Normans in Italy // Wars of the Lombards & Byzantines (1008-1053)

Prehistoric Civilization
160 followers
Are you ready to start your new online venture or creative endeavour? Make it happen with Squarespace,
the all-in-one platform to build an online presence and follow your dream, but more on that
at the end of the video. During the first half of the 11th century, Southern Italy was a tinderbox
just waiting to go off. In the peninsula itself, no less than three independent Lombard statelets
vied for power with their Byzantine Eastern Roman neighbours, leftovers from the days of Justinian.
These Latin-speaking descendants of Germanic invaders had their own unique Germanic laws
and increasingly looked to the Pope in Rome for guidance, often enticing
the neighbouring Lombard imperial subjects of the Byzantines into rebellion.
The first state to arise had been Benevento, which eventually splintered into two states
when Salerno seized its independence through fire and blood in the 9th century.
Next was Capua, which became independent once more towards the end of the millennium.
Just to the north, the papacy in Rome ever attempted to mediate in matters, whilst fighting
its own battles against the ever-present German kingdom to the north, yet another
continent-spanning superpower seeking to further its own ends in the region.
Finally, to the south in Sicily, an independent Islamic emirate had thrived for more than a
century after seizing the island from Roman rule. Now, they too sought to extend their own power
into the mainland. It was into this political maelstrom of vying factions and ambitious strongmen
that in 1009, Melus, a Lombard nobleman from the Apulian town of Bari, then the capital of the
Byzantine territories of southern Italy, rose up in open revolt against his overlords in an attempt
to throw off Constantinople's imperial yoke and lead his countrymen to freedom.
Though the Lombards had been allowed a certain degree of autonomy within the empire,
the cultural divide between them and their Greek-speaking neighbours was simply too much
at times. The Byzantines looked to the Patriarch in Constantinople for religious guidance,
whereas the Lombards looked to the Pope in Rome. It didn't take long for Bari,
the provincial capital, to fall. Truth be told, the imperial administrators of the empire were
few and far between, and besides, Italy had been a secure region for as long as anyone
could remember. The rebellion came as a complete surprise. After Bari, men from all over the region
flocked to Melus' cause. The rebels took Ascali and Troia the next year, whilst continuing to
swell their numbers with more and more disaffected Lombards seeking their independence from the
empire. Behind the scenes, another group of powerbrokers were likely involved too.
The independent Lombard princes of Salerno, Capua and Benevento who sought to undermine
imperial rule on their borders, in order to extend their own power. They were all too happy
to allow another to take the brunt of any potential backlash, whilst enjoying the benefits
if he was to succeed. Such had it been for the Lombards for centuries.
Originally a Germanic tribe from beyond the Rhine, the Lombards had arrived into Western Europe
later than the more famous Goths, Vandals and Huns during the fall of the Western Roman Empire.
In the mid-6th century, a hundred years after their service in the armies of Attila,
the Lombards, then known as Longbeards, had been utilised by the Eastern Romans under Justinian
to wrest back control of Italy from the Austro-Gothic kingdom which had taken hold there.
In reality, a much more Romanised group than the Lombards, the Eastern Romans,
perhaps operating out of spite or sheer naivety, didn't realise just what they had unleashed.
Soon enough, the Lombards, under their ruler Albuin, a pagan warlord partial to taking skull
cups of his enemies, after razing much of the peninsula and thus completing the desolation of
Italy held together by the Austro-Goths, instead of ceding their new lands to the Eastern Romans,
seized the opportunity to take over the peninsula for themselves.
Though areas of Roman rule did survive, for the most part the Lombards ruled Italy
for several centuries under a series of disparate dynasties and kingdoms.
These rose and fell over the years, never quite achieving the unity enjoyed by their
Frankish neighbours to the north, or the Visigoths of Spain. Yet, the centuries did change the
Lombards, who gradually adopted the language of the Romans and inherited many of their institutions
and surviving infrastructure. By the late 8th century however, all this was to change.
The northern Lombard kingdom being conquered entirely by the great king Charlemagne and added
to his ever-growing empire. From then on, the south remained divided between independent Lombard
statelets and Eastern Roman imperial holdings along the coasts, areas which had never been conquered.
By the turn of the millennium, the once powerful principality of Benevento had fallen on hard
times, splintering into three independent states. It was likely Melus' ambition to restore what he
saw as the glory days of his ancestors, to force out the enemies he likely saw as foreign oppressors.
Unfortunately for the Lombards however, by the early 11th century, the soldier emperor Basil
II, the Bulgar Slayer, had been on the imperial throne for over three decades, and he just so
happened to be one of the greatest Byzantine rulers of all time. The early 11th century was a
period of revival for the empire. Since the mid-10th century, a series of strong and militaristic
generals had come to power to oversee the greatest territorial expansion since the time of Justinian.
