China’s Economic Reality: From Sharing Shops to Sharing Beds; Vietnam's Imports From China Surge

China Truths
61 followers
"China's Economy Slumps as New ‘Sharing Economy’ Wave Emerges
Vietnam's Imports from China Surge, Experts Say: A Pathway for Chinese Firms to Bypass U.S. Tariffs
China Falls Two Places in 2024 Wealthy City Rankings, Hong Kong Loses Financial Status
Frequent Unusual Phenomena in China: Fire Meteor in Hangzhou, Fiery Clouds in Beijing
#china #chinatruths #chinanews"
China's economy slumps as new sharing economy wave emerges.
Vietnam's imports from China surge, experts say, a pathway for Chinese firms to bypass U.S. tariffs.
China falls two places in 2024 Wealthy City Rankings, Hong Kong loses financial status.
Frequent unusual phenomena in China, fire meteor in Hangzhou, fiery clouds in Beijing.
It's all covered in today's China Truths.
China's economy slumps as new sharing economy wave emerges.
In the first quarter of 2024, the Chinese Communist Party reported an official GDP growth
of 5.3%, which starkly contrasts with public sentiment. Despite numerous economic stimulus
policies, these efforts have proven ineffective. Across the nation, there's a growing trend of
belt-tightening with widespread layoffs, salary reductions, and a focus on cost-cutting and
efficiency enhancements. The CCP, once known for its financial robustness, is now facing severe
budget constraints, compelling it to break the iron rice bowl and make substantial cuts to
non-staff personnel. Currently, industries across the board are struggling as the CCP
continues to promote what it calls the new sharing economy. Business owners adopt sharing
shops model. Before the pandemic, physical stores often favored large layouts designed
to engage shoppers for hours. However, in recent years, this has dramatically changed,
with storefronts becoming increasingly cramped and the trend of sharing storefronts rapidly
spreading across mainland China. For example, a store in Beijing's Chaoyang District operates as
a bun shop in the morning, a fast food outlet at noon, and a barbecue stall in the evening.
By segmenting the rental time into three parts, the cost for the morning slot is only 13,000 yuan,
nearly 1,800 U.S. dollars, significantly reducing rental expenses which typically account for 25%
to 30% of a store's monthly overhead, including rent, labor, and materials.
The shift toward sharing spaces is underscored by the closure of approximately 460,000 restaurants
in mainland China in the first quarter alone. A restaurant owner in Beijing reported that
half of his annual earnings were spent on rent. The sharing rental model has become particularly
popular among tea and cold drink vendors. For instance, in Taiyuan, Shaanxi, the local post
office has partnered with Mishue Ice Cream. The traditional model of selling 9 yuan,
about 1 U.S. dollar and 25 cents, coffee is becoming obsolete as businesses across various
industries, including real estate agencies, clothing stores, bookstores, charging stations,
and even temples, now sell coffee, illustrating a broader trend towards reducing operational costs
in addition to consumer spending. Sharing employees treated worse than outsourced workers.
Many businesses are already under financial pressure, grappling with rising personnel
costs and increasing social security contributions. In Shanghai, for instance,
the social security base has surged by 55.6 percent over the last five years. To cut down
on wage expenses and sidestep social security payments, the role of sharing employees has
been introduced. These sharing employees are in a worse position than even outsourced workers.
One internet user compared it to how farmers once shared cows to help plow each other's fields.
In mainland China, employment within government and public institutions is categorized from
highest to lowest as civil servants, establishment staff, and non-establishment personnel.
In private enterprises, it ranges from formal employees, outsourced employees, to sharing
employees. Moving down these ranks corresponds with decreasing salaries and benefits. Particularly
in the private sector, sharing employees often lack even basic employment benefits like the
mandatory five insurances and housing fund, effectively leaving them unprotected in the
job market. As reported by Jiangsu Economic Daily, for a company where the average employee
salary is 5,000 yuan, about US$693, a formal employee paying full social security contributes
950 yuan, about US$132, whereas an outsourced employee on the minimum base pays just 570 yuan,
about US$79. Sharing employees might even save this 570 yuan. With labor costs escalating,
companies are increasingly opting for the more affordable sharing employees.
