To address California’s housing shortage, lawmakers in Sacramento are considering SB 79, a bill that would allow taller apartment buildings in neighborhoods currently reserved for single-family homes.
The measure is intended to add housing options, shorten commutes, and make better use of existing infrastructure. But this has also led to discussion of local control and how cities can manage growth.
In this episode, former Torrance City Councilmember Mike Griffiths and Nolan Gray, senior director of Legislation and Research at California YIMBY, offer different perspectives on what SB 79 could mean for California communities.
There's a new potential law in California
that would allow up to six-story buildings
in residential neighborhoods
as long as they have public transit.
This law, along with other laws that have passed,
created a lot of density, has worried the community.
At the same time, affordability in California right now
for homebuyers is at the lowest,
and only 18% of Californians can afford
to buy a home right now
with the current mortgage rates and housing costs.
Our guests today are Mike Griffiths,
who was serving a city council in Torrance for a decade.
He's concerned where these laws are headed
and how his community could be significantly impacted
from what it used to be to today.
We also talked to Nolan Gray,
whose organization is behind a lot of these laws
that have been passing on higher density.
We hear from both to find out what's happening.
I'm Siamak Kourami.
Welcome to California Insider.
Mike, it's great to have you on.
Welcome back.
Siamak, I'm really pleased to be back again.
We want to talk about SB 79, which is a new law.
It hasn't passed yet,
but it's in the process in California
that would allow building in residential neighborhoods,
up to six-story buildings,
if they're close to bus stops and places of transit.
Can you tell us what's happening with this law?
Right now, SB 79 is a new bill
going through the state legislature.
It's already gone through the California Senate.
The Senate approved it,
barely passed through the Senate by one vote.
It's now moved into the Assembly.
And once they return from recess next week,
they'll be going through committee meetings on SB 79.
And then the Assembly will have a full floor vote on that.
And if the Assembly passes it,
then it will go back to Senate one more time
for a final reconciliation vote.
And if everything passes there,
it will go to the governor for signature.
But we are certainly hoping that it does not pass.
We're fighting very hard to see SB 79 stop
because we believe it's a huge impact
and negative impact on R1 communities.
How will it impact you guys?
Most people know an R1 zone neighborhood
has traditionally been one residential unit per lot.
And that's been the way it's been
ever since there's been cities.
And cities were developed with different types of zoning.
And R1 zoning was kind of considered the zoning
where people had more space, it was less dense,
more suburban feel.
And so R1 zoning has now become under attack
from various groups.
And the state has taken up the cause
of trying to basically eliminate R1 zoning
and densify R1 communities by different laws
that increase the ability to have
more than one residential unit on a lot.
Other laws, I guess, B9, various ADU laws.
And now R1 zone no longer means
one household unit on a lot.
It could mean potentially up to three or even six,
depending on what laws might be applied.
That densification is upsetting to a lot of people
who bought into an R1 zone neighborhood
because they wanted that suburban feel of lower density,
quieter, calmer neighborhoods,
and density changes that feel.
And the more we densify the R1 zone neighborhoods,
the character of those neighborhoods will change
and change permanently.
And obviously people who want to live
in an R1 zone neighborhood are upset about that.
And R1 zoning is probably the most common zoning
for housing throughout the whole state of California.
How would this SB79 impact?
Well, SB79, it will allow extreme densification
of existing lots.
It might only have one home on it today
to build up to six-story multifamily property
without any change in zoning,
without any discussion by the residents
or the councils in those cities.
It would all be done ministerially, which means by right,
the developer comes in, submits their plan
to the planning department of the city.
The city is required by the law
to approve that within 60 days.
And next, your neighborhood next could sell their house
and someone could tear down that property next to you
and start building a six-story apartment building
and you wouldn't even know about it.
And you wouldn't have any ability
to say anything about it, complain about it.
And these types of construction projects
then would be allowed within a half a mile
of high volume transit, buses, train systems,
and that type of thing.
So if you look at some of the main streets
through some of our larger cities in our state,
that's a very common occurrence
to have high volume bus service.
And more and more, we're seeing transit through trains
being put into our cities.
And so anytime there's anything within a half a mile,
which that's a pretty big radius,
if you look at a half a mile from around a bus stop,
anything in that half a mile radius
could essentially be converted to six-story projects
by right with no discussion from the community
to say, we oppose this.
You've been on a city council for many years.
Based on what you're seeing,
there's a number of laws that passed.
This is kind of the newest one,
but there's a lot of different laws with the ADUs and SB9.
What do you think your community
that you were leading would look like in a decade from now?
Well, I'm fearful for what it would look like
because our community, I'm from Torrance,
and Torrance has always been a suburban community
outside of downtown Los Angeles.
And so people who wanted to live
in a more serene, quiet community
would tend to move to the suburbs.
And a lot of people, that's their dream
is to move out to the suburbs
and have a nice, quiet community to live in
as opposed to the hustle and bustle
of a downtown Los Angeles or other high-density areas.
