Times were already tough for young adults looking for ways to start living independent lives after high school and college: rents were up, wages were down, student loan debt was burdensome, then the Covid-19 pandemic hit. A generation of young people were forced out of their classrooms, jobs, and social lives, returning home to live with their parents. Now many of these young adults carry the scars of the internal pandemic, with increased anxiety and depression, poor coping, and the uncertainty of how to restart their lives. Parents want to help, but the old rules of advice-giving can clash with the need to respect their child’s autonomy.
DISCLAIMER: Links included in this description might be affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service with the links that I provide I may receive a small commission. There is no additional charge to you!
fun college life is over I've got to go
back home to my mom and dad and squelch
down all the stuff that I've been doing
for the past four years so uh and you
got to live with your parents again what
should that look like it's a negotiation
so unlike in your days where you got
squelched down it really is a
conversation about what are my
expectations what are you looking for
here's what would bother me and why so
it can be a hard conversation it's going
to probably be more than one
conversation
[Music]
Janet hibs welcome to the bookaholic
podcast thanks so much for having me my
pleasure yes so when I got this book in
the mail I was just stunned I stopped in
my tracks and in honor of the book today
and for parents everywhere in the
position that I'm in I have on no
makeup no lipstick
Noone of they I'm totally unfiltered I
don't even have it on any Tinted
Moisturizer because this is this is in
the raw and I think people have been
doing this for decades but but not
realizing that it was a whole thing and
that there's a way to get around this
particular area with certain points that
you will be telling us a little bit
about today so the book is called you're
not done yet and you know me and all my
friends who have children and I'm still
calling them children between the ages
of 18 to 30 we're like woo yay we
throwing up you know confetti you know
we love them so much we love them so
much but we are like I can be done being
a parent I don't have to do that anymore
you know and I am just you I can be the
loving mom at a distance and they're
grown and they just have to handle it
for themselves and uh this book tells us
that we still have a little bit more
parenting to do and that's going to be a
slight disappointment to a lot of folks
I know just saw my friend's husband the
other day and um had to give something
to him for his uh wife and he was just
mentioning oh my our youngest son will
be moving out for good in a couple of
days and our oldest she's away and she's
never going to come back and I'm going
to go for Five Mile Walk and I'm just
going to feel good and I was like yeah
okay I mean but I understand where he
was at but boy I think he's gonna be the
first person that I'm gonna show this
book to to put him into
reality uh but anyway so before we get
to the heart of the matters of you're
not done yet Janet please tell us why
you and your writing partner Anthony
rustan are qualified to write such a
book well there's the professional and
the personal and Dr rostain is a
developmental psychiatrist and he treats
a lot of typically developing but also
neuro atypically developing children
adolescence and then into young
adulthood as they continue to see him
and they get older and so he continues
to be available to them and to their
family so he and I are both what's
called family systems clinicians I'm a
family psychologist he's a family
psychiatrist but really more you know in
a kind of specialty area of Psychiatry
and so what's happened is that in our
earlier book The stressed years of their
lives which is really kind of the roll
out to college and the years in which
parents are pressured and you know their
children feel enormous pressured or like
kind of make the right choices and
Achieve what they need to achieve
because they understand they're in a
much more competitive world now so we've
been following these adolescence through
the youth Mental Health crisis and into
college crisis and now they're young
adults but the crisis haven't
necessarily gone away because people
that they resolved some you know of
their issues i' say earlier but life is
you know not like all tied up with a bow
by the time you finish your education
even whatever kind of education you get
and we'll talk about reasons for that
personally I learned a lot I give
acknowledgements to my sons as young
adults and my daughter-in-law cuz I
learned from their struggles they are
now uh 30 and 34 and it was an eyeopener
to me when they would come back you know
from various educational times and
either be having a much harder time than
I anticipated or feeling like this isn't
working for me like what's the off-ramp
to college and I was like whoa I hadn't
thought of that
so it was an eye opener and so I was
like your friend who thought Oh They'll
be out and gone kind of like I was right
that's a nice fantasy but it's really
not how it's rolling out for young
adults or their parents these days and
right so yeah it's different the world
has changed the world has changed
greatly so I'm going to throughout our
conversation I'm going to be throwing
out some of my personal experience
