Welfare vs Warfare: The Battle Keir Starmer can’t afford to lose
Jul 24, 2025 #Keirstarmer #Politicians
Thank you very much.
The front line, if you like, is here.
Welfare, not warfare!
You're the Labour PM that wants to be known for creating a warfare state.
Did you come into politics to cut benefits, sir?
But you're not putting your money where your mouth is.
It's not the Labour Party I have voted for.
Armies fight battles, countries fight war.
They've been for ages.
Ed Miliband, are you comfortable with the welfare cuts?
Did you sign it off? You're not happy about it, are you, sir?
Did you come into politics to cut benefits, sir?
What did you think when you initially heard
the government were trying to slow the growth of the bill?
I was cheering them on.
Millions of people who could work, trapped on benefits,
denied the income, hope, dignity and self-respect
that we know good work brings.
So the only game in town in the short term is welfare reform.
And taxpayers paying millions more on the costs of failure.
And if you tackle it,
it doesn't just make the Chancellor's life easier,
better for the economy,
and actually it should be better for the individuals involved.
So I really wanted the government,
and still want the government, to succeed on this.
My friends, my family are very angry about this
and they do not think this is the kind of action
that a Labour government takes.
I'm going to take you back to 2006.
Are you OK with that?
Yeah, I can kind of remember it.
The fact is the SNP are now a novelty that has worn off.
I mean, you were pushing through the 2006 welfare reform bill.
You were a Blairite moderniser.
You had the sort of brown wing of the party,
more cautious, bigger emphasis on social justice.
How do you remember that period and remember that job?
Is it with some fondness or with horror?
I loved the job.
Oh, you loved it? OK.
I loved it.
I was the Minister for Welfare and Labour in a Labour government.
How can you not enjoy being the Minister for Labour in a Labour government?
We should ask Liz Kendal about that.
It's going for her.
Today we take decisive action
and I commend this statement to the House.
We were able to reform welfare, and really difficult reforms,
but it wasn't driven primarily by the need for fiscal savings.
We've got to try to make sure that people who are on benefit
and want to move off benefit and into work, that work pays for them.
This is another world.
There are alternative, more compassionate ways to balance the books.
On every measure, this group of politicians
have everything harder than we ever had.
And I don't envy them the task.
Welcome and thank you for joining us today
here at the Janet Harvey Hall in Govan.
I'm delighted to introduce you to our Prime Minister, Keir Starmer.
A new era in the threats that we face
demands a new era for defence and security.
The topic of defence has become more mainstream in the last few months,
but it's been a burning problem for more than a decade.
The front line, if you like, is here.
The threat we now face is more serious,
more immediate and more unpredictable
than at any time since the Cold War.
Prime Minister Attlee was the Labour PM credited
with creating the welfare state.
You're the Labour PM that wants to be known for creating a warfare state,
but you're not putting your money where your mouth is.
NATO says members should commit 3.5% of GDP
to defence spending by 2032.
And you are not even committing 3% in the next parliament,
an ambition, but you are not committing it.
But let's start with Attlee,
because he led a proud Labour government
that was one of the founding members of NATO.
Of course there are discussions about what the contribution should be
going into the NATO conference in two or three weeks' time,
but that conference is much more about what sort of NATO
will be capable of being as effective in the future
as it's been in the last 80 years.
And that's a vital conversation that we do need to have
and we're right at the heart of that.
There have been a number of moments where I thought,
this is it, this is the moment that we wake up.
I thought the full-scale invasion of Ukraine
had to be that moment.
When I was growing up in the 1970s and 80s,
we knew that we couldn't take democracy and freedom for granted
because we had the Soviet Union there.
And it feels very similar now.
We've had this luxury of what's called a holiday from history.
Our country not having to contend with the idea
of an existential war coming to the home front.
Government and others who are interested in it,
I would suggest, have got a responsibility.
We have to be much, much better at making that argument.
Not just the Labour Party in government,
but all political parties in Westminster.
The public, I don't think, are being engaged on the truth here.
Yeah.
Which is that we now face a foreign foe
against whom we may have to be engaged
in a mass-scale war in our lifetimes.
And the country's not ready for that.
It's armies fight battles, countries fight war.
And that's something that we've forgotten.
Israel launched Operation Rising Lion,
a targeted military operation
to roll back the Iranian threat to Israel's very survival.
The Right Honourable Mark Carney,
Prime Minister of Canada,
and Mrs. Diana Fox Carney.
The Honourable Donald J Trump,
President of the United States of America.
Donald Trump in the White House
adds an unpredictability to the Western alliance.
And he's made no secret that he wants Europe
to do more to defend itself.
Kia has engaged with President Trump
in a way that no other leader in the world has been able to.
I wouldn't quite call it a bromance,
but there's a relationship there.
We've become friends in a short period of time.
He's slightly more liberal than I am, to put it mildly.
We stand slightly on the left.
For some reason we get along.
We make it work.
Mr. President, may I ask you a question?
G7 leaders are calling for de-escalation in Israel and Iran,
but you are the key to unlocking that.
And here I am.
And here you are.
So can I ask you, sir,
have you spoken to Prime Minister Netanyahu?
When might you speak to him?
And what will you say?
Israel is doing very well, as you probably noticed.
And I gave Iran 60 days, and they said no.
And the 61st you saw what happened.
Day 61.
So I'm in constant touch.
It sounds like an American attack could be imminent.
Do you know what's going on?
