Meet The Worst Province Of The Roman Empire.

The Roman Legacy - The Strength of Rome Endures.
17 followers
2 Video Views·Aug 7, 2025
The major topic on this channel that we've been exploring now for a few years
is the fall of the Roman Empire and how it could have come to this giant disaster.
How could that great power that had dominated the Mediterranean for centuries have fallen?
In countless videos we explored many different reasons for that disastrous fall,
from giant pandemics that would wipe out large percentages of the Roman population
to systemic problems such as a too large army that then consequently cost too much,
which led to monetary debasement and then to inflation.
From the lack of an ordered succession system to the propensity of the Romans for constant civil
wars to many more reasons, we have tried to find the main reasons for the fall of the Roman Empire.
But the reason that might sound surprising to many is actually one single province.
Yes, one province of the Roman Empire was actually so bad for Rome, that for all intents and purposes,
the Roman Empire might actually have been better off without it.
Because that province would spawn so many usurpers which would lead to so many civil wars,
that indeed it would greatly contribute to the fall of the Western Roman Empire.
And the name of that province was Britannia.
Now please don't get me wrong here, I have nothing against modern day Britain,
and this video is certainly not intended to bash Britain in any way.
It is a purely historical analysis to find out what went wrong in the Roman Empire.
Now why would I go as far as to say that Britannia, one single province,
played a big part in the fall of Rome? Well, because there was no other province
that spawned as many usurpers as would the province of Britannia.
But why? And when did things start to go bad?
The Romans already established quite early ambitions to conquer Britain.
Caesar landed twice in Britannia during the Gallic Wars, once in 55 and another time in 54 BC.
But this was not intended as a permanent conquering of the island, yet.
Caesar wanted prestige, and another motivation might have been to investigate the wealth
of that country. Great mineral wealth was suspected there, and the Britons were aiding
the Gauls against Rome, something which the Romans of course didn't like at all.
But it would be almost another century until the conquest of Britain would begin for good.
The emperor Claudius launched the first real attack intended for conquest in 43 AD.
In the following decades, the island was almost completely conquered,
with the Roman general Agricola even establishing a foothold in the far north in Caledonia,
modern day Scotland, decisively defeating the Caledonians at the Battle of Mons Graupius in 83 AD.
However, the far north of Britain would remain pacified for only about 20 years.
Then the Picts started attacking more frequently, and it appears that the Romans were content
leaving Caledonia to the barbarians in the early hundreds AD. Very likely because at the same time
the Romans were occupied in their wars against the Dacians, so there was not enough manpower
to keep Caledonia and fight the Dacians at the same time. So they built two walls against the
aggressive tribes in the north, one under the emperor Hadrian, and a second one under the
The island was initially not too bad. It is said that there were many silver and lead mines,
and a great part of the lead production of the entire Roman Empire might have come from Britannia.
As long as the Roman Empire was stable, so was Britannia somewhat stable. Of course,
it should come as no surprise that very few soldiers were actually keen on serving in
Britannia. The weather back then was not better than it is nowadays, possibly worse, and not only
was the weather bad, but of course there were often raids from the aggressive tribes in the north.
The walls of Hadrian and Antominus had to be guarded at all times, and so for about 150 years
after the conquest of Britain began under Claudius, things were actually quite stable in that province.
It was only when trouble started elsewhere in the Roman Empire, that Britannia would become very
unstable. If you are a fan of Roman history and you would want to buy an item for yourself or
someone else as a present, then you might want to consider the SPQR shop. They produce incredible
replicas of Roman history with a very high attention to detail. All their items are carefully
handcrafted and I think it will be difficult to find that level of craftsmanship anywhere else.
They handcraft Roman coin replicas, rings, pendants, attributes, and many other items
of Roman history. If you want to support the channel, or if you want to buy a present for
someone who likes Roman history, please go and check out their excellent site, link in the
description. If you buy over this link, you will receive a 20% price reduction, which I personally
find very generous. Thank you very much for your consideration and back to the video.