Now that the fragmenting Abbasid Caliphate was no longer a threat, and the new Shia Islamic
power of the Fatimids were themselves allied to Byzantium for the time being, the empire had little
to fear. Basil spent close to three decades completely subjugating the primary threat to his
power, Bulgaria, thus ending the First Bulgarian Empire, a mainstay in Eastern Europe for over 300
years. And now, his sights were firmly set upon the upstart Lombard nobleman seeking to undermine
the authority of his office. In 1011, Basil sent his subordinate, the Catapan of Italy,
Basil Mesodonites, along with a vast imperial army to put down the rebels. These were men
bloodied from three decades of brutal conflict, career soldiers, and they made light work of the
Lombard rebels. On the 11th of June 1011, not long after the imperial fleet arrived on the Apulian
coastline, Bari fell, and the rebellion fell apart soon afterwards. Malus managed to escape,
fleeing to the protection of Prince Guillemar III of Salerno, a Lombard lord with ties to the
papacy and the Holy Roman Empire to the north. Basil couldn't afford to anger the Germans whilst
the new gains of the empire were being consolidated. But he did manage to capture
Malus' wife and children, and took them to Constantinople as prisoners. Malus would never
see them again, though his son, Argyros, would still have a part to play.
Malus, along with a handful of followers, probably including his brother-in-law,
Datus, continued their struggle against the Byzantines,
attempting to rouse up underlying Lombard resentments throughout Italy into action.
According to the later chronicler, William of Apulia, it was in 1016 that Malus came across
a band of northern pilgrims at the famous shrine of Saint Michael at the imposing holy mountain
of Monte Gargano. In return for payment, Malus persuaded some of these men to join his cause,
and others carried word of the offer back to their homeland. These men were Normans,
and little did Malus know, but this act would inadvertently seal the fate of the Lombard
question once and for all, ensuring that not only would a unified Lombard state never exist again,
but also the already independent Lombard principalities would be stamped out of
existence too. And it wouldn't be either of the two empires that would land the killing blow.
By 1017, now bolstered by contingents of Norman adventurers and mercenaries led by the Drengo
brothers, an ambitious band of petty lords recently exiled from their homeland. Along with ambitious
Lombard soldiers, Malus launched a new rebellion. He quickly marched on Apulia and at first
successfully took the Byzantines by surprise, claiming large swathes of land and rousing up
yet more popular support for the cause. By 1018 however, at the Second Battle of Cannae,
fought at the same location as the famous Roman defeat by Hannibal some 1200 years earlier,
the rebel army was wiped out almost to a man. Malus managed to flee the field, as did one of
Norman lieutenants, Reinolf Drengo. The others, including most of his brothers, weren't so lucky,
being wiped out. Malus again fled north, this time to seek refuge with the Holy Roman Emperor,
Henry II, leaving his newfound Norman allies to their own devices. Drengo,
with just the handful of men he had left, fled to the mountainous Campania region,
where eventually he managed to seize a minor regional stronghold from some vying local nobles,
and began seeking a new patron, whilst all the while terrorising the local peasantry
into providing him and his men with food and supplies. From this point onwards, bands of
opportunistic Normans would increasingly integrate themselves into the political structure of the
north of Italy, and in time, subvert the entire Lombard independence movement to a Norman-led one.
In 1020, two years after the Battle of Cannae, while at the court of the Emperor, Malus died,
a broken man, just as his brother-in-law Datus was captured by the new Byzantine catapan of Italy,
Basil Boianes, and his new ally, later known as the Wolf of the Mesogiorno,
Pandolf IV, Prince of Capua, at the time ruling in conjunction with his cousin,
though before long becoming a powerhouse in his own right, a master of the shifting alliances
and Machiavellian politicking of southern Italy at this time. Over the course of his career,
Pandolf would be Prince of Capua on no less than three separate occasions.
For a man like Pandolf, any silly notions of a unified Lombard state meant little. He was an
ambitious realist, and the Byzantines were obviously the most powerful force in the region.
Ever the shrewd ruler, his going over to them coincided with all of the other Lombard princes
switching their loyalties from the Holy Roman Empire to the Byzantines too.
There was also another group that benefited from Pandolf's politicking, a group ever in need of
well-paying patrons, and happy to serve any of the different sides involved, the Normans.
