How do Makers Produce Museum-Quality Replicas?

Ancient Swords
6 followers
Aug 23, 2025
Tod presented a talk at the Wallace Collection Arms and Armour Summer School last month. This is a copy of the lecture, particularly displaying a recreation of the A728 German Steel Rondel Dagger that Tod made for the Wallace Handling Collection.
Hi it's Tod from Tod's Workshop and Tod Cutler here and I'm down at the Wallace Collection again
but this time it's a really important thing for me. They've asked me to give a lecture as part
of their adult education summer season on my thoughts on reproduction weaponry so I'm about
to go in and do that now but unfortunately it's not possible to film the event so I'm going to
go back to base and I'm going to film it in front of the logo and you'll all get to see what I was
Hi my name's Tod and I'm from a company called Tod's Workshops and we make reproduction items. I love
making things, I have always loved making things and it doesn't really much matter what. I found
my way here but I got here through product design which I started about 30 years ago, did that
professionally for a few years then I moved into the world of special effects which was I have to
say quite a lot more fun but at the same time I started reenacting and I wasn't able to buy
knives at the time so full workshop started making my own and about 23 years ago Tod's
Workshop was born. The company's split into a few different parts really so Tod's Workshop does
historical commissions for reenactors, collectors, martial artists, museums, a little bit of film and
tv really on that kind of side. Then we have Tod Cutler which is like the budget versions of the
same thing so they're a little bit more productionized, allows the prices to be kept really
so that's great. Then we have the Tod's Workshop side where I do sort of props and
real weapons for film and tv. I don't tend to like making props you know MDF and plastic,
it's not my kind of material. It means that I don't actually do that much for film and tv
but when I do whether it's fantasy or whether it's real I want to make it like a real weapon
because I think that's what translates the best. So those massive you know 50 kilo dwarven axes
from Lord of the Rings or something, not my thing. And then of course the last part of what
I do are YouTube films. Today's talk is going to be about making reproduction weaponry and I'm going
to use this dagger here that I made a reproduction of for the Wallace for their handling collection
and I'm going to use that to illustrate some of the points but I've got other pieces here as well
that illustrate other points during the talk but the first thing and this is a headline spoiler
is when I'm asked to make a reproduction I almost never make what the customer asks for
but we'll unpack that one later. So the first question to ask when you're making a reproduction
like this is actually what are you trying to make and it sounds kind of like an odd question because
obviously I'm trying to make a reproduction of that dagger that's in the museum case but what's
really important to how you go about the whole project is how accurate how good do you want that
reproduction to be so you could make a super accurate super meticulous copy of the piece that
is in the museum every scratch every crack every dent everything replicated as well as the
dimensions and the portions and the shapes. Now that becomes a very laborious very slow process
but the next approach which is the one that I tend to favour is that I will make the piece
and I'll take the major dimensions the forms the proportions and so on have my set of photographs
everything that I've got on the bench and then I just make it and the thing is what it feels
like for me is that when I just make a piece the work flows and there might ultimately be
slight differences in in what I make and what the original museum is but that's a price I'm
willing to pay because the work at the end of it has a reality to it a fluidity a realness
that you can lose when you're doing it like vernier by vernier tiny little measurement because
then it becomes well it can become very stilted and very sterile so when I make a piece I just
make it and then the third way is that superficially it's similar to the one in the
museum so you know from five meters away you go yeah it's the same knife you put them side by side
and you can begin to see differences the route that I usually take is you put them side by side
and you look at them you go yeah same knife and then when you really start to study it yeah then
you'll find differences but it's the way that you approach that that makes it an incredibly slow job
or a real job and I like the real job and one of the major things that you have to get through
in that client customer relationship is the expectation what I'm going to deliver what
you're going to receive so when these pieces were originally made they were just made by some guy at
a bench there might have been a little sketch on a bit of paper there would not be in a dimension
drawing there might have been a verbal brief a written brief there might have even been an
example on a bench to copy it might be like that one that you did last year of the bob that's the
kind of level of information that people had and they just worked to that pattern so even when you
get a piece like this where there's quite a few of these of basically exactly this form in existence
they're ostensibly the same dagger but actually you put them side by side and they're all different
