Ancient Virtue Ethics and Modern Business

Finance & Beyond
21 followers
What can Aristotle and Confucius teach us about business ethics?
#finacialtips #finance
If we are to consider ethics in the operation of business, which we certainly should,
we need to consider all manner and forms of ethical theory, and that includes ancient ethical theory.
And so this video is going to just quickly look at two ancient ethicists, Aristotle from
ancient Greece and Master Kung, more commonly known as Confucius, from ancient China.
We can consider them together, not just because they're both ancient, but because they really
did have similar approaches to ethics in that their ethical theories focus on virtue.
That's different from more modern theories, which focus either on the conceptions of duty to
commands or utilitarian consequentialist considerations. Virtue ethics focuses on the
with the idea that if one is virtuous, then one will do virtuous acts. It's like simple training.
The more we train to do ethical things ethically, the easier it becomes for us to do ethical acts.
Aristotle, he ties ethics to the concept that all human beings, like all things in the universe,
have a distinct purpose and goal. For human beings, Aristotle believed that our purpose
and goal is to live a certain kind of life. He wrote, we state the function of man to be a
certain kind of life, and this to be an activity or actions of the psyche, implying a rational
principle, and the function of a good man to be the good and noble performance of these.
Now, this quote is from his book on morality, Nicomachean Ethics, in which he summarizes his
observations of what constitutes the good. His moral theory is in line with his method of
understanding objects based on observations. And he's reporting to us what he sees as the
objective facts about achieving human excellence. And so his approach produces a straightforward
and grounded ethical philosophy, but it is constrained by the limits of his experience.
And being a man of privilege in a highly hierarchical society, his view of morality
included only men of his high social status. For Aristotle, human beings have the final
clause of fulfilling our nature. And it is in our nature, Aristotle says, to reach the ultimate goal
for all people, which is happiness. Well, not just happiness, really not happy feelings,
but a particular state of happiness that he calls eudaimonia. To understand eudaimonia,
don't think of it as pleasures, because those are fleeting, but think of it as the contentment of
living well, and having a life worth living. What's interesting about what Aristotle is claiming
is that everything we do is in one way or another directed toward the goal of this contented
well-being. Ask why you are doing anything you do. But you're listening to this right now. Why?
Well, you're wanting to learn something about business ethics. Well, why? Well, to get a good
grade in a course. Well, why? To get a university degree. Why? Well, to get a good job. Why? Well,
to make some money. Why? To have a good life. Yes. Eudaimonia is the ultimate goal of all human
beings. Now, yes, some people chase wealth, fame, honor, or other fleeting, feel-good ways. But
eudaimonia, what should also be called the good life, comes from living a disciplined life of
virtue. Aristotle taught that the good life is the life of virtue, and virtue is measured by what
helps people to achieve the good life. In other words, you achieve a good life by moving toward
constantly living a good life. Now, this isn't circular reasoning. It is the nature of virtue
ethics. For Aristotle, we must develop our mind and psyche to cultivate the virtues of temperance,
justice, and courage that define a good person. We cultivate virtue by practicing virtue. We become
just by doing just acts. We become temperate by doing temperate acts, and so on. In living our
lives this way, we fulfill our human purpose and will eventually achieve the state of eudaimonia.
Being virtuous brings us the good life. So this is the broad purpose of life. But what about
specific ethical decisions? When faced with the decision to do A or B, how do we know which choice
is the ethical course of action? Not surprisingly, Aristotle says that the person of virtue will be
able to decide on the correct choice by exercising virtue. This is because, Aristotle says, virtue is
a state of character concerned with a choice, relying on the mean relative to us, this being
determined by a rational principle and by that principle by which the man of practical wisdom
would determine it. And this sentence is the heart of Aristotle's ethics, and it holds a lot
of meaning. Let's expand on each component. First, virtue is a state of character. This is the
application of practicing virtue previously mentioned. We become just by doing just acts.
Being truly virtuous means wanting to make the correct ethical decisions. It is not enough to
know what is virtuous, one must live it and act on it. Aristotle says that a virtuous person
delights in virtuous actions and is vexed at vicious ones. So the virtuous person makes a
choice to act, but the choice must come from a certain type of character. The virtuous person
makes the virtuous choice by determining the mean course of action relative to the situation.
