This is the full interview with Dr Peter Clarkson, and there are two parts to it.
In February 2024, we made our first video about how hard older athletes should train for heart
health. It has had more than a million views, and it's used on NHS Highland's website. Dr Clarkson
is an NHS cardiologist at Ragemore Hospital in Inverness, in the Scottish Highlands.
We spent ages discussing follow-up videos, and we've ended up with two.
The first is how anyone should assess their own cardiac risk and the decision whether or not
they should take the drugs statins. The second video is about returning to exercise after a
heart attack or being diagnosed with atrial fibrillation. So that's how we divided up the
interview I did with Dr Clarkson. And I know some people are particularly keen to hear the full
source material. They don't want my edits or explanations or pictures. They want to hear
directly from the doctor. So that's why I'm making this available as an audio podcast and also a full
video podcast on the Always Another Adventure sites. There are links in the show notes and
video description. We're going to start the interview by explaining the goal of the interview.
I guess the bits I wanted to cover today that I thought were relevant to a general audience
is looking at people who've had some form of cardiac diagnosis and what you do in terms of
continuing exercise, what you do in modifying things for the future with people who've already
had a cardiac problem diagnosed. There's a huge range of cardiac problems. There's textbooks in
cardiac disease, but I think the ones we should concentrate on are coronary artery disease
and probably a little bit about atrial fibrillation. And I think we can split the
coronary artery disease into two groups, which is people who've been picked up as having
some abnormality in the coronary arteries, but they've not had a cardiac event. And cardiac
event means they haven't had a myocardial infarction or in layman's terms, a heart attack.
And then looking at the group of people who may have had a cardiac event, people who've had a
small or medium-sized heart attack in the past and wanting to get back to doing some exercise.
And I think they're probably the main groups we should chat about today, Simon.
Okay, because this is important because, could you give me that figure of the coronary artery
disease and sudden death? Yeah, so the bit we worry about is sudden death. And in people who,
in athletes, and athletes we use that in a broad term of people who are undertaking regular
exercise. We know that people who have sudden cardiac death in middle age, 80% of it is down
to having coronary artery disease. And obviously that's the bit we want to try and reduce the risk
of people presenting with sudden death. And it's how we structure and how we do that in people who
are already known to have cardiac disease. Now, some of the sudden cardiac deaths that can
unfortunately be the first presentation. So people may be completely unaware they've had
any problems with the coronary arteries and they present with sudden death. Now, there's not a lot
we can do about that, but there's also the groups of people who are known to have some degree of
coronary disease. And what do we do to reduce the risk of sudden cardiac events in the future?
What are the suggestions that they might have had that might be a diagnosis or it might be
something else that they could be at risk of having an event? So there's people who've got
conventional risk factors, people who don't know they've had any coronary artery disease,
they've never had a diagnosis. And people, if you've got hypertension, if you're a smoker,
diabetic, we know you're more at risk of developing atheroma. And that's the primary prevention,
no knowledge of having previous disease that people then seek medical help to reduce the
risks in the future. I think the bits for me as a cardiologist is mostly people who've already
had some form of diagnosis. And we're increasingly seeing people who've had, for instance, CT scans,
cardiac CTs done as part of a well-man or well-person check. And it shows there's a degree
of coronary atheroma. And these people are coming to see more of us in clinic to have discussions
about what we do with their hardening of their coronary arteries. I think if we go back to the
previous video we've had, we recognise that there is a small increase in coronary calcification
in people who undertake regular exercise in particular groups. There's also a lot of athletes
who have conventional risk factors. A lot of athletic people in middle age, some still smoke,
there are some people who've got high blood pressure, high cholesterol, there's diabetic
people amongst them. And in people who've got cardiac CTs that have coronary artery disease,
we start looking at is there something we can do to modify the process in reducing the amount
of atheroma you have in the future. Because in the last video, you said you recommended against
having a CT scan. That's still part of the advice we give on a screening level. It's not go to see
your doctor and say, can I be screened? No, this is UK advice. And I know it does differ.