because people made it by free hand they just made the pieces and that is how I like to work
it's how I get the best effect so the real secret to making a piece like this is that you have to
identify and capture the essence of the piece in the first place so how does it feel how does it
look and that's not just a body of dimensions it's just the flow of the work that's gone into it
so you find the major dimensions you find the forms and the shapes and the decoration sets and
then you just make it ultimately like I said there might be slight differences but the thing is what
you end up with is a piece that you can believe in and it's a piece that if it was transported
back 500 years would not look out of place on a table it doesn't have to be super amazing it
doesn't have to be super detailed covered in gold whatever it is although some of these pieces are
you just want a piece that blends in and that is when you are really capturing the essence of a
piece so how do I get the information to make a piece like this well obviously the absolute gold
standard is to be able to go into a museum and to measure it look at it examine it photograph it
make notes do little things about construction whatever it is that is going to allow you to go
home and to make this piece perfectly but that is not always possible so a great deal of my work is
made from pictures now you can pull pictures off the web and out of books and museum catalogs and
things but there's almost inevitably never enough you're going to get little bits of information
and it's usually little bits of information that accompany that and it might be a blade length
an overall length that kind of thing very occasionally you get weights points of balance
but those are quite unusual so really you have reasonably put not remotely enough information to
make a piece like this so you have to imagine and you have to interpret now in the case of this piece
here I was actually sent a body of pictures by the Wallace collection that they took especially for
the project I didn't have enough time to go in and examine it and it was all covered I had a few
dimensions on that were more than the normal ones a couple here and here but what I didn't have for
instance was that picture there underneath and that's really key to the manufacture of this but
we'll come to that later but so you are always missing information sometimes you just work from
a single picture and it's really quite pixelated or grainy or out of focus whatever it may be so
you have to use your imagination and your knowledge of other pieces to fill in the gaps but the other
thing that you need to do is to remember that these were tools for soldiers tools for knights
and any tool that does not function in the way it's supposed to is not a tool that would have
been made and used would have been thrown away recycled whatever so if it's not functioning
correctly you have got something wrong so in many respects I had a lot of information for this piece
so it was relatively easy to replicate and replicate accurately but of course I'll often
end up being sent a picture or I see a picture and I want to replicate from that and then we end up
with pieces like this Italian rondel here and so you can never actually say that it's a true
reproduction because there's no way of really knowing but what you can say is it's a good
visual facsimile of what was in that painting and again I can make it like a tool and if it's a tool
it's going to work and it will be plausibly correct so coming back to this dagger we had
a good but not complete set of dimensions from it and that means that everything else needs to be
scaled now of course scaling it you might think on the surface is a relatively easy thing it's
it's a simple mathematical job right got it we can all do it but the difficulty comes is that
every piece of this has four different possible sizes so for instance if I go in and measure it
I'll measure the blade measure all that lovely I've got my set of data that I write down presuming
I don't make a mistake then of course you've got the museum data that they've written down all
their measurements and you have to presume that they haven't made mistakes they might have done
now if I look at the museum photographs I can take something like a blade because I've got the
information from the museum says the blade's 28 centimeters long and I can scale from that but
then I might have my photographs and I use those to scale from the blade and create data sets from
now the difficulty is that they might all be different so let's unpack that so quite simply
when it comes to me measuring or museum staff measuring is we can all make mistakes and you
have to accept that any number that you're looking at might not actually be correct and especially
when your measurements don't match their measurements and then you have problems with cameras
and cameras bodies I assume I don't technical enough in this area to know but I assume that
the actual way the camera processes the image can distort things slightly but the lens certainly does
and also where the camera is over the piece because if it's absolutely dead center well that's fine
this area here will be replicated in your photograph absolutely brilliant but the further
you go out from side to side and of course the longer it is like a sword the more this is the
case you get a foreshortening of the object so actually you can end up with a picture of a sword
where the camera is let's say over the guard you now take the blade and you scale from that and
you end up with a different scale size for the grip than the actual real object is and of course
