Cleaning shells with muriatic acid & comparing acid to using mineral oil. Which works is better?

SWF Beach Life
219 followers
3 Video Views·Aug 10, 2025
Cleaning shells with muriatic acid is something I had put off for a while, but once I finally tried it I was addicted! This is the second time I'm doing this to my shells and the results are just fantastic. That being said, using muriatic acid isn't the only way to clean your shells. Mineral oil can also be used to bring back the color, so I wanted to see how shells would look after using muriatic acid compared to using mineral oil to bring back the color to sea shells. I was actually pretty surprised by the results!
welcome to another swf beach life
video today we're going to be dipping
some shells in acid
and if that wasn't fun enough we're also
going to be comparing
acid dipping to using mineral oil to
bring out the color on shells
if you're new to my channel you might be
wondering where i got all those shelves
every week i visit the beach and i bring
you a new video of my beach visit so i
recommend you hit that subscribe button
and the notification bell so you can
come along with me on my future beach
explorations
i wanted to try an experiment comparing
using mineral oil on the shelves with
dipping the shells in
acid i took a pair of the same type of
shells and split them into two
teams team oil and team acid
you see that these shells are the same
type size
and almost the same condition i thought
this was the best way to compare the
results of the two techniques i'll be
using
and let's just get another look of the
shells a little closer together so we
can see their condition is very
similar
a few days ago i took the shelves from
team oil and used the mineral oil
technique
this technique is really just putting a
thin layer of oil on the shelves and
then using an old rag or washcloth
and removing all the excess oil i put a
little mineral oil in a small dish and
then using a paint brush
i coated the shelves with a thin layer
of oil and then just wiped the excess
off
this is not a permanent solution and
over time the shells
might need to be re-oiled but i still
wanted to compare
the initial oil results to see if this
was a viable
alternative for those who don't want to
mess around with the acid
team oil is looking pretty good they
definitely look better than they did
before
currently team oil is in the lead but
how will they stack up compared to team
acid
let's dip some shells and find out
if this is the first time you're seeing
me dip my shells in acid
i recommend you watch my first acid
dipping video for all the correct
measurements and safety equipment needed
you can click that link in the upper
corner in this video we're just going to
get right down to business
i selected a specific bunch of shells to
dip today
we're going to dip team acid first so
they can dry
and then we can compare what they look
like to team oil
all right guys we're gonna start off
team acid welk lightning milk he's not
oops sorry he's not actually so bad
ready one two three
now i've also heard that you can dip
them longer or maybe even shorter
depending on how beat up the show
let's see how that's gonna compare to
team oil
let's take the crown
he's not terrible terrible one
two three oh he's so pretty
be really careful um someone had given
me the tip to
when you're doing this to not splash
because i'm kind of
flicking the water so just if you're
gonna do this be really careful all
right we're gonna do
a banded tulip one
two three oh it looks pretty
i will be very interested to see how
the oil stacks up to the acid i've
seen the oil all right this is going to
be a little tricky here's a moon snail
seen the oil work
we'll just see how it's going to compare
one two three
normally i wouldn't dip a moon snail
because they already have
a kind of a natural shine but these guys
were already
kind of calcium that's okay that i
dropped them in the water
already a little bit calcified so maybe
i'll dip them and then put oil on them
go crazy
all right these scallops are usually
really really fun
let's take a look at him before actually
let me get a better grip on him
there we go that's a little better all
right here we go
one two three
make sure we're not flicking any acid
anywhere
look how pretty
okay so we're gonna let them dry okay
what i have found to be the most fun to
dip
are mostly these guys or i just kind of
wanted to see what would happen
these angel wings they're really
delicate and i'm kind of
not convinced i should dip them but i'm
going to go ahead and do it anyway
because he's kind of got some muck i'm
going to do a quick one though
i'm not going to do three i'm going to
kind of try two and see what happens
all right here we go one two
that might not have been long enough
he's still got some muck on there but
again i'm
concerned that i'm just going to
disintegrate the shell so
i'm not going to try this i'm not going
to try those i'm probably
maybe i'll just try some bleach on those
guys because i'm afraid i'll just
wreck it all right okay ready
this apple murex i found and i kept it
specifically
to dip it in acid this clearly looks
like it's gonna need
a lot of time but i'm gonna start i
don't know
let's dip it and we'll find out and then
i might have to just go back and dip it
again
all right here we go ready he's
definitely
seen better days
two three four
okay got careful with the flicking
