華府智庫研討會:美國人 「用腳投票 」項目的結果

新唐人電視台NTDTV
3萬粉絲
318 次觀看·2025年7月28日
美東7月28日下午,總部位於華盛頓的智庫「釋放繁榮計畫」(Unleash Prosperity Project)將就其 「用腳投票 」項目(Vote With Your Feet)的結果舉行專題研討會,項目旨在研究離開某些州的美國人淨移民數量及其原因。新唐人、大紀元將進行網絡直播(即時翻譯字幕)。
Mic check check check
Mic check
You're not hearing it?
I'm not getting... I don't think it's coming
Check check check
One two
Check check
Check check check check
It's gonna be way too... I had turned all those down
It's way too hot
I know I'm saying
OK everybody
Testing one two one two
OK we're gonna get started here everybody
My name is Tim Besher
The executive director here at Unleashed Prosperity
I wanna turn it over to the big man on campus
The boss Stephen Moore here
He's gonna give an introduction to the governor
And we'll get started with Vote With Your Feet
Big pride of the year
Steve
Thank you so much
I appreciate everybody coming out on a hot summer afternoon
This has been a project
By the way
The great governor
Is it the state or the commonwealth of Virginia?
The commonwealth
OK
So the governor of the commonwealth of Virginia
Glenn Youngkin is here
So appreciate so much your participating in this
So I'm gonna give a kind of brief overview of the project
And then we'll hear from the governor
Who knows a lot about why some states grow and others don't
And then we will be taking some questions from you
So this is a project that has been
About two and a half years in the making
We have this idea
Let me put it very simply
I believe the single most important thing
That is going on in this country
Economically and demographically
Is the massive shift in migration
That's happened over the last 10 to 20 years
It is accelerating
It is not decelerating
And the picture
The quick picture here is that
You're seeing a big migration of people
Outside of
Out of the old northeast
Which once was the dominant region
For 220 years, governor
The northeast was the power center of America
You think of New York and Philadelphia
And Baltimore and New Jersey
And that area was the kind of apex
Of American economic and financial power
That is no longer the case
Just two years ago for the first time in history
The southeast is now the dominant region of the country
In terms of production
And that includes obviously Florida, Texas, Virginia
North Carolina, Alabama, Arkansas
In fact, what's really interesting
About this study that we've done
Is the states that used to be considered
The backwater states
Like Arkansas, Alabama, Mississippi
Are growing
And states like New York and Massachusetts
Are losing population to Arkansas and Alabama
That tells you a lot about
How bad those policies are in those states
So I thought I'd just very quickly
Show you a demonstration of the project
We did this
We want this to be available for demographers
For students
For people who are trying to understand economic policy
We made it as user-friendly as we possibly can
So Jackie, if you can put the first slide up
That shows what is going on with respect to
So the website is called votewithyourfeet.net
And so it is available to anybody
It's obviously free
We've made it as user-friendly as possible
And let's start with what is going on
With respect to these population movements
And this is pretty amazing
You can see that the states that have grown
The most in population over the last 10 years
And these are gigantic
These are net numbers by the way
These are the numbers of people
Who've moved into the state
Minus the number of people
Who've moved out of the state
And you can see the big winner
In the sweepstakes has been Florida
Which has gained almost 2 million people on net
That's gigantic
That's 4 to 5 congressional seats right there
And then you can see Texas
There's a real competition
Between Florida and Texas
To see which state can outdo each other
It used to be Texas
But about 3 or 4 years ago
Florida overtook Texas
As the number one state of migration
And then you look at
Some of these other states
I mean look at what's going on here
You see North Carolina
You see Arizona, South Carolina, Tennessee
You notice anything the same
About all these states
Governor, they're all states
In the southeast region of the country
And Washington State
Is one of the kind of outliers
But Washington State
Is a state that has no income tax
So it's not surprising
They're gaining population
So these are enormous numbers of people
That have mostly moved
Well, let's show next
The states that people are
By the way
These are the official census Bureau data
We're not making this data up
We took it straight from the census
And you can see that
The losers here are pretty remarkable
California and New York
Have been the biggest losers
And incidentally
You can understand
Maybe why people
Would want to move out of New York
The weather isn't always so great
In the northeastern state
It's cold there in the winter
But how do you screw up California
Governor
I mean really
That is a slice of heaven
As the most beautiful mountains
Beautiful people
Beautiful oceans
And this is the first time
Governor
In history
You know the history of our country
That California is now
Losing people to others
It used to be a place
Where people wanted to go to
And this is a good demonstration
Of what happens
When you put in place
Years and years and decades
Of bad policies
Incidentally
The two states in the country
That have the highest income tax
Guess which
Florida
I mean California and New York
And then you see
My home state of Illinois
Which has just been ruined
By progressive policies
What's happened to Chicago
Has been really devastating
And you can see
Some of these other states
Massachusetts etc.
