Transcending Time & Space Through Temples: From Bharat to Cambodia | Dr. Ujjwala Khot-Palsuley |

Southeast Asia: Geography, History and Culture
27 followers
2 Video Views·Aug 15, 2025
In this illuminating conversation, Dr. Ujwala Khot Palsuleji explores the sacred continuity between Indian and various Southeast Asian Countries particularly Cambodian temple architecture between the 9th and 13th centuries—a golden era for temple construction in both regions, revealing how structures like Angkor Wat represent "India Outside India." The talk highlights how temples functioned as administrative, educational, and cultural centers beyond mere worship spaces, and examines how the Chola dynasty's naval activities facilitated architectural exchange.
So 9th to 13th century is a golden time for temple architecture in India, also temple
architecture in Southeast Asia and especially in Cambodia, Gorwad is the largest religious
precinct in the world as nominated by UNESCO.
But eventually the belief also got shifted from Vishnu or Shiva to Buddha.
I will not call it Hinduism to Buddhism.
This is a shift, very, you know, a very subtle shift where nothing changed architecturally.
It is just people started worshipping Buddha instead of Vishnu and Shiva.
Every temple has a sthalavruksham.
So these sthalavrukshams are like, you know, the trees which are locally grown which impact
the microclimate of a temple.
So that's why when we enter a temple, there is a different experience.
Namaste!
Welcome to Sangam Talks.
In today's discussion, we would be discussing about India's architecture and how in our
history architecture has played a great role in civilizational prospects, not only within
the Bharatiya perspective but also how it transcended to the Southeast Asia and other
parts of Asia.
And how our temple architecture played a greater role in the political administration, in economic
pursuits and all.
Today we have with us Dr. Ujwala Khot Palsuleji, who is a globally recognized conservation
architect, cultural historian and founder of Samrachana.
She travels across Asia and conducts travel tours, specifically focused on temple architecture,
its conservation and also its research.
So welcome to Sangam Talks ma'am.
Namaste!
Ma'am, I would like to know about your pursuits.
What motivated you to shift or what motivated you to take temple conservation or temple
architecture as a means of subject?
So, to start with, this whole journey of pursuing temple architecture as a major subject started
very early in my life.
It is both because of the inquisitiveness, because of the curiosity as well as this interest
in how temple architecture is constructed all across India.
And the reason was my father was into government's job and he used to avail this scheme called
LTC.
And we used to travel every couple of years to different locations to visit different
cities, heritage cities.
What was interesting in this whole journey was not just visiting these places, but he
used to make sure that we meet local historians, local archaeologists, local scholars and local
people, artists and all, so that we understand these sites in a better way.
And my mother being an artist herself, she has a very keen aptitude towards details,
you know, sculptures, local art and craft.
So all these discussions on site eventually developed my interest towards heritage sites.
So when eventually the time came to select career, architecture was the very natural
way of progression.
Also because that was the step to get into architectural conservation, which was my very
obvious choice of career.
So I did my graduation master's from School of Planning and Architecture, New Delhi.
I also got an opportunity to get MPhil degree from Lund University, Sweden.
And that was the time when I visited Cambodia for the first time.
Eventually when I started working in conservation, I realized that temple architecture is something
which is misinterpreted or not really explored in India, the way it should be.
And when I visited Cambodia, that is the time when, that was the time when I really understood
that this is the place where I really want to explore temple architecture into.
And then eventually it became my passion to work in temple architecture of Cambodia, its
influences from India or across various regions of India.
And that's how this whole journey has been.
And since last 25 years, I have been working on temple architecture, influences of temple
architecture of India on Southeast Asia with a bigger focus on temples from Dravida region,
the southern part of India to Cambodia.
So that is how this has happened.
So when we talk about temples in Bharat and also in Southeast Asia countries, we see
that temple is also an administrative center, also a center of economic pursuits, a center
of knowledge, center of learning.
So it's all, it's the hub or it's the center of the entire civilization of that particular
occasion.
So, but when we see in a perspective, like when the Indian style of architecture is seen
also in the place like Cambodia, Java, Sumatra, etc.
What message does it carry when we also find temples similar to India are being found in
Cambodia?
What message does it carry and how do we need to see it?
So like you said, you know, this is what I meant when I said temple architecture is not
really dwelled into the way it should be because temples are not really only spaces of worship.
That is the narrative which is given to us by the colonial authors.
Temples used to be these administrative centers, the social cultural centers, a very important
center for law and order.
You know, these were the courts.
So the temple itself was all inclusive, you know, that was the nucleus of a settlement
and that's why we see many temples all across all the settlements in India because those
were the places where schools used to run, gurukulams are there, there are, you know,
people who are learning Vedas, Vedangas and other Shastras, there are schools which are
teaching Dharmashastra.
So that is one aspect of temple.