According to Xiaopin Research Institute's 2023 Q4 Talent Market Hotspot Brief,
out of hundreds of millions accounted for in the CCP's employment rates as flexibly employed,
38.5% of survey respondents are considering public service exams, with flexible employment
ranking second at 19.8%. These people, in order to maintain their livelihood, have no choice but
to join the sharing wave, becoming the practitioners at the bottom of society.
According to the 2023 Graduate Housing Survey report, more than 80% of young people believe
that rent should not exceed 30% of their salary. However, in Shanghai, experts have noted that
individuals relocating to the city spend an average of 4,170 yuan, about US$578,
per month on rent, surpassing this 30% threshold. As a result, on Xiaohongshu,
a Chinese platform similar to Instagram, in major work-paradise cities across China,
many such newcomers in cities like Shanghai and Beijing are posting requests like,
Does anyone want to share a bed with me? Notably, there are also posts from
individuals seeking help in Shanghai, hoping to survive, bed available for daily sharing.
This post is by a young woman who traveled a great distance from her hometown to Shanghai.
To reduce her living expenses, she is willing to offer her last remaining private space,
her bed, for rent at 30 yuan, about US$4.16, per day.
In these arrangements, strangers place significant trust in each other despite
the uncontrollable risks associated with co-living, affecting both their property
and personal safety. In an interview with the Holang Research Institute on WeChat,
one girl who shares a bed in Beijing described the unexpected trust she felt.
They are all in similar situations, impoverished and young, and she instinctively doesn't think
the other person would deceive her. From sharing shops and employees to sharing beds,
the trend of economizing through group buying, akin to Pinduoduo-style shopping,
has emerged as a stark reflection of the socioeconomic challenges facing mainland
China in 2024. Vietnam's imports from China surge, experts say, a pathway for Chinese
firms to bypass US tariffs. Vietnam's imports from China have surged as the United States
has increased tariffs on Chinese goods to restructure the global supply chain.
This response comes amid broader trade and technology disputes between the US and China
that began in 2018, with the US aiming to address the Chinese Communist Party's unfair
trade practices and diminish China's role in the high-tech product supply chain.
On May 14, the Biden administration announced substantial new tariffs on a range of Chinese
products, including steel, aluminum, semiconductors, batteries, critical minerals, solar panels,
dockside cranes, and medical products. These measures have exacerbated trade tensions,
boosting Vietnam's trade with the US and significantly widening the trade imbalance.
Vietnam's trade surplus with the US soared to nearly $105 billion last year, more than double
the figure in 2018 when the Trump administration first imposed significant tariffs on Chinese
goods. Presently, Vietnam holds the fourth-largest trade surplus with the US globally, trailing only
China, Mexico, and the European Union. Investigations by Reuters, supported by
World Bank estimates and expert analysis, suggest a symbiotic trade relationship among the United
States, Vietnam, and China. This relationship is evidenced by the high correlation, now at 96%,
up from 84% before Trump's presidency, between Vietnam's imports from China and its exports to
the US. Chinese companies avoid high tariffs, potential US responses loom. During his visit
to Hanoi last year, President Joe Biden elevated US-Vietnam relations to a comprehensive strategic
partnership. Concurrently, Vietnam is actively pursuing market economy status from the United
States. Darren Tay, chief economist at research firm BMI, noted the significant increase in
Vietnam's imports from China, alongside a rise in its exports to the US, could be interpreted by the
US as Chinese companies using Vietnam to circumvent the additional tariffs imposed on their
products. He suggested that this could lead the US to consider imposing tariffs on Vietnam after
the elections. US imports from Vietnam exceeded $114 billion last year, more than double since
the start of the US-China trade war in 2018, while US imports from China decreased by $110
billion over the same period. Nguyen Hung, a supply chain expert at RMIT University Vietnam,
observed that in key sectors like textiles and electrical equipment, Vietnam has filled over 60%
of the trade void left by reduced US imports from China. Statistical data also shows that
many components of the products Vietnam exports to the US are sourced from China. According to 2022
data from the Asian Development Bank, ADB, around 80% of the electronics Vietnam exported were
assembled from imported components. Official Vietnamese data indicates that one-third of its
imports are from China, mainly electronics and parts. The Organization for Economic Cooperation
and Development, OECD, highlighted that in 2020, about 90% of the intermediate products imported
into Vietnam's electronics and textiles industries were later exported, a figure significantly higher
than the average for industrialized countries and an increase from 10 years ago. Recent data
underscores the complex trade relationships among China, Vietnam, and the US. In the first quarter
of this year, the US imported $29 billion worth of goods from Vietnam, while Vietnam imported $35
billion from China, maintaining a consistent trend. Despite ongoing high inflation, the White
House has remained silent on Vietnam's significant trade surplus, but analysts predict this could
change following the November elections. Nguyen Ba Hong, ADB's chief economist in Vietnam,
commented, Post-US election, changes in US policy towards Vietnam could occur, regardless of the
election outcome. Vietnam's role in exporting Xinjiang cotton and solar panels highlighted.
