英國皇家軍械博物館 英國皇家軍械庫 MP43-1和STG44的區別
王者风范
22粉絲
10 次觀看·2025年12月8日
Hi guys, Jonathan back once more
With a not that unusual weapon to ask you the question
What is this weapon? You might think
But if you know us by now, you know that we like to throw some curveballs in there
If you don't know what I'm talking about
On social media, we do have a bit of a fun guessing game that ties into this series
You don't have to take part in that
Hopefully the episodes stand alone
But we think it's fun
So there is a thing about this gun
So first of all, what's the generic type?
Just in case you've been living under a rock for the past 80 years
Or just don't know that much about guns
The MP43 slash MP44 slash STG44
So MP standing for Machinenpistole
STG standing for Sturmgewehr
Now that doesn't come on the picture until 1944
There's a whole mess of complication in the middle
And this particular variant is part of that mess
So in broad concept, retrospectively calling it the Sturmgewehr
This is the invention of the modern assault rifle
The true assault rifle, whatever you want to call it
Everything after that, including the famous Kalashnikov
Followed in the mold of a short, compact
Not necessarily that light, but short and compact
Automatic weapon, so a rifle capable of automatic fire
Firing a reduced power cartridge
So this narrow looking magazine here
Is halfway between the very slim magazine of an MP40
The classic German submachine gun
And the very deep, very wide magazine of a full power rifle
Well, like the Mauser 98, the Kar98k
Only that's buried in the wooden stock
Or the G43, self-loading rifle
That came in 1943, hence the name
And that has that very broad magazine
So this becomes a sort of almost technological, ideological war
Going on in the 1940s
Between people who want to stick with full power rifle cartridges
Like .30-06, .303, 7.92x57
The full power German rifle cartridge
And those who see the way forward
By reducing the length of the cartridge
Reducing the amount of propellant inside
And you get much more of a rifle-type bullet
Coming out at significantly high velocity
But not as high velocity
Coming out of a more compact weapon
For use in the assault
So there's a lot of consternation
About the term assault rifle these days
Technically it's not a hugely useful term
But it's colloquially very popular
And it does originate from this German Sturmgewehr concept
A rifle that you can carry forward in the assault
And use like a light machine gun, like a submachine gun
But it has the capability of firing somewhat accurate shots
Out to, say, 300 meters as a rifle
So working back from the present
Almost all modern infantry rifles are assault rifles
And they all owe a debt to this thing
So that's the broad picture around the Sturmgewehr
Originally introduced as the MP43
For reasons that I will come to when we wrap up
Now, of course, we haven't got just any old MP43
For you today we have an MP43-1
So let me first of all show you that marking on the receiver
The other new concept
Well, not brand new
But relatively new concept around this weapon
Was extensive use of sheet steel to keep down cost
Once you've tooled up to make
Pressed or stamped steel receivers, handguards
Well, they were already doing it for magazines
But these more convoluted shapes
Required to create a whole firearm
Required a bit more technological know-how
But once you've done it
You can make a more cost-effective firearm
Not necessarily a lighter firearm
People think thin bits of metal are lighter
Than machined bits of metal
But certainly not always the case
This thing is a bit of a pig
And significantly heavier
Even than a first-generation Kalashnikov
So it's not so much about weight
It's more about cost
So MP43-1
What on earth does that mean?