all right let's see what we got all
right cleaned up a little
i wonder if i soaked him if i can get
the rest of those barnacles off but what
i'm gonna do
i'm gonna let him sit and maybe i'll
just i don't know i could dip him again
now but
i'm just gonna let him i'm gonna let him
hang out and i'll just dip him again
a little bit this
this guy i was gonna dip but why
this beautiful lace muric's i decided
against it but
why not google at it or oogle at it
rather it's such a pretty one but this
little guy
with a bug on it this little
lace let's see we're going to do a quick
dip on him because
he doesn't look like he needs too much
careful with the flicking
look how pretty all right i want to
do the dipped ones over here i know that
you're team acid so i'll leave those
alone
the murax are always really fun
let's take a look at this guy before
one two three
careful with the flicking oh he's
bubbling
get him into the water
oh he looks so good
i'm gonna put the after over here
[Music]
all right let's okay so see this nutmeg
he's got
he's kind of got a little bit of
calcification on him let's see
let's see what happens when we dip him
that's a big guy
all right here we go one two
three careful with the flicking
oh it's so pretty well first of all when
they're wet they're going to look more
colorful
anyway and then you've already removed
that layer of
calcification so pretty
all right let's do this horse conch he's
kind of got
a little green he's got some stuff going
on the inside
alright make sure you got a good hold on
him one
two three
oh no i don't know that i see all that
much difference in this guy maybe he
didn't need it that much
let's find one that really does need
this guy
all right you can see he's a little
white
actually i see a whiter one not sorry
we'll do him next the lightning milk
always
come out really good so let's do this
guy
one two three
careful not to flick oh yeah
the first time i did this i was freaking
out because it was so awesome the
changes that happened and now i
expect it it's still
quite awesome oh that's cool okay
let's this guy yep
all right he is definitely let's see
what happens with him he's really white
all right one two
three oh yeah
luckily i'm dropping these guys in the
look at the color on them now
let's do a really
oh yeah remarkable
awesome okay these guys are also really
fun the scallops clean up great
so i'm gonna get a hold of this guy see
he's kind of got
okay ready
two three okay he's bubbling can't quite
see
oh so pretty
he's still got a little bit of white
stuff on him but that's all right
make sure he doesn't get mixed up with
team acid
all right let's do this crown conch he's
a little white
one two three
oh yay
what do you think that's pretty cool
i honestly never thought i'd be an acid
dipper i really it was
it just feels really dangerous but after
i did it that first time
yeah it's addicting it's okay absolutely
addicting okay see this guy
it's kind of good he's got some weight
stuff make sure i get a good hold of him
one two three
look at them now oh so fun
oh pretty oh yeah
oh by the way this is the entire that's
everything i'm going to dip but
we aren't going to dip all those because
this will probably be a two-hour video
so
i'm just going to kind of pick out the
guys that
probably will be the best
let's just see what happens now this guy
i honestly don't know that dipping him
is going to help he looks like he might
be faded in addition to having some
calcification going on
so i'm going to go ahead let's just see
what happens get a good get a good hold
of him
one two three
four all right i see color
let's
[Music]
so he was pretty white anyway so he was
a little bleached out he had some
calcification
he still looks definitely looks better
but
i think the best um
results that you're going to find are
really from the harder
i'm going to say really the ones i
picked out tulips not
so much the moon snails it was really
just an experiment the nutmegs
the crown conks and the lightning welts
and the scallops now
florida fighting conch i already know
the results aren't fabulous
part of that is also because they have
this naturally shiny
i don't know if you can kind of say that
but this guy was
i already scraped a ton of barnacles off
him i just really liked them because of
the color and i just like i know they're
everywhere but i still like these
florida fighting conch so
i'm going to give him a dip see if i can
clean this guy up anymore
and we'll do let's do three
he's very foamy careful with the
flicking
all right he's still i'm probably still
putting acid on him but
there we go all right
okay
it definitely looks a little better i
could probably spend a little more time
i did get one of those dental tools just
off amazon
like three bucks or something and so
when you soak
the shells a lot of those white
i don't have one because i already
picked them all off but
there's like white stuff that gets on
the shell
and that will pick off with the dental
tool so
i did already kind of do a little bit of
cleaning here's a crown conch
he's not terrible but i bet you he's
going to look gorgeous
okay so we're aries before make sure he
got a good hold on him
one two three this guy didn't look like
he needed a oh
oh yes
oh yeah look at him oh
he's pretty oh that cleaned up great
that cleaned up great
okay we'll leave him again over here not
to mix them up with team acid
let's do this guy he has a little green
