愛爾蘭獨立戰爭--一戰老兵的新戰役
建築計畫觀
30粉絲
40 次觀看·2025年8月8日
This episode is sponsored by CuriosityStream. Go to curiositystream.com slash thegreatwar and you can sign up.
If you do, you'll get access to Nebula too, where you can watch current Great War episodes and other creators ad free.
So go to curiositystream.com slash thegreatwar and sign up for one year.
It's September 1920, and the British have introduced a new force of Great War veterans
to crush the independence movement in Ireland.
This month, the Auxiliary Division launches a major seek-and-destroy operation against the IRA.
It's the Irish War of Independence.
Hi, I'm Jesse Alexander, and welcome to the Great War.
By mid-1920, the Irish War of Independence had been going on for the better part of two years.
The political fight for Irish independence was led by Sinn Féin,
while the guerrilla campaign against Britain was carried out by the Irish Republican Army.
The British had at first relied on the Royal Irish Constabulary Police Force to maintain order,
but had soon introduced the RIC Special Reserve, better known as the Black and Tans, in March 1920,
and you can learn more about them in our previous episode about the war.
The Black and Tans were mostly English veterans of the Great War,
and in the summer of 1920, this reliance on Great War soldiers
to maintain British control in Ireland would take a new form, the Auxiliary Division.
They soon became known for introducing a new breed of violence
into the conflict exactly 100 years ago.
By mid-1920, the situation in Ireland, from the British point of view at least,
was becoming more and more fragile.
Attacks on the police by the IRA volunteers had forced many police departments
to fall back to more secure urban barracks.
This allowed Sinn Féin to set up a shadow state in rural areas,
since they were the leading party in the self-proclaimed Irish Parliament.
This parallel state was especially noticeable in the justice system.
By the summer, it had essentially come to a standstill,
as both jurors and witnesses refused to attend trials.
This was perhaps partly due to patriotic Republican leanings,
but also because of a mass campaign of intimidation by the IRA.
At some sessions, even the magistrates themselves refused to turn up for court.
One magistrate in Mayo even wrote,
Everybody is yielding to Sinn Féin, whether they approve of it or not.
They say they can do nothing else,
and that the government cannot or will not protect them,
and the police can barely protect themselves.
As British control weakened, Sinn Féin established more and more institutions
of government, including Republican courts, police patrols, and even taxes.
One of the reasons why the British were losing their grip
was that the government underestimated the sophistication
of the Irish Republican movement.
To many ministers, including Prime Minister David Lloyd George,
the IRA was nothing more than a rabble of quote murder gangs.
Military figures in Ireland, however, like former Great War General Lord John French,
were beginning to understand the full extent of the resistance.
They claimed that martial law was the solution
that would bring order to the island,
since this would provide them with a full set of military options
and control of the courts.
A close friend of the Prime Minister, Lord George Riddell,
wrote about his take after a conversation with Lord French.
If the position were recognized,
and if the Irish were met with a proper military force,
the whole agitation would be crushed in a few months.
It was absurd to think that the British army
could not quell such an insurrection if given proper powers.
French said it was an underground conspiracy.
You might pass from one end of Ireland to the other
and not see anything abnormal.
But the rebel organization was there.
But the Prime Minister disagreed.
Declaring martial law would be unpopular with public opinion
and legitimate the IRA as a real state army.
Lloyd George put it this way.
You do not declare war against rebels.
Instead, the burden would continue to fall on the police.
By the summer, this was a mix of the old Irish policemen
and the new, predominantly English recruits
of the Black and Tans Special Reserve.
But even the Black and Tans were in turmoil
after just a few months in Ireland.
Morale was low, and a small mutiny
even broke out in County Kerry.
Many Black and Tans resigned,
and within a year only half the men
who had joined in 1920 were still with the RIC.
So despite the introduction of the Black and Tan police,
the British were no closer to regaining control.
Even though the largely veteran force
had not brought the expected results,
the idea of recruiting British Great War veterans
still had appeal.
In July 1920, Lieutenant General Henry Tudor,
the lead policeman at Dublin Castle,
got permission to raise a new force of ex-officers
to take on the IRA.
This new force was officially called
the Auxiliary Division Royal Irish Constabulary,
or Auxies for short.
But they've often been referred to as Black and Tans as well,
even though they were a separate outfit
from the RIC Special Reserve.