Internationally, it does differ. And in the UK, our standard advice is we don't recommend CTs
as part of coronary screening. But you're seeing more and more people who've had them. But we still
And do they pick up? Yes, they pick up the calcification. Do they also pick up the soft,
soft, fatty plaques that we hear a lot about? Not a standard, not a, not a standard CT. There
are CTs we can do. So we can do a CT calcium score, where we're just looking at the amount
of calcium in your arteries. You can do a CT coronary angiogram, which does pick up the softer
plaque as well. And for most people, the screening test is the calcium score. So we have an idea of
how much calcification there is in your coronary arteries. And that's actually a pretty good
indicator. It doesn't show you all the soft plaques in your coronary arteries, but it's a
good indicator of the, how much coronary artery disease you have. And it can place a number on
the amount of coronary calcification people have. So while we're talking about numbers,
so these are people who've had some sort of a diagnosis of this. There's an easier way,
in many ways, to get a kind of an important diagnosis. And that would be to do with the
stuff your GP can do, because you might find out about cholesterol and blood pressure.
Could you just talk to me a little bit about them and how they then feed into this Q-score thing?
Yeah. So there's a Q-risk score, which is a, which you can get online, which is a calculator,
which will give you an estimate of what your risk is of having a coronary event in the next 10
years. And that plugs in things like your age, your sex, your cholesterol, your blood pressure,
where you live, that goes into a Q-risk score. And it comes out with a number at the end of it
as to what your risk is of having a coronary event in the next 10 years. Now, in the UK,
we don't think there's a lot of incremental benefit to having a CT calcium score on top of that,
because the Q-risk score helps refine what we should do. Now, it's a useful tool because
it helps us guide our discussions with people as to what risk factor modification you want on top
of it. So, for instance, quite a lot of relatively healthy middle-aged men, when you plug the details
into the Q-risk score, may have a risk of about 10% in the next 10 years of having a coronary event.
Now, we can use that to inform discussions about whether you want to be on drugs like a statin or
not. We know that with statins, if you take, statins reduce risk of coronary events. It
probably doesn't seem to make a great deal of difference what group you're in,
but they will reduce your risk of coronary events in the future by about 25%.
When you say what group you're in, you mean if you're in a high-risk group,
and you've got a 25% or 30% or 40% risk of having an event or 10%?
That's right. So, they lower your risk. So, if your risk is 1%, you'd be pretty lucky to have a
1% risk of having a coronary event in the next 10 years. Being on a statin will lower that by 25%,
so it lowers it to 0.75%. So, you're actually only lowering it by, in total, a quarter of a percent.
Right. So, 10% risk, you're down to 7.5%.
Yeah. So, 10% risk, it's down to 7.5%.
So, 40% risk.
Totally, yeah, that it lowers it to 30%. So, you can have discussions about how useful it is to be
on a statin. Now, I know that a lot of it is the standard advice, and it's easy for us to suggest
people should be on statins, but that's not a full conversation about discussions and risk. Yes,
that will lower your risk, but I think a lot of people want to know how much risk modification
there is. So, if, for instance, you're… I'm 58. If you're a 58-year-old man with a 10% risk per
decade of having a coronary event, we know that being on statins… So, for me, being on a statin,
it would lower it to roughly 7.5%. If you extrapolate that over the next 30 years,
so you add all those risks together, that means if I go on a statin, it will lower my risk of
having a cardiac event by about 7.5%. And you can definitely argue that's a really good thing
to lower your risk by that much, but the flip side of that is I've got to be taking a drug every day
for the rest of my life, and there's a 93% chance it will make no difference to my outcomes,
that either I'll have had a cardiac event anyway, or I won't ever have a cardiac event.
