AT&T Chief Security Officer Ed Amoroso Interviews Grace Hopper, Albert Einstein, and Richard Feynman
So now we come to the afternoon keynote from Ed Amoroso,
and we're doing a little stage work here.
But Dr. Edward G. Amoroso serves as Senior Vice President
and Chief Security Officer for AT&T Services.
His responsibilities include real-time security protection
of AT&T's network and computing infrastructure,
including mobility services, security policy, planning,
and architecture for AT&T's enterprise.
Security support for AT&T's IPTV and entertainment
initiatives, and lead design, development,
and operations support for AT&T's managed
and network-based security services.
Ed's 25-year career at AT&T began at Bell Laboratories,
where he worked on securing the Unix operating system,
as well as numerous federal government
security initiatives.
More recently, he has championed AT&T's network-based security
strategy, centered around emerging in-the-cloud protection
services, such as network-based firewall and DDoS defense.
Ed has authored numerous research papers, articles,
and five books on information security,
including the recently published Cyber Attacks Protecting
National Infrastructure.
He is the 1999 winner of the AT&T Labs Technology Medal
for his contributions to large-scale intrusion detection.
And actually, this year he joined a very prestigious group.
He was named an AT&T Fellow.
So that's a very small group of key people.
So Ed holds a Master of Science and PhD degrees
in computer science from the Stevens Institute of Technology
and is a graduate of the senior executive program
at the Columbia Business School.
He has served as an adjunct professor in computer science
department at Stevens for the past 20 years.
And his work has been featured by The Wall Street Journal, CNBC,
Network World, and The New York Times.
So please join me in welcoming Dr. Ed Amoroso.
Thank you, Ed.
Dr. Tarni, I thought that was a really, really good presentation.
I'd seen him give a similar talk some number of months ago,
and I thought you would enjoy it.
So I thought it was great.
The talks also this morning from Brian, Dave, and Steve,
I'm right on the money.
I mean, I think these are topics that are of interest to you,
and I hope they were useful.
We always try and feature some smaller companies
that we think are doing interesting things.
So I appreciate Cater and Randy sharing with you as well.
And Gus, for you and your team, always do a great job.
And Sanjay Makwan, who kind of invented this conference,
sends his regards.
He's off on the West Coast.
So let me try and set the stage here for you
a little bit with a story.
When I first started work, I had a chance
to meet a gentleman who had been the house
doctor, the medical doctor, at the American Stock Exchange.
I met him because I was cutting his grass.
So I started at Bell Labs.
Pay wasn't all that great, so we found these ways
to augment our income, what high tech means.
But the guy was rich.
He was old, and he was rich.
And I cut his grass, and I always
wanted to come up with some excuse
to go in and talk to him about investing.
Then he had some kind of a tip or something.
Eventually, finagled my way in and talked
to this old gentleman.
And he went through these basic principles.
And I remember, this is like in the early 80s,
he said, and if you apply these principles, blah, blah, blah,
it's something about data networking.
And I should have listened, right?
I mean, I don't know why I wasn't listening.
I didn't have any money, but I probably
would have made quite a bit.
But that image of somebody from one generation
kind of applying a set of recommendations
based on their learnings from generation A,
the things going on in generation B.
I remember him saying, oh, there's
all this dizzying stuff, the computers and software,
doing investing, all this stuff.
But there's still these basic principles.
That stuck with me.
And for me, it was a message that made a lot of sense.
Because I grew up in a family where
trying to take the lessons of one generation
forward is very natural.
Even in my own home, my wife's dad is 95.
He lives in the house with us.
And it drives you crazy a little bit,
but it's nice to have the kids sort of see
one generation's wisdom, so that World War II generation,
the wisdom come forward.
Now, we're in a time, as a computing and networking
community, when the pace of change is kind of dizzying,
right?
How many times in the last couple weeks
have you been in a meeting where you feel kind of inadequate,
because you're just not really following?
I'll go, and people are explaining something to me.
And I'm nodding, and I'm going, well, I
don't know what you're talking about.
It's just really, really, really difficult.
So you're laughing because you've had the same experience,
right?
I mean, it's one of the problems.
And when we were sort of thinking about,
we wanted to do a panel for today.
And I thought, well, who could we invite?
Wanted to think about maybe inviting
some people who had some deep insight into what
was going on.
And I grew up in a computer science family.
So my dad had an early PhD and master's.
