'Alien probe' could be coming toward Earth | FOX 10 Talks | FOX 10 Phoenix

Travel & Explore
223 followers
5 Video Views·Aug 3, 2025
And we're kind of hitting a new level today.
Expanding our horizons, you could say.
Big time.
I mean, for the first time ever in Fox 10 Talk's history,
I believe, correct me if I am wrong,
we have a Harvard professor here to talk to us
about some pretty cool stuff. Take it away.
And not just any Harvard professor,
we're talking about Avi Loeb.
Avi, thank you for joining us.
Now, his research has been pretty groundbreaking,
and I know very, very raising eyebrows
of what the implications might be.
But, of course, 2017, there was, I believe,
Avi, please correct me, but the first interstellar object
that was confirmed, Oumuamua,
that, of course, had the scientific community
very chatting about what could that be.
But there's a new object that was discovered July 1st.
31 Atlas, it is called.
And it's the size of Manhattan, seven miles across, right?
Hurling toward space, in your theory,
I know in a paper talking about
what the possibilities could be.
Please, sir, tell us about that.
Take it away.
Right, so we are often frustrated
by what happens here on Earth,
and I'm trying to say, let's look up,
and maybe we'll have some uplifting news.
And in this case, it's the third object
discovered from outside the solar system
that is heading our way.
And as soon as it was discovered on the 1st of July, 2025,
I realized that it must be quite big, as you pointed out.
And if it's a rock, it's just too big to be real,
because there is not enough material in interstellar space
to deliver a rock of that size,
20 kilometers or so, every few years.
And therefore, it's probably much smaller,
less than a kilometer or a mile in diameter,
in which case it must be surrounded by a cloud of dust.
That would be a comet.
But then I realized in a paper
that I wrote with two colleagues,
that in fact, it's moving on a very special trajectory.
It's aligned with the orbit of the Earth around the sun.
There is a special plane that it's aligned with.
The chance for that happening at random is 0.2%, very small.
But then even along that path that it's moving,
it will, it has several interesting, you know,
coincidences, for example,
it will arrive closest to the sun
when the Earth is on the opposite side of the sun.
So the sun will actually eclipse it.
We won't be able to observe it.
It's coming in the opposite direction
to the motion of the Earth around the sun.
So we won't be able to launch any rockets
that would intercept it
because it would move three times faster
than our best rockets.
It also will come extremely close
to Jupiter, Mars, and Venus.
The chance of that happening is one in 20,000
if you randomly arrange for an arrival time.
So the arrival time is very well selected.
And also it's coming from the direction
of the center of the Milky Way galaxy
where there are lots of stars in that region of the sky.
So it was difficult to detect it.
That's why we found it only in July this year.
And at this point, we can't intercept it from Earth.
And the question is, was this trajectory designed?
Because the chance of it having all these coincidences
is really small.
We will find out if in the coming month or two,
it doesn't look like a comet,
doesn't have a plume of dust and gas around it,
I would start getting worried.
And then when it gets closest to the sun,
that's the best place for a spacecraft
to slow down with the help of the gravity from the sun.
And if we don't see it coming
from the other side of the sun as expected,
the stock market may crash.
Professor, I mean, so many things go through my mind.
So we're saying there may be a possibility
that there's intelligent life moving this object our way.
I remember being in college
and first hearing someone, a professor, say,
you know, it's pretty arrogant for us to think
that we are the only living creatures in the universe.
What are your thoughts on other beings being out there
and then being able to get to our solar system
to check us out?
I mean, is that completely science fiction in your mind
or maybe not so much?
No, I actually, frankly, I don't like science fiction.
I enjoy doing science, which is let's look at the evidence.
And you know, one important fact is
that we are late to the party.
The sun formed in the last one third of cosmic history.
Most stars in the Milky Way galaxy
formed billions of years before the sun.
Now you may ask where will Voyager,
the spacecraft that we launched out of the solar system,
where will it be in a billion years?
The answer is it will be
on the opposite side of the Milky Way.
So there was plenty of time.
If you started the clock billions of years
before it started on Earth,
there was plenty of time
for their technological gadgets to reach us.
And we had only one century of science
since quantum mechanics was discovered.
Only one century.
They may have had the benefit of millennia
or even millions of years,
or maybe even billions of years
of knowing much more about technology and science.
And so we shouldn't assume anything.
You know, when there is a blind date
with someone from another star, all bets are off.
And we should be humble
and just consider the data and learn more.
And of course, if it looks like this one
is a comet or an asteroid that makes,
then we shouldn't lose too much sleep about it,
but we should check each
and every new interstellar object that comes our way.
