Diamonds in Meteorites ☄️ Carbonado Diamonds & Lonsdaleite Diamond (learn the truth) Scott McGregor

Gold Silver and Gemstone - Secret to Success
6 followers
8 Video Views·Aug 15, 2025
0:00 Intro to Scott McGregor
1:47 Nano-Diamonds in meteorites
3:07 How it all starts
4:07 Cutting Ureilites w/diamonds
4:45 Canyon Diablo graphite nodule
8:18 Lonsdaleite diamond
10:45 What are Carbonado diamonds?
13:30 Where are Carbonado diamonds found / why?
Hello everyone and welcome.
We are putting our thinking caps on and we are going to learn today.
We're going to have a little bit of an impromptu meteorite 101 and this is a topic that I know
virtually nothing about. That's why I'm asking a friend of mine, Scott McGregor,
who's on the Knowledge Bullseye crew and he's been with us for several years now
to give us a little bit of knowledge. We haven't covered it on this channel before and it's
something I constantly get hit up in the comments about. Everyone says they have diamonds in
meteorites. They have Lonsdale lights. They have Carbonado diamonds and the thing is I don't know
enough to even have that conversation with them. Scott, maybe you can tell us a little bit. First
of all, thanks for joining us and sharing your information with us. I really appreciate it.
Happy to be here.
The three things, I'm going to let you loose. There's no leash tonight at all. I know the
three things that we kind of talked about you going over today and educating us about and
setting expectations really about the three things, Carbonado diamonds, Lonsdale light
diamonds and diamonds in other meteorites like Canon Diablo. With that, I hope that was a worthy
introduction. Please, if you would, Scott, educate us and myself.
Thanks, Topher. The motivation for this is there are just so many fake diamond meteorites out
there. If you search any of the eBay or Etsy or any of those, you diamond meteorite, oh my god,
the stuff that comes up is so blatantly fake and it's really disappointing. The fact that
this stuff sells and people end up buying it. It turns out that diamonds do occur in meteorites.
They are common in some types of meteorites, but usually they're what are called nano diamonds,
which means really, really, really small. You don't even see them. Some are bigger and we'll
talk about some of the bigger ones in a little bit here, but there's sort of three main groups
of meteorites where you can find diamonds. The first one are Uralites. Uralites are between
5% or 10% carbon themselves. The highly shocked Uralites, where they've faced a lot of physical
impact and other things, will often have these nano diamonds in them. It's not much to see. If
you have an electron microscope, you can see them, but generally you'd need a pretty powerful
loop or microscope to see the nano diamonds in Uralites. You know they're there.
Scott, if we can, I apologize. Can we just take one step back
and talk about the creation of diamonds? There's two things that are required for creation of
diamonds. Maybe we can just start from that very entry level and I'm sorry if you pick up from
there. Diamonds are basically carbon. They're just an altered form of carbon that's a lot prettier
than charcoal. They are formed generally under high pressure and high temperature. We're not
of pressure here and so that will turn carbon, if it's compacted enough under sufficient pressure,
it will transform into a prettier material diamond. Now diamonds are still carbon. You
could make a nice little campfire out of diamonds if you were so willing. They burn just fine,
same as charcoal, but they have that property that they're extremely hard and that's what's
interesting about them. So for example, when diamonds are in meteorites, you'll often hear
from people who cut meteorites how they hate it when they're diamonds and meteorites because
they get very hard to cut. So people who've cut Uralites, some Uralites that are not shocked
but fairly easily, some are really hard to cut and it takes a long time to do so.
The other category of iron, the other category of meteorites that have diamonds in them,
one is irons, especially those with graphite inclusions and I'm going to talk about those
and then I'm going to talk about carbonado diamonds, which are diamonds themselves.
And so let me screen share here and I'll talk a little bit about these. This is a graphite nodule
and it is a normal graphite nodule that you would find in Canyon Diablo. These nodules,
they're quite pretty actually. They have the black graphite there and you can see the white,
that's actually reflecting metal. So it's a combination of the iron and the black graphite.