So what you get
You're starting to get
The picture here right
That people are moving
Out of the northeast
They're moving to the dynamic states
Of the south
I want to just interject
One other quick thing
When you look at states
As a percentage of their population
Because Florida and Texas
Are already big states
But the states that
Of the mountain states
States like Utah, Montana, Idaho
Are growing very rapidly as well
In terms of percentage terms
They're actually growing
Just as fast as Florida and Texas are
So what you're seeing is
The coasts are not doing so well
California and the northeast
And these states
In the mountain region of the country
And the southeast
Are doing really well
The next one I'll show you
Can you show the next chart
Thank you very much
Is now the second part of this study
That I think is maybe
Even more interesting
In the population numbers
Governor is
We now have IRS data
That tracks where people
We don't know who they are
But we know what their incomes are
On their tax returns
So we have a pretty good indication
Of where the money is flowing into
And this is really pretty amazing
So once again
Look at by the way Florida
Almost 200 billion dollars
Over the last 10 years
Of net income has flown in
Has flowed into that state
That's an incredible number
It's one of the reasons
Florida is such a prosperous state
Right now
We're trying to buy a home
In Florida right now
We can't afford it
Not in Virginia
OK, right
Great idea, Governor
And so Florida is
The big, big sweepstakes winner here
Texas is obviously doing well
I was surprised that Texas
Texas is gaining about as many people
But basically what this is telling you
Is the people with wealth
Are moving to Florida
And then you can see Arizona
North Carolina, South Carolina, etc.
Before I forget
Because this is a really important point
It's the reason we asked
Governor Duncan to come
Is Virginia is an example
Of a state that got it wrong
For the last 10 years
Your predecessors
Did not do a very good job
Of attracting people
It was high taxes
Too much regulation
Too much crime
All of those things
And you have turned that around, Governor
And our studies indicate
And the Census Bureau confirmed this
That last year
For the first time in a decade
Virginia is now a state
People are moving into
So congratulations for that
That's an amazing feat
You've made a huge difference
Show the next one
So that is
Those are the states that have gained
And then this is the sad story
Same thing
New York and California
And Illinois are just being
Bled to death
And the way I put it, Governor
Is that these states need to
Change or die
They need to change or die
Because this migration will continue
Some of our friends on the left
And some of our Democratic friends
Like to say
Well, taxes don't matter that much
They don't really have an impact
You're looking at the impact
Of taxes right here
I mean, this is
And incidentally, I've debated
Some of my liberal friends
For 25 or 30 years
And the one thing
They cannot explain
Is why it is
If their progressive policies
Work so well
People are voting with their feet
Against it
And they really have no
Response for that
Other than air conditioning
And by the way, air conditioning
Is a factor behind
The rise of the Southeast
But it is not the whole explanation
So that just shows you
The states that are going
Finally, I don't know if we can
Put this on the screen
Can we do this, Jackie
And show just a quick demonstration
Of how the website works
OK, so this is something
That Jackie did
Yeoman's work in putting together
And you can see
What's kind of fun about this
Is you can look
Let's do
You can click on a state
And then you can click on
A second state
And it will show you
How many people are moving
From one state to another
So let's start with
Jackie, let's do
How many people have moved
Over the last 10 years
From California to Texas
That's a big number
That's a huge, huge number
Now
And by the way
You can see the movement
And you can also do it
With respect to the money
That's changed
Can you do the
Well, before you do that
Let's do
The other one I want to show you
And by the way
As we get in the Q&A
If you have questions
About certain states
We're happy to do the demonstration
Let's do New York and Virginia
Let's see
Let's see how that turned out
So that's a
That's a New York and Virginia
What is that
That's actually a great number
That's a couple of people
Who've moved out
So you're the beneficiary, Governor
Of the bad policies in New York
So I want to turn it over to
Governor Youngkin
Who has been a superstar
I met the Governor
When he first started
Running for Governor
I said, are you crazy
You're going to give up this great life
That you have to run for Governor
Ran a spectacular campaign
And has been one of
America's great Governors
Over the last four years
Ladies and gentlemen
Governor Glenn Youngkin of Virginia
Keep that one up there
Just for a minute
So first of all, thank you
While this is up here
I just want to point out two things
The data ended in 2022
Which is the 2021 tax data
So this is the year that I came in
And I think
I will tell you
I think there are two states on here
Because they have different Governors
That are changing
And I will tell you
Virginia I know is changing
And on the other slide
Where the other one was
Louisiana
And Louisiana is fundamentally changing
And it's interesting to watch
What will happen in Louisiana as well
As they have common sense policies
That attract business
Reduce the cost of living
And the cost of business
And I bet you're going to see
Louisiana move as well
So thank you
We can move that
By the way, just so you know
This is the most recent data
But we're going to get the 2023 numbers
Sometime in October
So perfect
I already know how we're doing
And one of the things I recognize
And I'll just start
First of all, Steve, thank you
Thank you for doing this project