Well, I don't think you should read into that
that an American attack is imminent.
Thank you very much.
A short time ago, the U.S. military carried out
massive precision strikes on the three key nuclear facilities
in the Iranian regime, Bordeaux, Natanz, and Isfahan.
Lots of people watching you speak this morning
will be very worried about the news overnight
that the U.S. has carried out three strikes on Iran.
Well, we've long had concerns about the Iranian nuclear program
and been very clear that Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon.
It is important that we now de-escalate the situation,
stabilize the region,
and get the parties back around the table to negotiate.
It is a very difficult job.
Well, I actually think this is an area that Keir Starmer has handled very well.
Because Europe has allowed itself to become so weak militarily
and so dependent on the United States right now,
the U.S. is absolutely vital for the rest of NATO
to be credible when it comes to defense.
And the Europeans, they know that.
What was the biggest risk that Keir Starmer faced this year?
It was actually Trump pulling out of NATO.
As generations stood, united against this force.
Because safety isn't a given.
It's something you build together in 1949.
Today is about the unity of NATO showing that strength.
We're bigger than we were before.
We're stronger than we were before.
The safety and security of our citizens in the UK
is my first duty as Prime Minister.
I take that extremely seriously.
And they said, you did it, sir, you did it.
Well, I don't know if I did it, but I think I did.
They need to keep Donald Trump on side to buy time
so that they can rebuild and then stand on their own two feet.
Whether it happens is another matter,
and that comes down to whether societies want to make those painful choices.
What Keir Starmer has done on defence has so far been the right thing.
So much of the time that he's spent with Trump
he hasn't spent with Labour members of Parliament.
And there's a play-off there, and he's done the right thing
in engaging with Trump, because that is strategic.
I followed him around to every Trump meet there has been,
and it has been quite impressive, actually.
And I found it impressive, and I would say that to him.
But do you think that that has meant he's dropped the ball
domestically because he just hasn't had the bandwidth?
While the Prime Minister is rightly focused on geopolitics,
because that has a massive impact on the economy,
our way of life and much else,
I think the rest of his team have got to step up a bit.
Welfare, not warfare!
But Mr Speaker, there have also been real concerns about our initial proposals.
We have listened carefully, and we are making positive changes as a result.
We bleed!
You cut!
We bleed!
You cut!
We bleed!
The ayes to the right, 335.
The noes to the left, 260.
That is still quite a chunky rebellion.
Disappointed, not surprised.
I'm... yeah, I'm fed up.
We're just feeling really, really flat,
really let down by MPs and Parliament.
We're used to feeling like that.
I despise them.
I voted for them.
This is not the Labour Party I have voted for for the last three decades.
PM, your first year anniversary has been marked by self-inflicted shambles over welfare.
You've U-turned on your reforms.
Your MPs don't trust you.
It's the epitome, isn't it, of sticking plaster politics and chaos
that you promised voters you would end.
We've brought down waiting lists.
We promised two million extra appointments.
We've delivered four million extra appointments.
You were going to lose a vote in the House of Commons.
Are you just in denial?
You've totally ignored my question.
No, I'm not, and we didn't get the process there right,
but if we're looking at the entire year,
if we look at all the things we've delivered, and I was...
The reason that the welfare bill effectively collapsed
was because it was made on the basis of fiscal arguments
that the Chancellor needed to find £5 billion.
I think we need to make the moral argument
that the way our welfare system works at the moment is immoral, frankly.
Did you find the way in which they did it, they staged it, frustrating?
At that point, did you think, you're screwed here, you're not going to get that passed?
Look, at one level, I don't mind Members of Parliament saying,
I don't want this reform.
I don't mind that.
But they've got to find other reforms that save money,
because you can't spend the same money twice.
I was massively frustrated, massively disappointed,
because the risk is that the consequence of that
is that we get trapped in a doom loop
of ever higher taxes and ever lower growth.
But politics is a team sport,
and more of the team have got to step up.
For this government, we are now at a fork in the road.
The country, the markets will really worry
that we are going to drift for the next three to four years.
The problem they have is they've got the bond market on one shoulder
and they've got President Putin on the other.
But if they can show that they are actually capable
of taking difficult decisions,
selling that to their own backbenchers
and putting the country back on track,
then whichever political party you're from,
I think we will welcome that.
And I hate saying it,
because no Labour politician comes into politics
to cut welfare, schools or other budgets,
but on the basis that defence is non-negotiable.
Everything else, unfortunately, may face those cuts.
So for you, if it came to welfare versus warfare,
you're clear where the money needs to go?
I think President Putin gives us no choice.
Our Prime Minister, like other Western leaders,
is facing up to a new reality that the era of peace is over.
We're on a war footing and Europe must rearm.
And that's why the debate over welfare versus warfare
is a much more profound discussion,
because it's not just about political choices,
it's about a profoundly and radically changing world
and what the essence of leadership really is,
because the duty of any Prime Minister,
first and foremost, is to defend the realm.
But the problem Sarkis Starmer has
is that many of his MPs don't want to make that choice.
They want more spending on warfare and welfare,
even as the economy slows.
And so now the government finds itself in an unenvious position
of having committed more money to defence spending,
now finds himself with an unexpected black hole
in the public finances,
after his MPs rejected cuts to the welfare budget.
Now the conversation is moving instead to tax rises.
But that just delays a problem unresolved
for a government that's having to have a generational rethink
in what it means to fund defence
and also how to fund a welfare state.

