.
I travel far and wide in my vocation and the repose of a wanderer lies in
silence and solitude.
Though I am mindful of the emotional tendencies of my beloved,
how shall I approach the topic without having her resort to her salts as she
often does when anything vexes her gentle constitution?
Troubled and sincerely yours, E.L. Hawthorne.
Is this something that can be corrected or is this a natural predisposition?
It is possible that the lady feels so comfortable with you as to abandon all
shackles of society which taught her to be silent.
It is also possible there is not much she can do about it,
for her talkativeness is an integral part of her being.
You can delicately suggest your need for silence and agree on a period during the
day or your travels when that would be applied,
but to expect someone to change their whole demeanor is unwise.
Dear Martha,
it began with a letter unlike any other I'd ever seen.
Unusual paper, edges gilded and sealed with a crest so exotic
I felt a shiver of destiny.
Prince Shackleford of the distant kingdom of Almer wrote in the most
genteel hand explaining his tragic exile and the entrapment of his fortune,
20,000 sovereigns in the bank of Constantinople.
He said he had searched the world for someone both noble and discreet and found
in me, Lady Margaret Whittingham, the ideal confidante.
Prince Shackleford requested I assist with the necessary ministerial
arrangements, but alas, I find myself consumed with all manner of doubt.
What sort of a woman am I to doubt such honor in a man of royal blood?
Tell me, doctor of the heart,
when a man writes of loyalty, suffering and treasure in the same breath,
is that not love? Lady Margaret Whittingham. Lady Margaret,
I fear for your finances for it is a common trickery.
In fact, if you discreetly inquire upon your friends,
you will find that they too received similar letters.
Do not be as foolish as to believe this man's advances for he is only after
your savings.
Dear Martha,
I'm troubled and perhaps deluded by the eloquence of the men in the books I
read to while away my evenings.
They have possessed my fancies to an alarming extent. Every ball I go to,
I find myself wishing to find someone akin to them. Alas,
that is a very whimsical of me. For now,
the speech of men is pretty crass for my taste.
I might as well be a spinster in this life. Pretty Martha,
your wise words might be my only salvation. Abigail.
The sole reason literary men seem so desirable is that they do not
exist. In fact,
their characters are so tempting simply because they're not real.
They do not snore. They do not get irksome. They do not forget.
They'll literally descriptions are an ideal that we fall so easily pray to,
which then makes it harder for us to appreciate real human beings for how can
they compare to ideals?
I would advise remembering that while the book characters have some qualities
we can look for when trying to find a suitor,
they are after all a fantasy and we should not hold men to a fantasy
standard. These seem to be all the letters I have received for which I am so
grateful.
I pray that each and every one of you finds encouragement and hope in these
answers. Thank you.