And thank you for the warm welcome
And thank you for shining a spotlight
On something that I think
Has probably been in your DNA for decades
Which is to unleash prosperity
How about that for a concept
And to unleash prosperity
Because you believe in individual liberty
And you believe in free enterprise
And you believe that in fact
Those influences move businesses and people
And we can track this
And that's why I always read every day
And if you don't
Read the Unleash Prosperity hotline every day
Because I'm telling you
It is outstanding
I don't get it
Unleashprosperity.com
Go get it
But it's part of my daily reading
And the reason it is
Is because there's always
Actually usually four or five
Great nuggets in there
That either reinforce something
That I have been struggling with
And give me a new perspective on it
Or plant a new idea
And so thank you
Thank you for always pressing our thinking
There we go
Well, there's lots of challenges in there
And we've been talking about those numbers
About five
They're amazing
I mean, the bottom line is
We've dropped murders in Virginia by 30%
Simply by putting more badges on the street
How about that for an idea
More badges on the street
And by the way, we have the largest training class
In our state police academy
That we've had since 2018
The third largest one
In the history of state police
So guess what
You back the blue
You fund them
You stand behind them
When they have challenges
And you celebrate them with their wins
And people want to be police officers in your state
And more police officers means lower crime
That's just that simple
You are not alone in what you do
And I just
Art Laffer has been an amazing friend to me
And partner for you
But you also have a great
Executive Director of Communications
And I just want to thank Tim Docher
For all your work
Tim, I'm getting ready to go
I don't know where you are
But you're in the room here
So thank you
And then I want to point out
Justin Vallez-Hagan
Who is my Deputy Chief of Staff
And Justin is the keeper of all data
And so thank you, thank you, thank you, Justin
But what we find is that this concept of migration
Is not something that people have really grasped on to
I have been talking about this for five years
And for five years I have been basically an apostle
Talking about the fact that if you have
Fewer customers today in your state
Fewer people than you had yesterday
Your state is heading in the wrong direction
And when those people take their money with them
And that money represents
A disproportionate amount of your state's economic activity
You've got a major challenge
And I have to say, Steve and I just hit it off
Literally like two kids in a candy shop
Because we started talking about this
Right when I was running
And I finally found somebody else on the planet
That would listen to me
My wife was even not listening to me at that point
She's like, honey, I know this, I know this
Out-migration, I get it, I get it
But at the end of the day
This is at the economic
And by the way
The financial heart of a state
Because one of the things that
Is going to be on the next chart
Is states that are running deficits
And states that are running surpluses
Because if you are shrinking
You are running a deficit
If you are growing
You are running a surplus
And it's just that simple
And that's the difference between
Winning states and losing states
And that's why you can look at the states
That are increasing
Even their share of new jobs and people
And they're the ones that get to invest
Time and time and time again
And the ones that are consistently
Offering tax relief time and time again
And how about this for a basic economic cycle
We're going to start
We're going to reduce your taxes
And then we're going to see
More people come to my state
And those more people are going to
Bring with them their income
And they're going to pay taxes
And then we have a surplus
And with that surplus
We get to invest in education
And law enforcement and behavioral health
And we get to reduce taxes again
And guess what
More people come
And this virtuous cycle actually works
And we know it works
Because that is what we've unleashed
In the Commonwealth of Virginia
In 2022
We saw 10 years of data like this
With more people moving away than moving in
On average about 15,000 net out migration
To the other states
For 10 years in a row
Now by the time you get 10 years into that
That's not just billions of economics
That are going away
But it's about 500 million dollars a year
In tax revenue that disappears
Your tax base goes with them
And so in 2023
After we had our first round of great tax relief
And we had our first round of businesses
Coming to Virginia
In 2023 for the very first time
Virginia broke the mold
And we were number 9 in the nation
For net in migration
Coming from number 40 the year before
That is the big shift
And when that happened
We saw another amazing thing happen
We ran a huge surplus
And that allowed us to go for tax relief again
And that allowed us to invest
In all the building blocks again
Education, law enforcement, mental health
And by the way running government more efficiently
And guess what
More people came again
And more businesses came again
And this virtuous cycle works
And today as we look back over these 4 years
We now have 125 billion dollars
Of business investment
That's been promised to the Commonwealth of Virginia
We have more people working
Than we've ever had in the history of the state
The 2024 data again suggests
Virginia's net in migration
The allied
I actually watch all this data
Van line data
And anything I can get people to move
I actually stand at the border and count sometimes
But at the end of the day
Allied van line says
We were number 5 in the nation
In net in migration in 2024
United van line says
We're a 55-45 net importer
I mean this is the kind of stuff
That gives you real insight
Into what's happening in your state
