03 Mannerism 01 Parmigianino, Madonna of the Long Neck

Parmigianino
1 follower
8 Video Views·Jul 15, 2025
So here we're looking at the great Mannerist painting
by Parmigianino called the Madonna with the Long Neck.
It's a fun painting.
And it's a tall painting.
It's a big painting.
It's big.
And Madonna is big.
She's big in funny places, too.
If you look at her head, her head is really tiny.
Compared to her hips, especially.
Right, she's got really, really wide hips.
And then she comes down on these tiny little toes.
So it's always seemed to me like her body
is in the shape of a diamond.
In a sense, she's a landscape on which Christ sits.
Christ himself is also quite large.
It's not just large, but look at the way he splays his body.
There's this crazy kind of torsion
with his arm falling almost dislocated from his shoulder.
There is a precedent for that way
that his left arm falls down.
If you think about Michelangelo's Pietà and Christ
here as a child, but perhaps echoing
when Mary will hold Christ in images like the Pietà
when Christ is dead.
And in fact, Christ looks asleep,
but there's also a way that he looks dead, too.
So that reference actually, in some ways,
explains the mass of her lap.
Because in that sculpture, Mary is quite substantial
in order to be able to support the dead body of her son.
It's so clear when we're looking at this
that we're not in the high Renaissance anymore.
So what happened?
Mannerism happened.
It's almost like the artists of the high Renaissance
had done everything that could be done.
They had perfected the naturalism
that they had sought after since the time of Giotto.
So all of the illusionism that was
at the service of the high Renaissance
is here being used to distort and to transform the body.
It's not so much an ugly deformation
as a kind of deformation that accentuates
a kind of extreme elegance.
Exactly, it takes that ideal beauty and elegance
that was in the high Renaissance, that was there,
and exaggerates it.
And one way of thinking about Mannerism
is to think about it as art taken from art
instead of art from nature.
You know, we think about the Renaissance
as being based on observation of nature
and the natural world.
But when you look at this, you think back
to works of art like Michelangelo's Giuliano de' Medici
and that long neck, or back to the Pietà.
That makes a lot of sense, the idea that this is art
that is self-referential,
that is referring to its own traditions.
The respect for human anatomy
and portraying that naturalistically,
that's not important to Mannerists.
In fact, I think there's a letter
from one Mannerist artist to another Mannerist artist
where he says something like,
take a left hand and put it on a right arm.
It's like there's a willful complicating of the body.
And setting up relationships between forms
that are absurd, look at the relationship
between the vase that's being held by the angel
in relationship to his, her thigh.
Look at the relationship between the massive Virgin Mary
and the prophet in the lower right corner
that is presumably impossibly far away,
but somehow just a tiny figure at the feet of the Virgin.
And look too at the way that the Virgin
holds her hand to her chest
with these impossibly long, almost boneless fingers.
There's a way in which the gesture fails to mean anything.
It means gesture as opposed to a specific intent
of the figure.
Yeah, there's a kind of dramatizing here.
For its own sake.
Exactly.
That kind of willful compression
that creates a sense of almost the impossible.
If you look at the columns on the right,
there's actually a colonnade that is so deep in space,
it's seen at such an oblique angle
that it almost seems like a wall or a single column.
But if you look closely at the base,
you can see the alternating light and shadow
that passes between those columns.
But there is ambiguity, and that's in large part
because that part of the painting is not finished.
So mannerism, it seems to be this intense reaction
to the perfection of the high Renaissance.
You have the Renaissance, in a sense,
building itself into a kind of extreme naturalism.
And then this seems to be almost a kind of flailing reaction
against those strictures.
Or a sense that there was nowhere to go
except to do something really different.
Now, all of these ideas were very much a part
of a culture of the court.
And I think it's important to recognize
that there was a very specific, very learned audience
for these kinds of paintings.
And so these were not paintings that were made
for the artist's own wild interest.
This was considered a kind of high intellectual,
almost game.