I grew up around all these folks who
were sort of providing wisdom on computing
based on a number of things.
We couldn't really come up with a list
that I thought was satisfactory, at least
to people who were still around.
So what we decided to do was maybe suspend belief a little
bit and try something a little different.
So I hope you'll kind of go with me on this.
This is going to require that you just kind of loosen
the collar a little bit and kind of go with it.
I think it's going to be fun.
I suspect that at times you'll probably
be laughing a little bit.
And with that, I think what we will do
is get our panel started.
Our first guest was born on December 9, 1906,
in New York City.
She's been called the Queen of Software.
During a very successful career in the military,
she rose to the rank of Rear Admiral,
became one of the first pioneers in computer science,
was one of the designers of the Mark series of computers,
and played a key role in the development of programming
languages, most notably COBOL.
Her incredible achievements in computer science
have ensured her place as one of the most
influential and pioneering individuals in our field.
Ladies and gentlemen, please join me
in offering a warm welcome for Rear Admiral Grace Hopper.
How are you doing?
Delighted to be here.
You look so good.
Thank you so much for having me.
Thanks.
You know, I knew Moore's Law would take us very far,
but this is beyond my wildest dreams.
You were correct.
Why don't you have a seat, and we'll
introduce our next panel member.
Our second guest is a man I've admired for many, many years.
He was born on May 11, 1918, in Far Rockaway, Queens.
He studied physics at MIT and Princeton,
and eventually went on to teach at Cornell and Caltech.
His work in quantum mechanics and particle physics
earned him a Nobel Prize in 1965.
I'm certain that many of you remember in graduate school
trying to make sense of subatomic particle behavior
by drawing Feynman diagrams.
I know I did.
During this impressive career, he
worked on the development of the atomic bomb,
and is a member of the panel that
investigated the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster.
Ladies and gentlemen, please join me
in a warm welcome for Dr. Richard Feynman.
So you made it out?
I made it.
I wouldn't be anyplace else right now.
Appreciate it.
Thanks for coming.
I really want to know how you got us here.
We'll tell you later.
I can't wait.
Why don't you have a seat?
Your next guest is really going to impress them.
I think you're right.
Why don't we go to our next panel member?
Last, but by no means least, our third guest
was born on March 14, 1879 in Ulm, Germany.
He completed his doctoral degree in Zurich, Switzerland in 1908.
During the ensuing five decades, he
reshaped the very manner in which
we all think about physics.
His greatest insight was his recognition
that Newtonian was not entirely correct.
And this led to the formulation of his special theories,
which may be the most beautiful works of science
the world has ever seen.
Ladies and gentlemen, please join me
in welcoming the one and only Dr. Albert Einstein.
You made it.
I think that's possible.
Why don't you have a seat?
So I told you we'd have an interesting panel here for you.
Folks, on behalf of all the guests here in Middletown
and people watching on the internet,
I want to welcome you to 2011.
It is remarkable.
But I'm even more impressed that mankind
has managed to make it this far.
And that, Professor, is one of mankind's greatest achievements
to date.
We still haven't blown ourselves up.
But what I need to know is how you got us here.
Because we've established that you were all here.
How did you get us here?
Was it quantum chaos?
The arrow of time.
Did you use a DeLorean?
Regardless of how they did it, it
proves that there are no limits to what
great minds can accomplish.
And we recently met a few of your great minds
here at AT&T.
I had a feeling that you'd be interested in that question.
We'll get to that later.
But we had some fun yesterday.
I had our guests come and visit with some
of the folks in AT&T Labs.
I had them kind of visit and tour some of our data centers
and talk to some of our research scientists.
We brought a camera crew along, as you would expect.
And why don't we take a minute?
Why don't we run the video?
I think you folks will enjoy it as well.
Oh, I can't wait.
That's awesome.
You know, Barbara Lang and Dan Rubin and the team
put an awful lot of time into the video.
As you saw the earlier video when we started the conference,
I hope you enjoyed that.
I think the videos really play pretty nicely.
For those of you who are interested,
we'll be popping that and also the earlier video
up on YouTube later today.
So you can have a look.
And I'm guessing you might enjoy taking a look as well.
Well, that was the most fun I've had in a long time.
Wasn't that fun, Admiral Grace?
Yes.
I must admit, that was very enjoyable.
We met some great people.
And I learned a great deal.
