Ultimate Comparison | Type R v GR Corolla v Elantra N v Subaru S209 v Golf R

Cars Arena
18 followers
14 Video Views·Aug 6, 2025
Mark, look what I brought you. I brought you five four-cylinder cars. I brought you an STI S209,
the GR Corolla Circuit Edition, a Civic Type R, a Golf R, and a Elantra N. We were gonna call this
the shitbox shootout, but unfortunately that car over there is like 80 grand. They're almost
impossible to afford these days, Jeff. 80 grand? More like a hundred thousand dollars, and that's
how I want to spend my money. I want to spend my money on a $100,000 STI. But guess what? I
borrowed something even more special for the day, but it's costing me $300 an hour. Hey, Bobby, will
you go get this guy? Hey, where are you going, pal? I paid for you. You're mine. What's your name and
what do you do? My name is Carlos Lago. I've tested cars. I've reviewed cars. I've spent a lot of my
professional life around cars and telling people how much fun cars are to drive and that they
should drive cars. Why are you here? I don't know. We're at Autobahn Country Club in Joliet, and yes,
all five of these cars are about to be lapped by a pro driver, Britt Casey. At the same time,
at the same track, under the same identical conditions, and most importantly for our
testing, we've eliminated a variable. All five of these cars are on the same spec tire, a Bridgestone
Potenza Sport. While it is not the stickiest tire ever invented or ever designed, it is a tire that
all five of these cars could be fitted to in their factory size. So we've eliminated the issue of the
tire variable. However, this fine gentleman from a certain magazine is here to counter my point.
And by issue, you mean hundreds, if not thousands of comments saying, you idiots, why don't you put
the same tire on all these cars when you do track events? We get that a lot, especially at Lightning
Lap. And there's a couple of reasons for that, legitimate ones. The first one is practical. Find
me a make and model of tire that will fit on everything from a Mazda Miata to a Lamborghini
Huracan. The second one is philosophical. When engineers develop these cars, they do it for a
specific tire. And there's a lot of things that go into that development that range from ride and
handling to NVH. The other part of that is we don't want to reward a manufacturer for not putting the
best tires it can on a vehicle that it sells. That said, I'm really excited to see what all
these vehicles do on effectively the same tire, because I'm curious to see how it's going to line
up to what our results say when we run them on the tires they come with from the factory.
I guess you took all my lines because I got nothing to say.
Now, you can't do a comparison on cars like this without touching on the pros and cons of the
When I finish this, I'm going to rate the audio systems from best to worst
using our objective measurements as well. So let's get started with the Volkswagen
Golf R. And when you look at this on the outside, it's by far the most mature-looking of the group.
It can slide under the radar, it looks more timeless, and it maintains that classic hatchback
shape that many other manufacturers are ditching in favor of the fastback or liftback. It really
does have a good presence to it without screaming at you if that's what you're looking for.
The hatchback also offers plenty of cargo capacity, although of course not as much as
the Civic. It doesn't have the interior capacity of the Elantra either, but it still feels the
most luxury car out of the bunch. It feels far less sports car, more purposeful as a highway
cruiser. Things like the touch points, the plastic panels, and the carbon fiber accents,
and even the door panels felted storage space for drinks and all of that. It just
feels decluttered. And by design, that's what they were going for here. They wanted to get
rid of all the physical controls, all the clutter, and it's supposed to make you feel like, ah,
I'm not stressed out. And the problem with that, and it has been on all these new modern VWs, is
the decision from the top to do this, to remove physical controls, has had such a catastrophic
effect on people's willingness to buy into this. Because now everything's software, but you also
have the problem of having touch or capacitive touch controls, which make the usability of this
the worst out of all of these cars that we've tested. And I know internally, there's people
really working hard to try to fix this, but because of the way the car market works, supply chain,
when you design this, it's hard to just change it like that. It's not like updating a phone.
You have to literally redo interior. So as this stands, it's probably the worst
of the bunch in terms of usability, but let's head into the Corolla GR.
The GR Corolla, yet another true hatchback, much like the Golf R. However, unlike the Golf R,
this feels far more econobox. It feels closely related to a $20,000 car, more so than the 40
plus thousand dollars the dealers are commanding for it. The exterior proportions are definitely on
the smaller side. This would be appealing to somebody that doesn't want a big car,
namely compared to like the Type R, which feels like a huge sedan. This can get into tight spaces
in the city. If you don't have a big garage, it's perfect for you. And if you don't need
a massive cavern of storage, the GR Corolla is going to suit you fine. The interior space,
unfortunately, you just can't get away from that ---- box feeling. It feels more claustrophobic.
It feels more dated. The plastics are insanely hard. The huge bulbous pieces of the dash that
will break your leg in half and some of the piano black that does not belong in a driver's car like
this. However, the inputs are all physical. The steering wheel controls are great. The gauge
cluster is easy to read. The HVAC controls are all physical. And unlike the Golf R and the Type R,
you get a traditional manual parking brake here, which is very, very welcome in a manual
transmission fun to drive car. The negatives are it feels like a much smaller space and a much more
buzzy one. And with the removal of the armrest, it just feels like something's off in terms of
ergonomics in here. But let's talk about the Elantra N. The Elantra N, no hatch here, just a
trunk space with a giant support bar to add structural rigidity, which you could technically
remove if you didn't want the added performance there to gain extra space. The outside represents
the problem with Hyundai and Kia styling. It's very here and now designed to wow you with modern
elements. It doesn't particularly age well and it hasn't aged well. And it's not a car that you're
going to look at and be like, wow, that is just a masterpiece of sports car design. But when you
get on the inside, it definitely is the more one of the more purposeful, more spacious and
comfortable cars of the group. That's because it has a usable back seat. It has a usable front seat
and it also has a manual parking brake on the inside, which is great. However, the center
stack is kind of marred by the support or grab handle on the passenger side, which kind of
impedes or makes it feel smaller than it is. However, they use all physical controls for
almost everything. And the infotainment is one of the more thought out versions of any car,
including the way you customize all the performance gauges, including the gauge
cluster when you're driving displays the most pertinent things that you possibly want legibly.
