學者角鬥士 如何用西班牙刺劍打敗日本武士刀
王者风范
22粉絲
36 次觀看·2025年10月2日
Spanish Rapier vs Katana
How does the rapierist stop from being killed by the crazy samurai with a katana?
Hey folks, Matt Eaton here, scholar gladiatorial
So I did a recent video, if you haven't seen that already, there's a link below to that video
Basically looking at Spanish Rapier vs Japanese Katana
And you know, this isn't a crazy comparison because in fact they did come up against each other
We absolutely know they did in the late 1500s and 1600s
There were plenty of occasions when people using Japanese swords came up against people using various types of European swords
Now I had a bunch of really cool comments underneath the last video and they have inspired this video
And this video is fundamentally looking at advice for the rapierist to successfully kill or at least deal with, incapacitate the Japanese swordsman without then getting cut down
And this is a really pertinent and important point
That came up in the comments underneath that video
Because of course, just because you run someone through with a rapier doesn't mean that it's an insta-kill
In fact, for people who really know what they're talking about, even shooting people doesn't mean that
Anybody who's looked at the Moros and the Philippine War and the US adoption of the Colt 1911 and the .45 round moving away from the .38
Will know that shooting people multiple times, if they're charging at you with an edge weapon
There's the 21 foot rule that my friends over at the AHF have had a lot of fun with
The fact is if someone's running at you with an edged weapon, you can shoot them a number of times and they can still stab or chop you
And this of course happened within British colonial warfare as well
Most famously in India, but also in Afghanistan, Sudan and other places as well
So fundamentally, the issue here is advice for the rapierist to not get subsequently cut down by the katana
Because we accept, given, as I pointed out, the huge reach advantage of the rapier over the katana
The rapier is going to hit first
And not only is it going to hit first, it's reliably going to hit first
Because no matter what the katana wielder does to try and get past that point, they are not going to have a particularly high success rate
Now, I was somewhat, my heart was warmed by the fact that quite a few people in the comments
Actually practiced both Japanese and European swordsmanship and completely agreed with what I said
Because of course, they use rapiers, they use katanas or at least kendo shinai or bokken
And they pretty much agreed with my conclusion that definitely under normal circumstances
Both people being of similar skill, the person with the much longer weapon is going to make contact first
And not only, as I say, not only are they going to make contact because of the extra reach
But also because of the way that the weapons handle
The fact is that this rapier has got a very nimble and quick to maneuver point
So even if the katana wielder manages to get a cross or a bind on my sword
I can disengage it and get it somewhere else as they start charging in
And of course you can retract the weapon, it doesn't have a fixed reach
You can bring it back to your body to shorten that way, that way
You can even half sword it if you need to
So you can shorten the reach to stab them again even if they get past the point
Once you can retract and have another go at them
The katana wielder, however, has a big task on their hands
Because not only do they have the shorter weapon, they also have the less nimble weapon
Yes, it's very, very powerful cutting and will chop through all sorts of things and lock things off
But the fact is they have to get close enough to do that
So here's the quandary
How does the rapier user protect themselves from that person who's presumably been skewered and stabbed
as they come in and chop down the rapierist
And this is a real problem
Now, this also isn't a novel or unusual problem
We actually have to deal with this quite a bit
We deal with this when we're fighting spear versus long sword, for example, or arming sword
We also deal with it when we're doing rapier or small sword against people using sabre or back sword, things like this
So this is something that we experience in HEMA
And so here are three basic bits of advice
If you're using a rapier and a skewering weapon which will make contact first but won't insta-kill the enemy
It will run them through
They might die 30 seconds later
But in those 30 seconds, they're going to be trying to take your head off with a sharp katana
So the first piece of advice is run away
But run away while still keep fighting
So backpedal essentially, keep your distance, distance management
So fundamentally, you can skewer the opponent
And so long as you retract your weapon back here
Or pull it back out again
You can skewer them again
Or you can guard as need be against their cuts, their afterblows
That are going to come after the fact that they've been skewered
So first of all, whenever you do skewer them
It doesn't matter whether it's in their arm or their chest or their face or their thigh
Wherever you go, immediately retract the blade out
And get it ready to do something again
Whether it's skewer them again, for example, in the head
Which might stop them from running forward
Or parry if you need to
But that can only be done if they're charging forwards
By you running backwards as you do it
If they are charging you down
You've got to move backwards or at least tangentially move around
Move in a circle if needs be
If you don't have enough space to run backwards
Keep your distance such that they cannot reach you with their weapon
Or at least by the time that they do reach you
Your weapon is now free again in order for you to parry
Next piece of advice is nail them in a place
That either prevents them running forwards
Or disables or incapacitates their ability to keep attacking you
So one example of that is
If I just put the rapier down for a second
If a person is coming at you with their sword like this
Then nailing them through one of their arms
Might have enough incapacitating effect
In order to prevent them following through with that blow
However, I think that overall that is a risky approach
And I would rather advise you to thrust for the upper chest or face
Or possibly throat as well
So if someone's charging at you with a katana
If you can nail them in the face
It's relatively unlikely they're going to be able to continue moving forwards
With a sword sticking out of their face
Because quite simply it'll be stuck in their head
Now how do I know this?