All in all, eight usurpers were spawned, at least in Britannia, who would fight against Rome
and several of these usurpers would have devastating effects onto the Roman Empire,
such long-lasting effects, that in fact the Empire would never recover. We know that trouble started
in the Roman Empire in earnest in the decades following the Antonine Plague. In the mid-160s
AD, a deadly virus swept through the Roman Empire, killing millions of people and greatly destabilizing
Rome. Simultaneously, the first large waves of barbarian invasions occurred all over the Empire
and this was the case in Britannia as well. In 180 AD, shortly after the Emperor Marcus Aurelius
had died, the Picts had managed to breach Harian's wall. The troops were of course constantly not
super happy in Britannia as mentioned before, it was far away from Rome, cold and rainy,
and the Picts invading on top was not a lot of fun. So they proclaimed a legate called Priscus
Emperor. However, Priscus refused and so the rebellion quickly fell apart. On top,
Commodus sent troops and so the rebellion was over before it had even started. But this first
uprising attempt from Britain in 180 AD was a sign of things to come. It would be only 15 years now
until the next rebellion would start. Clodius Albinus, governor of Britannia, was named co-emperor
by Septimius Severus after the year of the five emperors, 193 AD, a time of a chaotic succession
crisis. In 195 AD, distrusting Severus, Albinus declared himself emperor over the entire empire,
with Britannia's three legions. He crossed into Gaul, gaining support, but was defeated by
Septimius Severus at the battle of Lugtunum in 197 AD. Albinus was killed and his forces
scattered. Nonetheless, this was a full-blown civil war, and many Romans died needlessly in
that civil war. During the crisis of the 3rd century, Britannia was part of the Gallic empire
from 260 to 274. While the rebellion didn't start in Britannia, it is of course still quite
noteworthy that Britannia would be part of that breakaway Roman state. After the heroic emperor
Aurelian restored the Roman world from 270 to 275 AD, it would be not long until there would be again
usurpers from Britannia. Marcus Aurelius Carausius, a Manapian naval commander, rebelled in 286 AD
after being accused of pocketing pirate loot while policing the channel between Gallia and Britannia.
After hearing of this, the emperor Maximian ordered his execution, but instead Carausius
seized Britannia and parts of Gaul in 286 AD, forming again a breakaway state. Carausius minted
coins proclaiming himself emperor, built a fleet, and even repelled invasions from enemy tribes.
His rule stabilized Britannia until his treasurer Alectus assassinated him in 293 AD.
After murdering Carausius, Alectus declared himself emperor, controlling Britannia and
northern Gaul. His rule was weaker, relying on Carausius' fleet and legions. In 296 AD,
Constantius Chlorus launched a two-pronged invasion, defeating Alectus' forces in Britannia.
Alectus was killed in battle, likely near modern-day Silchester, ending the Carusian revolt.
It was also in Britannia that Constantine was proclaimed emperor in 306 AD. Now technically,
Constantine was some sort of semi-usurper, so he should be mentioned as well. Because the
emperor Galerius, who was at that time the senior emperor of the Tetrarchy, was against
Constantine, but in order to avoid a civil war, begrudgingly made him junior emperor or Caesar.
So, the fate of the world was decided in Britannia, because we all know what
far-reaching consequences the emperorship of Constantine would have. It would now be a
surprisingly long time where no known usurpers would be spawned in Britannia. It should be the
year 383 AD then, when the most far-reaching usurper would emerge from that province,
a Spanish-born general called Magnus Maximus. And this usurper would really change the fate
of the world. But even before Magnus Maximus, events would happen that would make Britannia
even less appealing for anyone serving there. From 367 to 368, the Picts and Scots,
together with the Saxons, invaded Roman Britain in a coordinated huge attack.
This giant disaster, in which Britannia almost fell, is known as the Great Conspiracy.
