Researching David Martin's Portrait of Dido Belle and Lady Elizabeth Murray

La Beautes
153 followers
There has been much discussion about the clothing, posture and accessories of Dido Bell.
Some speculate that her dress, accessories and even stance were chosen to emphasise her
ethnicity and difference from her cousin, Lady Elizabeth Murray. However, the recent
attribution of the painting to the accomplished Scottish portraitist David Martin by Philip Mould
opened up a completely new avenue of research. We, the Crow's Eye Productions team of Nick,
Pauline and Liv, studied as many of the paintings attributed to David Martin online as we could find
and began to see patterns emerging. Philip Mould, in Fake or Fortune, described Martin's
signature technique as the brilliance with which he could layer transparent gauzy fabrics over
This must have been something the artist relished and he may have had a selection
of sheer textiles in his studio for use. We certainly spotted one identical sheer,
grey and silver striped silk in three different portraits and many others very similar.
Of the images available for us to study, many of Martin's portraits show the sitters wearing very
similar wrapping gowns to Dido, so similar that it left us speculating if the gown belonged
in the artist's studio. Another sitter was also wearing a turban.
Of course, a painting is not a photograph and many elements such as colour and embellishments
may simply be down to the artist's imagination and skill. However, there is nothing in this
observation to suggest that Dido's dress was chosen to emphasise her ethnicity,
but plenty to suggest that this may have been an artistic preference on the part of Martin,
possibly arrived at through discussion with the sitters. Perhaps Dido was simply more
adventurous in her choice of garment than Elizabeth, or it could be that the artist
relished the contrasts of colours, textiles and shapes that he could achieve in this rare
double portrait if the women were dressed differently. Further study of the paintings
revealed something Philip Mould also observed, the repeated gesture of the hand raised to the face
and fingers resting on the cheek. In all the other portraits featuring this,
the woman's elbow is raised on something and her hand resting against her face.
Perhaps that was Martin's original plan, but Dido is left somewhat curiously
appearing to point to her face rather than resting her hand against it.
However, any awkwardness is mitigated by Dido's charming and slightly mischievous smile.
Most interestingly, we observed a textile, or at least surface decoration,
that occurs in five portraits. It is a repeating pattern of alternating gold beads and gold beaded
flowers. It appears on three wrapping gowns, on a silk textile wrapped around an infant,
and on Dido's turban. Suddenly Dido's dress seems much more of a reflection of the artist's
skills and imagination than it was anything to do with the colour of Dido's skin.
Dido appears much like any other fashionable young woman painted by David Martin.
Whether the textile once existed in David Martin's studio or not,
it certainly could not be purchased today. So Liv hand embroidered the gold beads onto a turban
length of silk, while Pauline busied herself creating a near exact copy of the wrapping gown
as possible. To achieve the unusual glacial white of the gown, Pauline lined the cream silk with a
pale green silk. Like every other layer of the clothing in the film, attention to detail matters.
However, Pauline decided not to match Elizabeth's clothes to the portrait, as it is unlikely that
Dido and Elizabeth would have sat together for any length of time to be painted. There is also
an element of Elizabeth's dress that worried Pauline. The white transparent overlayer, separate
from her pinafore, looks as though it was added by the artist to soften the colour and to make the
overall composition more aesthetically pleasing. It is not something she had seen before on an
18th century dress. The underlying pink silk seemed to have small posies of flowers woven into it,
like a Spitalfield silk, another aspect that would have been beyond our budget to reproduce exactly.
Liv also studied and recreated the women's jewellery, observing that, as Lady Elizabeth's
pearls crossed over at the front, they were a single length of pearls wrapped twice around her
neck. We even went to Schoon Palace to study the actual painting, which revealed, in the surface
texture, details not visible in the digital image. We three spent a great deal of time pacing back
and forth in front of the painting, watching how the light picked out the surface details.
Liv could see Lady Elizabeth's hair in much more detail, which enabled her to recreate her hairstyle
and Dido's with more accuracy. Nick studied the painting to understand the artist's approach
and how she might recreate Dido and Elizabeth's postures with actors at the film location.
What struck all three of us most, though, was the presence of Dido Bell and Lady Elizabeth.
The love and friendship between the two cousins just radiated from the canvas.