And, you know, in the coming decade,
there is a new observatory that was funded
by the National Science Foundation
and the Department of Energy
that is starting operations in Chile
called the Rubin Observatory.
It will discover every few months
a new interstellar object.
And my recommendation is to keep our eyes open.
In fact, I do think that, you know,
in the past we worried about existential threats
from artificial intelligence,
from the change of the climate,
or from an asteroid that will impact the Earth.
But there is another item that we should add to the list,
which is alien tech.
I want to talk about that real quick,
if we could, Professor.
Now, you mentioned in your paper
that if it is the case
that this is a technological artifact
from an active intelligence,
then there are two possibilities that follow.
Can you talk about those possibilities?
Right, there are two possibilities
that bracket the range of everything that could happen.
They are either friendly or hostile.
And we should be careful because, you know,
as we know from the story of the Trojan horse,
they may look friendly,
but then there would be something else
behind their intent to visit us.
So I would be quite concerned.
I think there is a need to establish a risk scale
similar to the Richter scale for earthquakes,
where a zero would be a natural object.
If we see a cometary tail, it looks like a comet.
Forget about it, it's not risky.
A 10 would be an object that maneuvers,
that has propulsion, definitely has an engine,
or it looks very strange in its shape,
or it produces artificial lights.
You know, that should raise the alarm.
And of course, there should be an organization
that discusses how to respond to that,
because we are dealing with a visitor
that comes to our backyard.
It's not a radio signal from thousands of light years away
where we have plenty of time to think about how to respond.
Here, you have a visitor,
you have to decide what the intent of the visitor is,
and it could be a threat to the future of humanity.
So we need policy makers.
We need also psychologists
that will communicate the message to the public
without creating any panic.
My hope is similar to President Reagan's hope
that it will bring people together
when there is an external threat of that nature,
but it could also create a lot of chaos
because people will feel
that they're not protected by the government
the way they are from adversarial nations.
And we just have to look at human history,
and every time some human being has gone to another area
or invaded another landmass,
things really haven't probably gone well
for the indigenous people who were there originally.
So is that kind of the theory?
And would there be a way,
if they are so advanced that they can get here
from wherever they came from,
would your guests be professor
that we could somehow defend ourselves or?
There's no hope.
No, no, if they're hostile,
the experience would be very similar
to the Iranian air defense
when the B-2 bombers showed overhead.
Wow.
But the question is whether they care about us.
It might well be the case that we do not count.
I mean, we tend to think that we are very significant
in the cosmic scheme of things.
That's why we thought at first
that we are at the center of the universe,
and it took a while for the Vatican to revise that view.
And it took 350 years after Galileo died
for them to admit that he was right.
But not only that we are not
at the physical center of the universe,
we might not be at the intellectual center of the universe.
There might be a smarter kid on the block.
And as to the intent for them visiting us,
I'm not sure.
There is one solution to the paradox
that was posed by Enrico Fermi
when he asked, where is everybody?
Right.
And that solution is the dark forest hypothesis
where there are plenty of them out there,
but they are silent
because they're worried about predators.
And when they see us,
a young technological civilization,
gaining capabilities that may risk them,
that may threaten them,
they might visit us.
And until then,
we will know that they are around the corner.
You know, it's really difficult
even to see a spacecraft
that is tens of kilometers in size.
It's impossible to see it
when it's at a distance larger
than 10 times the Earth-Sun separation.
It doesn't reflect much sunlight.
Only when it gets to within 10 times
the Earth-Sun separation,
we start seeing it with our best telescopes.
So who knows what lies out there?
We just then have to look at the evidence.
And, you know, I suggest keeping our eyes on the ball.
In this case, interstellar objects.
Professor, we have about a minute left.
I wanted to ask you real quick
if you could maybe offer a recommendation.
If we see this object,
we're getting closer to it,
what should be the first communications
that human beings should have with this object
if it is another intelligence?
You know, my recommendation to people
who go on a blind date is,
first, you need to listen.
Don't speak.
Just listen to the other side.
And that's the approach we should take
because our imagination is limited
to what we had here on Earth.
But in dealing with a blind date from another star,
all bets are off.
Professor, all bets are off.
Sorry to cut you off.
We just ran out of time,
but I am so grateful for your thoughts on this.
And yeah, I'm gonna look up at the sky
a little differently from now on.
That's for sure.
Thanks for having me.
Professor, great stuff.
Have a great day.
Appreciate it.
Thank you, sir.
We'll be right back.