Now, I could make an entire video about the Great Conspiracy, but in essence,
it is suspected that many Romans deserted their posts and actually let in the barbarians
willingly into Britannia and even helped them. Which can mean only that it was so little fun
serving there, that they would prefer to see the island burn and fall, so that they would be rid
of having to protect it. Which really tells us just how bad it must have been serving as a Roman
legionary in the 300s AD in Britannia. It was now Theodosius the Elder, father of the later
Emperor Theodosius, who restored order in 368, driving the invaders back. But Britannia would
never recover from that blow. After these events, the province would become even more unstable than
before. Many cities had been sacked, the countryside looted, and many nobles had fled
from the island. And so it was only a matter of time until the next usurper would be proclaimed,
which was of course as mentioned, Magnus Maximus in 383 AD. Maximus was for a while uncontested in
the west. He had defeated the Emperor Gratian, and the later Emperor Valentinian II had fled
from Mediolanum to Constantinople upon his approach to Italy. And so the Eastern Roman
Empire under the Emperor Theodosius came with a large army, and there was a huge battle in 388 AD
at Poetovio in modern day Slovenia. Maximus lost, and a great number of western legions
were destroyed in the process. Britannia was left even weaker, and the Western Roman Empire
as a consequence as well. This defeat, together with the defeat of the west a few years later
at the battle of the Frigidus river, was the reason why the Western Roman Empire found itself
with far less legions than the east in the 390s AD. It was after the civil war of Magnus Maximus
and later Eugenius and Arbogast that the west would become weaker than the east,
because before that the Western Roman Empire was actually stronger than the east. This weakening
of the Western Empire due to these civil wars then of course made it easier for the Germanic
invaders to harass the west, invade Italy multiple times, only being fought back by the heroism of
Flavius Stilico. But the damage had been done. There weren't enough troops anymore, and so in
406 AD the huge disaster was allowed to happen, the invasion of Gaul and Spain by large groups of
Germanics which had invaded over the Rhine border. Had Maximus not rebelled in Britannia, the west
might have been in a much stronger position, strong enough perhaps, to fight off the invasions of 406.
It was Magnus Maximus thus which would initiate another big domino to fall that would culminate
in the fall of the Western Roman Empire, simply because the timing of that rebellion was so bad,
not being too long removed from the invasions of 406, the big turning point in the fall of the west.
Because we shouldn't forget that recruiting new troops in those days was super difficult,
so when entire legions fell, oftentimes they were only partially replenished.
After the disastrous invasions of 406, which would allow the Germanics to establish themselves
forever on the area of the Western Roman Empire, there were numerous other usurpers in Britannia,
because of course then the situation really went from bad to worse.
In very quick succession, one man called Marcus was made emperor in Britannia in 406.
However, it appears that the Roman troops were really unhappy with him, and so they killed him
in early 407 after only a few months of rain. They chose another one called Gratian, not to
be confused with the earlier Western Roman Emperor Gratian, and he too was apparently not good enough
for the dissatisfied troops. So they chose a soldier named Flavius Claudius Constantinus,
who would be better known as Constantine III. And indeed, this one they apparently deemed a worthy
regent, because they didn't kill him. It was Constantine III who would make history in taking
with him all remaining Roman soldiers in Britannia and setting over in Turgol. I wonder if
any of them foresaw that it would be the last time that Roman troops would leave the island of
Britannia. It can be assumed that Constantine III wanted to fight against the barbarian invaders,
and against the weak emperor Honorius at Ravenna, deeming himself a better emperor than Honorius,
which in all fairness he probably was. But then again, Honorius didn't set the bar very high,
to put it mildly. Constantine III unfortunately didn't manage to decisively defeat the Germanic
invaders, nor did he manage to overthrow the emperor Honorius. He unfortunately only managed,
as so many usurpers from Britannia before him, to destabilize the Roman Empire in a very crucial time
where the empire would have needed unity. Magnus Maximus' usurpation already cost the west dearly,
but Constantine III's usurpation came at such a bad time, that instead of fighting together
against the Germanic invaders, the Romans had to dispatch a large army under command of the
magister militum Constantius III to defeat this usurper, which then of course allowed the barbarians
to roam freely and ransack and plunder the Gallic and Hispanic countryside quite often at will.
We thus see the tragedy of Britannia. It was a fruitful province only for around 140 years,
until the troubles began already, and it would then spawn the largest number of usurpers of any
province, eight in total and one or two semi-usurpers if you will. But the damage that this did to the
empire was immense, especially the usurpation of Magnus Maximus cost the empire such an incredible
amount of resources and manpower, which would never be fully regained in the west. The final nail in
the coffin then was Constantine III. We could thus say that Britannia did contribute significantly
to weaken the Western Roman Empire in a crucial time period, and thus as strange as it sounds,
can be added as an additional reason why the Western Roman Empire fell.
If you like this video, please consider supporting this channel via Patreon or via YouTube membership,
because it is your support that makes this channel possible. You would have my utmost
gratitude. And of course I want to thank everybody who supports Major Janus, you people are amazing.
And if you want to learn more about what happened to Britannia after the Roman troops withdrew,
you can watch this video in the upper right corner. But if you want to learn more about the
post-Roman kingdoms of Britain, you can watch the other video in the lower right corner.
I say thanks again to all friends of Roman history, gratias ti biago and benevalete.
