Three MASSIVE Warship Design Failures

Warship And Aircraft
72 followers
In 1939 the Royal Navy was outfitting its newest class of destroyer when it became clear that
something was badly wrong. The ship was leaning to and fro at its fitting outwarf and hadn't even
reached the open ocean yet. At sea it would probably completely capsize and roll over.
There was a serious issue that had gone surprisingly unnoticed during the design phase
Designing functioning warships capable of operating in all kinds of conditions
is extremely difficult, and it was historically a complex process with many moving parts.
Of course it still is, it's just that now we have computers.
It was easy for simple mistakes to sneak in, some which would just require redesigns,
but others which would prove fatal. This is the story of three such ships.
The British destroyer escorts that couldn't stay upright,
the German battleships that plunged into waves like submarines do,
and the Japanese torpedo boat lost in a storm that uncovered a huge design flaw in almost the entire
fleet. Ladies and gentlemen I'm your friend Mike Brady from Warship Designs and these
are three bad warship design failures.
In the late 1930s the British Admiralty was preparing for an impending war with Germany
because at the time it seemed like an inescapable likelihood. If a war broke out the burden of
defending Britain's coasts and trade would fall to the world-famous Royal Navy, so much effort
was put into upgrading warships and phasing out older types wherever possible. By the late 1930s
Admiralty had realised it needed two completely different kinds of destroyers. These handy
warships were like a Swiss army knife, they were capable of doing many different tasks,
but some would need to be specialised to accomplish specific roles. The Royal Navy
needed destroyers for fleet work, that is serving alongside warships to engage enemy
fleets in open ocean. They prioritised speed and a heavy torpedo armament. By contrast the
Royal Navy also needed modern escort destroyers. These were smaller and easily mass manufactured.
The escort destroyers would protect the slow vulnerable merchant convoys from enemy U-boats
and surface warships as well as aircraft. In the First World War this type of warship was called
a sloop and not a destroyer because a sloop is not designed for big fleet deployments but simple
convoy escort work. They were typically slow, no faster than 20 knots, when most fleet destroyers
could steam along at 30 or more, but they were cheap and they were useful. In late 1938 a
specification was issued for a fast escort ship to help out with convoy duties. It had to be about
a thousand tonnes, achieve speeds of about 30 knots and be kitted out with a powerful anti-aircraft
armament. Crucially though they also needed to be easily mass manufactured and cheap to produce.
Rather than start from scratch and with the outbreak of war looming dangerously close,
the admiralty design team under the naval architect Sir Stanley Goodall took the recently
introduced HMS Bitterne, an escort sloop, and decided to base their design off of that. The
plan was to use Bitterne as a basis and upsize her to create a new larger more powerful class
of convoy escort warship. Now if that were all the design team had to accomplish it wouldn't
necessarily be a problem but as always bureaucracy crept in. The new class of ship would be expected
to lend a hand in fleet actions as well if necessary, meaning they would also need to be
fast. The design team got to work. The new ships would be called the hunt class. First Bitterne's
design was slightly lengthened from about 266 feet to 278 feet and her beam was narrowed from
37 feet to 28 feet 10 inches. A greater length and narrower width or beam would make the ship
faster through the water. On top of this the draft, which is the amount of ship below the
waterline, was reduced from 8 foot 5 inches to about 7 foot 9 inches. Now hopefully this is
ringing some alarm bells for you already because surprisingly apparently it didn't do so for the
design team. When equipped with powerful Parsons turbines outputting some 19,000 shaft horsepower
the hunts should have been able to achieve speeds close to about 30 knots. As part of their escort
duties the hunts would need to protect from German aircraft. They would need a heavy anti-air
defense armament and seakeeping behavior that would make it easier to aim the guns. The first
part of that equation was easy enough. For main armament the hunt class copied HMS Bitterne.
