What Is Human Nature?

Why We EXIST?
14 followers
1 Video View·Jul 23, 2025
What is “human” nature? While human beings are animals, we believe we are special, radically different from other animals. Why? What traits are unique to humans? Are we sure? How to explore human nature from an evolutionary perspective?
Featuring interviews with Quayshawn Spencer, Alexander Rosenberg, Massimo Pigliucci, Rachell Powell, Helen De Cruz, Paul E. Griffiths, and John Dupré.
I am haunted by my own existence.
I am a human being.
But in the great scheme of things in the vast cosmos,
what are human beings?
Perhaps accidental and incidental
without point or purpose.
Perhaps goal-directed and central
with a cosmic point or purpose.
If incidental, can we make our own point?
If central, can we align with the cosmic point?
While it is not for me to answer these big questions,
perhaps I can address my opening, smaller question,
what are human beings?
What am I individually as a human being?
What are we collectively as the human race?
Both questions reflect a common theme, human nature.
Is there even such a thing as human nature?
Special traits that all human beings have in common?
If so, how does human nature
differ from the natures of other animals?
Is human nature unique?
If so, what makes it so?
What is human nature?
Hi, I'm Robert Lawrence Kuhn,
and Closer to Truth is my journey to find out.
How to explore human nature, the nature of Homo sapiens.
How to get an overarching perspective.
Biology and psychology seem the default sciences,
but how to integrate all the information,
see a big picture.
How to see the forest of meaning from the trees of data.
I wonder if philosophy can help, a philosophical perspective,
a way of thinking that applies analytic rigor
to the problems and puzzles in biology and psychology.
In other words, visualize human nature
through the lens of philosophy of biology
and philosophy of mind.
I begin with a philosopher of biology,
an expert on the philosophy of race,
Quaishon Spencer.
Quaishon, as a philosopher of biology,
how do you look at human nature?
I'm a fan of the heavily genealogical approach.
These are the phylogeneticists.
And the way that they understand a species
is a phylogenetic species,
where you have a monophyletic group of organisms.
This is an ancestor and all of its descendants.
It's like a very tight family of organisms
that is either sustained by a deep sort of divergence
or a isolating mechanism.
So I would define Homo sapiens as the phylogenetic species
that's immediately descended from Homo gastroincestor
and Homo neanderthalensis.
Now, something that falls out of this way
of thinking about humans
is you're adopting something called relational essentialism.
This is a paradigm of thinking about unary properties
as being the essential properties of species.
So these are just sort of properties
that you have all by yourself versus relational properties,
properties that you have in relation to something else.
And if you make all your essential properties
relational properties, you can solve a lot of problems
in taxonomic classification.
And so this seems to be the right way forward.
But then what you get rid of is thinking about humans
as some sort of instantiating certain stereotypical traits,
like speaking a language or being bipedal
or having large brains.
From the phylogenetic point of view,
all those traits can fall off,
and you still have the monolithic group.
And that's because you're doing it in a relational way?
Yep, in relation to the ancestors and your siblings.
Hmm.
But what are the implications of that?
Well, the implications are that you start to think
about the properties that we stereotypically associate
with humans, like we're intelligent creatures,
we're linguistic creatures,
as being contingent properties, not necessary properties.
These are properties that might be universal
at a certain point in history of our species,
but they could not obtain in our species.
And still maintain.
And you can still be the same species.
So there's no biological essentialism in the species?
It's all relational?
There is. These are...
It's just a different way of thinking about essence.
So I'm thinking about essence as the thing
that makes you what you are.
Your identity conditions.
Not anything thicker than that.
They could just be relational properties.
And so what, then, is the distinction
between humans and other animals?
It's counterintuitive,
but there aren't any essential different traits.
Species can survive their traits
from this phylogenetic perspective.
This is part of the phylogenetic turn in conceptual thinking.
Kuishon has human beings, like all animals,
as phylogenetic species,
defined genealogically by connections
with ancestors and siblings.
He takes a deflationary view of human nature.
There are no essential human traits,
in that all species can survive the loss of any of their traits.
Is this gradualist, non-exceptionalist approach
to human nature a good starting place to explore further?
I take it further with a strong reductionist,
a philosopher of biology with interest in philosophy of mind,
Alex Rosenberg.
What Darwin taught was that everything comes
in this nice bell-shaped curve.
Height is the obvious example, right?
The medium height is what?
Among Dutch people, it's six foot two.
Among us, it's five foot 11, or something like that.