As historian Charles Townsend explains,
the second generation of Black and Tans
neither looked like police, nor behaved like them.
In July, advertisements appeared in Britain
calling on former officers with
courage, discretion, tact and judgment
to join the new force.
In exchange, the men would receive a pound a day,
making them the highest paid uniformed force
in the world at that time.
The recruiters stressed that social class
would not be a barrier to joining the auxiliaries.
This was important,
since class had been a key component
of the British officer corps before 1916,
but the Auxies would be mostly working
and middle class men.
As more higher class officers
were killed during the Great War,
rank and file men were promoted to take their place.
But once the war ended,
these working class officers
now found themselves shut out of the good jobs
that their higher class colleagues enjoyed.
To them, the high pay in the auxiliaries
was far better than a working class wage.
This meant the Auxiliary Division
became a diverse group,
including ex-officers from all parts
of the United Kingdom, Canadians, New Zealanders,
Australians, South Africans, and even Americans.
And at least 10% were Irish.
One in every eight auxiliaries
had been decorated during the Great War,
including three Victoria Cross holders
and a recipient of the French Médaille Militaire.
In all, about 2,200 men joined the auxiliaries,
about two-thirds of whom were in service at one time.
Like their background,
the Auxiliary Division's kit was also diverse.
Much like the Black and Tans,
there was a lack of official uniforms,
and so the auxiliaries generally wore
a mixture of military khakis
topped off with the regulation tam-o-shanter cap.
And the rules about this sort of thing were lax.
They were even allowed to wear
open-thigh, low-slung hip holsters
as former Auxiliary Bill Monroe recalled.
Some of us were influenced by Western films
and wore our revolvers in holsters
low-slung on the thigh,
which looked very dashing,
but which was the cause of
quite a number of shot-off toes,
as the enthusiasts attempted
to emulate the cowboys of Texas.
In terms of weaponry,
the Auxiliary Division men
had their pick of a variety of firearms,
including the standard Lee-Enfield rifle,
as well as Winchester repeating rifles
and pump-action shotguns.
Although the new Colt 1911 pistol
proved to be a particularly popular novelty
for a while,
many returned to their
reliable wartime Webleys.
They were also allowed to wear
service ribbons on their battle dress,
perhaps to intimidate
and impress the locals.
On their shoulders,
each wore an insignia
including the initials T.C.
for Temporary Cadet,
although as one Auxiliary Division
Quartermaster put it,
the Auxiliary's own interpretation
of those letters is unprintable.
And it's also unspeakable
in a history documentary,
but I can reveal
the first word is tough
and the second word
only has four letters.
So the British had now recruited
an Auxiliary Division of ex-officers
to join the police and the Black and Tans
in putting down the revolt in Ireland.
They were divided into companies
of 100 men
to better carry out
their intended mission,
as emergency reinforcements
for the badly stretched RIC garrisons,
but also to seek out
and destroy the IRA
in Ireland's most Republican regions.
By August,
15 companies had been formed,
which were immediately dispatched
to the counties of Dublin,
Kilkenny, Cork, and Galway,
the strongholds of the IRA.
One of their main activities
was to simply patrol the area
as a show of force
to reinstate Crown control.
Temporary cadet Ernest Lissett
explained their duties in his diary.
We were on dangerous duty,
which was to keep the highways
and roads open to traffic.
Every morning,
the patrols would leave the castle
at 8 a.m.,
with definite routes
to be followed
by the officer in charge.
All in battle order
and ready for trouble on the way.
Notwithstanding the tension,
it was very interesting,
passing through the most beautiful country,
but we never knew
what was just around the bend.
When passing through deep cuttings,
sometimes we sent out scouts
on either side of us,
for security against roadblocks.
Their most aggressive objective
of seeking out the IRA
was a difficult one,
as the IRA units
would generally only gather
when launching attacks of their own.
However,
if accurate information was available,
search and destroy operations
could be launched,
like the one at Kilmarshog
in the Dublin Mountains
on September 19, 1920.
An IRA unit
was based in an old quarry
in the mountains,
and was being trained
with a new explosive
nicknamed War Flower.
IRA headquarters
planned to send an inspection team
to the quarry,
and the British learned
of the planned meeting.
The auxiliaries launched an attack
which was a success,
and caught the IRA fighters
by surprise.
