Art This Week-At the Kimbell-The Brothers Le Nain: Painters of Seventeenth-Century France

ArtEcho: Exploring Art History and Critique
24 followers
1 Video View·Aug 17, 2025
This week, we visit the Kimbell Art Museum and our interviewer, Aimee Cardoso, speaks with curators, CD Dickerson and Esther Bell about the exhibition, The Brothers Le Nain: Painters of Seventeenth-Century France. The exhibition is on view at the museum through September 11, 2016.
Hi, I'm Linda Mowell and welcome to Art This Week. On this week's episode, we visit the Kimbell Art Museum and our interviewer Amy Cardoso speaks with curators
C.D. Dickerson and Esther Bell about the exhibition The Brothers Lennon, Painters of 17th Century France. Now for Art This Week.
Hi, we're here at the Kimbell Art Museum to talk about the exhibition The Brothers Lennon.
I'm here with C.D. Dickerson, who's the curator and head of sculpture and decorative arts at the National Gallery of Art.
Thank you so much for joining us. Absolutely.
So this is the first exhibition that's dedicated to the Lennon brothers since the one at the Grand Palais in Paris in 1978.
What was inspiration for this contemporary exhibition of the painters now?
While I was here as curator,
I recognized that the Kimbell Art Museum had one of the very best paintings by the Brothers Lennon.
And we also had a tradition of doing exhibition series, scholarly focused exhibitions on
17th century painters. And since the Lennon had not been celebrated in any exhibition since 1978-79,
that it was high time to do an exhibition and it made natural sense that the Kimbell should be the venue for that exhibition.
So give us a little bit of background.
What was the 17th century like for the people of France from the peasants that are
quite often depicted in their work to the nobility?
It was a time when
there were many wars that were
ravaging the countryside at that point in time. The Thirty Years War,
primarily during the 1630s and 1640s, hit the north of France particularly hard.
And this was also the place where the Brothers Lennon had grown up.
So they probably had firsthand familiarity going back to their hometown, seeing the ravages of the war.
There was a lot of combat between Protestants and Catholics at this point in time,
which was another dynamic that was playing out.
The Catholic Reformation was in full swing and it was really largely a product of the Catholic Reformation
that the Lennon turned their sights on creating paintings like this one, which were really
means of propaganda for a certain element of the aristocracy to champion certain things like the
sanctity of the Holy Communion as well as the virtues of charity.
So we see numerous depictions, as you were saying, of French peasants in these works.
Do we know why this aspect, as you were saying, of course, Catholicism, a French society in the 1600s, was such a large part of
their artistic focus?
I mean, even in this exhibition, pretty much, you know, this whole room really has the peasants, so why was that such a big deal to them?
Again, in my essay in the catalogue,
I've tried to reconstruct their lives and not paint them as these sort of
former painters who come from small-town France. Which so many art historians have said.
Exactly.
That I tried to show that they were really quite plugged in to the high society of
Paris at that time and by virtue of their social connections,
they got in with a group of aristocrats who believed deeply in Catholic Reformation ideology.
And as a result of that, they began to paint the kind of imagery that I think responded to what these
groups of aristocrats were doing. I focused a lot of attention on this one fellow called Gaston de Rinty, who ran the most important
Counter-Reformation
organization in Paris at the time. And, you know, he tells in his letters and
his biographer tells of the fact that he would have peasants to his house every day. He would dress like a peasant,
he would serve them meals, his family would take part in these meals, and he would teach them about the communion, about the Eucharist.
So I think that's what's playing out in these paintings.
More of a propaganda.
Exactly. I mean, you look at a painting such as this one behind me,
it's large. So somebody had to come to the Le Nain and say, make me a large painting,
not just of peasants going about their daily life. This was something that was commissioned. I think it's driving a certain
spiritual element that these patrons wanted, not something that they would paint
small and then sell in the market on the street.
And you think a lot of these were possibly commissioned by Gaston himself or just people? No, we don't have any inventories that tell, but
clearly, I mean, he, I've done a little bit of research,
we don't have an inventory by him, but when he was young, before he had this spiritual concern,
he did collect art. So he may have had, you know, a taste for art.
But I can imagine a number of his rich female followers in particular
wanting commemorations of the kind of work they were doing in the world of charity.
So we don't know too much about their early life or their training.
In the catalogue, it mentions some foreign painter could have possibly trained them. Of course, there's no record of anything. Right, right, right.
But once they got to Paris, who were some of their contemporaries? What were they doing? How did they get involved with the nobility?
Well, I think the
links with the nobility may have come through the family. I mean, the father had sort of a minor role appointment,
so there could have been certain introductions that led higher and higher within court society. In terms of painters,
I think one that was important right off is Philippe de Champagne,
who was a Flemish painter who became kind of royal painter right
1630 when the Lenin arrived. And some of their earliest altarpieces reflect his style, which is more idealized and less naturalistic like theirs.
Painter Horatio Gentileschi, important follower of Caravaggio,
who was in Paris just before the Lenin seemed to have arrived, but a lot of his paintings stayed back.
They seemed to have focused in on him.
Valentin de Boulogne, who was another painter that followed Caravaggio.
Frenchman, a lot of his paintings had gone back from Rome to Paris and were in collections and would have been seen.
Simon Vuillet came back from Rome. Georges Latour was a painter that was working out in the east of France in Nancy.
There were a number of paintings coming into royal collections that they could have seen.
They didn't really need to travel necessarily to be able to have a full range of
stylistic influences at their disposal. And it does mention also in the catalogue that, is it Anne of Austria?
Mm-hmm. She was one who had her signature on some paperwork about getting one of them into the guild.
Yeah, very good. Can you talk about that a little bit?
