General John J. Pershing and His American Army | Historical Documentary | Lucasfilm

Historical Identity
26 followers
5 Video Views·Aug 23, 2025
General John J. Pershing laid the foundations for the modern American Army.
Made by JAK Documentary for The Adventures of Young Indiana Jones on DVD, 2007.
Producer & Writer: Jennifer Petrucelli
Editor: Greg Sirota
Series Producer: David Schneider
Executive Producers: George Lucas & Rick McCallum
For more information about learning materials from Lucasfilm, visit https://www.lucasfilm.com/young-indy-...
France, 1917.
It was the third devastating year of World War I.
More than one million Frenchmen had been lost,
and there was no end in sight to the bloody conflict.
But on the morning of June 13, as the fighting continued
on the front lines, a ship pulled
into the French port of Boulogne,
bringing a long-awaited glimmer of hope,
an American general named John J. Pershing.
He's this barrel-chested guy, very upright, very stern.
He's got the big mustache.
And he sort of strides off the boat
to be greeted by cheering crowds.
Here's the savior come to release us
from this catastrophe, this Armageddon
that we're going through.
But Pershing would make the French wait months
while their soldiers continued to die
before he'd allow his army to offer any relief.
The American troops who had accompanied him to Europe
were hardly more than civilians in uniform.
What Pershing had to do in Europe,
and what he did very well, was create an organization.
It would take more than a year for Pershing
to transform his small, inexperienced force
into a vast, highly-skilled army.
This army would not only help win the war,
but would also become a foundation
for the modern American military
that would define the 20th century.
When World War I broke out in Europe in 1914,
John Pershing watched from across the vast Atlantic.
As the Allies, Britain, France, and Russia,
battled Germany and Austria-Hungary,
the U.S. kept its distance from a war it saw
as a purely European affair.
But three years later, when German submarines
sank four unarmed American ships,
President Woodrow Wilson realized
his country could no longer remain on the sidelines.
On April 6th, 1917,
the United States declared war on Germany.
The man President Wilson chose to command the American forces
was the 56-year-old Major General John Pershing.
Pershing was the only guy who'd had any experienced command
commanding large forces in the army at that time.
He had been given command of the expeditionary force
into Mexico to chase Pancho Villa in 1916.
And because of that, he was seen as the only officer
with any kind of experience in leading large units.
But the U.S. troops that Pershing commanded in Mexico
were little more than a glorified police force
made up of fewer than 15,000 men.
Soldiers rode on horseback and fought
with relatively primitive weapons
like rifles and bayonets.
World War I marked an entirely new kind of conflict,
one whose scope and scale were unprecedented.
16 countries mobilized nearly 65 million men
for a fight that raged across three continents.
New combat technologies such as poison gas,
the machine gun, liquid fire, tanks, and planes
were used with deadly effectiveness.
Those casualties in World War I are just unimaginable.
Now, the British, for example, lost 20,000 from one day.
I mean, it just blows your mind.
And the French, I don't know how many they lost at Verdun,
but that really was a meat grinder in the worst sense.
After three years of fighting,
the war had become a bloody stalemate.
Thousands of soldiers were giving their lives
to conquer just yards of terrain.
There was a line of barbed wire
from Switzerland in the south
all the way to the English Channel in the north.
On both sides, 350 miles of barbed wire,
350 miles of trenches, 350 miles of machine guns,
and they had gotten caught
into this kind of attrition warfare
of killing as many of the other guys as you can
and just wearing them down.
When Pershing arrived in France in June 1917,
he thought he knew a better way to fight the war.
He saw that if we were gonna win this war,
we gotta go past trench warfare
into what he called open warfare,
warfare pushing the Germans out of the trenches
and then fighting them in the open
and defeating them in the open
as opposed to trying to just push them
into the next trench line and the next trench line
and the next trench line.
He emphasized offensive tactics
that they would make a breakthrough.
Well, the French and British
both had wanted to make breakthroughs for three years
and they hadn't done it.
They wanted, how in the world
do you think you're going to do it?
Over the summer of 1917,
the Allies became increasingly concerned
that Pershing was not prepared for the war in Europe.
The newly instituted draft would swell US ranks
from 200,000 to 4 million men,
bringing desperately needed troops to Europe.
But it was fast becoming apparent
that Pershing lacked the supplies
and the logistical infrastructure to support them.
As one British writer commented,
They don't have any guns, they don't have any artillery,
they don't have, they don't even have helmets.
And so it's sort of this sense of,
you're supposed to save us
and you're not even ready to fight.
The British and French thought the quickest way
to get the Americans into the fight
would be through a process called amalgamation.
Under this plan, American troops would be sent
and American troops would be incorporated
into Allied armies that had been literally
bled dry of manpower.
The Brits and French thought,
what we need is men, men, send us all you've got.