And on the software end, they do a great job with the Elantra N. But let's hop into the Honda Civic
Type R. The Honda Civic Type R represents the largest vehicle in this segment. You can tell
that Honda knew that people were looking for bigger vehicles, so they made the Type R this
liftback design. While it is not the prettiest car of the bunch, they spent the most amount of
money modifying the exterior panels to match its wide body look without having to use tacked on
bits. So depending on the color, it has a presence to it. It has a more traditional presence as much
as a modern car can have. The hatch space is enormous. The back seats are completely usable
and the interior space and the way that the doors open are very wide. So you could use this as an
everyday car. It is also one of the newer vehicles in this lineup or in this test. So, you know,
they've had a little bit of leg up on the competition. The inside space is the standout
for a performance car application. They already started with a great interior from the Honda
Civic, the base Honda Civic. It doesn't feel like it's rooted as much of in a shitbox car like the
Corolla. It almost matches its price in many ways, namely when you start looking at the input points
or the seats. The seats are a large step up from the competition. Although, of course, including
this car, it was under the original 600 plus cars that were recalled for a faulty weld in the driver's
seat. It's early adopter problems. But other than that, all the inputs feel very clicky. The steering
wheel inputs are good. The shifter assembly feels great. All the major controls of this car
are physical as well. HVAC, all of that stuff just works instantaneously. The dimmer switch on here,
you can really dim down lighting at night. There's a lot of thought to detail that goes into
making this a real car, but also feeling more special like a sports car at the same time.
The infotainment, you know, while it has wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto in the functions
work relatively well, it's under processed. It doesn't have enough processing power in it,
it is slow. Everything delays. It takes a long time for things to happen.
And as this car ages, it's going to be worse and worse when the competition have done things much
better. So overall, the Civic has one of the better interiors. This is a much bigger car.
So if you're looking for that smaller, like more nimble feeling vehicle, that's not this.
The Subaru S209 represents much of what Subaru had been doing for the past 10, 15 years in terms
of interior space. Everything feels like it could be an early 2000s or 90s car. All the physical
controls are clicky. The visibility in the car is the best of the bunch. And it just feels like
old school. And that's because it is. Subaru carried over this design on interior and exterior
mostly for a long period of time. So you're not overburdened with any technology infotainment.
That's ridiculous. A gauge cluster that's all digital. If you like that old school feel,
the Subaru is definitely going to do it for you. It also has a trunk. So the trunk space is not as
big as the Elantra, but it is just a very usable car. You can fit car seats in the back. You can
use it as a true family car. While it's not as big as the Civic, all of the major components are
almost as usable. It may not be as aesthetically pleasing as the Civic, but it is a very, very
accessible car for multiple people. Last but not least, the audio system testing. From the worst
vehicle to the best. Starting with the GR Corolla, which takes last place. Big surprise. It's a car
that is rooted on economy car platforms that was never designed to scale up into more of a luxury
experience. They didn't spend a lot of time or energy or money on the audio system in this car,
largely because why? Most people don't care about that. However, it definitely tells it's one of the
more tin canny sounding experiences. It has the most harmonic distortion and the frequency
response is all over the place. The third place car is the Elantra N, and a lot of this has to do
with harmonic distortion. It is not a well designed audio system. The SPL levels are kind
of up and down. There's as much as a 20 or 10 to 20 dB swing throughout the frequency range,
but the left to right, the driver and the passenger frequency response is pretty even
overall. So you're going to get a neutral experience, whether you're on a driver or
passenger side. The second place car is the Golf R, and while at the base frequency response level
and some of the distortion levels, it looks better than the Civic. It starts to fall apart in the mid
to upper frequency range where you have these huge dips, as much as 20 dB swings up and down.
So that loss of SPL or energy, you can definitely hear it in the mid to high frequency range,
which is surprising because this is more of a luxury car interior design. So the audio system
is definitely not as good, although you do have the ability to tune the EQ on the Golf R, where
none of the other cars allow you to do that to a granular control. Left and right, the passenger
side versus the driver side is pretty equal as well in terms of tuning. The winner of the test
is the Civic Type R, which somewhat surprised me. It has the most natural frequency response
without any dips or huge drop-offs, with the exception of around 150 Hz. There is a slight
dip there, and the base response is not as good as the Golf R, but in the mid to upper frequency
ranges, it's pretty good for a price or car in this price point. However, they tuned more of the
work or Bose did most of the tuning for the driver. The passenger side is not nearly as good as the
driver side compared to the other cars, but I'm going to leave it at that. Let's briefly head
into the shop. We're going to talk about the highlights of each car. Speed round, Jack. Five
of these bad boys in the shop. We're going to cover the highlights of the mechanical attributes
of each car. However, it's strange in the modern age that every single one of these cars, despite
them being at the more entry-level price point for a sports car, has a unique manufacturing story.