And these are the typical ones, are found all over, they typically weather out of some of the
larger Canyon Diablo meteorites and they cut like butter. Graphite is extremely soft, think of it
like pencil lead. It is trivial to cut and there's not that much metal in it, you know, the wire saw
or the saw blade just slices through these. Now, if you have a meteorite, one of these graphite
nodules that is heavily shocked and especially right around the rim of the crater, that was the
maximum pressure, maximum heat, maximum impact, right around the very rim of the crater, you get
something that looks completely different and it looks like, it looks like this. And it's quite
different than the other and you can see that it was intensely shocked. You see all those sort of
metal traces that sort of lost the seams and now they're really agitated looking. Look at it more
closely here, you can see this. And this was hit sufficiently hard that some of that graphite
got converted into diamond. And you can't really see it here. You can see within the black areas
that there's some sort of like granule looking things. That's diamond in there. It's not real
easy to see because the diamond is mixed with the graphite and so it's a dark color. It's not like a,
you know, crystal sparkling clear thing to see. It's more charcoal looking but there are diamonds
in there. And Craig's Lyman cut this and it was interesting because there's an email exchange
going on over what is this and so forth. And I'm going to read an excerpt from Craig's email. I
think it would just be fun here. Craig says, this thing is truly uncuttable. It tore teeth off a
bandsaw blade, bent lapidary blades and ate wire like it was breakfast cereal. I couldn't cut it,
so I sent it to Martin Sills who couldn't cut it either. And he sent it back to me and I ultimately
just kept burning wire until after eight days on the wire saw it was finally cut. And he says
sanding was equally difficult. So it's really hard to cut something if what you're cutting it with
isn't as hard, is only as hard as what you're cutting. So that's the challenge on this.
Wow. That is so fascinating.
So again, it's not beautiful diamonds like you would wear on a ring, but there's significant
diamond content in this. And what I'm going to show you is what happens if it gets even more
shocked. So this is one that was found fairly recently and was studied at ASU and it's kind
of interesting. Oh, by the way, this is a closeup of the last one, sorry. So you can see a little
bit of the structure there. Apologize. So if you shock it even more, you get something that
looks like this. Wow.
And you can see that the metal is now completely disorganized. It's no longer it seems or you
can't even see where it used to be organized. Total disruption, yeah.
Total disruption and scattering here. And what's interesting is if you zoom in on this,
now you can actually see the diamond areas here. And so those sort of crystalline looking things
in the middle there that look in seams, appear in seams, those are diamonds, but those are also
Lonsdaleite. And let me explain the difference between diamonds and Lonsdaleite. So diamonds
have a cubic crystalline structure, octahedral crystalline structure. And Lonsdaleite is a
different, it's a hexagonal structure. And it is on some axes, harder than diamond.
If you catch it on edge, if you catch it right in the center against the plate, it's not as hard
as a diamond. But if you're using it as an abrasive or something like that, it would be
harder than diamond because you'll catch some of those edges. So Lonsdaleite occurs in meteorites
that are extremely, extremely shocked. There's some great studies on this, but they never appear
as large things. So if anybody tells you that they have Lonsdaleite, in fact, I think if you
look on eBay, there's some like these white golf ball looking things and they sell them as Lonsdaleite.
What those are, those are alumina ceramic mill balls. So in grinding mills for when they grind
powders and things like that, they dump in all these nearly indestructible ceramic balls and
they crush them all around and it grinds things up. They're extremely hard. They have a hardness
of nine or higher on the Mohs scale. So they're like sapphire hard, but they're not diamond hard.
And they're not diamond and they're definitely not Lonsdaleite. Lonsdaleite gets to be about
as big as one millimeter. So anybody selling you Lonsdaleite bigger than a millimeter,
I don't think so. I appreciate you calling that out by detail because again, that's one of the
things that we're trying to do here in the Knowledgeable Live channel is make sure that
we're getting accurate information and also attacking the misinformation. And there are so
many people, so many pictures associated with Lonsdaleite that are not Lonsdaleite that the
web is almost useless for teaching you now. It's full of so much bad information that if you
search for it, you're going to get these little mill balls thrown at you all day.
So if people tell you that they have meteoric diamonds and they're bigger than a millimeter
or two, okay, they're probably false with one exception. And we're going to talk about that now.
That's Carbonado diamonds. And Carbonado diamonds are interesting because
they found them and they didn't think they were extraterrestrial originally.
They used them for industrial abrasives. It's kind of fun because they would find these in
streams mostly in Brazil and also in Central Africa. And they would crush them and they'd
use them for abrasives. And they're very good at abrasives. But if you facet them,
they look black and opaque. And you may actually see fine jewelry with black diamonds in it.
And those are often natural Carbonados. They can also be treated other diamonds, but often they're
the black Carbonados. And they're not very big typically. They can get larger. This is a
Carbonado diamond. And I'm going to switch to screen share so you'll be able to see it a little
better. But this is a relatively big Carbonado diamond. This is 3.3 grams. And that would be
16.7 carats of Carbonado diamond. And let me go to screen share here and I'll say a little more
on this. This is very exciting for me because I've heard about these so much. And I've had so
many people communicate with me saying they have them, but they're, you know, dump truck size.
So Carbonado diamonds are Carbonado basically means carbon or charcoal in Spanish. And they
were named because they look like charcoal. And if anybody shows you, they say, oh, it's a
Carbonado diamond and it doesn't look this color. It's not a Carbonado diamond. And they typically
have this sort of interesting metallic, almost glassy sheen to them. They've been weathered over
time. They're about 1.9 billion years old, landing on earth a very long time ago. So they
had plenty of time to weather. But, you know, because they're pretty tough, they don't weather
like a typical rock would after 1.9 billion years. But they have this unusual sort of metallic color.
