Johan Westerholm pekar på att Europas gasberoende har sin grund i politiska beslut av bland andra Gerhard Schröder och Angela Merkel, som stängde kärnkraft och kol och ersatte det med rysk naturgas. Han menar att klimatpaniken bidrog till förhastade beslut och att Nord Stream ökade beroendet. Trots att andelen rysk gas har minskat står fortfarande nästan en femtedel av Europas behov på Ryssland.
För Sveriges del ser Westerholm stora risker eftersom gasen är nödvändig för både industriprocesser och rent dricksvatten, samtidigt som landet länge saknat en egen LNG-terminal. Han bedömer att EU:s mål om oberoende på två år är orealistiskt och menar att det snarare handlar om minst fem år – om samlade investeringar görs i hela Europa.
Han riktar kritik mot att politikerna som skapat dagens beroende nu är de som förväntas leda vägen ut, medan experter som tidigt varnat inte fått gehör.
Johan Westerholm having spent several years in the war in Ukraine says that Europe still has an energy dependency on Russia
How did it get this way in the beginning
We can go back to when Germany under Gerhard Schroeder decided to start phasing out brown coal and nuclear power
A development that gained extra momentum in connection with Angela Merkel and that abruptly shut down all nuclear power plants
This made it necessary to compensate for the energy loss with natural gas which is considered a transitional solution
Until alternative or fossil-free agreements that fairly release less carbon dioxide and hydrogen sulfide
This was also accelerated and facilitated by the fact that the Nord Stream was routed through Östersund
It was also Gerhard Schröder's initiative that came to a dead
end I would say that Europe ended up in a massive gas dependency
It is estimated that around 45 percent of the energy demand came from Russia during that period
It is now down to 19 percent but it is still almost a fifth of Europe's energy needs met by Russia
It is a fast and efficient team It is a series of political decisions
First and foremost by Gerhard Schroeder and Angela Merkel who have paved the way for this
Even the Spanish PSOE the Spanish socialists have pushed for this
In Spain they have thus expelled both coal and nuclear power and now rely essentially only on renewable energy sources and to some extent gas
This makes the power system unstable We saw that now I was foolish down in Spain during this blackout in the Iberian trade
It is therefore political decisions that are emphasized throughout this whole process which I call it
The sense of panic that Greta Thunberg and her network organization Fridays for Future have managed to create at the political level
You're ashamed of yourself going around with climate guilt here and there This has actually provided a very stable basis for thoughtless decisions
The EU left in May and said that it should phase out Russian gas over the next two years Is that possible
Good luck with that I'd say Firstly the Danish gas field is currently under renovation and I don't know if it will be completed within two years
It's also the case that gas is something we can buy from the liquid gas market that is LNG liquid natural gas which we can buy from other markets
The United States Canada the United Kingdom and South Latin America These are global trade goods
When gas is injected into the European gas network which Sweden is part of it cannot distinguish between Russian gas and other gas
But regarding Sweden this is especially serious because the Löfven government which was the government with Elisabeth Löfven halted the construction of an LNG terminal in Gothenburg
So Sweden has been under up until now and now the government has dusted off that plan so we have not had our own capacity to receive this LNG product
We only have one pipeline which runs between Malmö and Copenhagen supplying the western Swedish gas network
Oh well one might then ask but what we don't use gas Yes we do
Gas natural gas LNG or natural gas has some unique properties that you won't find anywhere else as it contains methane
But methane is just that it precipitates impurities and therefore we must have such natural gas or a similar product with methane in order to drink clean water
So someone is sabotaging this meaning they accidentally drop anchor in the wrong place in the Øresund and this gas pipeline gets damaged
Then I can say this: within a few hours Gothenburg Malmö and Copenhagen will no longer have clean drinking water
This is so sensitive Therefore I would like to recommend Energy Minister Ebba Börss and especially Minister for Civil Defense Carl-Oskar Bolin
To meet with Gustav Voetius Gustav Voetius wrote the book Leadership which goes through Sweden's and the EU's gas dependence and how the entire market is structured
I can only state that I find it highly unlikely that Europe will manage to eliminate its dependence on Russian gas or the influence Russia has on Europe's gas distribution
Since the construction of Nord Stream all Russian gas was sent through Ukraine which was the transit country We have seen many gas-related crises in Ukraine
Greece many countries around the Mediterranean were involved The gas through Ukraine has been shut off previously Why did Germany and Europe choose to get involved in such a project with Russia
We need to rewind the clock to the atmosphere of the period 2014-2021 Russia had just annexed Crimea and Nord Stream had been on hold for a longer period
I remember during my time at the intelligence security center and at MKO that were watching the draw and had a list of comments on this at the very least geostrategically and in terms of security policy
In 2014 we had to look at the mood it was peace in our time after Europe had given in to Putin's territorial claims on Crimea However Ukraine has never given up Crimea as we know
I know that my colleague Gudrun Persson from FOI and I were the only ones who publicly stated that Putin would not stop here with this annexation but would continue
Men Angela Merkel Gerhard Schröder and Carl Bildt as we know was peace in our time we will invest in this it is reasonable and clean and commercially acceptable
We have trade with Russia so everything will be fine and you won't end up killing your customer
It's the spirit of the times and were a few who said this is wrong and then the whole lot of them came out and excuse the expression but they turned the debate into something even more emotionally charged
We got Fukushima and everyone was scared that tsunami waves would crash into the Autobahn in Central City Germany
It was the mood that was that it was not possible to express any critical opinions directly
It's like today if you criticize something you suddenly become a climate denier and you're even worse than that
Then being a murderer meant pointing out the risk of becoming too dependent on Russian gas
Now as we sit here what I find serious is that yesterday's politicians who have put us in this situation
Not only Sweden but all of Europe it is they who also hinder any development that could get us out of this situation
How does the closure of Swedish nuclear power play into this
