Where is your separ (shield)? The positioning of a shield in Persian swordsmanship

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
13 Video Views·Jul 21, 2025
Good morning and welcome back to Arasmufsar TV.
Yesterday we had multiple requests to talk about the position of the shield.
That's why we titled this, I titled this, where is your shield?
First of all, there is a reason you have a shield in fighting.
It could be the shield, it could be a Qameh, a Khanjar, a card.
When you have a Qameh, Khanjar or a card, this is obvious.
It should always be in line next with your Shamshir.
You know, imagine there is a reason I have a secondary weapon.
Because shield is also for punching, shield punches is used.
And this means that your secondary weapon should be in line.
Now I'm in the middle guard, this is in line.
And I'm pushed asaba behind the shield.
I'm in the middle guard, I'm in front of the shield.
In front because this leg is here.
Look how I close my guard.
Behind the shield, in front of the shield.
And look how I close them, not like that.
This is an invitation to be cut.
I teach my students to keep like a scissor.
You see that?
Then it's going to be here.
So they always learn.
This is a horizontal guard.
So I change it.
Look.
Look how my hands change.
Look at this.
Right?
So.
Once I'm here again.
Right?
So I go and change.
I come back and change.
You see?
If I'm in the middle guard, I always keep that shield.
It does not make sense to have the shield here.
And to have the Shamshir here.
Or here.
Because you're exposed.
Which brings us to a very important fact.
Where is your Separ?
Where is your shield?
Meaning, where is your guard?
Let me show you something.
So you can see on this Persian miniature.
How the middle guard is kept.
Please take a look at how shields.
Now look at this line.
Are there to protect the face.
And how this is the high guard.
Second version of high guard is kept.
So they make sure that they can protect themselves.
Look at this one.
The shield is again kept in the front.
And Shamshir is about Dushna Hodan.
Here in a single Shamshir.
Look at the hand which is down there.
And how the attack is done.
Here you see that how the shields are in line.
To protect themselves.
And the other one.
Which you see that.
Look at this.
How to protect.
Turning towards the opponent.
And protecting it.
Even when it goes to the ground.
Look the man on the ground.
Tries to put the shield between him and his opponent.
Here again you see that shield is in front.
We had this picture already.
This is a certain guard.
Right.
In single Shamshir.
Staying behind the Shamshir.
The same thing.
I'm going to discuss the single Shamshir techniques.
Even on horseback you see that.
How the shield is kept there.
Which didn't help him.
But you see that there are different things.
So it is what I meant with the guard.
In any realistic martial art.
Realistic means combat oriented.
Now I'm not saying that I'm against conceptual martial arts.
Also love other martial arts.
For different reasons.
For concentration.
You don't need always to fight.
For it's like.
You know for concentration.
Doing different forms.
Different Katas.
They also help you.
For your positioning.
For your concentration.
For meditation.
Whatever.
We leave that part aside.
We come back and talk about realistic martial arts.
Let me start with a very basic one.
As you know I wrestled and boxed for many years.
Next to kickboxing.
Also I have my own school.
Imagine you are here.
Realistic martial arts.
I have a boxing guard.
In boxing you see that.
For example if I'm here.
Right.
I do jab.
Jab.
Look how I protect my body.
How I protect my body.
Here a shot here will take me down.
Here a shot.
Here a shot to the heart.
It will be hard for me.
Chin should be tucked.
And then I punch.
You see how I close my guard.
Also sometimes when I.
You know in America.
When I was on the team.
Or university.
You know we go and then.
We punch even like that.
Look how I protect my chin again.
With my shoulders.
So anything is.
Behind all this bobbing.
Reeling.
Anything is based on that.
Between you and your opponent.
There is a guard.
You neglect your guard.
Your guard is gone.
You know sometimes we do like.
Chin open.
Like this.
But then it comes back.
And they go like that.
But.
Always a guard.
You neglect your guard.
Like here.
You are knocked out.
