#Samurai #Japan#History The Kamakura Shogunate is set to fall and the Ashikaga will come to rise as a new ambitious Emperor, Go-Daigo, plunges Japan into a new age of war! This is the finale of the updated Setting the Stage series, as now, the stage is set for the eruption of the Sengoku period that is to come...
Setting the Stage UPDATED playlist: • Setting the Stage (UPDATED)
The original title for this video in the old Setting the Stage series was "The Divide."
Sources Used: "State of War: The Violent Order of Fourteenth-Century Japan" by Thomas Conlan "Warriors of Japan as Portrayed in the War Tales" by Paul Varley "The Taiheiki" translated by Helen Craig McCullough "Legends of the Samurai" by Hiroaki Sato "A History of the Samurai" by Jonathan López-Vera "A History of Japan" by R.H.P. Mason and J.G. Caiger "Samurai Battles" by Michael Sharpe Additional information found through the Japanese Wiki Corpus
Music from: Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2 World of Warcraft: Cataclysm
Artwork: Classical art, which in most cases can be considered public domain. Art from Osprey Publications Other modern artist renditions and photos as well as photos from Wikipedia, if you see your work in this video please contact me so that I can give you proper credit!
In the last episode, a threat from beyond the seas, the Mongol Empire, attempted two
mighty invasions of Japan. Yet, despite their best efforts and overall numerical superiority,
they failed time and time again against the determined forces of the Kamakura Bakufu.
With Japan victorious, one might have expected a new era of strength and stability to begin.
However, that was not to be the case, as the Mongol invasion had instead revealed cracks within
the foundation of the Shogunate, weaknesses that will embolden its rivals to mount a significant
effort to bring it down. It is an age of upheaval, division, transformation, and one which will
ultimately open the door to an even greater period of war in the centuries to come.
By the early 14th century, to many, it was clear to see that the Bakufu was in decline.
Although there had always been those throughout Japan who harbored various reasons for resentment
towards it, the aftermath of the Mongol invasions had created a new problem which may have not been
foreseen. As we discussed in the previous episode, this issue largely had to do with the topic of
reward. How were the brave warriors who fought heroically against the Mongol hordes
to be compensated for their efforts? Of all the ways warriors could be rewarded,
perhaps the most coveted gift of all was that of land. To be given territory to govern,
a place to call your own, generate wealth, and to be passed down for generations.
This method of payment for one's service worked great for wars fought in Japan against other
Japanese enemies, as land claimed during a conflict could then be distributed to loyal
warriors who had proven themselves. But there was no land claimed against the Mongols. The Mongols
were an outside threat, and the defense of the home islands was the main focus of the Japanese
war effort. Although there would be ideas tossed around of a counter-invasion into the mainland,
such a notion never materialized. Thus nothing was ever gained from the Japanese victory
other than the reassertion of their independence. The bakufu of course awarded what little they
could, yet it was insufficient, and a low grumbling of disgruntled samurai began to be
heard amongst those who had gone forth to fight. Not to mention those who were tasked with staying
in Kyushu in preparation for a third invasion if it would ever come, which it didn't.
The reliability of the Kamakura Bakufu was now being called into question, yet on the opposite
side, what more could the Hojo Regency, the real rulers of the shogunate, have done? Obviously
they had worked effectively to defeat the Mongol threat. It was just unfortunate that the threat
itself had to be an external one, and that so much of the precedence set for rewarding service
was centered on the giving of territory. Besides this crucial dilemma, however,
other factors outside of the aftermath of the invasion were also becoming increasingly
problematic. Specifically, the Hojo Regency itself. Despite the fact that they had usurped power and
come to dominate the shogunate since nearly the start of its reign, they had managed to maintain
an image of fairness and justice. Yet now, that image had become tarnished over the decades. The
rising issue of corruption within the military government and centered around the Hojo was a
problem that was becoming hard to ignore. And so, by the early 1300s, we can see that such
conditions were right for a cataclysm. All that was necessary was a spark to light the fuse,
and such a spark would emerge in the form of the new emperor, Godaigo.
