Top 6 Auto Insurance Companies

Auto Insurance
2 followers
Aug 24, 2025
Auto insurance is going crazy high and you want to shop around, right? Well, you should,
but who should you be shopping with? I got new information for you.
Premiums have gone up crazy amounts over the last several years and there are a lot of factors. I've
covered this in the past about how much the cost of used cars inflated, how much the cost of parts
is, shortage of body shop mechanics. All these things are factors. Now, tariffs on vehicles
pushing up the cost of repairs and insurers were not making money on their investments.
The way insurance works is they try to at least break even on insuring your home or your car
and then make money on the investments from the premiums. Well, what's happened in recent years,
a lot of big insurers have actually lost billions of dollars on just the policies themselves.
They've been scrambling to raise premiums to keep themselves solvent.
But the thing that I find the most interesting is something that came on my radar screen
two years ago. It's an annual report card on insurers done by body shops, which I find
fascinating because you got all these ads that the auto insurers, the big ones, run on TV
and some on social media, but still TV has been very popular as an outlet for insurers.
They're all trying to be cute in them and humanize a very dull product. Flow from
Progressive and Jake from State Farm, and then the Goofy guy from Liberty Mutual,
and then the Allstate Mayhem guy. What am I forgetting? Anyway, the ads run all the time.
Sometimes if you're watching a bad show or bad movie, the ad's more interesting and entertaining
than what you're watching potentially. I only see ads when I watch football. There's no football
right now except the UFL, which I've not found that exciting. Back to focus. Oh, sorry. I
immediately football. You saw that. My mind goes off into chaos, doesn't it? Can you imagine what
it would be like to have been one of my school teachers? It would be horrible, right? No.
Yes, it would have been. I'm sure you asked great questions. No, I didn't. I was staring out the
window. Except in economics class. That is true. Nerd alert. Anyway, so crashnetwork.com does this
list once a year where the body shop people warn each other and alert each other which insurers
are behaving and which aren't. And they get a grade from A plus to F. Now, they put out an
honor roll each year, which they include all the companies from A plus down to a solid B.
And what's fascinating on this list, there's almost not an insurer on here that is a name
that people routinely might recognize. Krista's insurer, Amica Mutual, came in 13 on the list
with a B plus. Wow. I'm surprised. They've usually been higher than that, haven't they? Well,
with the body shop, that's a good score. Auto owners, which is an insurer in some parts of
the country people are familiar with, came in 14. So by the way, that rating on Amica would be a
lucky 13 coming in 13th place? I guess so. With a B plus. And as to other brand names,
not a single big brand name makes the list. They're all smaller, not marketing-based insurers,
but smaller, boutique-y generally, service-based insurers. Why don't you run through the top 10?
I'm going to run through the top. I was going to run through all the A's and then have a link on
our notes where people can go to the full list. Perfect. How's that? In the episode notes. That's
amazing. Number one, North Carolina Farm Bureau, the only insurer in America that gets an A plus
from body shops, meaning that they're cooperative with the body shop. They want to do what's right
for the customer. That's what this is about. The only A went to Chubb, which is a rich people's
insurer. And then Acuity Insurance got an A minus, don't know who they are. Michigan Farm Bureau,
Alpha Mutual, and Erie Insurance. Those are the only people who got an A minus, A or A plus.
Then the B pluses, Pure Insurance, another insurer for rich people. Grinnell Mutual,
with a AIG private client, another rich people insurer. Mutual of Enumclaw, E-N-U-M-C-L-A-W,
what is that? Farm Bureau, Property Casualty, Wisconsin Mutual, and I already mentioned
Amica Mutual. The first well-known recognized brand name of a regular insurer, Amica Mutual,
the only one in the top 13. You can see the full list of all no-name insurers that actually do a
good job for their customer. They're not spending money, a zillion dollars on cute advertising.
They're just insuring people. And so, if you want to go to our link, easy,
or you just go to crashnetwork.com. And I love this list because what do people do when they're
shopping, when they get, most people are with these big insurers. And when they get a big
premium increase from one, the only places they go for quotes are the other big insurers.
Big mistake, big mistake for your wallet. Oh, and while I'm at it, when you're shopping for a car
with how expensive auto insurance has gotten, shop insurance quotes before you buy a brand
that you're unfamiliar with. Because there's enormous gaps now in the cost of insuring
different brands and models. So, you might have in your funnel, your funnels, the vehicles you're
interested in considering, you might have three or four different models. If you see what they
quote out for auto insurance, you may decide that the third one is a better choice than one, two,
or four, because the insurance costs could be so very different.