And so the California dream was to have
that nice little home out with a yard,
the white picket fence.
And all of a sudden, California must be thinking
that's no longer the dream we want to see people have.
And so they're trying to take that dream away from people
and say, well, now we wanna push density
into those communities where we could put density
in other places.
In fact, there are many rules that are forcing cities
to build housing in various areas of our communities
that do give the city the ability
to dictate where that will be.
And that's under the regional housing needs
assessment allotments that cities are given.
And the good part about that
is the cities can choose where, via their housing element,
they can choose where to build higher density housing.
And these laws that I'm talking about,
specifically SB 79, don't follow into that housing element
that cities are able to plan for.
It just pushes this density
into residential neighborhoods.
And cities have the right to do that anyway.
But now the state is mandating it
and saying, we don't have a choice.
It's done ministerially.
There's no public discussion.
And many of us believe that there still should be a choice
of what type of living you want to have.
That's what people wanted.
And people were willing to pay good money
to live in those communities.
What was promised to us when we bought into that R1 zone
is now being taken away.
And it's like, wait a minute.
I thought when I bought into this R1 zone community,
I would have the protection that this community would stay
in that look and feel of an R1 zone community
that we all had envisioned.
But apparently now the state is changing
what we're gonna see.
We have a section of our neighborhood that has views.
That's on a hillside.
And so people have ocean and city views.
And people traditionally have said,
yeah, I would like to have a view.
And I'm willing to pay substantially more
to live in a property that has a view.
And so we as a city and other cities
have done similar things where we've enacted laws
about development in those areas
that those views will be protected.
So that if a person buys a property with a view,
that they would expect to have that view forever.
And that someone will not come up and build
a second story building in front of their view
and block their view.
And so we have had this in place
for many, many, many, many years, decades.
And it's worked out really, really well
where the people feel comfortable that,
oh, I bought my house here.
I've paid a whole lot extra to have a view,
which should be allowed.
It shouldn't be illegal.
If I wanna buy a house with a view
and I have the money and the resources to buy it,
I should be able to buy it.
But now with these new ADU laws
and other laws that are coming into play,
it's taken our laws, thrown them out the window
and allowing people to build a two-story unit
without any review by the community,
without any regard to blocking someone's view,
even though we've instituted laws to protect those views.
And the state laws override our local laws.
And the traffic's already bad enough as it is.
And with all these new bodies in the communities,
those cars have to go someplace.
Is there any parking requirements for these?
No, this is something that the state has
in all these different laws that they've pushed
regarding the ADUs and other projects.
If it's within near transit,
they're feeling like people shouldn't need cars.
And so they eliminate the requirement for parking.
And unfortunately, my experience,
and I've been on the Torrance City Council for over 10 years,
I'm recently termed out.
My experience is that most people in California,
especially in Southern California,
need and want to have a car.
And I haven't seen a significant move
towards eliminating cars for transportation.
So people need to have a place to park their car.
But yet these new developments now
that are being imposed upon cities by the state
are not requiring any parking on site.
And so the people, if they have a car,
will be forced to park their vehicles out on the streets,
wherever they can find a place to park.
We've had state leaders on the show that have told us
that the cities didn't do enough.
And there's another side to this,
that people that have homes,
they've bought it earlier on, they're fine now.
And there's younger people that don't have access to housing
and the costs have gone up significantly.
About 18% of people can't afford to buy housing.
What are your thoughts on that?
Well, you touched on a key thing,
and that's affordability.
And I think most people will agree,
there's definitely an affordability crisis
related to housing in California,
and maybe even nationwide.
Housing has gotten ridiculously expensive
for so many reasons.
And that issue alone is a problem
because these bills aren't requiring any affordability.
And yes, there is absolutely a situation
where cities weren't building enough housing.
And so the state is right in saying
that we could have built more housing and we didn't.
And so now they're saying, well, because you were bad,
we're gonna impose this upon you.
You won't have any rights or options to discuss.
We will dictate how housing will look in your community,
irregardless of the uniqueness of what was our community.
And so now the state wants to see a uniform look
in every city in the whole state,
one size fits all, all across the state.
One of the things that the state did
is they took away one of those resources
that cities had to build affordable housing.
And that was a redevelopment agency money
where the state paid cities through a redevelopment agency,
the money to help cities build affordable housing.
The last time, in fact, in Torrance,
where we actually built a housing
under the redevelopment agency
before the state eliminated that,
I believe in 2011 or 2012,
the last affordable housing project
that was ever built in our city
was via the redevelopment agency money
that was funded before the state
took that money away from us.
And so they've taken away one of those opportunities
for us to build affordable housing
by eliminating the redevelopment agencies
that was available to cities all across the state.
Then the state was providing us that funding to do that,
which is no longer available to cities.
The state could incentivize cities to say,
we wanna have you do this type of densification.