Quite simply from stabbing people in the fencing mask
If you stab someone in the fencing mask
Yes, okay, if a blade enters a body
A person can physically move up the blade to an extent
If it's through a leg
If it's through an arm
Not so much if it's in the head
You are unlikely to keep moving towards the opponent
If a blade is in your skull
Largely because you physically can't
Because it will get stuck at the back of the skull
But also just sort of the effect
The effect of having a blade stuck in the middle of your face
Would I think make it quite difficult to keep moving forward
The chest is less sure fire
Although the chest might be in some ways more likely to kill them
Especially if you hit the heart
It can run out of the body
In fact if we look at treatises
We actually see rapiers passing right the way through the body here
And a person could run far enough up the blade
In order to still hit the person and cut them down
So both people are going to die
Of course this is why boar spears have a cross piece on them
Instead of a typical spear
Because boars do this
So I would say chest is a good target in general with a rapier
But against someone who's charging against you
A little bit less sure fire
So I would actually say go for the face
Go for the throat
And be ready to run backwards
And by distance, by time
If you possibly can do
So that by the time they do eventually catch up with you
If they catch up with you
They will have had a few more seconds of the damage
That you've done to them
By stabbing them in one of those places
Now the last point is a little bit more complex
And it relies on you understanding
Two fundamental fencing principles
One is thrusting in opposition
And the other one is tempting an attack
In order to parry riposte
Now why have I bunched those two together
Because actually the end effect is somewhat similar
You kind of lock out the opponent's weapon
At the same time as hitting them
So first example is
If we just take a simple example
Of the person with the katana
Charging in, ignoring what you're doing
Charging in and just coming with a straight
Downwards cut from one angle
It could be straight down the middle actually
But anyway, a downwards cut
OK
If they are doing this
One option you always have
And bearing in mind that you've got the longer weapon
Is to cover the line that their cut is coming down at
So if their cut's coming down here
To place essentially a bar in the way
A cross, a parry
At the same time as skewering them
This is what we call single tempo
As opposed to due tempo
We're going to look at due tempo in a minute
So due tempo would be parry and riposte
Single tempo would be parry and riposte in one move
You might wonder why do we not just do single tempo all the time
And it's quite simply because it's harder to pull off
And because of the angles of the blade required to do it
It's a little bit higher risk
It's less likely to have the desired effect
OK
But the single tempo response
In other words to parry and riposte in one movement
OK
So cross the line of the incoming attack
And put the blade in at the same time
There's always one option
And at that moment of you planting your blade into them
Their blade will be stopped around here
And bear in mind
You cannot cut through a rapier
Don't think that the katana or any other sword
Can do that because you can't
We tested it years ago
Look it up in my old videos
We tried to cut
We had tried to break through a rapier with a long sword
And completely failed
And we spent the whole evening doing it and failed
OK
You can't cut through a rapier
So
And bear in mind also you can defend with a hilt
Especially with a cup hilt
So you place the hilt in the way
As the blow comes in
And bear in mind you can also buy distance
So we look at the previous lessons here
You're moving off
You're planting your sword in the way
At the same time as nailing them in the face, chest or neck
At the same time as parrying
Now what's the due tempo option
So that would be buying distance
As they come in with their blade
You move off
You cross their blade
And then riposte
But notice that in doing this
You will end up covering the line
To where their blade is
OK
So the end result kind of the same
You end up locking out their blade
At the same time as nailing them in
Wherever your point goes
And finally you might ask
What if they try and cut you again and again
Well in that case you just parry
And riposte again and again
So if they come at you cutting
And you go for a single tempo response
And you nail them
You thrust them in the chest
And you lock out their blade
They pull back their katana
And go for another cut
Well at that point you can now switch
Into your parry riposte
They go for another cut
Parry riposte
And you can do this the whole time
I can't do it here
Because I've got doors behind me
But you do the whole time if you need to
If they're moving forwards
You move back
So what you do
It's back to the first lesson again
You maintain distance
So you can do all of these things
Whether it's single tempo responses
Or parry riposte
In whatever way you need to do it
At the same time as buying distance
So as they charge forwards
You charge either backwards in a circle
Or backwards in a straight line
Depending on what you need to do
Or what the environment's like
So that they never get to you
And the whole time
You're poking holes in them
From a distance at which
They can't reach you
With their shorter katana
I hope that's been interesting
And once again
I refer back to my previous video
I don't want you to think
That I'm just trashing and ragging
On the katana here
This is a good weapon
For its intended purpose
And in some situations
This is a better weapon
Than the rapier is
For example in a built up environment
In a small enclosed environment
Or indeed in a melee
Where you can chop around
And slice around
And you wouldn't be able to move
Very easily with a long rapier
And there's all sorts of other situations
As well for fighting in armour
For example this is a better weapon
Than the rapier is
So this is a very good weapon
I just think one on one
This is at the big disadvantage
To the rapier
But maybe in a future video
If there's any appetite for it
And post below if you're interested in that
Maybe I'll look at some of the ways
That I consider that the katana wielder
Could try and get the better
Of the rapier user
Even though I think the rapier
Has got the advantage
There are certain things
That I think the katana user
Should be trying to do
If they want to try and even the score
And I'm not just thinking about
Throwing their weapon
Although I might be thinking about
Throwing their weapon
But anyway let's look at that
In a future video
If there's any appetite for it
I thank you a lot for watching
I have been Matt Easton
And I will continue to be
Cheers folks
Thanks for watching
We've got extra videos on Patreon
Please give our Facebook a like
And subscribe if you haven't already
Cheers folks