so to give you a little bit of
background about myself when I was
applying to colleges way back in the
1980s um I did them all myself I did
them all myself they were pen and paper
um I did you know what maybe about seven
six to seven applications to various
colleges across the United States I did
them all on my own my parents cheered me
on they wanted me to go to college but
they did not write up my applications
they did not even do my financial aid
and all of that stuff I think I might
have had to ask them for their taxes and
things of that nature and turn that over
but other than that I did that all for
myself and by myself maybe with a little
sprinkling of guidance counselors I
sought my own scholarships Etc now fast
forward to now the kids have the a
common app they have all these websites
and sometimes it's a struggle to get
them to fill those out and everything is
just right there that's when I knew wow
this is a whole different scene I did
all my stuff painstakingly pen and paper
and they have all of these electronic
submission things and it's it's right
there in the palm of their hand why
aren't they taking advantage of this I
would apply to 20 colleges had I had the
Common
App you know so you know that was one of
the first indicators the second
indicator is uh Co came into play which
made you realize a lot of different
things and um then last but not least I
am a mother my husband and I we have two
sons one is 26 lives in Los Angeles very
independently I might add and we have a
21y old son who was greatly affected by
the pandemic he is currently in
community college but to seek to
transfer to a four-year institution and
complete the remaining two years of
college also going back when I was
growing up and my parents always
encouraged me when I was five and six
years old you're going to college my
siblings went to college I was going to
go to college so it was no choice about
the matter I was going to college right
so but my mother always famously said
you're either going to go to college or
you're going to the armed services or
you're GNA get a job one of those threes
but you can't just be here lying around
the house I don't think she cared so
much that you lived there but you'd had
to be doing something you know and there
was no gonna be laying around in the bed
and whatnot and everybody else was going
to work or doing chores or whatever so
that is my background and I think
somewhere in there I've covered a lot of
people's backgrounds by voicing all of
this stuff that I just told you so I
didn't realize I just always thought it
was a thing of society that you you all
brought out there are five markers of
adulthood and they are completing an
education obtaining a job and settling
into a career living independently
finding a partner and becoming a parent
and that came from the 1950s I thought
that was just something that was always
there explain that whole thing well
those are the traditional markers and I
want parents to know they are at a date
stamp it is they are really outstep with
what has happened in the world really in
about the last 40 years it's just that
you know it's kind of like a tsunami
that builds and then it hits and you go
whoa what happened but just to kind of
frame it also from like your vantage
point during the 80s mid 80s the Reagan
presidency went on this mission to
increase College enrollment so your
parents were ahead of the curve and like
go to college go to college but it was
to drive up College enrollment because
in essence we thought still the cold war
that they were we were falling behind
and the science and you know engineering
technology Fields because the Russians
were winning the you know space race or
something who knows anyhow that became
the Big Goal what happened also is that
so and it was successful by some
measures like okay it increased College
enrollment in the next 30 Years four
times over but what also changed was
that the burden of Finance in college
fell to families beginning in the 90s
the federal funds got lower the state
and local funding got lower and yet kids
were given this m you don't just have a
choice like your mom told you it was
like no you have to go to college it's
college for all which now the new saying
is college for all is broken for most
which sadly represents the students who
go or start a college and then they drop
out due to financial reasons obviously
you know those are more affected in you
know the minority and first gen you know
kids and yet I would want those parents
to know it really is the emotional
support maybe like you're saying you had
for college completion and educational
completion or even just goal completion
it's the emotional support that parents
give that's even as important as
material support which is saying a lot
so but what happened was that as
students felt like I have no choice and
college became more and more Regional
and National and branded if you don't go
to this one then you won't make that
career or this job and also after the
208 um 11 Great Recession which wound up
having a flatline recovery things did
not really get that much better
economically the parent generation was
hurt the younger generation was hurt
they had a hard time covering and so
many students start college and also the
employers because they were shrinking
their employee numbers they began what's
called degree inflation oh now you need
a college degree for what you used to be
able to do a job that only required a
high school degree so that began to