your camera when you take your photographs might be in a different distance from the object it
might have been a different way left or right and that's going to distort the image as well when I
say that there are four different possibilities basically if you are scaling from imagery or
scaling from the data that they've given or that you've made or whatever else there's lots of
different options what that number can actually be and so in the case of this saber which is the
a479 from the wallace I made the original and I did some scaling on it and when actually I took
it into the museum and I examined it side by side the original my grip was about five millimeters
too short I think I can't quite remember but it was just a scaling issue it was as simple as that
that was the day that I actually first realized the implication of where the camera was when the
photos were taken but another good example is this rapier from the Met Museum and this one was listed
as on the website I believe 1.2 pounds now that's exceptionally light for a rapier I made the
reproduction I made it as a tool as a working tool and I came through at about 2.2 pounds really my
only conclusion from that is there's a transcription error and that they dropped one of the pounds out
of the system it happens we all make mistakes but it means that you can never quite trust the data
so even when you have what you might consider to be hard data it's kind of never really much better
than medium hard take it with a pinch of salt does it work does it work as a tool really important
to keep remembering that so let's put this rapier down and we're going to get back to our wallace
dagger that I replicated for them we're going to go through a little fantasy scenario here
so let's just say as is often the case of me I only had one picture to work from and it was a
picture like that from the front so what can we infer from that picture well the first thing that
I know and oh and there's no no accompanying script with it so I know nothing about it
except that one picture now we know that this is a fighting dagger for armoured fighting and that
means that you're going to have a grip length that's going to accommodate a corner it's going
to be about 110 millimetres somewhere around there so that gives us with no other information
a datum point that we can scale from so now we can scale all other dimensions that this dagger
from that now even if there's bits from that are behind like for instance this downturn there maybe
it wasn't completely clearly shown again you can start to look for uh sort of tone changes um colour
changes in the imagery just little hints of a line even if it's a little blurred or out of focus
look for the things which are hidden look up similar objects on the web and it will begin
to fill in the gaps and begin to show you what's going on in the bits that you can't see but again
with our one picture here from the front I can see that there is no central rib down that blade
so that means that this blade has to be square or triangular well square blades exceptionally
unusual on rondels triangular blades on German rondels of this period relatively common so it's
given that it's going to be a triangular blade so we're already building up quite a lot of
information about this piece just from one picture now we also know and we'll come back to it later
that this pommel is most likely to be hollow but this one is too thin to be hollow so it's going
to be solid piece we have a conical handle here well lathe work wasn't a thing really for this
sort of thing so I know that that is going to be rolled up out of sheet and forge welded to
create a seam on it that could be relatively thin maybe about one millimeter something like
that maybe a touch more so we've got that and then we come to this top disc here it is going
to be hollow and the reason for that is it's a tool because if that was a solid piece of metal
it's going to be very unwieldy in the hand it's heavy and cumbersome to wear it clunks around
it'll even hurt when it just taps against you if you're running or something like that and it's
likely to turn upside down in the scabbard now the last thing that we know is that this top disc
here it's a big area so even if I can't see it from my picture I know it's going to be decorated
and the reason I know it's decorated is no renaissance anything pretty much or medieval
anything that big is going to be left undecorated on a weapon that is going to have something on it
now again with my lens distortion it's just possible I can sort of see just over the brim
of that and get a hint of what that decoration is if I can't then I have no choice but just to choose
some geographically chronologically suitable decoration and apply that but what I do know
and what would be wrong is that will be decorated and putting nothing there would be incorrect
so again from our single fantasy picture we know how wide and long the blade is we know how thick
that material is it's not going to be brass you're going to be able to tell that even in black and
white so it's going to be steel we've got dimensions on the handle we know roughly how thick the handle
is going to be let's say 1.2 millimeter sheet something like that and then we come to this
I am certain that it is going to be hollow it's it's just a given on something like this
but the bottom part is quite structural quite curved and that means it can be relatively thin
so keep the weight down so that could be 0.8 one millimeter thick something like that the top part