By mean, Aristotle refers to the course of action that lies between extremes. He explains
that excess is a form of failure and so is defect, while the intermediate is praised and a form of
success. Aristotle's position is that the middle path is always the correct path. Here's an example
from Aristotle's time. Let's say your infantry unit is in a battle and the enemy is charging
your position. One extreme reaction to this would be to run away in panic. The opposite extreme
would be to abandon your defensive position and charge the enemy. Between these extremes
of cowardice and foolhardiness is the mean of standing your ground and meeting the enemy's
charge. This simple example is emblematic of how Aristotle wants us to think about every moral
decision that confronts us. Thinking is the key because the mean is determined by reason. The mean
is relative to us, to the particular situation that confronts us. That relativity does not imply
that we have any leeway to make personal moral choices. Aristotle specifies that the mean
relative to us is being determined by a rational principle that any and every man of practical
wisdom would determine. What Aristotle is indicating here is that though every situation
is different, every situation has one rationally correct moral answer to it. Every rational man
in that situation would reach the same conclusion. And Aristotle does mean men only. He believed
women lacked the capacity for reason, a clearly extreme and irrational belief, and quite hypocritical.
But back to the infantry example, if any man in that unit can keep his head and think rationally
about that situation, he will be able to determine the correct prudent action to take. The bottom
line for Aristotle's ethics is the demand that we always practice rationally driven moderation.
Aristotle's word for this is phroniceas, which is best translated as practical wisdom with a strong
sense of prudence. We do not make moral decisions based on emotion or personal preferences. We make
moral decisions based on the middle path as determined by rational principles. If we live
life in this way, we will develop virtue. And living the virtuous life is the efficient cause
of us reaching our final cause of eudaimonia. It is important to remember that living the
virtuous life is a process. It is not an action we do once and there we are. Acquiring virtue
for Aristotle meant developing the habit of phroniceas. Only the person who consistently
practices phroniceas can develop moral virtue. Like any good habit, the more we practice it,
the easier it becomes. Acting virtuously creates a virtuous character, and a virtuous character
will more readily act virtuously. Aristotle's example is developing courage. You may lack
courage at first, but by performing an initial act of courage, you begin a habit. Developing
courage is the process of incremental change, small steps of prudent courage taken over time
that molds the person's character. The person of moral virtue cares not about fame, fortune,
or power, but to act according to the dictates of reason, seeking neither to control others
or to submit to others. He acts with wise, prudent self-control, and has the contentment
of living well and having a life worth living. So how does this relate to business, especially
because Aristotle says nothing specifically about business? Well, within Aristotle's ethics, greed
is excessive, irrational, and dishonorable. There's nothing wrong in making money in business,
but in business transactions, one should always act with prudent, practical wisdom, being fair
and honest, never giving in to extremes, always taking the middle, prudent path of practical
wisdom as can be rationally determined. The mean within any business transaction would be a fair
exchange, neither party profiting excessively in the transaction. To be dishonest and cheat someone
in business is to be unvirtuous and should bring the dishonest business person into dishonor and
ridicule. In Aristotle's ethics, virtuous conduct is the measure of a person. This is in stark
contrast to the corporate capitalist world today, when greed is considered good and the amount of
wealth one has accumulated is the measure of a person. The idea that one should be honorable and
virtuous is not entirely gone, but it has become a secondary concern to what is now considered
success in business, making high profits. Another system of virtue ethics was that of the ancient
Chinese philosopher, Confucius, known in the West by the Latinized version of his name, Confucius.
He didn't have anything to do with martial arts, but his name means Master Kung, because he became
a revered teacher in Chinese society and still has a strong influence in China. Master Kung
developed an elaborate ethical system of practices based on virtue. Above all, Master Kung's system
called for harmony and order. Central to this call for order was the abstract idea of
Li, an ancient Chinese concept meaning ritual, proper conduct, or propriety. Li is a set,
concrete guide to human action. It originally was a system of ritual practice within the imperial
court, and Master Kung saw the imperial court as the microcosm of the world. The reason for this
is that strongly implied with the concept of Li is that performing it brings gain and benefit
to the system in which it is performed. Correctly practicing the rights and protocol within the
imperial court will bring harmony and order to the court. Similarly, Master Kung taught
there are rights and protocol of every aspect of human life that should be correctly practiced
and that doing so will bring harmony and order to the world. Master Kung saw his ethical system
as a mean between the one extreme of tyrannical brute force to maintain order and the opposite
extreme of relying on individuals to practice mutual love and aid to bring about harmony.