So, we should probably be more honest and upfront with people about discussing risks when they have
coronary calcification and a CT. How much calcification is there? What your risk factors
are like? Is it justified to be on a statin? And do you want to take a drug for the rest of your
life to lower your risk by a small percentage, and roughly what that percentage is? And that
will vary depending on the extent of your risk factors, what age you are, what your blood
pressure is, what your cholesterol actually is, how much abnormality there is in your coronary
vessels. Have you had a previous cardiac event, for instance? So, it's a much fuller discussion,
and presumably this is why a lot of people stop taking the statins. People stop taking statins
for a variety of reasons, because I view them a bit like taking out life insurance. You don't feel
good for taking out and spending money on life insurance, but it does something for the future.
The people on statins don't feel better for taking statins. We know that about, in some studies,
there's about 40% of people stop taking statins once they're prescribed taking statins. And is
that because there is a nocebo effect? A nocebo is the sort of flip side of placebos. Placebos
is you take a drug with the expectation that you're going to feel better taking a drug.
There's a lot of negative publicity about statins, and there is definitely a nocebo effect where
people think that they're not going to feel well taking a statin. And so, psychologically,
they're more likely to stop taking it because of that effect. And there may well be a side
effect profile associated with taking statins, so a lot of people stop taking them. A lot of people
don't want to be reminded every day that they're taking a drug for future prevention, and it's
easier just to stop taking it. So there is an attrition in the number of people who remain
on statins. And they are controversial, aren't they? I've heard radio programs.
They're still controversial. I'm a cardiologist. You're not going to get me to tell you that
statins are bad. Statins definitely reduce your risk of coronary events, but it's how much risk
benefit there is. And I think there's definitely populations which are high risk, which we think
that you really are definitely strongly recommended to continue to take a statin because these do
modify your risk substantially. But there's other populations where the level of risk modification
is actually quite small. And if you're down in the, you know, 5% chance of having a cardiac event
in the next 10 years, do you really want to take something that might lower it by 25%? Because
if you've got 100 people in a room, you've got that same risk factor profile, all taking the
drug, one of them will not have an event because you've put them onto the statins.
Can you tell when you meet someone out on the crag when you're climbing, can you tell
when chatting to them about their lifestyle? Could you kind of get a fair idea of where their risk
factor is? No, not really. Unless they've got a cigarette in their hand. You see, I just wondered
that. I remember going back decades when the Conservative government was out there having
all the GPs to try to do cholesterol when that was a target for them and they were rewarded for
it. And this was in England. I remember my GP saying to me, I can tell when they walk in the
door what the cholesterol score is going to be. And I just wondered whether or not, I mean,
you can't tell, presumably in your clinic, otherwise they wouldn't be there. I just
wondered whether these risk factors are more insidious. Because there'll be people out there
who think, oh, listen, I train three times a week, four times a week, I go to the gym, I ride my bike,
I'm going to be all right, surely. And that's not necessarily the case. Not necessarily.
For cholesterol, for instance, there's some people who've got cholesterol deposits that
you can see in their tendons around their eyes. You can see that they've got abnormal lipids
simply by looking at them. But that's a very small subset. The majority of people,
cholesterol is unseen. And there's no way of knowing unless you get it tested. Unless you're
having your blood tested. There's a genetic condition, familial hypercholesterolemia,
affects about one in 500 people. And unless you've got other family members, you've got
premature coronary disease and have had their lipids checked, you're probably not going to
know about that unless you've had your lipids checked. I'm just looking at what are my notes,
fit and unfit, 20%. There was a coronary CT thing you're talking about, a study with 400 people,
fit as a baseline. The other bit is, so if you do have the, you've been picked up as having
coronary atheroma. Whilst there's this very small risk of sudden death associated with exercise,
so there is, when you're exercising heavily, there's a very small increased risk of coronary
event. But the flip side of that is that regular exercise is undoubtedly beneficial for people.
And they did a really good observational study in people who have coronary artery calcification
scores greater than 400. And that's a lot. It is a fair amount of coronary artery disease.