And then I get to look at our financials
And Virginia for the 4th year in a row
Is running a multi-billion dollar surplus
We've had over 10 billion dollars
Of surpluses in 4 years
Record investment in education
Record investment in law enforcement
Record investment in behavioral mental health
Record investment in taking care of God's green earth
Because I believe that if we take care of it
It will take care of us
And 9 billion dollars in tax relief
During this entire time
It works, it works, it works
And the states where it is not working
We see over and over again
And those states continually see
Out migration, businesses leaving
And as a result
Deficit after deficit
And what do they have to do
Because they refuse to cut spending
They raise taxes, they raise taxes
And all it does is
Turn their out migration faucet
From medium to high
And before you know it
Those states are in trouble
And that's exactly what you see
My friend Governor Little
Who is in Idaho
Will frequently say
As he and I were on
An economic development panel last week
The very best economic development program
I have in the state of Idaho
Is California
It's true
And I have to say
There is a state just north of us
Where they have now become
The third heaviest tax load in America
We have more people moving here from there
By just a huge factor
And in fact just recently
One of the chairman of their senate
Economic development authority
Who voted to raise taxes on business
Then moved his business
From Maryland to Virginia
It happens
It works
So Steve thank you
Thank you for caring so deeply about
Not unleashing prosperity in itself
But recognizing that we as decision makers
Can make a decision everyday
To help our citizens be more prosperous
To help our states be more successful
And the formula is not that hard
We just got to do it
So God bless you
Thank you
And we look forward to the conversation
All right
We'll take a few questions
I just want to punctuate a few points
That the governor made
He kids me all the time
Because I actually moved from
Virginia to Maryland about six years ago
And I'm kind of regretting it
And we
I live in Montgomery county
In Montgomery county, Maryland
I don't know if you're familiar with this
We have a six percent state income tax
In Montgomery county
I don't know
維吉尼亞是否允許城市和縣市增加稅?
城市和縣市沒有稅
但他們都知道有稅
瑪麗蘭有稅
所以我付9.5%
我不是富人
我付9.5%稅
所以我可能會回到維吉尼亞
所以我想再說一件事
我不知道Jackie
我們有這個嗎?
這是哪個縣市人移民
這是收入稅的圖表
你有這個嗎,Jackie?
這是一個
她在找這個圖表時
這個圖表顯示
如果我們可以把它翻譯出來
是美國
我剛才展示給你們的
是美國最多人損失的國家
兩個最多人損失的國家
也是美國最高收入稅
所以在紐約
紐約市有美國最高收入稅
我不知道你們認不認同
他們的收入稅率現在是14.4%
14.4%
加州
我認為是13.5%
這是數學
你們可以付14%
住在紐約市
或者可以移民到佛羅裏達
或者移民到德州
並付零
這是我們的研究顯示
非常有吸引力
稅務系統有很大的影響
人們移民到哪裡
一旦你開始減稅
人們就開始移民到德州
為什麼人們要移民到德州
我的想法是
如果紐約市的總統選舉
就像現在那樣
我已經有一個預約
寫著
半路到佛羅裏達95%
然後你就回家了
我們開玩笑
這是很嚴肅的事
因為紐約市是美國最重要的城市
8億人住在那裡
紐約市是華爾街最重要的城市
是一個非常奇妙的城市
如果
那個候選人說
他想增加國內稅
再增加2%
如果他在看
C-SPAN或者其他網站
如果你這樣做
我真的相信
紐約市不會再有華爾街了
他們已經很接近
失去華爾街了
我以前去華爾街
15年前對比今天
華爾街只是一個鬼城
很可憐
所以我不希望這件事發生
我希望紐約市的人
不會讓這件事發生
我們為什麼不打開
這個問題
如果你們有問題
或有其他問題
我們再回答
好的
打開
Virginia has that in spades
Historically
particularly in the last 4 years
before I came in
the previous administration
passed a green new deal
and they basically said
we're going to dismantle
all hydrocarbon based power generation
and replace it solely
with wind and solar
that's it
that's all you got
and they also based all of that
on an economic forecast
that had flat growth
no job growth
no economic growth
and by the way folks
no state growth
and that reflected their view
of Virginia's prospects
now 4 years later
Virginia's growing like crazy
and we need more power
and so I brought an all American
all of the above power plan
back in late 2022
and said we need it all
we need anything we can build
but particularly
we need natural gas
and we've got to go build
a lot of natural gas
generating capacity
we need it now
we need to develop nuclear
faster than anybody else
and we're not going to
dismantle anything that we've got
because we can't replace it
with weather dependent power generation
and we have a bunch of solar
under developed
and we've got an offshore wind
and that stuff was so far down the road
when I came in
I was like just finish it please
we need it
and so this is the big step for us
as a state
which is to meet
the power demand
that underpins economic opportunity
that underpins jobs
and migration movements
so I am cautiously optimistic
that we're heading in a reasonable direction
but I will say
I need the General Assembly
in Richmond which is controlled by
one seat in the House and one seat in the Senate
by the Democrats
I need them to start undoing
the Virginia Clean Economy Act
because without us undoing it
we are going to be limited
in how fast we can grow
and I don't think Virginians should be limited
I think Virginians should be allowed to run as fast as they can
so this is our next big step
and I've even heard a couple of the senior Democrat leaders
saying what I've been saying
for four years
which is the Virginia Clean Economy Act doesn't work
so that's a
I bet a lot of people
in this room and a lot of people around the country
don't realize that the largest data center
in the country is there
in Loudoun County
a lot of people even in Loudoun County don't know it's there
Virginia's the largest data center market in the world
by a factor of four
So are you going to have enough energy
I mean need electric power
If they do what I've asked them to do
the short answer is yes
If they reverse trend
and stop the development of gas
stop the development of nuclear
and pick back up
the decommissioning
of our existing power stack
then we can run into real problems
and of course
what comes with that plan
their plan
are utility bills
that go through the roof
because they're putting it all on the back
of the rate payers
and one of the great things that we've done
is negotiate with all of the data center folks
that they can now apply
through the state corporation commission