When they first arrived in Paris, in order to work in Paris,
you had to belong to a guild and there were two guilds. You could either belong to the city guild of Paris,
but there was this little neighborhood that maintained some autonomy from the city of Paris and
also where all the foreign painters went because it seemed to be a bit easier to get into the painter's guild
of the Faubourg Saint-Germain. And on their matriculation papers, Anne of Austria sort of signs as their sponsor,
which was quite unique at that time.
So again, this is a big piece of evidence suggesting that somehow they came with really important entrees to the capital.
Thank you so much for your time. I appreciate it.
Hi, I'm here at the Kimbell Art Museum to talk about the exhibition's Brothers Le Nain with Esther Bell,
who's the curator in charge of European paintings at the Fine Arts Museum of San Francisco.
Thank you so much for joining us. My pleasure.
So it's written that this is the first known collaborative workshop and a few of these paintings are believed to be
collective in nature. Do we have any idea what prompted this way of working? It seems to be kind of a modern idea.
Right. Well, we know, for instance, that the Carracci brothers in Italy were very tight-knit and collaborated on certain commissions.
So it's not without precedent, but it is incredibly special.
They were unmarried. They were childless. They lived and worked together in a very tightly interwoven manner.
And it's something really incredibly unique to the 17th century in Paris.
So this exhibition looks at the three brothers as a group, like we're saying a collective,
but one can only try to separate the paintings into the different hands of each brother.
So there's a book, Le Galanterie de la Cour, that was written around this time period. Did that help you guys,
you know, give you any insight into which brother specializes in which painting or which parts of the painting?
Right. So the book that you mentioned is very interesting.
It's a fictional account of three brothers who live together, work together in Paris,
and we believe the account to be about Mathieu, Louis, and Antoine Leunen.
And we learned certain things from the book, for instance, that their paintings were collected,
that their large, grand history paintings were collected in Paris.
And that's something, for instance, that they're a little bit less known for.
And then the book also gives clues about, for instance, that Antoine likes to paint in miniature.
And the artist that we call Antoine Leunen
paints on copper with these tiny brush strokes. So it is helpful, but at the same time, it's not archival evidence.
So it only can be used so far.
So speaking about evidence and research, y'all went through some painstaking research.
Can you talk a little bit about that? And there's actually a room in this exhibition that's dedicated to kind of figuring out
which painting went to which painter, and like you were saying, Antoine with the miniatures.
Can you just talk a little bit about kind of the process that y'all went through?
Sure. Well, one of the important things that we did from the outset was that we hired an archivist
who is a really brilliant woman. Her name is Frédérique Lanouet, and she's a specialist of 17th century French painting.
And so we hired her to scour the archives in France.
And she was able to unearth some previously unknown documents about the Leunen,
which are, you know, original contributions to our catalog. And something that C.D. and I and our two
conservators, Clare Berry and Elyse Effman Clifford, did is that we examined these paintings up close,
many of them unframed, and we took thousands of digital images.
And so we used close looking and skills of connoisseurship to divide the paintings into three groups.
And we created something called an attribution map, which you see in the room
over there, in which we kind of show how our minds kind of parsed out the information.
And we feel pretty confident about the groups that we were able to determine.
So, moving on to the work itself, what do we know about their numerous commissioned projects,
including their altarpieces and their private devotionals?
How did they get the opportunity to work with people kind of in the nobility in order to create these?
Well, we're not
entirely certain how that first connection was made, especially when they arrive in France, or in Paris in 1629.
But they immediately are kind of in the orbit of Anne of Austria,
also likely Cardinal Mazarin, and we're not entirely certain how this happened.
And in terms of their commissions, there are some commissions that we know a little bit more about, and we've used kind of
clues to lead us. For instance, that wonderful St. Michael
altarpiece. We believe we know who commissioned that painting
by the clues around the moment.
And so it depends on which painting we're talking about.
So a lot of times we can make very educated guesses about the patrons who commissioned the specific work.
Well, for the St. Michael one, for instance.
Right, so we believe that it was,
it is a commemoration of a battle, a military victory of Louis XIII's army
against the Spanish troops in a town called Lucat on the Mediterranean coast.
So we wonder if it was the king's commander who commissioned the painting. And we, you know, we wonder this because this
man
was a member, along with his wife, of the
Compagnie du Saint-Sacrement,
and we believe that some of the Linnel's patrons were part of this religious order.
So it's our educated guess that he would be the commissioner. Right, which is all you have because there's no documentation.
It's very, very little. Yes, very little.
And so then earlier when we were walking through, you talked about the painting, the Nativity of the Virgin, that's from Notre Dame.
Yes. And in the catalogue it talked about this debate that came up after it was exhibited in Paris.
And Pierre Rosenberg claims that it represents a collaboration between two of the brothers, in which half of the painting was done by one brother
and the other half
by the other. Yes. Can you tell us a little bit about that debate and the research?
So, Pierre Rosenberg is the former director of the Louvre and is a member of the Académie Française and is a great
mentor to both C.D. and myself. He's one of the greatest living art historians and a wonderful scholar of the Linnel brothers
and someone who we greatly respect. He actually wrote the preface for our catalogue.
And so he believes that, yes, the Notre Dame altarpiece is a sign of collaboration, and he published an article
many years ago in which he kind of outlines which parts were done by Louis and Mathieu and etc.
C.D. and I believe that it likely is
perhaps more the product of a single brother, maybe with a little bit of intervention by the others.
And we come to that conclusion by just very carefully looking. And that's one of the things about the Linnel brothers is that there are a lot of
differing opinions, a lot of debate about which brother painted what. And so it's a very healthy debate, I would say.
All right. Well, thank you so much for your time. I really appreciate it.
We want to thank C.D. and Esther for speaking with us. For more information on the exhibition, go to kimballart.org.
That's it for Art This Week. Thanks for watching.