And why do we have MP43-1
Comes first, confusingly
Then MP43
Then MP44
Then STG-44
And then the story ends
And there are more designations than that as well
By the way, there's MP43-A
There's MP43-B
And the granddaddy of this whole family
Is the MKB-42
Which comes in two flavours
Completely different weapons
One is the brackets W
One is the brackets H
So go away and look that up if you're interested
We won't try and get into that minefield today
Except to say that the MKB-42H
Is the progenitor of this thing
And that whole lineage that I've just outlined there
MKB being yet another period German acronym
Or abbreviation for Maschinen Karabiner
So machine carbine
Which very confusingly is what the British
Called a submachine gun
But the Germans were using it to differentiate
From MP
Which was their submachine gun
To try to cover the fact that this is more of a rifle
It's more of a self-loading slash automatic rifle
So that initial designation made quite a lot of sense
And we have examples of those too
Which we might surprise you with another time
So returning to the main event here
What is an MP43-1
Well, the best way to show that
Apart from the marking, of course
Which does mark it out as different
Is to put it side by side with an ordinary
Although they're not that common
MP43
Let's just confirm that I have in fact
Picked the right weapon off the rack
This is an MP43, not an MP44
Or an SGG-44
Although, as I'm fond of saying, spoiler alert
Those three are all identical
But this is actually a real MP43
So it's the direct successor to the other gun
So let's just take off the magazines
Or this magazine anyway
So I can get them closer together
And we'll try to show you what the differences are
Because these are the only members of this design family
So ignoring the MKBs
That have any meaningful difference
That's associated to their name
If that makes sense
Build standard changes happened
Through the development of the rifle
But the name did not change
The name did change
With respect to these changes that I'm about to show you
I hope that makes sense
So working forward from the middle
Because everything back here is the same
Apart from the name
Note these
Or this
Because I can only show you the one side at the moment
But this rib here
And the fact that there is no rib on this side
That was a sight mount
For a magnified optical sight
So they were already
Early 1943
February, March 1943
Looking at
Having the ability to fit an optical sight
Which is pretty forward thinking
We're already looking at
One rifle to rule them all kind of thing
Something that could potentially replace all the bolt action rifles
If you had self-loading rifles
Those as well
And all the submachine guns
The ability to also mount an optical sight
Doesn't give you a sniper rifle
But it might give you a designated marksman rifle
That is the logic
So the early gun
The MP43 Slash 1
Has
I'll just show you them
Both sides
See what I mean
They have pressed out
So triangular section ribs
Both sides of the rear sight block
And there's also a little notch
Cut in there as well
As a sort of detent
So the sight won't come off
Now the ZF-41 optical sight
Did make a comeback
Later in the development of this
Family of weapons
With a different mount
On the left side of the receiver
But that's a different story
And it's not tied to the changes in designations
So all of the other design changes
Are right at the front end of the rifle
In front of the gas block
So that's this
Big chunky cast component here
Contains the little hole
That the high pressure gas is piped through
To drive the long operating piston
Back and cycle the weapon
Fairly straightforward design
It's just pinned over the barrel
Which has a little hole in it
That's not why we're here
Why we're here is
Firstly the diameter of the barrel
So on the 43 Slash 1
It's a constant diameter
Or a plain diameter
Just a tube
On the 43
Which remember comes after the 43 Slash 1
It's a two diameter design
They have turned down
This bit of the barrel
To a smaller diameter
Why?
You'll see in a moment
Then we have the front sight block
So on the 43 Slash 1
It is wider
And it's also a different design
So it just has a straight edge here
It doesn't have the reinforcement
For the pin here
It is narrower on the 43
Wider on the earlier 43 Slash 1
Ignore the missing front sight protector
That is just something
That was easily lost
In fact in troop trials
There were complaints of this
And I don't think they ever solved it
Because I've nearly managed to
Knock one off myself previously
This is a heavy weapon for its size
And a slight knock on this
Can displace it
And cause it to pop off
So that's the reason
It's missing on the 43 Slash 1
Not because it didn't have it
You can see the grooves
Where it would have fitted
So if you're trying to work out
Whether something is a 43 Slash 1 or not
You may not be able to see
The two diameter barrel
Look for a short gap
Between the front of the stacking hook
Which is what this is
This little sticky outy bit
On the front of the gas plug
Well this is also the gas plug
Is for stacking rifles together
Like that
So they can sit in a sort of cone arrangement
While you go and have your dinner or whatever
So the 43 Slash 1 sight block
Distance between that