If every interesting biological trait, hard-wired trait,
comes in a nice bell-shaped curve,
then what we can say about human nature
is only that it's a matter of what the median
and the standard deviations are,
and that the extreme ends, tails,
are always going to be with us as a result
of the constant recombination of the genome,
even of the individual organisms that are very close to the mean.
And therefore, the idea that there's a human nature
in the sense of a set of traits common and peculiar to us
seems to be a non-starter
from the Darwinian biological point of view.
Since there isn't human nature, humans are not unique.
Right, and so if you describe traits for other primates,
OK, our distribution is going to be quite distinctive
compared to others,
but is it going to be in the same ballpark?
Roughly.
There are some traits, of course,
that humans have that other primates don't.
Language, and the artifacts
that language has enabled us to produce.
So it's certainly clear as a way
of distinguishing us from other species,
there isn't much controversy or difficulty, OK?
But that difference is, again, going to be a matter of degree,
maybe very substantial degree,
but still always a matter of degree.
And there's no gap?
No, I don't think there's a gap.
There are some differences that are so striking
that they demand explanation.
So, for example, we humans, even from the earliest ages,
have the property of cooperative intentionality.
You give a little baby a ball, right?
You throw it at a ball, at the baby,
and the baby will throw it back to you, right?
Because the baby already has a theory of mind in operation,
treating you as an agent with whom they can interact, OK?
Whereas chimpanzees, even bonobos, OK,
they can't seem to do that.
And that looks like at least a particular,
relatively low-level, simple behavioral trait
on which a lot of human differences
with other organisms, other primates, have been built,
that we need to find out the basis of.
And if science eventually teaches us
that the basis is some kind of step function change,
like Chomsky's recursion, OK,
then we're going to have perhaps another basis
for that distinction between us and other species.
So there's something where it looks like the beginning
of something that, if it isn't human uniqueness,
is at least a big enough difference
to be more than merely a gradual increase.
By defining all animal traits as bell-shaped distribution curves,
Alex has human nature on the same spectrum
with the natures of other animals.
This resonates with his reductionism
and reinforces the view that human nature is not exceptional.
But then he hesitates on language.
So, could human nature be somehow special?
Are there other philosophers of biology,
while still in every way physicalists,
who see human nature as distinct?
I ask a philosopher who was an evolutionary biologist,
Massimo Piglucci.
It's interesting, when I talk to my colleagues in philosophy,
they really have a sort of knee-jerk reaction
against the whole idea of human nature.
And I think the reason for that
is the idea of human nature is often being linked
to genetic determinism, you know, biological determinism.
And that position is not very popular in philosophy these days.
And when I talk to my biology colleagues,
they tend to emphasise the continuity
between human beings and other animals.
My position, I guess, is very different.
I mean, there is a human nature,
and we're damn different from everything else on the planet.
Now, are we different in the sense that we have something unique,
that it's us and only us?
I don't think we have.
Probably not, with the possible exception of language.
But I don't think we need something unique.
Sometimes a quantitative difference is large enough
that for all effective purposes, it becomes qualitative.
We are certainly quantitatively smarter
than, say, other mammals, other social mammals.
But that quantity is so large
that we went to the moon and they didn't.
The same goes with the use of tools.
Animals use tools.
Well, yeah, but look at the tools.
You're not going to get much done
with the tools that a typical chimpanzee uses.
Some animals have culture.
True, but again, that kind of culture
is nothing compared to what we're talking in terms of humanity.
Now, what about human nature?
Every animal, I think, or plant or living organism
has a nature in the sense that
there are things that I can tell about that species
that are characteristic of that species.
You get a cactus, for instance, and there is a cactus nature.
Among other things, it means that even though it's a plant,
it doesn't need a lot of water
because otherwise you kill it, right?
And so, therefore, cactus nature is different
from the nature of another plant.
The same goes for human beings.
We do have a nature,
meaning that there are certain things
that are species typical or species normal
that are different from, let's say,
the equivalent traits in a bonobos or in a chimpanzee.
I don't think there is anything magical about that.
The ancient Stoics got it close to right.
They focused on two aspects of human nature
that they thought were particularly informative.
One is our ability to reason.
Again, other animals possibly have that ability,
but we have it to a much larger extent.
And we are highly social.
Again, there are other social animals, of course,
but human societies are far more structured
than anything else on the planet.
Massimo comes down hard that there is a human nature
and that we are different from other animals.
If so, how so?
Certainly, he invokes no spooky stuff,
no spirits, no souls.
How, then, did human uniqueness happen?
I put the question to a philosopher of human evolution
and the natural history of mind, Rachel Powell.