This was in the spirit of Aristotle, though Kung predated Aristotle. Also similar to Aristotle,
Master Kung emphasized self-control in all things, never acting too rashly or too timidly.
Balance was key. Maintain a constant mean of prudent action between extremes in order to act
properly. Too much hostility or too much love toward others are extremes to be avoided. Act
instead according to the rules of Li or proper conduct. If you are in a situation in which the
rules of proper conduct are not clear, then you should weigh the circumstances and act with a
sense of rightness. Proper conduct was everything for Master Kung because this was the only way to
attain the good. He thought that humans were, by nature, desiring the good but are easily
corrupted and therefore need to be thoroughly educated in virtue. A significant aspect of Li
was training people in the way of virtue. Because Li brings gain to the system in which it is
practiced, all people and the society in which they live benefit from learning and the practice
of what they learn. The education he proposed was strict and not tolerant of failure. He wrote that
we should advance the good and set aside the corrupt because rotten wood cannot be carved.
Education carves a person into a virtuous, productive human. And you can guess what he
should do with rotten wood. Essential to proper conduct was observing the proper relations between
people. Master Kung believed that harmony and order required hierarchical relations.
The emperor ruled over his subjects, a master rules over his apprentices, and a father rules
over his family. Respect for one's superiors and elders was perhaps the most important ritual to
observe in Li. Master Kung saw the family as the basic unit of society and the structure of the
family was rigidly hierarchical. Disobeying one's parents is unthinkable and honoring one's parents
is essential to social order. Everyone in the family should be deferential to their elders,
respecting, serving, and obeying them. That hierarchy maintains harmony and order in the
family just as it does in the imperial court. That hierarchy implemented in every aspect of
social life is what will maintain harmony in society. Therefore, Master Kung requires that
society teach every member the correct procedures to show respect, servitude, and obedience to one's
superiors. It's easy to see how Master Kung's ethical philosophy applies in a business setting.
Li, in business, is proper conduct, following the rules, following the protocols, what we now call
in businessese policies and procedures. A business's policies and procedures should be determined
through a prudent and rational means of decision making based on tradition, and employees should
be thoroughly trained in following procedures and indeed the following of following procedures,
knowing how to follow procedures. Employees should be cultivated in this practice. The family
in business is the business itself, and one must have respect and be willing to serve and obey
one's superiors within the business. Disobedience to the company or one's superiors is just as
unthinkable as disobeying one's parents or one's emperor. To be fair, Master Kung also thought that
the ethics of Li included the rules that supervisors, business owners, parents, and emperor
have an obligation to take care of the people who are under them. No one is above the rules of
virtue, and in fact Master Kung taught that if the emperor ever violates the rules of Li,
ever acts in a dishonorable and non-virtuous manner, his kingdom will topple, that the heavens
themselves will bring down his kingdom and end his rule and bring in someone who will follow the rules of Li.
And so ideally in business, the owners of a business and every supervisor within a business
who has any authority at all should also follow the rules of proper conduct, should also be
persons of virtue, and care for, not abuse, their subordinates. In summary, what ancient virtue
ethics says for us for business practices today is that the bottom line of only looking at
consequences, only looking at short-term gain or even long-term gain is not a proper way to run a
business. Behaving prudently, not taking excessive risks, but not being excessively timid in business
Always looking for fairness, always remembering that business transactions should benefit all
parties involved, not just one party, are at the heart of ancient virtue ethics for business.
If a company were today to apply ancient virtue ethics to their company, they would need to
cultivate a culture of virtue within the company, educate people within the idea of attaining
excellence within all of their business dealings and all of their practices. And of course the
company would have to act virtuously, never abusing their employees, never trying to be
dishonest to their customers. Some would say such practices are not practical in today's business
world, and maybe that's true, maybe it's not, but it's something to consider.