And the front of the stacking hook
Is really quite short
It's less than the length of the actual hook
Whereas on the 43
It's significantly wider
It changes the proportions
Of the front of the gun
And it is essentially the same width
Maybe even a little bit longer or wider
Than that stacking hook
So that for me
Is probably going to be the easiest
Recognition feature in period photos
Period footage
You're going to struggle to spot
The other features
Which brings me to the final one
And then to bring all this together
As to why they made these changes
It is the barrel nut or the muzzle nut
So the original design
Is significantly longer
It has a smooth center
Between a wide
I should say a wide smooth center strip
Between the two ribbed sections
That are there to get a grasp on
To unscrew this
And then the fully developed
43 Slash 44 Slash SDG 44 component
Is this much shorter nut
Concealing a shorter thread of course
That has only a very thin strip
Between those two strips
Of ribbed metal
Which are themselves narrower
Now why were all these changes made
Well easiest way to show you that
Is to grab the grenade launcher
For the Kar 98K rifle
Which is a simple
Relatively simple cup launcher
Albeit it is quite deeply rifled
And this clamps onto the barrel
So it slips over
And clamps onto the barrel
Of the Kar 98K
Which is what it is designed for
You can't fit it
To the 43 Slash 1
I believe the intent
Was to design a whole new suite
Of muzzle accessories
I have even seen
Suggestion of a suppressor
That would use this
Attachment system
And fit around this
Thickness of barrel
But in the event
What they went with
Was the turn down barrel
And the shorter nut
And actually I have just realized
That has been set
That's what that should look like
Let me just put that
Back together briefly
There is a little spring plunger here
That sits in between those ribbed sections
They are not just there
To get a purchase on
They are there to locate the muzzle nut
And stop it from unscrewing
It's much like the muzzle device
On the AKM
So it's a plunger
So you press the plunger down
Unscrew the nut all the way
Revealing our
Accessory attachment system
Also known as a thread
And then we slip
Grenade launcher
Over the muzzle
Flip closed
The attachment at the rear
And spin that up
And there you are
There is your MP43
Not Slash 1
Magazine loaded with
Grenade cartridges
Cycling it manually
One at a time of course
Loading in a grenade
Into the muzzle
And bloop
Away you go
Those of you who know
A bit about this subject
Will already know
This same attachment system
Was used for the
Krummlauf curved barrel attachment
So all of that
There are two main aspects to this
One is the ability
To fit an optical sight
Which was temporarily
Done away with
And the other
Is to allow you to use
The existing grenade launcher
And the existing grenades of course
From the Kar98k
Now that brings us to
An interesting bit of
Law slash history
Around this family of weapons
In that
One of the running arguments
Amongst the various
Organizations and personalities
Involved including Adolf Hitler
Was whether this thing
Should replace
All the rifles and SMGs
In a platoon say
And be a jack of all trades
Or whether it was
Basically a glorified submachine gun
That had greater range
Accuracy
Terminal effect
All of that
And that exact same argument
Was repeated
In the Soviet Union
Years later
When the SKS was introduced
As the standard
Albeit reduced power cartridge
Carbine
And the AK
Was going to be essentially
An SMG on steroids
And then they soon realized
That actually
The AK does it all
Let's focus on that
Well same thing was happening
In 1943
And was one of
Hitler's apparent reservations
Over actually ordering
This thing into production
And sources' opinions
Vary on this
There's the very good book
Sturmgewehr by Hans Dieter Handrich
Who details three separate occasions
When Hitler cancelled
The MKB-42-MP-43-1
So the last of those is in February 1943
But then by end of March 1943
He has perhaps reluctantly
Allowed the 43-1
Into limited production
Special production
To sort of keep that
Ticking along
But he has supposedly
Also cancelled
Any further development
He's focusing on rifles
In existing production
And for the future
He seems to be favoring
The G-43
Full power self-loading rifle
That's the sort of
Received wisdom
Leszek Ehrenfeicht
Forgive my pronunciation
Of your name
Challenges that
And suggests
Hitler was not
Cancelling this thing per se
That he was concerned with
Introducing it piecemeal
He wanted to sort of
Save it up until it was
A. Finished
And B. They could ramp it up
Into full production
And start replacing
Other weapons
And then there's this question of
What's it going to replace
Is it only going to replace
Submachine guns
Is it only going to replace
Weapons in certain units
As the Soviets were starting to do
Giving a whole platoon
Papasha 41
Submachine guns for example
And in the event
Cutting out all the
Controversy over who said what
And whether Hitler
Really did hate this thing
I'll leave that to other
Colleagues to argue about
He did
Well firstly reluctantly
Order this into limited production
Then by 44 he relented
And decided that this thing
Should enter mass production
He even coined the name
Sturmgewehr
That as far as I can tell
