Alfred Marshall's "the Seen and the Unseen" - Explained by Milton Friedman
One of the great economists of the 19th century was Alfred Marshall, and he has as a sort
of motto for one of his books, The Seen and the Unseen, and it's a marvelous motto for
this.
What happens in economics over and over again is that there are two sets of effects of any
action, the immediately visible effects and the widespread invisible effects.
And the widespread invisible effects are often much more important than the visible ones,
but people don't see them.
Let me give you very simple examples.
We have a quota on the amount of sugar that can be imported from various countries.
The visible effect of that is that there are about a couple of hundred thousand growers
of beet sugar who benefit greatly from it, who are able to keep on growing beet sugar.
They don't benefit so greatly because most of the money goes into paying the expenses
of growing the beets, and indeed if there were no such quota, they would find something
else to do.
But who believe in the short run, appear, the visible effect is that they are able to
have a market they would otherwise not have.
The invisible effect is that every consumer in the United States pays twice as much for
the sugar he or she buys as the world price.
Now you're a consumer, how much attention do you pay to the fact that you pay twice
as much for sugar as you ought to?
Is the fact that you pay twice as much for sugar as you ought to going to lead you to
go down to Washington to testify against the sugar quota?
But are the beet sugar farmers going to go down to Washington to testify in favor of
the sugar quota?
It's a typical example of the seen versus the unseen.
The concentrated visible versus the dispersed invisible.
And the major reason why roughly half the income of this country is controlled by governmental
agencies instead of by the people who earn it is because of this contrast between the
visible and the invisible.
We talk about a majority government.
It is a majority government, but it's a very funny kind of a majority.
It's a majority made up of a whole bunch of minorities.
You've got one-tenth of one percent of the people who are beet sugar growers.
They're part of this majority.
You've got another two-tenths of a percent, maybe one or two percent of the people who
are in the textile industry, and they make us pay twice the world price for shirts and
for other things because of textile tariffs and the textile agreement around the world.
And so down the line, you've got all these special interests.
You've got labor unions.
You've got these and those.
Each one separately is a little minority, but they all get together.
Each minority is more interested in its own little problem than in what happens for the
rest of the country.
And so it's willing to give its vote to the other things if they'll give it.
It's a case of log rolling.
So what we have is a log rolling majority in which the majority of the people are not,
in fact, represented.
Is there any doubt in your mind?
Suppose you were able to get an effective poll from the people at large on this question.
The government imposes quotas on the import of sugar.
The result of that is that X thousand farmers are able to grow beet sugar who otherwise
would not, and that you are paying twice the world price for sugar.
Are you in favor of this?
Is there any doubt in your mind that a majority would say they're opposed to it?
Let me give you another example which is much more important and much more dramatic.
Of course, the most socialized industry in the United States is the military.
But next to the military, the most socialized industry in the United States is schooling.
Nine out of ten youngsters leave for a moment, the colleges and universities aside, although
it's true for them, too.
But let's stick to elementary and secondary schooling.
Everybody recognizes that over the course of decades, the amount of money that's going
into that in real terms after adjustment for inflation has been going up per student very
sharply.
And everybody recognizes that the quality of education has been going down.
There's not the slightest doubt.
All socialist enterprises are the same.
If you take them in Europe, whether you take them in Russia, in Poland, in Czechoslovakia,
or in the United States, socialized enterprises produce poor quality products at high prices
but confer special benefits on small groups.
That's a characteristic.