Every brand took a different approach, but it's all a specialty approach. So which car are we
going to start with? Let's start with the Elantra N, and before we discuss that car, if you are
looking to learn more about each one of these individual cars, we have separate videos, and we
do have an upcoming independent FL5 Civic Type R video where we're going to discuss all the
engineering in great length. So if there's a car you like the most, you can go watch that video.
Elantra N is one of the few cars in this test that has an optional dual-clutch gearbox. So if
you can't drive stick, you can get it in this vehicle. Honestly, it's faster as a dual-clutch,
but for the sake of evenness for this test, we opted for the manual. It has a different body
rigidity strategy than a regular Elantra, so it's stiffer, it has wide tires, it has big brakes,
and most notably, it's one of the few cars in this test also with an electronic front
limited-slip differential. Every corner of this car has been touched. Every corner, from bushings,
to the strut mounts, to the knuckles, to the bearings in the hubs, like all of these things
have been beefed up and all of the changes have made have been made from the learnings of the
Veloster N and the previous N cars. So the Elantra N is the culmination. It is the best version of
all the N products, at least with an internal combustion engine. And it's one of the best
driving Hyundai products we've ever been in. It also has a slightly different engine, at least
turbine for the turbo in this four-cylinder, versus the Veloster N. I think the next thing
to talk about though, Mark, is the next car. Let's do it, Jack. The next car is going to be
the GR Corolla. The Corolla is built on a modified version of the TNGA-C car that everybody knows and
loves. It has wider fenders, wider tires, same type of strategy, increased rigidity, better brakes,
everything that the Elantra N had, but with a slightly different strategy in terms of dynamics
because they've thrown on all-wheel drive here, Jack. This car mostly acts. You can't decouple
the front wheels, but it chooses when it wants to send power to the back actively based on the
drive modes. Also, the other thing to note is it is a three-cylinder, so it has a different character
to the engine. It's a little more agricultural sounding. Some people find it charming. It only
can be had as a manual, and in this test we did the circuit edition. While you can get an even
harder-core version, the Marizo, they only make 250 a year, which essentially makes it irrelevant.
The circuit mechanically is identical to the core model, which is the one that you and I could
probably actually buy, and it has the performance pack as standard, which means it has both of the
mechanical limits. Which is absolutely something you'd want to option if you're doing any type of
aggressive driving. This is a true Toyota sports car. They took the development from the Yaris,
and they co-developed this car, the Corolla, at the same time. So all the development there
was transitioned into this. It's just a bigger car for the North American market. It has a longer
wheelbase, so the main focus was stability in terms of engineering and driving character. The
next car to talk about is the FL5 Civic Type R. Tell me about it. I'll tell you about it, Jack.
This is an evolution of the FK8. So everything they learned from the previous generation Type R,
they've taken, they've put it in a more attractive body style, or I'm sorry, a less
aggressive body style. The interior has been improved to align itself with the current
generation Civic. So the main highlights here is there's improved aero, there is a different
turbocharger, they've made some adjustments to engine tuning, the cooling has been increased,
so the cooling capacity has been increased. So you have less overheating, or you have a longer
period of time you can run on a track. More consistency. Correct. The brakes are a carryover
from the second end of the FK8, where you have a flat-faced two-piece rotor with no slots or
cross-drilling. And the body structure has had some subtle improvements. Again, it's the subtle
transition from model year to model year, generation to generation. The main thing here is
the front end. This is a front-wheel drive only car. You have a dual-axis suspension layout in
the front with a strut or adaptive dampers by ZF. It is tuned on the more aggressive side, but
the fundamental idea of this car was to make a front end that had a limited amount of torque
steer, a limited amount of wheel hop. You can just put the hammer down in the corners and it feels
less front-wheel drive. That's where all Honda's know-how is. Everybody's like, oh, why do they
keep doing front-wheel drive? Well, Honda clearly knows how to do front-wheel drive. They've been
doing it forever. So this is the pinnacle of what they can do with a chassis. But one thing I will
say about this car is it is very hard on brakes. When we talked to our friends at Counter Space
Garage, if you are going to run this car flat out, you're going to need to do pads because it does
torque vector by brake in the front of the vehicle. So if you are a god-tier driver and you're going
flat out, you're going to run into that issue. The next car, Mark, is the Mark 8 Golf R. This,
along with the Elantra N, is the only car that gets a dual clutch. You can either get a manual
or a dual clutch. We have a manual, again, to keep the tests consistent. This is on the latest
variation of MQB, which is VW's front-wheel drive architecture. The joy of this is because it's
shared with luxury cars. This is one of the most premium platforms of any of the cars in this test.
It has an aluminum front subframe, aluminum suspension links. They've done their best to
make this vehicle as isolated and as comfortable and as refined as possible. That's always been
the joy of a VW GTI or Golf R. So it's the only car in this test with a torque vectoring rear diff
that is also all-wheel drive. The last car, though, Mark, we're going to talk about is the STI S209.
This is a Subaru built or engineered by STI, Subaru's racing division. It is a hand-built car.