And if you do it,
we will reward you with some sort of incentive,
whether it's financial, we'll help pay for police and fire,
we'll help pay for the infrastructure upgrades,
we'll incentivize you to build higher density
and give cities the choice to say,
you know what, I'm okay with,
let's densify this part of our community
along with those incentives that we get from the state.
But the state's providing no incentives whatsoever.
They're beating cities over the head with these new laws
without any benefit to the cities,
except for a very small increase in property tax.
And cities only see a very small percentage
of the property tax revenue
that is generated by some of this new housing.
So cities are really getting the shaft,
so to speak, in this regard.
And they're paying a huge price
to do what the state's wanting and they have no say in it.
Cities have enough trouble functioning
as a city these days.
It's harder and harder to be a city
and the state's making our lives even more difficult.
And to even have affordable housing now,
if we'd say that this housing is affordable,
well, if the developer builds it as affordable
using some incentives or something from the city
or the state or wherever,
there's nothing that's saying that we as a city
are gonna be able to enforce that
because cities are the ones that ultimately have to enforce.
Is this housing gonna be continued as affordable?
If two years after it gets built,
all of a sudden they start charging market rate
for that property, who's gonna enforce that?
The cities would be the ones that would do it,
but the cities don't have the capacity to do it.
So there won't be any enforcement
on what people will say should be affordable.
And so people will build
under the guise of affordable housing,
but eventually it will flip to market rate
and there'll be very little enforcement
of keeping it as affordable housing.
Before we move on to the rest of this interview,
we wanna show you some headlines
from the Epoch Times this week's California section.
There is a big battle
between Trump administration and UCLA.
Trump administration is saying
there is racism, antisemitism,
they don't agree with their transgender policies
when it comes to athletes.
As a result of this,
Trump administration has cut UCLA's research fund
by $324 million.
There was a judge order saying
that Trump administration need to give
some of this research money back.
Street takeovers in LA have become a major problem
for the city.
And sometimes people are taking the streets over,
they're doing donuts,
and then they go to auto zones and attack the stores
and rob them and vandalize them.
Now, district attorney of LA,
Nathan Huckman has come up with some harsh punishment
for the spectators.
They could face up to 190 days in jail
or face $500 fine or both of them.
We have an article
about California Energy Commission's effort
to keep the refineries in California.
A couple of refineries have announced
that they wanna leave California
and this would put 20% of California's gasoline
on the risk.
So California Energy Commission
has been working very hard to get everybody together,
make sure they do whatever they can
to keep these refineries
so that we don't have an energy shock.
This is just a few headlines in our print edition.
We have many, many headlines on California,
national stories and beyond.
And they're balanced,
they're multifaceted issues.
Some of these stories are not reported anywhere else.
You can just try the paper for a month
and we have a special deal for you.
There's a link below.
It's a dollar a week for the first month.
Make sure you try it and let us know what you think.
So from what you're saying
is that these state laws,
they're pushing for a lot of housing.
Good portion of them are not affordable.
It's like market-raised housing.
Market rate.
And then what will happen,
from what it looks like,
the character of that community will change
because you will have,
there wouldn't be as much organization
in the look of that community.
You might have a six-story building somewhere.
You might have one with a bunch of ADUs in the backyard
and you might have,
it will be a different look
from the neat, organized communities
that you guys bought into, right?
There's no question.
When you switch from a typically,
a neighborhood that's typically home-owned,
people own the property that they live in
versus properties that are primarily rental,
there's a huge difference
in the character of those communities right off the bat
because homeowners tend to be much more concerned
with the appearance of their community,
the upkeep of their community.
Renters, they don't own the home.
They don't own the property.
They don't care as much about it.
And so there's a noticeable difference
in rental communities
versus communities lived in by the property owners.
And so by shifting our communities
through this change in densification
through high-rise multifamily housing,
we're changing that character
and that concern about our community
because renters, they're not here for the long haul.
They're here temporarily to move on.
And maybe their dream is to, in fact,
have an R1 zone property,
but the state's taking away that R1 zone dream from people.
And yes, we need some stepping-stone housing.
I did that myself, my very first home.
I rented initially.
Then eventually I bought a small home that I could afford.
And over time, I was able to build enough equity
and then buy a bigger home.
And that's, I think, what most people tend to do
is they start out small
and they get whatever they can afford
and they work their way up over time.
And generations have been doing it that way.
I'm not sure why all of a sudden the change isn't.
And it all goes really back to
what is this housing emergency
that some people in the state seem to think we have?
Is there really a housing crisis?
And some people will debate that very strongly,
but use an example.
Recently, we had the two big fires
in Palisades and Altadena.
16,000 residential units were lost in those fires.
Where did all those people go?
They all found housing,
or the majority of those people found housing.
If there's a housing emergency,
where is that emergency
and how did all these people find housing
in a relatively short amount of time?
Obviously there is housing available.