He had come to power already entering into his thirties, not young and manipulatable,
rather he already had a head full of ambitions. Godaigo wanted to retake power over the country,
power that he knew rightly belonged to the emperor and not the bakufu. So, as soon as he
ascended the throne, he began to scheme in the shadows. A century prior, we saw how another
emperor, Gotoba, had attempted the same. Yet for a variety of factors, Gotoba's efforts were doomed.
Godaigo, on the other hand, had several different things going his way. For one, support for the
bakufu was in a much rougher spot. Many had begun to question their authority and they could not
easily call upon legions to defend the shogun as they might have done in the past. Additionally,
Godaigo took a rather slow and cautious approach to gaining support and control. His initial
efforts were centered on consolidating the power he rightly could before attempting any action
against the bakufu itself. To this effect, he worked hard to dominate the court and by 1321
persuaded his retired father, Gouda, to relinquish any power he had as a cloistered emperor.
Through these actions, Godaigo quickly became the most powerful reigning emperor Japan had seen in
perhaps over a hundred years. Yet, his next course of action would be his most challenging, actually
attacking the shogunate. At court, Godaigo began to encourage secretive anti-bakufu groups,
and by 1324, one such group was discovered and its leader sent into exile by the Rokuhara Tandai,
who as we previously established, were bakufu officials in Kyoto tasked with overseeing the
imperial city and its politics. Surprisingly, Godaigo was not punished for this. In fact,
his involvement with it might not have been revealed. But soon enough, his intentions
would become far more plain to see. Over the next seven years, Godaigo only became more and more
active in the anti-bakufu movement. He sought more allies with which to challenge the bakufu's
authority, and sought to gain the backing of powerful warriors and Buddhist temples of the
central provinces. And while he was successful for a time, eventually his scheme would come to light
when he was betrayed by one of his own advisors, the court minister Yoshida Sadafusa. Sadafusa
informed the shogunate of Godaigo's plot and thus he was forced to flee Kyoto. For a time,
he hid on Mount Kasagi before being discovered by the Rokuhara Tandai who sent a military force
to apprehend him. Eventually, he would attempt an escape but would be caught and later exiled.
He was sent to Oki Island, where a century prior Gotoba had once been exiled. Yet while Gotoba
would live out the remaining days of his life there, Godaigo was determined not to do the same.
This entire course of events is usually referred to as the Genko Incident, which then leads straight
into the Genko War itself. Because the situation back in Honshu was only just heating up, it was
here Godaigo's allies continued to muster support against the bakufu, and more specifically the
Hojo Regency. Godaigo's son, Prince Morinaga, was instrumental in this effort, rallying those to his
father's cause. Throughout the central provinces, the flames of rebellion were on the rise,
as warriors began openly opposing the bakufu and attacking them. One of the most notable of these
figures was that of a warrior leader from Kawachi, Kusanoki Masashige, who began using guerrilla
warfare-like tactics to harass bakufu forces. By 1333, the situation was getting out of control
for the Rokuhara Tandai, and Godaigo would soon enough escape from Oki and return to Honshu,
where he was to be sheltered by loyalists. Thus, the bakufu finally dispatched their own
army from the east to march west in aims of crushing any resistance and restoring stability.
The army was led by none other than the head of the Ashikaga family, Ashikaga Takauji.
Rokuhara officials must have felt such a great sense of ease when they believed that he had
arrived to salvage the situation. However, their joy must have soon turned to terror
when Takauji, instead of aiding them as intended, turned his forces on them,
annihilating the Rokuhara Tandai. Takauji, either through devotion to the emperor,
dissatisfaction with the bakufu, or perhaps even his own ambition, threw up the banner of Godaigo
and joined the loyalists. Had this been an isolated incident, the bakufu might still have
stood a chance. Yet around the same time, Nita Yoshisada, head of another prominent branch of
Minamoto family, also rebelled in the east. Leading an army of his own, he attacked Kamakura
itself. With so many warriors now in opposition to them, there was little that could be done to
defend the seat of the shogunate. The Kamakura bakufu would be destroyed, and the Hojo regency
with it, as many of its leading members would choose to end their own lives in defeat.
Thus, the Kamakura period, which had lasted for nearly 150 years, came to a violent end.
With the shogunate no more, all power returned back to Godaigo, who triumphantly marched into
Kyoto, ousting the emperor Kogon who had temporarily taken his place. Godaigo proclaimed
a new age of imperial rule, and so began the brief period of the Kemu Restoration.