if that was one millimeter thick it's going to be very vulnerable for denting and distortion and so
on so they're going to go thicker so it's going to be 1.2 1.5 so even though I'm not taking this
just looking at that one single picture I've been able to infer an awful lot of information
even the things that I don't know about and even the things that I can't see and two good examples
of can't see is at the top here so I can't see that the original of my one picture has a peen
washer on it but I am almost certain it's going to have one and the reason for that is that if
you put a thin tang through a thin sheet like this and you try and peen it down it's going to
distort that sheet and there's no reason they had to do that sometimes it wouldn't it wouldn't
have impinged the functionality and sometimes they just don't care but it's an easy fix for them to
do put a peen washer in so again I can't see it but I kind of know it's there and then we come to
the way that this top rondel is put together you've got two two pieces of steel and you've got
an edge that's going around it now if you're looking at that photograph those two pieces
could have been welded or they could have been brazed those are two standard ways of making a
hollow pommel like this but they very often leave a little witness a little discoloration line a
little bit of texture a little bit of porosity whatever it may be but there's hints that
something's going on along that seam line but the picture I have shows none of that and so I know
that there's only one other method that this really would have been put together and that's
crimping what you do is you take the top disc starts flat you turn down the edge of the top
disc a little bit put the bottom disc in and you tap it over and you mechanically connect the two
and what that will then do is it will give you a clean line around here there will be no marking
there'll be no color change because it's the same piece of metal that's forming the top and so it's
just completely smooth unblemished you know that this knife from that one picture was crimped and
whenever I'm presented with a picture to replicate that's exactly what I do I sort of pour over all
the little details trying to get as much information as I can about it from the pictures I'm given
of course I'll go and look on the web and find stuff but very often that's quite difficult to do
especially if the picture sort of comes to you anonymously with no context
take your time work through all the little details try and work out how it is manufactured
and of course working from actual modern photographs it's not necessarily straightforward
but there's a methodology to it since you start working from artwork you have to think a little
differently and so if we come to this dagger here it's not necessarily harder to make but it's
because you have so much less information so again on the painting you can look at the guy
who's wearing it he was not wearing armor he was in civilian dress so I suppose you could argue
that this is kind of like a poncing about town kind of a dagger it's unlikely to be a full-on
military dagger the hilt itself was black and it could either be let's say buffalo horn well there's
a lot of that in Italy or it could be ebony now ebony is prone to splitting but also unprotected
like this guard and this pommel is it's going to be quite vulnerable so I've made the assumption
and I don't know it for a fact but I'd be fairly sure that that guy's dagger was originally
horn and then you've got a gold in this case bronze could have been either for the painting
fretwork so you're laying those panels into it and again you just have to find a way you can't
know from that picture how that fretwork was done but you do a fretwork that you can manufacture
and will give the next you know the visual result you're looking for but then the guy's dagger when
he was wearing it as well there was a fitting up at the top here too indistinct to make anything out
but you could see that it was a bronze fitting same with the shape very long and thin scabbard
this was a high status piece so I decided to make you know an interesting high status blade so we've
got a rondel blade here and it is all rondel there's you know it's it's not thin and pretend
and flimsy it's all proper the rondel world it's probably a little delicate up at the tip
you get them but nonetheless you end up with something that is really fancy showy high status
and looks like the one in the picture so is this a reproduction where you can't say that it is
but you can say that it is a plausible piece that fits with what we know so let's go back to the
wallace dagger and I'll go through how I made this piece most of the work that I do is stock removal
it's not forging so I started with a round bar of spring steel but something especially that's round
and relatively thin if you're grinding like I grind most of my blades like a diamond blade
it's going to turn in your hand as you're going through it's going to be unavoidable
and it's not going to come through flat so I grind the blade vertically going down the
linear shield like that and to get an equilateral triangle which again is a very difficult thing to
forge you can rough forger it but not precisely you just keep grinding and measuring until every
face is exactly the same and then you will end up with a completely pure uh equilateral triangle
the bottom guard again it's relatively straightforward because it's just thin
sheet drill a hole punch a hole down to recess the handle into it so you get a nice clean joint