on him
that was wondering if the acid would
would clean up and he's just
he's in pretty good shape but let's see
what a quick dip will do
and one two three
i wonder if that green came i don't
think it did
let's see
um i still think it's there a little bit
it still looks better
but there's still a little bit of that
green so
to figure out if i want to just leave it
the way it is because sometimes
imperfect is just perfect all right
here's another crown
he's not too bad but he's going to look
a little bit better
all right let's ready
one two three i love these shells
oh my gosh
oh wow oh he's so pretty
that one came out great
looks like he had to repair himself he's
got like little
little lumpy things going on in his
shell but oh man
that was a really good one all right
let's see now this guy
i think we have a little bit of
calcification but i also think
that he might have been faded so let's
find out
all right make sure i got a good hold of
them one
two three
oh my gosh
wow
all right he already was you can kind of
see the colors he's a little
faded but wow that cleaned up nice
all right what else are we gonna dip
let's do
let's see this guy
all right let's go let's just see
i don't know if anything's really going
to change too much and
that's okay too
once i get the acid out i go a little i
start dipping everything
that looks great oh that looks so pretty
i love the sound of those guys too all
right let's do check this guy out
i just thought that he was such a pretty
color and
i bet you we're gonna make him a little
bit brighter so we'll
do a quick one one two
let's do a quick one make sure we're not
flicking
look at them now now again when the
shells are wet
it's going to bring the color out kind
of like the concept of the mineral oil
so it's a little hard to tell but from
first glance i mean these guys look
fabulous oh really happy
so let's see if i can you know go
through a little quicker
or let's i'm gonna try to move it along
so we can see
as much as we can without making it a
two hour video
okay
that guy cleaned up nice
all right let's just keep we're going to
keep dipping
come on buddy i'm going to
start moving and trying to go a little
bit quicker
safety first though people this is acid
after all and
let's let's try this nutmeg he
definitely
he's got some calcification going on
make sure he got a good hold of him
oh he came out really good
look at him oh that's
these harder shells those those they
work really really good
and let's do this guy
he's not in perfect shape
but let's i bet you dipping them will
make them even better let's see
careful with the flicking and i'm trying
to be very careful
yeah that looks great
it's not perfect but that's a you know
what doesn't have to be yes finding the
perfect shell
is awesome but sometimes the
imperfections can be okay too
actually speaking of imperfections i
know i have this guy
he's only a piece and i was going to dip
him in there so come on imperfect guy
all right get a hold of him
be very careful with the flicking
oh yay look at the color on him now
that looks awesome all right
next up i'm going to do this other crown
make
sure i got a good hold of them i just
don't want to drop them in the acid i
don't care if i drop them in the water
here's a do a quick one
look at the color on them now how you
like me now
that's this guy it came out good all
right so
i'm going to quickly
well i don't know how quick he can
really dip things into acid
i'll just try to not talk so much i
don't know although that's not really
going to help it move along is it now
they're looking great oh it looks
so good all right let's try
this little mirex
make sure i just try to make sure i got
a good hold of him
he's gonna do a quick dip
he's a pretty
and let's try a tulip
so it's got a little you know kind of
like that white layer going on
white layer is gonzo oh that looks
awesome
look at that gorgeous
gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous
so why don't we do another one while
we're at it this this shell is a little
bit more worse for wear
but that's all right let's see if we can
help him out with this color
yep
looking good buddy now this guy this is
like oops
i want to be really careful with him
because it's like the only like really
orange true tulip i have i know
considering i go out there so much i
don't
always find everything i want so
the tulips have been elusive to me also
the true tulips like a nice big one i
find lots of banded tulips
what do you think i think he looks
pretty good
i'm gonna go quick on those guys and
this guy
i was pretty convinced he was just
missing his color i don't think much is
gonna happen if i dip him
but let's find out okay
yep don't think much is gonna
too much is gonna change he's still
pretty weight
that's okay he's got a lovely shape
we'll just let him hang out with his
friends
okay so let's do this guy
i suspect he's gonna clean up real nice
and i think he looks like he's gonna be
a dark color
make sure he got him he's big enough to
get there we go
good handle on him get him in there
get him out of there his tail didn't
really get dipped maybe i'll go back
oh yeah guys
it's like magic
look at how much that guy cleaned up
oh it's gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous
all right what we're doing let's do this
guy
two three
gorgeous now again i know these guys are
wet so they're going to look
even brighter but we'll hopefully i'll