The most obvious sort of thing about human beings
compared to, say, other primates
is that they're extraordinarily cooperative,
whereas other primates can be quite hierarchical.
Humans have these deep egalitarian sentiments.
They have these incredible abilities to share.
How does that help explain human success?
And so a lot of people think that it's human morality
that really has underpinned human ultra-cooperation
and that that's what's really giving us
the best explanation of human success.
But here's where I would want to kind of push back against that.
So if you're thinking about why humans are so successful
and so ultra-cooperative compared to other primates
or other vertebrates, you're going to be talking
about the evolution of moral capacities
that allowed humans to cooperate in various ways,
to cooperatively forage, to cooperatively brood.
But here's the interesting thing.
Those same ultra-cooperative capacities,
though lacking in all of the vertebrates,
are present in the social insects
and have been around for a lot longer
than they have for human beings.
I mean, humans evolved these capacities in the last eye blink.
Social insects have evolved them, you know,
for millions of years,
and they are equally profoundly impactful
on global ecosystems as human beings are.
So what you're saying is that cooperation
is necessary but not sufficient.
Well, so we know that cooperation is important
for explaining success.
But here's another example in the social insects
where you have these ultra-cooperative capacities
that don't require the kind of higher cognitive,
moral capacities that we normally think
were critical for human beings.
And so what I'm interested in is the ways in which
human societies and social insect societies
have converged on a kind of social normative capacities
that then underpin these ultra-cooperative functions.
To explain human nature,
Rachel combines the evolution of social cooperation,
exemplified by social insects,
energized by the human capacity
for language and cultural accumulation.
The evolutionary theories are all well and good,
but is there evidence in the archaeological record?
I ask a philosopher of biology and mind
who has a second doctorate in archaeology and art,
Helen de Kruis.
Human evolution tells us something about ourselves.
We want to learn more about ourselves,
and that's why we look in the past
and we project our own ideas onto the past, right?
So you had, like, in the 50s, 60s,
you had the idea of man, the hunter,
or you had the idea of the sort of, like, murderous apes.
Then you had the idea about, like, you know,
peaceful humans who lived in communities.
So you have to be always cognizant
that looking at the archaeological evidence,
that we sort of read into it, in part,
what we find interesting about ourselves
or how we conceive of ourselves.
Nonetheless, I do think that we can learn so much
from paleoanthropology that it really tells us something
about who we are today.
The idea is briefly this,
that at some point,
a spectacular change occurred in human evolution.
And all of a sudden, we all started talking
and making art and making complex tools.
But I think that a lot of the work
of African Middle Stone Age cultures,
and particularly also very recently in Indonesia,
in Sulawesi, have sort of overturned this idea
of cultural modernity into something more gradual.
So initially, there was the idea
that even though humans were anatomically modern
at least 100,000 years,
and now maybe as much as 300,000 years,
that cultural modernity was much more recent.
And so the evidence for that was like the great rock art
in France and the sculptures in southwest Germany.
But now we see a sort of more gradual picture.
So anatomically modern humans have gone out of Africa
a lot earlier than we thought.
And they also started doing these things,
making art, making beads, for example.
You have beads in Morocco and in the Levant
of about 135,000.
There's also all this recent work on Neanderthals
established that, yes, Neanderthals could do this stuff
before they met anatomically modern Homo sapiens.
So there is the very concept of a creative explosion
has to be sort of nuanced.
There is a more gradual picture of,
and that doesn't make it any less spectacular.
I think that even so, it's still interesting to ask,
like, why did humans, why did Homo sapiens make art?
When we then look at what really matters,
when we want to see what is really and truly human,
we say it's art.
Helen calls upon paleoanthropology,
especially with respect to ancient art,
to evidence the unique evolution of human nature.
Now, assuming that human nature is distinct,
what is its scope?
I put the question to a philosopher of biology
who applies systems theory to evolution
and biological development, Paul Griffiths.
Human nature is such a problematic idea.
It's got this long history of being used
to distinguish between human beings who are really human,
who are the correct expression of our real nature,
and other inferior or different people.
But we can't do without a notion of human nature
if we believe in the possibility of learning about human beings.
So, we have all these human sciences.
We have economics, sociology, anthropology,
and they all purport to tell us something
about what human beings are like.
And they seem to do that with some degree of success.
So, it must be the case that there's things we can say
about human beings that are reasonably true enough of the time
that they're really worth knowing.
And so, my long-term collaborator, Karola Stotz,
and I like to call that descriptive sense of human nature.
Descriptively, human nature is just what people are like.
And what are they like?
Well, they're diverse,
but they're diverse with some regularities and patterns and limits.