The trade between China and Vietnam has grown significantly, reflecting increased investment
in Southeast Asia's manufacturing sector as companies move factories from China to Vietnam.
Many of these companies are Chinese, and while they are investing in new facilities
in northern Vietnam, they still rely heavily on supply chains back in China.
The US Department of Commerce has raised concerns about these manufacturing practices.
During an investigation into solar panels last year, it was found that some products
labeled made in Vietnam did not actually undergo significant processing in Vietnam.
Further investigations are ongoing into aluminum cable products and solar panels
that may be benefiting from unfair subsidies. Another issue prompting US scrutiny is the use
of Xinjiang-sourced products in Vietnamese imports from China, violating US sanctions
related to human rights abuses by the Chinese Communist Party. Xinjiang is a major source of
In fact, cotton apparel and solar panels comprised about 9 percent of Vietnam's total
exports to the US last year. US customs data reveals that Vietnam is the leading country
for rejections by the US for importing products made with forced labor from Xinjiang.
Despite this, Vietnam's imports of raw cotton from China dropped by 11 percent to 214,000 tons
last year, which is still about twice the volume imported in 2018.
Meanwhile, the US saw a 25 percent decrease in cotton apparel imports from Vietnam,
totaling $5.3 billion, which might not cover all imported cotton products.
Hung Nguyen, an economist at RMIT University in Melbourne,
stated that the decrease in US imports from Vietnam is due to Vietnam overtaking China last
year as the primary exporter of products implicated in the US-Xinjiang ban.
China Falls Two Places in 2024 Wealthy City Rankings, Hong Kong Loses Financial Status
The recently published 2024 Global Wealthiest Cities report has shown a decline in the wealth
of six Chinese cities previously ranked among the world's top 50 wealthiest. These rankings,
based on the number of residents with assets over 1 million US dollars,
indicate that these cities have fallen an average of two places from last year.
New World Wealth released the report on May 7, listing New York City as the wealthiest,
followed by the San Francisco Bay Area, Tokyo, and Singapore. Hong Kong and Beijing were ranked
9th and 10th, respectively, with other Chinese cities like Shanghai, Hangzhou,
Shenzhen, and Guangzhou also making the top 50. A year-over-year comparison reveals a general
decline in these cities' standings, with an average fall of 2.33 places. Notably,
Hong Kong fell from 7th to 9th, Beijing from 8th to 10th, and Shanghai from 9th to 11th.
Additionally, Shenzhen dropped three places, Guangzhou 4, and Hangzhou 1. Despite a 91.5%
growth in the millionaire population in five of these cities over the last decade,
Hong Kong saw a 4% decline in its number of wealthy residents, illustrating broader issues
such as China's rapid economic downturn over the past year, a decade-long economic slump in Hong
Kong, and an expanding wealth gap within China. Economist Li Hengqing explained to The Epoch
Times that China's severe economic downturn and real estate market collapse have significantly
eroded wealth, leading many affluent individuals to face liquidation and indebtedness.