Is absolutely true
So the modern term assault rifle
Was invented by Adolf Hitler
Do with that information
What you will
But in actual issue
It did go only to particular units
In 1944
The Nazis never quite got to the point
Of replacing the weapons
That this can do the job of
And later history has shown
That it absolutely could have done
The job of all submachine guns
And all rifles other than
Designated marksman rifles
And sniper rifles
It couldn't really replace
The light machine gun
The intermediate cartridge
Isn't really powerful enough for that
Although the Russians did
Or the Soviets I should say
Did sort of show that
You can at least have a go
With things like the RPK
That's kind of up for debate
But the Germans
The wartime Germans
The Nazi government
Did not fully exploit
The capability of this weapon
There wasn't really time
By the time this thing
Was ready to go
The tide was turning
And they really should
Probably have been focusing
On existing production
They shouldn't probably
Have bothered to
Go down this route
As far as they did
Or down the route of the G43
As far as they did
The Brits stuck with
A bolt action rifle
All the way through the war
And it was the Allies that won
So all gets a bit complicated
I'll leave that
To the military historians
But hopefully you found this interesting
So just for absolute clarity
MP43 Slash 1
Has these features
And that's the only difference
Between that
And the whole rest of the family
The MP43 in front of me
Is identical to the MP44
Is identical to the SGG44
And there's one final
Little footnote here
Which is that
The story of this rifle
Did not end in 1945
With Allied victory
East Germany initially
Made limited use of the SGG
The former Yugoslavia
Ended up with quite a few of them
And used them for a while
And then somehow
They keep cropping up
So there was
I helped to document
Some of the material in Ukraine
In the initial Russian invasion in 2014
And there was an SGG or two there
In Syria a few years ago
Crates of these things showed up
Pristine
Presumably with ammunition
And they were even used for a while
I saw one of them
Adapted into a remote weapon station
With a camera and a mount
Absolutely bizarre
But of course
Once the ammunition runs out
You're just going to fall back on AKs
And other modern self-loading
And automatic rifles
But this thing isn't quite dead yet
They're still out there
They're still being used in anger
And it speaks to the design genius really
Of this basic design
Yes it's a bit heavy
For a modern assault rifle
Yes it doesn't have
The modern accessory capability
But hey early on
It had more than the AK did later on
So yes this is still
A capable combat rifle in theory
Albeit technology has surpassed it
So the other interesting thing
About this family is
They're not last ditch weapons
In the same way that
The simplified Mauser rifles
The Volkssturm rifles
That you have seen are
But they are getting on toward
The Sten as a semi-last ditch design
As in resources are already tight
And quality control
As getting into 1945
Especially as the Germans
Try to keep production going
You can almost see it
If you lined up enough
Of these things in a row
You'd see mismatched assemblies
Made in different places
And finished in different ways
That's something you'll see
If you look at the books
And just quality of individual components
Breach blocks tend to crack
We've experienced that
We know other collectors
That have as well
They would keep on trucking
For probably thousands of rounds
Without causing any major problem
We're not in the business
Of doing that
But you might have been in 1945
And of course
So you start out with a design
That's relatively cheap and quick
And easy to produce
And then you see
Build standard changes
That we won't go into here
But that make things cheaper
And simpler over time
The buttstock changes shape
And becomes easier to make
For example
And then you see
The actual quality
Go through the floor as well
You see this with all weapons
On the losing side
In a major conflict
As they're having to
Still keep making them
So amazing how you can read history
Through these artifacts
So if you'd like to read more
The Hans Dieter Handrick
Collector grade books I mentioned
Is really quite comprehensive
Well worth a look
And for a more sort of
Coffee table pretty book
The Vickers Guide
World War II Germany Volume 2
Covers these amongst other things
Like the FG 42
If I remember rightly
And funnily enough
Their front cover
Is a lovingly taken
Beautiful photo of this
Very workmanlike
Wartime gun
And it's this exact same
Front bit of the MP 43
Slash 1
Which is an indicator of its rarity
And its importance
In this very narrow area
As always
Thank you very much for watching
This episode of
What is this weapon
We are a charitable
Organization here at the museum
As I'm sure you know
So we very much appreciate
Any donations that you might like
To send our way
Link in the description
As to how to do that
Otherwise of course
We're very happy that you
Watch us here on YouTube
You can also check out
The GameSpot channel
Where we make regular
Appearances as well
And our various social media outlets
Twitter, Facebook, Instagram
You're welcome to check out
All of those as well
In any case
We'll see you again next time