And so to say there's an emergency
enough that you wanna override the state constitution,
giving cities the right to be able to continue
to manage their own land use and zoning,
but yet we don't see the evidence of a real emergency.
Who declares this as an emergency?
And what's the proof of it being an emergency?
There's no question, it's an affordability crisis.
But is there really a housing crisis?
And some people say also
that the state has been losing population
for several years now.
So why do we need to build more and more housing?
And why do we need to change the nature
and the feel of our residential communities?
There's a blatant attack on R1 zoning.
Some people just think that should be flat out eliminated.
Why?
I haven't heard a good explanation
for why R1 zoning is bad.
And I'd love to hear that.
I can dispute, people say it's because
it's some sort of a racial issue
that R1 zoning is prejudicial.
I grew up in Altadena, the town that burned here recently.
And the Altadena is a town very diverse
of all different races,
especially high percentage of black people.
And yet they all owned homes in R1 zone
and there was no problem.
So to say it's a racial profiling, I dispute that.
To say that there's other issues
that make R1 zoning irresponsible.
Yes, some people wanna have a little space
around their property.
Why is that so wrong?
Only 5% of the buildable land in California is urbanized.
There's 95% of the state left
that hasn't got anything built on it.
And so can we expand out
without destroying the neighborhoods that we have today?
I think so.
But some people believe that we shouldn't be building out
from where we are today
and that we need to densify and go up
as opposed to building out.
Do you think there will be a lot more renters
in your community?
Oh, absolutely.
When you get the density that they're talking about
via these bills or the regional housing needs assessment,
the amount of building that cities
are now being forced to allow to be built.
I know in Torrance, there's now thousands
of new rental units coming on the market
that all majority of them will be rental property
as opposed to home ownership.
We're already close to a 50-50 ratio
of homeowners versus renters.
And that percentage is going to definitely increase
on the rental percentage.
And that changes the look and feel of the whole community
as I already spoke early to the fact
that homeowners care more about their community
than those who are there temporarily.
The fact that we're moving away from home ownership
and to a renter environment is taking away the ability
for people to generate wealth.
People generate wealth by home ownership
and the equity that increases in their homes over time.
When you're a renter, you never have that.
And the only person who's gaining the wealth
is the owner of the property.
And so we're creating a situation
where people will not be allowed to build wealth
because they're permanently stuck in a rental environment.
And if we're not providing homes that people can purchase,
that's hurting the ability for wealth to grow
at the individual level.
Let's hear the other side of the story.
We go to Nolan Gray with California GMB
to find out why these laws are getting proposed
because this organization has been behind them.
Can you tell us more about this law?
First, I think it's important to set
a little bit of a baseline here.
California has some of the highest housing costs
in the country.
The median home price is now many multiples
with the median household income earned.
So the typical California family
doesn't have a path to homeownership.
The typical California renter spends
at least a third of their income,
and in many cases, half of their income just making rent.
And then we have the largest homelessness population
in the country, over 100,000 Californians
sleep on the streets every night.
Many hundreds of thousands of people
have been forced to leave the state altogether.
So we're in a five alarm fire housing crisis.
We have to take bold measures to get California building.
And that's why we have a crisis.
California has over-regulated the housing market
for decades, and now we have a significant shortage.
If you look at what SB9 does, where it applies,
most of where it applies are existing commercial areas
and existing multifamily areas.
There are a handful of parts of the state
where local regulations say the only thing
that can be built in these areas
is a detached single family home,
despite the fact that it might be next
to a major job center,
or it might be next to major transit lines.
And in fact, many property owners in those areas
might say, hey, if the government would allow me,
I would like to build more housing on my lot.
But local regulations don't allow that.
So to my mind, I'm absolutely agnostic as to housing.
I would say, look, let the market provide
all different types of housing,
and we'll find out what's best for consumers.
You know, I think if you ask a lot of real estate
professionals and young professionals
who are trying to become homeowners in California,
the best type of housing for them,
the housing that's affordable in their price range,
is going to be a townhouse or a small lot home,
or a two or three bedroom condo,
where they can become a homeowner and start a family
and start building wealth.
So to my mind, absolutely nothing wrong
with a single family home.
I grew up in a single family home.
I can see at many points in my life that making sense,
but it doesn't make sense for government regulations
to say that's the only form of housing
that we're going to allow.
Can you explain that?
How would it work?
Some reasonable amount of housing along these transit areas.
Can you tell us the details?
Absolutely.
So we've designated certain types of transit lines
that would be eligible.
So just rail, so subway lines,
commuter rails that meet a really high frequency.
So there are lots of trains running
to and from job centers each day.
And then bus rapid transit lanes.
So bus lines where the bus has a dedicated lane,
24 hours a day,
and it's going much quicker than a typical bus.
This is a really limited geography of California.
This is, I think, something on the order
of two or 3% of California,
mostly clustered in extremely high cost places
like Los Angeles and San Francisco.