But Dave, one of your computer scientists,
told me something that was very surprising.
You've already run out of the more than 4.3 billion
unique IP addresses.
That so?
That's true.
Well, I think you'll be fine with IPv6.
It gives you, I believe, 340 undecillion addresses.
That should hold you over for a while.
That's 10 to the power of 36.
You know, Admiral Grace, she loves those big numbers.
I do.
And I'm pleased to say that you seem
fully prepared for this considerable transition.
You know, it's nice to hear you at least suggest
that we're ready for that.
It's going to be a big problem and something that we'll
certainly try to solve.
So I think what we'd like to do is maybe take you
through a number of issues.
We've got some things that are current to this group.
And we're very interested in your collective thoughts
and your ideas, and maybe suggestions
on how we might approach certain problems.
That make sense?
Is that OK?
Yeah, let's do it.
So one of the first ones is something
that our first speaker alluded to.
Has to do with cyber warfare.
This idea that potentially technology
might be, in some sense, turned against sort
of the goodwill of scientists and kind of the user base.
And this idea that perhaps from a societal perspective,
certain types of technologies and inventions
that we've come up with may actually
be used in a military context and from a warfare perspective.
Professor Einstein, I know this is something
you've thought quite a bit about.
What advice do you have for us on this issue of cyber warfare?
Well, first I would like to talk about the late, great Alfred
Nobel.
Now, as you may recall, he was the man
who invented the most lethal explosive known
at that time, dynamite.
And when he realized the implications of what
he had done, and to ease his own personal conscience,
he set up a group of awards for the furtherance of peace
and humanity called the Nobel Prize.
Now, I personally understand this.
What you'll see in August of 1939,
it was I who wrote the letter to President Franklin Delano
Roosevelt. I wasn't crazy about him.
I liked his wife.
And in this letter, I explained that we had discovered
properties of uranium.
And this, of course, led to his starting the Manhattan Project,
which led to nuclear weapons.
So I understand how Nobel felt.
Now, what you must now ponder are the implications
that we have now wired the entire world for computer
and network systems.
And this could lead to misuse, either deliberately
or accidentally.
We were wise to worry about it then
in the beginning of the nuclear age.
And you are wise to worry about it today.
Fair point.
What about Commander Hopper?
Any thoughts on this issue of cyber warfare?
And from your perspective, you've
got a military background and computing background.
Certainly.
Well, first of all, one of the primary objectives
of a successful military campaign
is to take away the enemy's ability to communicate.
Now, with the internet, everything
is connected, computers, power, telephone,
which leaves us very vulnerable.
If you can't communicate, you can't really
function as a cohesive unit.
So what's the solution?
I think you can't overestimate the importance
of global cooperation and standards.
People of good faith and conscience
must be brought together to minimize
the risk of damage to critical infrastructure.
This has to become a priority as you continue
to develop these capabilities.
Yes.
Science never stops advancing.
And so technology evolves.
And as you continue to relentlessly innovate
and create, as you've done at a staggering rate since 1988,
might I add, you must focus on the protective elements
of cyberspace.
You know, I learned during our visit
yesterday that security research has slowed in recent years
due to many scientists being lured
into businesses, including startup groups that
offer more money than academia or research.
Well, got to laugh.
Need to know more back story on that one.
Well, to me, that's an unfortunate and potentially
dangerous trend.
You know, you need to really integrate and infuse research
on protection and security with energy and excitement
and funding.
Cybersecurity needs to be an integral part of progress
in technology, not an afterthought.
I agree with you in this pursuit.
You know, you must realize that one of the reasons
we have been able to so far avoid nuclear destruction
is because we have always realized
that it was in our best interests
to be universally, globally rational.
So this debate, I think, that we hear frequently
about cyber warfare.
I think Scott put it well earlier this morning
when he suggested, in many cases,
we don't really know what cyber warfare will be.
But one of the main reasons I wanted
to ask the three folks here this question
is not so much that I think their answer
gives you a particular insight,
but that I think there's probably some basic elements
of our history that we need to do a better job applying.
I think you heard Commander Hopper reference
global standards and cooperation
and kind of mutual self-interest.
Never talk about that in the context of computer security,
right?
We tend to talk about other things.
And I think there's quite a bit to be learned
from our three panelists.
I appreciate your thoughts on the first topic.
Now, the second one, I'm guessing you would expect
coming from someone at AT&T,
it's about mobility and wireless.