They widened a RA and now can run 265 wide tires. It's more rigid. It has a zero-defect policy,
which means all of the bolts were hand-torqued and they did their best to maintain the highest
levels of QC. It even has a hand-built EJ engine. This car, when they were developing it in the late
20-teens, was benched against the ATS-V. This is the most motorsports-capable STI they ever built.
It's the culmination of years of experience and all these little details, as we talked about in
the original video, make no sense when you look at the price. But when you look at all the little
things they tinkered with, it's one of the most connected cars of its generation. And it's included
in this test because it feels so special to drive at the limit. Hydraulic steering. Yes, hydraulic
steering. And despite it not looking all that fancy underneath, little things like the draw
stiffeners in the front end and, of course, in the back hatch, the way that they've tuned the
suspension, they really did an amazing job to make this a driver's car. The engine does have
some modifications. They went to a different turbo and different fueling strategy. They weren't able
to do a forged bottom end because they found they ran out of time and development money to do that
because they couldn't get it to be reliable. Now, the stickler with this test is this is the only
car of the bunch that DNFed. However, to be fair to it, it's the only car in the test that was
provided by a viewer, and it does have 40,000 miles on it. The car is completely stock. There's
nothing touched on it besides brake pads. Counterspace Garage was kind enough to lend us
brake pads, and we also did brake fluid, both because this car had 40,000 miles on it. And being
an owner's car, we did not want to run into any braking issues. Absolutely. But that's the only
modification, of course, other than the Bridgestone Potenza Sport tires. Let's talk about that briefly,
Jack, before we get into the drive. The Bridgestone Potenza Sport, we brought it up in the beginning.
The whole point of putting every car on the same tire isn't for giving a specific vehicle an
advantage. I understand that Carlos's point. Clearly, each car, like the STI 209, they worked
with Dunlop to develop a specific tire for that car. So you're throwing a lot of that away. But
what you're doing is you're giving the consistency across the board that one car is not going to be
potentially faster than the other for the sake of doing lap times. The Bridgestone Potenza Sport is
not a track day tire, but it's a great example of it's available in a wide variety of sizes for all
these fun cars that you can take on the street where you're going to live most of the time and
not worry about it burning up after 6,000 miles. It can be used in the rain. It can be used in the
dry. And then if you want to go pound around on track, it's not, you know, it's not a full track
day tire, but it's still completely competent, which you're going to see right now as we take
these things out to Autobahn Country Club South, Jack. Let's do it. Let's do it. No, let's do it.
God, it sounds so good. It's a snap yang mark. You get the TCR mode on.
This is Autobahn South. Oh yeah. Feel that rotation. So let's talk about it. We wanted
five of the best of the best of the fun performance cars that you could potentially
use every single day. With the exception of the Subaru, you know, that's an older car,
but that's Subaru's best. So we wanted to give the Subaru bros a taste. So we're starting with
the Elantra N-Jack and this has been one of our favorites because it's the Kirkland edition. It
is the cheapest by far. You can get into one of these in the low thirties. Dealers, thankfully,
aren't really marking these things up. They have a long warranty. As we talked about in our original
compact test, it is a barrel of laughs. This is definitely one of the most fun cars you can buy.
It may not be the best interior. It feels pretty chintzy overall in a lot of ways, but
damn, when you push this thing, this, they deserve awards for this. And I know they're
going to be going all their electric cars and you're never going to have this. So if you really
want that like amazing front wheel drive car, this is the one to buy because it's, it, it does
everything so good. Do you know why Mark? Why? German engineering. Oh, okay. You got Albert
Biermann. He was in the room next door in the bathroom while this was being engineered, Mark.
Yeah. And that's why it's tremendous. But you know what else is tremendous, Mark? What? How low our
bank accounts are because we have a certain gentleman from Michigan here with us who's
going to tell us all about the Civic Type R and the GR Corolla. I've instructed him to be
way more handsome than me. So he will. Is that even possible, Mark? No, it's not. His hairline
is tremendous. Yeah. It's plugs. He's got plugs. That's fake. Maybe it's a tube.
Now I know what this is going to be like in winter. It's going to be a riot. The Toyota GR
Corolla, another car and driver 10 best winner. I might add, I don't think more grip is the
solution for this car. When I drive this car, I imagine or fantasize maybe what it would be like
in a Michigan winter on a set of winter tires. That to me is where this car is truly going to
shine. As enjoyable as this is on a track, and it is enjoyable, I think it's going to really come
into its own on unfamiliar roads with rough surfaces where you don't have a lot of traction.
I think that's truly where this car wants to be. Versus the other cars here, you notice some
distinct advantages and disadvantages. Let's start with the disadvantages. This three-cylinder
engine packs a punch, but it's pretty boosty. You have to wait for it to come into power.
The gearing in particular, we'll notice it on this straight, in order to be smooth,
you have to wait on each gear change. And that kind of stuff can make you a little frustrated
on a racetrack when you just want to get the best time you can. Two, the powertrain can sound a
little coarse, but I'm honestly okay with a lot of that because this car, much in the same way
like the Civic Type R, still has that degree of specialness. There's that certain like
indefinable element to this vehicle that gives it just an overall uniqueness because
they really don't make cars like this anymore. And that's very exciting. Now with regard to
handling, this gets the job done. It's not as maybe sharp or composed as some of the other
cars here, but it is enjoyable. I've got the diff set to the 50-50 split to maximize the track
driving behavior because that mode's called track. I don't know. But I'll say this, this car has a
really enjoyable neutrality on entry on these particular tires, and it is something that you
can play around with in corners in a way that's overall, again, a lot of fun. Is it maybe the
best tool for chasing lap times? Probably not amongst this group, but this would be a really
fun vehicle to explore a winding road with, especially an unfamiliar one. Also, I gotta
imagine this, too, would make a very enjoyable daily driver because this is something that you
would drive and really, really want to explore. And the fact that it doesn't look too extravagant,
you know, I get that it's wider, I get that it's got a lot of vents and stuff on it, but there's no
big wings. So someone might not notice this in the same way that they might notice a Civic Type R.
