Rozhovor s Danielem Lacallem, ekonomem 6 miliardového hedgeového fondu Tresses a autorem knihy Svět energetiky je plochý.
Proč máme v Evropě vyšší ceny energií než v Americe? Proč je EU závislá na ruském plynu? Vše to pramení z politických rozhodnutí Unie postavených na postupném vyřazování „neekologických“ forem tuzemské výroby elektřiny a jejich nahrazení levnými dodávkami z Ruska. Evropská zelená politika vedla k zavedení celé řady daní a poplatků, které se odrážejí do konečné ceny elektřiny, plynu a ropy. Daniel Lacalle vysvětluje, proč má obavy z budoucího vývoje nejen energetické politiky v Evropě, a jak neschopnost politiků přiznat si chybu vede ke vzrůstu nespokojenosti mezi občany.
There are already protests. Electricity bills were up 60, 70 percent in one year.
Russian gas was the cheapest and most reliable alternative to any other that they found.
That's okay. But you cannot solve that puzzle by limiting and banning nuclear
and natural gas development, etc, etc, etc. So we're paying up to 10 times for natural gas
that's coming from the United States. It is truly lunacy. They don't want to recognize
that the European Union has committed very serious mistakes in its energy policy.
The rise of populism and the rise of discontent within the European Union is very evident.
Good evening. Welcome to NTD's Fresh Look America. I'm Paul Graney.
Joining us to discuss Europe's severe energy crisis is one of Europe's most influential
economists and money managers, Daniel Akai. Akai is the Chief Economist at the Tresses
Hedge Fund where he manages over six billion dollars in assets. He's also the author of
The Energy World is Flat. So Daniel Akai, thank you. Thank you very much. Daniel, from speaking
with friends and family, perhaps even businesses there in Europe, how serious is the energy
situation? It is truly serious because it's not easy to solve what has been damaged for decades.
The problem of the European energy crisis has been created with a series of missteps and massive
intervention for many, many years. And you cannot solve a situation that was created
by political intervention and political design in very little time. What is called
the dependency on Russian gas was politically designed. I have to remember that only 15 years
ago the European Union produced more natural gas than what Russia exported and that that reverted
because of political decisions, banning production, putting curbs to different types of
developments, etc. Same with the closing of nuclear plants. So it's very, very difficult.
Now it is virtually impossible to solve in a couple of months and certainly it will take a
very long time before anything is truly done to revert the problem. So are we seeing people
unable to pay their bills? Are we seeing businesses closing? How is the situation on the ground?
If you look at, for example, the business and consumer confidence figures, they're already
reflecting what a difficult situation it is. In the case of European households, we have seen
bills, electricity bills, go up 60-70% in one year. In some cases, for businesses, the increase
in prices has been twofold, in some cases threefold, because energy-intensive businesses,
small shops, hairdressers, all these types of business have huge problems to pay their bills.
So it's massively affecting the lower-income families and it's certainly creating a very
big problem for businesses that, although they may have seen some improvement in sales
because of the recovery, are making losses because of energy costs. Of course, if those small
businesses go out of business, we have even higher unemployment rates. It affects households
as a knock-on effect. Are you expecting to see that wave of bankruptcies, for example?
Certainly. So far, it doesn't look too aggressive because in the European Union you have seen a very
large public incentive program and also numerous subsidies helping some of the businesses to
overcome the situation. But it's inevitable because it's not even a question of having
higher access to credit or a little bit more subsidies here and there. It's that the increase
in household and business bills are so huge that many of these businesses simply cannot survive,
even if they get a loan, because it's not a question of access to credit. It's a question
of solvency. How serious do you expect it to get? I think it will get to a very serious level.
I would even call it dramatic for a very simple reason. It's that to start with,
the European recovery was significantly slower than what we had seen, for example,
in the United States. And at the same time, household and business costs, both for natural
gas and power, were significantly higher than those of the United States. Twice as expensive,
in fact, because of the chain of taxes built upon them, plus the cost of CO2 permits, etc. Now,
the situation is truly dramatic, because it's not like we come from a period of cheap prices,
like in the United States, and prices are rising. It's that we come from a period of
hugely expensive prices, and prices are rising faster than in the United States.
So it's adding fire to an already very dangerous situation.