They already had their logistical infrastructures built,
they already had those manned,
you could simply feed Americans into them.
And they're stunned when Pershing just says,
no, we're going to fight as an American army.
We're not throwing them away piecemeal.
They're going to build and train together
as an American army.
And when they're ready to go and not before that,
we're going to fight as a single unit.
On the surface, Pershing's opposition to amalgamation
rested on practical concerns.
There are a lot of American Irish,
how would they feel wearing British uniforms?
How many Americans spoke French?
Very few.
So if you put American private Joe Smidlop
in a French uniform, put him in a French army,
he won't know what's going on.
But Pershing also wanted to keep the U.S. Army
distinct and united to prove America's strength
on the world stage.
Pershing is not going to be bullied by the Europeans
into letting the American force be carved up
and doled out to be used as replacements.
That was going to be unacceptable
because it would be very difficult
to see the United States playing a distinct role.
It would have been, well, the French did this,
the British did this, but there wouldn't be mention
of what the Americans had contributed
other than as a part of somebody else's war effort.
But the allies and even some Americans
worried that Pershing's determination
to create an independent army
might come at the cost of the war itself.
In the face of mounting pressure to accept amalgamation,
Pershing held his own.
One of the reasons why he is so steadfast and so firm
in 1917 and 18 in France is because he's very used
to standing alone against the tide.
He's very used to being the only person
on one side of an argument.
That's what his military career has been like,
and this is just more of the same.
Pershing's military career began at West Point,
where he quickly distinguished himself as a leader.
After graduation in 1886,
the ever-ambitious Pershing sought out
one career-advancing assignment after another.
He proved himself a capable leader
in the Indian Wars on the frontier,
fought in the Spanish-American War,
where he was said to be cool
as a bowl of cracked ice under fire,
and rose to the status of celebrity
for his command of American forces in the Philippines.
He was driven by his own character.
I think he was hardworking, he was determined,
maybe determined is one of the best adjectives
you can use for John Pershing.
Pershing wanted to be somebody.
In the Library of Congress, in his papers,
there's a small little booklet,
you could stick it in your jacket pocket,
and I ran across that thing and I read it,
and it sounded exactly like the little booklet
that F. Scott Fitzgerald had Gatsby carrying
of how to be a success.
He was interested in that, very interested.
I think he was a very ambitious man.
In 1905, Pershing married Helen Warren,
daughter of an influential senator from Wyoming.
For some, the marriage cast him as a scheming social climber.
And this is a man who marries a senator's daughter,
a senator who's the head
of the Senate Armed Services Committee,
or the equivalent, an acquaintance,
if not a friend of Teddy Roosevelt,
and these things help him.
Just one year after the Pershing wedding,
President Theodore Roosevelt made an unprecedented move.
He promoted the 46-year-old Pershing
from captain to brigadier general,
ignoring the seniority of hundreds of other officers.
What he does by doing that is he isolates Pershing
within the American officer corps.
He's jumped him over 800 other officers,
all of whom are a little resentful
about being jumped over like that.
Pershing ignored accusations of political favoritism.
As his career advanced,
he and Helen began their life together.
Questions about Pershing's motivations
in marrying Helen Warren were tragically silenced
on August 27th, 1915, when a fire erupted
at the Presidio military base in San Francisco.
The flames engulfed the Pershing home,
claiming the lives of Helen and three of their four children.
Pershing, who was stationed in Texas at the time,
was devastated.
He is broken by the experience.
For a time, his fellow officers think
that he will go insane.
It's a horrible way to prove that you really loved someone,
but I think it really does show
that there was a genuine love between him and Helen.
It changed his life, I think, in two ways.
One is he became more reserved to the outside.
He had been very austere to begin with,
and this is gonna make him even more so.
Then he also threw himself in those boots.
All he's got left after 1915, he seems to decide,
is his role as an officer of the United States Army.
By the time Pershing arrived in Europe
in the middle of World War I,
he was fully immersed in his role as commanding officer.
While staunchly resisting Allied pressure
to hand over troops, he set about building
his independent American army.
Pershing was expecting more than two million men
to land in Europe over the coming year.
Before these fresh recruits arrived,
he had to create an organization that could support them.
He restructured his staff of officers
to more effectively deal
with the overwhelming logistical challenges.
When the American army went into World War I,
the way that they organized battles
was essentially the commanding general did everything,
and that was the way we'd run the Spanish-American War
and it'd been an utter disaster.
Pershing gets over there and he's determined
to have a staff of officers whose sole job
is to plan and organize,
not just the campaigns and the battles,
but everything, supplies, food, ammunition, everything.
It was a gargantuan task, but fortunately,
Pershing had assembled a group
of highly capable young officers
to help him get the job done.
His team included future military leaders
such as George Patton, Douglas MacArthur,
and George Marshall.