The other aspect of temple is cultural continuity.
So like dance forms, like Tanjavur is very famous for Bharatanatyam and that is the origin
of Bharatanatyam also and Tanjavur temple has 108 Karanas carved on the temple itself.
So likewise, it is all inclusive.
Temple used to be a very important center where kings used to sit and conduct his courts
and we don't see in Indian context palaces of kings.
We only see temples, royal temples like Brihadeshwara temple.
So that is the context for Indian temples in India and when we look at temples in South
East Asia, these temples are also their political, socio-cultural, administrative centers and
now this is, you know, the compartmentalization that we are looking at, you know, social,
cultural or administrative.
So the time that we are looking at, say around 2000 years ago, when these temples were flourishing
in South East Asia or even in India, it is a fluid thing, you know, everything is interrelated,
everything is overlapping with each other.
So these Cambodian temples are also constructed as important political centers.
These are important cultural centers and educational centers.
Just to name like in Angkor Wat temple, we get many Sanskrit inscriptions which talk
about the number of books which are preserved in the library of Angkor Wat or how many students
are learning there, what is the, you know, the background of teachers who are teaching
in that institution.
So there are many such temples in Cambodia also which record all these things.
They also maintain records of their treasury, they maintain records of their agricultural
producers, how they are dealing with taxes.
So all of that is recorded in temple inscriptions and that is the continuity that we are looking
at.
So, you know, not just the architecture of it, but how these spaces were utilized and
how this overlapping happened, how this continuity was carried from generations after generations
for almost 1500 years.
So starting from 1st century till 15th century, we see this continuity in both these regions,
India as well as Cambodia and that is one of the influences that we see.
I mean that is not the direct influence, but the cultural continuity, the civilizational
continuity that we see all across the cultural region of India and Cambodia.
I would like to take a moment to go back to into the political history wherein along with
administrative politics, along with the pursuits for kingdoms, the temple architecture also
travelled to Southeast Asia.
So could you give a glimpse about how the Cholas, the Pandyas were in pursuit of travelling
to Southeast Asia and how temple architecture became a symbol of their pursuits?
Okay, to answer this, I would start with Indian temple architecture because when we look at
Indian temples, the start point of Indian temples, the structural temples that we see,
starting from 1st century BC, we get structural evidences of temples and eventually by 5th
6th century, we get sites like Pattadakkalaihoe, Badami or even in North India, we have Udayagiri
which is in Madhya Pradesh.
All these sites were experimenting with temple architecture.
So how a temple should be, what is the language, architectural language of a temple.
So the overall aim of constructing temple is, it is a replica of a macrocosm or the
universe into a microcosm and there are many permutation combinations which this Sthapatis
have experimented with and that these sites show us all these experiments and eventually
by the end of 8th century, we see a good model of a temple, fully constructed, fully developed
temple in India.
But after 8th century, we get a larger temples in history of temple architecture like Brihadeshwara
temple, Gangaikonda, Cholapuram.
These temples are more public temples, these are like, you know, royal temples because
these are, not only because these are constructed by royal family but these were constructed
to accommodate more and more people in the premises of a temple and eventually…
It's a temple city in its own way.
Yes, and all these temples, so this also shows us how social conditions have changed.
So from a singular or, you know, from a very private worship that used to happen earlier,
now this is more of a, you know, larger festivals or more celebrations in the temple, more cultural
identity related to temple like dance and like I said, you know, agricultural activities.
Everything is happening within the premises of temples and similarly, after 8th century,
we see larger temples like Brihadeshwara in southern part of India, we see Lingaraja temple,
Sun temple Konark in Kalinga region, we see Somanatha temple or other temples like Sun
temple Modhira in western India, northern India we see Khajuraho group of temples.
So all these temples are like epitome of temple architecture in India.
Now when we look at Indian temple architecture in Cambodia, they also have their own journey
of evolution.
So they started since 1st century AD, we see footprints of Indic culture or Hindu culture
in Cambodia.
So we see, you know, Sanskrit inscriptions, Sanskrit as a language of their royal codes,
their political, all the endeavours, we see Shaka era being used as their normal calendar
system, Varmana title being used by the kings as a honorary title for their kings, which
is also very similar to Indian context and we see very smaller footprints of singular
temples like only Garbhagriha or temple constructed as part of larger ashramas.
So these references are there from 1st century to 5th century.
Now 5th century onwards, there is a revival in their political system.
So there is a kingdom called Shenla, which unified the larger Kambuja desha and we see
slightly, you know, temples with more evolved architecturally.
These evolved temples have Garbhagriha mandapa, Mukha mandapa, enclosure wall.
So slightly better of architectural than earlier temples, which are just Garbhagriha temples.
But after 8th century, they also have a political shift and now there is a king called Jayavarmana
II.
He shifts from Java to Cambodia.