Now, it is interesting to examine the reign of Godaigo, and perhaps more so to ponder upon his
own character. As we know, his Kemu Restoration was not long lasting, but one that instead came
crashing down. We discussed how he long sought to retake power and to tear down the military
government. But then after accomplishing such goals, what would his rule have resembled?
For hundreds of years now, the emperor and the court had either been dominated by
warrior leaders or by Fujiwara statesmen. Instead, Godaigo sought to return to a distant time,
when the emperor himself held absolute power. But then, what was to be done about the status
quo which had been established by the bakufu? How were the victorious warriors to be rewarded,
and how was the governing of the provinces to resume now without a shogunate overseeing various
military land governors across the country? Of course, Ashikaga Takauji, Nita Yoshisada,
and Kusunoki Masashige were all handsomely rewarded for the role they played, being given
lands and titles for their service and loyalty. Yet the feeling of gratitude was not widespread,
and one of the primary criticisms of Godaigo's reign was his supposed dismissal of the warrior
class. Many over the years have attributed his plans to turn back the clock to a time before
warriors held such prominence as the main reason why it was so easy for many of them to eventually
turn against him. Historian Paul Varley cites a passage from the Taihiki as evidence of the
forming resentment many warriors had towards the new regime. After the re-establishment of peace,
there were unknown tens of thousands of fellows who had served loyally and wished rewards,
but the only ones who have thus far received them are courtiers and their underlings.
This is the reason why petitions have been abandoned and why suits are no longer submitted.
Others, resentful over their failure to receive rewards for loyal service and
dissatisfied over unjust governing practices, have returned home to their provinces.
Although the court should be seeking to dispel the resentment of the warriors,
it has decided first to undertake repairs to the palace. For this purpose, stewards of the
provinces are being levied one twentieth of their incomes. How grievous it is that the burden should
be placed on these men when they are still suffering from the ravages of war. However,
to believe that Godaigo was an arrogant ruler that was unqualified and ill-prepared for the
challenges of reforging the government might also be incorrect, as Varley also brings up the
argument of another historian, Andrew Goble, who instead challenges such a notion.
Goble contends that Godaigo worked firmly and successfully to consolidate his regime,
develop a coherent policy for handling land claims, assert authority over the courtiers
and great religious institutions, and provide leadership for the provincial warrior class.
Yet, despite whatever attempts Godaigo could make, there were just too many warriors who
became dissatisfied with his rule and wishing to return to a time when they felt more respected.
Perhaps one could make an argument that they were short-sighted,
not seeing the greater picture of the world Godaigo was trying to create. Yet,
that short-sightedness must have also plagued them in taking his side to begin with during
the Ginko War, if they were only to several years later now be growing dissatisfied.
However, just like how it took a powerful leader such as Godaigo to upend the Kamakura Bakufu,
it would also take another powerful leader to upend Godaigo's Kemu Restoration.
By 1335, remnants of the Hojo family attempted to regain power in the Kanto. They launched what
would come to be remembered as the Nakasendai War. In response, Ashikaga Takauji eagerly requested
that he be granted the title of Seitaishogun and dispatched at the head of an army to put
down the Hojo resurgence, yet his petition was refused. For one, the title of shogun had been
passed down to Godaigo's own sons, the Imperial Princes, whom would hopefully be seen as leaders
of the warrior class without actually being from the warrior class. Which is also another reason
why appointing Takauji to such a position was seen as dangerous lest a strong warrior leader such as
We don't know for certain if this denial was what ultimately caused Takauji to lose faith in Godaigo
or if, as we discussed earlier, he already had ambitions of his own.
What is for sure, though, is that Takauji would still march east regardless of permission
and that his campaign would ultimately be successful as well as rebellious.