So basically, we have this energy crisis in the midst of a record-setting inflation crisis,
almost, for Europe. You mentioned an interesting thing earlier, Daniel. You said the government
perhaps would give subsidies. But where's the money for these subsidies coming from? I assume
it's being printed up, right? That is the problem. The problem is that you cannot
solve an inflation situation with inflationary measures. More importantly, you cannot solve
the problem of energy bills that are filled. Up to 70% of a household in Germany is subsidies
and taxes that have absolutely nothing to do with energy consumption. 70 to 75% of the
electricity bill of households in European countries are taxes, charges, regulated costs,
etc. So, you cannot basically give a small subsidy and try to solve a situation that was already
extremely problematic beforehand. So, as you very well say, they're going to give subsidies
with newly printed money, which generates a weaker euro. Then the European Union imports
energy from the rest of the world at much higher prices, because obviously they have to buy dollars
and sell euros. So, it's a truly difficult situation. So, you're saying that the high
energy prices at the moment, not only are they dealing with everything in Russia,
their own inflationary problems, but we have massive taxes that the European Union and local
governments, local sovereign states, individual countries are placing on energy. Why is nobody
asking the government to take away some of the taxes? Very few people are actually, because
there is in Europe, there is this widespread view that energy prices are high because of
the evil utility conglomerates. But it's not because of that. Energy prices in Europe are
extremely high because governments control the energy mix and they have shut down nuclear,
they have shut down many of the gas development facilities, they have put all types of brakes to
the different developments of domestic energy. And on top of that, for years they have been
creating a system by which the bill that consumers pay is completely filled with items that have
nothing to do with what we call energy consumption. Because it's, as I said,
renewable surcharges, subsidies, taxes, taxes that are by the way chained. So, you have taxes
on generation, taxes on distribution, taxes on transmission, and then taxes on the final price.
Then you have the CO2 price, and the CO2 price is a hidden tax. So, the entire energy complex
within the European Union is extremely onerous for the consumer and unnecessarily so. It could be
solved by reducing or eliminating some of those surcharges and taxes, and it could be reduced as
well by allowing the development of domestic energy. Because think about this, the European
Union is now the largest importer of United States liquefied natural gas. What does that
liquefied natural gas come from? Fracking. Fracking is banned in the European Union. So, we're paying
up to 10 times for natural gas that's coming from a source and a technology that is banned
and importing it from the United States. It is truly lunacy. How do they justify this in Europe,
Daniel? There is a chain of political things that, on the one hand, they don't want to touch,
things that have been done incorrectly in the past, but they won't change or make a U-turn.
It's a big combination of intervention that the governments and politicians always try to solve
with more intervention. But it's amazing because it's not even this that we are discussing. We
talk about it in a U.S. network. We talk with United States citizens. Everybody understands it.
But in the European Union, there is absolutely zero debate about recovering European domestic
natural gas production. There is absolutely zero debate about restarting the nuclear plants that
have been shut down. In Germany, in the middle of a huge energy crisis, the government has not even
restarted the three nuclear reactors that they still have operative. They have put them on
standby. So, it's almost like a stubborn decision from the political spectrum. It comes from all the
different sides of the political angles in which they don't want to recognize that the European
Union has committed very serious mistakes in its energy policy that could be solved,
not short term, but certainly they could be solved looking at a more distant future.
And they still continue with those political, I would say, machinations.
So, where does this go, Daniel? Are you expecting protests from the people? Are we seeing any
protests already? There are already protests. There are already protests about the increase
in energy bills and the lack of serious political response. But what truly worries me is that
there's not a real debate in the political landscape by which the main political parties
sit together and say, look, we made this energy transition program that was
not well designed. Let's change the things that are wrong and let's put some measures to reduce
in the midterm and in the long term the dependency from Russian gas and the high cost of energy.
But there's no debate about it. For example, I find it amazing that in the middle of an energy
crisis with bills multiplying by two and three times, nobody is saying, why don't we pause
the CO2 permit scheme by which governments collect about 22 billion euros, almost 22 billion dollars
of taxes, and use at least those revenues to reduce the bill of households or at least stop
the system so that at least the power price comes down because that cost is added to the power
price. The same with taxes. In Germany, there is absolutely no debate about doing something about
cutting the 75% of the household bill that comes from taxes and subsidies. The entire debate is
whether they have to intervene the so-called liberalized generation market, which is the
remaining 25%, which is not even liberalized because it has the CO2 cost that I mentioned
and because the government decides the energy mix. So it's almost like the political world
does not even want to acknowledge the mistakes of the past, correct them, and make it easier.
They think it's a winter problem, but it's a long-term problem.
Back to your point about how there doesn't seem to be much debate or much opposition to the path
Europe is walking, we see in Italy just now a new prime minister come in. She doesn't seem to
perhaps toe the line of the European Union. We see the European Union saying they may have tools
to kind of combat some of her new policies. Do you expect more of this kind of
quote-unquote populism to come about in Europe because of this issue?