And so, that's a very unproblematic notion of human nature.
You might even wonder whether it's worth calling it human nature.
Because the other thing that people have traditionally wanted
from human nature is an explanation
of why human beings are the way that they are.
So, your nature is something inside you.
It's why you're human rather than a dog or a cat,
because you've got human nature
and they've got dog nature and cat nature.
And there's this idea that you can more or less
perfectly express human nature.
And if you don't get it right,
you're kind of a bad representation of what you really are.
You have somehow something wrong with you.
So, we think it's possible to have a kind of underlying
explanatory notion of human nature like that
without any of those problematic overturns.
So, what Stotz and I argued is that we will understand human nature
when we understand human developmental biology
and human developmental psychology.
Then that will explain both the things
that are broad generalisations about people.
It will explain the diversity of people
and will help us understand why that is.
So, for us, a theory of human nature
is a theory of human development,
and it embraces both what's distinctive about human beings
and how diverse human beings are
and how they're different at different times in different places.
If there's one thing that's unique about human beings,
it's their variation, how varied and diverse they are.
And that's because of the variation and diversity of human cultures.
We are continually innovating in the way that we live
and the way that we bring up our offspring,
and that creates a continuing change,
continuing development in human diversity.
Everything in biology is continuous, right?
Nothing comes from nothing.
But when you look at those phenomena in other species,
they are very marginal,
whereas for humans, they're absolutely at the heart
of understanding us as a species.
And what's the potential cause of that in humans?
It's cultural transmission.
To Paul, we will understand human nature
only when we understand human development,
biological and psychological.
In other words, we cannot understand human nature statically.
We can understand human nature
only dynamically, developing over time.
Does this mean there is some kind of special property
in human development that makes us human?
I ask a philosopher of science who sees evolution
as pluralistic principles
and where process is fundamental, John Dupre.
I don't believe in there being some property
which makes us human that we can somehow find
has some really wonderful and special, unique importance.
I do think we're a unique species,
but one of the reasons I think so
is I think we are uniquely plastic,
which, of course, is to say
our developmental outcomes are uniquely variable,
and this is obviously at odds with the idea
that we follow some developmental path
determined by human nature.
One of the ways in which this makes us actually unique
is that it facilitates an absolutely unique division of labour
in the human species,
and I think it's one of the things that we know
but usually forget,
and I think particularly because of the way it relates
to the very dominant ideologies of individualism
that we've lived with.
So we tend to think that...
I sit there here feeling how pleased I am
to have understood the nature of life so well,
but, of course, my ability to do so
has been made possible by the fact
that countless other people have provided me with food,
housing, clothing, heat, transport, paper.
You know, the list goes on and on,
and I go into this because I think it diverts, in a way,
from what is unique about the human species,
which is our extraordinary ability to cooperate.
So where does that come from?
It comes from our plasticity,
our ability to develop all kinds of different skills
which no individual could encompass within their lifetime.
And so that plasticity came through biological evolution
of the brain in some way?
Yes, I think it did.
I mean, whether it was the individual evolution of the individual
or evolution at a higher level, cultural, social evolution,
but, of course, the biological side of it
was the gradual decrease of biological determination
of our developmental outcome,
the skills that we were able to obtain.
I mean, clearly, if you look at the other end of the living world,
at, say, insects,
often what you find is very stereotyped behaviours,
a very limited range of behaviours
that every member of the species,
more or less in the kind of genetic determinist model,
sort of unfolds.
We're just not like that at all.
What the human uniqueness is largely about,
the ability to cooperate,
and to cooperate by many different individuals
acquiring many different skills.
I remain haunted by my own existence,
trying to discern human nature
to address what it means to be human.
Here are some ideas.
A phylogenetic approach privileges the genealogy of ancestors
and siblings and denies essential human nature traits.
All animal traits, including all human traits,
are distributed along the same spectrum,
each with its bell-shaped curve.
Human nature is not a distinct kind or category.
Human nature is real, and humans are unique,
especially our capacity to reason and social structure.
Human nature combines social cooperation
with language and cultural accumulation.
Ancient art provides evidence for the gradual,
though no less spectacular, development of human nature.
To understand human nature,
one must appreciate human developmental biology,
which embraces the distinctiveness
and the diversity of human beings.
Human uniqueness comes from the capacity to cooperate.
I've been looking at human nature from the outside,
a third-person perspective.
What if I'd look at human nature from the inside,
a first-person perspective?
Would I be any less haunted?
Would I be any closer to truth?
For complete interviews and for further information,
please visit closertotruth.com.