I think, as you saw during your visit yesterday,
pretty astounding changes and pretty cool gadgets.
I see Professor Einstein,
you've got something in your hand there.
I love this iPhone that you gave me yesterday.
It's a little complicated,
but do you think I could take it back with me?
You know, we thought about it.
We went and looked at the terms and conditions
and you're kind of unique scenario here.
I'm not sure whether it would necessarily make it with you,
but we can certainly try, I presume.
It'd be hard pressed to find a wifi connection
in Princeton in the 1950s anyway, Professor.
You're right, you're right.
Fair enough.
So on this issue of mobility, Commander Hopper,
any thoughts on just in general,
the idea of how kind of mobility and other types of devices.
I mean, in your career,
you've had a lot to do with the advancement of computing.
What are your thoughts on this?
Wow, the widespread adoption of all of these devices
and the miniaturization of computing is a wonderful thing.
By the way, did you know that the very concept
of nanotechnology was first introduced in 1959
in a lecture given by our very own Dr. Feynman?
What was the title of that lecture?
Admiral Grace, you're embarrassing me.
It was called, there's plenty of room at the bottom.
Yes.
Indeed.
I mentioned that because I happen to have a copy
of that lecture here.
My new friend Dave was kind enough to pull it from the web.
We Googled it.
Google, Google, I like that word, Google.
Sure, sure.
Sounds a little like Google.
It's similar.
Yeah.
So, you said, I want to build a billion tiny factories,
models of each other,
which are manufacturing simultaneously.
Very inspiring words,
considering that the latest CPUs are capable
of more than 150,000 MIPS.
That's million instructions per second.
1,170 million tiny transistors
packed in a 45 square millimeter size process.
Well, we've only scratched the surface.
I agree.
See, back in 1949,
I began work on what was known at the time as UNIVAC-1.
Now, when I first saw it, I was scared to death.
It's 29,000 pounds
and only capable of 1,900 instructions per second.
To imagine the advances in computing power
from that computation engine to these mobile devices today
in just 60 years, it takes my breath away.
Does all the intercontinental communications
still go through the full farm
in Lawrenceville, near me, in New Jersey?
I think that that bottleneck was resolved
in the 60s, 1960s.
So, that's not how the architecture worked.
Well, consider by way of comparison
that the automobiles of that era
could still be operated today.
A car built in the 1950s-
Or a DeLorean.
Could still be driven down the modern highway today,
but you would never use a Mark IV to compute today.
That would be unthinkable.
I never learned how to drive.
I find it too complicated.
It is complicated.
And another achievement that is unique
in computing today is the network.
I learned from the engineers
that AT&T has seen a 5,000-fold increase
in data traffic on the network in just three years.
It's true.
This is unprecedented.
Very, very true.
Commander Hopper, we'll come back
to the original question.
I'm sorry, we've gone round and round.
I've not even addressed your question.
Cloud computing, yes?
Yes.
It was first introduced to me yesterday
by the AT&T scientists.
I think it is a marvelous approach.
In fact, it reminds me so much of the mainframe.
The model is the same.
Centralize the administrative support with experts
and minimize the burden on end users.
This is precisely the motivation
behind my early work in programming languages.
So, might I dare to say that cloud computing
is definitely on the forecast?
Oh, that's a good one.
Thank you, Professor.
Anyone in software development should begin planning
for this transition.
Start to consider how to move your applications
to the cloud today.
Or get it on Rally if you don't.
It's a good callback.
Yes.
I think that in doing so, you're doing a great service
to your company or agency and your customer.
So, I'm sure the marketing folks at AT&T
are scribbling away that we've got Grace Hopper
essentially putting her stamp of approval
on cloud computing.
But one of the key issues and something
that we've talked about as we prepared our questions here
for our three guests is that we're at a dizzying pace
in terms of advancement in technology.
But I think we just need to kind of get over it, right?
We need to recognize that it was probably just as dizzying
in 1940 and 1950 as it is now.
And if you graph it forward, chances are
that when our youngsters are off in our positions,
it'll be the same rate of pace.
So, if we know that it's happening,
we just kind of have to get used to the new normal.
From a security perspective, I'm kind of struck by the fact
that an awful lot of what we do in security
seems to be solving the problems of today
as opposed to solving the problems we're moving toward.
Kind of where the puck is going,
that's where you want to skate.