He declares himself as a Chakravarti Samrat of Kambuja desha.
Now during this time, the Cambodian region, the Kambuja desha is currently Cambodia, Laos,
Thailand, Vietnam, Singapore, Malaysia and some part of Indonesia.
So this is the huge cultural, huge region which was under Kambuja desha and Jayavarmana
also brought with him a different way of looking at temple architecture.
So he wanted to construct temple as a nucleus of city and every king afterwards started
constructing this nucleus for the city, which is a temple.
Now this temple would have, it becomes a center of that city enclosed with multiple
layers of settlement and all of this is abiding by the rules of temple construction or city
planning principles, which are given in our Shastras, which are followed in India and
they are, they have modified it, suiting the culture, the landscape of that place.
So we see, you know, some amalgamation of local landscape with Shastras overlapped on
it, a different city form, which is exact square in shape, at the center of it is temple,
which will be constructed on a higher platform or they will construct a platform to have
it on a higher locus and that's how this temple cities are constructed after 802 AD.
So he actually wanted to sanctify the whole land of Kambuja desha using temple as a medium
to do it and eventually we see temples dedicated to Shiva, Vishnu, Harihara and temples constructed
as astronomical centers, temple constructed as observatories, as a place where which is
exclusively institution in itself to teach Vedas.
So likewise there are kings who are constructing these temples year after year up to 14th century
and that's how we see this journey going simultaneously.
Now coming back to the political history, kings have always been in association with
Kambuja desha, the kings who are ruling in India.
So they have this to and fro trade with Kambuja desha, being, Kambuja being in a center for
trade route from India to China.
So we, the very popular silk route that is, you know, known to everybody, the route started
from China, it went to the Western world up to Rome, but there are many smaller routes
also to this larger silk route.
So, these smaller routes are, they are either sea routes, so China, South East Asia, India
and then through inland port, it will go to the Western coast of India and then it will
go to Rome.
So, in this context, the way India got benefited because of the trade between China and Rome.
Similarly, Cambodia also became a major hub of trade because of the trade between India
and China.
And now all the kings that we are looking at from 1st century till about 10th century,
they have this conversation going on with Cambodian kings and with China because that
is the best place for them to keep their ships, to halt there, they have beautiful ports there,
they have all conducive environment to keep their port or a halting station at Cambodia.
What happened in 1025 AD, which changed this whole scenario about trade and ports in South
East Asia is till 9th century, everybody is working independently.
So, Kambuja Desha is independent, there is a Shama dynasty, there is a Champa dynasty,
there are Srivijaya dynasty, Tram-Tamra-Lipti, all of these are part of South East Asian
dynasties.
Here in India, we have Chola dynasty, so Chola's, Raja Raja Chola who constructed Bhradeshwara
temple has very keen eye on how this trade is happening between India to China and how
all these trade routes, sea routes are managed by Srivijaya dynasty, which is currently Indonesia.
So, Indonesia has all of these smaller islands and there are these bottlenecks.
So, all these bottlenecks were handled by Srivijaya dynasty, these were monitored, taxed
by Srivijaya dynasty.
Now, Raja Raja Chola's son of Raja Raja Chola, Rajendra Chola, he was extremely ambitious
and he knew how to streamline these things.
So, he was ambitious also because he wanted to annex lot of these kings like Kalinga or
even he went up to Pala dynasty, he brought Ganga from there to the southern part of India,
he constructed Ganga-Konda Cholapuram to celebrate his victory.
Along with that, he also had a close eye on what is happening in South-East Asia as part
of their political policies.
So, what happened during this time is 1025 AD, Kambuja Desha has a king called Suryavarmanavan,
he is extremely powerful, very much likes Rajendra Chola, you know ambitious and he
consolidated his kingdom, he consolidated Vietnam, all of these surrounding countries
which we see today, part of Kambuja Desha.
Now, slowly gradually he started attacking Shri Vijaya's ports and Shri Vijaya retaliated
obviously because Shri Vijaya is known for, it is a sea-faring kingdom, they are ruling
from sea because they are owning up all these ports in South-East Asia.
So, as Khamer king Suryavarmanavan started attacking ports of Shri Vijaya, Shri Vijaya
along with Tamra-Lipti dynasty, they retaliated this attack.
Now during this time, to support Khamer's, Rajendra Chola started his naval expedition
towards South-East Asia and he conquered these, he defeated Shri Vijaya dynasty and these
benefited Khamer's in a way.
So, Khamer's and Chola's, though they were not alliance, direct in alliance, but because
of the expedition which happened from southern part of India, Kuru-Mandala coast to the Shri
Vijaya dynasty, these Shri Vijaya and Tamra-Lipti got defeated.
Eventually Khamer's and Chola's, they got control of all these ports and all these bottlenecks
which were very prominent, important, significant for the trade between India to China and they
made lot of these policies eventually.