I might be wrong. I could probably be wrong. Often am wrong, but I think you could probably get away
with some pretty nefarious driving in the GR Corolla. And that's something I really enjoy.
The Honda Civic Type R is a very special machine. At Car and Driver, we named the Honda Civic one of
our 10 Best Award winners, meaning it's one of the best vehicles you can buy this year.
The Civic Type R was a massive contributor to that award because this is just a special, special
hot hatch. In fact, I think that's what I like the most about this car is it's not any one attribute
of this vehicle. It's that someone cared about it. And that even comes down to the shifter.
The shifter feels great in your hand because someone cared to make it feel good in your hand.
They decided that was an important aspect of this vehicle. The seats that I'm sitting in,
they hold me in place while I'm cornering. I don't have to brace against the door or the
steering column like I have to do in some of the other vehicles here. This engine pulls. It has a
nice, broad power band. It's got shift lights and indicators that tell me when I'm about to get to
redline. Overall, it's the entire package that makes the Civic Type R so good. It's also really,
really quick. Everything from the amount of grip you have, the power delivery through corners,
the sense of stability, the confidence. This is just supremely enjoyable.
In fact, I'd say it has some of my favorite elements of some of the better cars here.
It has the stability and confidence of the Golf R. It has the rowdiness of the Elantra N.
And I think it has some of the, I guess, specialness that you feel with the
GR Corolla. That's what makes this such a complete package. It's just delightful.
I'm driving right now with automatic rev matching on. I've got the artificial sound enhancement
happening too. I know it's not the traditional or purest way to do things, but I kind of don't
care because I'm having fun while doing it. And I also like the fact that when you're done with
racetrack, you can drive this thing home in relative comfort. I set this comparison up.
I do everything and I get stuck driving this while you guys get to drive all the good ones.
I was supposed to drive the STI and somebody had to go blow that thing up.
Now you're going to suffer through this. Okay. I think your partner in crime is doing the most
suffering. He deserves it. Look, I have a love or hate relationship with Volkswagen. I'm probably,
that's what you get. My love of these cars comes from owning them. My hate comes from them breaking
and this car's hate comes from, well, the screen below our camera. I think that's the biggest
problem with this vehicle because the E888 is still a tremendous engine. It's not a B58 Mark
or a B48 and it doesn't have a ZF eight speed, but the engine is spectacular.
You just have to understand what this car is about, right? I mean, clearly it's
our viewer that brought out a Subaru said, this car is really, the problem with it is it feels
like a normal car out here on the track instead of actually feeling like something special. And
it can do track duty, but it's like as exciting as getting a small cosmetic surgery, which I
typically get to reduce wrinkles and my, my testicle skin ironed out now. Cause my girlfriend
said there's too many wrinkles on it. Is that a cosmetic surgery? Is that an actual thing?
Well, it's a patient for me. I mean the veterinarian that I have to, he's gotten me a
deal. So this is definitely not my favorite car for sure, but from on track dynamics perspective,
this thing was exceptionally confident, inspiring or confidence inspiring. I should say one of the,
the faster left-hand corner over there, I think turn four. I think I was going the fastest in
this car, the quickest because there's just a ton of confidence in this car. And you're right
about the power train. This is a broad engine that you can largely leave in third or fourth
around this track, especially like me, when you're just trying to learn it. And it makes
it a really friendly driving experience in spite of everything else. Right. I would agree with you.
So the main takeaways that I had from this car is all the inputs are just not as precise as the
other cars. There's a huge, like sloppy transition from the front. It's really soft. The transition
of the back, it lacks sharpness in the steering, the shifters, the most plasticky, the pedals feel
kind of, you know, it's not a sharp, like agile feeling car, but when you start to drive it hard,
you appreciate how approachable it is. And it's very easy to get around. And with the rear diff
doing what it does, especially compared to the front wheel drive cars, it, the rear diff really
does do a lot of the heavy lifting for this car. It doesn't particularly understeer. It rotates its
way out of a corner and you can lift just a little. It doesn't rotate like the other cars,
but it's a very, very easy car to drive fast. Well, the torque vectoring rear diff in this car
does so much of the work for you. Turn in may be slower than the other cars.
Mid corner speed might be slower than all the other cars. I mean, just that, I mean,
you can mash on the throttle and you just feel that diff sort everything out. There's no push.
It's just like a rear wheel drive car for a moment. That's what I really like about it.