They would mount three turrets each with a pair of four inch dual purpose guns for a total of six
guns. Now the hunt class had their anti-air armament the designers went to work ensuring
they could aim them easier. A ship's designer can actually influence just how much the ship rolls in
the water. We've looked at this on the channel before. It has to do with the ship's metacentric
height. For a ship designed to engage aircraft like the hunt class was a long slow roll would
be better than a quick snappy one. If the ship was rolling slower and more predictably it would
make the guns easier to aim so the hunt class needed a low metacentric height. Now this was
calculated with complex mathematics by the design team and even checked by Sir Stanley himself. But
off the bat Sir Stanley had his reservations. In his daily diary he wrote that he felt the design
team was quote poor and they might need more supervision but in the rush to rearm and upgrade
the royal navy in the face of a war Goodall's remit was completely overloaded with projects
that all required his attention and sign-off. Unfortunately it meant that several obvious
signs that the hunt class would be a disaster went unnoticed all the way from the drawing board
to construction. Upsizing a ship's design like that of the bitten class sloop is actually quite
difficult because it means all the careful calculations that were made to ensure the
stability and good sea keeping need to be done and done again. The first hunt class ship HMS
Atherstone went down the slipway in December 1939 and was completed ready for duties in March 1940
but tests showed some alarming behaviors. Before even putting to sea at the fitting out wharf it
was found that Atherstone was dangerously unstable which was a serious serious problem because the
first 20 hunt class ships were already ordered and under construction nearing completion. Atherstone
with her anti-air turrets mounted high up seemed likely to capsize in anything more than a moderate
sea. Something had gone terribly wrong. The complex mathematics required to calculate the
ship's center of buoyancy and its rolling motion had taken the design team some time to calculate
but somewhere somebody had made a mistake in their math. Basing the hunt's design on the
bitten class sloop meant concessions would need to be made and in the quest for more speed it
should have already been setting off alarm bells that the hunt class would be required to mount
a heavy defensive armament high up on the superstructure while also being significantly
narrower than the bitten class. Early on Sir Stanley had actually caught wind of this issue
and he figured that the beam would need to be increased. Before Atherstone the first hunt class
ship was laid down the beam was increased by nine inches but clearly it wasn't enough. To account for
the additional heavy guns and the need for a specific metacentric height to provide a stable
platform lots of calculations were done around the predicted vertical center of gravity. In fact
so much mathematics were done for these ships that each new design ended up with its own class book
of calculations. This was full of formulas and information that was checked and signed off by Sir
Stanley Goodall but it seems like he, the design team and even a second independent calculator
brought in to check the figures missed a simple error. In calculating the predicted center of
gravity a figure of seven feet was given from the keel to the upper deck instead of the actual 17
feet. This meant that a huge amount of weight was emitted from the equation from low down in the
ship. Thinking they had more to play with the designers essentially stacked more weight up on
top and didn't realize they were too light down at the bottom of the ship. The independent checker
should have caught this but they didn't. Instead they just copied the figures, the final numbers
lined up, the calculations looked right and the design was approved. A year and a bit later the
hunt class ships lulled in the water pathetically without even going to sea. So with a dud series of
ships the admiralty design team got back to the drawing board. Clearly not much could be done for
the 20 or so hunt class ships that were already completed or underway. For these ships known as
batch one, one of the three four inch gun turrets was removed, the funnel's height was cut down and
some of the superstructure around the bridge was removed giving the ships a leaner silhouette. No
less than 50 tons of cement were poured in to the bottom to provide additional ballast and weigh down
the ship below. Now that would do for the first lot but it was far from ideal. The ships had needed to
carry a full battery of six guns not just four. The admiralty design team caught their error.
The hunt class's beam was increased from a mere 28 foot 3 inches to 32 foot 6 inches.
The simple change to the ship's width ensured all six guns could be fitted as intended.
In the end 86 hunt class ships were built. They did a fine job during the war but the
inglorious start to their career was an avoidable embarrassment. It can probably be chalked up to an
overworked design team trying to get a design through as quickly as possible with the best of
intentions and then a senior overseer like Sir Stanley who was just as overworked and preoccupied.