They made Nagapattinam a free port, they made these import-export policies very clear between
India and South-East Asia, which is Khamer's now and China and all of these, because of
this political change 1025 onwards, for next 50 years, all the ports were under control
of Chola's and Khamer's directly or indirectly and that is the time when we see larger temples
getting constructed in both the regions and this prosperity which is gained because of
the trade, control on trade, control on these, you know, the ports which are there, import-export
became very frequent between China and South-East Asia to India, again to Rome.
We see southern part of India getting flourished, extremely prosperous because of the trade,
lot of people are settling in southern part of India.
So Nagapattinam is like a metropolitan, there are many people who are coming from China
and South-East Asia and getting settled in Nagapattinam or Mamallapuram.
So we have records which tell us that people knew multiple languages so that they could
interact with different, you know, multicultural people, there were fortifications, they had
added few places, surrounding places to Nagapattinam so that it becomes a larger administrative
centre to cater to the infrastructural requirement of trade which is happening at Nagapattinam.
So these are also, you know, architectural advancements that we see during this time.
So 9th to 13th century is a golden time for temple architecture in India, also temple
architecture in South-East Asia and especially in Cambodia because after Suryavarmanabhan's
reign, around 50 years after that, we see the largest temple getting constructed in
Cambodia which is Angkor Wat temple, exactly after, you know, 53 years of Suryavarmanabhan's
reign and that is how these, you know, political will, their understanding of the geopolitics
of that period, understanding of commercial policies that they could devise to enhance
prosperity.
This all came together to give prosperity to both these regions and they worked in alliance
for a long time.
That was wonderful insight because not many know that Cambodia was at one point of time
a catalyst between China and India when it comes to trade.
In the meanwhile, something went wrong when the British turned up and they had their own
distortions to introduce, they had their own misappropriation of knowledge, myths to spread
and so what do you think is the most damaging myth which was spread by the British when
it comes to temple architecture, when it comes to spiritual pursuits, when it comes to the
holistic approach that we had towards temples?
When British rule started in India, the colonial rule started in India, the first and foremost,
you know, much discussed topic about distortion is about education system which is distorted
during their time.
Apart from the main education system which was there in India, which was again temples
were at the centre of this education system.
So we had Guru Kulams, we were, you know, everybody was offered with education irrespective
of their status in the society, that link got disturbed because of the British rule
and very importantly, the way we used to look at temples or the culturally there is a system
of understanding of temples in India.
So every Hindu knows, knew what temples were like, what is the role of temple in the society,
in, you know, society as in their personal lives, their, you know, their work wise, you
know, everybody has to visit temple for one or the other reason.
But eventually after this colonial invasion, the biggest problem which arose was this disconnection
of society from temples because all the literature that we get from colonial period, they talk
about temples in isolation, they talk about temple as sacred space, spaces of worship,
whereas this whole concept of worshipping in Hindu religion is very different from what
we find in other religions.
So when they started comparing temples with say mosques or churches, the whole objective
or the whole perspective of looking at temples have changed and in last 200 years, starting
from 1810, this, whatever is published by the western authors starting from Ferguson,
they have not understood the essence of temple itself because temples, the way they looked
at it is more of an aggression of spaces or you know, lot of spaces added irrelevantly
within the temple premises, a lot of sculptures which they didn't understand why these are
there and what is the relevance of these sculptures, what are the stories carved on the temples,
what is the significance of the different parts of temples.
So they started explaining these temples only physically.
So the documentation which Ferguson has done in his book, which is published in first in
1850s, 1860s, republished in 1910, this book talks about a very drastic Aryan-Dravidian
divide.
It talks about very stringent Nagara and Dravida divide, temple architecture.
He actually divides it into two parts.
He divides it into Buddhism, Jainism, Hinduism.
Another thing is after Ferguson also, whatever people have explained, you know, all these
scholars who explained temple architecture, they only talk about the physicality of temple,
certain type of temple columns, certain type of temple motifs or dynasties.
So this is all again in compartments that we see and the understanding developed is
only about one compartment of dynasties, one compartment of elements, one compartment of
certain spaces within temples because there is no relation with people, there is no relationship
with rituals, there is no relationship with the continuity of culture, which is because
of the temples and because of this segregation, even the later scholars or later architects
started looking at temples as one, either it is very complex.
So you know, don't touch him because these are extremely complex entities and secondly,
they are monuments or they are center of pilgrimage or tourism.
So, these are different perspectives which emerged because of this lack of understanding
of temples holistically and that holistic understanding was disturbed because of the
colonial invasion in between and this link completely broke in say early 18th century,
19th century and it is still going on because even today people don't realize what is the
importance of a temple in society, it is again seen in isolation, it is seen as a site to
be visited once in a while or irrespective of or eliminating all other cultural aspects
related to temple and that is the biggest disadvantage of last 200 years of colonial
rule as well as later on which people followed as a continuity of that literature which was
published earlier.