and get their own customized rate
which forces them
to pay for the infrastructure
that goes into their power developments
not the rate payers themselves
who are already suffering
from the result of the green new deal
that was passed
one of the states
that is for the first time
in a long long long time
growing is one of your neighbors
West Virginia
and one of the reasons
West Virginia is growing
is because they have bountiful energy
and Virginia does too
and so it's frustrating
that so many states
one of the things
that I've been so encouraged
by the leadership in West Virginia
is that they recognize
they have an advantage
they're reducing tax burdens
ahead of the game
and what they've seen as a result
is guess what
population migration heading to West Virginia
so I mean this is not a difficult formula
which is tell your customers
you care about them
your customers are your citizens
and we're going to reduce the tax burdens on you
we're going to create more opportunity
for you and your family
to live a fabulous life
and the virtuous cycle works
so if people want to see
exactly what the governor is talking about
go to our new website
votewithyourfeet.net
and you can find these
migration patterns
and you're exactly right by the way
that energy is so important
to this formula
other questions or comments
Hello, Dr. Merton Alexander
here in Washington, D.C.
So we're looking forward
and looking at what's taking place now
with USDA
how does that affect
Washington, Virginia, Maryland
when you're going to have USDA
moving out to other states
how will that factor into your
with what
the USDA
so let me start
we have a very large number
of folks in Virginia
who work for the federal government
and in fact we have again
a disproportionate number
of people who live in Virginia
but work in the federal government
and other places
they make good decisions
they decided to live in Virginia
because we have lower taxes
the roads are better
the schools are better
it's safer
and therefore you should move to Virginia
But what we of course
are going to see
we're going to see some job reductions
Virginia is on the face of
a little protected
because a disproportionate number
of our jobs are in defense
national security and intelligence community
and there's $150 billion more
coming into that community
but we are going to see
other areas either be moved out
of the greater DMV area
or reduced in an absolute sense
and you may have seen
just recently the
department of housing and urban development
moved their headquarters
from DC to Virginia
and once again
they found great real estate
and that's where their folks
wanted to live, work and raise their families
so the net of it is
there will be movement
and then my job
is to make sure that
when people do experience
that dislocation in their employment
it happened to my family twice
when I was growing up
in 7th grade and 11th grade
my dad lost his job
it's rough
but in this case
what I have clearly put in place
is a pathway to a great future
we have 250,000
open and unfilled jobs
in Virginia
and I'm going to say that again
250,000 open and unfilled jobs
and those jobs
about 100,000 of them
require a bachelor's degree or greater
so these are really high paying jobs
and about 110,000 of them
are in northern Virginia
and so there is great opportunity
for people to find a new pathway
and then we have laid out
if anybody is curious
at virginiahasjobs.com
a pathway for
people to find
educational resources
if they need a credential
or they want to get a master's degree
or take a course
we've got all that online
ready for people to sign up
we have pathways for people
to maintain their healthcare coverage
so that they can get through this bridge
and then of course
the website has the jobs on it
and you can actually search on
almost any field in any location
and my goal is to help people
migrate quickly from
a public sector job
at the federal government
to another job in Virginia
in the private sector
or with one of our state agencies
So Governor, one of the things
that we've talked a lot about
but we can't talk enough about
is the importance of taxation
and as you know
there are nine states
in the United States today
that have no income tax at all
and many of them
are in the southeast
some of them are neighboring states
to Virginia
so you've got Texas
you've got Florida
you've got Tennessee
you've got Mississippi
just passed a lot of phase out
their income tax
one of the things that we would like to see
that unleash prosperity
we have this dream
that the entire southeast region
of the country
because all of
you're not the only governor
in the southeast that's cutting taxes
almost all of these
republican governors are doing that
this is our dream
to make the southeast
a kind of income tax-free zone
a school choice zone
you've done a lot of school choice
that's a big issue
right to work
are you
Virginia is a right to work state
we need to elect the correct governor candidate
to maintain a right to work state
because we find
twice as many jobs
and people are moving to right to work states
than forced to leave the states
so just any thoughts about
what you also see is
that the states
that are aggressively moving to phase out
their personal income tax
have one single characteristic
unified republican leadership
in their general assembly
and their governor's office
it's just true
and so what West Virginia talks about
that's what they're moving toward
you've mentioned Mississippi
and that's why elections matter
and so I have
been in divided government
since the day I came in
I will say that common sense does prevail
when the doors are shut
most of the time
and you can usually convince people
with all of the data
that we've been talking about
that the future of Virginia requires us
to have tax relief
and to invest in site development
and economic development
but the reality is
that every time I have moved
to really restructure our tax code