there do a bit of firework here and then just hot bend that little flange down so that's
really pretty basic stuff now in the case of the handle here they forged welded it with probably
more skill than I've got and I took a different approach so I turned that out of a piece of steel
ironically enough the steel tube is electrically welded so it starts as flat sheet it's rolled
around electrically welded to become a tube so in terms of manufacture in many ways not
significantly different to this but then of course I turned that profile down on it
to get this taper the original piece had all of the decoration put into it I think probably
chiseled and then cleaned up with a file because you can see a little bit of both
I just used a bar top disc well that's you know pretty pretty simple stuff it is one millimeter
material so you take a pipe basically because you can see you put this bulge down in the middle
take a pipe and you just dome that piece down into the pipe the sides of it are gonna flare
up it's just the way the sheet material works and you end up with basically exactly the shape
if I had just folded that over bent the edges around and then wrapped it over the edge of the
at 1.5 millimeter thick material you're going to get a 1.5 mil step and I didn't want that I wanted
it to be cleaner than that so I tapered the edge down and that does two things it makes the
turnover much easier and then when actually it does get over and underneath then it makes a much
cleaner joint here so we've ended up with I'm going to say 0.3, 0.4 millimeter joint now
interestingly on the original I wasn't able to see that view and I wasn't able to go back into
the museum to examine it and what they did at that point is they actually had a slight joggled
joint so a slightly knocked down joint on this piece here so when the two pieces came in they
pretty much aligned so you got on the original piece just a slightly cleaner joint than I did
here nothing wrong with this and they certainly did it but that actually of everything that I did
is where it drifts furthest away from the original piece of the museum and then it came time for me
to put it together so everything fitted everything was square and lovely but I filled the handle with
glue and I did that just like I am almost certain they did it so they would have used cutler's resin
so rosin pitch dust I used an epoxy resin but make no mistake about it it is not a structural part
it is not a required thing to keep this dagger in one piece it is simply there to remove any
possibility of movement squeaks rattles that sort of thing because don't forget I'm a commercial
enterprise so in my case it's required because I don't want this to be in the middle of America
and suddenly for something to slightly move they did it well because they wanted to for whatever
reason but again plenty of times they didn't but that knife is so tight after 500 years I am certain
that they backfilled that handle can't say for sure but I'll put a lot of money on it so as well
as the actual manufacture of the piece I think it's really important to talk about what the customer
is expecting so first of all I have two kinds of custom work that I do the pieces like this ale
house dagger here which I've made for myself to put into stock and I'm then at liberty to make
whatever changes I want and then pieces like this Met Museum rapier here where the customer has been
very specific about what he wants and it's my job to try and interpret that try and interpret
what he wants and what I'm going to deliver and to try and marry those two things up so that we
it's a real thing that the customers ask for something and very often I don't give them what
they ask for but they're very rarely unhappy with what I give them so of course as the supplier it's
my job to try and make my customers happy but I've learned that if you give your customers what they
ask for they often end up unhappy so as I've already explained I like to just make a piece
I think that's what flows best and gives you the end result but of course it does mean that errors
can come in so let's just say I make one piece two millimeter too big at the beginning then by
the time I've kept my proportions and my shape the same and everything looks kind of the same
it ends up being four millimeters out at the end but I think those areas are worth
handling because I think the end result is really beneficial for it but then of course I can just
purely quite simply make mistakes just like they did too and if I replicate a piece I might make
a different mistake to the guy who originally made it so there will be something in the spirit
of what he's done what I've done that's exactly the same but the exact detail of whatever that is
might be slightly different and then of course I can make changes deliberately now that's easy when
it's a piece for me so this alehouse dagger for instance the original piece has guards that come
down sort of I don't know what you call them crab claw guards or something like that they
swoop right down here but they're plain and they're made of what looks to be bent six millimeter
rod pug ugly piece from the royal armories so most of that dagger is exactly as the royal armories
piece is I changed the guard now the thing is when I can avoid it I don't like making pug ugly
and there's this assumption that everything that's in a museum was beautifully crafted
proportioned detailed and all the lines flowed and everything was just a thing of beauty again
look in the museums but don't just look at the piece and wonder at it look at the piece is it