So, without understanding the essence of the temple, without understanding the spiritual
or the scientific aspects of the temple, the British or the western perspective saw
the temples as mere stone.
But at some point of time, they had an understanding that this is beyond that.
But still they tried to hide something about it.
What do you think was the strategic thing which they thought this needs to be hidden
or this needs to be distorted, destroyed so that their colonial rule can be implemented
in a better way?
What do you think?
See, I think the biggest strategy was they wanted to destroy because they knew the whole,
the soul of Indian culture lies in temples and without having that understanding, they
would not arrive at this strategy of destroying this culture, through eliminating temples
from the society.
Afterwards what we see during colonial time, what happened is because they understood that
this is how this culture is working or the continuity is through temples, eliminating
temples or separating temples from the society, separating culture or even naming them as
only sacred or only dividing them based on styles, dividing them based on dynasties,
dividing them even based on how people are entering into a temple, different divides
that were created during this time affected a lot of how Indians look at temples.
So this westernized perspective of looking at temples is what has been followed for a
long time and this westernized perspective is dividing or compartmentalizing lot of things
which were not there earlier.
So they created this divide with even the intellectual properties, even the cultural
continuities that we had, even the north and south dance forms, cultural reforms, the literature
which is available, which was earlier there, Shastra.
So they tried to divide.
The iconography.
Yeah, so they had this understanding of temples, they knew it is much beyond what is the physicality
of a temple, but deliberately they secluded it or they created whole generations after
generations of people who now don't know what temples are all about.
We are completely disassociated from the original concept of temple, why temples were constructed,
how they were important centers of society at one point in time and now they are completely
into isolation, they are just monuments or they are just some entity, physical entity
for the settlements today.
You gave us a political history as to how long with political pursuits architecture
also traveled to Cambodia and how it took shape there and how Hindu thought or Sanatana
Dharma spread there also and how several of the iconography are also seen there and how
gradually there was also diminishing of such architectures in Cambodia because we come
to know in the later stage that there are many temple complexes which was later discovered.
So what caused the decay over there or was it left to abandon, was even Angkor Wat was
not completely excavated for a long time and also recently also there was one excavation
which gave a glimpse to the world as to how a similar architecture of the size of Angkor
Wat also discovered.
So please tell us something about this.
So in Cambodia starting from first century till 1113 AD, so they have their own growth
of temple architecture, there are larger temples getting constructed, there are temple cities
getting constructed from 8th century till 14th century.
So as you mentioned Angkor Wat is the largest religious precinct in the world as nominated
by UNESCO and when it was constructed, the king also envisaged it as the largest temple
in the world at that point in time, Suryavarmana tomb.
He wanted to construct a temple which nobody has ever seen and nobody has ever witnessed
the enormous city of a temple and that's why he conceptualized this temple on a concept
of Paravishnu Loka and that is which is embedded in the architecture of temple.
So what we see this influence of Indian temple architecture on Cambodia, it's not a linear
influence, it is like a civilizational continuity, it is a civilizational sibling of India.
So it is not that Hindu religion is adopted, it is inherited like other regions of India.
Similarly they have also inherited the religion and they continued, they modified certain
practices, they modified architecture based on their local conditions and all.
What happened is after Suryavarmana II's period which is a glorious period of Cambodian
history, Cambodia history, after this period there are lot of invasions by Siam and Vietnam
which is Champa dynasty because at one point in time whatever Suryavarmana I and Suryavarmana
II starting from 1006 AD till 1150 AD, this 150 years, they have their ups and downs but
more or less whole of South East Asia was under Khmer rule, Khmer is the local Khmer
kings, Cambodia kings.
But all these smaller kingdoms like Thailand, Vietnam, Laos, they had their own kingdoms
there.
So they were in alliance with Cambodia.
So eventually there was this rivalry, there was this internal conflict started happening
after 1150, after the death of Suryavarmana II.
So the legacy of Suryavarmana continued for another 50 years.
But after that there was a period of decline, slowly gradually this kingdom started attacking
Cambodia and the last big attack was in 1432 by Siamese and they destroyed much of the
architecture of Cambodia.
So destroyed as in they took away the wealth, treasure from the temples, they enslaved people
from Cambodia and if you look at the location of Siam Reap which is Angkor region where
Angkor Wat is situated, it has easiest proximity to Thailand.
So Siam which is current day Thailand, they had easy access to Angkor region.
But when we look at the larger Angkor, Cambodia, Siam Reap or Angkor becomes the center point
of their capital or their kingdom.
But eventually all these smaller kingdoms started attacking, 1432 is the last straw
where everything got destroyed.