And split them into, well they looked at people's baseline levels of fitness,
the how much metabolic activity, how much METs they could do of exercise and split you into
fit groups versus unfit people. And found that people who were unfit, your risk of having a
coronary event if you had coronary artery calcification scores greater than 400 was
greater than 50, was around about 50%. Whereas the fit group of people is about 20%. So continuing to
exercise undoubtedly is protective. And that's the sort of, of all the messages is don't stop
doing what you're doing. It's really important to keep exercising across pretty much all
populations of people with cardiac disease. There's a couple of rare cardiac conditions
which we advise not to do a great deal of exercise with, but the vast majority,
continuing to exercise seems to confer significant health benefits. And certainly for people with
coronary artery disease, the risk of not doing something is vastly outweighs that
very small risk of an event when you're pushing yourself, doing heavy exercise.
In the second part, we're talking about people who've had an adverse cardiac event.
I always thought event an odd word in such circumstances. We're talking about someone
being given a diagnosis of atrial fibrillation, or having had a heart attack, like our friend
Duncan, who was one of the founders of the climbing gym in Inverness where we recorded this.
He was advised to keep his heart rate below 134.
I'd like to say there's still variations in thinking across cardiology practice. And
whilst Duncan's been told keep his heart rate below 134, that's not the advice that I would
generally give. So there is a variation in practice. There are bits which we universally
agree on, and that is if you've had a cardiac event, if you've had a myocardial infarction,
heart attack, the cardiac rehabilitation programs make a big difference to the initial recovery.
What do they do?
The cardiac rehabilitation programs is a team of nursing staff, physiotherapists,
that go through educational stuff and promote a sort of resumption of exercise.
And these reduce hospitalisations, they improve patient recovery, they reduce anxieties,
so people get back to exercising sooner, going through a structured cardiac rehabilitation
program. Once you're through that, so if we're talking the months after, so you've had a cardiac
episode, I'll call them an episode rather than an event, that's fine. The longer term recovery
following that depends, well there's the coronary artery process, which is similar to the discussions
we've had about people who've been detected as having coronary artery disease. Most people who've
had a cardiac event in the UK who will have an angiogram performed, and that applies to most
western countries. We know what your coronary arteries look like, the worst areas, the part
that's caused the heart attack, is likely to have been opened up by putting an intracoronary stent
in the coronary artery to improve the flow beyond that. Now a lot of what we do in terms of promoting
what sort of exercise levels people should do afterwards, depends on is there a loss of
narrowings elsewhere in your coronary arteries, what's the extent of that, and how much scar tissue
there's been inside the heart. Now I think that when I see people I'm looking at sort of three,
I'm looking at three things when it comes to what we do to reduce your risk of sudden cardiac
death, because sudden cardiac death can come about because you have a further heart attack,
one of the plaques in your coronary arteries ruptures and causes a blockage, and we know the
risk of that is low, but it can happen, and being on risk-modifying drugs or treatments or lifestyle
changes that we discussed earlier is the way we tackle those. We look at whether there's a large
chunk of thick scar tissue which potentially can cause rhythm disturbances in the heart itself,
so we call it ventricular tachycardia caused by scar, and we also look at whether there's
a area of narrowing that is reducing the blood supply to the muscle beyond the narrow coronary
artery that then that may cause rhythm disturbances under levels of extreme exercise when people are
pushing themselves. And so I think that for me, if people are keen athletic people and want to get
back to doing exercise, and we know there's persistent coronary artery disease, I like doing
a treadmill, some form of exercise where we monitor your cardiac, your heart for both its rhythm
and whether there's ischemia. Ischemia means a reduction of blood supply to the heart muscle,
and seeing where there's any signs of that as a guide towards your treatment. And if
your arteries are otherwise okay and the blood supply is good into the blood vessel with no
evidence of any rhythm disturbances, then I think a lot of people can get back to complete normal,
full normal exercise rather than being capped towards an arbitrary heart rate.