And it would say, okay, in these places
where the state and the federal government
have invested billions of dollars
in high quality transit to job centers,
local governments would have to allow some housing.
This would scale based on the quality of the infrastructure
and the quality of the transit.
But essentially it would say,
okay, hey, we need workforce housing.
We need multifamily housing.
We need the types of two and three bedroom apartments
that are gonna be immediately affordable
to working and middle-class families.
And that's a sliding scale
based on the quality of the transit.
Doesn't apply in the vast majority of the state.
Doesn't apply in parts of the state
that have no transit whatsoever.
Really only applies in those very transit rich,
jobs rich parts of the state
where the crisis is at its worst.
So the idea is to put six story building,
up to six story buildings in these areas, right?
That would be the most extreme case.
So near the Los Angeles subway, for example,
where you've got high quality transit
to and from many job centers.
Yeah, within a reasonable distance of that,
a quarter mile of that,
you might, local jurisdictions will be required
to allow mid-rise housing.
So, four or five stories of apartments over shops.
The vast majority of these areas that are covered
are commercial areas
or they're areas that already have apartments.
But there are some parts of the state
where significant investments have been made
in extremely high quality transit
and local zoning regulations
continue to make it illegal to build
anything other than a single family home.
And if you actually look at those single family homes,
those are not homeownership opportunities
for working middle-class Californians.
Those are two, three, four, $5 million homes
that only the very wealthy can afford to live in.
And if we limit our state to housing of that type,
we're never gonna get back on track
and attract the families
that are leaving the states and droves.
Because you're next to transit,
is the idea for these people not to have cars
and just use the transit,
is that what you guys are thinking?
You know, I think they would have choice.
I mean, some developers would say,
you know, I can't rent these units out
or I can't sell these units
unless I provide off-street parking.
So, some will provide off-street parking and some won't.
You know, there are many California households
for whom maybe having one car or no car
is the best opportunity for them.
You know, there are many households
who might only need one car
or, for example, retirees who don't need to own a car
and for whom a unit in a multifamily building
where the property is managed
and there's onsite security is the best opportunity.
So, as with so much of what's gone wrong
with California housing,
I think the goal here is just to allow
for a range of housing types to be built.
You know, the vast majority of most California cities,
the only thing that can be built
is a detached single-family home.
And that's great.
You know, of course, that's the dream
and we need to continue building that
on the suburban periphery.
But if we're going to make
existing job centers more affordable,
we have to also be building infill
and we have to be building infill
that accommodates young families.
We have to be building infill housing
that accommodates empty-nester retirees,
a range of housing types
that accommodate a range of Californians.
SB 79 targets the particular types of housing
that are least provided for,
which is the apartments and areas
where folks will have easy access to job centers
and potentially be able to walk or take transit
for most of their daily needs.
You guys have passed a number of laws.
We have the ADU laws and SB 9
and different kinds of laws
that will increase the density
of California cities significantly.
Some people might argue that this is becoming too much
and it will change the character of our neighborhoods.
It's a great question.
I mean, I would say that the character of California
is changing dramatically.
You know, when I was growing up,
I had an aunt and uncle who had moved out to California.
They're a middle-class family.
They were able to buy a home.
They were able to raise kids out here.
And now if you look at the home
that they'd bought in the 70s or 80s,
it would be completely unaffordable
to a middle-class family.
So the character of California is changing dramatically.
Our working and middle-class families are being priced out
and only really the wealthiest people
are able to stay in California.
The question is how do we reverse
that undesirable change in character
and the demographic change in character
of folks having to leave the state?
Well, we have to build more housing.
You know, there's a lot of folks who are from California
and want to stay here.
There's a lot of folks who want to move here
and we can either say,
well, we're going to become
an increasingly affordable exclusionary state.
We're working in middle-class families don't have a place
or we can build more housing to accommodate that.
You know, I think in recent years,
we've done a few things
that have been really positive on this,
allowing for accessory dwelling units
or granny flats or mother-in-law units
as they're variously called.
Those have empowered homeowners
to add an additional unit to their property.
That's unlocked something on the order of 100,000 new homes
that wouldn't have existed
if the state hadn't come in
to protect the rights of property owners
from local regulation.
So that's a positive example,
but we need housing of all different varieties.
We need a homeownership housing.
We need ADUs.
We need townhouses.
We need small lot single-family homes
and we also need apartments.
One of the things that has happened
is that the cities have lost control
and because the state has taken over,
the cities almost have no say in these new laws,
the way they're passing.
And if the state could help them
or give them some incentives to do the development
instead of punish them,
which is right now they're facing punishments
if they don't meet their numbers.
Well, so I would say something that's been added to the law
is for the small number of jurisdictions
where this law would apply.
And again, this is a few dozen jurisdictions
across California where SB 79 would apply.
They have the option to adopt a local alternative plan
that's well-designed to reflect local conditions
where they say, hey, okay,
these are the areas within a quarter or a half mile
of transit, but density doesn't make sense
in this entire area.