It probably doesn't make much difference for Sweden's overall situation
There one can say that natural gas has a limited but very very important part of Sweden's energy supply
It is clear that when we shut down Swedish nuclear power the need for other energy sources in Europe will increase
Since the Swedish network is shortened via Denmark to the European one
It is relatively not a large transfer capacity but these systems are connected
Sweden and Europe would have been much better prepared if we had both the Ringhals reactors and the Oskarshamn reactors
The government of Löfven locked them down if we had them running
For the reactors a power link called the western link guarantees
This means equipping West Sweden with impact
Can we then provide West Sweden with power so that the pressure on gas as an energy source is reduced
and also admits to a larger extent an export of effect which
would then reduce the need for European dependence on Russian gas
So the energy systems are connected and there the Löfven government has suddenly made the power source unprofitable with a decision
And this is also a decision we must remember that
It was indeed Magdalena Andersson Åsa Romsson and Per Bolund together with Mikael Landberg
It turned out to better to revise the taxation of this rather than to ban it
It is faster to change the tax rules for nuclear power than to ban nuclear power
So they chose that path which in practice made two plus two nuclear power plants poorer overnight
He was fully grown and had at least 10 in some cases 20 years left to live
So what we have removed at one end we have not managed to compensate for at the other end
To have LNG or gas is also dispatchable energy and you cannot replace dispatchable energy with non-dispatchable
When the wind blows like that it blows hard and you can only run factories or for example such a case as this is
At the only sugar factory in Sweden they can't even stand still for a minute I can tell you
When the ovens cool down they crack the molasses dries up and the ovens crack again and thus you end up with an interruption lasting several years
There are many such sensitive individuals who depend on a continuous supply of effects
Some manufacturing processes at SKF for example these furnaces must not stand still
So you end up with irreversible capital destruction in quite long production chains
It means that by removing electricity which is a powerful source of nuclear energy it affects the total and perfect supply
But there the gas is a very small part of Sweden's exports but for Europe it is a large part
Until Nord Stream was built all gas went to Europe through Ukraine and Ukraine had an entirely different negotiating position
To what extent was it a difficult question to answer but to what extent did Nord Stream enable the invasion of Ukraine
Now you have another distribution network this network it matters less where you inject gas into this system
You have the South Stream pipeline going through Turkey so you shut one off and it's not like we now have no functioning Nord Stream
The point is that gas to Germany takes other routes from Russia partly through Ukraine but also through Turkey and Italy
So in a way it's a self-compensating system
How does the dynamics work where Russian gas is still being sold through Ukraine to Europe while Ukraine is at war with Russia
Yes if you turn off the gas what happens to Europe You won't have a single drop of clean national water after 24 hours
Water training works that way too
Recent evidence strongly suggests that Ukraine is behind the attacks on Nord Stream What do you think about that
I'm thinking of nothing I think that yes it is a likely or even probable actor
I don't think anything at all even after I've seen the sword and been able to change it
The EU says it will take two years to become independent from Russian gas How far are we and what would you say is the path to get there
I would say five years It depends on Denmark getting its gas field up and running and starting production
The Norrmen are increasing their capacity and our own biogas production that is our food waste that everyone brings in brown plastic bags for source separation
To get that production going Because we need the methane We need the methane And even in some special steel processes we need methane
It's one of the things we have to build We need to expand the terminals to receive LNG liquefied natural gas in liquid form We have to expand them
I'm talking about building permits and other things I see as well as capacity development I think five years is reasonable But that means five years must be a concentrated to some extent coordinated investment that has to take place across all of Europe
Since these networks are interconnected and they are constantly seeking self-regulation and new balances Here it is probably necessary for the European Energy Agency which has an office in Paris to step forward and show where the cabinet should be placed
And indeed I think we must start nationalizing the entities that are responsible for balancing the gas network And in this regard Sweden is one of the few countries in Europe that has privatized the entity responsible for balancing
It is therefore not the Swedish power grid or the energy agency that is responsible for ensuring availability to demand in the system Instead it is Nordion And Nordion is owned by a foundation with unknown stakeholders in New Zealand
The current chairperson of Nordion is Anders Sundström former minister of commerce best known as a shareholder in both Stegra and Nåsort
The energy dependency that Europe has had is beginning to awaken many people Countries and Europe are starting to do something about it People are beginning to expand nuclear power again But the lead times are very long
At the same time we also have a very strong dependence on Russia and other countries especially China when it comes to rare earth metals and 16 strategic raw materials that Ingvar has identified Approximately half of them depend on China
Overall if you look at energy dependencies and dependencies in general what do you think about the work being done in Sweden and the EU
If we start where we are I would like to say that both previous and the previous energy minister have been driven more by populism than by reflection
I would rather see experts in the field such as myself and Professor John Blomgren from the energy sector and Gustav Boetius the author with a background from the Energy Agency come in and input their knowledge into the system
If we had done as Janne did as Blomgren also says we would have done as he said from the beginning and then we wouldn't be in the situation we are in
Has Sweden become better at heeding this kind of warning
No we haven't We haven't at all It's just a short parallel here The past week turbulence at the Public Health Agency which is one of Sweden's most important emergency preparedness agencies
So all the information that claims Sweden has become better at handling second opinions and acting in a timely manner is information that should be considered as disinformation I actually have to say that
Sign up for web access for only 49 kronor the first month