The Bonsai Beginner Mistake We All Make (And How To Avoid It)

Bonsai Ideas
277 followers
17 Video Views·Aug 1, 2025
There's a bonsai beginner mistake that we all make that has a material effect on the quality
of our bonsai trees. Keep watching and not only am I going to show you what that mistake is,
I'm going to show you the dramatic effect and difference that makes your bonsai trees
and I'm going to show you what you can do to avoid it and level up your bonsai development.
Keep watching because this could be the most important bonsai lesson you ever learn.
Let me ask what at first might seem like a foolish question but bear with me. I've got
here two oak trees but which of them do you think is the oldest or most mature tree?
I'm going to guess that you chose this tree but what was it about this particular tree
that made you think it's an older more mature tree? What are the characteristics
that make you think that this is older than this?
The objective of bonsai is to create the impression of an aged tree in miniature.
In order to do that there are certain desirable characteristics. For example a thick trunk,
aged craggy bark, a good nebari or root spread, ramified branching, canopy density,
foliage pads and proportion, deadwood features. These are all characteristics of age. They give
the tree character and the appearance or illusion of age. Trunk thickness. An aged bonsai tree
typically has a thick gnarly trunk, fissured aged bark. This conveys strength and resilience.
The trunk develops over years and indeed decades as the tree ages and exhibits interesting textures
and colours. Nebari. The nebari refers to the visible surface root. A good nebari gives a
sense of a tree anchored and stable in the soil. A good nebari literally grounds the tree.
Branching. A mature tree has gradual taper from the trunk to the tips of its branches.
Branches divide and subdivide to give a fine and increasingly twiggy structure.
This is called ramification. Canopy. Canopy refers to not only the foliage density but leaf size and
pad development. Deadwood. This gives an impression of a tree that has struggled through hardships
and has history. This deadwood can take the form of gins, shari or uru. Proportions.
Older bonsai often exhibit more balanced proportions. This means that the height,
trunk thickness, branch lengths and overall structure are in harmony
conveying a natural and mature aesthetic. The bonsai mistake that we all make as beginners
is simply this. We put an immature tree into a bonsai pot and think that we've created a bonsai
and whilst bonsai literally means plant or tree in a pot or tray there's a little bit more to it
Effectively what we've done is we've put this young tree into an environment where it's limited
in terms of resources and nutrients and that will affect the growth of the tree and it means that
this tree may look pretty much the same in another five years time because we've really slowed down
the growth and development of the tree in this pot. The natural beginner impulse in bonsai is
get a tree directly into a pot and hey presto instant bonsai. Problem is this is a constrained
and managed environment. Contrast a tree in a pot with a tree in the ground. In the ground the tree
is free to extend its roots in search of nutrients. The pot is limiting physically. It has limited
resources, limited water and limited nutrients. There is also only finite space in the pot.
This will often mean that as the tree develops the roots will eventually become pot bound.
This is one of the reasons why trees in pots will need regular root work and repotting. For a tree
newly planted or transplanted into the ground year one will be slow as the tree is in shock.