And here's another angle on it. You can sort of see they have that, again, semi glassy look.
And you can, after you've seen a few of these, you can instantly look at a Carbonado diamond and
it's real or not. It's even easier to tell, you know, the difference between like mold-a-bite,
real mold-a-bite versus fake mold-a-bite. Fake Carbonado diamonds just simply don't have this
sort of look. And it's interesting because they're found in Brazil, Bahia, Brazil,
and Central African Republic. And you say, well, those are like 2,000 miles away.
What's going on? Well, if you wind time back to 1.9 billion years ago, the earth
looked a lot different and had merged continents back then. And South America and Africa were
actually up against each other. And you have a single strewn field across Brazil and Central
African Republic. And then they drifted apart, separated by, again, the tectonic plates moving.
So the best theory on these, and it's not completely proven, there is a theory that
they're terrestrial, but that doesn't really check because they have extraterrestrial isotopes
and they have predominantly hydrogen in them, whereas earth diamonds have more nitrogen in them.
So the ratio of elements in them isn't right. The isotopes aren't right. And these Carbonado
diamonds are not found in pegmatic veins, which is where all the rest of the terrestrial
diamonds are found. So very different in that sense. Some people said, well,
maybe it's radiation and the radiation caused the carbon to form diamonds.
That's my least favorite theory. And there's another theory they're formed by impact,
meaning that an asteroid hit in earth and hit some carbon deposits or had carbon deposits in it
and formed these. That has some merit. It must have been really big because you saw the ones
in Canyon Diablo were millimeter sized. So imagine how big it must have been to produce,
you know, things like this. That must have been something. And Steve Haggerty published a paper,
a couple of papers actually, and his theory is that they were formed in a supernova.
And that's a very interesting theory because it would allow them to be quite large.
It would allow the, it would certainly explain where you got enough pressure and heat to form
something like this. I think supernova definitely checks the box on pressure and heat. And they
could theoretically be up to a kilometer in size if that was how it formed. And imagine a meteorite
or an asteroid that was primarily Carbonado hitting the earth. It would shatter. Diamond
is very brittle. Shatter them all over. And so you might have had an event where a large Carbonado
asteroid hit right around what was then Brazil and Central Africa and created this occurrence.
So very interesting things. This is, again, it's not proven. It's probably meteoric.
I'd say high odds on it. That's the best theory these days, either from impact or from
the supernova theory, but work in progress. But it's definitely a fun thing. So in summary,
if you see meteorites for sale somewhere and they claim diamonds, if they're bigger than a millimeter
or two or Lahn's delight, unlikely unless it's a Carbonado. Carbonados look like charcoal. They're
not usually very big and they have that glassy look. If they don't have that glassy look,
probably not real. So caveat emptor. Fantastic. A little Latin with you today.
I really appreciate you digging into that and give us some examples. And the the
gradation of shock in the Canyon Diablo was cool to witness in the graphite nodule from basically
a normal one of cutting like butter to one that took eight days to cut. And it literally shows
it explains to me visually it's the same exact material. It just went through different events,
shock events that caused the same exact composition to be transformed into another
assemblage. And that's really all we're talking about when you boil it down. Exactly. Well, Scott,
thank you so much for your time. I think we're going to check in with Sue for a chat check
to see if we have any crew questions. The Lahn's delight is in plates that we are seeing on the
edge. Pat asked that a while ago. Yeah, the Lahn's delight is embedded within the diamond. It's a
mix of Lahn's delight and diamond. It isn't like in a separate region or zone. So that's why you
see it intermixed. And if you look at the Garvey paper on that, they have some SEM pictures on that
and you can see that it's it's intermixed and it's like little little dots of Lahn's delight
embedded within graphite and diamond all mixed. So sort of a slurry with a little Lahn's delight
in it. It's not like you get a Lahn's delight crystal. It's more you have to use X-ray diffraction
to prove it's there. I think that's really important to remember and focus on. We also
talk about the exact same thing. It's not a garnet or a ruby that's sitting there in the
middle of a diamond like a geode you crack open. When Mike did his 101 on colors of the rainbow
or gems and meteorites, we were talking about microscopic stuff. And that's exactly
we started the conversation today with Scott emphasizing the word nanodiamonds. And
I want to close loop with that as well. We're talking about nano everything, super small,
not gem quality, clear diamonds that you're going to put on your girl's ring. We're talking about
dirty industrial type looking diamonds. Scott, once again, thank you very much for being our
guest tonight and taking us through the reality of diamonds in meteorites. So thanks a lot,
everyone. Remember, if this is the kind of education and entertainment you enjoy,
we would really like you to support us on Patreon or on YouTube. If not, enjoy tonight, guys. Bye.