And I think this is one of the things
that helps to create sort of the legend of John Pershing
is that he plays an important role
in the development of some of America's
other great commanders and keeps these people close
and relies heavily upon these people.
At their headquarters in a chateau outside Paris,
Pershing and his staff worked tirelessly.
They set up training schools
where soldiers learned about the new technologies
being used to fight the war on the ground and in the air.
They created an elaborate supply system
of horses, trucks, and trains
that could continuously deliver food, clothing,
and ammunition to the front lines.
They laid over 22,000 miles of telephone wire
so that headquarters would be able to communicate
with units miles away.
Their ultimate goal, to make sure the men
doing the fighting had all the support they needed.
Pershing expected all operations
to meet the highest standards.
He is determined that they are going to perform.
And if they didn't live up to his expectations,
he was quite ready to yank them out.
What he did in World War I
was prove himself to be a superb manager.
He created a great organization.
He picked good people to run it.
He had good planners on his staff,
and that was his great contribution.
It doesn't sound very sexy.
I mean, we're sort of like, yay, great,
he's a great manager, you know, yippee.
Americans sort of fall in love with generals
like George Patton, you know, dashing, bold guys
who are sweeping through.
But there's an old military saying,
amateurs study strategy and tactics.
Professionals study logistics.
And in the war that Pershing was fighting,
in the wars that America fought in the 20th century,
organization and management have been as important
as actual battlefield tactics.
But in 1917, all this organizing was taking time,
time Pershing's desperate allies
increasingly felt they didn't have.
Six months after the United States entered the war,
not one American division was actively engaged in combat.
Every day that the Americans aren't fighting
is another day that the French are fighting and dying.
And so this isn't gonna make
for the best relationship between sides.
In November, this relationship was strained still further.
Russia, France, and Britain's ally on the Eastern Front
negotiated a truce with Germany and withdrew from the war.
And now there's this sort of ticking clock
in the heads of all of the commanders on the Western Front
because they know that all of those German soldiers
fighting over in Russia are coming
and they're coming back to the Western Front
and the Americans better be ready to deal with those guys
because the British and French
don't think they can handle them.
In the spring of 1918, those fears came true.
Beginning in March, the Germans launched
five consecutive attacks
that threatened to defeat the allies.
The Germans used the reinforcements coming over from Russia
to mount a major attack
on the French and British simultaneously and broke through.
And at one point, it looked like Paris was gonna be taken.
General Haig, the commander of the British forces,
sent out a telegram to his forces saying,
you cannot retreat any farther.
I don't care what happens.
You can't, you stand and die where you are.
Well, this is all the backdrop
because now the British are coming back.
The Germans and the British and the French
are going to demand American manpower.
They want American manpower to help them out.
In the face of the escalating crisis,
Pershing compromised on the amalgamation issue,
but he did so on his own terms.
U.S. troops could fight under European command,
but only in distinct American divisions
and only temporarily.
In an emergency, Pershing is willing to go so far
and to allow for American forces to serve
under non-American commanders at the highest levels.
But he wants those forces back.
American divisions were thrown into the line.
They blocked the road to Paris
and helped beat back the German advance.
It's more of a psychological and emotional victory
rather than a full tactical victory.
But nonetheless, Americans are now in the battle.
They're now playing a role
that cannot be denied by the Allies.
The success of the American effort
gave Pershing new credibility among his European peers.
They finally agreed to support the creation
of his independent American army.
Over the summer of 1918,
American divisions that had been scattered
among Allied forces were gathered up and united.
Their first job as an all-American army
would be to attack a four-year-old entrenchment
of German troops near the town of Saint-Michel.
The Germans had broken through the Allied defenses there
to create a heavily fortified bulge in the front lines.
The French never had enough strength
to go ahead and get rid of the bulge.
And so when the Americans looked at that,
they said, here's a spot for us to cut our teeth on.
If the Americans could eliminate the bulge,
it would clear the way for subsequent attacks
on German railroad lines and valuable coal and iron mines.
On September 12th, 1918,
more than a year after arriving in Europe,
Pershing led the first American army into battle.
Pershing himself spoke to his country
about the contributions this army would make.
3,000 miles from home, an American army is fighting for you.
Everything you hold worthwhile is at stake.
Invoking the spirit of our forefathers,
the army asks your unflinching support
to the end that the high ideals for which America stands
may endure upon the earth.
Pershing is determined that the Americans
are gonna do this and do this well.
And he sends them over the top against the salient.
And it is a rout for the Americans.
They sweep the Germans away.
They are over their first day's goal
within a few hours of the attack and past it.
They're past where they expected to be on the first day.
And Pershing takes this as justification,
not just for his one American army idea,
but also for the American strategy and tactics.
Open warfare, not trench warfare.