Of course, everybody really loves the Golf R because let's be honest, you're not driving on
the track. You're living on the street and that's where it shines. Yeah, it's a compliant,
comfortable vehicle. Well, it shines dynamically on the street, but then you have to use the
infotainment and you have to, and this shifter too, like I love manuals. I even like not great
manuals, but how long have we been designing good manual transmissions? And this is what comes out
in 2022 or whatever this year, whatever year this generation is. It's a really unfortunate
thing because you interact with it so frequently. Every time you drive the car, you need to touch
it and it should make you feel good when you use it. And you don't. And Jack and I complain about
this all the time. If you're going to put a manual transmission in a car in this era,
it had better be good because it's become such a niche device that we expect a higher level of
like mechanical joy out of it. And this feels like something that would have been good like
15 years ago. It's not good anymore, but you could argue this about the Golf R all the way
around from what you said, infotainment use, the usability of it. It's just, it's so botched that
it's hard to get excited for this. So Mark, I think before you give me a concussion back here
or I tear a muscle trying to hold onto these monkey bars, I think it's time for us to head
into our round table discussion with Britt. All right. So we've just wrapped up the world's
longest five-cylinder shootout. So we've just wrapped up the world's longest four-cylinder
shootout. We've had this gentleman, Britt Casey, who's an IMSA driver and a TCR champion set all
lap times. We started at the exact same time of day. They're all on the same tire and you had the
same amount of time in each and every car. We started with the Golf R and we ended with the
Civic Type R. And yes, there was a four degree ambient change throughout the day, but it is
essentially impossible to control every variable as you've run into in the past. Right. I mean,
you can put every car on the same tire. You can't control the sun, right? You can try,
it's not going to work. You can also can't control how much rubber gets put on the track
as cars go around. So in order to do this truly without any variables, you need five clones of a
racing driver. You need five identical racetracks and you need to run them all at the exact same
time. And there can't be any variation in any of it in order for it to be perfect. And I've tried
to fix that to the best of my abilities. I'm sure the comments are going to address those issues.
I will walk you through very briefly what was fastest and what was slowest. Civic Type R was
fastest, followed by GR Corolla, then Elantra N, then Golf R. Lastly was the S209. The reason
why there is no S209 driving clip is it did the Subaru thing and blew up. The other car that ran
into a problem, which was actually the second fastest thing, was the GR Corolla. But to be
honest, after four or five laps at our track with not the world's stickiest tire, the Potenza Sport
is a Pilot 4S competitor, it overheated the rear diff. You were apparently too spicy of a driver.
Couldn't handle spice. So with that, Britt, you are a race car driver, a real race car driver,
not YouTube commenters who think they're God and, you know, I did it in Forza better. If you have,
your priorities are different than 99.9% of people. And I say this all the time, you don't drive a
lap ton, but you do, you're a race car driver. Sure. What are your two favorite and what are the standouts?
Wait, is he a race car driver? Oh, whatever, keep going. Well, the two standouts for me, number one is
the Honda Civic Type R, number two is the Hyundai Elantra N. Those two, I think, were a tick above
the others in terms of performance and usability on the racetrack. You know, looking at track
performance, the topics are simplified in terms of the length of the list, chassis dynamics or
braking performance, straight line acceleration, mid-corner grip. So those two cars were standouts
in that regard. I also appreciated the shift lights on the Type R, I thought that was very
race car-esque. Actually helped a lot, just as long as you have a steering wheel to have it clear
and you can see it. Another thing about the Type R I liked was the seating in terms of
side support, definitely the stickiest seat. Now, not in like a gross, germy way, but just it had
good bolstering on the sides, right? I was thinking grip tape. Seats are different, I understand that,
but dynamically, when you're behind the wheel, what are the differences between those two cars?
Shifters are obviously different and the diffs are different, how do they feel? Yeah, so shifter in the
Type R was shorter throw, very positive feeling, I would say, on both cars, but the throw was
shorter and the knob is way shorter. Whereas in the Hyundai, the shift lever is, I would say,
almost double the height, so you get a lot more leverage. You still feel the positive sensation
going into each gate. I never missed a shift in any of them and also the auto blips, I thought
were really crisp, like really, really well done. It didn't matter if I was on a cool-down lap and
just dropping a gear, it knew exactly where to rev it to every time. So that's a cool feature I like
of these new cars, I think it's pretty handy for a racetrack. Another thing I would say, the Hyundai
had a softer brake pedal feel, but it wasn't like it had less braking performance. I would say brake
torque was similar between the two of them, they just had different modulation ranges between the
two brake pedals. I like the clutch feel of these cars way more than the other ones. I would say
the S209, for me, did have the best clutch feel because it was the stiffest, whereas the
worst clutch feel was the GR. For me, it felt like a sim racing clutch, not really real. And, you know,
I have to say, because it deserves props, that the S209 had the best steering feel too because
it was hydraulic. And from a race car driver perspective, I don't really like electronic
car steering. I've driven both, but I still like hydraulic. You get resistance changes as grip or
yaw in the car changes with a hydraulic, whereas electronic is just too artificial and
you can run into overheating issues. And there's also a computer attached to it, and I don't know.
Suspension. The one thing I did hear you mention off camera is the Type R is hilariously bouncy.
For sure. Thank you for mentioning that. So it was bouncier on the entry. I was finding bumps
that I didn't think existed. It did take curbs well and it was stable, but it was just in the
car, like breathing out of my nose, I could feel my breath like cut as I was going over a bump.
So it was bumpy. Speaking of entry, I think the Veloster, not the Veloster, sorry. The Elantra N.
The Elantra N. I used to race against the Veloster too, so I kind of get them mixed up.