I get blocked
and I do think somewhere along the way
Virginia's going to have to wake up
and recognize that the states
just south of us
are eliminating or at least substantially reducing
both their personal income tax
and their corporate tax
and that is a really important milestone
Virginia back in 2012
was one of the low-tax states
in the southeast
and now we find ourselves
chasing in order to
keep up with the tax reductions
every place else
so again the formula is really straightforward
I have been advocating
and an apostle for it
since the day I was elected
and the states who figure it out
are the ones that are going to continue to compete and win
and the ones that don't
are going to fall behind
that's what gowithrepeated.net is all about
so one other issue I want to bring up with you
you mentioned energy
and thanks Ann for bringing that up
because I agree with her and you
that that is a huge issue
I don't think a lot of states are prepared
for the increased demand
it could be double or even triple
the other issue of course is housing
and we have a housing shortage
in the United States
Trump has talked a lot about this
we've been doing our analysis
and I'd love to get your perspective as a governor
it's pretty clear
that the states and the cities
that have the worst housing shortages
are states that have two things
one is rent control
and the other is very strict zoning laws
that don't allow
multifamily homes to be built
are you doing
what are your thoughts about that
are you doing anything
so on top of that
I think you should have a fourth page
on Vote With Your Feet
which is just housing development
by the numbers
and you literally can see
the number of homes
either based on the current census
of homes or per capita
and you will also see
that these same areas
that are growing the most
actually have the largest
home production
they just do
and states that are struggling with home production
are the ones that are losing people
and then there's folks like Virginia
where we straddle
and Virginia's got a challenge
it's been one of my big issues
which is so much of home construction
and the zoning for home building
is handled at the local level
and the state
we have streamlined regulations
we've taken out 80,000 regs in Virginia
25% of our reg base
we have streamlined
saves people 1.2 billion a year
we've taken $25,000 out of the cost of a home
by redoing the regulations around a home
but the flip side is
if the local authorities
are going to continue
to proffer people to death
and those of you in the real estate industry
know what that is
they just layer on
requirement after requirement after requirement
and before you know it
it becomes uneconomic
to build medium priced homes
and the only homes
that make sense to build
are big ones
because you can overcome
the development cost
by the absolute price of the house
and so this is a huge thing for us
and I have really started
to put a huge amount of pressure
on our localities
to the point where
if you want economic development assistance
you've got to come to me with a housing plan
on how you're going to enable
the construction of housing units
to be workforce housing
for people who are going to move there
we've got time for one or two more quick questions
my name is Marnix van Rey
I'm from the Netherlands as you might hear
we just moved my wife and myself
to Virginia last year
but she is American
I have a question
because I'm pretty impressed
about what you just said
and what we do see
the Netherlands is also
a relatively small country
but a big economy
we are one of the
major investors in the United States
both companies
but also institutional investors
your president
has concluded a trade deal
with the EU
and as you know
part of that is an investment
of at least 750 billion
in the United States
how are you going to promote
Virginia especially
for foreign investors
because I'm a former minister
of taxation in the Netherlands
so I heard you talking about
the personal income tax
and the corporate income tax
these are crucial factors
for foreign companies to invest
and I would love to see at least
Dutch and European companies
investing in Virginia
ok great question
and we live in Paul's church
hooray
I hope everybody that doesn't live in Virginia
is feeling compelled to move
so thank you
and so let me just tell you
what we've been doing
first of all we have had
just a massive uptick over the last three years
and businesses committing to expand
build and grow in Virginia
and put it in context
we're about 125 billion
of committed expansion capital
and that's more than the previous
two administrations combined over four years
so big big movement
and companies wanting to be in Virginia
because we've worked hard to make
Virginia business friendly
we have shovel ready sites
we solve power problems
we have a great workforce
companies want to come
so interestingly as soon as President Trump
signed the deal with the UK
I was in the office
of the largest publicly traded company
in the UK
trying to convince AstraZeneca
to move to Virginia
33 days later they announced
$50 billion commitment to America
and the biggest piece of it in Virginia
last week I was on the phone
with a whole bunch of Japanese companies
convincing them to come to Virginia
and I've started today
with all my European friends
and I get up really really early
and so at 5.30 I'm smiling and dialing
so I'm six hours ahead in Europe
and I'm calling all of them
but the bottom line is
there's a moment here
where there's an investment decision to be made
and whoever's there first
is going to have the best chance
to explain why you should come to Virginia
for those of you who like football
I am in the SEC of Economic Development
I mean I'm competing against Tennessee
North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida
and Texas all the time
and I gotta get there first
How about you pay in those court?