We've shown the old world
that they've been doing it wrong all along
and that the Americans can do it better than they can.
Pershing was elated by the success at San Miguel.
In just two days, his army captured 16,000 prisoners
and regained 200 square miles of territory.
But there was more to the story than Pershing realized.
What turns out to have happened at San Miguel
is that the Germans were actually already retreating
when the American attack went in.
The Americans were attacking the backs of a retreating army.
The true test of the American army
would come only two weeks later in October, 1918
in an area known as the Meuse-Argonne.
Here, Pershing's men would be asked to play a key role
in a campaign designed to push the Germans out of France
once and for all.
This time, it would not be easy going for the Americans.
At Meuse-Argonne, the Germans stand and fight.
And for the first time, the American soldiers experience
what trench warfare is really like.
They experience a fight
where the Germans are fully organized.
They have all their machine guns going.
They have the barbed wire up.
They have the artillery ranged in.
And tens of thousands of Americans die
over the course of the next couple of weeks.
You start to see the breakdowns.
You start to see the cracks in the system.
You start to have problems at the planning level,
logistics.
You're trying to move from the Saint-Mihiel Offensive
to the Meuse-Argonne Offensive.
But as you're trying to sustain the new offensive,
all of a sudden, it becomes a nightmare.
The new American army was finally confronting
the horrendous conditions that had plagued the Allies.
For all of Pershing's talk about open warfare
and the strength of the independent American army,
his forces were failing to meet their battlefield goals.
Pershing thought that he could do a better job at it.
As it turns out, he was probably about the same.
Pershing was criticized for the Meuse-Argonne
by the other Allied commanders.
And they were a little bit self-satisfied about it.
You know, they were sort of,
they felt like he'd finally been shown
what they'd been dealing with for three years.
But in the face of criticism and rising casualties,
Pershing pressed on.
Pershing's role was one of determination.
When things got tough, he was the one that said,
no, we gotta keep pushing.
Tactically, he probably didn't add too much.
It was more from the command, from the leadership,
from the inspirational side.
Oftentimes, we'll say Gettysburg was the greatest battle.
It was three days, it was a huge battle.
But actually, the Meuse-Argonne was a larger battle
than any battle before or since.
Bigger than D-Day.
One million Americans were fought in the Meuse-Argonne.
That was Pershing's battle.
Those one million Americans struggled seven long weeks
in the Meuse-Argonne and eventually made a breakthrough.
Their efforts, along with those of the Allies
fighting in adjacent campaigns,
finally overwhelmed the Germans.
On November 11th, 1918, the 47th day of the Meuse-Argonne,
the Germans agreed to an armistice.
For his part in the victory, Pershing led a triumphant march
through the streets of Paris and was received as a hero
when he arrived home in America.
After World War I, the American public
only really recognized one name, and that was Pershing.
It was a great victory, and he was a great hero.
Though he was honored as a hero,
Pershing's actual contribution to winning the war
has been debated for decades.
The role that Pershing and the Americans played
in winning the war is substantial but not decisive.
We sort of have this vision of,
we came over and won the war for them.
You know, the Americans rode to the rescue.
And the war is really won by the British and French armies
with the assistance of the Americans.
I don't think the Allies could have won the war
if the Americans had stayed out.
I think absolutely the best thing they could have gotten
would have been a stalemate.
They might have lost it indeed.
If there hadn't been Americans there,
where would the British and French have gotten
the people to stop the Germans?
It wasn't American battle skill, tactics or strategy.
It was simply the fact, basically a logistical one,
that the Americans were able to get
two million people over there
in a fairly limited period of time
that I think really won the war.
After the war was won, Pershing's force
of two million men was dramatically downsized.
America entered a period of isolation.
By 1932, the U.S. Army ranked only 17th in the world.
Even though the American army that fought World War I
disappeared almost immediately after the war ended,
Pershing's effect on it is permanent.
He's essentially created the precedent
for an American army that can be enlarged enormously
whenever needed, built up from a small core
of officers and men who know how to organize
and run such an army.
The structure that he's created remains in existence.
Pershing would live to see this structure
spring to life again nearly 20 years later in World War II.
The young men he had trained in the First World War,
now high-ranking officers like George Marshall
and George Patton, would draw on their experiences
to help defeat the Nazis and the Japanese.
On July 15th, 1948, General John J. Pershing died
at the age of 87.
Decades after leading America in World War I,
the nation he served had not forgotten him.
Pershing had a huge ceremony.
A lot of five-star generals were in the entourage.
I think they all understood what he meant
to the American army when he died,
because it was his army of World War I
that set the tone for the army of World War II.
It was the army that had the modern staff.
It was the army that had fought at a large level
that had never been seen before.
And that really was the great thing he did.
He created this great organization and he maintained it.
He had the strength of character,
the firmness of will to do that.
