【The Armchair Historian】世界歷史故事合集:普魯士、俄羅斯、拿破崙、二戰、大不列顛、意大利、美國 P4 - 18世紀的英國軍隊是最強大的嗎?
建築計畫觀
30粉絲
35 次觀看·2025年8月24日
Hi, I'm Griffin Johnson, the Armchair Historian.
Today's video, whether or not the 18th century British Army
was actually the greatest in the world.
As regular viewers of our channel know,
we've been doing a series covering all of the battles
of the American Revolutionary War.
Throughout the course of researching those videos,
time and time again we've come across the claim
that America's soldiers bested the greatest army in the world.
For instance, in a lecture on the history
of the U.S. military, General Wesley K. Clark
calls the British Army the finest fighting force in the world.
And in the book 1776, The World Turned Upside Down,
it is written that the Red Coat was quite the finest soldier of his day.
He only lost one battle during the whole American Revolution,
fighting in the Orthodox formations.
Every part of what I just read is flat out wrong.
And the funny thing is that outside of the context
of the American Revolution,
we rarely see historians make the same claim.
That got us on the Armchair Historian team wondering,
was Britain's 18th century army really the best?
Great Britain's position as a military power
isn't really up to debate.
But as an island nation,
its greatest military asset was the awe-inspiring Royal Navy.
To assess how the army measured up,
we'll be looking at a handful of specific categories,
leadership and logistics,
training,
size,
and finally, its actual record in warfare.
We're also going to be comparing the British
with some of the other European great powers at the time,
especially France and Prussia,
which some military historians refer to
as the gold standard of 18th century armies.
With all of that said,
let's begin with our first category, leadership.
Leadership within the British Army was,
like in other nations at the time,
largely dominated by wealth.
Commissions had to be purchased
and the going rate was not cheap.
Usually, only wealthy landowners
could afford to buy commissions,
so it was not an especially meritocratic system.
While offering leadership positions
on the basis of wealth wasn't unusual,
it certainly wasn't beneficial for British leadership.
For much of the 18th century,
no formal training institution existed
for British army officers,
nor was military experience
required to purchase a commission,
just a recommendation from a major or higher.
However, some of the officers on the ground
did receive an education.
The Royal Military Academy at Woolwich
was opened in 1741,
but it only trained officers
in the Engineering and Artillery Corps.
Compare this to the contemporary Prussian Army,
which opened its first major officer cadet school,
the Cadet House, in 1716.
Now, let's take a look at the army structure.
The organization of the British Army
was kind of a mess.
There were a number of divisional commanders
with one commander-in-chief
to preside over the entirety of the army,
a position that was often vacant.
When someone actually did hold the job,
they were often preoccupied
by conflicts all over the world.
For instance, Geoffrey Amherst,
a man I doubt you've ever heard of,
was in charge during the American Revolution.
and had to juggle another half dozen
simultaneous or near-simultaneous conflicts
in which Britain was embroiled.
In the absence of any overall
organizational direction,
individual generals, high-ranking civilian diplomats,
and even corporate interests
like the British East India Company
had enormous control over troop deployment
and strategy.
With so many different people
exercising or trying to exercise power,
there was very little cohesion.
What's more,
artillery gunners and engineers
technically weren't even part of the army.
Instead, they took orders
from the Board of Ordnance
with their own ranks,
organizations, supplies,
and medical services.
The army's bureaucratic tangle
was a nightmare of incoherence,
insufficiently undone by mediocre leaders.
As a result,
it proved difficult to coordinate
on a large scale,
and logistics frequently had to be handled
on a local level.
More often than not,
commanders had to finance
their own units while abroad
and would only be reimbursed later.
Nonetheless, Britain made up
for this shortcoming
in the training of its common soldiers,
which was rather impressive.
Before they ever saw battle,
new recruits were thoroughly drilled
in accordance with impressive command manners
such as those written by John Churchill,
Duke of Marlborough.
The quality and standardization
of this training helped establish
the British Army's reputation
for being able to turn any man
into an effective soldier.
Troops were highly disciplined,
and lapses were often punished harshly,
with penalties including flogging,
branding,and even execution
for repeated deserters.
That strictness did wonders
for discipline,
but often did the opposite for morale,
which proved to be a long-running problem
for the army.
That was predictably an even bigger problem
among those who were forced to join.
Military service was also
often used as a punishment
for certain crimes.
Those convicted of public drunkenness,
vagrancy,and unpaid debt
were frequently conscripted.
Press gangs were not uncommon,
and their proliferation was actually
one of the causes for the War of 1812
with the United States.
Still, the level of discipline
of British soldiers was undeniably impressive,
even if many of the people
that served in it did so begrudgingly.
Redcoats could hold a line
and maintain an impressive rate of fire
on par with the best armies
in the world, and just about anyone
could be trained to be one of them.
Before we move on, it is important to note
that the 18th century featured
a prolific amount of global conflicts.
Because of this, British military
discipline and leadership quality
had many troughs and peaks
depending on when or where the war was fought.
The last factor we'll talk about today
is the army's overall size.
During the 18th century,
the British army had around
120,000 to 150,000 soldiers
at its peak,
and 45,000 at its lowest.
That's compared to the peak
of 200,000 that the Prussians
had at its disposal,
or the 130,000 that the French
had toward the turn of the century.
While that many redcoats
sounds impressive,
let's consider the fact that
neither of those countries had an empire
that compared to the size of Great Britain,
especially after the Seven Years' War.
Thus, mercenary groups,
usually German ones,
were often relied upon
to supplement troop numbers.
In the American Revolutionary War alone,
37% of the 78,000 British troops
that fought in the Americas
were German mercenaries.
But everything we've discussed here today
hardly means a thing
if we don't look at the actual record
of British successes and failures
on the battlefield.
The British fought six major wars
during the 18th century,
and won just three of them,
maybe four, depending on...
Overall, Britain's army was not terrible,
but it certainly wasn't the battlefield-dominating
force you hear about in high school
textbooks or documentaries
shown on the so-called History Channel.
In fact, considering the excellent
new model army of the 17th century,
the performance of Britain's ground forces
was comparatively lackluster.
The navy, on the other hand,
was, quite reasonably,
always seen as absolutely vital
to British national security,
and thus better maintained.
So our conclusion is that Britain's army
was not the finest in the world
during the 18th century,
but it didn't need to be.
The thriving global empire Britain was building
relied heavily on its navy,
and more often than not,
its ground forces faced non-European foes
with poorly organized
and technologically backward militaries.
And if Britain couldn't conquer the foe
in question using its army,
it could utilize its superior navy
to isolate and starve her enemy,
a tactic that continued to be used
for much of Britain's history.