On the 15th of June 1020, on Pandolf and Basil's orders, Datus, the last hope of the Lombard
independence movement, was tied up in a sack on the Italian coastline. Along with him was thrown
a monkey, a rooster and a snake. The sack was then tossed into the sea, an excessively harsh execution
and throwback to ancient Roman traditions. Datus's grisly execution prompted an immediate
response from the Holy Roman Empire to the north, ever looking for an excuse to involve itself in
the Messigiano, and a huge army soon marched south to fight the Byzantines, now supported
by Norman mercenaries, ever making themselves indispensable to both sides of any potential
conflict. The German detachment under Pilgrim, the Archbishop of Cologne, marched down the
Tyrennian coastline and besieged the city of Capua. Hesitant to fight the Germans, who were equally
unwilling to do the same, Pandolf was instead seized as a scapegoat and taken before the Emperor
Henry II. Pandolf was very nearly executed before being saved at the last minute by Pilgrim,
and instead thrown into a dungeon, before being released two years later after Henry's death
and the instalment of a new German leader, which prompted a new strategy of reconciliation.
Nearly two decades passed before Milos's son, Argyros, was finally released from his captivity
in Constantinople. Much had changed in Italy since he had been carried off from his homeland as a boy.
Resentment towards the Byzantines was still strong amongst their Lombard subjects,
as well as the independent Lombard states, now supported by increasingly powerful bands of
militaristic Normans, who had made it their business to be integral to the various power
struggles playing out. Unfortunately for any independent-minded Lombards of southern Italy,
each one of their leaders had their own ambitions and aims, which led them to rarely band together
for a common cause, more often than not fighting amongst themselves. Just to add further to the
confusing mesh of magnates in the Messiageno, Argyros had spent much of his life in Constantinople,
not in a prison cell, but as a wealthy imperial citizen. For all intents and purposes,
he was now a Roman. Rather than returning back to Italy as his father's son, he returned as a
Byzantine general, along with a vast army comprising of Greeks, Varangian guardsmen under
the Norwegian Prince Harald Hardrada, fierce Rus mariners from the riverlands of Eastern Europe,
Lombards pressed into service, and of course Normans, all under the overall command of the
General George Maniakes, the greatest Byzantine commander of his generation.
The destination of this multinational invasion force was the island of Sicily, home to an Islamic
emirate for close to two centuries. The overall aim of the campaign was to dislodge the Muslim
leadership entirely and re-establish imperial control once and for all. Maniakes was the
closest thing to a celebrity that early 11th century Byzantium had. During a time of relative
inactivity, following the overwhelming success of Basil the Bulgar Slayer, Maniakes was a dashing
giant of a man, who led from the front, fighting in the vanguard alongside his men. He'd made a
name for himself in the early 1030s during an unsuccessful imperial attack on Aleppo.
Despite the defeat of the main army, Maniakes had led a splinter attack largely on his own volition,
successfully capturing the town of Edessa from the Arabs, and earning himself an immediate
promotion in the process. Since that time, his stature had only grown, and now he was ready
for his most ambitious project yet. The famed soldier-emperor Nicephorus Phocas had undertaken
similar conquest of Crete just less than a century earlier, which had spring-bolted him
to the imperial throne, and there were many in the empire who saw Maniakes as attempting
to do the same. The new reigning family in the capital, the Paphlagonians, were hardly legitimate
themselves, simply being the most crafty of the bunch in playing the political game following
Basil's death and the decline of the Macedonian dynasty. Yet nonetheless, despite high hopes and
some initial successes, the differences between the vast coalition were simply too much to bear,
and before long, the various leaders of the campaign turned on each other.
The story recorded by Byzantine sources goes that Maniakes, a brilliant yet hot-headed tactician,
had asked his admiral Stephen to halt the retreat of a force of Arabs after he defeated them in a
surprise battle, and thus win a decisive victory. When Stephen failed to do so, unwittingly allowing
the Arabs to escape to their ships, Maniakes, on the back of his mighty warhorse, rode up to the
unfortunate man, berated him with insults, before publicly whipping him for his incompetence for all
to see. In doing this, Maniakes had made a grave error, for Stephen was married to the emperor's
sister, and was thus an inner member of the Paphlagonian clan, who now held sway in the capital.