So we'll move some of the density
to places where it does make more sense.
So local governments under this law
will have wide authority
to adopt local alternative implementation plans.
And that's a really powerful tool.
And we're gonna be beefing that up
in future iterations of the law.
The other thing I'll say here is I completely agree.
We have to expand support for local governments
that are building a lot of housing.
You know, not every city, we always,
I think the discourse ends up beating up on cities
that are not doing their fair share
and that are making it really hard to build.
And that's a big problem.
That's a problem that SB 79 is trying to address.
But a lot of cities in California
are already building a lot of housing
and doing more than their fair share.
And those are the cities, in fact,
that have actually come out and endorsed SB 79.
You know, cities like Emeryville or Sacramento
or various smaller cities,
even across metropolitan Los Angeles.
They say, hey, we're allowing a lot of housing.
We're building housing.
But all of the cities around us
are building absolutely nothing.
And in many cases, those are the cities
that are asking for the state to nudge every city
to at least allow some housing.
So all the birds not falling on the handful of cities
that do allow more housing.
So I completely agree that we have to expand support
for cities that are building more housing.
But we also have to put guardrails
and protect the rights of property owners to add housing
and make sure that every city is at least allowing
the market to provide a reasonable amount of housing.
Thank you for watching California Insider on YouTube.
If you like our content,
make sure to press the like button and comment
so that the algorithm can reach more people.
If you're not a subscriber yet,
make sure to subscribe to our channel
so that we can update you with the trends
and issues that are going on in California.
Now let's go back to the interview.
And some people argue that only 5% of California is built.
Why don't we build more single family home units
in other areas, in suburbs, more suburbs?
What are your thoughts on that?
Absolutely.
I think if you look at cities across the US
that have maintained affordability, they're growing out.
So they are building new suburbs.
They're building new single family homes on the periphery.
And they're also building up.
They're building townhouses in existing urban areas.
They're building apartment buildings
where strip malls or office parks used to be.
So I think it's a both and solution.
But I think to say, well,
we can solve California's housing crisis
simply by building more subdivisions on the periphery,
that's not a sustainable solution
for a place like Los Angeles or the Bay Area
where suburbs might be two, three hours
outside of existing job centers.
So in the areas where the crisis is most acute,
near high quality job centers in many of our major cities,
building new suburbs might be helpful on the margins,
but we really also have to be building infill as well.
And we got to build the range of housing typologies
that reflect California's needs.
Is there an affordability component in this?
Well, there is.
So I would say two things.
I think the evidence is very clear
that states and cities that build more housing,
places like Florida and Texas,
have much better overall affordability.
When you let the market provide the supply that's in demand,
prices equilibrate and they fall.
You know, in places like Texas,
they of course had a run up in prices
over the course of the pandemic,
but then they allowed for markets to respond to that
by building a lot more housing.
And so now they're seeing rents fall
and they're seeing home prices stabilize.
And that's really positive.
That's allowing for the next generation of folks
to get into homeownership.
In California, you see the opposite.
So I would say that increasing the overall supply of housing
is absolutely essential.
But yes, for SB 79 projects,
they will have to set aside a certain share of units
that are deed restricted affordable
to low and moderate income households.
And so to make sure that, you know, in the immediate term,
those folks are getting the housing that they need.
Now, Nolan, some people say that this new type of housing
will encourage more investors and renters.
What are your thoughts on that?
Well, so there's been a lot of investors buying homes
in recent years,
and they actually have to disclose why they're doing this
to the SEC, to federal regulators.
And they'll say, we are buying homes in markets
where we think there's going to be a permanent shortage.
Investors will buy homes in states and in cities
that are not building enough housing
because they know that the price is going to keep going up
and up and up.
And that's what's happened in California.
I tend to think that housing should be something
for families and for folks to live in,
and not an investment asset.
And the way you get it back to that healthy place
is to build a lot more new housing.
And to say, yeah, a home will hold its value.
A home might slightly increase in value.
That's what happens in a lot of America.
But in California,
where you can expect a home to increase by 10, 20 times
over the course of your ownership,
then the home becomes an investment asset
and working and middle-class families
start getting priced out.
So it's a significant concern,
and it's brought on by the fact
that we've just not been building enough housing.
The cities will have more density in California.
They're going to have more pressure on their infrastructure.
They're going to have more traffic.
They need more parking.
What are your thoughts on that?
Well, if you look at a lot of coastal California,
many of these cities,
and especially a lot of the suburbs,
are actually below their peak historic population.
And this was something that was revealed in the 2020 census.
Why is that?
Because when a lot of these suburbs
and many of these communities were built,
they were housing families.
They were housing extended families
that would live in one home.
But as we've slowly priced out families,
and so many homes are occupied by empty nesters
or individuals living alone,
the population density and the total population
of a lot of coastal California has declined.
And again, that's a function of families being priced out.
So we've actually got a lot of spare infrastructure capacity
in many of these communities.