According to the Huruan Research Institute, Zhong Shanshan, chairman of Nongfu Spring
Beverage Company, remains China's richest individual despite a 9% reduction in his
wealth from the previous year. The wealth of China's high-net-worth individuals,
predominantly derived from corporate equity, has suffered due to the CCP's strict pandemic
measures and a $6.3 trillion reduction in stock market value over the last three years.
This downturn has affected not only corporate stock values but also personal fortunes,
with the real estate market decline further impacting wealthy property owners.
Moreover, the Forbes 2024 China Rich List shows a continuing reduction in the number
of wealthy Chinese, decreasing to 406 this year from a peak of 626 in 2021,
with the total wealth of these billionaires also showing significant reductions from previous years.
Hong Kong's decade-long decline continues. The 2024 Global Wealthiest Cities Report
reveals that Hong Kong has dropped from 7th place in 2023 to 9th this year,
with its millionaire population seeing a 4% decrease from 2013 to 2023.
These years overlap with Xi Jinping's leadership and the increasing mainlandization of Hong Kong,
highlighting a persistent downtrend in Hong Kong's economy.
Formerly Asia's largest financial hub, Hong Kong has faced increasing pressures starting
with the CCP's crackdown on the 2019 anti-extradition law protests, the enactment
of the national security law in 2020, and the recent legislation under Article 23 of the Basic
Law. This series of events has instilled fear among Hong Kong's affluent, leading many to
emigrate. As a result, not only are Hong Kong's wealthy leaving, but also many of its financial
and legal professionals, with Singapore seeing the most significant influx. This migration has
boosted Singapore's ranking from 5th in 2023 to 4th this year. Today, Hong Kong is losing its
luster, increasingly overshadowed by cities like Tokyo and Singapore. According to Mr. Lee Heng
Ching, the CCP's initiatives like the development of the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area
and the Hainan Free Trade Zone were aimed at replacing Hong Kong's economic position,
further contributing to its economic decline. Meanwhile, the wealth gap in China is widening.
Over the last decade, while Hong Kong's wealthy population decreased, cities like Beijing,
Shanghai, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, and Guangzhou saw substantial increases in their millionaire
counts. Despite the overall economic slowdown impacting the number of wealthy individuals last
year, the past nine years have seen continuous growth. However, the average income growth for
the general populace has been slow, contrasting sharply with Xi Jinping's push for common
prosperity. The extent of China's wealth disparity remains largely undisclosed as it is considered a
state secret. Yet, former Chinese Premier Li Keqiang admitted before his death that at least
600 million people in China earn less than 1,000 yuan, about 138 U.S. dollars and 49 cents,
per month, illustrating the profound inequality. Mr. Li Hengqing has starkly noted,
China is currently on a significant downward trajectory, with both its economy and political
environment deteriorating. Frequent Unusual Phenomena in China
Fire Meteor in Hangzhou, Fiery Clouds in Beijing On the evening of May 16, netizens from Hangzhou
and Shanghai observed a bright object resembling the moon's intensity streaking across the sky
around 6.55 p.m. Its nature, whether a meteorite or fireball, remains unconfirmed.
Just two days earlier, on May 14, another unusual phenomenon occurred near Langfang,
Beijing, where ominous blood-red fire clouds eerily lit up the sky.
That same day in Zhengzhou, Hunan, a violent dust storm wreaked havoc at a night market,
sending tents, furniture, and dishes flying. The following day in Jinping County, Hunan,
strong winds toppled a streetlamp, fatally striking a cyclist.
In Zhengzhou, additional footage revealed a row of charging stations knocked down by the wind,
uncovering their substandard construction devoid of concrete and proper materials.
A netizen lamented online,
Just when we were a month from a promising harvest, all the wheat was flattened overnight.
Senior commentator Li Linyi drew parallels between these extreme weather conditions
and those before the fall of the Ming Dynasty, noting significant financial troubles in local
governments back then. They resorted to covertly tampering with measurement standards to extract
wealth from the populace, leading to a complete erosion of public trust in the government,
one of the main factors in the dynasty's downfall. From the perspective of the
unity of heaven and humanity, he remarked, this reflects the decline typical of an era's end.
Don't forget to leave a comment in the section below to share your opinions on today's topic
with us. Make sure to like and subscribe to see more interesting topics from China Truths.