Similar stories abounded of Maniakes humiliating Arduin, the leader of the Lombard detachment,
which had been sent by Prince Gwiamar IV of Salerno. According to the Norman chronicler,
Amitus of Monte Cassino, when Arduin refused to surrender a captured horse to the Byzantine
general, Maniakes had him stripped and beaten. This was an act which apparently caused Arduin
and his Norman allies to finally desert the Byzantines once and for all. Though this could
easily be an excuse for a rebellion that was already in the works. Thus, despite winning
all of the engagements he fought in, Maniakes was soon recalled by the emperor Michael IV
to answer for his crimes. Ultimately, whether he had been planning to in the first place or not,
Maniakes would launch an ultimately unsuccessful attempt on the imperial throne,
dying in battle as he fought on the front line with his men. Although the Arabs soon took the
Sicily back, Maniakes' successes there ultimately inspired the Normans to invade for themselves
just a few decades later. In the interim period, and with the backdrop of Maniakes' attempt on
the imperial throne, a full-scale Lombard revolt again broke out, once more supported by even more
contingents of Normans. In particular, the current eldest Hauteville brother active in the region.
Like the Drangos before them, and no doubt other families, the Hautevilles, a brood of relatively
obscure landless knights, had uprooted themselves from Normandy to start new lives in the south.
By 1041, their leader was the eldest surviving brother, William Ironarm, named for his
supposedly defeating the emir of Syracuse in single combat during the imperial campaign in Sicily.
The Lombard rebels, led in battle by Ironarm, won several victories, most notably at Olivento
and Montemaggiore, the first time Normans had faced Byzantines since Cannae in 1018,
with a decisively different result. In September 1041, the rebels even defeated the new Byzantine
catapult, Ex Augustus, the son of the great Basil Boianes, taking him captive to be ransomed back
to the empire. Boianes was taken to Benevento, whose prince was at the time aligned with the
rebels, led now by Atenulf, the prince's brother. At about the same time however, the prince of
Salerno, Guillaumar IV, allegedly began to draw the Normans under his banner with his own promises.
By February 1042, probably feeling abandoned and perhaps bribed by the Byzantines,
Atenulf negotiated the ransom of Ex Augustus, and then fled with the ransom money to Byzantine
territory. It is at this point in the story that a curious event happens. In February 1042,
after the original leader of the rebellion, Atenulf, brother of Prince Pandulf III of Benevento,
defected to the Byzantines, he was replaced as leader by Argyros, the son of the famed hero
Melus of Bari. Despite having lived most of his life as a Roman, apparently switched his
allegiances to become an instant figurehead of the rebellion. In reality however, by this time,
the rebellion seems to have already taken on a distinctly Norman character. By the time Argyros
took command, the Normans were already making the military decisions entirely on their own.
Either realising the larger threat to his people, or his greed getting the better of him,
the truth depending on which sources you read. Before long, it was Argyros who accepted titles
and money from the Byzantines, and was accepted back into the imperial fold,
thus throwing the rebellion into confusion once more. It has been suggested by some historians
that Argyros had never really been a supporter of the Lombard Rebellion, his going over being
rather a result of Byzantine intrigue, much like the Bulgarian nobleman Alusian during their
rebellion in the Balkans, which took place in the same era. Perhaps realising the greater of two
evils, Argyros continued to try and counter the emergence of the Norman menace in Italy,
going on to fight them for the Byzantines for the next 16 years,
under the title Duke of Italy, Calabria, Sicily and Paphlagonia.
Though in reality, the damage was already done. Normans now fought on the behalf of almost every
leader in the region, and had even been legitimised and given lands by various Lombard nobles,
seeking to keep their own titles against their neighbours, such as Pandolf IV of Capua,
who remained allied to the Normans for much of his life, finally seeing the city of Capua
taken over by the Normans after his death. In 1053, an independent Norman force under Richard
Drengo, the nephew of the Reynolf that had once fought alongside Melus back in 1018, and a rising
star, Robert Hauteville, known as Guiscard or the Crafty, the leading Hauteville brother after the
death of the other contenders, defeated a coalition of almost every other group in southern Italy
at the Battle of Civitat. Argyros commanded the Byzantine detachment during that battle,
but he seems to have missed the actual combat. In the aftermath of Civitat, it became overwhelmingly
clear that the Normans were now the paramount power in southern Italy. Rather than an independent
Lombard kingdom in the south, a Norman one had been born.
This video is brought to you by Squarespace. From websites and online stores, to marketing tools and
analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build an online presence and follow your dreams.
Whether it's podcasting, creative writing, photography, or an online shop, whatever it is that
you do creatively in your life, you can make it more connected and visible to the world with
Squarespace, one of the best website designers in the world. They offer great features such as
so you know all of the important stats for your project, email campaigns and mailing lists to keep
your fans or customers up to date with what you're doing, seamless integration with other social
media and blogging platforms, podcast support for helping you get started on the radio, and access
to a high quality library of Getty images. If any of this sounds like something that you might be
interested in, then there's a whole load more over on their website. Head over to squarespace.com for a free
trial now and when you're ready to launch go to squarespace.com forward slash history time or
simply use the offer code history time to get 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