happen right after the Great Recession
so that's been the roll out for about
the past 12 to 15 years that's changed
since Co but our mindset didn't change
our mindset is got to co and you got to
do this and you got to do that which
hasn't always worked I mean it's never
worked for
everyone think now becoming more alert
to this right now the Jin Z high
schoolers fewer than half of them are
considering a four-year college and the
notice because they realize whoa we
didn't see this coming we got to change
up something give more credits for job
give more connection to employers from
our student population so colleges are
trying in a different way now but it's a
little late for many students yeah it
indeed it is now to Circle back to like
those five markers of adulthood here's
two other false markers you're an adult
when you turn 18 you're an adult when
you turn 21 and I find that and as you
all said here you've got to reset your
thinking to this new normal really it
never was a reality just because you
turned 18 or 21 right but to bring it to
current date right that's not you know
what that means we really have to know
that we have to stick with these young
people emotionally and as a support um
and Beyond until they get up to a level
that they feel good and safe and that we
all feel good and safe and Progressive
whatever that looks like for the
individual and what I love about your
book is that you know there's so many
books about how You Know What To Expect
When You're Expecting I read that book
from cover to cover okay in 1997 98 I
read from cover to cover very great book
but there's never been any book to my
knowledge that addresses our 20s
something year old people because I just
don't think dawned on anybody the
problems or challenges were in existence
but nobody addressed them until yourself
and do Ran So Bravo to both of you but
let's talk about resetting your thinking
to this new normal that all of a sudden
because your kid turns 18 or 21 or goes
to college or in a relationship they
still need coaching or they still need
support yes talk about that thank you
what young adults most want they really
do want and value their parents support
and part of why we wrote this book is
because we felt like parents had gotten
um sidelined you know their mental
health their worries their anxiety about
like why isn't my kid doing you know
what the neighbor down the streets kids
doing or whatever and some you know
young adults like your son in La they
have more smooth sailing it's like good
Anna we wanted to also help parents
understand but the new normal is delayed
adulthood so like take a breath and calm
your own worries because there's a
difference between this normal
developmental stall and where things
kind of hodgepodge come into place and
also what we call you know the emotional
barriers that really stall success so
we'll go back to that but part of it I
think is just helping the mindset of the
parents in a way accept that it's not
that the goal has changed the goal
absolutely is help your young adult
launch in all the ways that we want them
to for them to have a successful life to
do something meaningful because so many
young adults have lost Direction feel a
drift perceive the world as pretty crazy
and also feel lonelier and parents
really are a cottage industry right now
they're the primary safety net and so
part of how parents can help if they're
concerned like be positive about talking
about like what you see that's good what
you think has been helpful what progress
you see and kind of learn in this new
stage of parenting which is adult to
adult that what kids most want I say
kids but young adults they most want to
be understood which involves our
listening to them not lecturing them so
we changing from a kind of authoritative
I know best this is what's good for you
go ahead and do it to a collaborative
model which is where in a stage the
longest stage we will ever have with our
children adult to adult and you want it
to be a good one because you put in so
much work to get here so be positive be
brief about your concerns but tell them
your concerns ask them what they think
are they concerned about that are they
worried about their screen time or
they're difficulty getting a job young
adults will turn to their parents the
majority of them for job advice career
advice sometimes for financial support I
also want to help parents know this has
always been the case for thousands of
years that parents helped their young
adults launch so this isn't just like
well what's wrong with us now it's that
your generation we were in a historic
blip that had Economic Security more
than it does now that America was kind
of this economic superpower really until
like like the late 80s early 90s and so
that's when harsher competition came in
and yet we just thought that was normal
and that it would just continue which is
like okay but it changed and so partly
it's offering an understanding statement
like it's not that it was your fault or
my fault and not blaming each other
generationally it's like you know the
world really has changed and it is
harder and it's harder to like you know
kind of tick off all the boxes of uh
these are the five Milestones um and
unlike developmental milestones for
toddlers these can take a decade or more
to tick off correct correct because
there's so many outside factors
affecting the uh young adults and I love
what you're saying about the adult to
adult relationship but you also said
