What happened in HD 208487 ?

A Door to Mysteries
791 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
HD 208487, a star that's officially named Etonda, is a sun-like star about 15% larger
than the Sun in both mass and radius.
It currently hosts one confirmed exoplanet, though there are two other candidates around
the star that will be important for this video.
The confirmed planet is a gas giant with minimum mass around half that of Jupiter, and takes
130 days to orbit the star.
It was originally called HD 208487b, but was later named Mintome in 2019, after a mythical
The other two candidates in its system don't have official names yet, and so are designated
HD 208487c and d.
But something seems off with the HD 208487 system.
Assuming candidates c and d are real planets, then there's something strange going on with
their orbits.
Mintome is about 0.53 AU away from Etonda, while planet c is 1.94 AU away, and d is 2.54.
This means there's a very large gap between Mintome and planet c, larger than the distance
between Mercury and Mars.
Meanwhile, planets c and d are separated by only about 0.6 AU, closer to the distance
between Earth and Mars.
At face value, this doesn't seem too strange.
It's not like the solar system planets are evenly spread out.
Mercury and Venus are only 0.3 AU apart, while Mars and Jupiter are 4.
But the difference here is that HD 208487 isn't like the solar system.
As already mentioned, Mintome is a gas giant that is at minimum half as large as Jupiter,
or bigger than Saturn, around the distance where Mercury orbits the Sun.
Planet c is at least a third the mass of Jupiter around where Mars would be, making it a cool,
potentially Saturn-mass planet.
Planet d is around the distance of our asteroid belt and is at least 15% the mass of Jupiter,
making it a small gas giant or large ice giant.
In short, there are potentially three massive planets very close together, which is a very
different arrangement of planets in our solar system, and suggests that this system formed
differently from ours.
Because we know of thousands of exoplanets, we've seen enough stars to see some general
patterns emerge.
Most notably in this case, HD 10180, a system of 6 confirmed and 3 unconfirmed mini-Neptune
planets close to one another, a decently similar arrangement to the HD 208487 system.
HD 141399 is another similar case, hosting 4 Jupiter-sized planets in the inner system.
And in these two systems, almost all the planets have very circular orbits, with eccentricities
close to zero.
This is not true for Mintome, which has an eccentricity of 0.37, which means its orbit
is more of an oval shape than a circle.
This combined with the large gap between Mintome and planet c suggests that some kind of instability
may have occurred in the system to produce the current orbital arrangement.
In fact, the paper that proposes this even suggests that there may be unseen additional
planets in the system, and that during formation, its planets may have started out evenly spaced,
before some disaster destabilized the system.
And most interestingly, there's some evidence that Mintome formed violently, and the result
of collisions between smaller planets, the collisions of which were caused by this instability.
So what's happening in HD 208487?
Why is it different from other compact systems we've found?
Are there any additional planets we haven't found yet, and is Mintome an exoplanet formed
out of planetary collisions?
To answer these questions, we'll first need to know if planets c and d actually exist
or not.
Despite how I've been describing them in the video, they are still unconfirmed candidates,
not known to definitely exist.
However, both of them are likely to exist for a few reasons.
The biggest of them is that the paper, which I'll link in the description, that claims
to have discovered them also did an analysis of the star, and ruled out stellar activity
as a possible source for the signals.
Many planetary signals like this turn out to be stellar activity in disguise, which
is a major reason many planets are refuted, but we know this isn't the case here.
Photometric data looking at the brightness of the star over time also doesn't reveal
any signals relating to these planets, providing strong evidence that these signals were caused
by real planets orbiting the star.
Planets c and d, if real, would also be close to a 3-2 orbital resonance, something we expect
in compact planetary systems like this.
So while these planets are unconfirmed, I would bet on them being real, which is why
I'm confident enough to make this video in the first place.
I should also mention that there is a fourth candidate planet in the system that, if real,
would be between Mintel and Planet C, suggested by this paper.
But it's much less confirmed than the other two planets, and it doesn't seem to be important
for the purposes of this video, so we'll be skipping it.
So assuming all three planets are real, the next big question is how they got to their
current orbital arrangement.
And this is where things get interesting.
The paper also ran dynamical studies of the entire system to test potential formation
scenarios, and found that this system could have formed after the instability and destruction
of another.
More specifically, they proposed that the original HD208487 system could have been composed
of 6 Neptune-sized planets that were, for some reason, gravitationally scattered, causing
the system to become unstable and leading to the arrangement we see today.
Such a system is sometimes called a peas in a pod system due to their close distances
and similar sizes, and we found a few systems like it.