nice and a lot of pieces aren't it's quite clearly the case that they were not if I can change detail
sympathetically chronologically that works and it's not part of what the customer requirement is
then I will do that so a good example of that for instance coming back was the guard on this
uh alehouse dagger but another really good example is this balustrino here which is very loosely
based on a piece in the royal armory but the royal armory's piece has a little rectangular
trigger block here with a couple of slot head screws in it holding the whole thing together
for all the world it just looks like an industrial micro switch stuck on top of a bit of beautiful
renaissance engineering and it looks even though it's period out of place and this is a stock item
for me if somebody buys this what I want and what they want is to be able to get it and to look at
it oh that's fabulous and when their friends come in they can show it off and their friends go oh
that's fabulous what they don't want is to put it out the box and go oh what's that micro switch
doing on there and their friends walk in and go that's nice but what's all that about it doesn't
work and it's those sort of changes that I'll make but they're always made if I do it sympatheticly
so I changed the trigger system on this balustrino to not be so weird and prominent and to be a bit
more flowing and a bit more in line with what I felt looked good for the piece but of course it's
but then if we come back again to this rondel here quality of finish on the original was
all right but it wasn't great and it had loads of scratches here and here file marks file gouges
where it hadn't been decently polished because it's kind of hard to get into and it presumably
just wasn't required the overall look of the piece looked great functioned great they didn't worry
about it too much but there is this modern perception that because it's in a museum because
it's a bit interesting because it's been put on display that it is some thing of magnificent
beauty that the craftsman would not stop until it was just perfect in every way and we look at it
and that's what we think but actually when you really look at it you can see that that's clearly
not the case that craftsman then like now has deadlines and bills to sort out they just made
the work they didn't overthink it they didn't over polish it they just made the piece presented it
and it was bought and loved for what it was so historically these little blemishes and
mistakes and bad detailing whatever else weren't that important they weren't concerned with it
that much they were really concerned with function does it work as intended will it keep working as
intended will it break those are really important questions does it do the job that you want it for
what wasn't so important was is there a slight asymmetry to the guard is there a slip in the
those were not that important and the original of it of the stagger in the wallets is absolutely
fascinating because it has a detail that i hadn't seen before but it's brilliant and it has a crack
running from guard all the way down to tip all the way along the blade and the thing is that
crack didn't spontaneously arrive sometime after it was bought it wasn't a crack that was made
during use that crack was there when the piece was made and really importantly it was there when the
piece was bought and the guy paid good money for it and he looked at that dagger and he went
lovely i'll have it he bought the thing crack and all it wasn't a concern because it wasn't
structural but of course that kind of detail would be that kind of detail that kind of crack
imperfection would be an unsellable item now but you see that a lot with original swords and so on
but the guard and the blade and the handle and the pommel never ever from day one really fitted
that well and again if you look at um your oak shop's books he'll come across swords where they've
rammed a bit of copper or lead or wood up into the guard just to tighten everything up the thing is
if you've got a bit of lead wedged into your guard day one sword fight one things are going to start
moving and so when we get obsessed about a rattle these days or a slight movement or a guard that's
a little bit squiffy these are things that they just didn't care about and we know that they
didn't care about them because so many of their objects exhibit that and another good example of
that is this pit river stiletto here so this is a high status piece high status people tended to own
them but the guard is about three or four millimeters asymmetric one side to the other
it's bigger you can see it but only a little bit but the thing is it was made like that it was
bought like that it was loved like that and that is really how we know that they didn't seem to
because so much of it is like that so they're absolutely concerned with the structure of a
piece but they were also concerned of course with what it looked like but perhaps not in the way you
think because if we take a piece like this italian rondel again you know you wear your money you
wear your status this is the side the side of me the side of my weapon that i show to the world
and that's the impression they want to give well any money you spend on the back side is not spent
on the front side so the back of weapons the back of scabbards lockets that sort of thing
is often much worse finished than the front because it's not important but again what does
it look like at three meters four meters five meters that seems to be what they're concerned