that this is a merging adulthood you
know that gets you away from that 18 and
21 milestone
you are an emerging adult and I think
it's sooner rather than later that most
parents and young people Embrace that
will all be a little bit better for it
and that this is a new development stage
and I thought that was very eye
openening you know it's kind of like it
was always there it was there in your
face but to recognize that this is now a
new development stage now let me like I
said before let me drop back to my
experience so when I graduated
successfully from UNCC Chapel Hill you
can see my degree and my little emblems
on the wall back there you know was a
great place to eat back
then but again I think well was coming
upon the George Bush years George Bush
the senior years and um there was a
recession there and so my degree was in
journalism and there really wasn't
anything for me do in journalism believe
it or not at that time and so I ended up
having to work part-time at a local
department store I started off my career
in an ad agency it started off pretty
good but then very quickly it got rocky
because of a recession that came in the
early 90s but I was at home I graduated
from college and came back home again my
parents didn't mind that they were not
the kind that necessarily wanted I tried
but my mother just was like no I you
know she just did not want me out there
so I came back home and you know had I
been a little bit more an emerging adult
or let's say even Wilder you know
there's a lot of parents that would say
well you're back home now and my rules
are my rules right and uh you know you
got to be home at a certain time and you
you know you certainly can't bring a boy
or a girl or whoever home you know those
kind of things so you had to reset
yourself and say oh my fun college life
is over I've got to go back home my mom
and dad and squelch down all the stuff
that I've been doing for the past four
years so let's take that and all of
that's wrapped up into that and talk
about this new development stage and if
a child has to come home for whatever
reason that they have to come back home
High rents uh can't find a job or
whatever else maybe a mental health
challenge uh and you got to live with
your parents again what should that look
like it's a negotiation so unlike in
your days where you got squelched down
it really is a conversation about what
are my expectations what are you looking
for here's what would bother me and why
so it can be a hard conversation it's
going to probably be more than one
conversation and what parents need to do
is be a bit more patient than maybe they
want to be because they are dealing with
someone like you said who has had
freedom in their lives and also
borrowing from your experience if you
can normalize it let's say for your
21-year-old you know I went through
living at home again in my 20s or yeah
you know this is what I learned this is
what I wish my parents had done
differently this is what I'm trying to
do differently but also it's a
conversation in that sense of like well
what's reasonable to expect if I don't
want to be woken up at 4 in the morning
because you're having a party someplace
let's talk about what's reasonable
because I have needs too
so it's asking your young adult to
recognize that there is a responsibility
in the freedom to live at home and in
the privilege to live at home that your
parents are sponsoring parents in the
earlier days May really have had a my
way or the highway kind of um I'm the
boss here you're a kid what do you know
that really doesn't work and you can say
well maybe that's still how parents feel
and I think they may feel that way it's
you just have to focus on is your goal
to have a relationship that gets closer
and better because if you stick with
that authoritative role it's going to be
a Break um and I've seen kids basically
go live on the street because their
parents had rules that some of them were
reasonable some of them were like iffy
but they didn't have good conversations
about what's going to work for you
what's going to work for me because I'm
not just a kid kid anymore even though
I'm really in between I'm not a kid I'm
not an adult and they'll you know young
adults appreciate that being understood
being listened to but also being
understood that like you don't exactly
feel like a kid and you don't exactly
feel like an adult so we have to kind of
make it up as we go along depending on
the
circumstances right definitely
definitely well dropping back to college
and one of the things that I found in my
life that I just told somebody this the
other day and I can't remember who it
was but I told them I used to be a very
much an education snob and uh I'm here
in North Carolina like I said I went to
UNCC Chapel Hill our greatest rival Duke
University is right down the road we
have H various my son went to North
Carolina State and Raleigh uh we have
various HBCU North Carolina entt North
Carolina Central University we have all
these great universities in North
Carolina and you know I just was a super
snob you know and I was like well s such
and such didn't go to college H you know
and they ended up working you know but
as life has gone along and I had
children and I saw other people's
children I began to realize that college
is not for everyone then you fast
forward a little bit more and that there
one of the other things I Learned was um
once my kids and my kids friends started
to go to college there were so many