remember to come back and give you a
shot of what these guys look
all dry and so you can see that their
color
has really really this acid really helps
the color come out and that's basically
what it's doing it's just kind of eating
away the top layer of
of calcium and i guess maybe there's
other muck although
the acid doesn't seem to be really
working on the muck per se
let's do this guy can get a hold of him
so he
it's not terrible but i bet he could be
better
let's just see
gorgeous so it's fun because after i had
done this the first time there's shells
that were
i might have in the past i might have
left them
but i knew that i'd be able to dip them
and it would bring all that color out
so look at that guy oh he came out
awesome
all right let's do another
another lightning walk
sorry about that
oh yeah it just works i don't know what
else to say other than it just works
all right this one might give me a
little bit of trouble this guy's pretty
big
and i'm a chicken and i'm only really
dealing with these these little bits of
acid so i'll just kind of put the bigger
end in there just kind of get them as
much as i can
get them safely into
the water
let's see how we look oh my gosh
awesome sorry about the
trying to be safe and shoot this at the
same time ain't always easy
gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous
all right we'll do this guy too
all right some of the white stuff i was
talking about did not come off
but all that calcification did so maybe
i can just soak this guy
maybe get those other white things off
i'm still learning as i go do a crown
conch because they seem to have really
good results
yep it's really it's just gonna get as
good as
it can get in my opinion i'm also gonna
say i'm pretty sure
team acid is gonna beat team
mineral oil but not everybody
has the luxury of having their own
driveway i realize this that maybe you
have i don't know a condo or an
apartment
so at least the mineral oil will give
you another option it's not permanent
but it gives you another way to safely
he cleaned up so nice safely
kind of go through this process without
actually using the acid you have
something to take your
take that calcification off or at least
real bring the color of your shells out
that's
basically what that as you can see is
what the mineral oil does
oh it's
it's like magic right this guy doesn't
need much
so i'm just one do him quick
and then i have a
lot of dipping to do so i'm going to
go ahead and just kind of do this behind
the scenes and then we'll come back and
take a look at what everything looks
like
and we'll also compare and we'll see who
won
either team oil or team acid
okay i've dipped almost everything i
saved i couldn't help myself because i
think that that
this guy's gonna come out really good so
i figured i'd circle back and let's
share it
i'll share it with you guys this i'm not
really sure
i just really really really like this
shell and
i've never really seen anything bad
happen with the acid especially on a
scallop or anything that's not supposed
to be shiny
he's still looking pretty awesome that
little white thing is still there but i
kind of knew that
speaking of which something i already
probably know this is an albino
lightning milk and there's some like
stuff on him i don't think it's going to
come off but i'm going to give him a
quick dip
and i guess confirm my hypothesis
one two three
yep i'm still thinking i see some of
that green
yep so at least in my experience so far
the acid doesn't help with that green
stuff maybe bleach will all right i know
this guy's gonna come out good
ready
i knew it look at how dark
isn't it awesome okay so that
is the last knot of the entire uh that's
the last of the stuff i intended
to dip i still have that whole thing to
go through so this is what everybody
looks like
they look all bright all that
calcification is gone i did dip this one
a second time
and i just he's just too
far gone maybe i think i'll just try him
with the water and i'll go back to that
dental tool and
see what i can do because you know
that's a pretty good sized apple mirex
so i'm gonna try
and then we have the welks and
everything else came out
really really really really good so now
we're gonna go compare and see how team
acid stacks up against
team oil okay
so here's the final results i'm kind of
trying to keep them next to each other
so we can really kind of see
and i just might be wrong
i thought team acid was going to win i
don't know if you could see
i feel like the tulip uh
well i don't know what do you think
i think they both look pretty good moon
snail is probably not the best uh
choice of shell because it's not quite
as dramatic the changes but
i don't know i think i might
go with a tie on the results now of
course with the oil it's not permanent
the acid is a little more dangerous so i
guess depending on your circumstances
your comfortability
dealing with caustic liquids
you can just choose to do either so
that's the comparison i'm gonna go with
a tie i don't know if you think
different by all means leave me
a comment and let me know what you think
thank you
so very much for watching i love you
guys you guys are the best
if you haven't hit that subscribe button
i do recommend you do it because
every week i do bring you some sort of
beachy goodness
and i really hate for you to miss out so
hit that subscribe button
and i'll see you again soon