So describe that to me, what would you see, how would you monitor the blood flow?
I get you put an ECG on them and you go on a treadmill, presumably you get their heart rate
to go up and up. Yeah that's right. But how would you monitor the blood flow?
So it's looking at the ECG recordings. So you can tell from that. So you can tell on looking at the
ECG whether there's shifts in the electrical patterns that imply that the heart's not happy,
that it's getting the starvation of blood supply to the muscle beyond the narrow section.
Because you explained to me earlier that it's a perverse situation in that you're more likely to
have an event when you are really, I'm still using the word now, you're more likely to have
a problem when you are going for it and your heart rate's high and yet doing that is good
for you in the long run. Like immediate short-term it's not good and long run it's better.
It is. But could you put that into better words than that? Probably, I think the way you describe
is actually fairly good Simon but it's that the risk of pushing yourself very hard is actually
still very low. So we see lots of middle-aged athletes doing the Loch Ness cycle event every
year. The number of people that have a cardiac event, there have been one or two, is actually
very low compared with the number of participants. Same with things like the London Marathon but
these things get a lot of publicity because it's devastating for athletic people to suddenly
present out of the blue with something's happened to cause a sudden cardiac death or
major rhythm disturbance or a cardiac event when they're exercising. So they get a lot of publicity
for these whereas the bits that don't get publicity and the bits you don't hear about is that people
who are not doing much exercise who then get their cardiac events afterwards. But it's more that
idea though that if you are training, can you still do high intensity? I think so, in the
majority of people. Now this does vary depending on how much muscle damage has been, what the
cardiac function is like. But for most cardiac events that we see there's been a small amount
of muscle damage. The heart muscle still pumps normally. The amount of scar tissue can be very,
very small that sometimes we can't even see the amount of scar because it's so small we can't
pick it up on our current imaging techniques. And for people who've got limited amounts of scar,
I think a full recovery and returning to complete normal levels of exercise after the initial
period, after you've been through that period of cardiac rehabilitation is entirely appropriate
for the majority. And I think that that's broad advice. Of course that any individual
watching this who's had cardiac events should see their cardiologist and or general practitioner and
discuss the individual level of risk. But for the majority of people, I encourage people to get back
to complete normal full levels of exercise including some of the high intensity stuff
because the high intensity stuff is, as we've alluded to in several of the previous videos,
is very beneficial as long as it's kept under moderation. You don't want all your stuff to be
high intensity. Atrial fibrillation doesn't kill people. It's a nuisance arrhythmia, it's unpleasant
and it reduces your ability to exercise when you have it. Now the majority of people who develop
atrial fibrillation, the initial bits of it is short bursts. It's called paroxysms. So that you
get some atrial fibrillation, it then settles and that as time progresses, the bursts get longer
and they get more frequent. So the initial part of it, I think it depends on how much atrial
fibrillation you're getting as to what sort of modification you want to do about things.
We do know that in people who do a lot of intense exercise that atrial fibrillation is more common
and I think that in people who are exercising very heavily, who present with paroxysmal atrial
fibrillation, we'll often have some discussion with them about what they want to do. Do they
need to carry on exercising as intensely? Do they want to cut back their exercise slightly
to modify the amount of atrial fibrillation they're going to get in the future?
Once you start getting atrial fibrillation, the majority of people it does progress over time.
So that once you've had your first episode, you're more likely to the next ones be a bit longer and
the intervals between them start becoming shorter. You're going to get more atrial fibrillation.
And it comes to this point where there's a discussion about what treatments do we offer
and those treatments are based on how much these things are impacting your lifestyle.
Right, so can people get back to full fitness after some of those treatments?