They shifted their capital from Angkor region to Phnom Penh which is their current day capital
and though it is popularly believed that these sites were abandoned, these were never abandoned
but the capital city got shifted and that's why the focus was more on Phnom Penh rather
than Angkor region and people were residing in the temple premises, the way we have it
in India.
So there is a settlement, there are people who are residing within prakarams of the temple
but eventually the belief also got shifted from Vishnu or Shiva to Buddha.
I will not call it Hinduism to Buddhism.
This is a shift, a very subtle shift where nothing changed architecturally, it is just
people started worshipping Buddha instead of Vishnu and Shiva.
It was a specialization of a particular lineage and eventually the vigraha of Vishnu which
was there in Angkor Wat, now people started worshipping it as Buddha.
So that is the change of culture, if we can call it that but eventually the people celebrated
various festivals within temple premises.
So till 19th century, till French colony got established in Cambodia, there was this, you
know, all these places were known to local people but French, when they got introduced
to Cambodia, they started new way of looking at this site.
So they got these sites more popularized in Western world, they published material on
this.
They also defined the chronology of different kings of Cambodia and they contributed towards
exploration of this place and they diverted funds also, they captured some part of Thailand
so that this whole Khmer typology of temples could be under their control.
They established few institutions in that region but eventually even after doing that,
the whole approach was to deforestation of the temples because in this 500 years, considering
the climate of this region, there are lot of trees which grew over these temples and
they have actually encapsulated, you know, engulfed into this temple.
So temple and forest became one because there was no fund, you know, for earlier people
there, it was only to be there on site and they have no restoration, nothing, I mean
they never maintained these sites as temples before.
So in around 1910, they started, French rule was there and they started with deforestation
of this area.
They cleared many temples there but after Cambodia got its freedom, again there was
a decline phase.
So they knew about these temples but they were into this revival phase, they are still,
you know, overcoming this colonial power, re-establishing their pride and so lot of
ups and downs in their political history and then there was Khmer Rouge.
So there was, that is the darkest period of Cambodian history after, you know, 1050 AD
when there is a darkest period, this is the darkest period of their history.
Now, after that India helped them in 1988 to re-establish so called dignity of Angkor
region.
So the nomination dossier was filed for UNESCO's nomination for Angkor Wat and India helped
Cambodian government to support as a, as a knowledge partner for that assignment and
eventually in 1992, Angkor Wat got nominated as world heritage site.
But after that there are around 40 countries which are working in Cambodia for the restoration
and maintenance of this site.
So there are more than 120 temples which are still, which are discovered so far and there
are many more to come because lot of it is within forest till now, only 400 square kilometers
area could be cleared by this time but there are more to it.
It is all spread across till Laos, Vietnam and wherever, you know, Khmer temples were
constructed, wherever this dynasty ruled.
So there are temple traces, there are temple cities which are there in beneath this forest
areas and these are non-approachable because of various reasons, because of the, you know,
the Vietnam-America war.
So they had these landmines, they have unapproachable areas, dense forest, climatic conditions.
So there are reasons of not exploring many of it but whatever is explored is also enough
for us to understand how this whole continuity must have been at that point.
In your book Cambodia, India outside India, you mentioned some really interesting information
about how Dravidian architecture resembled with the Khmer temples of Cambodia.
Could you please explain that?
Yes.
So this book Cambodia India outside India is actually an outcome of my PhD, the doctoral
studies that I have undertook for almost 5 years and before that another 10 years of
studies in Cambodia.
So this book talks about the architectural influences of India and Cambodia at a larger
scale and at a contextual scale how Dravidian temples influenced or some traces of Dravidian
temple architecture on the architecture of Cambodia.
And during this journey of influences, we see many similarities in temple architecture
of India and Cambodia.
So Dravidian temple architecture though at various levels, like I said physically they
look very different.
So when we visit any Khmer temple, there is a glimpse of Indian temple, Dravida temple
but on a very second moment you feel that there is something local about these structures.
When we look at architecture of it, we get into intellectual parameters or intellectual
details of these temples like how they have placed these columns, how these spaces are
evolved in each temple.
So there is different language to it, there is a different approach of developing spaces
in temples in Cambodia which is different from Indian temples at a larger scale.
But when we get into more detailed study of these temples, it is observed that though
these are physically different or specially they have a different way of doing it.
They have more formal way of approaching temple architecture than our temples in Dravida part
of India.
But the Shastras which are used, they are extremely same.
For example, Vaikhanasa Agama which is used to construct or which gives us philosophy
of Vishnu temples, very same Agamas are used there in Cambodia also.
We also get references where they have written in inscriptions that people from southern
part of India, Cholanadu, they came here and they constructed this temple.
So likewise there are many references that we get which give us direct association of
southern part of India and Cambodia at various levels.
So when we look at this relationship of India outside India, it is not just that word India
versus India there.
