How hard should you exercise after a heart attack or after a diagnosis of atrial fibrillation?
In this video we try to answer those questions and there is one overarching message.
The risks of exercising are vastly lower than the risks of not exercising.
All the data shows that people who are sedentary and people whose fitness levels are lower
have much worse outcomes than people who continue to exercise.
And if people are anxious about continuing to exercise once they've had a cardiac diagnosis,
well you should actually be more anxious about not exercising.
Dr Peter Clarkson is a climber, cyclist and an NHS cardiologist based in Inverness
in the Scottish Highlands. In his first video, 13 in the Elder Athlete Series,
he explained the risks of training too hard too often.
More recently he explained why we should all do a Q-risk assessment to gauge our risk of a cardiac
event and how a CT scan can produce a similar risk score. This video is aimed at people who
have had a clear diagnosis, a heart attack or atrial fibrillation. It's not specific
individual advice, it's general advice on how to continue exercising.
About five years ago I had a mini heart attack. I started walking up a hill and I got 50 meters up a
tiny little slope and thought I've got really bad indigestion right in the middle of my chest.
But I also had pain behind my ears and in my jaw and thought yeah that that's not right.
Duncan McCallum is one of the founders of the climbing gym where Dr Clarkson trains,
however Duncan never expected to become his patient. After surgery to insert a stent,
Duncan received the usual cardiac rehabilitation. As Duncan explained in an earlier video he was
advised to monitor and moderate his heart rate. Before the heart attack I used to do quite a lot
heavy HIIT workouts, high intensity training and then also a lot of hill climbing on a road bike
where your heart rate, my heart rate at my age would be in the 160s mark and I was told right
your limit is 124 as a mean and don't go over 136. Hearing Duncan say that on video surprised Dr
Clarkson and prompted him to want to make this video. There's still variations in thinking across
cardiology practice whilst Duncan's been told keep his heart rate below 134 that's not the advice
that I would generally give so there is a variation in practice. The first step is usually a cardiac
rehabilitation program and these reduce hospitalizations, they improve patient recovery,
they reduce them and they reduce anxieties so people get back to exercising sooner going
through a structured cardiac rehabilitation program. Most people who've had a cardiac event
in the UK who will have an angiogram performed and that applies to most western countries. We
know what your coronary arteries look like, the worst areas the part that's caused a heart attack
is likely to be opened up by putting a intracoronary stent in the coronary artery to
improve the flow beyond that. Now a lot of what we do in terms of promoting what sort of exercise
levels people should do afterwards depends on is there a loss of narrowings elsewhere in your
coronary arteries, what's the extent of that and how much scar tissue there's been inside the heart.
There are three ways exercise can cause major problems after a heart attack according to Dr
Clarkson. A plaque can cause a blockage, this risk is usually moderated with drugs and lifestyle
changes. A narrowing in a different section of artery to which a stent was added and scar tissue
in the heart, a consequence of the attack which can cause rhythm disturbances. And so I think that
for me if people are keen athletic people want to get back to doing exercise and we know there's
persistent coronary artery disease, I like doing a treadmill, some form of exercise where we
monitor your cardiac, your heart for both its rhythm and whether there's ischemia. Ischemia
means a reduction of blood supply to the heart muscle. If your arteries are otherwise okay and
the blood supply is good into the blood vessel with no evidence of any rhythm disturbances,
then I think a lot of people can get back to complete normal, full normal exercise rather
than being capped towards an arbitrary heart rate. It's a pounding thing in your heart,
heart flickers if you like, you know you said somebody's walked over my grave sort of thing,
that was an expression I always heard. Alan Kimber is one of Scotland's most successful
mountain guides. He is now 79 and was diagnosed with atrial fibrillation around 2011. The first
episode came while guiding clients on a route in Glencoe. All of a sudden this great tiredness
came over me, gross tiredness which looking back was probably due to my heart rate going up or
something for some reason. It was a nice sunny day, we'd done most of the route, anyway so I
stopped, had a rest, made an excuse saying I wasn't feeling too good and carried on. Atrial
fibrillation doesn't kill people, it's a nuisance arrhythmia, it's unpleasant and it reduces your
ability to exercise when you have it. Now the majority of people who develop atrial fibrillation,
the initial bits of it is short bursts, it's called paroxysms, so that you get some atrial
fibrillation it then settles and that as time progresses the bursts get longer and they get
more frequent. Because Alan guided on big mountains like the Matterhorn that would be unsafe, so after
his second more prolonged AF episode he found himself in hospital with a line up an artery.
And when he introduced some adrenaline in I started twitching and he, ah, because he was
looking for a short circuit in the system which eventually found. So once he found it he went in,
they operate on some of the, some of the nerves or pathways within the heart and he said I think
you'll be fine now. Alan's case went from diagnosis to surgical intervention quicker than most because
of his work in extreme conditions which might have contributed towards the AF in the first place.
We do know that in people who do a lot of intense exercise that atrial fibrillation is more common
and I think that in people who are exercising very heavily who present with paroxysmal atrial
fibrillation we'll often have some discussion with them about what they want to do, do they
need to carry on exercising as intensely, do they want to cut back their exercise slightly
to modify the amount of atrial fibrillation you're going to get in the future.
Once you start getting atrial fibrillation the majority of people it does progress over time
and it comes to the point where there's a discussion about what treatments do we offer
and those treatments are based on how much these things are impacting your lifestyle.
Beta blockers are our commonest drug that we use in atrial fibrillation and a lot of athletic
people struggle when they're on beta blockers because they cap your level of aerobic exercise,
they reduce your maximum heart rate. So once you're getting more frequent there is consideration do
you do ablation procedures, electrical burning or freezing of parts of your heart to create
small scar lines to make it less likely to get atrial fibrillation in the future and what we
don't know is the people who then carry on exercising at high intensity after pulmonary
vein isolation are they more likely to get breakout other atrial fibrillation arising
from elsewhere in the future. As it stands at the moment there is no evidence to show that
people who carry on exercising are more likely to get problems after pulmonary vein isolation
than people who don't exercise. Alan isn't deliberately limiting his exercise, any
reduction is the result of age. I think about health quite a lot more now than I'm getting
older. I think about it, I don't let it stop me from trying to do things. The specialists have
suggested that I should do that, work within physical output range that feels sensible
because if you're constantly worrying about what happens you know is this going to make me
ill or more ill or whatever you're continually worrying about something so just get on with it
and do what you can. And that is close to what the cardiologists say too but in a video we have
to stress general advice simply cannot apply to each and every individual. Any individual watching
this who's had cardiac events should see their cardiologist and or general practitioner and
discuss the individual level of risk but for the majority of people I encourage people to get back
to complete normal full levels of exercise including some of the high intensity stuff
because the high intensity stuff is very beneficial as long as it's kept under
moderation you don't want all your stuff to be high intensity. Dr Clarkson has contributed to
two other videos, the first on how hard to train for heart health and more recently the video about
calculating your risk of a cardiac problem. Check them out here and I'll see you again next time, bye.