Trappist-1 is an example of such a system, having 7 planets roughly the same size, roughly
evenly spaced apart, and close together.
For an example around a larger star, there's Kepler-444, a system of 5 Mars-sized planets
around a very old K-type star 75% the mass of the Sun.
Kepler-444 itself is 11 billion years old, suggesting it is possible for systems like
this to remain stable for extremely long periods of time.
HD208487 is somewhere around 2 billion years old, likely younger than the solar system.
Just because some systems remain stable doesn't mean all of them do, and there are a ton of
factors that can destabilize a planetary system.
As I talk about my instability of the solar system video, something as simple as a passing
star altering Neptune's orbit by 1% can throw the entire solar system into chaos.
The paper suggests that an instability could have been caused by the dissipating of the
star's debris disk after the planets formed.
Essentially they propose a system of 6 ice giants form, relatively evenly spaced apart
from each other.
Due to interactions between the planets and the disk they orbit in, the planets are caught
into a resonance chain.
However, after the disk, which is mainly composed of gas, dissipates, this resonance chain is
broken, leading to chaos in the orbits of the planets.
So if this system used to have as many as 6 Neptune-sized planets in it, the obvious
question is what happened to all of them.
They suggest that after the resonance chain was broken, the planets either collided with
one another or got ejected from the system.
The paper ran several simulations of the system, and collisions between planets were fairly
common, though only about 20% of the simulations where collisions occurred resulted in the
system we see today.
That's about a 1 in 5 chance, which while not terribly likely, isn't so rare that we
can discount it as a possibility.
All of their other simulations resulted in instability after formation, and all of the
simulations led to planetary collisions occurring.
However, only 50% of simulations ended in a 3 planet system, and it's mentioned already,
only 20% led to a 3 planet system in the arrangement we see today.
So let's go over the scenario that resulted in the system that exists today.
HD 208487 forms with 6 ice giant planets.
After the debris dissipates, the orbital resonance of the planets break, and chaos unfolds.
The first, second, and third planets collide, resulting in a large gas giant on an eccentric
orbit mid-tome.
The fourth and fifth planets also collide, producing HD 208487-C. The sixth planet is
the only one left unscathed, becoming HD 208487-D. After this, the system returns to stability,
leaving the planets we see today.
If this scenario is what actually happened, it's pretty exciting.
Earth as we know it today formed out of the debris of 2 planets, Proto-Earth and Theia.
But in this system, mid-tome formed out of the debris of the collision of 3 separate
planets.
HD 208487-C, assuming it exists, also formed out of the debris of 2 different planets.
And HD 208487-D had nothing interesting happen to it.
This raises the question of moons around these planets.
The moon formed after Theia and Proto-Earth collided, so could something similar have
happened here?
Does mid-tome have a large moon system formed out of the dead remains of 3 different planets?
Unfortunately, mid-tome is very close to its star, so if it does have a moon system, it's
likely a small one, because the star will take away any moons that are on longer orbits.
But as I talked about in my Habitable Exa-Moons video, simulations of moon formation suggest
that the closer a planet is to its star, the larger its moons are on average.
Mid-tome may be a special case if it did form after a 3-planet collision, which could mess
things up, but it may be a possibility that it's one or two large, interesting moons.
Planets C and D are much further from the star, having orbits that last 2.5 and 3.8
years respectively, increasing their chances for large moon systems, but are also smaller
than mid-tome, decreasing their chances.
The study mentions the chances of exa-moons, saying that they didn't find any candidates
around any of the planets, but that doesn't mean they don't exist.
They mention the helispheres of both outer planets, the area around them where stable
orbits are possible, are more than large enough for big, interesting moon systems, so I wouldn't
rule them out.
This theory, unfortunately, is not confirmed.
We don't currently know for sure that planets C and D exist, and if they don't, then it
kind of ruins this entire idea.
And even if they do exist, the scenario I mentioned in this video of a 3-planet collision
forming mid-tome is still one scenario of many, and could be changed if additional planets
are found.
This paper assumes a 3-planet system, and if the weak evidence for a 4th planet turns
out to be true, it may need to be re-evaluated.
But for now, it does seem like there is a possibility that a very violent event occurred
in the HD 208487 system, resulting in two planets forming out of collisions, one of
which involved a collision with three separate planets.
If this is confirmed to be true, which it may not be, that would definitely make mid-tome
one of the most interesting exoplanets ever found, and this system one of the most noteworthy
we found.
Thank you for watching.
If you enjoyed, check out my other videos about exoplanets and space exploration.