After reaching the Kanto and eradicating the insurgents, Takauji occupied Kamakura and set
up his own power base there. His army, ever loyal to him, remained as such as he began to award
conquered land to his supporters. Twice now, Takauji had made a stunning betrayal that would
signal the end of a regime. He ignored orders from Kyoto and thus, in open opposition to the court,
Godaigo tasked Nita Yoshisada to lead his own army against Takauji. It is suspected that both
Yoshisada and Takauji were already bitter rivals, two great lords of Minamoto branches who each
desired to rule the warrior class. In fact, Takauji's rebellion might have been more to do
with simply opposing Yoshisada. Yet while Takauji sought to fight on his own, establishing his own
government and attracting many other prominent warriors, Yoshisada instead sought to win by
wielding the legitimacy granted to him by Godaigo. Despite this, however, Takauji would initially
prevail over Yoshisada, defeating him at the Battle of Hakone-Takinoshita. In victory and with more
warriors rallying to his side, Takauji pursued Yoshisada's retreating forces back towards Kyoto,
where by early 1336 he would enter the imperial city, causing Godaigo to flee to Mount Hiei.
Despite his success, Takauji, however, would not be able to maintain his position for long
and would soon after be counterattacked by loyalist forces. Both Nita Yoshisada,
Husanoki Masashige, and Kitabatake Akiie, who had come from Oshu, overwhelmed the Ashikaga army
and pushed Takauji out of the capital. Caught now in a desperate war against the loyalists
throughout the central region and drained of his earlier momentum, Takauji could not afford
to maintain his efforts there. Unfortunately for him, he was not able to turn back east either,
as the Kitabatake had also seized Kamakura during their march down from the north. Thus,
he made the decision to retreat the complete opposite direction and boarded a ship bound
for Kyushu in hopes of rallying more forces there. Now, some stories say that around this time,
Husanoki Masashige might have actually suggested to Godaigo that they arrest and execute Yoshisada
as a means of making peace with Takauji. This displays that Masashige may have been aware that
Takauji's rebellion might have had more to do with his rivalry with Yoshisada and less to do with
actually opposing Godaigo. And although it sounds absolutely wild given their recent victory
against Takauji, Masashige's logic might have been pretty sound given the fact that Takauji
was a far more popular leader than Yoshisada and that the war against him was likely to still be
a difficult one. Still, if this is true, Godaigo obviously refused such a notion and instead the
Takauji would only spend several months in Kyushu defeating loyalist leaders there and bolstering his
own army. He was also given some further legitimacy through connections he had made to the retired
Emperor Kogon who had previously reigned during Godaigo's exile several years prior. Kogon issued
an edict to return west and defeat the forces of Godaigo and so, soon enough, with his numbers
restored, Takauji headed back towards Kyoto. It was here in anticipation for the coming bloodshed
Masashige once again offered his advice to Godaigo, advice that would become famous.
He requested Godaigo retreat once more to Mount Hiei so that Takauji could take Kyoto, thus allowing
Masashige, Yoshisada, and the loyalist forces to surround the city and destroy him. Sadly,
Godaigo did not heed his advice and refused to recall Yoshisada who had already been dispatched
at the head of an army. Yoshisada, however, was already contending with stiff resistance from
enemy forces in the west and was unable to hold Takauji back once he landed in Honshu and began
moving east. Both Yoshisada and Masashige would attempt a desperate stand at the Battle of
Minatogawa where Takauji would crush the loyalist forces and Masashige would ultimately end his own
life, many generations later coming to be known as a great imperial martyr. Yoshisada, on the other
hand, would narrowly escape. He would not finally be slain until two years later. It was now Takauji's
turn to triumphantly enter into Kyoto, this time without a significant challenge to his position.
Briefly, Godaigo would flee back to Mount Hiei, yet knowing he was defeated would soon enough
come back down the mountain and submit to the Ashikaga. Takauji would place Kogon's brother,
Komyo, on the throne and Godaigo would hand over the imperial regalia in order to legitimize the
reign of the new sovereign. He did not remain in Kyoto too long, however, as within a short amount
of time he fled the city and went south to establish a new imperial court in Yamato province.
He claimed that the imperial regalia he handed over to Komyo were in fact fake and that the true
regalia was still in his possession, thus making him still the rightful emperor. The establishment
of this new southern court obviously challenged the legitimacy of the northern court, perpetuating
the conflict which had for a brief moment appeared to have ended. Seeking now to not only compete
against his enemies but also create a new regime ruled by the warrior elite, Ashikaga Takauji would
go on to establish his own military government, this time in Kyoto and not far away in the Kanto.