40 were made prisoner,
and one was killed in the assault.
The operation was seen
by the British
as a great success
by an efficient
and disciplined force.
In reality, though,
this kind of raid
was extremely rare,
since the accurate intelligence
that made it possible
was usually not to be had.
And behind the scenes,
trouble was brewing
in the auxiliary division.
Discipline had been a problem
right from the start.
Tudor had not made adequate
logistical preparations
for the unit,
according to its first commander,
Brigadier General Frank Crozier.
A lot of misery,
inconvenience,
and hard drinking
could have been avoided
had arrangements been made
for the reception of these men,
for their ordinary comfort,
quartering, messing, and discipline.
But instead,
the men were running around Cura
as they liked.
The original members
of the division,
which then had no name,
had to arrange
their own messing and canteens,
and there was nobody in command.
So without much to do,
and with a lot of money
in their pockets in the early weeks,
many auxiliary men
passed their time with drinking,
with little supervision
from the chain of command.
In one incident,
RIC and auxiliary men
ended up shooting
at each other
while drinking in a hotel.
In the resulting inquest,
the Deputy Adjutant General
in Ireland noted,
They all had the wind up,
blood up,
and did what they used to do
in the trenches of France.
In the circumstances,
you cannot hold them
criminally responsible,
but they are not fit
to be policemen.
But are any auxiliaries?
Within the first four months,
50 men had been dismissed
for disciplinary issues,
and another 40 would desert,
which was an extremely rare thing
amongst British officers.
Some contemporaries
and historians
have explained these problems
by pointing to the men's
traumatizing experience
of fighting in the Great War.
But a more likely explanation
was the poor preparation,
the lack of command structure,
and the pressures
of the situation in Ireland,
which had much more in common
with a counter-insurgency
than with a traditional war.
So the Auxiliary Division
had begun operations,
but was suffering from problems
with discipline and morale.
In spite of its stated goal
of seeking out and fighting the IRA,
the Auxiliary Division
is best known for its important role
in reprisals against
the civilian population.
Now, up until the middle of 1920,
both sides had shown
some degree of restraint
in the conflict.
IRA attacks usually targeted
individuals for assassination,
and the RIC were reluctant
to punish whole communities
for alleged Republican support.
These last inhibitions, though,
disappeared in the summer of 1920,
and in the face of
increasing police frustration
at IRA attacks,
the Irish people themselves
became targets.
The RIC and the Auxiliaries
began to respond to IRA attacks
with reprisals against local residents.
Between July
and September,
there were notable reprisals
in Turles, Upper Church, Limerick,
Templemore, and Balbriggan, among others.
These attacks varied in scale
and in the degree of violence,
but often involved
the destruction of homes
and businesses,
as well as shooting
and grenade attacks.
Now, explaining these reprisals
in detail is a bit complex.
The RIC were facing
a general boycott campaign,
which meant that local shop owners
often refused to sell to them.
In some places,
this led to severe food shortages
among the police,
even though the boycott
was not observed by all,
and some only participated
under pressure from the IRA.
This hostile environment
in many communities
was seen by the police
inspector general
as one of the reasons
for the reprisals.
The men are boycotted,
ostracized,
forced to commandeer their food,
crowded into cramped quarters
without light or air,
every man's hand against them,
in danger of their lives,
and subjected to the appeals
of their families
to induce them to leave the force.
In these circumstances,
an IRA attack
could easily ignite
police retaliation,
and the Tabarkari reprisal
is a typical example.
A police inspector
was killed by the IRA,
and his body brought back
to the barracks,
where it was seen by the men.
They promptly drove
into town on trucks,
shouting for Sinn Féin to come out.
They fired at windows
and threw grenades at buildings,
and wrecked 11 shops.
The troops then destroyed
two dairy creameries,
which were vital
to the local economy.
Local resident Mrs. Murican
described the behaviour of the police.
They all seemed to me
to speak with an Irish accent.
The swearing was awful.
The men asked me
where my husband was,
and I asked him
what they wanted him for.
They replied, to shoot him.
Journalist Hugh Martin
visited the place two days later,
and described the destruction.
Little spires of smoke
were twisting up
from three jagged stone skeletons,
and the breeze twirled ashes
instead of autumn leaves
across the open ground.