But while Britain was preparing to face the might of the German navy it turns out that the Germans
were making some design blunders of their own. If there's one thing that can be said for German
warships it's that they are extremely pretty with their long sleek silhouettes. But it was exactly
this quality that early on meant many of Germany's battleships and cruisers functioned more like
submarines than surface warships. In the early to mid 1930s Germany was hurriedly rearming its navy
pouring hundreds of millions of marks into replacing the grand fleet it had lost following
the first world war. The resultant surface warships actually took a lot of internal design
cues from first world war ships as far as armor layout and things like that but essentially they
were designed for close range engagements in the Atlantic and North Sea and especially for hunting
down allied merchant ships and convoys. Early on the surface warships were given relatively small
caliber main guns. The famous pocket battleships like Admiral Scheer were designed as a kind of
heavy cruiser but in 1935 Nazi Germany committed to building proper battleships with the sisters
Scharnhorst and Gneisenau. These were formidable modern fast battleships that mounted nine 28
centimeter or 11 inch guns a small caliber as far as battleships go but one ideal for picking apart
merchant ships. The real secret to their success was their speed an impressive 30 to 31 knots
thanks in part to the immensely powerful triple steam turbines outputting some 160,000 shaft
horsepower but the speed was derived from that power plant coupled to the hull shape. The
battleships were long and narrow a hull form ideal for cutting through the water like a hot knife
through butter. It would make the pair a deadly duo able to engage and disengage the enemy at will
attack a convoy with impunity before escaping quickly into a developing rain squall if the
resistance proved too dangerous. They would be quick. Another aspect of the ship's design to
enhance their speed through big seas was their bow shape which featured a straight stem. The stem is
the very front of the ship and it gives the bow its shape. In the glory days of the ocean liner
back in the late 18 and early 1900s designers had toyed with a variety of shapes for their stems in
the ever-growing quest for speed. Cunard Line introduced Mauritania and Lusitania in 1907
with very straight stems. A straight stem differs significantly from a raked stem which introduces
an angle to the bow. An angled or raked stem essentially provides more bow structure meaning
there is more buoyancy simply more ship to float. It means that a ship with a raked bow is more
likely to ride over the waves comfortably as the raked stem and bow is lifted by the ocean
but a straight stem by contrast has less buoyancy. It means the ship will cut straight through a
wave and maintain its speed. Lusitania and Mauritania with their straight stems could
easily cut through massive Atlantic swells and maintain their fast record-breaking crossing times
but they also exhibited some strange behaviors. One of my favorite stories is from the Mauritania.
The straight stem gave the ship a weird tendency to drop suddenly underfoot something that
occasionally startled passengers. Once her captain dressed up to the nines for dinner went quickly to
bridge to check that all was well before heading below when suddenly in the face of a big wave
Mauritania's bow dropped and the wave rolled up the bow crashing over the bridge wing dousing the
captain completely in seawater. Designers back then used to account for this loss of buoyancy
forward with an emphasized shear that is an exaggerated angle on the ship's deck. As the
bow narrows the shear line flicks up dramatically providing once again simply more ship structure
to float and prevent any unwanted dropping by the head. Scharnhorst and Gneisenau were each
designed with straight stems to emphasize their speed. In fact most of those early Nazi German
surface warships were including the pocket battleships and even the modern heavy cruiser
Admiral Hipper. Scharnhorst and Gneisenau went for their sea trials and they sure were fast
but then their bows started dropping into the sea. The straight stem meant that there just wasn't
enough buoyancy for the ship to ride over waves which to be fair is exactly what the designers
had wanted. They wanted their ships to cut through the waves instead but with such low sleek hull
forms there was barely any freeboard that is to say barely any ship above the waterline to begin
with. Lusitania and Mauritania had tall hulls it meant that they could deal with the heavy seas
even with a straight narrow bow but Scharnhorst and Gneisenau were the opposite and even worse
they had relatively little shear to account for it. They shipped tons and tons of water over the
bow when the sea was up and waves were bigger. With the forward decks awash the sea water found
its way through ventilation ducts and hatches to flood the inner workings of the bow and cause
short circuits in wiring around the first gun turret. Now this was obviously not okay and it
became pretty obvious that some serious modifications were needed. Scharnhorst and Gneisenau were both
held up while their bow section was redesigned. The old straight stem was cut away and a new raked
shape was added instead. The anchors which had sat in horse pipes on the side of the hull were moved
to sit up on deck because with decks awash they were likely to be ripped away. The new bow came
to be known as the Atlantic bow and it turned out the Scharnhorst and Gneisenau weren't the only
ships that actually needed them. The surviving pocket battleships like Admiral Scheer had their
bows replaced so did the brand new heavy cruiser Admiral Hipper. Then the famous Bismarck newly
launched was given one too but her sister ship Tirpitz didn't have a completed hull yet so she
was actually launched with the new raked bow installed. For Scharnhorst and Gneisenau the
fix didn't totally remedy the issues but it did enough to prevent serious flooding.