I think it's rising and I think that the rise of populism and the rise of discontent
within the European Union is very evident. Politicians in the major parties don't want
to acknowledge it. They say that these are French parties, but in France, Marine Le Pen
almost won the elections. In Italy, the populist right has won the elections. In so many different
countries, we recently saw it also in Sweden and other areas, there is certainly a very high
level of discontent with top-down policies coming from even unelected politicians that decide
what has to be done. And when they make a mistake, we all make mistakes. There's no problem in making
mistakes. What I find absolutely astonishing is that you make mistakes and instead of
recognizing those mistakes and putting measures to limit those problems in the future, what they
decide to resort to is to tax increases and freedom and taking away freedom from people by
forcing consumption shutdowns, etc. So, the unwillingness to change mistakes that are, by the
way, easily solvable. They're not things that are impossible to solve. There are things that can be
done. So, I think that is very, very dangerous because by misanalyzing the rise of populism
as some sort of, oh, people don't know how to vote, they're not listening to the people that
really know, you end up missing the reality of a European Union that is truly suffering from
these measures in energy and in other things like immigration. But not understanding the discontent
is something that is truly dangerous in my opinion. Do you worry about the future of the
European Union as an institution? I worry because instead of recognizing that there have been some
mistakes, listening to people and saying, okay, maybe creating a system that is designed to make
power and natural gas bills more expensive, no matter what happens with commodity prices,
is not a good idea. Because let's remember that household bills in natural gas and in electricity
in Europe were rising even when commodities were coming down. So, it's not just a problem
of today. So, all these things, not paying attention to the concerns about immigration,
not paying attention to the real wage loss coming from inflation, not paying attention to the
loss of purchasing power that the average citizen is living, all these things
generate the seeds of not just populism but somebody coming up with the magic idea that
breaking the European Union would solve it all, which is obviously not true
in any case. So, I'm truly worried. Yes, I am. You feel that the leaders there, Daniel,
they're not listening to these concerns that you just listed at all. They're not addressing them
at all, even in the rhetoric? I don't think that they are. I think that when they see in France
that Le Pen was almost the president, the prime minister, they disregarded it because they
managed to, in the second round, see that Macron continued to be the prime minister. In Italy,
they disregard the vote that had just happened, saying that the turnout was lower than usual.
But the turnout being lower than usual is also a sign of discontent. That you have low turnout
and that you managed to get the prime minister that is perceived as more
mainstream is not a sign of lowering discontent or that everything is fine. It's actually a sign
of concern. And precisely if you want the European Union to thrive, politicians need to understand
that these signs have to be interpreted correctly, not get together and say, oh,
these people really don't know how to vote. That is a mistake. So, what are the leaders
focused on instead? Well, in Europe, there is a very clear sort of view from the European Union
main political parties, which is that energy transition and climate policies are the
flagship of the European Union. And we all agree with, you know, taking care of climate and taking
care of the environment and being responsible about energy conservation, etc. We all agree
with that. What we don't agree is with the idea that the whole policy has to be built on
nothing can change and consumers have to suffer regardless. So, I think that there are two main
problems in the European Union today. The first one is that its unlimited public spending seems
to be the solution to everything. And obviously it doesn't work. The second is that the energy
transition that has been designed from the political elites needs to be preserved at any
cost and that everything else is expendable. So, those two things, think about it. Massive
government spending plus very high and highly inefficient and highly uncompetitive energy
policy. Those two things make the European Union grow less, recover more weakly from crisis,
get more indebted, have higher levels of unemployment and, more dangerously, youth
unemployment. And it doesn't get any better. So, there are things that need to be, you know,
a lot of people, when I give these messages that I'm giving to you, that you probably,
everyone that's watching us thinks they make certain level of sense, at least, in the European
Union immediately, you are labeled as anti-European. And that is not being anti-European,
that is being pro-European. Because I don't want the European Union to end up in shambles and
all countries governed by, you know, whomever populist decides to take the flagship of what
people are really concerned about. I think that those things can be solved and they should be
solved. Let's take Europe's economy, okay? So, let's take Germany, for example, was so reliant
on cheap energy from Russia. Yeah. What happens if the European Union doesn't change its policies in
the direction you're saying and energy prices just stay high in Europe? What happens to the
European economy long term? What happens is that the European economy stagnates and that the main
strength of the European economy, which is exports, gets worse because it becomes uncompetitive.
The energy transition has to be competitive and it has to be taken into account the most
important factor in energy policy, which is security of supply. If you don't take into
account security of supply and competitiveness, no energy policy can survive. More importantly,
no economy can really survive. So, let's remember why Germany is dependent on Russian gas.
Germany is dependent on Russian gas because Russian gas was the cheapest and most reliable
alternative to any other that they found. That's okay. But you cannot solve that puzzle by limiting
and banning nuclear and natural gas development, etc. So, ultimately, if Germany and the European
Union are doomed to consistently have more expensive energy, labor and overall costs,
de-industrialization of Europe is almost inevitable. And de-industrialization in a
European Union that is very far away in the technology battle from China and the United
States is very negative because that's the other problem. On the one hand, you lose the manufacturing
side of the economy, you become uncompetitive and you don't have the technology muscle that
the other two large economic areas have. Just incredible. I think some big lessons
for the rest of the world. Daniel Akai, we appreciate it. Thank you, Daniel.
Thank you very much.