And I think that that's something that our three guests
have certainly reinforced, particularly Ms. Hopper,
I appreciate your comments.
So, third issue, something that's very much on the minds
of many of us, particularly with the mobile devices
that we use, is that this original concept
that we referred to as hacking,
but I think it was sort of in its original incarnation,
it was this mischievous kind of joy around technology,
this curiosity about how things work,
much like Professor Feynman read about
in some of your books.
Which are still available today.
I encourage you to go out and buy some of my books
and my relatives can maybe get some residuals.
It'd be great.
I'm sure that can be arranged, right?
But the idea is that this original sort of conception
of hacking has morphed into something different.
Now we see criminals and individuals
with a much more malicious intent,
perhaps even to include warfare type things,
but more typically theft and other types of crimes.
Wanted to get sort of your thoughts on that.
Is that something, I don't know if Professor Feynman,
is that something in your own career?
I know you're very familiar with that joy of exploration
and we all, many of us were attracted
to computer security because of that.
What do you think?
Well, first thing to me, the unfortunate thing
is how the use of the term hacking
has evolved over the years to encompass criminal activities.
To me, those people are not hackers, but simply criminals.
And the unfortunate thing is how they've not only robbed us
of a great deal of valuable data and assets,
but also of the term as well.
You can say that again.
Let me tell you a story.
Back in the years leading up to World War II,
I spent a great deal of time at Los Alamos
working on the big project.
It was during this time of all times
that I learned that people are sloppy
when it comes to security.
Now, back in those days, locks on safes
were not as well designed as they are today.
When you open a safe, the dial did not rotate arbitrarily,
but rather stayed in the last digit of the sequence.
Anyway, using some clever deduction
and some sneaky investigation,
I was able to get the safe combinations
of everyone on my floor
and left little notes in there for them.
So here's what I would do.
Because you have to have fun with this.
So I would get up and I would call everyone around
and I'd say, I can crack safes.
And I would get a stethoscope.
And I would, shh, be quiet, Feynman is working.
And I would listen.
Of course, I had already figured out their combination
because it wasn't that difficult to figure out.
And I would pretend to crack the lock.
And they'd be, oh my gosh, Feynman can crack safes.
And that would fool them.
It was so much fun.
Nuclear secrets, no less.
Yes, at Los Alamos, at Los Alamos.
This isn't a, it's not U-Haul, it's Los Alamos.
I mean, seriously.
But anyway, I eventually had got to the point
where I realized the military brass
needed to be aware of these risks, of course.
So I went to some of the more senior persons
and let them know about my process.
And so instead of increasing security awareness
or training, what did they do?
They told everyone to keep Feynman out of their offices.
They blamed the hacker.
That's shameful.
It is, it is.
And look, I believe that a healthy curiosity
for science and engineering,
along with a mischievous dose of delight
at how things operate, is essential to be a good scientist.
And I think it is a downright disservice
that criminals have robbed honest hackers of this pleasure.
You know, that's an important point
because with this crime comes,
I think, a community belief
that the idea of penetration testing
or trying to break something
is always going to be of some sort of a malicious origin.
I know when somebody's working on my car,
I hope that they've at least broken
three similar engines before
so that they'll have a better understanding
of how the thing works.
I ride the bicycle.
I know.
That's right.
There's some very famous pictures
that survive to this day
that we all have on our walls
with you on a bicycle.
Do you have any pictures of me on your walls?
We have this one on our wall.
I like that one.
It's a very nice one.
Perhaps we can send it back with you.
But at any rate,
the idea of hacking
kind of as a joyous kind of curiosity,
I hope that we can recapture that.
I know when I first started,
when we wanted to learn how something like Unix worked,
we hacked.
You broke the thing.
And it was just kind of a given
in the engineering community.
You know, nowadays,
that concept has kind of gone by the by.
We need to bring that back.
And I appreciate your story.
What a wonderful story.
Now, we've got a few questions
that we've gotten from our group here
from the audience.
And the first one is for Admiral Hopper.
Our understanding is that the term bug,
something that unfortunately we use way too often
in this community,
is a term that you actually coined.
What were the circumstances of that term?
Yes, I'll tell you.
It was an actual bug.
In the earliest days,
we had relays on our computers
and the contact portion of an important relay
was not working.
So I took a closer look
and I saw that there was a moth creating the problem.