Communities from LA all the way up onto the Bay Area,
in many cases, they're having to close schools
because there simply just aren't enough children.
So we've actually got excess capacity on things
like sewer and sanitation, schools, et cetera.
And the other thing I'll say is that nothing in SB 79
precludes local governments from charging impact fees
that reflect the marginal impact of the project.
So if a project is gonna come in as a result of SB 79
and add new housing to a place
where there's a significant shortage,
a city will be able to say,
hey, we're gonna charge you a certain fee
on a per unit basis,
and then use that to scale up the infrastructure.
And that'll all be paid for.
I think the only unacceptable response here
is what cities offer up today,
which is, well, we don't have the infrastructure,
we haven't really done the analysis,
and no, we're not going to scale up the infrastructure
if we do need to increase it.
To my mind, that's just not an acceptable answer.
It's an answer that forces many Californians
to have to leave for other states.
And we all know the harm that that causes.
So one of the things we have noticed
on a lot of the new housing in California is rentals.
Homeownership is a key here and in this country.
Are you guys looking at that
when you're proposing these kinds of laws?
Yeah, I mean, I completely agree
that homeownership is a top issue,
and not just because my wife and I
would like to be homeowners in California someday,
but that's certainly a factor.
The SB 79 is agnostic as to whether or not
the units created are rentals or homeownership.
So cities have to allow housing,
but in many parts of the state
that are affected by this law,
what cities would likely probably prefer to allow
would be townhouses or small multifamily units
where you could own one unit and rent the other unit out.
And then in multifamily buildings,
some of these multifamily buildings could be condos.
They could be homeownership opportunities.
There are other aspects of California policy
that make condos difficult,
and we're eager to work on that.
But this is not necessarily gonna be,
all of the units created by SB 79
are not necessarily going to be rentals.
And in fact, I hope that many of them
are homeownership opportunities.
But I think we have to be pursuing
a range of policy options.
Other laws that my organization, California EMBY,
has sponsored and helped to pass
have really been focused on small lot,
single family homes and townhouses
that are great homeownership opportunities.
We're also working on getting more condos built
and more homeownership opportunities
because I absolutely agree.
I think homeownership is the key
to stability and wealth building
and building the next generation
of middle-class Californians.
But as long as the housing is illegal to build,
as it is in so many parts of California,
it's not going to matter how much progress
you make on those other rules.
And SB 79 is an important first step on that.
Now we go to Mike Griffiths to hear more from him.
Now, Mike, people have mentioned to us
that even though the population of California is going down,
because of family formations, there is a shortage.
And there's always been a shortage in California
of 2 million homes, something like that.
Well, somebody says that,
but is there any evidence to support that number?
And there's been actually an audit
that was done on that number of 2.3 million housing units
that some people in the state think that were short.
And we believe that those numbers are greatly inflated.
And those numbers were used as a basis
for the regional needs housing allotments
that the cities were given.
And so that's assuming those numbers are correct,
but the audit showed that those numbers were incorrect.
In fact, they were potentially even over double
what they truly should have been,
but yet nobody's correcting the bills
as a result of this audit.
Now, there is another side to this
that California is, especially Southern California,
maybe Northern California too,
we're a little bit biased because we're in the South.
The demand is so high internationally
that once you have a nice unit,
we are competing with all the wealthy people
across the globe that wanna buy that unit.
What are your thoughts on that?
Well, it's certainly happening.
I know for a fact that in Torrance,
there's a lot of foreign investment into real estate,
whether it's commercial or residential.
And we see that happening, not just international,
but corporate home ownership for their employees
and things like that, where if I'm a family
and I wanna buy a home in Torrance,
I'm now competing with international buyers
as well as corporate buyers who wanna buy that property.
And now even developers under these new rules,
developers now wanna buy these R1 zoned homes
so that they can potentially tear them down.
And if SB 79 passes,
potentially build a six-story apartment complex.
And the value of these homes will go up more, right?
Probably.
Obviously, when you have these competing interests,
foreign investments, corporate investments,
developer investments, they drive up the cost of real estate
by overbidding for the price so that they can get it,
flip it around, intensify the property,
and then turn it around and make more money.
And developers and investors have the resources
to be able to do that,
where the poor single family homeowner
is gonna be outbid almost every time in those situations.
And we're definitely seeing that happen
where I, as a single family homeowner,
I can't afford to compete against those types of forces
where if you're in a desirable community,
there is gonna be a high competition
from those outside interests to buy that same property.
The other thing that people aren't really talking about
that affects the housing industry
is the aging out of our population.
Our communities are getting older and older and older.
I know that's a fact in Torrance.
Our residents are older and older.
And as those people die off, which they will,
those homes will become available again.
And so there's this constant churn of homes as people age.
And the older the population is,
the faster that's gonna happen.
We're not taking into consideration
the fact that there's gonna be
a higher percentage of turnover
as a result of people aging out in their communities.