It is the feeling that one gets when we visit Cambodian temples, when we are there in the
temple, iconography that we see, stories that we see on temples, even their manifestation
of different stories, that is very local, that is very pertaining to their own understanding
of stories of Ramayana, Mahabharata or Samudramantana which is widely seen all across Cambodia.
And that's how this is extended cultural region of India.
So whenever I look at Cambodia or when I call it India outside India, it works at two levels.
One is the academic word using, which is breaking this colonial mindset of looking
at India in compartment like India and Cambodia and there were few people who visited Cambodia
at one point in time and that's how this whole thing reached there.
That is breaking that notion of singular or linear way of looking at Cambodian history
or Cambodian architecture.
The second level is very emotional because when I visited Cambodia for the first time
and when I was there in the temple of Angkor Wat, I could feel that this is India, it is
extremely like Indian temples but like I said at the second moment you don't recognize it
because there are very smaller details which are their details, overall story is same and
that's why this whole term which is India outside India came to my mind when I was there
in the temple.
So when your research took place, what was that one experience or what was that one particular
exposure that made you feel this is it, Cambodia is India outside India?
Any specific experience of like maybe literary source, maybe an architectural exploration,
maybe a discovery of something which was unique as a part of your PhD?
So I started going there in 2005, like I said as part of my MPhil program, I visited Cambodia
for the first time and I could explain it to all my participants there.
So we were 30 people from 30 different countries, I was representing India in that group and
I was not aware about Cambodia when I started, when I visited it for the first time because
of lack of social media and internet, it was not as easily available as it is today but
once I came back, I started reading more and more about Cambodia.
So I researched a lot, I read more about Cambodia, India, this association, cultural history
but while documenting temples in Cambodia, I documented more than 70 temples, architectural
documentation of temples and I realized that every temple in Cambodia has a different aspect
of Indian philosophy to offer.
So there is a temple called as Nom Bekhing, it is a capital temple of Jayanagari which
is constructed after the first king Jayavarman II, he constructed Hariharalaya as a capital
city and then after two generations, the next king shifted his capital to Jayanagari and
he constructs this Nom Bekhing.
Now that temple is a square temple on hill which is oval in shape.
Now as per their standard application of principles, the city has to be square and the temple has
to be square at the center but now this hill on which this temple is located is oval in
shape.
So what they did is, on hill top there is this temple Nom Bekhing, so gradually they
have created this enclosure walls which are rectangular.
So they have enclosed this hill base as a rectangular enclosure wall and then at the
end again there is a square shaped capital.
Eventually that small square oval gets converted into another square enclosed with a moat.
What is interesting in this temple is, on the top of the hill which is the main temple
of Bekhing, it has 108 shrines there and they are designed so beautifully.
So it's a stepped kind of a temple, on every step there are certain number of Garbha Grihas
and at the bottom of that stepped pyramid again there are certain temples.
Now all of them putting together there is a 108 temples and from every side of this
square, when you stand at the center of one age of temple, you can see 33 smaller temples.
Now when we look at this Shiva philosophy or the numbers relevance also 108, 33, all
of this relates to certain significant numbers in Indian philosophy.
So this was the place, Nom Bekhing where I realized that every temple like Angkor Wat
is very famous for its intense philosophical aspect of architecture, but even the small
temple like Nom Bekhing or a small temple like Preru, these are constructed with utmost
detail, with using precise Shastra, precise message that they want to convey through
these temples and that's what triggered my interest in delving into more and more about
this temple architecture because each temple gives you a different story, which probably
you know at times we have to dig deep into our Shastras, we have to really understand
what is written here because we can see architecturally it is there.
So there must be something written in our Shastra, so it is other way round now.
So your conviction as a part of your research during your PhD was the passion behind the
start of Samrachana also and you conduct temple architectural tours to Cambodia.
So how has been the experience so far and how has been the response so far?
Okay, so Samrachana was in my mind for couple of years.
So when I started working on Cambodia, I realized there is very little awareness about this
larger cultural region that I always talk about, South East Asia being sibling of ancient
India, that awareness is not there in India.
People used to ask me, when I used to tell them about Cambodia, they even didn't know
this name, you know if there is any temple is like far-fetched thing, but Cambodia as
a country was also not known to people in 2005-2006.
So I wanted to do something to bring this to people's memory, back to people's memory
that there was a large cultural region called South East Asia, ancient Bharat Varsha which
included all of this together and Indian or Hindu culture can be seen in all these countries.
But because of my role as an administrative head of many organizations before or heading
many institutions, I could not really focus on the research of it.
So finally I started Samrachana as an organization which will completely focus on research, conservation
and the continuity of heritage in these regions.
And as part of this, the first and foremost, I started conducting few online courses.
Eventually it reached a lot of people all across the world.
So every month I conduct these courses to educate people to at least create awareness
about Cambodia in India and across various countries.