other Majors than just prear pre-law
business and journalism I mean you know
it's so much more expansive and a little
bit more on the creative side of even
majors and then outside of that there's
well and productive careers one can go
into with just certificates or associate
degrees or on the job training and since
we already know that college is not for
everyone you know let's talk a little
bit about the career Pathways here in
the 21st century okay so I want to also
appreciate that I was also an
educational snob like you can see I have
too many degrees right part of it was my
training and I had to get extra training
in my field but part of it was I was an
educational snob and my oldest son
surprised me one day when he came home
and he said well my English profess in
college agrees with me that I really
don't need this degree to write and I
was like
what I'm going to leave College I'm like
what and I had to kind of take a breath
and go okay well thanks for telling me
I'm not sure what's next but we'll help
you figure it out because I thought all
right like you know what it's not linear
we got to figure out what works for each
kid and not just bring our snob s to the
equation I these are my hopes and dreams
hi you had your own chance to fill your
hopes and dreams whatever so to go back
to the credentialing pathway and we do
devote a chapter in the book to kind of
the transition from education to Career
there are for I really say to parents I
think the best thing I ever did you know
for my kids was get them aptitude
testing because otherwise know so what's
aptitude testing aptitude is different
from what you're your best grade or
which is usually how people figure out
oh well I want that kind of job so
attitudes really are kind of the inborn
things that you're just naturally easy
to learn you're naturally good at now if
you have a super student they'll work
really really hard and get good at
something but they won't particularly
like it because they have to work so
hard to do it and that's what we in like
going to college and sometimes dropping
out so there's College there's
credentials there's many employers the
larger ones are offering kind of boot
camps and Technical Training because
many people with with good aptitudes
they can do those jobs without a college
degree it's like they have a superpower
but they don't even know that they have
because college and school only test
specific knowledge bases right right
exactly exactly well that's good advice
to know like my younger son he has a
god-given talent for uh drawing um
painting colors uh recognizing
creativity videos editing he just has
that natural talent and that's the path
he's going down you know we're not you
know trying to block it and say well you
should be a doctor you know and when
that does not when that does not fit him
whatsoever now but it's very respectful
also like hey your kid actually knows
themselves yes they definitely do they
definitely do now let's talk about you
know we had the huge blip didn't know it
was coming no excuse me tsunami it was a
tsunami Co was a tsunami and this has
always been around but there was a lot
of mental health going on during those
pandemic years a lot of influences
brought a lot of attention to me about
mental health they brought out words
that we weren't really used
correctly that we became to get used to
and know the definitions gaslighting
narcissist
narcissism uh self-care all of these
things were really emphasized during
those covid years so thankfully for
those influencers in case you don't like
influencers I think that was one really
great positive thing that influencers
did so let's talk about parents as
mental health Advocates because the kids
of to day freely tell you and express
who they want to be who they are and the
things that are bringing them challenges
let's talk about how we can support our
emerging adults as mental health
Advocates absolutely parents I think
really do well by also sharing stories
that begin with what runs in the family
because to the extent that we can
normalize hey like I recognize a bit
more what you're going through because
Aunt Susie or Uncle Bob or you know or I
struggled with this that or the other
then it's a conversation opener to
reduce the mental health stigma to feel
encourage you know our children that
they can share what's going on because
as much as as young adults are willing
to ask about jobs or career stuff or you
know finances or sometimes raising their
own kids they're less willing to share
their mental health struggles and so the
more openly we can talk about like how'
that work how's that rolling out for you
especially you know during what many
people and probably your younger son
call like the Lost Years of Co where
people like you know if they wanted to
go to school like if there was so much
that was online that it was like hard to
do and wasn't as gratifying most kids
enjoy the social stimulation and
sometimes really need in person to learn
yes that's usually how people learn best
so part of know how the advocate is both
recognizing the signs and symptoms of
mental health disorders and they can
start small like I'm super worried about
such and thus and you can say oh you're
overblowing this but that's called
catastrophizing that it's a distortion
of how serious an issue is it's kind of
not that serious but if a young adult
believes it is they've entered a mind
state that's an anxiety driven mind
State called catastrophizing it's a