His regime would in time come to be known as the Muromachi Bakufu, and thus we now officially
enter into the Muromachi period. Muromachi coming to be the street in Kyoto where the Ashikaga
mansion would be located. And finally, by 1338, Takauji would at last be granted the title of
Seitaishogun, beginning the reign of the Ashikaga shoguns. Yet, while technically we are now in the
Muromachi period, for a time we enter into a sub-period called the Nanboku-cho, the age of the
northern and southern court. And while many point to the start of this period being only after
Kodaigo's flight south, others have instead speculated the true beginning of this period lay
in the polarization already felt years earlier, perhaps instead beginning as early as 1331 with
Kodaigo's initial rebellion. Now, this video is not going to cover the entirety of the Nanboku-cho,
but rather to highlight its significance in the grand scheme of Japanese history,
and specifically to this video and series, the way it affected Japan, setting the stage for the
later Sengoku period. The Nanboku-cho, like the later Sengoku, has been characterized as a period
of incessant war, a time where supporters of the northern court would continue to clash with
loyalists of the southern court as violence gripped the land far and wide. Only finally, coming to an
end by nearly the close of the 14th century, in large thanks to the efforts of the third Muromachi
shogun, Ashikaga Yoshimitsu, who was able to reconcile both courts, bringing them together
once more. But in terms of defining the impact the Nanboku-cho would have, I feel it is best
to look at the summarization of its impacts discussed by historian Thomas Conlon in his book,
State of War, the Violent Order of 14th Century Japan. The very fact that the war continued for
approximately 60 years during the 14th century necessitated a reordering of state and society,
much as did the five years of war during the 1180s. But although the older, shorter conflict
has received exhaustive attention, the latter wars proved more significant because they ensured that
state power would devolve to the provinces and that violence would become a legitimate means
of asserting judicial claims. A further innovation, less immediately obvious, was a new basis for
determining social status. Instead of being prescribed by those in authority, status came to
be based on performance and control over physical resources. The autonomy of warriors, bolstered by
their refusal to obey blindly the dictates of political authority, thrived in the environment
of a civil war during which two courts competed for support. Violence, likewise, became incorporated
into the fabric of daily life, as rights and statuses were defended or asserted by hard steel
instead of by notarized pieces of paper. Each war they waged unfolded according to its own
particular logic. Nevertheless, the tides of warfare altered what they created, for the
excessive cost of waging war eroded this very autonomy and allowed regional magnates, or shugo,
to achieve military and political dominance in the provinces. War's great constant is its
transformative power, for it leads to new associations and new attitudes.
Little was external to this war, and little was untouched by its powerful forces.
Fourteenth-century warfare transcended all contemporary boundaries and subverted political,
intellectual, and social norms. Furthermore, the process of its unfolding ensured that violence
would remain woven into the fabric of daily life for centuries to come. In sum, rather than being
an eddy of the sea of change, warfare was perhaps the tide, or the very ocean itself. It is doubtful
that Emperor Godaigo foresaw these consequences when he embarked upon his fateful uprising
in the autumn of 1331. The world was changing, and the instability caused by the Nanboku-cho
would ultimately lead to new social norms, perpetual and normalized violence, and the
transfer of power to warriors in the provinces. The Muromachi bakufu would never be able to
maintain complete authority, and following the reign of Yoshimitsu, each successive Ashikaga
shogun would shirk more and more away from their duties, embracing a life of luxury in the capital.
It was the perfect stage set for a new age of war, one which would last far longer and would
ultimately be more transformative than anything which had come before, this of course being the
eventual Sengoku period, an age in which warrior leaders would compete openly for regional dominance,
entire families would be snuffed out, betrayal would run rampant, and men born as peasants
could rise to become great lords of the land. It would take roughly 150 years and three successive
great unifiers to piece Japan back together, yet by then it would never be the same.
But this is the story of my main series.
I hope you enjoyed this updated, much improved version of my setting the stage series.
It was truly a joy to revisit these periods more thoroughly, diving deeper into the history
and reading more work done about these topics. I certainly learned a lot more in the process,
and I hope you did as well. In the weeks to come, I imagine I might come back to do a full series
recap, like I originally did for the first series. I hope to see you again there. But for now,
thank you so much for watching, and don't forget to like, subscribe, and ring that notification
bell if you enjoyed this video and found it to be most informative.