about so when you look at a piece in a museum and you've got this much distance between you and the
actual object itself that's probably much closer than people peered at it in reality because you
know if you're a lord or something like that you're not going to have people coming up and
just looking at your waistband going oh could i just have a look at that oh very nice oh they
missed a bit here that's not what it was does it look good from a distance does it look good
from the camera to me here and the answer is yes it does and that is what they're concerned with
because i know that because when you look at the close-up detail of things like an absolute classic
again is the guard on the a489 which is another german longsword in the wallace collection that
guard it's asymmetric it's crude and especially on the back side of it the engraving is all over
the place loads of slips incomplete certainly not straight certainly not flowing the work on that
guard can't really be described as anything other than a bit crap but it's in the museum and it's
seen and it's loved and it's iconic and we all think it's fabulous but look at the craftsmanship
it's not so another fantastic example of this is the writhen hilted sword from the royal armoury
an incredibly iconic piece but the hilt and the pommel have got casting pits and casting flaws
in them they've got holes in them now they could have filled those holes and gilded over it they
didn't they just gilded over the holes and left them and the blade itself is just a cracker so
the blade it's not been damaged through use it's not been over sharpened that's basically what it
was it's got center line that bends and at the worst case you've got about 35% of the flat on
one side of the center line 65% on the other but this was a high status piece you know it was well
made a late 15th century well made german sword presumably by some very good cutlers owned by a
very good man but he looked at it couldn't miss that blade and he went brilliant it's in the
scabbard most of the time when it's not in the scabbard it's flying through the air going for
your face or whatever it is does it look good from a distance the answer is yes does it look
good from here not at all and the thing is i've made reproductions of that but if i made the
reproductions like the original it would be thrown straight back and that's what's really interesting
and that's why i don't make what people ask for because when somebody asks for a reproduction
that sword they're not asking for a reproduction that sword if you gave them that they'd be
what they're asking for is the image of that sword that has been created and constructed
within their head what it is that they think it is and somewhere and that's what's fascinating
somewhere between the object in the museum and those little photons of light coming into their
eyes and then your synapse is doing your thing in your brain it has been metamorphosized into
something far better than the thing that is over there so i've done reproductions of the german
longsword the 489 and the wallace as well and i had to sanitize that guard i had to make it
symmetrical clean up the carving on it clean up the engraving on it because if i delivered what's
actually in the museum it would not work for the customer so it is that fine line of trying to work
out what it is and to deliver it that is just as hard just as hard as the actual manufacturer and
it's taken me years to get to grips with it and you don't always get it right and you don't always
hit the nail on the head but i usually do but remember when you ask for a museum copy it is not
what you want it's clear because what we're all looking for now is a crisp blade with crisp
center lines smooth edges no increasing decreasing uh thicknesses no wobble to the blade edge all of
these things are in pretty much all of the museum example what we want is something that's been
clearly made by man the odd little stray mark or whatever it may be you can see that it's handmade
it hasn't just been 3d printed or cnc but where is that line because by very definition i make a
reproduction but by making it cleaner and better which is what i try and do than the original was
you are not making a reproduction of it and it's a real interesting situation so that was it i hope
you enjoyed the talk it was uh not against the clock this one so probably i put a bit more content
in fact in than i did when i was actually at the wallace but it is my heartfelt feeling about all
this and and that's the presentation that i was giving that it's an absolutely fascinating area
to work in and just it's fascinating way it's fascinating structurally how did they make these
pieces why did they make them like they did why did they make those choices all of that is really
interesting but the other side is none of us need this stuff in the way that they needed it then you
might spiritually need it but you don't need it to fight in a battle and so our requirements become
different our experience of modern manufacture clouds what it is we think we should be getting
for our 800 pounds 2 000 pounds 4 000 pounds i hope you've enjoyed it and i'll see you again
but don't forget we've got a second youtube channel which is todd cutler we've got primary
one todd's workshop oh cutler tends to deal with sort of niche stuff more museum things book reviews
tool reviews whatever whatever i fancy doing at the time then we've got patreon of course and we've
got our two websites so if you've enjoyed this like this kind of stuff you'll find it on our
website and i hope you've enjoyed it but anyway see you again bye