A bug, that's funny.
I guess back in those days,
debugging consisted of this.
That's exactly how we fix our software today.
That's pretty much the same.
You're gonna slap him?
Pretty much the same approach.
But as we use that term,
unfortunately we'll probably have your image in mind,
Commander.
Second question for Professor Einstein.
Came from one of the members of the audience
asking about the intelligence of scientists today
and whether there's really any chance of us
ever comparing with the incredible creativity
you saw in physics,
say from 1900 to 1930.
There was a period of time,
I think George Gamow called it,
30 years that shook physics
and you were a big player then.
Was there something special about that time
or something?
Can we ever recreate that?
And is it possible in computing
that we can ever have that kind of an era
with that kind of creativity?
Or maybe we're going through it now.
That's a good question.
And of course what I want to say is,
yeah, we were just smarter.
But no, that's not true.
We were not smarter.
We just didn't have the tools that you have today.
We didn't have search engines.
We didn't have super computers
to do our calculations for us.
We had to do it by hand,
with our minds,
and a blackboard.
But today things are much more complex.
For example, the problem of more than,
in nature of more than four space time elements in nature.
So I think overall it evens out.
You remember.
Of course I do.
I believe it was the principle of least action
in quantum mechanics.
Well, you see, back when I was a student at Princeton,
about 24 years old at the time,
Professor Einstein attended my very first seminar
where I presented my thesis on quantum mechanics.
Well, you see, I live on Mercer Street.
It's not that long walk.
I just walk up there, please.
I mean, I get nervous when there's a girl in the room.
And Einstein was at my first seminar.
It was crazy.
Do you remember what it was you said to me at the time?
Of course I do.
It was just last Friday for me.
That's a good point.
So what did he say?
Oh, he said that when a mouse observes.
Does it change the state of the universe?
You've done very well, my boy.
Very well.
Thank you.
Well, we think so too.
We think so too.
So next question for Professor Feynman.
Goes back to the hacking question.
I know a lot of people feel very connected to you
from a hacking perspective.
Your book, Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman
is enormously popular amongst computer security enthusiasts.
So we learned quite a lot from that.
But there's a story that is sort of relayed
in the question here about somebody goes in
and finds a utopia, but breaks into everything
and shows everybody the inherent vulnerability
in this utopia and suddenly the utopia goes away
and what you're left with is everything under lock and key.
And the question is, is that quote unquote hacker
in some sense doing a disservice
or really is it a service in pointing out
these vulnerabilities?
Like, is that a good thing or a bad thing?
That's a key issue as we move into mobile security.
Well, that's a good question.
First of all, to me, utopia is Middletown, New Jersey.
This is a lovely place.
I think it's Princeton.
Great minds can disagree.
It's definitely not Iowa.
Well, it's such a good question, Ed, thank you.
Times have changed and look,
an unauthorized hacking into systems
that do not belong to you is against the law.
Even if the intent is to make the owners
of the system aware of their flaws.
It's kind of like trying to break into someone's home
to sell them a security system.
The minute you step onto their property
and pick that lock, you've broken the law.
Absolutely, so the short answer is no.
Hacking is not acceptable,
but I think it is important that we keep the spirit
of the hacker alive, especially in organizations
whose duty it is to secure computer systems and networks.
Always look for the weak link or the flaw
and you'll naturally discover better ways to secure.
Furthermore, individuals who have a talent
and a passion for hacking should be allowed
to use those talents in a productive way.
I say, put them on the payroll.
I think you're probably right, that's a fair point.
Now a question, maybe a last question for each of you.
Based on what you saw yesterday with the folks in the labs
and some of your interactions today
and certainly our discussion,
what would you say is the biggest change
that you've seen from maybe your era to present times?
Amanda Hopper, maybe we'll start with you.
Lots has changed, Ed, lots.
But I'll tell you what hasn't changed.
We always search for answers.
We're always looking for a better way of doing things
or a new discovery, so our potential is limitless.
That is very comforting.
Professor Feynman, what do you think?
Well, to me, one of the things that really stood out
is during my visit yesterday,
after talking to a number of the scientists and researchers,
they told me that many of their sons and daughters
aren't pursuing careers in science.
This was surprising to me because the U.S.
has always been sort of at the forefront of such things
and now I understand that India and China
are sort of rising up in those areas.
I think that portends well for them
and we'll see what it says about us.