And second outcome of this was when people started attending these courses, they asked
me about the visits to Cambodia and that happened eventually.
So one thing led to other and now I visit, I mean, I take people to Cambodia, whosoever
is interested into knowing the cultural region of Cambodia.
So it is like a study tour, a day study tour which people attend, it's like morning to
evening intense understanding of temples.
Again there is a sequence to it.
So based on my understanding of whatever I have learnt so far, I try to share it with
people with certain layers so that, you know, everybody gets something out of this study
tour.
And when they go back to their own countries, they can research more about it with respect
to their own interest area.
So there are historians, researchers, architects, even practitioners or people from MNCs, people
like IAS officers, retired officers and those who are interested to know more about Cambodia.
So far it has been really going well.
Lot of people are interested in visiting Cambodia and I am happy that I could contribute
to the way they are looking at temple architecture in more Indianized way than earlier.
So you have academic experience, you have published your own works, the same time you
are also on ground.
You visit temples, studying, conducting study tours and on having hands-on conservation.
So just a comparative question, which one is easier, conserving a thousand-year-old
temple or reviving a five thousand-year-old perspective or a mindset in today's generation?
Neither or either?
These are two different things completely because conserving a temple or say a thousand-year-old
structure, temple architecture, it involves lot of energy, lot of time because it needs
attention, it needs technology, expertise, coordination with different agencies.
But it is a material, it is a physical entity which is to be conserved, restored for future
generations or to prolong life of a structure, that is conservation.
But when I look at this reviving culture, it's an ongoing process because it is an
intangible thing and because of the distortion which happened in last two hundred years,
it is difficult to bring back people from their mindset to the lens that we want them
to look at these temples as and it's a huge process, it will need another hundred years
to ensure that people understand significance of temples.
Again there are many layers to it, I mean, I feel that restoration or having cultural
practices is one thing, but temple as an entity itself, there were lot of layers which
were there in temple cities, like there were artists, there were artifacts which were produced,
there were every region has its own weaving technique, there are weavers which are still
there, all of this has gone into isolation.
There are even literature which is there in the temple, lot of manuscripts, lot of literature
which is in the temple as a library, lot of techniques which were used during that
time, all of that is lost in this process.
So reviving them, putting them together as a part of larger context of temple, as part
of temple itself, you know, the temple culture, reviving that is difficult because it depends
on how the society is thinking about temples.
So changing the narrative, changing this perspective of society towards temple will
take lot of time, lot of energy and lot of people to come on a same platform and start
spreading awareness about these things.
So this is difficult.
Swamiji – Ma'am, even today we have temple geography which has an amalgamation of rivers,
hills, even oceans and forests.
So it's a very sacred geography, apart from being a socio-administrative area, it's a
very sacred geography and they have been existing for the last hundreds and centuries together.
But it's the human perspective which has changed.
How do you think in the current minds, in the modern perspective, what are the initiatives
that we need to take or the government needs to take or society needs to take so that in
the younger generation, we imbibe in them the same perspective which we had in our ancestors?
Dr. Swamiji – These natural elements that we are talking about, they were always integral
part of developing architecture and that's how eventually it becomes sacred architecture
or sacred geography of any place.
So, the temples like, you know, when the temple is constructed, all these elements are taken
into consideration as part of the larger ecosystem of temple.
So we have water as an important element of a temple or having governance or forests within
the temple premises, having trees, significant trees within temple premises has always been
part of our culture.
And the way Indian culture looks at this aspect of ecology is a long lasting or making a longer
impact on society or this ecosystem.
For example, every temple has a sthalavruksham.
So these sthalavrukshams are like, you know, the trees which are locally grown, which impact
the microclimate of a temple.
So that's why when we enter a temple, there is a different experience, you know, microclimate
changes as you enter the temple.
Eventually, again, the disconnect which I am looking at right now is the modern way
of looking at sustainability is a short term view, you know, we have certain measures to
take and then it becomes sustainable, which is again a short lived kind of a concept.
But when we look at the ancient Indian wisdom about sustainability, it has a larger impact
on society, on microclimate, on micro level issues of certain settlement.
And that's how we think, we see all these elements that you have mentioned were integral
part of temple architecture, starting from the earliest times, starting from the site
selection, starting from how this temple material was acquired, how construction technology
was implemented on site.
So all of that was extremely local, extremely defined by certain principles, so that nature
is not disturbed anywhere or to certain extent, it is imbibed in the culture of temples in
many ways.
Dr. Jola, it has been really nice talking to you today on temple architecture, its conservation,
how it was linked with economy, socio-administrative, political, trade, etc, etc.
And at the end, how temple still stands as a important aspect of sacred geography and
it connects, interconnects and also transcends our life with our previous, the previous ancestors,
our heritage, our culture, etc.
So it's been really nice discussing with you, thank you so much for your time.