Many shops, I counted 11,
and there may have been more
between and beside
the burnt-out buildings,
had their fronts battered and broken,
so that the whole triangle
had the air of having
barely survived an earthquake.
The auxiliaries
soon gained a reputation
as the main perpetrators
of these reprisals,
especially after a string of murders
in the summer and fall.
Now, reprisals
were officially banned in August,
but the British authorities
often turned a blind eye.
Tudor was reluctant
to punish those responsible.
How the devil can we round up
and try 50 policemen
when we know that they know
that the bulk of their officers
up to the top
agree in principle
with their action?
Some officers actually
encourage the men to commit crimes,
like Lt. Col. Gerald Smith
of the RIC.
The more you shoot,
the better I will like you,
and no policeman
will get into trouble
for shooting a man.
Even Lloyd George
didn't oppose the reprisals,
but he did prefer a policy
of shooting suspected IRA men,
known as quote counter-murder,
to indiscriminate destruction.
Some military leaders
worried that the police attacks
were bad for discipline,
but even critics acknowledged
that they were having some effect.
In some places,
locals began offering
the police information on the IRA
to avoid reprisals
against their communities,
a development one officer
called quote cringing submission.
And so,
as the conflict developed
later into 1920,
the villages and towns of Ireland
had become battlegrounds in the war.
For local residents,
this meant that they had to navigate
not only the danger of police reprisals,
but the IRA's program
of intimidation as well.
It's quite difficult to accurately
estimate the degree of IRA support
amongst the general population.
It's likely that most people,
especially in the South,
did sympathize with the Republican cause
to some extent,
but the degree of that support varied.
There were some who remained
loyal to the Crown,
and now they could be seen
as potential spies or informers
by both sides.
And there were also those
who cooperated with the police
out of fear of reprisal
or economic pressure,
even if they themselves
were Republicans.
To weaken support for the British
and cooperation with them,
the Republican movement
operated a system of ostracization.
Families or individuals
known to harbour loyalist beliefs,
or who were relatives of policemen,
could find themselves excluded
from public and commercial life.
In close-knit village communities,
such ostracization
could have a major impact.
Women who were known
to fraternize with the police
were often targeted,
and some were even dragged
into town squares
to have their heads shaved.
In many cases,
known or suspected informants
were murdered,
their bodies often bearing notices
warning others against
providing information to the RIC.
Many normal Irish people
found themselves caught
in this tense middle ground
between police reprisals
and IRA intimidation.
Historian Peter Hart
explained this cycle of violence.
This little cycle of killings
reveals the runaway,
tit-for-tat logic
of the guerrilla war in Cork,
driven by fear
and the overwhelming need to respond.
Murder was more common than battle.
This dirty war
was waged largely
by small bands of gunmen,
young, tough,
and barely under the control
of their superiors.
The active squads on both sides
did what they liked,
undeterred by orders
or discipline
further up the organization.
And it was the Republicans
who benefited the most,
politically speaking,
from the violence.
Chin Fain was able to exploit
police violence
for propaganda purposes,
and portray it
as an organized campaign
of murder and destruction,
which was not a difficult task
given the nature of the reprisals.
Following the increase
in police violence,
Lillie Yates,
the sister of the Irish poet WB Yates,
wrote to her brother,
As you know,
I was no Chin Fainer,
just a mild nationalist.
But now?
So the IRA had begun
to gain more support
as a result
of violent police reprisals,
even while it also
put pressure on civilians.
But it wasn't gaining ground
all over the island.
In the Ulster region
in the northeast,
the population
was mostly loyal to Britain.
Back in the 1918 general election,
Chin Fain had swept
the power across Ireland,
except in the northeast counties,
making up the region of Ulster.
This mostly Protestant area
supported the Irish Unionist Party,
which opposed republicanism
and wanted to remain
within the United Kingdom.
Officially,
Chin Fain continued to say
that an independent Ireland
must include all of its counties
and provinces, including Ulster.
In reality though,
the IRA had little influence
in the northeast,
and their units operating there
were much less active
than in the Catholic
parts of the island.
Instead of focusing
on guerrilla attacks,
the republican leadership
organized an economic boycott
of the region.
Initially,
the Irish president,
Emmanuel de Valera,
was reluctant to do this,
since he thought it might damage
the chances for a united Ireland.
But activists began to organize
spontaneous boycotts,
and Chin Fain eventually
threw its support behind them.