Unfortunately.
In swordsmanship.
There are some people.
Who have not practiced.
Any realistic martial arts.
So they neglect.
The importance of having a guard.
Guys.
Always.
Do that.
Like in boxing.
If you come to Muay Thai.
You see in Muay Thai.
The guard changes.
Or in Kyokushin.
Let's stick to Muay Thai.
Muay Thai you need to protect your hand.
But you cannot do bobbing and reeling.
Because if you do that.
You are going to eat.
Knees.
Or you are going to eat.
Shin kicks.
But still.
You are closed.
So you see.
I check the legs.
And then.
I punch.
I have a more straighter guard.
Because I also protect.
Myself.
With the shin.
If there are American kickboxing.
Without low kicks.
It is more or less.
A bit.
Upright.
But more like boxing.
Again.
There is a guard.
Your first job.
In fighting.
Kickboxing.
Without low kicks.
Muay Thai.
With low kicks.
Boxing.
Is to.
Destroy the guard.
Get rid of the guard.
And land your punch.
You know.
Sometimes we hit in the guard.
To weaken the guard.
But you don't.
Knock him out.
Or knock him down.
So the idea is.
To get the guard away.
Again.
The idea is.
To push the guard to the side.
Like.
For example.
I punch.
And he defends.
He gives me an opening.
Then I come into the opening.
Right.
I punch.
He brings his guard up.
Neglects his leg.
And I do a shin kick.
Same as in Kyokushin Karate.
There are no face punches.
Like in Muay Thai.
But all kicks.
You can grab.
And kick.
The knee to the hand.
You can kick.
You can knock out a guy in the head.
Punches.
Full contact to the body.
Bare knuckle around.
Elbows to the body.
You see.
But again.
In Kyokushin.
Everything.
Guard.
In Muay Thai.
Guard is there.
If you think.
Guard is only.
Ok.
MMA is of course.
MMA you need also to be careful.
That they are not going to take you down.
You know.
Changes in combination.
Of grappling guards.
And also.
Of striking guards.
Now.
If you think.
Only when striking.
Many of you know.
That I started.
Many years.
Greco-Roman wrestling.
If you do Greco-Roman wrestling.
It's the same thing.
You hold.
For example.
The back of the neck.
You hold.
Here.
The arm of your opponent.
You know.
So the idea.
Is to keep.
Between you.
And him.
Your guard.
This is a guard.
You see that.
How they do it.
In Greco-Roman.
And it's very interesting.
Once.
You know.
When I started to do Wing Chun.
It improved also.
My Greco-Roman.
So in Greco-Roman.
Is to get rid.
Of these arms.
Same in Judo.
If I grab the collar.
And grab here.
The gi.
On the elbows.
And then I'm here.
You know.
You need to loosen the grip.
Of your opponent.
Which is in Judo.
Which is a guard.
Then once I.
You know.
Loosen the grip.
I can go in.
And do.
A throw.
Otherwise.
You cannot throw him.
Because he has what?
A guard.
So.
Judo.
Greco-Roman.
If you go to.
Freestyle.
You see.
They are.
Down.
And they also.
For example.
If he wants to go to my leg.
I sprawl.
This is my guard.
I try to hold him.
Check his shoulder.
Sprawl on him.
Freestyle.
Has a guard.
And we also say.
In Persian.
That.
As to guard.
Even in Freestyle.
You need to get.
Through his guard.
So.
Freestyle.
Wrestling has a guard.
Greco-Roman has a guard.
Judo has a guard.
Now.
Let's go to the BJJ.
Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.
Every one of you.
I have been doing it.
Over now.
13 years.
If you do BJJ.
What is the main.
Tenet of BJJ?
To keep.
Someone.
When you are on the ground.
In your guard.
As long as.
He sits in your guard.
He is going to have a problem.
What is the guard in Jiu-Jitsu?
Imagine.
You are on the ground.
Right.
You are here on the ground.