But the Hyundai had, I like the way that it used the rear of the car to rotate the car
on the entry. And once it was pointed sort of at the angle I needed, I could just get back to power
and it would drive out. That was unique to that car. The rear, it felt like rear steer was
happening, but I know it's not rear steer. It's the- It actually rotated. Yeah, it rotated very
well. It rotated like what you would need a front wheel drive race car to rotate like, in order to
save the front tires. Because if you're using the front to turn all the time, you're just going to
burn those off big time. Meaning front axle tires versus rear. What are your- What's your favorite
car and what was your least favorite and why? Favorite car, easily Civic Type R. And I think
there's probably not going to be a lot of disagreement here. And for a lot of the same
reasons, that car does everything right, especially with the shifter, especially with the seats. Best
seats in this group by a country mile. And for me, my favorite shifter as well. But beyond that,
it does the best thing, I think, of every other car here. The best attributes of every other car
and makes the whole car feel more special as a result. When you sit in the Civic Type R,
you feel like you sit lower. The way the hood chases down towards the ground,
seating position, everything about that car is designed, it seems, to pleasure you as a driver.
Even though, yes, it was the fastest vehicle here, not significantly so. You could make a case that,
you know, change drivers and you might see different result depending on skill level,
it still makes me feel the best while I drive it. And that's, I think,
the most crucial aspect of any of these vehicles. My number four, because I didn't drive the S209,
is the Golf R. And that's not to say it's a bad vehicle. It has its flaws like the infotainment
system, like the shifter and so on. But I got to really commend that vehicle for how confident and
stable it feels consistently throughout the entire drive. I choose that car to learn the
track because I knew it was going to be one of the easier ones to get up to speed with.
And I still think I was fastest in that car in some corners here, just checking speeds through
some of the fastest corners on this track. And I think I carry the most speed just because I had
the most confidence in that vehicle and in the way it reacted to corners. All-wheel drive system is
really trick too. I got to say the GR Corolla, I go back and forth between the Elantra and the
GR Corolla between second and third place because I don't think a racetrack is the best place for a
GR Corolla. I think that car is a lot more fun on a mountain road. I dream about what that thing
would be like in winter on snow tires. I also have to say that at Virginia International Raceway,
at Lightning Lap, we didn't get that dip overheating issue. But that may be because
there's more straightaways for it to cool down. So I don't know. It's a mystery, I guess.
Let's talk about me.
Number one, Civic Type R. Again, Mark's paying me a lot of money because he owns one,
so I have to say the Civic Type R is great. And you should buy his for $50,000 over.
That car does everything well. It's got the Porsche thing, right? Everything's perfect.
Inputs are good. Shifter's great. Best seats. Looks good. Probably going to be reliable.
It's a very well sought after car. We had someone else sit in briefly with us as they got in and out
of these cars, and he said immediately that was the most special car to be in. Number two,
launch or end. It is essentially the great value version of that. It's worse by like 3% in every
metric. And probably the dealer experience is 500% worse because it's a Hyundai dealer.
But the rest of that car is brilliant, and it makes you giggle. There's a childlike wonder
that exists in that car that does not exist in the Civic Type R. Number three, even though it
pulled the Subaru, is the S209. I think if you got one, or if you were the owner of this car
and bought one before they were $100,000, it's an experience that none of these other cars can
replicate. It comes from a different era. Steering's good. Really good steering. Lotus
levels of feedback through the front end of the car. Hydraulic rack. Past that, you probably have
to appreciate the heritage and the engineering story that goes into it. And then probably
number four, and I'm going to get a lot of flack for that, is the Golf R. I have a love-hate
relationship with Volkswagen. I think that car has the best all-wheel drive system. It didn't
overheat as a good engine. Yes, the invotainment will make you want to crash the car, but the rest
of the car, it's refined. It does the Volkswagen German thing exceptionally well. My least favorite
is the GR Corolla, at least out here to your point, Carlos. Shouldn't be on a racetrack.
It overheated the diff. It's not that exciting. You feel like you're sitting on top of a box as
it rolls around the track. And my mistake, I said all of these cars had a four-cylinder. No,
this car has a three-cylinder, and this three-cylinder was the most peaky. It had some
character, but out on the racetrack, you're sitting at the top of the RPM band the whole time,
and the character sort of disappears, and you're just like, why does this thing go in timing?
Mark, tell me about you. So I'm going to mirror basically what everybody said, and yes, I own
a Type R. How much are they paying you? I got a car for MSRP, apparently, so I'm...
So 20 grand? Yeah, 20 grand. It's the best car, not just because of the lap time, it's because
it does, to Carlos' point, you feel special when you drive it. And when you get to this level of
the hot, high-performance, semi-affordable, less affordable cars now, you want to get in it,
and you want to feel like all of the inputs were thought out, and that's where the Type R excels.
It's got a great interior. It functions as a normal car. It's got a huge amount of space on
the inside. You don't feel any penalties for driving it daily, and then when you go to drive
it hard, braking works. Shifter's great. Like, they thought about the shifter mechanism, right?
It wasn't an afterthought. Steering is, you know, it's modern steering, but all the core things that
you want from a high-performance car and a streetable, like, everyday car, the Type R does.
But the thing that really surprised me when we had it back-to-back was the Elantra N.