They arranged the boycott
of Belfast-based banks
and insurance companies,
and this boycott quickly expanded
to almost all goods
manufactured in Ulster.
The idea behind the blockade
was to remind people in Ulster
of their economic dependence
on the rest of Ireland.
But it seemed to have
the opposite effect.
In response to IRA attacks
and the boycott,
a pre-war unionist
paramilitary organization
was reformed –
the Ulster Volunteer Force.
Some figures
in the British administration
supported the UVF,
like the Chief Secretary
for Ireland, Hamar Greenwood.
But others were worried
that its resurgence
could trigger even more violence.
And violence did begin
to increase between Protestants,
who were more likely to support
the union with Britain,
and Catholics,
who were more likely
to favour a republic.
One incident occurred in August,
after the death of an RIC
district inspector in Lisbon,
in the mostly Protestant northeast.
Three hundred homes
belonging to Catholics
were destroyed,
and nearly the entire
Catholic population of the town
were forced to flee.
In some areas
with a Catholic majority,
Protestant families
living in Catholic neighbourhoods
were pushed out into Protestant areas.
And in many northern towns,
a sectarian divide was established
that would endure for generations.
So by the early fall of 1920,
British authorities
had some grounds for optimism.
The auxiliaries seemed to be
gaining some control
over Republican areas,
even though they had
created controversy
because of their role
in violence against civilians.
And they had yet to sustain
a single fatal casualty,
which helped increase police morale
and correspondingly weaken
the morale of the IRA.
The IRA rank and file
was also frustrated
with the slow pace of operations,
police reprisals,
and the death of some
leading Republican figures,
like the Mayor of Cork.
In early November 1920,
British authorities
reported on their progress.
Much of the moral and material
support lent to Sinn Féin
is due to fear.
And with the growth
of the realisation
that the government
is beginning to get a grip
of the situation,
there are indications
of a return to sanity
and revulsion against Sinn Féin
on the part of more responsible persons.
Despite this optimism,
British confidence
on how things were developing
in Ireland would soon be shaken
by events on a late November Sunday.
As history creators,
we're facing more and more problems
talking about certain aspects
of history here on YouTube.
Our 18-part,
five-hour-long documentary
that we made
about the Battle of Berlin
wouldn't be allowed on YouTube
because it shows a part of history
that's not really,
let's say,
advertiser-friendly.
So we got together
with some of our other creator friends,
and we teamed up
to have a platform
where creators like us
don't have to worry
about demonetisation
or YouTube's algorithm,
and where the subscribers,
like you,
are directly supporting
the creators
that you guys watch.
So the content is ad-free,
and for example,
the Nebula version of this video
doesn't feature this very ad
that you're watching right now.
So imagine sparing yourself
from this experience of advertising.
Now what does that all have to do
with CuriosityStream,
our main sponsor
that we mentioned
at the beginning of the videos?
Well,
they like documentaries
and educational content,
so they partnered with Nebula,
and they're offering you guys a package.
If you go to curiositystream.com
slash the great war,
you can sign up for CuriosityStream,
and not only get access
to their library of documentaries,
but you also get access
to the creator platform on Nebula for free.
It's not a trial.
You'll have it as long
as you're a CuriosityStream member.
So for a limited time,
CuriosityStream is offering
26% off of their usual annual plan,
and that means
it's less than 15 US dollars a year
for both CuriosityStream and Nebula,
which, if you ask me,
is a pretty fantastic deal.
And since virtual learning
is quite important right now,
given the world circumstances,
you can watch and learn about space
with astronaut Chris Hadfield,
who's a Canadian, by the way,
or learn about the Battle of Berlin
with our very own documentary series,
16 Days in Berlin,
and it's all on Nebula
and CuriosityStream.
And if you sign up and watch,
you'll be directly supporting our channel.
So that's curiositystream.com
slash thegreatwar for 26% off,
and we appreciate your support.
Now as usual,
you can find all our sources
for this episode
in the video description below.
And if you want to support our channel,
you can support us on Patreon,
and the links for that
are in the video description below as well.
And Patreon supporters
will also be able to ask
questions on our Great War Audio podcast,
and as you've guessed,
the link to that
is in the video description.
I'm Jesse Alexander,
and this is The Great War 1920,
a production of Real Time History
and the only YouTube history channel
taking on all of the TCs on YouTube.