In year two the roots will begin to develop as the tree gets established and in years three
and subsequent years the tree will begin to put on significant growth. By comparison for a tree
grown in a pot growth over the same period of time might be negligible. Whilst growth may not
have stopped consider it has been put into slow motion. Before I continue and show you some almost
unbelievable examples I just need for you to hit the like button and you might want to consider
subscribing to be notified of future videos. Here are two garden center hawthorn trees that I bought
from the same batch about two, two and a half years ago. You can see that the first one of these
is still planted in its nursery container. It started ramifying and developing some tugginess
in the upper branches. What I'd like to show you is this tree from the same batch planted into a
pond basket and I don't know if you can see there but the trunk is significantly thicker on this one
than on this one and the reason for that is that these pond baskets provide a lot of aeration to
the roots and if your tree has got healthy roots that helps it to thicken up faster and develop
more foliage. I have here a four year old silver birch sapling which was a cell grown tree which I
bought from the woodland trust four years ago and you can see it's been sat in the corner of the
garden. It's in this nursery pot and it's just been sat in the quiet corner of the garden left
to its own devices for the last four years. Now I want to show you a dramatic example of what might
have happened if I planted this tree into the ground. This little area of the garden is a growing
bed where I'm ground planting and thickening up some trees. In here I've got one of the silver
birch trees from the same batch as the first tree which I showed you. So in this deepest darkest
corner here's the original silver birch tree from the woodland trust in its nursery container
and just behind that we've got another tree from exactly the same batch that was originally like
this that was ground planted about three years ago and you can see that the trunk of this tree
again is about two inches across and significantly thicker than this one which is exactly the same
age and just demonstrates the benefits of growing your trees in the ground where they've got
unrestricted access to the water and the nutrients and the space that they require to grow and what
that means is this tree is thickening up significantly faster and will acquire a more
aged looking bark and a thicker trunk than the tree that's still in the pot which is in a more
restrictive environment where we're managing the water and the nutrients in the pot. But if you
think that's impressive just let me show you this. Believe it or not this is a one year old
silver birch sapling that's self-seeded into the front garden and you can see by comparison
this is the four year old tree in a pot
and this is the one year old tree growing in the open ground. You can see that whilst the
trunk of the tree that's in the pot is barely a centimeter wide the tree that's growing in the
ground is probably about two inches thick and that tree which is possibly about five foot tall now
is only a year old.
A good bonsai starts with a good trunk. The trunk is the framework on which
everything else literally hangs.
Nibari. My preferred way to develop Nibari is in a wide aerated basket.
This develops shallow roots and provides aeration for healthy development.
Branches and foliage. This comes with ramification and can be done by using a
has been developed to the right stage.
Branches and ramification can be built or rebuilt in a short number of growing seasons.
Ramification comes from judicious pruning and pinching out or pruning of the growing tips of
the branches. That causes back budding and activates latent buds further along the branch
to develop and form new branches.
It causes a continual subdivision along the branches.
Foliage pads. These are a final step in refinement. Once you've got the trunk
and you've developed the branches you can then worry about placement of the foliage.
So how to improve your bonsai? Pick good starter material.
Don't waste time on weak and poor material that's unsuited to bonsai.
It's good for learning the basics but sooner or later you'll want to elevate your bonsai development.
Start with the trunk. Get Yamadori or collected trees if you can.
Grow your trees in baskets or in the ground to help thicken up the trunk.
In year one the tree will be in shock and recovering after being transplanted. In year
two it will be getting more established in its new environment and beginning to send out roots
and fattening up. By year three the tree starts to run away and growth becomes more rapid. The
longer you can leave it to grow in the ground the better. Allow unrestrained growth and for
leaves to develop. Since leaves are like solar panels more leaves means more energy means more
growth. You can cut back that foliage and reshape the tree once you have the trunk to the point that
you need it. So the vital lesson I want for you to take away from this video is this that when you put
a tree into a pot you reduce the speed of development of that tree and that's why you'll
talk about only putting trees into a ceramic finished bonsai pot once that tree is already
refined because at that stage you're not putting on additional growth on the tree you're maintaining
it at that size and state of development and you do that by constantly pruning and maintaining the
roots and you're keeping it in a constrained environment where you're controlling the
watering and the nutrients and feed on that tree and that helps maintain it in that particular
state and the mistake that many beginners make is that they'll put an immature tree into a pot
far too soon and the result is that that slows down the tree and it could be decades before that
tree makes for a refined bonsai. It's something of a cliche that bonsai is a marathon rather than a
sprint but it's certainly true and the longer into the future you can plan the development of your
trees and the more refined your trees will be. If you'd like to see more advice on how to
supercharge your bonsai development I suggest you need to check out this video next.