NIL's another problem
But to me it is
having a great value proposition
and then getting in front of the decision makers
and helping them understand
why Virginia's the right place to be
Listen, we win more than our fair share
but anybody that's got a good lead for me
I'll take it and I promise
that we'll follow up by tomorrow
No issue at all, thank you
Last question
then we're going to cut this off
I don't want to abuse your time
No, I'm good
All right, so we'll take a couple more
Speed round, speed round
All right, real quick
As an economist, it's great
you're talking about taxes, talking about regulations
Those are key to coming in
But also the underlying issue
is you've got a special election
and you have a district to chime in
and we have a governor race
and a lieutenant governor race
We'll take a couple of that
We'll call them all up
My question
Well, I did come from Texas two and a half years ago
So I feel safe in this room saying
My question is
I'm into health care policy
and actually one of my dreams
is to get a research institution
I did go to law school
to study health care policy
and I know that
Virginia has CON laws
the certificate of need laws
and some of the states
like Texas and Florida
have kind of eased up on those certificates
to make it a little easier for
competition in the health care industry
which will drive prices down
So I just wanted to know
your thoughts on that
and possibly
changes in that
since they're so old and outdated
By the way
As you probably know
our mutual fund Arthur Laffer
is really into this idea of health care
price transparency
So could you kind of add that
and take those on
So first of all
we have a giant election
in Virginia, actually two
September 9th is CD11
It's a special election
and then we have
a great candidate
I was with him this morning
And so
But on top of that
we've got a big election on November 4th
And so elections matter
I can't put it any other way
I mean if anybody hasn't figured out
that elections have consequences
they have not seen the nation
in the last six months
I mean think of the difference today
than where we were this time last year
And so elections have consequences
We've got to win elections
We won in 2021
We've got to win in 2025
And so anybody who is in Virginia
We need you to get out to vote
And let me tell you
Vote for Winsome Earl Sears for governor
She will continue what we're doing
And do a great job
On the health care front
First of all
I am a big fan of competition
And therefore I would look forward
To inviting you to help me
Grease the skids with our General Assembly
On why it is a good thing
Remember I've got people on the other side
Who
I always talk about cutting red tape
And I've started to change my tune
I call it cutting blue tape
Because we know where the tape comes from
And so I need some help
Cutting some blue tape
That'd be awesome
And then finally
Price transparency is critical
And it's critical
Because no one really understands
What things cost
Because you cannot see
A look through price to them
And just start with pharmaceuticals
We cannot tell
What pharmaceuticals cost
And particularly with the middlemen
The PBMs
You really can't tell what they cost
And so we need
Net look through pricing
In health care
Which then will allow us
To allocate resources
The right way
In order to get at those areas
Where prices really aren't reflective
Of good supply and demand
And other ways to work
To bring down prices
Where we really are seeing
Patients taking advantage of
And I think that's what's happening
Bill
We'll take these last two
You go and then you go
And then we'll stop
Absolutely
Thank you for coming
Governor
I agree that
In-migration is definitely better
Than the alternative about migration
Can you put your microphone
Absolutely
But I guess my one question
Would be are there any concerns
About how you might manage
The effects of a large amount
Of in-migration
I mean you go around
Northern Virginia
And you migrate
In-migration
You go out to Fairfax County
They used to have a hunt
You drive through Fairfax
Now you can't imagine
Hunting out there at all
You look to Aldi
And it used to be beautiful
Pristine countryside is now
You see townhome development
For people who work in D.C.