So the real estate prices have gone up
significantly in the last decade.
People are probably excited to invest
and hoping that it will go up more and more from here.
Do you think we are overdoing it from the state perspective
to the point where we might build a lot
and then at some point there's too many?
Oh, that's a very, very real possibility.
We're seeing that now in the commercial side is,
for a while there was this huge demand
for industrial buildings.
There wasn't enough industrial buildings
to handle all the needs
for industrial type buildings in our communities.
All of a sudden people went crazy
building industrial buildings
so that people could fill that need.
Well, now there's a glut of industrial buildings
on our market and industrial buildings are,
either projects are stalling
because they can't find tenants
or the financing goes away
because industrial buildings have plummeted in their need.
The same thing has happened in the commercial space.
Office buildings are becoming vacant.
Let's convert some of those areas into housing
that potentially can handle more high density.
And that's what RENA allows for,
the Regional Housing Needs Assessment.
We can say, hey, we wanna change this old industrial area
into residential because there's more need for residential
than there is industrial these days.
And this particular area,
because it's not already a nice R1 zone neighborhood,
we can go ahead and make that high density.
It's closer to the shopping.
It's closer to the things that people need and want.
And so higher density makes sense in those areas.
But why take a perfectly good R1 zone neighborhood
and destroy it by densifying it?
That's the issue that so many people have.
And I'm seeing this firsthand
and being in this almost every day
is that as these new projects start popping up
in our R1 zone communities, the ADUs, the SB9 projects,
those types of projects are now starting to pop up
in our communities and the public is starting to say,
whoa, how did this happen?
Where did this come from?
And most people don't like it.
Now, obviously there are people that do like it.
The people who build ADUs love the fact
that they can build high density into our communities.
They walk away.
They don't live there.
They make a profit building the ADU.
They make the promise to the homeowner,
you're gonna make some extra money.
Well, we see it all day long that these ADUs
are now renting for a one bedroom or a studio unit
for $2,500 a month for a little tiny 700 square foot ADU
with no amenities and no yard.
How is that affordable?
How is that really benefiting what people are looking for?
It's certainly not the American dream
of the house with a white picket fence and a yard.
So you mentioned RHNA,
the Regional Housing Needs Assessment.
We talked to people that were against this in the cities.
Do you think this is better than the laws
that are passing right now with the ADU and SB9?
It's like there's two different attacks
on cities right now.
RHNA has been in place since the late 60s.
The Regional Housing Needs Assessment
has been in place for a long time.
And so cities have always been given every year cycle
a number of housing that the state would like
to see the city build.
The thing that's changed is previously there was no penalty
if a city did not meet
their Regional Housing Needs Assessment allotment.
And so many cities didn't do it.
They didn't meet their required needs assessment under RHNA
but there was no penalty.
But what's changed now is the state
has now imposed penalties on cities
for not meeting those numbers.
And on top of that,
they've increased the numbers dramatically.
For instance, in Torrance,
the eight-year Regional Housing Needs Assessment allocation
for Torrance was 1,450 residential units
that we were expected to build over that eight-year cycle.
And keep in mind, cities don't build housing.
Developers have to do it.
But we have to give them the opportunity to do that.
And so in 2021, then the new cycle started
and the state imposed new numbers upon all of us
where it goes back to that 2.3 million residential units
that someone in the state says we need.
Well, that was divided up amongst all the cities.
And so we got all of a sudden
from 1,450 residential units in eight years,
we went up to 5,000,
which is greater than 10% of our existing homestock already,
which took us 100 years to get to.
And so now they want us to build in eight years
what took us decades to build,
but we had space before and now we have no space.
Torrance is a built-out city like many cities,
especially in Southern California.
There's no room to expand.
We're right up against every other neighboring city
around us and there's no available land anymore
except for potentially converting
industrial commercial to housing.
And so we've been put in the situation
where now we have to build
these gigantic quantities of housing.
The penalties that'll be imposed upon city,
both financial and planning wise,
the penalty for not meeting
your regional housing needs assessment
is basically to say developers can come into our city
and do whatever they want
and we won't have the right to stop it at all.
And that's called the builder's remedy.
And the builder's remedy penalty
is something that no city wants to see,
that basically the developers can come in
and do whatever they want in our city
and we have nothing to say about it.
So right now we would like to maintain some ability
to manage and plan our communities,
but if we don't meet our numbers,
which we have really no control over meeting,
the state's gonna impose these penalties upon us
and basically turn over our city's planning to developers.
And I'm not sure we wanna see our cities
being turned over to developers for planning
because they're doing it for different reasons
and they're doing it for financial reasons.
Mike Griffith, former city council member from Torrance,
it was great to have you on California Insider.
Always a pleasure to be with you.
Let us know what you think about density
and housing in California.
Do you think we should build more
or do you think we should stop?
You can always email us
at siamakacaliforniansider.com or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Khorrami, this is California Insider,
and we'll see you next time.