And I keep him in the guard.
When I am in the guard.
I can do different things.
Right.
And I can submit him.
Once he tries to pass my guard.
He has to pass.
Both legs of mine.
And also.
The best is.
Even if he passes this guard.
In Jiu-Jitsu.
You teach him.
You instruct him.
As they say.
The professor.
In Brazil.
Teaches you.
At least.
Between you and your opponent.
There should be one limb of you.
Being.
One leg.
The best is two legs.
And control with the arms.
If he passes one leg.
At least one leg should control with the knee.
Once he passes your legs.
And.
Sits on you.
He passes your guard.
You are going to have.
Huge problem.
So you see.
Passing the guard.
Be it in striking arts.
Or in wrestling arts.
Is a big.
Big.
Huge problem.
Never do that.
Let me explain.
And go back.
To the Shamshian Sepah.
Ok.
We are in Shamshian Sepah.
I explain this middle guard.
Push the Sepah.
Horizontal guard.
Jolui Sepah.
You can also have.
Push the Sepah.
Eye guard.
You go.
You see how.
Eye guard.
Jolui Sepah.
You see how.
My Sepah.
Is always there.
Is not here.
You see.
Someone does that.
This is wrong.
Right.
Now.
There is a principle.
In Shamshian Sepah.
Before.
In this Sepahism.
At least.
Look.
One up.
One in the middle.
If you are forced.
To go down.
I don't.
Recommend it.
To protect here.
Then.
This should come up.
Never.
Both down.
I know.
Some of these.
European.
Sword and Buckler.
Where they both go down.
But this is.
In a bind.
They hold the weapon.
In a bind.
Down.
But then.
Even if they hold the weapon.
Down.
He can shield punch you.
My.
Our idea is.
Once.
You defend here.
Then.
You attack.
To up.
Right.
So.
I defend.
They attack.
Come here.
Normally.
You don't need to go that much down.
You can just pass with your leg.
And attack.
But if you have to.
Right.
This is the whole idea.
Not this.
Right.
This is not only.
Exposing you.
Completely.
But.
Your back and your side.
Completely.
This shows.
A lack of true understanding.
Of a full contact guard.
Or a swordsmanship.
Real swordsmanship.
Back then it meant.
You know what it meant.
Like.
So.
If one goes up.
Down.
The other one.
Is threatening up.
Right.
Always like that.
If I.
Have to defend.
With the back of the shield.
Excuse me.
Shamshir.
And bring it to the side.
Then I can shield punch.
One down.
One up.
Not both down.
Right.
Sometimes.
When you are going.
Up.
I go up.
You see.
We have that.
Trusting here.
I go up.
I can trust here.
Right.
I go to the side.
I can cut.
I go to the side.
Right.
I can cut.
These things.
You can do as well.
These are.
Important factors.
To take into consideration.
Right.
And.
Now.
Let me just explain.
About.
Other.
Styles.
So we.
Know.
What it is.
Many people back then.
Always compared it.
To European.
Sword and buckler.
European sword and buckler.
Is a different game.
First of all.
You have a straight sword.
Not as we use it.
In Shamshir.
We have in Shamshir.
You know.
Different miniatures.
Where even the.
The.
Shamshir comes here.
And the shield is here.
Sword and buckler.
As you know.
The swords fought like that.
They always protect the hand.
Because they don't have.
A boss band.
Or whatever.
And they think.
From this binding.
Which is very interesting.
A straight.
Blade.
And then.
They use it.
They make sure.
That.
Their hand is always protected.
But what do they do?
What does it teach.
And of course.
Because we have like a saber.
Shamshir.
If you want to use.
European term.
Sweeping action.
We have a different time.
But they.
What they have in common.
Both of them.
Keep the guard.
Again.
I repeat.
Keep the guard.
Interestingly.
If you go to.
Caucasia.
Georgia.
And look.
In the beginning of the.
Even 20th century.
Or at the end of 19th century.