It essentially does everything almost as good as the Type R. You can just feel the pedigree
wasn't there. Like, they kind of took the car and, like, they had to make a lot of compromises on
what they wanted to do and not do, so it doesn't feel as well sorted out on the interior. The
styling is hodgepodge, typical Hyundai stuff. Like, what are we going to do this year? So it's
not that cohesive. It doesn't look the greatest. And you have the Hyundai problem of, you know,
when you track it, are they going to warranty it if you have a problem? That's always the thing I
think about. And then, of course, the other thing with the Hyundai that kind of really was better
than the Type R was the suspension tuning. You could go out there flat out. There was still
compliance in the suspension, something the Type R doesn't have. And the reason why the Type R gets
a huge ding on that is because when you're in Plus R, that's the only time you can disable
stability control and traction control. If you go into individual mode with everything on,
with the exception of putting the dampers in comfort, which you need to run a faster lap,
you can no longer disable the stability control. And that's straight from their engineers that said
they designed it to do that. Unless you do a pedal dance. Right, a diagnostic mode, which most of the
people are going to do that on it, but it's stupid that you have to do that. So it's a huge bonus to
the Elantra N team or the N team that they did that. The negatives are, like, you know, we talked
about it with the Golf R. You have an R badge. You have this, like, hard core, their hardest core,
like, hatch car, and it just feels nerf. It's, like, way too soft. It's way too accessible.
Nothing in it feels special or thought out. Like, it just, it felt like 10 different teams worked
on it. Like, it wants to be a luxury car. It doesn't. It wants to be a hot hatch, but it's
not. But the bones are there. Engine's good. Diff is amazing. And that kind of puts me into the GR.
I really think the GR is the biggest disappointment. I mean, it's a car that's, like,
Akio Toyota wanted to make. It's, like, all the media is the car going sideways. You couldn't
spin this thing sideways on dry pavement if you, like, liquefied the rear tires and put oil on
them. It just, it's not a car that feels like it excels on a track. The three-cylinder feels like
it heat soaks a lot. The more you push it, the more power falls off compared to the four-cylinders,
which always felt more consistent to me. And then it's got the Corolla problems.
It's too long of a wheelbase car to have any, like, edge or rotation to it, but it's still,
like, built on a Corolla, an older Corolla that feels more of, like, a shitbox on the inside.
And then it's still pushing $40,000 plus. It's a lot of money for this car, and it just doesn't
feel, like, as special as the Type R. What I was most surprised is I wanted the S209 in this video.
I thought it was, like, one of the best, like, attempts Subaru has ever made on any sports car.
Like, you had the engineering, you had all this stuff. I wanted it there because it was really
hardcore. It felt special, much like the Type R, but even more because it was old. And, you know,
it's frustrating. I don't know if it's money, development problem, but they, that engine,
like, we did two warm-up laps. You did two warm-up laps, and I instructed you to do two
warm-up laps. And we let it idle before that. It was, like, up to temperature before it got
pushed, and you got two laps out of it before the engine let go. So, the last thing I wanted
to say, Jack, is with the lap times, I think this is really, really gonna hit one big point home.
It's like lightning lap is a far more comprehensive thing, but what this proves is
you can take the same driver, you can change the driver, you can change, like, the hour of the day.
We could have done this in the morning, and then the night. You could have had all these variables,
and you're never gonna get the same lap time. So, the lap times are just kind of a loose
measurement to gauge performance, but it's not the ultimate measurement of how to judge a car.
And I just wanted to put that out there. I'll also add, too, that it's nice that the car that
we enjoy driving the most is also the fastest one of the group. Yeah. Yeah, sometimes that
doesn't happen. No. Yeah. Yeah. Not until your Chevy Trax shows up. Hey, you watch your mouth.
Congratulations! If you made it this far, you sat through almost an hour-long comparison video.
It does not go unnoticed. The people behind this project, including myself, did it because we love
cars. That's the reason why a video exists. They certainly will not make their money back in terms
of time and commitment. Even having Carlos come out from Michigan and do this on his own time
is incredible. It's something I've always wanted to do. I can check it off my list of things I've
always wanted to work with him. I have such utmost respect for his approach, and it's helped shape
some of the way that I look at cars now, today. And that's really the point of a video like this,
is to share that knowledge, to help transfer that knowledge and passion to other people,
so maybe in the future somebody can pick up where we left off. And the biggest lesson here is
growing up, seeing all these objective measurements, lap times, data, and getting to this
place where I can have five of these cars on the same day, driving them, and then see the lap times
almost identical. You might want to know what you learn from that, and what you learn is those
numbers don't mean anything. You could have the fastest car on the planet, and you might drive it
and feel nothing other than speed. It's about the nuances of how the mechanical connection to the
car and the driver work. It's about the design philosophies from the engineers, and even
marketing, how they sell the car, that perception that you get by sitting in it or looking at it
or touching it. And the biggest part is everybody's different. Sometimes there's no right answer.
What might be good for me might not be right for someone else based on our life experience. And
again, it's about trying to capture that and explain that story, that the numbers are not
everything. And don't discount something because it may not look as good on paper.
So the entire team that was a part of this, even our reps from Bridgestone, our reps from Subaru,
Honda, Acura, I could go down the line. Autobahn Country Club, AFA Performance,
Encounter Space Garage. I mean, there's so many people behind the scenes that want us to do this
and try to share this knowledge. And I appreciate everybody that spends their time watching this.
And also, if you want to support, please head up Patreon. Subscribe to this so we can get some of
these final projects done. Thanks for watching. I'll see you next video.