But can't afford to live here
You see a lot of like
Ten years ago
Virginia was a much more
Conservative state I think
Than it is now
And you see a lot of the places
That have benefited the most
From in-migration
Let's hand it over to Bill
I actually have an answer
Not a question
Because in your opening
You said you love the hotline
You read it every day
I'm part of the editorial team
And just for anyone who didn't hear
Where to get it
Unleashprosperity.com
You go to unleashprosperity.com
Click on hotline
You will get it every weekday
I do the first draft every night
And then Steve rewrites every single word
And so it has his wit and wisdom
And you get it totally free every day
Unleashprosperity.com
And thank you for the kind words
About the hotline
We praise you often as you deserve it
So go ahead
So one of the big things
That attracts businesses to Virginia
Is the educated workforce
So with the rise of AI
Is there any plan
To give educational
Benefits to people
Who are structurally unemployed
So let me cover first
With growth
Comes challenges
And opportunities
And so I always start first
With localities have to work with us
And have to have a plan
And if the locality doesn't
Want economic development
They're not working with us
They generally don't get it
And what we're seeing
Is there some localities
That are really working hard with us
And they're the ones that are getting
A lot of investment
There's other ones that aren't
And that's their choice
I will say what comes with that
Is a deep integration
On transportation planning
On school construction
On law enforcement support
On all the services that come with it
And the state's deeply engaged in that
With growing localities
And you have to be
Because we know that more people
Need more services
But if we're doing this right
The tax receipts
And the economic impact
Of a growing community
Far outweigh the demand
Of needing to invest
In all that infrastructure
So I'm very much
From the school that says
Get the decisions closest to the voters
And these are decisions
For localities to make
And localities need to make them
I will say just if I could for a minute
Fairfax County is an interesting one
The leadership in Fairfax County
Eight, ten, fifteen years ago
Was deeply engaged with Virginia
As far as economic development
Would demand
Helping us recruit companies
And those kinds of things
And Fairfax County was growing
Over the last few years
Fairfax County no longer
Really participates very much
In wanting to attract companies
And so you see Fairfax County
Not growing and in fact not shrinking
And in fact they were running
A $300 million deficit
And so what does Fairfax County do
Is they raise taxes
And they go to a meals tax
And they go to their property taxes
And their car taxes
And guess what that does
Is it drives more people out of Fairfax County
And so the bottom line is
You have to have a top line economic engine
Driven by business investment
To hire more people
To give them the wherewithal to live
In order to drive this economic engine
Otherwise you become Fairfax County
Now one of the great questions about AI
We have the most spectacular workforce
In Virginia
We rank top of the list
In just about every single poll or survey
Our customized talent development program
Which is called
Our talent accelerator
Which is rated the number one
Customized talent program in America
For the third year in a row
One of the challenges is
We do have AI involved
In every aspect of work
And it's here
Not coming, it's here
And so last Monday
We announced
A special program
In partnership with Google
Our community colleges and our universities
To provide pathways
To AI certificates
And here's how it works
By the way if you haven't been to
virginiahasjobs.com
It's a magic website
You can find jobs but you can also find
The AI landing spot
And there right on the front page
If you want to go get a scholarship
From Google
There's 10,000 of them available
To obtain
An AI credential
And no matter where you're
Whatever you're doing
Or you can move and get literally an
Associate's degree at one of our community colleges
Or you can put yourself on a secondary degree
At one of our four years
And what we're finding just in this first week
We've been up for a week
We had 13,000 people
Go apply for a credential
Scholarship from Google
We've got 10,000 scholarships
So they're starting to move their way through those
The good thing is it's like a library book
And once somebody uses
That scholarship and obtains
Their AI essentials credential
They can put the library book back
And somebody else can come use it
And so these don't get exhausted
It's a huge opportunity for us to develop a workforce
That is capable of working
In the manufacturing sector
Or in the marketing office sector
Or even being a coder in AI
To take advantage of both the opportunities
But the reality that AI
Will influence everything that happens
In the workforce going forward
Well, Governor
That is a fantastic analysis
And thank you so much
Just to summarize
By the way, can you, Jackie, put up
I want to show one more thing on this chart
Just put up the charts
Just do
New York and Florida
So that's just showing you
You can see the moving balance
And the dollar bills
This is a crisis for New York
New York has to figure out
How they can retain their people
Because your people are your best assets
And so one of the things
That is a remarkable statistic
You probably know this one
But New York and Florida right now
Roughly have the same population
You know, within a few hundred thousand
New York spends twice as many
Much money per person
On their government as Florida does
Think about that
New York spends twice as much money
Per person as Florida does
And I've been to both states
And I would say Florida has superior
Public services than New York
So the question is
Where is all that money going
And that's the same thing
With Texas and California
You have been a fiscally lean governor
Who's invested in the right things
And taken money out of the things
That we shouldn't be spending money on
And so congratulations
On your great job
The website is called
Votewithyourfeet.net
It is anyone
Kids should be using it
Demographers, people who are doing research
On what's happening in the states
I'll say this again
I really believe the most important thing
That's happening in America
That people aren't paying enough attention to
Is this internal migration
That's changing the nature of our country
And states like Virginia and North Carolina
And Texas and Florida
Are gaining
And for my friends who live in New Jersey
Or my home state of Illinois
Or New York
Or Pennsylvania
You need new leadership
Because you're quite right, Governor
Leadership is everything
Let's give Governor Leong
A great round of applause
For being here
Thank you all for being here
I want to just give a quick thanks to
Tim Desher who put this whole thing together
Jackson Avery
Jackie, you did an amazing job
Putting this together
Shelly, thank you so much
For all of your work on this
And my wife Anna is here
She tolerates me
And we'll have a nice little reception afterwards
Thank you for coming
And have a great day
And vote with your feet
Thank you very much