I think that's true.
I think that we certainly celebrate
what our friends in other countries are doing,
but here in the U.S., I think your points are well taken.
Professor Einstein.
There is no question in my mind
but that the biggest change is in communication.
You now have instantaneous access
to information and computers and networks.
This is amazing.
In my time, things were much slower.
For example, how do I get most of my information?
It's called the United States Post Office.
Every day, I get hundreds and hundreds of letters.
I receive so much mail
that the postman installed a great big mailbox
right in front of my house just for me.
Now, my dog, Chico, is very smart
and he doesn't like the fact that I get so much mail.
A lot of it is worthless, you know.
So every day when the mailman comes,
he tries to bite the mailman.
I think you could say that Chico
is the original spam filter.
To be serious, this explosion in communication
has truly changed mankind.
If you look at totalitarian states,
they do not want to see the flow of information
to their people.
They try to cut this off
because you see, when people learn things,
learning leads to understanding
and understanding hopefully will lead
to peace and freedom.
It is my belief that had the internet existed in 1939,
World War II might never have happened.
It is impossible to demonize people
you know and understand and respect.
Absolutely profound, certainly appreciate it.
You know, I wish we had a longer time with you.
There's so many things I'm sure we'd all like to ask,
but you've all written extensively, hint, hint,
and I think there's quite a bit to be learned
by going back through your writings.
I know when I received my PhD,
the present my parents gave me
was Professor Feynman,
your three-volume lecture series on physics.
Oh, that's wonderful.
Yeah, I remember.
They bought it new and not used.
They bought it new.
Oh, good.
They bought it new.
Good, that's important.
But on behalf of all the folks here
and those watching on the internet,
it's been my pleasure, my honor to speak with you.
Appreciate your comments and thank you very much.
Thank you.
I think I can speak for my two colleagues
that that was a great deal of fun to be here
and it means a lot that you bought our books,
my books and everything.
And I was wondering if it's possible
that maybe we could come back at some point in the future
and check on your progress.
We could probably arrange something, I'm sure.
Okay, let's get something down in stone then.
How's your May 18th in 2036 looking?
Oh, check my iPhone.
I'm sure it's gonna be fine, I'm sure.
Wonderful, it's a date then.
I'm gonna try and work something out.
So now tell me though, how did you do it?
It was kind of all of the above.
That's a whole jumble of-
Including the DeLorean?
Not the DeLorean, but we appreciate you coming.
Absolutely wonderful seeing you all.
Thank you.
Yeah.
Good job, wonderful.
Thank you.
Appreciate it.
Thank you very much.
Thank you.
Thank you so much.
Thank you for having us.
Thank you.
We go now?
Yes.
We're gonna watch a short video.
Thank you.
When did Richard Feynman die?
I want you to see that.
I need to see that.
I'll tell you what the line was.
He said,
so the line when we all started clapping,
he said, when did Feynman die?
I'm not gonna tell you.
So look, the reason we brought them here
is that I thought it made sense to remind all of us
that sometimes the answer,
the problems that seem so current and so new
and so kind of, you know, forward thinking,
like cloud and all these things
kind of lie in our history, right?
I mean, you heard Grace Hopper allude to the fact
that mobile devices accessing cloud infrastructure
kind of look just like computer terminals
accessing mainframes, right?
Same thing, really very, very similar.
So I think it probably makes sense for all of us
to take a moment and maybe go back and look for answers
in some of their great writings.
If you have not read Richard Feynman's book,
surely you're joking, Mr. Feynman,
get on Amazon or whatever your favorite site is
for buying books, buy it and you'll thank me.
It's just a delightful read
and the lessons for computer security are so obvious.
And ditto a lot of the things that Albert Einstein wrote,
some of his essays out of my later years
are almost carry the answers to questions
that were posed by Scott earlier this morning.
So once again, I appreciate you all coming today.
Hope you enjoyed the couple of talks.
We're gonna take a little break
and what you can do is if you're interested,
at break, our three guests are gonna be out at a table
with pictures, you can get your picture taken.
They'll stay in character, but don't ask something too hard.
Because it took a lot of talking to get there.
We said we're gonna have about 400 computer scientists
and engineers come up and they all turn green.
We said, don't worry, people will be kind,
but you can get a picture
and you might have some fun with them.
And we'll come back for our afternoon session.
I think you'll enjoy the poster session, so take care.