distortion of reality and it won't help
for parents to brightsight it oh it's
nothing you'll get over it they have to
take seriously so you're worried about
that tell me more about it like have a
conversation so you understand um how
often like how bad is it like is it
keeping you up at night like is it
disturbing your sleep kind of go after
the biological signs of like uhoh are we
are we going down the wrong path here
you know in terms of like does my young
adult need treatment so we need to kind
of familiarize ourselves with like the
signs of the symptoms whether it's
coping by substance use whether it's on
screen time that's like cutting out face
tof face time whether it's anxiety
depression because those are the major
mood disruptors in young adulthood and
their Pathway to successful launch um
and for parents to also recognize if
this runs in the family let me just talk
about it I used to use my mother as an
example to my kids because they knew my
mother and my mother was probably by the
time they knew were the happiest person
on the planet and I said well she went
through a really terrible depression you
know when I was a teenager and they were
like what so just helping them know he
you can go through awful times and get
through it here's what helped her maybe
want to you know consider that you have
to be prepared for they'll dismiss it no
I'm not that bad because the main reason
kids don't get professional help is they
think it's not that bad I don't have
time like this will pass so you
periodically have to kind of remind them
I don't think that's passed yet huh
right patient and and you also need to
say would you just go check this out
with a doctor if you feel strongly that
that's needed for my peace of mind even
if the kid goes I don't need it well for
my peace of mind because I just don't
know so sometimes you know young adults
will do things for their parents that
otherwise they would refuse to do if
their parents take more ownership of
like this is why I think it would help
me just to understand it um but I would
never send someone to someone who
wouldn't talk to the parents at least
when it's appropriate or when they can
participate in a treatment session
because parents are the safety net they
are the primary safety net there's like
other than that children and young
adults have to make their own safety net
but it takes a while yes yes yes yes you
know in my church one of the things we
say uh sometimes is the preacher will
ask well would anybody like to come up
and stand in the gap of this person
meaning uh maybe someone is very ill and
asking for parishioners to come up to
pray for this person and stand in the
Gap uh because they're so sick they
can't pray for themselves must support
be in the gap and this book right here
is a parents way to stand in the gap of
their child their early uh adult
emerging adult standing in the Gap
closing that Gap to the emerging
adulthood I love it I love this book I
love this concept I will be promoting
this to all of my friends because again
majority of my friends are in the very
same shape that I'm in and we need this
book now before we go how would you
recommend that a parent would read the
book could they just read the chapter
that they feel was affecting them I mean
a lot of them were pull out chapters if
you're really concerned about your kids
um education you know should they go to
college shouldn't they should they go
straight to work what are the options
there's a chapter on that there's a
chapter on specific mood problems for
young adults there's a chapter of are
interested in like how did we get here
there's a chapter on that there's
another chapter on like kind of catch
your stereotypes because it doesn't help
us to cross- blame each other which is
kind of what's happened like parents get
labeled oh you were helicopter kids get
labeled oh you're snowflake or
materialistic it's like actually that's
just not true and and we need to join as
you said to fill the Gap I'm so pleased
for you that you have a group of friends
that you can talk to because I wish more
parents you know really just had those
social connections to share and get
support and go yeah me too as opposed to
feel like I just have to present a kind
of nice good face so everybody thinks I
didn't screw up as a parent right right
exactly or make it excuses you know with
uh you meet somebody at the grocery
store you haven't seen in a couple of
years and both of you are asking each
other oh how's your child you and the
other one was saying maybe oh yeah they
graduated got engaged and be getting
married in June and maybe the other
parent will have to say well right now
my child is working at a quick stop
convenience store I mean you know so
instead of having to go down Road and
whatever or make up stories or whatever
it is parents do sometimes you know this
will help that situation we so
appreciate your understanding and
support of this book because we feel
like parents deserve that support they
really do yes yes most definitely well
Janet thank you so much for joining the
bookaholic podcast today give my
greetings to Dr rostan as well thank you
so much for writing this book it is very
well needed in the non-fiction book
verse and in the uh parental Arena uh
thank you so much again and we'll have
the information uh for Janet and Dr rain
in the podcast show notes as as well as
in the video description box on YouTube
again thank you jenet for joining me
today thank so much