Now they rode the waves a little easier instead of sinking under them but it was still common
in heavy seas for the ships to travel with their forward gun turrets traversed to point backwards
to prevent damage to the gun barrels from any unusually large waves. The fact was they had such
little freeboard and such a shallow shear line they would be doomed to ship water over their
bows for the rest of their careers. To be fair this problem wasn't unique to the German battleships.
Other warships from the time including allied surface vessels became known as wet ships for
doing the same thing but for the Germans the issue was serious enough as to require a full
redesign and refit for most of their big surface warships. Germany's little bow shape problem was
irritating to be sure but it wasn't a fatal design error and unfortunately the same cannot be said
of this next ship. It was a design and a very unfortunate incident that would go on to expose
a whole fleet of modern warships and the fact they had some inherent design deficiencies.
During the course of world war one the allies comprising the UK, the US, France, Italy and Japan
had all built up impressive naval fleets but immediately after the war there was concern
amongst the allied powers of the potential for a naval arms race as this momentum continued
and that would prove costly for countries already reeling from the expenses of war
and unpopular with the public who were clamoring for peacetime. In an attempt to appease the public
and slow further progression towards this arms race the Washington naval treaty was signed in
1922 among the major allied powers. As part of this treaty limits were placed on the size and
weight of future warship construction in an attempt to keep any one navy from outclassing
the others but where the other signatories saw an agreement to equalize their navies,
Japan instead saw loopholes. In an attempt to circumvent the limitations imposed by the treaty
the Imperial Japanese Navy or the IJN came up with the idea to build vessels that were too
lightweight to be considered legitimate members of that category as per the treaty but then outfit
them as heavily as vessels twice their size. By doing so they were still bulking up their naval
power using smaller scale versions of the vessels that they had been producing for the war without
sacrificing on the firepower and therefore without technically violating any terms of the treaty.
Enter the now infamous and illegal torpedo boat the Tomizuru. Tomizuru weighed in at only about
600 tons but was positively overloaded with complex and heavy gun systems. Her high center
of gravity also led to serious stability issues in rough seas. Now it's rather easy to imagine
how such a design may cause structural problems and we now know these issues would sadly prove
fatal. In what would become known as the Tomizuru incident in March of 1934 during a routine
nighttime torpedo exercise in rough weather radio contact with the Tomizuru was suddenly lost.
Initially it was assumed to be the result of power loss or radio failure but 15 minutes later however
Tomizuru's lights were completely dark. A search and rescue mission would find the Tomizuru capsized
floating completely upside down some 10 hours later. The ship was ultimately towed to shore
while 16 men somehow managed to survive 100 sailors including the captain sadly perished in
the disaster. The Tomizuru incident was ultimately attributed to the myriad design flaws present on
the ship. The structure was horrifically top heavy fitted with far too many heavy guns and munitions
for the ship's comparatively small size. Munitions were also fully loaded at the time of her capsizing
which had not been the case during her sea trials and this also contributed to an even greater
instability than originally feared and with all of these factors taken together combined with the
unfavorable weather conditions the Tomizuru had been completely unable to keep herself upright.
As a result of the incident a committee was established by the IJN to identify weaknesses
across their entire fleet. Many vessels like Tomizuru had been designed with the exploit of a
loophole in mind and they were summarily declared to be unseaworthy. A total of 14 vessels were found
to have potentially catastrophic stability issues and these issues were summarily addressed and
corrected. However this incident would ultimately prove to be a scandal for the Japanese navy
delaying the construction of new vessels for several crucial years while they sought to correct
the errors in their present-day fleet. Guns were downsized and reduced in number, deck heights were
lowered and excess equipment was removed whilst bulges and ballasts were added to the hulls of
the ships for stability. Whilst the Japanese undoubtedly believed their design concept was
clever and that it would allow the freedom to build up their naval force while also circumventing
limitations created by the Washington Naval Treaty, in reality these concepts would have
fatal consequences that sent shockwaves throughout the nation. Inevitably they learnt from their
mistakes and the loopholes in the treaty were later closed as a result but it was too little
too late for the hundred men lost in the Tomizuru incident. History's pages are filled with badly
designed warships from those that sank on their very first outings to those that fell victim to
poor planning and cooperation. Join us next time here on Warship Designs when we explore more of
history's most dramatic warship design failures.