Well, in between the episodes of atrial fibrillation, initially you may get an episode
every year, every 18 months, and in between those episodes you can be exercising completely normally
and have no issues with it. Some people, we see people who have atrial fibrillation and some
people get very minimal symptoms from their atrial fibrillation and can carry on exercising
a very comparable rate to what they did before. Unfortunately, there's some people who are
debilitated by atrial fibrillation and when they get the episodes, they find that they are
incapacitated, unable to perform any significant levels of exercise. And the advice we have on
these people is really depending on the level of symptoms, how much trouble you're getting
versus what we can do to modify it. So a lot of athletic people who get recurrent increase in
frequency of atrial fibrillation, a lot end up, a lot of people don't like the drugs that we
potentially can put people on because beta blockers are our commonest drug that we use in atrial
fibrillation and a lot of athletic people struggle when they're on beta blockers because they cap
your level of aerobic exercise, they reduce your maximum heart rate. So once you're getting more
frequent, it's consideration do you do ablation procedures which is an electrical burning or
freezing of parts of your heart to create small scar lines to make it less likely to get atrial
fibrillation in the future. And a lot of people if they find they are debilitated by atrial
fibrillation will go on and have pulmonary vein isolation, that's the electrophysiological ablation
procedures to reduce the risk of it happening in the future. And what we don't know is the people
who then carry on exercising at high intensity after pulmonary vein isolation, are they more
likely to get breakout, other atrial fibrillation arising from elsewhere in the future.
As it stands at the moment there is no evidence to show that people who carry on exercising
are more likely to get problems after pulmonary vein isolation than people who don't exercise.
Is there any evidence to suggest that people who have these intermittent episodes of AF,
if they keep exercising, that that will increase their frequency of AF?
I don't know actually Simon. Theoretically you'd think that if the substrate, the thing that's
caused this has been high intensity exercise, you'd think that there's going to be a progress,
it's more likely to progress with people who continue to exercise. So back off the high
volume, high intensity. Let me ask you the question that's kind of bugging me because
the easiest thing for me to film is me. And that is, and the answer to this is I think is,
I don't know. But as you know, as we've talked about it, I've had a couple of little episodes
that I've been trying to work out what it is you've advised me. I'm just wondering how
common it is for blokes in their 60s, in their 50s, 60s, to get these. That probably don't,
I went to my GP with it, but I've not actually followed up much with that. I'm still getting
them occasionally and I've worked out how and why, what triggers it. And so I'm trying not to
do that. I'm just wondering, do we know that there are people out there watching this who might be
going, yeah, I've been feeling a little, I've been feeling a little funny too, but it'll just be one
of those things. It's probably anodominite, just my head. So we do have some data on this, which
is that palpitations and irregularity of the heart rhythm is extremely common. That the ectopic beats,
awareness of ectopic beats. Now, most of us get ectopic beats. If we put on 24-hour rhythm analysis
where we attach an ECG to people for a 24-hour period, we know that seven out of eight people
have got some form of ectopics or rhythm disturbance during the 24-hour period.
The majority of those people aren't aware of. Now, what we pick up, what your brain picks up as
signals and alerts you to depends on how much your brain is listening in to what you're coming from
the heart. So we filter out a lot of the signals and it's actually very hard to know
how much people present with. We know that I don't see that many people in hospital clinics
who come in with palpitations in sort of middle-aged athletic people who are just aware of
intermittent ectopic beats because they're very common and most people rationalize and think
these are short-lived. I don't need to do anything about them. If you're getting a sustained period
where for minutes you're aware that the heart's jumping around, it's erratic, there may be
something more in that. So I think one of the most important things that we want to emphasize though
is that for people is that the risks of exercising are vastly lower than the risks of not exercising.
All the data shows that people who are sedentary and people whose fitness levels are lower
have much worse outcomes than people who continue to exercise. And if people are anxious about
continuing to exercise once they've had a cardiac diagnosis, well you should actually be more anxious
about not exercising. It's I think one of the fundamental messages to put forward, Simon.
Huge thanks again to Dr Clarkson. If this has been helpful to you, you might consider buying me
a small coffee. It's a little payment that helps keep this show on the road. I'm Simon Willis,
thank you for listening and for watching. Until next time, goodbye.