There are some pictures.
And some very old films.
You see that also.
They use.
Similar concepts.
As.
Not completely.
But.
You see.
This sometimes.
They also open an attack.
Of.
As if.
Their hands are handcuffed.
Of.
Georgian swordsmanship.
But.
What do you have.
Common with.
Or with.
European sword and buckler.
Again.
They keep.
The guard.
This is extremely important.
If you go to the.
To the Japanese.
Swordsmanship.
You see.
Keeping the guard.
Like in.
Rio.
Like in other.
Swordsmanship.
Keeping the guard.
Is extremely important.
Always threaten.
If you're in high guard.
With the tip of a katana.
Or like here.
Always threaten.
If the guard is gone.
You're going to be cut down.
You're going to lose.
So.
Let me explain.
With a larger shield.
Medium sized shield.
The concept.
Of holding the guard.
Even with a medium sized shield.
Becomes even more.
Relevant.
Because first of all.
It is not.
As fast.
As a.
You know.
It's a medium sized.
As a.
It's heavier.
Than.
And if you go.
Down with that.
And especially.
If you have.
Strong arms.
I do sport every day.
I'm a strong guy.
I think.
And then you can bring it up.
I can bring it up fast.
Still.
There are physical.
Restrictions.
Moving the.
Heavier shield.
Is much more difficult.
So.
There even.
You need to have.
Less.
Movement.
Large shield.
Even more.
Because even your.
Arm here.
The forearm.
Is tight.
Another strap.
Right.
So.
Then.
If it comes here.
Bringing them down.
With a large shield.
Makes even.
Less sense.
Keeping the guard.
With a.
With a big one.
With a.
With a big.
You know.
You see that.
How I.
Keep my guard.
Right.
Is even more.
Important.
In consideration.
Because that's the reason.
You have a shield.
To work with.
So please.
Remember one thing.
Go and box.
Go and do.
Muay Thai.
Do MMA.
Do wrestling.
Freestyle.
Greco-Roman.
Judo.
Do a realistic.
Martial arts.
Let yourself.
Be taken down.
To see how it hurts.
When you get punched.
When you get kicked.
Only then.
You understand.
The mechanics.
Of realistic fight.
When you come to.
The swordsmanship.
Then you have an.
Understanding.
Why.
Keeping the guard.
Is important.
Otherwise.
You will not.
Understand.
Thank you.
Very much.
Imagine.
Now.
If I have a single.
Shamsher.
Or single.
Let's stick to single.
Shamsher.
And if I'm going to see.
I am not a big fan.
Of a single.
Shamsher.
Because of his curve.
But in sometimes.
In miniatures.
It's shown mostly.
Ninety percent.
Ninety five.
Are with the shield.
But even.
If you have.
A single.
Shamsher.
It is even more.
Important.
If you're in a high guard.
Or if you're in a middle guard.
If you're in a.
Horizontal guard.
Is important.
That most of the time.
Ninety to.
Ninety five percent.
You're behind the shield.
Could be that.
I cut.
And it could be that.
I go to the side.
And cut.
Then I come back.
Most of the time.
I am in.
Front.
And if you put your hand.
Here.
Because you have a.
Basel band.
Most of the time.
I am.
In front.
Excuse me.
My weapon.
Keeps the guard.
Like in Jiu Jitsu.
Remember?
At least one limb.
Between you.
And your opponent.
Your weapon.
Is always between you.
And your opponent.
Doesn't make sense.
To be all the time.
Like that.
Or to go like that.
If I'm here.
Then I need to come back.
Immediately.
To.
To the guard.
So keep the guard.
Even if I swing.
Doesn't make sense.
That I go to the side.
Expose myself.
And.
Then I'm going to be.
Cut.
So.
Take this also.
Into consideration.
Even in single.
Weapons.
Especially in single weapons.
So once you have a shield.
Your shield needs to protect you.
Gives you more protection.
Shield is not there.
To go to the side.
